The Original Goodfellas
MenuAbout
The Original Goodfellas Menu

The Original Goodfellas

Dinner, Italian
4029 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10308
(718) 987-2422
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Popular menu items

Menu powered by Grubhub

Pizza Alla Vodka

Fresh mozzarella, our famous tomato cream vodka sauce, seasoned fresh mushrooms, pea and prosciutto di Roma tomatoes.

$16.50 +

Beverages

Can Soda

$1.50

2 Liter Soda

$3.50

Bottled Water

$1.50

Snapple Ice T

$2.50

Stewarts Sodas

$3.00

Starters

4 Piece Homemade Mozzarella and Carrozza

Fresh mozzarella cheese between two pieces of bread, breaded and lightly fried. Served with marinara sauce.

$14.50

Goodfella's Famous Fried Calamari

Always tender, crisp and light. Served with lemon wedges and our famous Goodfella's sauce.

$16.00 +

Goodfella's Baked Clams (10)

A dozen beautifully baked clams served with fresh lemon wedges.

$16.50

Mussels Marinara

A lb. of cultured mussels sauteed with garlic, sherry wine and plum tomato strips.

$18.50

Goodfella's Buffalo-Style Chicken Wings (6)

Delightfully seasoned and spicy.

$13.50

Homemade Mozzarella, Tomato, & Basil

Thick slices of fresh mozzarella and fresh tomato, with a garnish of basil and a drizzle of our seasoned olive oil.

$14.00 +

Bruschetta

Diced tomato, onion, herbs and garlic marinated with extra virgin olive oil, served over grilled garlic toast.

$10.00

Chicken Fingers

A great starter for the kids. Served with honey mustard.

$10.00

Homemade Garlic Bread

$5.00

Stuffed Mushrooms

$12.50

Buratta

served over arugula, roasted pepper pesto, balsamic fig reduction

$15.00

Fried Zucchini

lightly breaded and fried, served with marinara sauce

$12.50

Octopus Carpaccio

Thin sliced octopus, drizzled with balsamic fig glaze, garnished with olives and tomato.

$21.00

Panko Fried Soft Shell Crab

served with mango habanero

$12.00

Stuffed Long Hots

2 long hots stuffed with sweet sausage and smoked mozzarella, and baked in our wood fired oven.

$14.50

Soup and Salad

Strawberry Mesclun Salad

Fresh mesclun greens with strawberries, candied wallnuts and homemade mozzarella tossed with honey balsamic.

$13.50

Goodfella's House Salad

Mixed greens, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, carrots, red cabbage and croutons.

$11.00 +

Caesar Salad

Crisp romaine lettuce combined with our freshly made Caesar dressing, topped with shredded Pecorino Romano and croutons.

$12.00 +

Grilled Salmon Salad

Filet of salmon over Goodfella's fresh garden greens with raspberry vinaigrette.

$17.00

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Strips of breaded chicken cutlet marinated in a hot and fiery wing sauce with fresh garden vegetables and shredded mozzarella tossed in bleu cheese dressing.

$15.00

Our Famous Lobster Bisque Soup

Delicious bits of lobster in an incredible cream bisque.

$9.00

Minestrone Soup

Fresh made minestrone made with organic vegetables.

$7.00

Baby Arugula Salad

Baby arugula tossed with candied walnuts, goat cheese, green apple, and craisins, served with raspberry fig reduction dressing

$14.00

Dinner Pasta

Goodfella's Famous Rigatonialla Vodka Sauce

Rigatoni pasta served with our famous tomato cream vodka sauce, peas and diced prosciutto.

$18.50

Mussels Marinara Linguini

A lb. of cultured mussels sauteed with garlic, sherry wine and plum tomato strips served over a generous bed of linguini.

$27.00

Cavatelli with Broccoli Rabe and Sausage

Sauteed broccoli rabe with white wine, garlic, sausage and sun-dried tomatoes, served over a generous bed of penne pasta.

$22.50

Baked Rigatoni - 4 cheeses

Mozzarella, Ricotta, Asiago, and Provolone baked Rigatoni

$18.50

Shrimp Romulus with Lobster Sauce

Jumbo shrimp sauteed with a delicate cream sauce, served over fresh made bucatini

$28.00

Linguini and Baby Clams

Baby clams and fresh little necks sauteed with olive oil, white wine, fresh parsley and garlic served over a bed of linguini.

$28.00

Fresh Bucatini and Meatballs

Freshly prepared meatballs served over a mound of bucatini and our famous marinara sauce.

$18.50

Bucatini and Sausage

Freshly prepared sausage served over a mound of bucatini and our famous marinara sauce.

$18.50

Fresh Cheese Ravioli

Round jumbo ravioli stuffed with fresh ricotta cheese and served with goodfella's smooth marinara sauce.

$18.00

Cacio e Peppe

Fresh made spaghetti in a light imported romano cream with fresh ground black pepper

$18.00

Dinner Entrees

Wood Fired 10 oz Filet Mignon

10 oz Filet Mignon seared in our 900 degree wood fired oven, served with roasted potato and roasted vegetables

$40.00

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana

Tender breasts of chicken breaded and lightly fried. Topped with fresh mozzarella and our smooth marinara sauce. Served with your choice of pasta or roasted vegetables.

$24.00

Chicken Francese

Tender breast of chicken lightly floured, dipped in egg, sauteed in white wine, lemon and butter. Served with your choice of pasta or roasted vegetables.

$24.00

Chicken Marsala

Tender breasts of chicken, sauteed with Marsala wine and fresh seasoned mushrooms. Served with your choice of pasta or roasted vegetables.

$24.00

Chicken Balsamico

Diced chicken breasts sauteed with mushrooms and sun-dried tomatoes in a balsamic vinegar reduction served over a mound of angel hair pasta.

$15.99

Eggplant Parmigiana

Tender pieces of lightly fried eggplant topped with fresh mozzarella and our smooth marinara sauce, served with your choice of pasta or roasted vegetables.

$18.00

Bone in Veal Parmigiana

Bone in Veal Parm served with pasta or roasted vegetable

$42.00

Shrimp Marinara

Jumbo shrimp sauteed with white wine, garlic and marinara sauce served over linguini.

$28.00

Frutti Di Mare

Jumbo shrimp, clams, mussels and calamari sauteed with olive oil, garlic, fresh basil and marinara sauce. Served over generous bed of linguini.

$32.50

16 oz NY Strip Steak

CAB 16 oz NY Strip seared in our brick oven at 900 degrees, served with wood fired potato and vegetables

$38.00

Duck Fat Infused Pork Chop

12 oz bone in duck fat infused pork chop seared in our brick oven, served with roasted vegetable and potato

$30.00

Pork Shank Ossobuco

Tender Pork Shank served over a safron risotto

$33.00

Red Snapper

Broiled in blush wine and butter, served with risotto

$29.00

Mediterranean Salmon

Fresh Atlantic Salmon fired in the brick oven with tomato, capers, onions, sun dried tomato, olives and artichokes

$29.00

Shrimp Francese

Jumbo shrimp francese served with fresh made linguini

$30.50

Specialty Pizzas

Pizza Alla Vodka

Fresh mozzarella, our famous tomato cream vodka sauce, seasoned fresh mushrooms, pea and prosciutto di Roma tomatoes.

$16.50 +

World's Best Pizza Smoking Goodfella

Smoked mozzarella, roasted red pepper cream sauce, roasted red, yellow and green peppers, sausage and onions, topped with imported Pecorino Romano and basil.

$16.50 +

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Imported provolone, fresh mozzarella, creamy Buffalo sauce, breaded chicken and garnished with bruschetta tomatoes and blue cheese crumbles.

$16.50 +

Clam Pie Oreganata

Fresh mozzarella, baby clams and our gourmet bread crumbs seasoned and baked to perfection.

$16.50 +

Putanesca

Plum tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, sun dried tomato, calamata olives, capers, mushrooms and artichokes

$16.50 +

Quattro Formaggi Pizza

Four seasons. Fresh mozzarella, our famous plum tomato sauce and a delicious blend of imported provolone, fontina and Pecorino Romano.

$16.50 +

Pizza Bianca

White pie with prosciutto di parma. A classic pizza smothered with fresh mozzarella, ricotta cheese, Romano cheese and topped with prosciutto di parma.

$16.50 +

Porccini Arugula

Fresh mozzarella and porccini marsala cream sauce, freshly seasoned sliced mushrooms, arugula, truffle oil

$16.50 +

Arugula Bianca Pizza

Fresh mozzarella and roasted garlic, topped with baby arugula, prosciutto di parma, and parmigiano reggiano. Drizzled with truffle oil.

$16.50 +

Grandma Pie

A thin crispy crust square made with imported Italian tomatoes, shredded mozzarella, fresh basil and Pecorino Romano cheese. Cut in nine slices.

$22.00

Gluten-free Pizza

12-inch individually made with imported Italian tomatoes and fresh mozzarella.

$14.00

Caldo e Dolce (Hot Honey)

Fresh mozzarella and plum tomato, topped with pepperoni and soppressata, drizzled with Mikes Hot Honey

$16.50 +

Roasted Vegetable

Roasted pepper cream sauce and fresh mozzarella, topped with roasted pepper, onions, garlic, and mushrooms

$16.50 +

Italian Heroes and Wraps

Chicken Parmigiana Hero

Tender chicken breast lightly breaded and fried topped with fresh mozzarella and marinara sauce. Served on our homemade brick oven bread.

$15.00

Meatball Parmigiana Hero

Topped with fresh mozzarella and marinara sauce. Served on our homemade brick oven bread with a side of fries.

$15.00

Eggplant Parmigiana Hero

Thin slices of eggplant, breaded and lightly fried topped with fresh mozzarella and marinara sauce. Served on our homemade brick oven bread with a side of fries.

$15.00

Italian Cold Cut Sandwich

Prosciutto, Salami, Provolone, Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers, Tomato, Lettuce, Creamy Italian Dressing

$15.00

Grilled Chicken Broccoli Rabe Hero

topped with smoked mozzarella

$15.00

Grilled Chicken Caesar Hero

Grilled Chicken, romaine lettuce, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, Caesar dressing

$15.00

Brick Oven Pizzas

Individual Brick Oven Pizza

Our old world pizza is made with fresh mozzarella and topped with imported Italian tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil and Pecorino Romano baked to perfection in our wood-fried brick oven and topped with fresh basil. Four slices.

$12.00 +

Large Brick Oven Pizza

Our old world pizza is made with fresh mozzarella and topped with imported Italian tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil and Pecorino Romano baked to perfection in our wood-fried brick oven and topped with fresh basil. Eight slices.

$20.50 +

Calzone

Made with fresh mozzarella and ricotta cheese

$12.00 +

Small NY Style Pizza

Our semolina dough, plum tomato and shredded mozzarella blend baked in a wood-fired brick oven

$12.00 +

Large NY Style Pizza

Our semolina dough, plum tomato and shredded mozzarella blend baked in a wood-fired brick oven

$20.50 +

Goodfella's Sides

Fresh Sauteed Baby Spinach

sauteed in garlic and extra virgin olive oil

$8.00

Sauteed Broccoli Rabe with Garlic and Oil

$8.00

3 Meatballs

served in marinara sauce

$9.00

2 Sausage

served in marinara sauce

$8.00

Sauteed Vegetables

carrots, broccoli, zucchini, and cauliflower sauteed in a garlic, oil, and white wine ]

$8.00

Children's Menu

Kid's Chicken Fingers

$8.00

Kid's Cheese Ravioli

$6.00

Kid's Spaghetti and Meatballs

$6.00

Kid's Pizza

$7.00 +

Lunch Specials

Penne Vodka Lunch Special

Fresh made Penne pasta served in a rich Vodka Cream sauce with peas and prosciutto

$16.00

4 Cheese Baked Rigatoni

$16.00

Cheese Ravioli

$16.00

Bucatini With Meatballs

$16.00

Cavatelli Broccoli Rabe Sausage

$16.00

Chickeen Parm Lunch Special

served with fresh pasta

$16.00

Chicken Francese

Served with fresh made pasta

$16.00

Chicken Marsala

Served with fresh made pasta

$16.00

Eggplant Parm

Served with fresh made pasta

$16.00

Grilled Salmon with Potato and Spinach

$16.00
Restaurant closed
.

About The Original Goodfellas

  • 4029 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10308
  • Dinner, Italian, Lunch Specials, Pasta, Pizza, Salads, Sandwiches, Soup, Wraps
  • (718) 987-2422
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / Staten Island / The Original Goodfellas
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.