Colby's Ice Cream & Bake Shop
MenuAbout
Colby's Ice Cream & Bake Shop Menu

Colby's Ice Cream & Bake Shop

Coffee and Tea, Donuts
7272 W Henrietta Rd, Rush, NY 14543
(585) 533-3525
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Donuts

Menu powered by Grubhub

Dozen Colby Made Fry Cakes

Plain Chocolate, Glazed Chocolate, Plain Fry cake, Cinnamon Sugar Fry cake, Plain Apple, Cinnamon Sugar Apple, Plain Blueberry, Glazed Blueberry, Plain Red Velvet, Glazed Red Velvet, Plain Sour Cream, Glazed Sour Cream

$14.99

Mixed Dozen Filled & Fry Cakes

Bavarian Cream, Angel Cream, Lemon Filled, Raspberry Filled, Strawberry Filled, Glazed Chocolate, Cinnamon Sugar Fry cake, Apple Cinnamon Sugar, Glazed Sour Cream, Plain Blueberry, Plain Red Velvet, Plain Fry Cake

$17.99

Bakers Dozen Special (Limited Time)

Baker chooses 13 mixed varieties of donuts including our delicious fry cakes and raised donuts

$14.99

Bakers Choice Bag of Donuts

6 of Colby's Homemade Donuts 2 filled, 2 glazed, 2 decorated

$7.99

Fresh Pies

8” Apple Fresh Pies

$10.49

8” Strawberry Rhubarb

$10.49

8” Brownie Caramel Walnut Fresh Pies

Pie Crust fill Brownie filling and caramel walnut topping

$10.49

8” Raspberry Fresh Pies

$10.49

8" Blueberry Fresh Pies

$10.49

8" Cherry Fresh Pies

$10.49

10” Peach Fresh Pies

$12.00

10" Pumpkin Pie

Pie crust filled with pumpkin filling

$12.00

Coffee

12 oz Regular Coffee

12 oz. Fresh Brewed Canandaigua Blend Coffee 2 Creamers & 2 Sugars

$2.00

16 oz Regular Coffee Canandaigua Blend

16 oz. Fresh Brewed Canandaigua Blend Coffee 2 Creamers & 2 Sugars

$2.50

12 oz Decaf Coffee Finger Lakes Decaf

12 oz. Fresh Brewed Canandaigua Blend Coffee 2 Creamers & 2 Sugars

$2.00

16 oz Decaf Coffee

16 oz. Fresh Brewed Finger Lakes Blend Coffee 2 Creamers & 2 Sugars

$2.50

96 oz Coffee Box Canandaigua Blend Coffee

96 oz. Kraft Box, 8 cups, 8 lids, 16 creamers, 16 sugars, 8 stirrers

$19.95

Grab N Go Frozen Food

Pulled Pork

Frozen and requires being microwaved for 5-8 minutes

$6.99

Stuffed Shells & Meatballs

Frozen and requires being microwaved for 5-8 minutes

$6.99

Pulled Beef

Frozen and requires being microwaved for 5-8 minutes

$6.99

Chicken & Biscuits

Frozen and requires being microwaved for 5-8 minutes

$6.99

Ham & Potatoes

Frozen and requires being microwaved for 5-8 minutes

$6.99

Veggie Lasagna

Frozen and requires being microwaved for 5-8 minutes

$6.99

Barbecue Lunch Menu

Pulled Pork Sandwich

$9.99

BBQ Combo Meal

$11.99

Hot Dog

$5.99

Hot Dog Combo

$7.99

Sides

$3.99

Lunch Box BBQ

6 Sandwiches, 6 Sides, & Cornbread

$59.99

Hot Dog & Chips Lunch Box

$29.99

Hot Dog & Sides

Please Select your 6 Sides below

$32.99

Pulled Chicken

$9.99
FYI, this restaurant is only taking phone orders: (585) 533-3525

About Colby's Ice Cream & Bake Shop

  • 7272 W Henrietta Rd, Rush, NY 14543
  • Coffee and Tea, Donuts, Ice Cream
  • (585) 533-3525
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / Colby's Ice Cream & Bake Shop
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.