Borderline Bagels
MenuAbout
Borderline Bagels Menu

Borderline Bagels

Bagels, Breakfast
440 Madison Ave, New Milford, NJ 07646
(201) 599-1990
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Breakfast Sandwiches

Menu powered by Grubhub

Bacon, Egg and Cheese Sandwich

3 strips of hotel grade bacons

$5.25 +

Taylor Ham, Egg and Cheese Sandwich

3 slices of trenton pork rolls

$5.25 +

Ham, Egg and Cheese Sandwich

$5.25 +

Taylor Ham and Cheese Sandwich

6 slices of trenton pork roll with double american cheese melted

$5.50 +

Steak, Egg and Cheese Sandwich

$5.99 +

2 Eggs Sandwich

double fried eggs

$3.50 +

Egg and Cheese Sandwich

double eggs and cheese

$4.00 +

Bacon and Cheese Sandwich

6 strips of hotel grade bacon with melted double american cheese

$5.50 +

Sausage & Cheese

Double Sausage & Double Cheese

$5.50 +

Sausage Egg & Cheese

Sausage pattie & Cheese with fried Egg

$5.25 +

Bagels with Spreads

Bagel with Butter

$2.25 +

Bagel with Cream Cheese

$2.85 +

Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese

Flavor Cream cheese spreads Vegetable, Scallion, Cinn-Walnut Raisin, Funfetti, Lox spread, Olive, Strawberry

$3.99 +

Bagel with Lox Cream Cheese

$4.99 +

Bagel with Fresh Nova and Cream Cheese

Nova scotia freshly sliced with cream cheese

$9.99 +

Bagel with Peanut Butter and Jelly

$3.50 +

Muffin

$2.50

Muffin with Butter

$2.95

Mini Bagel with Butter

$1.25

Mini Bagel with Cream Cheese

$1.50

Breakfast Specials

Protein Wrap

4 egg whites, spinach, Boar's head oven gold turkey, onion and green peppers.

$7.50

Hungry Man

3 eggs, Ham + Sausage + Bacon and Triple American cheese on a hero.

$7.50

Breakfast Burrito

3 eggs, sauteed onions & green peppers, home fries and ham.

$7.50 +

Omelettes

Big Breakfast Platter

2 eggs any style with Bacon or Sausage or Ham & home fries and buttered toast

$8.50 +

Spinach Omelette

$6.50 +

Meat and Cheese Omelette

please choose among bacon or sausage or ham

$7.50 +

Side Order Home Fries

$2.99

Hash Brown

$1.50

Western Omellettes

Grilled onions and pepper with sliced ham

$7.50 +

Home Fries with onions & peppers

red skin potato home fries

$2.99

Beverages

Coffee

$2.00 +

Iced Coffee

$2.50 +

Tea

Lipton Decaf Green Tea, Earl Gray , Raspberry chimomile, lemon zinger

$2.00 +

Hot Chocolate

$2.00 +

French Vanilla Cappucino

$0.25 +

Sodas

20 oz bottle coke, diet coke, sprite, seltzer, welch grape

$2.50

Snapple

16oz bottle all natural

$2.50

BelVoir Organic Ginger Beer

8.5 oz bottle

$3.50

Fentimans Ginger Beer

9.3 oz bottle Organic ginger beer

$2.50

Lorina Natural Sparkling premium pink lemonade

11.1 oz glass bottle

$2.99

Martinellis Apple Juice

10 oz bottle

$2.50

Tropicana Family Size

1/2 gallon Original 100% pure juice bottle

$6.99

Nesquik Chocolate

14oz bottle

$2.99

Yoohoo

16 oz bottle

$2.50

Milk

Pint Valley Farm Regular milk

$2.25

Half & Half

cream o land quart size

$3.99

Naked Juice

100% natural 15.2 oz bottle

$4.50

Bai

18 oz bottle 1g sugar no Artificial sweeteners

$2.99

Poland Spring water

$1.25 +

Fiji Water

Natural Artesian water

$2.25 +

Coco Well Coconut Water Original

11.2 oz paper pack

$2.50

Gatorade

20 oz wide mouth bottle

$2.50

Joe Tea

20 oz natural tea bottle

$2.75

Vitamin Water

16oz bottle

$2.75

V8

Original 100% vegetable Juice 12oz bottle

$2.75

Orangina

Sparkling Citrus Beverage 16oz Bottle

$2.75

Red bull

8.4 oz can

$2.75

Core Ph balanced Water

30 oz bottle

$3.75

Bagels

Bagel

Plain Poppy Sesame Cinn-Raisin Everything Whole Wheat Egg Pumper Nickel Marble Rye

$1.00 +

Cream Cheese By Half Pound

8oz Container of our Freshly made Cream Cheeses Plain , Scallion, Vegetable, Olive, Strawberry, Lox Spread

$4.99 +

Breakstone Butter

8oz whipped butter

$5.25

Philladelphia Whipped Plain Cream Cheese

8oz packed Philladelphia Whipped Cream cheese

$4.25

Nova Lox

1/4 lb Nova (smoked salmon from Brooklyn) Freshly sliced

$11.00

Signature Sandwiches

Atlantic Wrap

Breaded chicken, lettuce, bacon, onion, tomato, pepper Jack cheese with ranch dressing.

$7.99

Manhattan Wrap

Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella with honey mustard.

$7.99

Mediterranean Wrap

Grilled chicken, black olives, roasted red pepper, feta cheese, tomato, and spinach with balsamic vinegar.

$7.99

Chicken Quesadilla

Grilled chicken, onion, pepper, pepper with melted Pepper-Jack cheese topped with ranch dressing

$7.99

Chicken Supreme Sandwich

Breaded chicken, crispy bacon with melted cheddar cheese & Russian dressing

$7.99

Monte Cristo Sandwich

Grilled ham and turkey with Swiss.

$7.99

Chicken Parm Hero

Cutlets with mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce on a hero

$8.99

Club Deluxe Sandwich

Boar's Head Turkey, Deluxe Ham and Alpine Swiss cheese with Crispy Bacon , Lettuce, Tomatoes on 3 layered toasts.

$7.99

Italian Bomber Sandwich

Boar's head Deluxe ham, pepperoni, salami and provolone with roasted peppers, red onion, lettuce, tomato with oil and vinegar on a hero bread.

$8.99

Turkey Delight Sandwich

Boar's Head Oven gold Turkey and home made coleslaw with Russian dressing.

$6.99

Hot Roast Beef Special Sandwich

With fresh mozzarella and roasted red pepper on toasted garlic roll.

$7.99

Turkey Club Sandwich

Thinly Sliced oven gold turkey With bacon, lettuce, tomato on 3 layered white toast.

$7.99

Hot Pastrami Sandwich

On a Toasted Rye bread Brooklyn Style boar's head pastrami with Swiss cheese melted with mustard.

$7.99

B.L.T Sandwich

6 strips of hotel grade bacons with iceberg lettuce and tomatoes

$5.99

Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich

Thinly sliced sirloin steaks with melted american cheese with sauted onions and bell peppers on a long roll

$8.99

Paninis

Italiano Panini

Grilled chicken, sweet peppers, basil pesto sauce & fresh mozarella

$7.99

Fajita Panini

Grilled chicken, Salsa, hot & sweet peppers, Cheddar and Pepper Jack Cheese

$7.99

Parmigian Panini

Breaded chicken, marinara sauce & fresh mozarella

$7.99

Buffalo Panini

Grilled chicken, buffalo sauce & blue cheese

$7.99

Chicken wings

Original pepper Chicken wings

6 pieces of Organic chicken wings Choose your choice of style

$6.99

French Fries

Crispy French Fries

$2.99

Cheese Burger Deluxe with French Fries

6oz Black Angus burger with melted american , lettuce, tomotoes, burmuda onions

$7.99 +

Classic Sandwiches

Ham Sandwich

$5.49 +

Turkey Sandwich

showing : Boar's Head Oven gold turkey with lettuce and tomatoes on our Rainbow Bagel

$5.49 +

Roast Beef Sandwich

Our oven baked Fresh Boar's Head Roast Beef

$5.75 +

Tuna Melt

Albacore white tuna with melted cheddar cheese on a Rye toast

$6.99 +

Chicken Salad Sandwich

Our slowly oven cooked Chicken Breast

$5.49 +

Egg Salad Sandwich

$4.99 +

Chicken Cutlet Sandwich

$5.99 +

Bologna Sandwich

$4.99 +

Cheese Sandwich

$4.50 +

Salads

Traditional Greek Salad

Mixed field greens, diced cucumber, ripe tomato, Bermuda onions, Kalamata olives and crumbled feta cheese. Served with a fresh bagel.

$7.99 +

Chef Salad

Romaine lettuce mesculine, carrots, red cabbage, cucumbers, tomatoes, topped with turkey, ham, cheddar cheese and Swiss with choice of dressing,

$7.99

Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

Romaine, lettuce, mesculine, Bermuda onions, croutons and Parmesan cheese topped with grilled chicken cutlet.

$7.99

Garden Salad

Mix greens, tomato, cumber, green pepper and onion.

$4.99

Borderline Remedies

Fresh Fruit Cup

16 oz fresh fruits watermelon, cantalope, honey dew, pineapples

$3.50

Rice Puddings

16 oz Rice Pudding

$2.75

Parfait

Low Fat Vanilla Yogurt with Fresh Strawberry and granola

$4.99

Potato Chips

Frito Lay

1.5 - 1.75 oz bags

$1.50

Dirty Chips

2 oz bags all natural ketlle cooked with peanut oil chips

$2.00

Deep River Chips

2 oz bag kettle boiled chips

$2.00

Wise Chips

1.25-1.5oz bags

$1.25

Popcorn Indiana original kettlecorn

4.0 oz bag

$3.50

popcorn Indiana Movie Theater buttered

4.0 oz bag

$3.50

Glico Pocky Chocolate

2.46 oz box

$3.50

Kinder chocolate

kinder brand cholates

$2.50

Sweet Deserts

Belgian Waffle

$2.75

Cheese Danishes

$2.99

Cinnamon Roll

$2.75

Plain Crumb Cake

$2.75

Chocolate Marble Crumb cake

$2.75

Plain Pound Cake

$2.50

Lemon Iced pound cake

$2.50

Marble Pound Cake

$2.50

Black & White Cookies

$2.75

Chocolate Chip cookie

$2.75

Croissant Plain

$2.75

Ritter Chocolate

3.5 oz German Chocolate

$3.75

Breakfast for the Group

Baker's Dozen

Please choose 13 bagels from the following flavors: plain, sesame, poppy, everything, whole wheat, whole wheat everything, pretzel salt, onion, cinnamon raisin

$12.00

Baker's Dozen Value Pack

includes 2 tubs of 1/2 lb cream cheese

$19.00

Borderline Bagel Platter

15 assorted bagels, 6 assorted pastries with 2 tubs of cream cheese and butter. serves up to 20

$45.00
FYI, this restaurant is not accepting orders right now.

About Borderline Bagels

  • 440 Madison Ave, New Milford, NJ 07646
  • Bagels, Breakfast, Lunch, Sandwiches
  • (201) 599-1990
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NJ / Borderline Bagels
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.