Atlantic Bagels
Popular menu items
1/2 Dozen Bagels + One Extra for Free
Hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh all day from the best ingredients. Six of your choice, and a seventh on the house just to be nice.
$11.00Coffee and Tea
Coffee
$2.00 +Iced Coffee
$3.00 +Hot Tea
$2.00 +Iced Tea
$3.00 +Cafe Latte
Freshly ground and expertly pulled espresso with steamed milk of your choice. More milk and less foam than a cappuccino.
$5.00 +Mocha Latte
$5.00 +Matcha Latte
$5.00 +Chai Tea Latte
$4.00 +Iced Latte
$5.00 +Cappuccino
$5.00 +Espresso
$3.00 +Box of Coffee 96oz
$25.00 +Hot Cocoa
Rich, delicious hot cocoa made with your choice of steamed milk or non-dairy milk options.
$4.00 +Cold Beverages
Hal's Seltzer Lemon
$3.00Hal's Seltzer Lime
$3.00Coke
$2.00 +Diet Coke
$2.00 +Sprite
$2.00 +Hal's Ginger Ale
$3.00Fresh Lemonade
$4.00Fresh Orange Juice
$4.00Tropicana No Pulp
$3.00Just Ice Tea Lemon
$4.00Just Ice Tea Mint
$4.00Snapple Lemon Tea
$2.50Snapple Peach Tea
$2.50Electrolit Orange
$5.00Electrolit Grape
$5.00Electrolit Coconut
$5.00Bagels and Bialys
Bakers Dozen Bagels
Hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh all day from the best ingredients. Twelve of your choice, and a thirteenth on the house so you have something nice to nosh on.
$22.001/2 Dozen Bagels + One Extra for Free
Hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh all day from the best ingredients. Six of your choice, and a seventh on the house just to be nice.
$11.00Egg Bagel
$2.00 +Pumpernickle-Everything
$2.00 +Lardo Bread Bagel
A 100-year-old Carroll Gardens tradition-- famous Italian-American specialty, LARD BREAD-- now made into one of the most delicious bagels you've ever tried. Packed with salami and black pepper, plus a bit of provelone, there's nothing more delicious. Try to eat just one!
$3.50 +Salt Bagel
$2.00 +Caraway-Rye Bagel
Rye flour and caraway seeds both inside and out. Jewish rye bread as a bagel, it gets no better.
$2.00 +Golden Raisin Fennel Bagel
$2.00 +Whole Wheat Sesame
$2.00 +Whole Wheat Everything
$2.00 +Flat Bagel Assorted
$2.00 +Flat Plain Bagel
Our delicious plain bagel flattened out before being baked, making for more crusty surface area and less doughy bread on the inside. A customer favorite.
$2.00 +Flat Cinnamon Bagel
$2.00 +Flat Everything Bagel
$2.00 +Flat Whole Wheat Bagel
Our delicious whole wheat bagel flattened out before being baked, making for more crusty surface area and less doughy bread on the inside.
$2.00 +Flat Sesame Bagel
$2.00 +Flat Poppy Bagel
Our delicious poppy bagel flattened out before being baked, making for more crust, more seeds, and less doughy bread on the inside. A customer favorite.
$2.00 +Flat Whole Wheat Everything Bagel
Our delicious whole-wheat-everything bagel flattened out before being baked, making for more crusty surface area, more flavorful seeds and spices, and less doughy bread on the inside. Big customer favorite!
$2.00 +Gluten Free Bagel
$4.00 +Cream Cheese/ Lox/ Prepared Salads
Jalapeno Cream Cheese
$3.50 +Egg Salad
$4.00 +Tuna Salad
$4.00 +Chicken Salad
$3.50 +Whitefish Salad
Top quality smoked whitefish mixed with a little mayonnaise and a nice grind of black pepper. Delicious on a bagel, or almost anything else.
$6.00 +Nova Lox by the Pound
The very best smoked nova lox in NYC, hand-sliced, carefully packed, and ready to eat on bagels, eggs, or straight out of the package.
$9.00 +Blueberry Cream Cheese
Juicy fresh blueberries and a touch of blueberry preserves mixed into luscious, top-quality cream cheese. One of the tastiest, most beautiful spreads ever. Amazing on an egg bagel.
$3.50 +Rainbow Sprinkle Cream Cheese
So good, even grown-ups can't stop eating it! Rainbow sprinkles and vanilla mixed into fresh, top-quality cream cheese. A not-too-sweet but oh-so-satisfying treat that brings out the kid in anyone.
$3.50 +Hot Breakfast
Sausage Egg and Cheese
A juicy, flavorful homemade sausage patty, melting American cheese, and two scrambled eggs on your choice of bagel, roll, or bread.
$10.00 +Two Eggs Any Style
Served cooked however you like them, with homefries, and a bagel or toast of your choice.
$9.00 +Yogurt, Fruit, Oatmeal & Granola
Chia Pudding & Fruit Parfait
Organic chia seeds with coconut and almond milk, honey, mango, and blueberries. An in-store favorite.
$7.00Hot Oatmeal with Toppings
$7.00 +Cantaloupe Cup
$6.00Pineapple Cup
$6.00Honeydew Cup
$6.00Soup/Salad
Grandma Millie's Chicken Soup
Homemade chicken soup from scratch, with pulled chicken breast, carrots, celery. And love, just like Grandma's.
$8.00Tomato Bisque Soup
Homemade from scratch from oven-roasted Roma tomatoes and a touch of thyme. Served with bagel chips.
$8.00Large Kale Caesar Salad
Kale, shaved brussels sprouts, parmesean cheese, pepitas, and a homemade Caesar dressing. Add grilled chicken or salmon for extra protein.
$12.00 +Atlantic Chickpea Side
Chickpeas, cherry tomatoes, kalamata olives, cucumbers, za'atar, and extra virgin olive oil. Delicious, high-protein, vegetarian, and satisfying on its own or over a green salad.
$5.00Large Waldorf Salad
$12.00Sandwiches
1. If Brooklyn Were a Sandwich Nova Lox Deluxe
Brooklyn-smoked Nova Lox, scallion cream cheese, sliced tomatoes and red onion, plus capers. On an everything bagel, or bagel of choice.
$15.00 +2. Grandpa Moe's Kosher Salami on Rye
Hebrew National kosher beef salami, grainy mustard, and love on a caraway-rye bagel (as a default, or your bagel of choice.)
$12.00 +3. Red Hook Waterfront
Tuna in Olive Oil, Artichoke Hearts, Olive Tapenade, and Arugula on a toasted Bialy.
$13.00 +4. Brooklyn Heights Top Turkey
Sliced roasted turkey breast, muenster cheese, avocado, tomato, kale salad, and herbed aoili on a fennel-raisin
$13.00 +5. Court Street Chicken Caesar Wrap
Hearts of romaine, marinated and grilled chicken breast, and crunchy croutons tossed with homemade Caesar dressing and rolled up in a large whole wheat wrap.
$13.00 +6. Cobble Hill Park Picnic
Hummus, avocado, tomato, red onion, and arugula on a whole wheat everything bagel.
$12.00 +8. BoCoCa Cheeseburger
Hand-formed fresh 100% Beef patty from Atlantic Avenue's famous Dellapietra's, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, special sauce on a sesame seed bun from Court Street's 100-year-old Caputo's Bakery.
$14.00 +9. Your Favorite Fried Chicken Sandwich
Juicy, marinated chicken, crispy on the outside, with American cheese, coleslaw, pickles, and house sauce on a brioche bun
$14.00 +10. Carroll Gardens Social Club
Roast Chicken, Provolone, Pepperoncini, Arugula, and Balsamico on our soon-to-be-famous Lard Bread Bagel.
$14.00 +11. Gowanus Tuna Melt
Homemade albacore tuna salad with capers and melted cheddar on griddle-toasted whole grain bread.
$14.00 +12. Atlantic Antic Reuben
$12.00 +13. Modern Like It's 1935 BLT Sandwich
Thick-cut bacon, crisp iceberg lettuce, sliced ripe tomatoes, and homemade aioli on sourdough toast. Like the 1935 Art Deco building Atlantic Bagels calls home, a classic for a reason.
$12.00 +14. Sometimes You Just Need A Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Three cheeses melted to perfection on the griddle on buttered whole grain bread. What could be better?
$10.00 +Sides and Extras
Whole Dill Pickle
$1.00 +Side of Bacon
$4.00Side of Ham
$4.00Side of Sausage
$4.00Side of Homefries
$4.00Side of Hash Browns
$4.00One Egg on the Side
$3.00 +Side of Turkey Bacon
$4.00Pastries and Desserts
Chocolate Cake Pop
$3.75Vanilla Cake Pop
$3.75Red Velvet Cake Pop
$3.75Black & White Cookie
$5.00Peanut Butter Cookie
$5.00Brownie
$5.00Crumb Coffee Cake
$5.00Lemon Pound Cake
$5.00Butter Croissant
Baked fresh daily, our pure butter croissants are perfect on their own or as a sandwich. Bon appetite!
$5.00 +Chocolate Croissant
Baked fresh every day, our all-butter croissant filled with bittersweet chocolate. Huge favorite for breakfast, a snack, or dessert anytime.
$6.00Almond Croissant
Our flaky all-butter croissant, baked fresh daily, filled with almond paste and covered in sliced almonds. Incomparably delicious.
$6.00Cheese Danish
Our all-butter croissant dough, formed into a scrumptious danish, filled with sweetened cream cheese, and sprinkled with a few almond slices before being baked to perfection. Unbeatable for breakfast, a snack, or a dessert anytime.
$5.00Cranberry Scone
$5.00Blueberry Scone
$5.00Chocolate Chip Scone
$5.00Lemon Poppy Muffin
Baked in-house every day, our jumbo lemon-poppy muffin is superb for breakfast, as a snack, or for dessert any time of the day.
$5.00Chocolate Chip Muffin
Baked in-house every day, our jumbo chocolate chip muffin is superb for breakfast or as a snack or dessert any time of the day.
$5.00Corn Muffin
$5.00Pistachio Muffin
$5.00Banana Nut Muffin
Baked in-house every day, our jumbo banana-walnut muffin is superb for breakfast, as a snack, or for dessert any time of the day.
$5.00