Popular menu items
The Rivalry Hero
Our version of a philly cheesesteak, peppers, onions, mushrooms and yellow cheddar cheese.
$14.00 +Appetizers
Hot Soups
Salads
Caesar Salad
$10.00 +Buffalo Chicken Salad
Our famous Buffalo chicken, fresh tomatoes over a bed of romaine lettuce.
$15.00 +Arancini
Grilled Burgers
Over-Sized Heros
New York Giant Chicken Parmesan Hero
Crispy tender chicken cutlet topped with homemade marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese.
$13.00 +The Staten Island Hawks Hero
Crispy or grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, provolone cheese and chipolte mayo.
$15.00 +The New York Red Bull Hero
Prosciutto di parma, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and balsamic glaze.
$15.00 +The Rivalry Hero
Our version of a philly cheesesteak, peppers, onions, mushrooms and yellow cheddar cheese.
$14.00 +The New York Cosmos Special Hero
Grilled or crispy chicken, fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, arugula and pesto mayo.
$15.00 +Chicken Marsala
Our version of a philly cheesesteak, peppers, onions, mushrooms and yellow cheddar cheese.
$19.44 +The Staten Island Hawks Hero
Crispy or grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, provolone cheese and chipolte mayo.
$20.00The New York Red Bull Hero
Prosciutto di parma, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and balsamic glaze.
$20.00The Rivalry Hero
Our version of a Philly cheesesteak, peppers, onions, mushrooms and yellow cheddar cheese.
$19.00The New York Cosmos Special Hero
Grilled or crispy chicken, fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, arugula and pesto mayo.
$20.00Panelle Specials
Everyday Deals
Crazy 8's Special
8 cheese slices (medium pie), 8 wings, 8 garlic knots and 8 mozzarella sticks.
$28.88Large Cheese Pizza
$10.95Pizza
Large Sicilian Pizza
$19.00 +White Pie
$16.00 +Cheese Pizza
$12.00 +12" Gluten Free Cheese Pizza
$13.72 +Gourmet Pizzas
Chicken Parmigiana Pizza
Crispy chicken tossed in marinara sauce, layered on a crispy crust, topped with ricotta & fresh mozzarella.
$20.00 +Chicken Francese Pizza
$20.00 +Grandma Pie
$23.00Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
Sirloin steak, sauteed onions, smothered with yellow American cheese.
$21.00 +16" Large Gravesend
Sicilian pizza topped with fresh mozzarella, homemade pizza sauce, flavored with italian herbs, grana padano.
$26.00Calzones and Rolls
Buffalo Chicken Roll
$7.00 +Broccoli Roll
$6.00 +Chicken Roll
$7.00 +Eggplant Roll
$7.00 +Philly Cheese Steak Roll
$7.00 +Pepperoni Roll
$6.00 +Spinach Roll
$6.00 +Chicken Marsala Roll
$13.72 +Meatball Parmigiana Roll
$10.29 +Chicken Francese Roll
$13.72 +Sausage and Broccoli Rabe Roll
$13.72 +Pasta
Alfredo Sauce Pasta
$12.00 +Broccoli Rabe Pasta with Sausage
$16.00 +Chicken and Broccoli Pasta
$16.00 +Red Clams Pasta
$16.00 +White Clams Pasta
$16.00 +Marinara Sauce Pasta
$8.00 +Meat Sauce Pasta
$10.00 +Pesto Sauce Pasta
$12.00 +Baked Ziti Pasta
$11.00 +Homemade Lasagna
$14.00 +Scungilli Fra Diavolo Pasta
$12.00 +Marinara Over Pasta
$25.15 +Half Tray Entrées
Chicken Marsala Half Tray
$27.95 +Chicken Parmigiana Half Tray
$27.95 +Chicken Francese Half Tray
$27.95 +Chicken & Broccoli Half Tray
$27.95 +Meatball Parmigiana Half Tray
$27.95 +Sausage Parmigiana Half Tray
$27.95 +Eggplant Parmigiana Half Tray
$27.95 +Eggplant Rollatini Half Tray
$27.95 +Mamma Soprano’s Baked Ziti
$27.95 +Calamari Marinara Half Tray
$27.95 +Jumbo Shrimp Parmigiana Half Tray
$27.95 +Lunch Specials
Desserts
Coffee
Beverages
Gluten Free Section (Archived)
Dinners (Archived)
Chicken Marsala Dinner
$28.58 +Chicken Parmigiana Dinner
$27.44 +Chicken Francese Dinner
$28.58 +Eggplant Parmigiana Dinner
$27.44 +Jumbo Shrimp Parmigiana Dinner
$32.01 +Scungilli Fra Diavolo Dinner
$29.73 +Scungilli Marinara Dinner
$29.73 +Nonnas Sunday Sauce Pasta Dinner
1/2 tray. Ziti pasta with homemade meatballs, sausage and braciole.
$34.28 +Sauces and Dough (Archived)
Let's Do Lunch (Archived)
Personal Cheese Pizza with 1 Topping Lunch
Extra toppings available for an additional charge.
$12.52 +Penne Vodka Lunch
$12.52Ravioli Marinara Lunch
$12.52Bottled Beer (Must be 21 to Purchase) (Archived)
Wine by the Bottle (Must be 21 to Purchase) (Archived)
Dinner Chicken (Archived)
Chicken Marsala Dinner
Golden pan-fried chicken cutlets and mushrooms in a rich Marsala wine sauce.
$27.00 +Chicken Parmigiana Dinner
Breaded chicken breast covered in tomato sauce and mozzarella, Parmesan cheese.
$26.00 +Chicken Francese Dinner
Plump chicken breasts dipped in seasoned egg batter and sautéed, served with a sauce of dry white wine, butter and lemon.
$27.00 +Dinner Eggplant (Archived)
Dinner Seafood (Archived)
Catering Appetizers
Catering Boneless Wings
Figure 2-3 wings per person. Cooked wing of a chicken coated in sauce or seasoning.
$65.00Catering Rice Ball Special
Deep-fried rice balls with ricotta cheese, Romano cheese, and marinara sauce. Vegetarian
$7.00Catering Appetizer Sampler
Includes 3 mozzarella sticks, 3 Buffalo wings, 3 chicken tenders, 3 breaded ravioli and french fries.
$25.00Catering Buffalo Bites
Deep-fried pizza dough stuffed with Buffalo chicken and mozzarella cheese. Spicy.
$5.75Catering Salads
Catering Chef's Salad
Tossed salad with ham, salami and provolone. Add proteins and extra dressing for an additional charge.
$11.75 +Catering Buffalo Chicken Salad
Romaine with Buffalo chicken and tomatoes. Add proteins and extra dressing for an additional charge. Spicy.
$13.75 +Catering Fresh Mozzarella, Salami and Peppers Salad
Add proteins and extra dressing for an additional charge.
$11.75 +Catering Philly Steak Salad
Tossed salad with beef and onions. Add proteins and extra dressing for an additional charge.
$13.75 +Catering Value-Added Packages
Catering Capri Package
Includes chicken francese (over pasta), garlic knots, tossed salad, and your choice of dressing.
$60.00Catering The Real Deal Package
Includes 2 medium cheese pizzas, 10 garlic knots, and a 2 liter soda.
$25.00Catering Ravello Package
Includes assorted paninis, penne vodka, house special salad, and your choice of dressing.
$95.00Catering Calabria Package
Includes grandma pizza, Neapolitan pizza, veggie pizza, and Sicilian pizza.
$95.00Catering Modena Package
Includes assorted white or wheat wrap (choice of 4), penne with broccoli garlic and oil, and tossed salad with your choice of dressing.
$95.00Catering Roma Package
Includes cold antipasto, traditional potato croquettes, vegetable whole wheat wraps, white pizza, penne with chicken and broccoli, and Caesar salad.
$155.00Catering Napoli Package
Includes cheese ravioli, chicken Parmesan, sausage, potatoes and onions.
$125.00Catering Crazy 8 Package
Includes 1 medium cheese pizza, 8 wings, 8 garlic knots, and 8 mozzarella sticks.
$28.88Catering Office Package
Includes a 1/2 tray of sausage, peppers, potatoes and onions, 1 large cheese pizza, 1 large house salad, and 4 cannolis.
$39.99Catering Sicilia Package
Includes traditional arancini (spinach and cheese rice balls, ham and cheese rice balls, and sausage and broccoli rabe rice balls), rigatoni with meat sauce, eggplant rollatini, and garlic knots.
$45.00Catering Traditional Italian Favorites
Catering Sausage and Peppers
Seasoned ground meat that has been and peppers, wrapped in a casing.
$45.00Catering Clam Sauce
White clam sauce: savory sauce with finely chopped clams. Red sauce: tomato sauce with finely chopped clams.
$55.00Catering Mussels
Mussels in the marinara sauce: mollusk with a seasoned tomato sauce. Mussels in the white sauce: mollusk in a creamy sauce.
$55.00Catering Calamari
Squid in the marinara sauce: squid with a seasoned tomato sauce. Squid in the white sauce: squid in a creamy sauce.
$55.00Family Size Tray Specials
Catering Pasta Tray
Catering Pasta with Broccoli Rabe and Sausage Tray
Your choice of pasta with broccoli rabe and sausage.
$55.00 +Catering Pasta with Clams Tray
Your choice of pasta with clams. White clam sauce: savory sauce with finely chopped clams. Red sauce: tomato sauce with finely chopped clams.
$60.00 +Catering Pasta with Chicken and Broccoli Tray
Your choice of pasta with chicken and broccoli.
$50.00 +Pasta with Butter Sauce Tray
$45.00 +Pasta with Meat Sauce Tray
$45.00 +Pasta with Meatballs Tray
$45.00 +Pasta with Sausage Tray
$45.00 +Catering Desserts
Catering Assorted Desserts Platter
Includes cheesecake, cannoli, tiramisu, and chocolate chip cookies.
$65.00Catering Cannoli
$5.25Catering Cheesecake
$6.25Catering Tiramisu Cup
Lady fingers soaked in espresso and layered with sweetened mascarpone cheese. Topped with cocoa.
$6.00Catering Beverages
Catering Miscellaneous
Catering Cancellation Policy
Catering Soups (Archived)
Catering Holiday Packages (Archived)
Catering Jingle Bell Package
1/2 tray baked clams, 1/2 tray crispy shrimp, 1/2 tray rice balls, 1/2 tray assorted eggrolls.
$139.00Catering Santa's Package
1/2 tray fried clams, 1/2 tray seafood combo, 1/2 penne vodka, 1/2 tray chicken parm, 1/2 tray house salad.
$179.00Catering The Grinch Package
Tray assorted panini, tray cold antipasto,1/2 tray traditional rice balls, 1/2 tray penne vodka, 1/2 tray fried calamari, 1/2 tray baked clams, tray tossed salad.
$259.00Catering Sandwiches (Archived)
Catering Crispy Eggplant Sandwich
Broccoli rabe, fresh mozzarella, and roasted eggplant. Vegetarian.
$13.25 +Catering Meatball Parm Sandwich
$10.25 +Catering Sausage Parm Sandwich
$10.25 +Catering Crispy Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
Crispy chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, provolone cheese, and chipotle mayo. Spicy.
$13.25 +Catering Pizza House Special Sandwich
Grilled chicken, bacon, tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, and ranch dressing.
$13.25 +Catering Wraps (Archived)
Catering Chicken Francese Wrap
$13.25 +Catering Crispy Eggplant Wrap
Broccoli rabe, fresh mozzarella, and roasted eggplant. Vegetarian.
$13.25 +Catering Meatball Parm Wrap
$10.25 +Catering Sausage Parm Wrap
$10.25 +Catering Jumbo Shrimp Parm Wrap
$14.25 +Catering Crispy Chicken Cutlet Wrap
Crispy chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, provolone cheese, and chipotle mayo. Spicy.
$13.25 +Catering Pizza House Special Wrap
Grilled chicken, bacon, tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, and ranch dressing.
$13.25 +Catering Burgers (Archived)
Catering Bacon Cheeseburger
$12.25 +Catering House Burger
Mushrooms, onions, bacon and cheese on a brioche bun. Served with pickles.
$13.25 +Catering Cheeseburger
$11.25 +Catering Pizza Burger
Pepperoni, mozzarella cheese and pizza sauce on a brioche bun. Served with pickles.
$13.25 +Catering Mac and Cheese Burger
$14.25 +Catering Buffalo Burger
Lettuce, tomato, bleu cheese and Buffalo sauce on a brioche bun. Served with pickles. Spicy.
$13.25 +Catering Philly Burger
A 1/2 lb. burger with Philly cheese steak, mushrooms and onions on a brioche bun. Served with pickles.
$15.25 +Catering Panini (Archived)
Catering Pete's Panini
Your choice of chicken with ricotta cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, arugula and pesto mayo.
$14.25 +Catering Americano Panini
Crispy chicken, chicken tenders, bacon, mozzarella sticks and vodka sauce.
$15.25Catering Chipotle Chicken Panini
Your choice of chicken with bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomato and chipotle mayo.
$14.25Catering Pizzas (Archived)
Catering Calzones and Rolls (Archived)
Catering Cheese Calzone
Choice of a baked or fried calzone. Add toppings for an additional charge. Vegetarian.
$9.25 +Catering Family Size Calzone
Baked family size calzone. Add toppings for an additional charge. Vegetarian.
$20.25 +Catering Francese Roll
$11.25Catering Individual Hot Entrees (Archived)
Catering Eggplant Rollatini for 1
Rolled eggplant stuffed with cheese and tomato sauce. Vegetarian.
$17.25 +Catering Shrimp Parmigiana for 1
$20.25 +Catering Hot Entrees Trays (Archived)
Eggplant Rollatini Tray
Rolled eggplant stuffed with cheese and tomato sauce. Does not include pasta. Vegetarian
$50.00 +