172 Presbyterian Deli
MenuAbout
172 Presbyterian Deli Menu

172 Presbyterian Deli

American, Bodega
1230 St Nicholas Ave, New York, NY 10030
(212) 685-1230
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Breakfast Plates

Menu powered by Grubhub

13. Eggs any Style

Two eggs any style.

$4.99 +

14. Cheese Omelette

$6.99 +

15. Turkey Omelette

$7.99 +

16. Mushroom Omelette

$6.99 +

17. Vegetable Omelette

Green pepper, tomato and onion.

$7.99 +

18. Lorraime Omelette

Bacon and onion.

$7.99 +

19. Garden Omelette

Broccoli, spinach and tomato with home fries and toast.

$9.99 +

20. Western Omelette

Turkey ham, onion and pepper with home fries and toast.

$9.99 +

21. Meat Lover Omelette

Beef bacon, turkey ham, beef sausage with home fries and toast.

$11.99 +

22. Greek Omelette

Spinach, tomato and feta cheese with home fries.

$9.99 +

23. Breakfast Burritos

Beef or turkey bacon, beef or turkey sausage, egg and cheese with home fries in a wrap.

$9.99 +

24. Power Breakfast Wrap

Egg whites, Swiss cheese, turkey and tomato.

$8.99 +

25. Pancakes

Syrup and butter on the side

$6.99 +

25. French Toast

Syrup and butter

$6.99 +

26. Banana Pancakes

Syrup and butter

$7.99 +

26. Strawberry Pancakes

Syrup and butter

$7.99 +

27. Smoked Salmon Bagel

Cream cheese, tomato, onion and cucumber.

$5.99 +

27. Chocolate chip pancakes

Syrup and butter on the side.

$7.99 +

Breakfast Sandwiches

B.E.C

Beacon, scramble eggs and cheese.

$5.99 +

1. Egg Sandwich

$2.99 +

2. Egg & Cheese Sandwich

$3.99 +

3. Egg & Potatoes Sandwich

$5.49 +

4. Egg & Turkey Sandwich

$5.49 +

5. Egg & Turkey Bacon Sandwich

$5.49 +

6. Egg & Beef Bacon Sandwich

$5.49 +

7. Egg & Beef Sausage Sandwich

$5.49 +

8. Egg & Pastrami Sandwich

$5.49 +

11. Grilled Cheese Sandwich

$3.99 +

12. BLT Sandwich

Bacon, lettuce and tomatoes.

$5.99 +

Bagels and Muffins

73. Bagel with Butter

$1.99

74. Bagel with Cream Cheese

Plain or scallion cream cheese

$2.49 +

75. Bagel with Cream Cheese and Jelly

$2.99

76. Bagel with Peanut Butter and Jelly

$3.49

77. Bagel with Peanut Butter

$2.49

78. Egg & Cheese on English Muffin

You can add meat on your muffin.

$3.99 +

73. Roll with Butter

Roll whit butter or jelly or butter and jelly

$1.49 +

74. Roll with Cream Cheese

Cream cheese, scallion or cream and jelly

$1.99 +

75. Roll with Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter, PB & jelly, PB & honey, PB & banna

$2.50 +

76. Jumbo Muffin

Corn, blueberry, cranberry, chocolate chip, double chocolate and banana.

$2.49 +

77. Croissant

$2.99 +

80. Pound Cake

Plain, marble, banana, carrot and lemon

$1.50

Salad Sandwich

107. Egg Salad Sandwich

$6.99 +

109. Tuna Salad Sandwich

$6.99 +

110. Mexican Tuna Salad Sandwich

No mayo.

$6.99 +

111. Chicken Salad Sandwich

$7.99 +

113. Crab Meat Salad Sandwich

$7.99 +

114. Shrimp Salad Sandwich

$7.99 +

Presbyterian sides

French fries

$4.99 +

Curly fries

$5.99 +

Waffle fries

$5.99 +

Sweet potato fries

$5.99 +

Onion rings

$5.99 +

Lunch Sandwiches

28. Park Avenue Sandwich

Chicken salad, beef bacon, lettuce and tomato.

$8.99 +

29. Big Ruby Sandwich

Honey turkey, coleslaw, tomato and turkey bacon.

$8.99 +

30. Club Special Sandwich

Choice of turkey or roast beef, beef bacon, lettuce and tomato.

$8.99

31. Turkey Supreme Sandwich

Turkey, Swiss cheese, coleslaw and tomato.

$7.99 +

32. Cracked Pepper Mill Sandwich

Pepper turkey, melted American, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard.

$7.99 +

33. Monte Cristo Sandwich

Honey turkey, melted Swiss, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing.

$7.99 +

34. Turkey Deluxe Sandwich

Turkey, turkey bacon, melted American, lettuce and tomato.

$8.99 +

35. Turkey and Roast Beef Sandwich

Turkey, roast beef, Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato.

$8.99 +

36. Chicken Deluxe Sandwich

Chicken cutlet, turkey bacon, melted Swiss, lettuce and tomato.

$8.99 +

38. Grilled Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

Chicken cutlet, melted mozzarella, lettuce and tomato.

$8.99 +

39. Chicken Delight Sandwich

Chicken cutlet, broccoli and melted cheddar.

$8.99 +

40. Buffalo Chicken Bleu Sandwich

Buffalo chicken and melted Swiss.

$8.99 +

41. Grilled Chicken Caesar Sandwich

Grilled chicken, lettuce and tomato, Parmesan cheese, croutons and Caesar dressing.

$9.99 +

42. Grilled Ranch Sandwich

Chicken breast, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing.

$7.99 +

44. Dr. Ruben Sandwich

Hot pastrami, melted swiss, coleslaw and russian dressing.

$8.99 +

45. Pastrami King Sandwich

Pastrami, melted Swiss, lettuce, sweet pepper and honey mustard.

$8.99 +

46. Roast Beef Delight Sandwich

Roast beef, beef bacon, melted mozzarella and brown gravy.

$9.99 +

47. Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich

Steak, melted mozzarella, grilled onion, pepper and teriyaki sauce.

$8.99 +

49. Cheeseburger

beef burger, american cheese, lettuce and tomato

$7.99 +

50. Bacon Cheeseburger Deluxe

Beef burger, beacon, lettuce and tomato.

$9.99 +

Salad Plates

84. Garden Salad

Romaine lettuce, red onion, green and red pepper, tomato, carrot and cucumber.

$8.99

85. Greek Salad

Romaine lettuce, feta cheese, baby corn, red onion, cucumber and black olives.

$8.99

86. Chef Salad

Garden salad with turkey, roast beef, American and Swiss cheese.

$10.99

87. Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

Garden salad with grilled chicken, Parmesan cheese and croutons.

$9.99

88. 165 Salad

Any three toppings of vegetables and one type of meat.

$9.99

Panini

99. Chicken Fajita

Moist grilled chicken, sauteed onion, pepper salsa and melted cheddar cheese.

$7.99

100. Chicken Club

Moist grilled chicken, french cheese, tomato and ranch dressing.

$7.99

101. Tuna Melt

Albacore tuna, lettuce and tomatoes with cheddar cheese on Greek pita.

$7.99

102. Chicken Parmesan

Breaded chicken breast, mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce.

$7.99

103. Eggplant Parmesan

Breaded eggplant, mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce.

$7.99

104. Veggie Panini

Breaded vegetable, balsamic vinegar and melted mozzarella cheese.

$6.99

105. Roma Panini

Moist grilled chicken, chipotle and mozzarella cheese.

$7.99

Make Your Own Salad

4 Topping Tossed Salad

$8.99 +

Quesadillas

68. Chicken Quesadilla

Grilled chicken, white onion, red and green pepper, melted cheddar and mozzarella. Chipotle and sour cream on the side

$10.99

69. Steak Quesadilla

Steak, red onion, green and red pepper, cilantro, melted cheddar and mozzarella. Chipotle and sour cream on the side

$10.99

70. Chef Salad Quesadilla

Grilled chicken, sauteed broccoli and melted cheese.

$9.99

71. Vegetable Quesadilla

Mushroom, sauteed spinach, tomato, red onion, green and red pepper and melted cheese.

$8.49

72. Cheese Quesadilla

Cheddar, mozzarella, Swiss and pepper jack cheese.

$8.99

Presbyterian Special

51. Chicken Pepper Roast

EverRoast chicken, melted mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, pepperoni Gourmaise sauce.

$0.00

52. The Ranch

Hot roasted beef, melted provolone, lettuce, tomato and horse radish dressing.

$0.00

53. Bacon Cheddar Roast

Bacon, EverRoast chicken, honey dagon, melted cheddar, lettuce and tomato.

$0.00

54. Fire House Chicken

Blazing buffalo chicken, honey mustard, pepper jack cheese, hot pepper, lettuce and tomato.

$0.00

55. Dr. Ruben

Hot pastrami, melted Swiss, coleslaw and Russian dressing.

$0.00

56. Honey Moon

Grilled honey turkey, melted Muenster cheese, roasted pepper and honey mustard.

$0.00

57. Chicken Salad Club

Chicken salad, lettuce and tomato, bacon and American cheese.

$0.00

58. Presebyterian Special

Chicken cutlet, bacon, lettuce, tomato, American cheese and mayo.

$0.00

59. Chicken Cordon Bleu

Chicken cutlet, grilled honey ham, Swiss cheese and bleu cheese dressing.

$0.00

60. Italian

Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone cheese, lettuce and tomato, roasted peppers, oil and vinegar.

$0.00

61. American

Ham, roast beef, American cheese, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and Russian dressing.

$0.00

62. Cha Cha Cha

Pepper turkey, pepper jack cheese, lettuce and tomato.

$9.99 +

63. Pope of Fulton

Hot roasted beef, turkey and Muenster cheese.

$0.00

64. Turkey Club

Turkey breast, crispy bacon, lettuce and tomato.

$0.00

65. New Jack

Turkey, salami, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato and mayo.

$0.00

66. Amigo

Pepper turkey, roasted turkey, smoked turkey, Muenster cheese and mayo.

$0.00

67. Sweet Honey Moon

Honey ham, honey turkey, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard.

$0.00

Special

115. Fish Deluxe

With fries and a can of soda.

$7.99

116. Chicken Wings Deluxe

With fries and a can of soda.

$10.99

117. Turkey Burger Deluxe

With fries and a can of soda.

$8.99

118. Beef Burger Deluxe

With fries and a can of soda.

$8.99

119. Shrimp Salad

With fries and a can of soda.

$11.99

120. Seafood Salad

With fries and a can of soda.

$5.99

121. Chicken Salad

With fries and a can of soda.

$8.99

122. Chicken Fingers

With fries and a can of soda.

$9.99

123. Mozzarella Sticks

Eight piece.

$5.49

Candy

Chocolate Bar

$2.99

Gum

$2.99 +

Protein Bar

$3.49

Starburst

$2.49

Halls

$2.50

Sour Patch

$2.50

Now and Later

$1.99

Sour Patch Straws

$2.25

Nuts & Fruit

Pistachios

5 oz.

$6.99

Cashews

10 oz.

$7.49

Mixed Nuts

6 oz.

$6.49

Walnuts

4.5 oz.

$6.49

Almonds

8 oz.

$6.99

Omega-3 Deluxe Mix

6 oz.

$5.99

2 Bananas

$2.00

Apple

$1.49

Orange

$1.50

2 Green Plantains

$1.00

Pototoes

1 bag.

$3.99

Cereal

Rice Krispies

12 oz.

$8.99

Cap'n Crunch

14 oz.

$9.49

Raisin Brand

18.2 oz.

$9.99

Luck Charms

11.5 oz.

$8.99

Honey Nut Cheerios

12.25 oz.

$8.99

Cookie Crisp

11.25 oz.

$8.99

Hershey's

10.9 oz.

$8.49

Special K

12.5 oz.

$8.99

Trix

10.7 oz.

$7.49

Fruity Pebbles

11.2 oz.

$8.49

Cocoa Puffs

11.08 oz.

$9.49

Apple Jacks

$9.49 +

Frosted Flakes

$6.99 +

Honey Bunches Almonds

14.5 oz.

$8.49

Cheerios

18 oz.

$9.99

Cinnamon Toast Crunch

12.2 oz.

$7.49

Froot Loops

17 oz.

$7.50

Corn Flakes

12.2 oz.

$6.99

Kix

18 oz.

$8.99

Soup

Cup of Noodles

$1.99

Bowl Noodle

$2.99

2 Top Ramen

$1.99

Progresso

$4.49

Chunky

$4.99

Boyardee

$2.99

Snacks

Oreo

$3.49 +

Chips Ahoy

$3.99 +

Ritz

$6.49 +

Chip Lay's

2 3/4 oz.

$2.99

Doritos

3 1/8 oz.

$2.99

Deep River Chips

2 oz.

$2.99

Kettle Chips

5 oz.

$4.99

Kettle Chips

2 oz.

$2.99

Popcorn

5 oz.

$4.49

Ice Cream

$9.49

Miscellaneous

Diaper

$6.99 +

Clorox Wipes

9.1 oz.

$7.99

Pampers Wipes

72 pieces.

$6.99

Tide

$4.99 +

Gain

$5.99 +

Air Wick

$3.49

Febreeze

$5.99

Lysol

12.5 oz.

$6.49

Palmolive

12.6 oz.

$3.49

Fabuloso

16.9 oz.

$3.49

Mistolin

15 oz.

$3.49 +

Bounty

$3.99 +

Scott Tissue

$2.99

Marcal Tissue

$1.99

Beverages

Ice coffee

$2.99 +

89. Gourmet House Blend Coffee

Black coffee whit milk or half and half.

$1.99 +

91. Flavored Coffee

$1.00 +

93. Herbal Tea

$1.49 +

97. French Vanilla

$1.99 +

Naked Juice

$4.99

Red Bull

$3.99 +

Starbucks

$3.99 +

Muscle Milk

$4.99

Tropicana Juice

Gallon.

$6.99

Simply Juice

$5.99

Best Guava Juice

32 oz.

$6.99

Best Cocktail Juice

32 oz.

$6.99

Aloevine Juice

$5.99

Smart Water

$2.99 +

Poland Spring Water

$1.50 +

Fiji Water

$1.50 +

Ensure Milk

$2.99

Monster Drink

$3.99

Nesquik Milk

$2.25

Tropicana Twister Juice

$3.49

Snapple

$2.99

V8 Juice

$2.00

Tropicana Juice

12.2 oz.

$3.50

Vitamin Water

$2.99

Gatorade

20 oz.

$2.99

Soda 20 oz

$2.49

Arizona Tea

$1.49

Milk

$3.50 +

Half and Half

Quart.

$7.99

Almond Soy Milk

Half gallon.

$6.99

Lactaid

Half gallon.

$7.99

94. Hot Chocolate

$1.99 +

95. Cappuccino

$1.99 +
Restaurant closed
.

About 172 Presbyterian Deli

  • 1230 St Nicholas Ave, New York, NY 10030
  • American, Bodega, Breakfast, Deli, Dinner, Late Night, Lunch Specials, Salads, Sandwiches
  • (212) 685-1230
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / 172 Presbyterian Deli
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.