MenuPages

I found Mary's on this website. I went with my husband and son. We were not disappointed. We started with shared lobster knuckles and the watercress/avocado salad . Two of our main courses were the lobster roll - best I've ever had and the thin cut fries were great. My husband had the Red Snapper Tacos. The salsa and sauce were perfect. We also had the asparagus with dill and tarragon in a lemon dressing. We chose to sit at the bar to have a shorter wait. This turned out to be the best seating in the small restaurant. We were able to observe chef/owner Mary Redding and her crew prepare all of the food like a well oiled machine. They didn't need to speak to one another to get the food prepared and out in an efficient manner. The wait staff truly work together as a team. I will definitely return. We were so satisfied with our meal that we could only split one dessert - the key lime square with cream fresh.

My favorite NYC spot for a lobster roll. Also love the lobster knuckles, melt in your mouth, sweet flavorful lobster. A little messy but extremely delicious! Fish and seafood are fresh and perfectly prepared. It's a small and noisy place, but definitely worth it. One of my fave spots.

We go here often and it's always excellent. If you don't like it, then you don't get it. And yes the lobster roll is great but there are so many other great things on the menu.

Everything here is great except the fact that you have to wait to get in. Service is great. I've never seen a wait staff work so hard, consistently. Food is excellent.

Went with bf and friend. Seafood was "fishy" and fries were cold. Waitress was doing us a favor. Expensive. Will not be back.

The ambience was okay, but it was cramped. Not a place to dine if you are claustrophobic or like good service. The food is okay, but overpriced.

The food here is so fresh. It was presented beautifully but not in a too-fancy way, and all this went really well with the atmosphere. It's a little crowded, but it's really a lovely place to eat and talk. The service was also very friendly and attentive.