McWethy's Tavern
Popular menu items
Lunch Pick Two
Soup • Salad • 1/2 Sandwich with Chef-Made Chips Menu Available Daily | 11AM to 4PM
$17.00Snack and Share
'Ellsworth Creamery' Cheese Curds
white cheddar cheese from Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery-Ellsworth, WI + Chef-made marinara sauce
$10.00Jumbo Chicken Wings
breaded bone-in chicken wings + choice of ranch or bleu cheese dipping sauce + celery sticks
$13.00 +Mac N' Cheese
$8.00 +Lunch Pick Two
Lunch Pick Two
Soup • Salad • 1/2 Sandwich with Chef-Made Chips Menu Available Daily | 11AM to 4PM
$17.00Signature Sandwiches
'90 Miles from Cuba'
shaved ham + pulled pork + Swiss cheese + pickle + whole grain mustard aioli + French roll
$14.00 +Italian Beef sandwich
Chef-made Italian roast beef + provolone cheese + roasted peppers + garlic aioli + French roll
$16.00 +McWethy's Burger
Black Angus beef + lettuce + tomatoes + red onion + pickle + garlic aioli + old fashion bun *Niman Ranch - Windsor, WI
$13.00 +Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
lettuce + tomatoes + red onions + pickle + garlic aioli + old fashion bun
$13.00 +Butcher's Steak Sandwich
8oz USDA Prime strip steak + caramelized onions + garlic aioli + arugula + cheddar cheese + roasted red peppers + sunny egg + French roll
$18.00 +Lamb Burger
feta & goat cheese + cumin mayo + olive relish + arugula + asiago black pepper bun
$16.00 +Classic Reuben
corned beef + Swiss cheese + sauerkraut + 1000 island dressing + seeded rye bread
$15.00 +"The Impossible Burger"
Impossible Burger has all the flavor and protein of a beef burger, but it's made from plants, so it has zero cholesterol. lettuce + tomatoes + red onions + pickles + old fashion bun
$16.00 +Patty Melt
Black Angus beef + caramelized onions + Bourbon Street horseradish + American cheese + garlic aioli + seeded rye bread *Niman Ranch - Windsor, WI
$14.00 +Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
crispy chicken + Buffalo sauce + tomatoes + coleslaw + old fashion bun
$14.00 +Tavern Fish Filet Sandwich
fresh hand-cut Icelandic cod + lettuce + tomatoes + Chef-made tartar sauce + B&B pickles + old fashion bun
$15.00 +Entrees and Specialties
Caprese Pesto Bucatini
pesto + bucatini + cherry tomatoes + pearled mozzarella + balsamic glaze + basil
$23.00 +Ale Battered Fish and Chips
fresh hand-cut Icelandic cod + black pepper fries + Chef-made tartar sauce + malt vinegar + lemon
$23.00 +Roasted Half Chicken
Little Farm on the Prairie roasted half chicken + Anson Mills red beans & Carolina gold rice + Chef-made mango jerk sauce + micro cilantro
$25.00 +Faroe Islands Salmon
roasted salmon + sugar & spice blend + fire threshed farro risotto + Marcona almond gremolata
$34.00 +Chicago-Style Shrimp & Grits
Argentinian shrimp + Wapsie Valley gouda grits + Italian sausage + giardiniera + roasted tomato + caramelized onions
$27.00 +FEATURE! Corned Beef & Cabbage
Chef-made corned beef, red skin potatoes, cabbage, glazed carrots.
$25.00Wild Alaskan Halibut
pan seared halibut (Western Bering Sea) + Brussels sprouts + sweet corn hash + tomato bacon vinaigrette
$34.00 +Soups and Salads
Strawberry Salad
quinoa crispies + fresh strawberries + cilantro + red onions + Romaine lettuce + Chef-made pad Thai dressing
$15.00Classic Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce + radicchio + Parmigiana Reggiano + anchovy + ciabatta croutons + Chef-made Caesar dressing
$10.00 +'EAT' Cobb Salad
hard-boiled egg + avocado + tomatoes + grilled chicken + green onions + diced bacon + bleu cheese crumbles + Romaine lettuce
$15.00Marinated Cauliflower Salad
lupini beans + pecorino romano + marinated cauliflower + cherry tomatoes + Romaine lettuce + Chef-made creamy roasted garlic bacon dressing
$15.00Broccoli Salad
broccoli slaw + ginger + crispy noodle + snap peas + edamame + sesame soy vinaigrette
$12.00 +