The Original Goodfellas

The Original Goodfellas

Dinner, Italian

4029 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10308

Loading menu item photos

Pizzas

Menu powered by Grubhub

NY Style Cheese Pizza

$13.20 +

Old World Cheese Pizza

$13.20 +

Vodka Pizza

$18.15 +

Smoking Goodfella

$18.15 +

Caldo E Dolce

$18.15 +

Buffalo Chicken

$18.15 +

White Clam Pie

$18.15 +

Smokin Hots

$18.15 +

Roasted Vegetable

$18.15 +

Pesto Artichoke Tomato

$18.15 +

Tequila Sunrise

$18.15 +

Quattro Formaggi

$18.15 +

Pizza Bianca

$18.15 +

Arugula Bianca

$18.15 +

Porcini Arugula

$18.15 +

Grandma Pizza

$24.20

Puntanesca

$18.15 +

Rolls

Chicken Parm

$13.20 +

Vodka Chicken

$13.20 +

Fresh Spinach

$13.20 +

Sausage & Peppers

$13.20 +

Pepperoni

$13.20 +

Calzones

$13.20 +

Appetizers

Goodfella's Buffalo-Style Chicken Wings (6)

$14.85

Garlic Knots

$6.60 +

Homemade Mozzarella 'N Carrozza

$15.95 +

Goodfellas Baked Clams (10)

$18.15 +

Mussels Marinara

$20.35 +

Homemade, Mozzarella, Tomato & Basil

$15.40 +

Stuffed Mushrooms (6)

$13.75 +

Bruschetta

$11.00 +

Octopus Carpaccio

$23.10 +

2 Stuffed Long Hots

$15.95 +

Smoked Burrata

$16.50 +

Fried Zucchini

$13.75 +

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail

$19.80 +

Goodfella's Famous Fried Calamari

$18.15 +

Sides

Baby Spinach

$7.70

Broccoli Rabe

$9.90

Meatballs (3)

$13.20

Sausage (2)

$8.80

Rstd Vegetables

$8.80

Italian Heroes

Chicken Parmigiana

$16.50 +

Meatball Parmigiana

$16.50 +

Eggplant Parmigiana

$16.50 +

The Goodfella's Italian Cold Cut Sandwich

$16.50 +

Grilled Chicken Broccoli Rabe

$16.50 +

Grilled Chicken Caesar

$16.50 +

Stuffed Brick Oven Pitas

Grilled Vegetable

$15.40

Chicken Caesar

$15.40

Grilled Chicken Strawberry Wallnut

$15.40

Salads

Strawberry Mesclun Salad

$14.85 +

Goodfella's House Salad

$12.10 +

Caesar Salad

$13.20 +

Baby Arugula Salad

$15.95 +

Soups

Our Famous Lobster Bisque

$9.90

Housemade Minestrone

$7.70

Entrees

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana

$28.60

Bone-In Veal Parmigiana

$37.40

Eggplant Parmigiana

$26.40

Chicken Francese

$27.50

Chicken Marsala

$27.50

Steak & Chops

Filet Mignon 10oz

$55.00

Duck Fat Infused Porkchop

$33.00

New York Strip 16oz

$49.50

Pork Shank Ossobuco

$36.30

Porter House 40oz

$121.00

Fresh Housemade Pasta

Penne Vodka

$20.35 +

Bucatini & Meatballs Or Sausage

$20.35 +

Ravioli (8)

$18.15 +

Four Baked Cheese Rigatoni

$20.35 +

Cacio E Pepe

$19.80 +

Cavatelli

$24.75 +

Lobster Raviolis & Jumbo Shrimp

$37.40 +

Seafood

Shrimp Rhomolus

$30.80

Red Snapper

$31.90

Mediterranean Salmon

$31.90

Mussels Pomodoro

$30.80

Linguini White Clam Sauce

$28.60

Shrimp Marinara

$33.00

Fra Diavolo

$33.00

Frutti Di Mare

$37.40

Shrimp Francese

$33.55

Desserts

Tiramisu

$8.80

NY Cheesecake

$7.70

Pistachio Tartufo

$8.80

Tartufo

$8.80

Toasted Almond

$8.80

Chocolate Cake

$8.80

Limoncello Flute

$8.80

Cannoli

$6.60

Brownie

$8.80

Nutella Calzone

$13.20

Apple Pizza

$19.80

Drink

Coke

$1.65 +

Diet Coke

$1.65 +

Sprite

$1.65 +

Orange

$1.65

Seltzer

$1.65

Gingerale

$1.65

Snapple

$2.75

San Pellegrino

$8.80

Stewarts

$3.30

Bottled Water

$1.95

FYI, this restaurant is not accepting orders right now.

About The Original Goodfellas

4029 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10308
Dinner, Italian, Lunch Specials, Pasta, Pizza, Salads, Sandwiches, Soup, Wraps
(718) 987-2422

Powered by Grubhub

Home / NY / Staten Island / The Original Goodfellas

About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info

© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.