The Brooklyn Firefly
Popular menu items
86th Street SMALL
12" Pie - tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, grana padano, fresh basil
$21.00 +Sausage & Pepper
sweet or spicy sausage, shredded mozzarella, caramelized onions, sauteed green peppers, topped with garlic aioli
$20.00 +MEATBALL
Mama's Meatball
one large beef meatball stuffed with fresh mozzarella with tomato sauce & ricotta
$17.00RICE BALLS
Spinach Mushroom Rice Balls
rice, spinach & mushroom with arugula, walnut pesto ricotta with a side of pesto ricotta (Three rice balls to an order.)
$16.00Prosciutto Balls
fresh mozzarella, ricotta, & prosciutto served with a side of tomato sauce (Three prosciutto balls to an order)
$17.00The Big Ragu Rice Balls
Aunt Margie’s Recipe - rice, ground beef, peas & carrots with a side of tomato sauce. . (Three rice balls to an order.)
$16.00FIRE FRIES
Fire Fries - Lemon Ricotta
twice cooked crispy new potatoes with fresh herbs served with a side of lemon ricotta
$14.00Fire Fries - Truffle
twice cooked crispy new potatoes with fresh herbs topped with truffle oil & grana padano
$16.00Fire Fries - garlic aoli
twice cooked crispy new potatoes with fresh herbs served with a side of garlic aioli
$14.00PIZZA PIES
Lentos Ghost
super thin crispy crust, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, grana padano, fresh basil
$24.00 +Lentos Ghost SMALL
12" Pie - super thin crispy crust, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, grana padano, fresh basil
$17.00 +Buffalo Gal SMALL
12" Pie - chicken, fresh mozzarella, cognac gorgonzola cream sauce, hot sauce
$23.00 +86th Street SMALL
12" Pie - tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, grana padano, fresh basil
$21.00 +The Lord of Brooklyn
tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, smoked ricotta, sweet & spicy Italian sausage
$32.00 +The Lord of Brooklyn SMALL
12" Pie - tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, smoked ricotta, sweet & spicy Italian sausage
$23.00 +Sweet Sunday
cognac gorgonzola cream sauce, fresh mozzarella, sweet Italian sausage, honey, balsamic reduction
$32.00 +Sweet Sunday SMALL
12" pie -cognac gorgonzola cream sauce, fresh mozzarella, sweet Italian sausage, honey, balsamic reduction
$23.00 +The Bad Racket SMALL
12" Pie - vodka sauce, mozzarella, smoked ricotta, sweet peas, prosciutto
$23.00 +The Kick in the A$$
tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, hot sausage, red onion, jalapeño, hot honey, cilantro
$32.00 +The Kick in the A$$ SMALL
12" Pie - tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, hot sausage, red onion, jalapeño, hot honey, cilantro
$23.00 +Saturday Night Fever Pie
tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, hot honey, hot soppressata & caramelized onions
$32.00 +Saturday Night Fever SMALL
12" Pie - tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, hot honey, hot soppressata & caramelized onions
$23.00 +White Pie
fresh mozzarella, ricotta, olive oil, house seasoning, fresh basil (white pie - no tomato sauce)
$24.00 +White Pie SMALL
12" Pie - fresh mozzarella, ricotta, olive oil, house seasoning fresh basil (white pie - no tomato sauce)
$17.00 +The Shrooms SMALL
12" Pie - fresh mozzarella, fontina cheese, mushrooms, truffle oil (white pie - no tomato sauce)
$23.00 +Scalabesh White Pie
cognac gorgonzola cream sauce, fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, figs (no tomato sauce)
$32.00 +Scalabesh SMALL
12" Pie - cognac gorgonzola cream sauce, fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, dried figs (white pie - no tomato sauce)
$23.00 +Verrazano Boy Pie
arugula walnut pesto ricotta, fresh mozzarella, arugula, cherry tomatoes, pear (no tomato sauce)
$30.00 +Verrazano Boy SMALL
12" Pie - arugula walnut pesto ricotta, fresh mozzarella, arugula, cherry tomatoes, pear (white pie - no tomato sauce)
$21.00 +Personal VEGAN Margarita
$15.00 +Personal VEGAN Shore Road
$16.00 +VEGAN Margarita
$24.00 +VEGAN Shore Road
$28.00 +VEGAN Square
$22.00 +VEGAN PIZZA PIES
Vegan Margarita
tomato sauce, house-made vegan mozzarella, fresh basil Large Pie 16" [OUR HOUSE-MADE VEGAN MOZZARELLA IS NUT FREE & DAIRY FREE! ]
$24.00 +Vegan Margarita SMALL
tomato sauce, house-made vegan mozzarella, fresh basil Personal Pie 12" [OUR HOUSE-MADE VEGAN MOZZARELLA IS NUT FREE & DAIRY FREE! ]
$17.00 +Vegan Square Pie
sunday sauce, house-made vegan, mozzarella, fresh basil [OUR HOUSE-MADE VEGAN MOZZARELLA IS NUT FREE & DAIRY FREE! ]
$26.00 +The Shore Road [VEGAN]
tomato sauce, house-made vegan mozzarella, mushrooms, caramelized onions, fresh basil Large Pie 16" [OUR HOUSE-MADE VEGAN MOZZARELLA IS NUT FREE & DAIRY FREE! ]
$26.00 +The Shore Road SMALL [VEGAN]
tomato sauce, house-made vegan, mozzarella, mushrooms, caramelized onions Personal Pie 12" [OUR HOUSE-MADE VEGAN MOZZARELLA IS NUT FREE & DAIRY FREE! ]
$19.00 +92nd Street [VEGAN]
16" LARGE PIE - tomato sauce, house-made vegan mozzarella, vegan pepperoni, fresh basil [OUR HOUSE-MADE VEGAN MOZZARELLA IS NUT FREE & DAIRY FREE! ]
$26.0092nd Street SMALL [VEGAN]
12" PIE - tomato sauce, house-made vegan mozzarella, vegan pepperoni, fresh basil [OUR HOUSE-MADE VEGAN MOZZARELLA IS NUT FREE & DAIRY FREE! ]
$19.00 +Ernie Barry [VEGAN]
tomato sauce, house-made vegan mozzarella, vegan pepperoni, sauteed peppers,artichokes, black olives, fresh basil [OUR HOUSE-MADE VEGAN MOZZARELLA & RICOTTA ARE NUT FREE & DAIRY FREE! ]
$32.00 +Ernie Barry SMALL [VEGAN]
12" PIE - tomato sauce, house-made vegan mozzarella, vegan pepperoni, sauteed peppers,artichokes, black olives, fresh basil [OUR HOUSE-MADE VEGAN MOZZARELLA IS NUT FREE & DAIRY FREE! ]
$23.00 +San Gennaro [VEGAN]
arugula walnut pesto, vegan sausage, house-made vegan mozzarella, house-made vegan ricotta, caramelized onions, sautéed green peppers, topped with roasted red pepper sauce
$32.00 +San Gennaro SMALL [VEGAN]
12" Personal PIe arugula walnut pesto, vegan sausage, house-made vegan mozzarella, house-made vegan ricotta, caramelized onions, sautéed green peppers, topped with roasted red pepper sauce
$23.00Crumble Rumble [VEGAN]
tomato sauce, vegan beef crumble, house-made vegan mozzarella, house-made vegan ricotta, fresh basil
$32.00Crumble Rumble PERSONAL [VEGAN]
tomato sauce, vegan beef crumble, house-made vegan mozzarella, house-made vegan ricotta, fresh basil
$23.00CALZONES
The Blaze Burger Calzone
ground beef, cognac gorgonzola cream sauce, caramelized onions, shredded mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, garlic aoili served with a side of fire fries
$24.00Sausage & Pepper
sweet or spicy sausage, shredded mozzarella, caramelized onions, sauteed green peppers, topped with garlic aioli
$20.00 +VEGAN CALZONES
Sausage & Pepper [VEGAN]
arugula walnut pesto, house-made vegan mozzarella, house-made vegan ricotta, vegan sausage, caramelized onions, sautéed green peppers, topped with roasted red pepper sauce
$20.00 +The Crumble Calzone [VEGAN]
vegan meat crumble, vegan blue cheese sauce*, caramelized onions, house-made vegan mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, vegan garlic aioli* served with a side of FIRE FRIES (*vegan blue cheese sauce & vegan aioli contain cashews)
$24.00 +SANDWICHES
Chicken Cuzzie
chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella on an Italian hero with choice of sauce (tomato sauce or cognac gorgonzola cream sauce)
$17.00SALADS
Kale House Salad
Shredded kale, carrots, radish, fennel, crispy prosciutto, red cabbage, pickled eggs and toasted almond vinaigrette.
$14.00 +SWEET STUFF
Aunt Butchie's Cheesecake Cone
hand rolled almond sugar cone filled with creamy New York cheesecake.
$10.00Aunt Butchie's Chocolate Mousse Cake
chocolate mousse filling and topped with rich dark chocolate ganache
$12.00TiRAWmisu [PLANT-BASED]
delectably rich & creamy, yet fluffy with the perfect dose of strong espresso, tastes just like classic, sinfully delicious tiramisu (*contains almonds & cashews) **[Raw, Vegan, Dairy-Free, Gluten-Free, Soy-Free, Paleo Friendly, Zero Refined Sugar, 100% Natural Ingredients]
$14.00Trisome [PLANT-BASED]
a magnificent chocolate chip crust layered under a smooth, rich vanilla cream, topped by a perfect layer of refreshing mixed berries and finished with a drizzle of dark chocolate sauce & tangy freeze-dried raspberries. (*contains cashews) **[Raw, Vegan, Dairy-Free, Gluten-Free, Soy-Free, Paleo Friendly, Zero Refined Sugar, 100% Natural Ingredients]
$12.00Banana Dark Chocolate Pie [PLANT-BASED]
Deep, velvety dark chocolate with a hint of banana makes this pie unstoppable - you’ll enjoy every bite! (*contains cashews) **[Raw, Vegan, Dairy-Free, Gluten-Free, Soy-Free, Paleo Friendly, Zero Refined Sugar, 100% Natural Ingredients]
$12.00