Brother Jimmy's BBQ
MenuAbout
Brother Jimmy's BBQ Menu

Brother Jimmy's BBQ

BBQ, Chicken
416 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001
(212) 779-7427
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Starters

Menu powered by Grubhub

Jumbo Quesadilla

Served with salsa and sour cream add pulled pork, pulled chicken, or brisket for an additional charge.

$12.00 +

Famous Chicken Tenders

$15.00 +

Award Winning Wings

$15.00 +

Delicious Rib Tips

$16.00 +

Southern Cobb Salad

Seasonal greens, tomato, crumbled blue cheese, smoked bacon, avocado & onion. Add meat for an additional charge

$16.00 +

Handhelds

BJ's Pulled Pork BBQ Sandwich

Pulled pork & slaw, our signature sandwich for 30 years.

$16.00

Pulled Chicken Sandwich

Tossed in BJ original BBQ sauce.

$16.00

Smoked BBQ Brisket Sandwich

Smoked low and slow for 14 hours.

$18.00

Dixie Chicken

Fried chicken, jalapeno Jack cheese, onion rings.

$18.00

BJ's Burger

8 oz. brisket blend burger, served with lettuce, tomato, and topped with onion ring and choice of cheddar or Swiss cheese

$17.00

BJ's Impossible BBQ Burger

Plant based burger topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, chipotle BBQ sauce, and choice of Swiss or Cheddar cheese.

$17.00

Chicken Sandwiches

$16.00 +

Mains

1. BJ's Signature Carolina Pulled Pork

Boston butt smoked for 12 hours. Brother Jimmy’s Carolina clear BBQ sauce.

$18.50 +

2. BJ's Hand Pulled BBQ Chicken

Brother Jimmy’s original BBQ sauce.

$18.50 +

3. Half lb. Low Country BBQ and Mac and Cheese

Choice of pulled pork, pulled chicken, or smoked brisket.

$18.00

4. Low and Slow Smoked BBQ Brisket

Our beloved Brother Jimmy’s competition winning black Angus brisket. Smoked for up to 14 hours over hickory wood.

$28.00 +

The Fried Chicken Dinner

Southern fried half chicken (4pc) + a side

$23.00

Award Winning Ribs

Wet Award Winning Ribs

Jumbo St Louis style pork ribs, smoked, baked, and finished on the grill these ribs really “fall of the bone” (5-7 large bones)

$28.00

Dry Award Winning Ribs

Jumbo St Louis style pork ribs, smoked, baked, and finished on the grill these ribs really “fall of the bone” (5-7 large bones)

$28.00

Combo Wet & Dry

5 to 7 bones of both styles of rib

$30.00

Sides

French Fries

$6.50

Corn Bread

$6.50

Mac and Cheese

$6.50

Onion Rings

$6.50

Collard Greens

$6.50

Coleslaw

$6.50

Fried Brussel Sprouts

$6.50

Mashed Potatoes

$6.50

Pick Four!

Pick four of our homemade southern sides.

$20.00

Beverages

Soda

$4.00

Coke

$3.00

Diet Coke

$3.00

Dr Browns Root Beer

$4.00

Sprite

$3.00

Bottle Water

$3.00

Sweet Tea

$4.00

Lemonade

$4.00

Game Day Packages and Specials

Game Day Bulk Jumbo Wing Order

$29.00 +

Game Day Bulk Rib Tip Order

$29.00 +

Game Day Tailgate Party To Go

Wings, Pulled Pork or Pulled Chicken, and 1 Side. Please schedule large orders in advance.

$54.00 +

Game Day Package 1

Pulled Pork, Pulled Chicken, and 2 Sides. Please schedule large orders in advance.

$60.00 +

Game Day Package 2

1 Starter, 2 Mains, and 2 Sides. Please schedule large orders in advance.

$70.00 +

Game Day Package 3

2 Starters, 3 Mains, and 3 Sides. Please schedule large orders in advance.

$80.00 +

Dad's Day Off - BBQ for 6

Serves 6. All the BBQ and fixins’ you need for a perfect picnic spread: 1 lb Pulled Pork, 1 lb Brisket, 2 lbs Wet or Dry Ribs – 1 Bucket of Wings -- 1 quart Mac & Cheese -- 1 quart Coleslaw -- 6 Cornbread Muffins 4 oz BJ ORIGINAL Bbq Sauce, 4 oz. BJ CHIPOTLE Bbq Sauce, 4 oz. BJ CAROLINA Bbq Sauce Picnic ready with plates & utensils - no substitutions. Please schedule large orders in advance.

$165.00

Lunch Special

BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich

Pulled pork & slaw, our signature sandwich for 30 years.

$12.00

Smoked BBQ Brisket Sandwich

Smoked low and slow for 14 hours

$12.00

Dixie Chicken Sandwich

Fried chicken, jalapeno Jack cheese, onion rings.

$12.00

The BJ Burger

8 oz. brisket blend burger, served with lettuce, tomato, and topped with onion ring and choice of cheddar or Swiss cheese

$12.00

BJ's 'Impossible' Burger

Plant based burger topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, chipotle BBQ sauce, and choice of Swiss or Cheddar cheese.

$12.00

Chicken Sandwiches

$12.00

The Southern Chopped Cobb Salad

Seasonal greens, tomato, crumbled blue cheese, smoked bacon, avocado & onion. Add meat for an additional charge.

$12.00 +

Tall Boys (Must be 21 to Purchase)

PBR

Must be 21 to purchase.

$4.00 +

Miller Lite

Must be 21 to purchase.

$4.00 +

Guinness

Must be 21 to purchase.

$4.00 +

Natural Light

Must be 21 to purchase.

$4.00 +

Narragansett

Must be 21 to purchase.

$4.00 +

Coney Island Mermaid Pilsner

Must be 21 to purchase.

$4.00 +

Smith & Forge Hard Cider

Must be 21 to purchase.

$4.00 +

White Claw Mango

Must be 21 to purchase.

$4.00 +
FYI, this restaurant is not accepting orders right now.

About Brother Jimmy's BBQ

  • 416 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001
  • BBQ, Chicken, Hamburgers, Salads, Sandwiches, Soup, Wings
  • (212) 779-7427
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / Brother Jimmy's BBQ
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.