Untamed Sandwiches (Prospect St)
MenuAbout
Untamed Sandwiches (Prospect St) Menu

Untamed Sandwiches (Prospect St)

Dinner, Lunch Specials
60 Prospect St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
(718) 360-2956
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

WINTER PLATES

Menu powered by Grubhub

Chaljeri Grass Fed Beef Brisket

$13.00

Freebird Chicken Tinga

$11.00

Heritage Farms Cider Braised Pork Butt

$12.50

Vegetable Plate

$10.50

Untamed Test Kitchen Special: Chaljeri Meats Lamb Meatballs

Note: Meatballs contain cheese and breadcrumbs

$13.00

Sandwiches/Salads

Sloppy Gringo

Salsa verde braised squash, black bean hummus, cilantro, red onion and crispy tortillas.

$10.50 +

General Zapata

Chicken tinga, queso fresco, pickled onions, pickled jalapenos, cilantro and radishes.

$11.00 +

The Butt

Cider braised pork butt, broccoli rabe, pepper jelly, Dijon mustard and sharp cheddar.

$12.50 +

Nettle Neck

Braised lamb neck, walnut nettle pesto, Gruyere cheese, pickled spring onions and charred onion tops.

$13.50 +

Carla Bruni

Ciambotta style braised vegetables, goat cheese, olive spread and basil.

$10.50 +

Hot Goldie

Beer braised beef brisket, sweet and sour cabbage, red onions and black pepper aioli.

$13.00 +

Sheemakers Bounty

Charred broccoli, fried almond butter, pickled raisin jelly and cress

$9.50 +

Special Sandwich: Chupacabra

Red wine braised goat, chermoula roast carrots, kohlrabi slaw, red onion, and whipped goat cheese.

$15.00 +

Special Sandwich: Sloppy Gringo

salsa verde braised squash, black bean hummus, cilantro, red onions, crispy tortillas. *$1 from every sandwich sold will benefit the Appalachian Trail Conservancy, which protects and maintains one of the most important outdoor spaces in the US

$10.50 +

Special Sandwich: Red Dreidel

Habanero braised duck, pickled radicchio, Gruyere cheese, hot hot jam.

$15.00 +

Mamma Formaggio

white wine braised lamb neck, mint ricotta, pickled carrots, fried lasagna

$14.00 +

Sheemakers Bounty

charred broccoli, fried almond butter, pickled raisin jelly, cress

$10.00 +

Roasted cauliflower farro salad

Cauliflower,pickled onion, farro, olive oil

$4.50 +

Bonita Applebum

Barbecue braised pork , apple gravy , red radish, pickled green beans, red onion, and aged cheddar

$13.00 +

Untamed Test Kitchen Special: Lamb Dominik

Chaljeri Meats Grass Fed Lamb Meatballs, Marinara, Tzatziki, fresh herbs

$13.00

Untamed Test Kitchen Special: Dumbo "Cheesesteak" (Vegetarian)

Roast winter mushrooms with rosemary, carmelized onions, housemade cheese "whiz", sage

$11.00

Brunch

Ol' Grumpy

Soft scrambled egg, grass-fed beef chili, pimento cheese, hot hot jam and cilantro.

$8.00 +

Jaclyn Park

Sunny-side egg, cider braised pork butt, cheddar, dilly beans and black pepper aioli.

$8.00 +

The Giula

Sunny-side egg, ciabotta style veggies, olive spread and basil.

$7.00 +

Toots Toastie

Grandaisy roll and choice of spread.

$4.50 +

Untamed Granola

Housemade granola, yogurt, seasonal jam

$6.00

Soup

Grumpys Chilli

Spicy Grass-Fed Beef Chili, served with side of pimento cheese toast.

$6.50 +

Extra Pimento Cheese Toast

$1.00

Butternut Squash, Aleppo Pepper

$2.50 +

Sweet Potato Soup, Aleppo Pepper

$4.50 +

Cauliflower Soup

Garnished with aleppo pepper.

$4.75 +

Cremini Mushroom Soup

With olive oil and mixed herbs.

$4.50 +

Grumpy's Chili

Spicy grass-fed beef and black bean chili, served with a side of pimento cheese toast

$6.50 +

Lentil Soup

Red chief lentils, charred onions, nice olive oil

$4.50 +

Sweet Potato Cilantro

Sweet potatoes, Cilantro, Aleppo

$4.50 +

Tomato poblano soup

Golden brown garlic, charred onion, grilled poblano peppers and aged cheddar

$5.00 +

Untamed Test Kitchen Special: Free Range Chicken Bone Broth (8 oz cup)

$4.00

Sides

Cremini Mushroom Pasta Salad

cremini mushroom pate, sunflower seeds, champagne vinaigrette

$4.75 +

Cheddar Jalapeno Grits

$4.75 +

Jersey Tomatoes

ricotta, basil, olive oil, red onion, turkish chili pepper

$6.00

Sliced Dill Pickles

$4.75 +

Route 11 Potato Chips

$2.50

House-Made Grass Fed Beef Jerky

$4.50

Hot House Cucumbers

Cucumbers in a habanero oil

$4.75 +

Pickled Beets

Cumin Yogurt

$4.50 +

Spicy Braised Mustard Greens

$4.75 +

Guacamole

8 oz container with housemade tortilla chips

$6.50

Roasted Garlic Quinoa

Roasted garlic, charrred onion and quinoa

$4.75 +

Untamed Test Kitchen Special: Multicolored baby carrots with fennel and coriander

$4.50 +

Untamed Test Kitchen Special: Broccolini with Honey Tahini and Black and White Sesame Seeds

$4.50 +

Desserts

Walnut Chocolate Chip Cookie

$2.25

S'mores Cookie

$2.25

Aleppo Peanut Butter Cookie

$2.25

Drinks

Blackberry Lemonade

$3.00

Serendipitea Iced Tea

$3.00

Virgil's Root Beer

$3.00

Virgil's Zero Root Beer

$3.00

Reed's Extra Ginger Brew

$3.00

Saratoga Spring Water

$2.50

Saratoga Sparkling Water

$3.00

Brooklyn Roasting Coffee

$2.50 +

Bottled Soda

Please contact restaurant for selection.

$2.50

Brooklyn Roasting Cold Brew

$4.00

Bruce Cost Ginger Ale

$3.00

Housemade Black Iced Tea

$3.00

Puck's Natural Fountain Soda

Please contact restaurant for selection.

$2.00

Saratoga Spring Water

$2.25

Seriously Unsweetened Flavored Sparkling Water

$3.00 +

Sparkling Seltzer

$3.00

Virgil's Cola

$3.00

Virgil's Soda

$3.00

Brooklyn Roasting Cold Brew

Dark roast cold brew.

$4.00

Virgil's Cola

$3.00
FYI, this restaurant is not accepting orders right now.

About Untamed Sandwiches (Prospect St)

Info

Braised meat sandwiches, salads and plates made with sustainable ingredients, as well as a few braised vegetarian sandwiches, salads and plates too!

  • 60 Prospect St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
  • Dinner, Lunch Specials, Sandwiches
  • (718) 360-2956
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / Brooklyn / Untamed Sandwiches (Prospect St)
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.