New York Slices Pizzeria

New York Slices Pizzeria

American, Calzones

1843 2nd St, Highland Park, IL 60035

Loading menu item photos

New York Style Brick Oven Pizza

Menu powered by Grubhub

10" Small Cheese

Feeds 1-2

$15.54 +

16" Large NY Cheese

Feeds 3-4

$21.54 +

20" XL NY Cheese

Feeds 4-6

$25.14 +

Sicilian - Pan Style (allow 1 1/2 hour prep time)

$29.94 +

Grandma's Pizza - Pan Style (Allow 1 1/2 Hour Prep Time)

$29.94 +

20" Pasta Pizza (Baked Penne Pasta on Pie)

$29.94 +

20" Veggie (Spinach, Carmelized Onions, Sauteed Green & Red Peppers)

$31.14 +

20" Spinach & Garlic

$29.94 +

20" NY White Pizza (Ricotta Cheese,Spinach,Tomato & Rosemary - No red Sauce)

$29.94 +

20" Pepperoni & Bacon

$29.94 +

20" Spicy (Pep & Sauaage)

$29.94 +

20" Pie Of The Day

$28.74 +

20" Protein Combo (Pepperoni,Sausage,Meatballs,Chicken)

$33.54 +

20" The Un-Kosher (Smoked Bacon & Cheese)

$28.74 +

20'' Hawaii Five O (Canadian Bacon,Pineapple & Jalapeno)

$29.94 +

20" Meat Lovers (Pepperoni,Sausage,Meatball,Bacon)

$29.94 +

20" Italian Beef Pie (Italian Beef & Giardiniera)

$29.94 +

20" BBQ Chicken Pie (Chicken,Red Onions & BBQ Sauce)

$29.94 +

20�� Pie of the Day(call store for details- at least 3 toppings)

$31.14 +

16" Pasta Pizza (Baked Penne smothered on top)

$23.94 +

16" Veggie (Spinach, Sauteed Onions, Sauteed Green & Red Peppers)

$26.34 +

16" Spinach & Garlic

$25.14 +

16" NY White Pizza (Ricotta Cheese,Spinach,Tomato, Rosemary - No Red Sauce)

$26.34 +

16" Pepperoni & Bacon

$26.34 +

16" Spicy (Spicy Sauce, Pepperoni & Sausage)

$26.34 +

16" Protein Combo (Pepperoni,Sausage,Meatballs,Chicken)

$27.54 +

16" The Un-Kosher (Cheese & Smoked Bacon)

$23.94 +

16" Hawaii Five O (Canadian Bacon, Pineapple, Jalapeno)

$26.34 +

16" Meat Lovers (Pepperoni, Sausage, Meatballs & Smoked Bacon)

$27.54 +

16" Italian Beef Pie (Italian Beef & Giardinera)

$26.34 +

16" BBQ Chicken Pie (Chicken, Red Onions & BBQ Sauce)

$26.34 +

16�� Pie of the Day (call store for details-at least 3 toppings)

$28.74 +

10" Pasta Pizza (Baked Penne Pasta Smothered with Cheese)

$16.74 +

10" Veggie (Spinach, Carmelized Onions, Sauteed Red & Green Peppers)

$17.94 +

10" Spinach & Garlic

$17.94 +

10" NY White Pizza (Ricotta Cheese,Spinach,Tomato & Rosemary-No Red Sauce)

$17.94 +

10" Pepperoni & Bacon

$17.94 +

10" Spicy (Pep & Sausage)

$17.94 +

10" Protein Combo (Pepperoni,Sausage,Meatball,Chicken)

$19.14 +

10" The Un-kosher (Smoked Bacon & Cheese)

$16.74 +

10" Hawaii Five O (Canadian Bacon, Pineapple & Jalapeno)

$17.94 +

10" Meat Lovers (Pepperoni,Sausage,Meatballs,Smoked Bacon)

$19.14 +

10" Italian (Italian Beef & Giardiniera)

$17.94 +

10" BBQ Chicken Pizza (Chicken, Red Onions & BBQ Sauce)

$17.94 +

10�� Pie Of The Day (call store for details- at least 3 toppings)

$20.34 +

SLICES

Cheese Slice

$4.50 +

Pepperoni Slice

$4.74 +

Sausage Slice

$4.74 +

Veggie Slice (Spinach, Sauteed Onions, Green & Red Peppers)

$5.22 +

Pasta Slice (Baked Penne Pasta on Top)

Baked Penne On Top

$4.74 +

Sicilian Slice

$5.22 +

Grandma's Pizza Slice

$5.22 +

1 Slice/Drink

$7.20 +

Marinara

$0.60 +

Ranch Dressing

$0.60 +

CALZONES

Cheese Calzone

$10.74 +

Pepperoni Calzone

$11.94 +

Sausage Calzone

$11.94 +

Spinach & Mushroom Calzone

$13.14 +

Pasta Calzone (Filled w/Baked Penne)

$11.94 +

Veggie Calzone (Spinach, red/green peppers, Carmelized Onions)

$13.14 +

Spinach & Garlic Calzone

$13.14 +

SANDWICHES

Italian Beef

Juicy Italian Beef cooked in Au Jus and baked on a fresh wedge

$9.54

Meatball Sub

Meatballs drenched in NYS Marinara Sauce, Baked on Wedge with Melted Cheese

$9.54

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

Lightly breaded chicken smothered in NYS Marinara sauce and Melted Cheese Baked on a fresh wedge

$9.54

Philly Cheesesteak

Classic Philly cheesesteak sandwich with onions and peppers baked on a fresh wedge

$9.54

ITALBEEF/FF

$11.94

Meatball/FF

$11.94

Chicken Parm/FF

$11.94

Philly/FF

$11.94

Wings N' Things

5 Jumbo Buffalo Wings

Mild-Medium-Spicy

$10.74

10 Jumbo Buffalo Wings

Mild-Medium-Spicy

$19.14

15 Jumbo Buffalo Wings

$27.54

20 Jumbo Buffalo Wings

$35.94

Chicken Fingers

$10.74

Chicken Fingers/FF

$13.14

Fries

$4.74

Jalape��o Popper

$7.14

Mozzarella Sticks

$8.34

PASTA

Penne

$9.54 +

Spaghetti

$9.54 +

Bowtie

$10.74 +

Shells

$9.54 +

Baked Penne w/ Cheese

$11.94 +

House Specialities

Chicken Parm Plate

with Pasta & Garlic Knots

$17.94

Italian Rolls

Think Stromboli- Filled with Caramelized Onions & Cheese. Choice of either Pepperoni, Sausage, or Veggies (saut��ed red & green peppers)

$8.34

Broccoli Swirl

NYS Pizza Dough Baked With A Broccoli & Cheese Center

$8.34

Garlic Knots (Each)

New York Style Garlic Knots

$0.90

Pizza Sliders

4 Small Pizza Sandwiches with Cheese and NYS Sauce. Add Toppings for $.50

$8.34 +

Cheese Fritters

Baked Mozzarella Squares

$1.20

Garlic Knots (4)

$3.60

Salads

Salad

$9.54 +

Side Salad

$7.14 +

NYS Salad Creations

Maddison Square Garden

Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Red Onion, Mozzarella Cheese

$9.54 +

Beverages

San Pellegrino

$3.42

Bottled Water

$2.34

Apple Juice

$2.34

Fountain Drink

$2.70

Arizona Arnold Palmer 1/2 & 1/2

$2.82

Soda Cans

Coca-Cola, Can

Coca-Cola Original Taste �� the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love

$2.34

Diet Coke, Can

Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink

$2.34

Sprite, Can

Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free

$2.34

6 Pack Can

$10.80

Soda Bottles

Mexican Coke

Coca-Cola Original Taste �� the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love

$3.42

Sprechers-Rootbeer

$3.30

Sprechers- Cherry Soda

$3.30

Sprechers- Cream Soda

$3.30

Green River

$3.30

Half Pan

Half Pan Penne w/ Butter

$31.19

Half Pan Penne w/ Sauce

$33.59

Half Pan Spaghetti w/ Butter

$31.19

Half Pan Spaghetti w/ Sauce

$33.59

Full Pan

Full Pan Penne w/ Butter

$53.99

Full Pan Penne w/ Sauce

$56.39

Full Pan Spaghetti w/ Butter

$53.99

Full Pan Spaghetti w/ Sauce

$56.39

Large Pan

Full Pan House Salad

$47.99

Full Pan Caesar Salad

$47.99

Pizza

Cheese Pizza 20" (8 Slices)

$25.14

20" Cheese (12 Cut)

$25.14

20" Cheese (16 Cut)

$25.14

Veggie Pizza 20" (8 Slices)

$29.94

20" Veggie (12 Cut)

$29.94

20" Veggie (16 Cut)

$29.94

Grandma��s Pan Pizza

$29.94

Sicilian Pan Pizza

$29.94

Sandwiches

Italian Beef Sandwich (Catering)

$70.74

Meatball Sandwich (Catering)

$70.74

House Specialties

Veggie Rolls

$9.54

Pepperoni Rolls

$9.54

Sausage Rolls

$9.54

15 Garlic Knots

$12.00

20 Garlic Knots

$18.00

25 Garlic Knots

$24.00

Desserts

1 Dozen Chocolate Chip Cookies

$33.60

Restaurant closed

.

About New York Slices Pizzeria

1843 2nd St, Highland Park, IL 60035
American, Calzones, Dinner, Lunch Specials, Pasta, Pizza, Sandwiches
(847) 432-6979

Powered by Grubhub

Home / IL / Highland Park / New York Slices Pizzeria

About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info

© 2026 Grubhub Holdings Inc.