Bagel Mill
MenuAbout
Bagel Mill Menu

Bagel Mill

Bagels, Breakfast
1700 1st Ave, New York, NY 10128
(212) 426-0868
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Beverages

Menu powered by Grubhub

Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice

$4.50 +

15 oz. Bottle Tropicana

$2.95

32 oz. Tropicana Orange Juice

$4.95

1.75 Liter Tropicana Orange Juice

$5.99

Simply Juice

$3.00

Welch's Juice

$2.85

Quart of Skim Milk

$3.35

Quart of Half and Half

$4.35

Gatorade

$2.99 +

Snapple Tea large

$3.85 +

Smart Water

$3.25 +

Coffee

$2.25 +

Mango Iced Tea

$2.49 +

12 oz. Tropicana Bottle

$2.85

Tropicana Carton

$2.85

Tropicana Quart

$4.95

Red Bull

$3.35 +

Naked Juice

$4.99

Zico

$3.59

Half Gallon of Whole Milk

$4.25

Arizona Tea

$2.25

Snapple

$2.85 +

Poland Water 1 liter

$2.99 +

Fiji Water 1.5 lt

$4.75 +

Iced Coffee

$5.60 +

Soda

$2.75 +

Old Fashioned Lemonade

$3.49 +

Old Fashioned Orangeade

$3.49 +

Gourmet Coffee

$1.99 +

Herbal Tea

$2.25 +

Hot Chocolate

$2.25 +

Cappuccino

$3.25 +

Latte

$3.25 +

Tea and Coffee

Iced Coffee

$2.75 +

Iced Tea

$2.49 +

Green Iced Tea

$2.75 +

Espresso

$2.50 +

Decaf Coffee

$2.25 +

French Vanilla

$2.25 +

Hazelnut

$2.25 +

Breakfast Sandwich on a Regular Bagel

Egg on a Regular Bagel

$3.99 +

Bacon on a Regular Bagel

$4.99 +

Bacon, Egg and Cheese on a Regular Bagel

$6.25 +

Sausage on a Regular Bagel

$4.99 +

Sausage and Egg on a Regular Bagel

$5.50 +

Ham, Egg and Cheese on a Regular Bagel

$6.25 +

Turkey and Egg on a Regular Bagel

$5.50 +

Vegetable and Egg on a Regular Bagel

$5.00 +

Lox and Egg on a Regular Bagel

$7.25 +

BLT on a Regular Bagel

$5.99 +

Egg and Cheese on a Regular Bagel

$5.25 +

Bacon and Cheese on a Regular Bagel

$5.50 +

Bacon and Egg on a Regular Bagel

$5.50 +

Sausage and Cheese on a Regular Bagel

$5.50 +

Sausage Egg and Cheese on a Regular Bagel

$6.25 +

Ham and Egg on a Regular Bagel

$5.75 +

Turkey, Egg and Cheese on a Regular Bagel

$6.25 +

Western Egg on a Regular Bagel

$6.50 +

Grilled Cheese on a Regular Bagel

$5.25 +

Egg and Cheese on a Regular Bagel

$3.99

Egg and Cheese on a Regular Bagel

$5.25 +

Breakfast Sandwich on a Flat Bagel

Egg on a Flat Bagel

$4.50 +

Bacon on a Flat Bagel

$5.75 +

Bacon, Egg, and Cheese on a Flat Bagel

$7.25 +

Sausage on a Flat Bagel

$5.99 +

Sausage and Egg on a Flat Bagel

$5.99 +

Ham, Egg and Cheese on a Flat Bagel

$7.25 +

Turkey, Egg and Cheese on a Flat Bagel

$7.25 +

Western Egg on a Flat Bagel

$7.25 +

Grilled Cheese on a Flat Bagel

$5.75 +

Egg and Cheese on a Flat Bagel

$5.50 +

Bacon and Cheese on a Flat Bagel

$6.25 +

Bacon, Egg and Cheese on a Flat Bagel

$7.25 +

Sausage and Cheese on a Flat Bagel

$6.79 +

Sausage, Egg and Cheese on a Flat Bagel

$7.25 +

Ham and Egg on a Flat Bagel

$6.75 +

Turkey and Egg on a Flat Bagel

$6.75 +

Vegetable and Egg on a Flat Bagel

$6.25 +

Lox and Egg on a Flat Bagel

$6.99 +

BLT on a Flat Bagel

$6.25 +

Ham, Egg and Cheese on a Flat Bagel

$7.25 +

Egg and Cheese on a Flat Bagel

$5.99 +

Breakfast Sandwich on a Mini Bagel

Egg on a Mini Bagel

$3.50 +

Bacon on a Mini Bagel

$3.99 +

Bacon and Egg on a Mini Bagel

$4.65 +

Sausage on a Mini Bagel

$3.99 +

Sausage and Egg on a Mini Bagel

$4.65 +

Ham and Egg on a Mini Bagel

$4.65 +

Turkey and Egg on a Mini Bagel

$4.65 +

Vegetable and Egg on a Mini Bagel

$5.00 +

Lox and Egg on a Mini Bagel

$5.50 +

BLT on a Mini Bagel

$4.99 +

Egg and Cheese on a Mini Bagel

$3.99 +

Bacon and Cheese on a Mini Bagel

$4.50 +

Bacon, Egg and Cheese on a Mini Bagel

$5.00 +

Sausage and Cheese on a Mini Bagel

$4.50 +

Sausage, Egg and Cheese on a Mini Bagel

$5.35 +

Ham, Egg and Cheese on a Mini Bagel

$5.35 +

Turkey, Egg and Cheese on a Mini Bagel

$5.35 +

Western Egg on a Mini Bagel

$5.35 +

Grilled Cheese on a Mini Bagel

$3.99 +

Hearty Breakfast

2 Eggs

$3.50 +

2 Egg with Cheese

$4.50 +

2 Egg with Tomato

$4.50 +

2 Egg with Bacon

$4.99 +

2 Egg with Sausage

$4.99 +

2 Egg with Ham

$4.99 +

2 Egg with Turkey

$4.99 +

2 Egg with Bacon Cheese

$5.75 +

2 Egg with Sausage Cheese

$5.75 +

2 Egg with Ham Cheese

$5.75 +

2 Egg with Turkey Cheese

$5.75 +

Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato Sandwich

$5.75 +

Grilled Cheese

$5.25 +

Veggie

$5.50 +

Western

$5.99 +

Lox and Egg

$6.99 +

Breakfast Egg Platters

Eggs and Home Fries Platter

Served with your choice of bread or bagel.

$5.85 +

Ham, Eggs and Home Fries Platter

Served with your choice of bread or bagel.

$7.25 +

Turkey, Eggs and Home Fries Platter

Served with your choice of bread or bagel.

$7.25 +

Vegetable Omelette and Home Fries Platter

Served with your choice of bread or bagel.

$7.25 +

Bacon, Eggs and Home Fries Platter

Served with your choice of bread or bagel.

$7.25 +

Sausage, Eggs and Home Fried Platter

Served with your choice of bread or bagel.

$7.25 +

Western Omelette and Home Fried Platter

Served with your choice of bread or bagel.

$7.25 +

Lox Onion Omelette and Home Fried Platter

Served with your choice of bread or bagel.

$7.99 +

Eggs and Home Fries Platter with Flat Bagel

Served with your choice of bread or bagel. Includes an extra flat bagel with spread.

$7.25 +

Ham, Eggs and Home Fries Platter with Flat Bagel

Served with your choice of bread or bagel. Includes an extra flat bagel with spread.

$7.25 +

Turkey, Eggs and Home Fries Platter with Flat Bagel

Served with your choice of bread or bagel. Includes an extra flat bagel with spread.

$7.25 +

Vegetable Omelette and Home Fries Platter with Flat Bagel

Served with your choice of bread or bagel. Includes an extra flat bagel with spread.

$7.25 +

Bacon, Eggs and Home Fries Platter with Flat Bagel

Served with your choice of bread or bagel. Includes an extra flat bagel with spread.

$7.25 +

Sausage, Eggs and Home Fries Platter with Flat Bagel

Served with your choice of bread or bagel. Includes an extra flat bagel with spread.

$7.25 +

Western Omelette and Home Fries Platter with Flat Bagel

Served with your choice of bread or bagel. Includes an extra flat bagel with spread.

$7.25 +

Lox Onion Omelette and Home Fries Platter with Flat Bagel

Served with your choice of bread or bagel. Includes an extra flat bagel with spread.

$7.99 +

Eggs and Home Fries Platter with Regular Bagel

Served with your choice of bread or bagel. Includes an extra regular bagel with spread.

$8.99 +

Ham, Eggs and Home Fries Platter with Regula Bagel

Served with your choice of bread or bagel. Includes an extra regular bagel with spread.

$9.75 +

Turkey, Eggs and Home Fries Platter with Regular Bagel

Served with your choice of bread or bagel. Includes an extra regular bagel with spread.

$9.75 +

Vegetable Omelette and Home Fries Platter with Regular Bagel

Served with your choice of bread or bagel. Includes an extra regular bagel with spread.

$9.75 +

Bacon, Eggs and Home Fries Platter with Regular Bagel

Served with your choice of bread or bagel. Includes an extra regular bagel with spread.

$9.75 +

Sausage, Eggs and Home Fries Platter with Regular Bagel

Served with your choice of bread or bagel. Includes an extra regular bagel with spread.

$9.75 +

Western Omelette and Home Fries Platter with Regular Bagel

Served with your choice of bread or bagel. Includes an extra regular bagel with spread.

$9.75 +

Lox Onion Omelette and Home Fries Platter with Regular Bagel

Served with your choice of bread or bagel. Includes an extra regular bagel with spread.

$11.00 +

Breakfast Platters

French Toast Platter

Served with butter and syrup.

$5.50 +

French Toast with Eggs Platter

Served with butter and syrup.

$6.99 +

French Toast with Sausage Platter

Served with butter and syrup.

$7.50 +

French Toast, Bacon and Eggs Platter

Served with butter and syrup.

$8.75 +

French Toast, Ham and Eggs Platter

Served with butter and syrup.

$8.75 +

Egg Whites, Sausage and French Toast Platter

Served with butter and syrup.

$9.25 +

Side Order of French Fries

$4.25 +

Pancakes Platter

Served with butter and syrup.

$5.00 +

French Toast Platter Deluxe

Served with butter and syrup.

$7.75 +

French Toast with Ham Platter

Served with butter and syrup.

$7.75 +

French Toast, Sausage and Eggs Platter

Served with butter and syrup.

$8.75 +

Egg Whites and Bacon with French Toast Platter

Served with butter and syrup.

$9.25 +

Egg Whites and Ham with French Toast Platter

Served with butter and syrup.

$9.25 +

Breakfast Bakery

Butter Breakfast

$2.75 +

Jelly Breakfast

$2.75 +

Butter and Jelly Breakfast

$3.25 +

Plain Cream Cheese Breakfast

$3.50 +

Flavored Special Cream Cheese Breakfast

Includes veggie, walnut rasin, garlic and herb, blueberry, strawberry, olives and lowfat.

$3.75 +

Lox Spread Breakfast

$3.99 +

Bagel Mill Breakfast Combo

1. Bagel with Butter

$4.99

2. Bagel with Cream Cheese Combo

$6.25

3. Muffin Combo

$5.75

3. Croissant Combo

$5.50

4. Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese

$6.99

5. Bagel with Bacon, Eggs and Cheese Combo

$7.99

5. Roll with Bacon, Eggs and Cheese Combo

$7.99

6. Bagel with Sausage, Eggs and Cheese Combo

$7.99

7. Bagel with Ham, Eggs and Cheese Combo

$7.99

8. Bagel with Veggies and Eggs Combo

$7.99

9. Pancake Combo

$7.99

9. French Toast Combo

$7.99

10. Hash Browns and Eggs Combo

$7.99

10. Home Fried and Eggs Combo

$7.99

Roll with Sausage Eggs and Cheese Combo

$7.99

Appetizers

6 Piece Buffalo Wings

$6.99

5 Piece Mozzarella Sticks

$5.75

5 Piece Chicken Fingers

$7.50 +

Soup and Salad

Garden Salad

$6.75 +

Greek Salad

$7.75 +

Macaroni Salad

$5.75

Watermelon

$5.25

Caesar Salad

$7.75 +

Yogurt with Furfait

$5.25

House Salad

$6.75 +

Salad Sandwich

Tuna Salad

$8.99

Light Tuna Salad

$8.99

Chicken Salad

$8.99

Egg Salad

$6.99

White Salad

$9.50

Shrimp Salad

$10.75

Baked Salmon Salad

$10.25

White Fish Salad

$10.25

Smoked Fish and Salads

Lox Salad

$10.50 +

White Fish Salad

$5.00 +

Shrimp Salad

$5.99 +

Egg Salad

$3.99 +

Tuna Salad

$3.99 +

Italian Tuna Salad

$4.00 +

Tomato Salad

$3.00 +

Potato Salad

$4.50 +

Loxspread and Cream Cheese

$4.25

Baked Salmon Salad

$5.00 +

Seafood Salad

$5.00 +

Egg White Salad

$3.99 +

Vegetable Tuna Salad

$4.00 +

Chicken Salad

$3.99 +

Coleslaw

$4.50 +

Sandwich on a Flat Bagel

fresh Lox on a Flat Bagel w cream cheese

$13.25 +

White Fish Salad on a Flat Bagel

$10.99 +

Shrimp Salad on a Flat Bagel

$10.99 +

Egg Salad on a Flat Bagel

$8.25 +

Tuna on a Flat Bagel

$9.99 +

Italian Tuna on a Flat Bagel

$9.99 +

Lox and Cream Cheese on a Flat Bagel

$12.99 +

Baked Salmon Salad on a Flat Bagel

$10.99 +

Chopped Liver on a Flat Bagel

$5.75 +

Seafood Salad on a Flat Bagel

$10.99 +

Egg Whites Salad on a Flat Bagel

$8.50 +

Vegetable Tuna on a Flat Bagel

$9.99 +

Chicken Salad on a Flat Bagel

$9.99 +

Sandwich on a Mini Bagel

Lox on a Mini Bagel

$8.25 +

White Fish Salad on a Mini Bagel

$6.50 +

Chopped Herring on a Mini Bagel

$3.75 +

Shrimp Salad on a Mini Bagel

$6.50 +

Egg Salad on a Mini Bagel

$4.99 +

Tuna on a Mini Bagel

$6.50 +

Italian Tuna on a Mini Bagel

$6.50 +

Lox and Cream Cheese on a Mini Bagel

$4.25 +

Baked Salmon Salad on a Mini Bagel

$6.50 +

Chopped Liver on a Mini Bagel

$3.75 +

Seafood Salad on a Mini Bagel

$6.50 +

Egg White Salad on a Mini Bagel

$4.99 +

Vegetable Tuna on a Mini Bagel

$6.50 +

Chicken Salad on a Mini Bagel

$6.50 +

Sandwiches on a Regular Bagel

Lox on a Regular Bagel

w/cream cheese

$12.49 +

Baked Salmon Salad on a Regular Bagel

$9.99 +

Seafood Salad on a Regular Bagel

$9.99 +

Egg White Salad on a Regular Bagel

$7.25 +

Vegetable Tuna on a Regular Bagel

$8.75 +

Chicken Salad on a Regular Bagel

$8.75 +

White Fish Salad on a Regular Bagel

$9.99 +

Shrimp Salad on a Regular Bagel

$9.99 +

Egg Salad on a Regular Bagel

$7.25 +

Tuna Salad on a Regular Bagel

$8.75 +

Italian Tuna on a Regular Bagel

$8.75 +

Cold Cut Sandwiches on a Flat Bagel and Hero

Ham Sandwich

$8.99 +

Turkey Sandwich

$8.99 +

Honey Turkey Sandwich

$8.99 +

Salsalito Turkey Sandwich

$8.99 +

Cajun Turkey Sandwich

$8.99 +

Cold Pastrami Sandwich

$8.99 +

Bologna Sandwich

$8.99 +

Breaded Chicken Sandwich

$8.99 +

Oven Roasted Chicken Breast Sandwich

$8.99 +

Virginia Ham Sandwich

$8.99 +

Smoked Turkey Sandwich

$8.99 +

Pepper Turkey Sandwich

$8.99 +

Turkey Pastrami Sandwich

$8.99 +

Roast Beef Sandwich

$8.99 +

Hot Pastrami Sandwich

$8.99 +

Genoa Salami Sandwich

$8.99 +

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

$8.99 +

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

$8.99 +

Cheese Sandwich

$5.75 +

Cold Cut Sandwiches on a Regular Bagel

Ham with Regular Bagel

$8.99 +

Turkey on a Regular Bagel

$8.99 +

Honey Turkey on a Regular Bagel

$8.99 +

Salsalito Turkey on a Regular Bagel

$8.99 +

Roast Beef on a Regular Bagel

$9.25 +

Hot Pastrami on a Regular Bagel

$9.25 +

Grilled Chicken on a Regular Bagel

$8.99 +

Breaded Chicken on a Regular Bagel

$8.99 +

Virginia Ham on a Regular Bagel

$8.99 +

Smoked Turkey on a Regular Bagel

$8.99 +

Pepper Turkey on a Regular Bagel

$8.99 +

Cajun Turkey on a Regular Bagel

$8.99 +

Cold Pastrami on a Regular Bagel

$8.99 +

Buffalo Chicken on a Regular Bagel

$8.99 +

Cheese Sandwich on a Regular Bagel

$5.50 +

Healthy Sandwich

Turkey

Roasted, smoked and honey pepper.

$8.75 +

Fresh Lox

$11.75 +

Beef

Roast, corn and beef.

$9.25 +

Pastrami

$9.25 +

Ham

$8.75 +

Salami

$8.75 +

Chicken Cutlet

$8.99 +

White Fish

$11.25 +

Fish, Chicken, and Burgers

Hamburger

$4.50 +

Turkey Burger

$4.00 +

Philly Steak Sandwich

$8.20 +

French Fries

$2.75

Bacon Burger

$5.50 +

Veggie Burger

$4.00 +

Gyro

$5.50 +

Crispy Chicken Sandwich

$5.49 +

Chicken Tenders

$4.24 +

6 Boneless Wings

Served with honey BBQ, original buffalo, and chipotle BBQ.

$5.25 +

Hamburger

$5.25 +

Cheeseburger

$5.99 +

Super Cheeseburger

$6.99 +

Bacon Cheeseburger

$6.99 +

Fish Sandwich

$5.99 +

Entree Wraps

1. Tuna Melt

Tuna salad, romaine lettuce, plum tomatoes, roasted peppers and whole wheat wrap.

$9.99

2. Classic Chicken Caesar

Romaine lettuce, roasted peppers, rRomano cheese, Caesar dressing and wrap.

$9.99

3. Turkey Club

Turkey, crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, spicy mayo.

$9.99

4. Tex Mex Beef

Roast beef, monterey jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, avocado, cilantro, sour cream and wrap.

$9.99

5. Arizona Wrap

Cajun chicken, celery, carrot, roasted pepper and cheddar cheese.

$9.99

6. Grill Chicken BLT

Grill chicken, crispy bacon, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and light mayo.

$9.99

7. Reuben

Russian dressing and rye bread.

$9.99

8. Smoked Turkey Cuban

Smoked turkey, Swiss cheese, pickle and Russian dressing.

$9.99

9. All Panini's

$9.99

Nathan's Hot Dogs

Hot Dog

$4.49 +

Cheese Dog

$4.99 +

Chili Cheese Dog

$5.49 +

Corn Dog on a Stick

$4.49 +

Hot Dog Nuggets 6pcs

$4.29 +

Regular Bagels

Regular Bagel

$1.75 +

Regular Bagel with Butter and Jelly

$3.25 +

Regular Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese

$3.99 +

Regular Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese

$4.50 +

Regular Bagel with Vegetable Cream Cheese

$4.50 +

Regular Bagel with Jalapeno Cream Cheese

$4.50 +

Regular Bagel with Walnut and Raisin Cream Cheese

$4.50 +

Regular Bagel with Scallion Tofu Cream Cheese

$4.50 +

Regular Bagel with Lite Lox Spread

$4.99 +

Regular Bagel with Lite Scallion Cream Cheese

$4.50 +

Regular Bagel with Peanut Butter

$3.99 +

Regular Bagel with Butter

$2.99 +

Regular Bagel with Jelly

$3.25 +

Regular Bagel with Cream Cheese and Jelly

$4.65 +

Regular Bagel with Lox Spread

$4.99 +

Regular Bagel with Blueberry Cream Cheese

$4.50 +

Regular Bagel with Strawberry Cream Cheese

$4.50 +

Regular Bagel with Vegetable Tofu Cream Cheese

$4.50 +

Regular Bagel with Plain Tofu Cream Cheese

$4.50 +

Regular Bagel with Lite Vegetable Cream Cheese

$4.50 +

Regular Bagel with Olive Cream Cheese

$4.50 +

Regular Bagel with Peanut Butter and Jelly

$4.50 +

Flat Bagels

Bagel

$1.75 +

Flat Bagel with Butter and Jelly

$3.25 +

Flat Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese

$4.75 +

Flat Bagel with Vegetable Cream Cheese

$4.75 +

Flat Bagel with Walnut and Raisin Cream Cheese

$4.75 +

Flat Bagel with Olive Cream Cheese

$4.75 +

Flat Bagel with Blueberry Cream Cheese

$4.75 +

Flat Bagel with Lite Vegetable Cream Cheese

$4.75 +

Flat Bagel with Lite Scallion Cream Cheese

$4.75 +

Flat Bagel with Plain Tofu Cream Cheese

$4.50 +

Flat Bagel with Vegetable Tofu Cream Cheese

$4.75 +

Flat Bagel with Peanut Butter and Jelly

$5.00 +

Flat Bagel with Butter

$3.50 +

Flat Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese

$4.50 +

Flat Bagel with Jelly

$2.99 +

Flat Bagel with Cream Cheese and Jelly

$4.75 +

Flat Bagel with Lox Spread

$5.50 +

Flat Bagel with Strawberry Cream Cheese

$4.75 +

Flat Bagel with Jalapeno Cream Cheese

$4.75 +

Flat Bagel with Lite Lox Spread

$5.50 +

Flat Bagel with Scallion Tofu Cream Cheese

$4.75 +

Flat Bagel with Peanut Butter

$4.75 +

Mini Bagels

Mini Bagel

$1.25 +

Mini Bagel with Butter and Jelly

$1.99 +

Mini Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese

$3.75 +

Mini Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese

$4.25 +

Mini Bagel with Lox Spread

$4.75 +

Mini Bagel with Olive Cream Cheese

$4.25 +

Mini Bagel with Blueberry Cream Cheese

$4.25 +

Mini Bagel with Lite Vegetable Cream Cheese

$4.25 +

Mini Bagel with Lite Lox Spread

$4.25 +

Mini Bagel with Scallion Tofu Cream Cheese

$4.25 +

Mini Bagel with Peanut Butter

$2.99 +

Mini Bagel with Butter

$1.75 +

Mini Bagel with Jelly

$1.75 +

Mini Bagel with Cream Cheese and Jelly

$4.25 +

Mini Bagel with Vegetable Cream Cheese

$4.25 +

Mini Bagel with Walnut and Raisin Cream Cheese

$4.25 +

Mini Bagel with Strawberry Cream Cheese

$4.25 +

Mini Bagel with Jalapeno Cream Cheese

$4.25 +

Mini Bagel with Lite Scallion Cream Cheese

$4.25 +

Mini Bagel with Plain Tofu Cream Cheese

$4.25 +

Mini Bagel with Vegetable Tofu Cream Cheese

$4.25 +

Mini Bagel with Peanut Butter and Jelly

$2.99 +

Yogurt

Chobani Yogurt

$2.75

Muffins

Blueberry Muffin

$3.50

Chocolate Chip Muffin

$3.50

Double Chocolate Chip Muffin

$3.50

Orange Cranberry Muffin

$3.50

Oat Bran Muffin

$3.50

Apple Bran Muffin

$3.50

Raisin Bran Muffin

$3.50

Cappuccino Muffin

$3.50

Corn Muffin

$3.50

Croissant Muffin

$3.50

97% Fat Free Blueberry Muffin

$2.75

97% Fat Free Bran Muffin

$2.75

Banana Nut Crunch Muffin

$2.75

Blueberry Crumb Muffin

$2.75

Bran Muffin

$2.75

Carrot Pecan Muffin

$2.75

Chocolate Velvet

$2.75

Lemon Poppy Muffin

$2.75

Famous Fries

Original Crinkle-Cut Fries

$4.25 +

Cheese Fries

$4.99 +

Chili Cheese Fries

$4.54 +

Bacon Cheese Fries

$4.54 +

Bacon Ranch Fries

$4.54 +

Cheese Spreads

Butter

$4.50 +

Plain Cream Cheese Spread

$4.25

Vegetable Cream Cheese Spread

$4.25

Lox Spread

$4.75

Walnut and Raisin Cream Cheese Spread

$4.25

Strawberry Cream Cheese Spread

$4.25

Jalapeno Cream Cheese Spread

$4.25

Lite Vegetable Cream Cheese Spread

$4.25

Lite Lox Spread

$4.75

Scallion Tofu Cream Cheese Spread

$4.25

Peanut Butter

$3.25 +

Jelly

$2.00 +

Scallion Cream Cheese Spread

$4.25

Garlic and Herb Cream Cheese Spread

$4.25

Sun-dried Tomato Cream Cheese Spread

$4.25

Olive Cream Cheese Spread

$4.25

Blueberry Cream Cheese Spread

$4.25

Lite Cream Cheese Spread

$4.25

Lite Scallion Cream Cheese Spread

$4.25

Plain Tofu Cream Cheese Spread

$4.25

Vegetable Tofu Cream Cheese Spread

$4.25

Pastries

Jumbo Cookie

$2.75

Croissant

$2.85

Hamentashin

$2.75

Caramel Tart

$2.75

Pound Cake Slice

$2.85

Cinnamon Sticks

$2.75

Chocolate Croissant

$2.95

Oatmeal Tart

$2.75

Chocolate Sprinkles

$2.75

Cold Cuts (Boar's Head)

Ham

$4.99 +

Turkey

$4.99 +

Honey Turkey

$4.99 +

Salsalito Turkey

$4.99 +

Cajun Turkey

$4.99 +

Cold Pastrami

$4.99 +

Bologna

$4.99 +

Breaded Chicken

$4.99 +

Oven Roasted Chicken Breast

$4.99 +

Virginia Ham

$4.99 +

Smoked Turkey

$4.99 +

Pepper Turkey

$4.99 +

Turkey Pastrami

$4.99 +

Roast Beef

$4.99 +

Hot Pastrami

$4.99 +

Genoa Salami

$4.99 +

Grilled Chicken

$4.99 +

Buffalo Chicken

$4.99 +

Boars Head Meat Cold Cut

$5.25 +

Fresh Nova Scotia Salmon Cold Cut

$11.25 +

Shrimp Cold Cut

$6.25 +

Baked Salmon Cold Cut

$6.99 +

Whitefish Cold Cut

$6.25 +

Tuna Cold Cut

$4.99 +

Chicken Cold Cut

$4.75 +

Egg Cold Cut

$4.25 +

Eggwhite Salad

$4.25 +

Cheese Cold Cut

$4.25 +

Homemade Special

Hot Oatmeal

$3.99 +

Large French Toast Deluxe

Includes 2 eggs, choice of bacon or sausage.

$7.50 +

Large Pancake Deluxe

Includes 2 eggs, choice of bacon or sausage.

$7.50 +

Fresh Homemade Pancake

$5.25 +

French Toast

$5.25 +

Gyro

$6.50 +

French Fries

$4.25 +

Cheese Fries

$4.99 +

Home Fries

$4.25 +

Philly Cheese Steak

$9.25 +

Buffalo Chicken Wings

$7.75 +

Ham Burger Deluxe

$9.50 +

Sides

Granola Bar

$2.75

BBQ Chips

$2.25

Salt and Vinegar Chips

$2.25

1.5 oz. Kettle BBQ Chips

$2.25

1.5 oz. Stacy's Parmesan Garlic and Herb Chips

$2.25

1.5 oz. Kettle New York Cheddar Chips

$2.25

1.5 oz. Kettle Sea Salt and Vinegar Chips

$2.25

Kind Bar

$3.00

Plain Chips

$2.00

Pringle Chips

$2.25

1.5 oz. Stacy's Simply Naked Chips

$2.25

1.5 oz. Kettle Sea Salt Chips

$2.25

1.5 oz. Kettle Jalapeno Chips

$2.25

1.5 oz. Kettle Salt and Fresh Ground Pepper Chips

$2.25

Desserts

Strawberry Cheesecake

$4.50

Chocolate Chip cheese cake

$4.50

Apple Pie

$3.75

Vanilla Parfait

$5.25

Strawberry Parfait

$5.25

Fresh Smoothies

$6.99 +

Fruit Salad

$4.99

Catering Bagel Mill Breakfast

Bagel Mill Traditional Breakfast

Assorted fresh bagels, assorted cream cheese and butter platter, assorted pastries: muffins, danish, croissant, fresh garnished berries, coffee and tea, orange juice.

$7.50 +

Bagel Mill Classic Breakfast

Assorted fresh bagels, assorted cream cheese and butter platter, fresh berries, coffee and tea, orange juice.

$6.50 +

Bagel and Coffee Breakfast

Assorted fresh bagels, assorted cream cheese and butter platter, coffee and tea.

$5.00 +

Continental Breakfast

Assorted pastries: muffins, danish, croissant, fresh berries, coffee and tea, orange juice.

$6.00 +

Hot Breakfast

Scrambled eggs, bacon, ham or sausage, pancake, waffles or french toast, coffee and tea, orange juice.

$8.95 +

Catering Bagel Mill Vegetarian Special

Vegetarian Special

Vegetarian sandwiches or wraps served with a choice of 2 of our side salads-potato salad, macaroni salad, Israeli salad, coleslaw or tubule.

$8.50

Spread and Salad Sandwiches

Fresh homemade spread and salads on a sandwich served with a choice of 2 of our side salads-potato salad, macaroni salad, Israeli salad, coleslaw or tubule,

$9.00

Catering Bagel Mill Panini Lunch

Tuna Melt Panini

Fresh tuna salad cheddar cheese, lettuce and tomato.

$10.95

Turkey Club Panini

Sliced roast turkey, Swiss cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and honey Dijon.

$10.95

Italian Panini

Grilled chicken, pesto sauce, and fresh mozzarella.

$10.95

Chicken Parmigiana Panini

Chicken cutlet, mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce.

$10.95

Chicken Fajita Panini

Grilled chicken, cheddar cheese, roasted red peppers, onions and salsa.

$10.95

Kansas Panini

Roast beef, cheddar cheese, lettuce, onions, Russian dressing.

$10.95

Roma Panini

Fresh cilantro, onions, fresh mozzarella, grilled chicken and chipotle sauce.

$10.95

Super Chicken Panini

Grilled chicken, sliced prosciutto, roasted red pepper, fresh mozzarella, and pesto sauce.

$10.95

New York Panini

Hot pastrami, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and honey Dijon.

$10.95

Chicken Club Panini

Grilled chicken, smoked bacon, brie cheese, tomato and honey mustard.

$10.95

Catering Bagel Mill Lunch

Cold Cuts Sandwiches

Sandwich are arrange bountifully on a platter and served with potato salad, macaroni salad and pickles on the side.

$10.95

Cold Cuts Wrap

Wraps are arrange bountifully on a platter and served with potato salad, macaroni salad and pickles on the side.

$10.95

Chicken Caesar Wrap

Grilled chicken, Parmesan cheese, croutons, lettuce and caesar dressing.

$10.95

Crispy Chicken BLT Wrap

Crispy chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese, and ranch dressing.

$10.95

Roasted Turkey Wrap

Roasted turkey, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard.

$10.95

Cajun Chicken Wrap

Cajun chicken, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, chipotle mayo.

$10.95

Grilled Vegetable Wrap

Served with fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, fresh basil and basil vinaigrette.

$10.95

Mexican Wrap

Spicy grilled chicken, grilled vegetables, salsa and avocado.

$10.95

Classic Wrap

Grilled chicken, bcon, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, ranch dressing.

$10.95

Tuna Salad Wrap

American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and roasted peppers.

$10.95

Chicken Salad Wrap

American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and roasted peppers.

$10.95

French Wrap

Smoked turkey, brie cheese, lettuce and honey dijon.

$10.95

Mediterranean Wrap

Romaine lettuce, tomato, olives, cucumbers, oregano, feta cheese, olive oil and red vinegar.

$10.95

California Wrap

Grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, avocado, tomato and ranch dressing.

$10.95

Catering Platters

Smoked Fish Platter

Choice of 3 smoked fish, with cream cheese, capers, tomato, onions and bagels.

$18.00

Spreads Salads

Choice of salad with assorted bagels and Greek olives.

$11.00

Cold Cuts Platter

Choice of 3 meats with 2 side of salads, pickles, Greek olives and assorted bagels.

$11.00

Assorted Cheese Platter

Choice of 4 cheeses with fresh berries, bagels and crackers.

$8.95

Catering Salads

Greek Salad Platter

Mixed greens, tomato, black olives, onion, feta cheese, stuffed vine leaf with rice.

$6.00

Nicoise Salad Platter

Mixed greens, tuna, tomato, onion, boiled egg, thousand Island dressing.

$6.00

Chicken Caesar Salad Platter

Romaine lettuce, sun-dried tomatoes, Parmesan cheese, croutons, grilled chicken and caesar dressing.

$6.50

Chef Salad Platter

Romaine lettuce, tomato, onions, ham, American cheese, Swiss cheese, turkey, roast beef.

$7.50

House Salad Platter

Turkey, crispy bacon, spinach, romaine lettuce, mushrooms, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, egg whites and balsamic basil vinegar. Fresh mixed.

$6.50

Vegetable Platter

Cherry tomato, carrots, cucumber, celery, broccoli, cauliflower with choice of dip.

$4.00

Fresh Cut Season Fruits Platter

$4.99

Catering Specialties

Long Hero

3" to 6" hero with Boar's head meat and cheese.

$30.00

Catering Desserts

Cookie and Brown Tray

Selection of freshly baked individual cookies and brownies garnished with fresh berries.

$4.50

Brownie and Sweet Bars

Luscious chocolate, apple crumb, lemon, pecan, oreo, fudge brownie bar, arranged on a basket, garnished with fresh berries.

$4.95

Mini Fruit Tart Tray

Assorted seasonal fruit and berries with custard in a sweet pastry crust.

$5.95

Cupcake Tray

Assorted cupcakes tray.

$3.95

Assorted Italian Desserts

An assorted of miniature tiramisu, eclairs, napoleon, cannoli, lemon rolls and more, garnished with fresh berries in a tray.

$5.95

Chocolate Covered Strawberries

Covered with Belgium chocolate. 3 for each guest.

$3.75

Cakes and Pies

Assorted sliced cakes and pie tray.

$5.95

Whole Cake

Pre sliced whole cake serves 12-14 guests.

$35.00

Catering Fruit Smoothies

1. Mango Smoothies

$7.50

2. Mystery Blue Smoothies

$7.50

3. Tropical Smoothies

$7.50

4. Hurricane Smoothies

$7.50

5. Nutter Butter Smoothies

$7.50

6. Hawaiian Smoothies

$7.50

7. Berry Smoothies

$7.50

8. Blender Blast Smoothies

$7.50

9. Create Your Own Smoothies

Upto 3 fruits and juice or milk.

$7.50

Catering Bagel Mill Fresh Healthy Squeezed Juice Bar

1. Green Machine Juice

Spinach, kale, parsley, cucumber, celery.

$7.50

2. Refresher Juice

Cucumber, apple, carrot, spinach.

$7.50

3. The Classic Juice

Carrot, apple, orange, celery.

$7.50

4. Cleanser Juice

Carrots, beets, cucumber.

$7.50

5. Deep Cleanser Juice

Carrot, apple, spinach, kale, ginger.

$7.50

6. Detox Juice

Apple, lemon, carrot, beets, ginger.

$7.50

7. Cintas Punch Juice

Pineapple, grape fruits, orange, mint, lemon.

$7.50

8. Energizer Juice

Ginger, garlic, spinach, carrot.

$7.50
FYI, this restaurant is not accepting orders right now.

About Bagel Mill

  • 1700 1st Ave, New York, NY 10128
  • Bagels, Breakfast, Deli, Dinner, Lunch Specials, Sandwiches
  • (212) 426-0868
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / Bagel Mill
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.