Buttercup Bake Shop
MenuAbout
Buttercup Bake Shop Menu

Buttercup Bake Shop

Bakery, Breakfast
167 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016
(212) 350-4144
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Popular menu items

Menu powered by Grubhub

Red Velvet Cupcake

$4.25 +

S'mores Cupcake

$4.25 +

Strawberry Cupcake (STAFF FAVORITE)

A fluffy strawberry cake with sliced strawberries inside, topped with a white chocolate infused vanilla buttercream.

$4.25

Valentines Day Cupcakes / Bars / Cookies

Valentines Cupcakes!

A classic assortment of vanilla, chocolate, and red velvet cupcakes. Valentines Decoration

$25.00 +

Valentine's Heart Cookies!!

Decorated shortbread cookies

$4.00

Valentine's Love Bites Truffles

Cake trufles

$3.78

Heart Shaped Fudge Brownie

Heart shaped brownie dipped in ganache with sprinkes topping

$5.00

Valentines Day Cupcake

Please choose the cake flavor Icing Vanilla Buttercream

$4.50

Chocolate covered Strawberries

$2.50

Pies Pies Pies!

9" Pecan Pie

$30.00

9" Pumpkin Pie

$30.00

9" Strawberry Rhubarb

$30.00

9" Triple Berry

$30.00

Lemon-Blueberry

$3.55 +

Apple Crumb (our 2nd staff favorite)

$3.55 +

Gluten Free Cupcakes & Bars!

Gluten Free Carrot Cupckaes

Our famous carrot cupcake iced with a spiced cream cheese frosting. (Includes walnuts)

$4.10

Gluten Free Red Velvet Cupcakes

Our traditional authentic cream cheese red velvet cupcake!

$4.00

Gluten Free Van/Van (Vanilla cupcake w/ vanilla icing)

Our buttercup golden vanilla cake with a vanilla buttercream.

$4.00

Gluten Free Van/Choc (Vanilla cake w/ Chocolate buttercream)

Traditional golden vanilla cake with a Chocolate buttercream

$4.00

Gluten Free ChocVan (Chocolate cake w/ vanilla buttercream)

Chocolate moist cake with a rich vanilla buttercream

$4.10

Gluten Free ChocChoc

Our moist chocolate cake with our Chocolate buttercream

$4.10

Gluten Free Fudge brownie

Gluten Free chocolate fudge brownie bar

$4.00

Gluten Free blondie choc chip gooey bar

Gluten Free Gooey Chocolate chip blondie bar

$4.15

Main Menu

Chocolate Lover's Mix Cupcakes

A dozen of our top chocolate cupcake flavors. Contains nuts.

$45.00 +

Assorted Bar and Chocolate Cookie Platter

1 dozen assortment of 6 bars and 6 cookies.

$37.00 +

1 Dozen Macaron Sampler

Fresh macarons. Salted caramel, pistachio, lemon, chocolate, mocha, vanilla, coconut and raspberry.

$33.00 +

1 Dozen Premium Cupcakes

A dozen of our top flavor cupcakes of the day.

$45.00 +

1 Dozen Traditional Assortment

A dozen traditional cupcakes, free of nut.

$45.00 +

Cookie Lovers Platter

An assortment of a dozen cookie. Raspberry thumbprint, caramel chocolate chunks and triple chocolate.

$27.00 +

1 Dozen Mini Cupcakes

A nut free assortment of mini cupcakes.

$20.00 +

1 Dozen Premium Mini Nut-Free Cupcakes

A dozen of our top flavors in mini. (coconut, chocolate espresso, salted caramel, lemon raspberry, red velvet, chocolate raspberry, lemon)

$24.00 +

Banana Pudding

10oz clear cup of Banana pudding with Nilla Wafers.

$6.00 +

Cupcakes

Apple Pie a La Mode Cupcake

$4.25 +

Chunky Monkey Cupcake

Banana cupcake with Chocolate buttercream

$4.25 +

Oreo Cookies 'n Cream Cupcake

$4.25 +

Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cupcake

** When adding a personalized notecard, bow or candle, please order specialized cupcake(s) individually.

$4.25 +

Espresso Shot Cupcake

$4.25 +

Hummingbird Cupcake

$4.25 +

Lemon Raspberry Meringue Cupcake

$4.25 +

Marble Ganache Cupcake

$3.65 +

Spiced Carrot Cupcake

$4.25 +

Red Velvet Cupcake

$4.25 +

S'mores Cupcake

$4.25 +

Turtle Cupcake

$3.50 +

Twinkie Cupcake

$3.99 +

Van/Van (Vanilla cake / w vanilla buttercream)

$3.99 +

VanChoc (Vanilla cake w chocolate buttercream)

$3.99 +

ChocVan (Chocolate cake / vanilla buttercream)

$3.99 +

ChoChoc ( Choc cake / Choc buttercream)

$3.99 +

Devil Dog Cupcake

$3.99 +

Strawberry Cupcake (STAFF FAVORITE)

A fluffy strawberry cake with sliced strawberries inside, topped with a white chocolate infused vanilla buttercream.

$4.25

Cookie Dough Cupcake

Burnt Butterc Cookie dough frosting, full cookie baked inside a vanilla cupcake

$4.25

Pumpkin Spice

Pumpkin spice cupcake topped with cream cheese frosting, dusted with cinnamon and drizzled with honey

$3.50

The Thaly *Raspberry Choc*

Soft decadent chocolate cake with a rich raspberry filling, topped with a raspberry buttercream, ganache drizzle.

$4.44

Ube *Filipino Yam*

Ube cream cheese frosting Ube cake Staff fav

$4.25

Salted Caramel Dulce de Leche Cupcake

$4.25 +

Cookies

Bestest Oatmeal Cinnamon Chocolate Cookie

Oatmeal cinnamon cookie loaded with chocolate chips.

$2.50 +

Salted Caramel Choc Chunk Cookie

Break into one of our gooey Caramel Chocolate Chunk Cookies for the ultimate cookie experience!

$2.50 +

Snickerdoodle

A delicious cinnamon sugar cookie. No worries, it's soft .

$2.50 +

Chocolate Chip Cookie

A classic Chocolate chip cookie, but not so basic after all.

$2.50 +

Bars and Squares

Berry Captain Crunch Cereal Treat

Berry cereal coated with melted marshmallows.

$4.00 +

Campfire Bar***

Toasted graham cracker crust with chocolate ganache, fire-roasted marshmallows and fluffy meringue.

$5.00 +

Raspberry Dream Bar

Luscious white chocolate swirled with homemade seedless raspberry jam atop a buttery shortbread crust.

$4.00 +

Fudge Brownie

Decadent fudgy brownie made with the darkest chocolate.

$4.00 +

Lemon Square

Tart lemon curd filling atop a buttery shortbread crust.

$4.50 +

Coconut Magic Bar

Graham cracker crust, chocolate chips, walnuts and shredded coconut magically layered with sweetened milk. Contains nuts.

$4.25 +

Marble Rice Krispy

Puffed rice cereal and chocolate cereal coated with melted marshmallows.

$4.00

Oatmeal Fudge

Housemade fudge layered between a chewy oatmeal crust.

$4.00 +

Peanut Buttercup

Crunchy oatmeal crust with a creamy peanut butter filling and dark chocolate ganache. Contains nuts.

$3.75

Walnut Brownie

Our house made fudge brownie loaded with walnuts

$4.25 +

Funfetti Rainbow Sprinkle Rice Krispy Treat

Traditional rice krispy with rainbow funfetti sprinkles.

$3.79 +

Raspberry Dream Bar

Luscious white chocolate swirled with homemade seedless raspberry jam atop a buttery shortbread crust sprinkled with toasted slivered almonds and raw sugar.

$4.15 +

Gooey Chocolate Chip Bar

An ooey, gooey, buttery cookie bar loaded with chocolate chips.

$4.00 +

Peanut Butter Jelly Bar (*staff favorite*)

Staff favorite. Peanut butter and grape jelly bar! Topped with peanuts. A classic pb&J sandwich

$4.58

Pecan Pie Bar

A rich heavy layer of pecan pie filling in between a shortbread crust, topped with toasted pecan!

$5.00

Butter Cake Bar * NEW BAR ALERT*

Golden butter cake crust topped with gooey butter cake filling.

$4.00

1 dzn assorted bar platter

mix of bars. will include nut flavors unless requested otherwise.

$54.00

Specialty Pudding

Strawberry Shortcake

Available as 9 oz. or 32 oz. Choose from strawberry shortcake, tiramisu, oreo, cookies 'n cream, lemon raspberry gingersnap, chocolate milk, hazelnut Nutella, and caramel brownie cookie dough.

$5.55

Tiramisu pudding

$6.00 +

Cookies and Cream pudding

$6.00 +

Lemon Raspberry Gingersnap

$5.55

Chocolate Milk

$5.55 +

Hazelnut Nutella

$5.55 +

Caramel Brownie Cookie Dough

$6.00 +

Triple Chocolate Trifle

Chocolate based pudding, rich chocolate ganache layers, seperated with chocolate cake crumbs. Definitely a chocolate lovers choice.

$6.00 +

Banana Pudding

Layers of luscious vanilla pudding with vanilla wafers and bananas.

$6.00

Mini Cheesecakes

Raspberry Almond Marzipan (staff favorite)

$7.50 +

Strawberry Swirl

Graham cracker crust, strawberry base cheesecake with our signature house made strawberry filling.

$7.50 +

Chocolate Marble Ganache Swirl

$7.50 +

Quadruple Chocolate ganache cheesecake

$7.50 +

Pumpkin Spice Cheesecake

Staff favorite.

$7.50 +

Oreo Cookies and Creme Cheesecake

$7.50 +

Red Velvet Cheesecake

Red velvet-smooth cheesecake with a chocolate bottom crust.

$7.50 +

Vanilla Bean Cheesecake

Graham cracker crust, plain vanilla bean cheesecake.

$7.50 +

Candles

Individual Candles

$0.27 +

Box of Candles

a box of classic candles. Includes 24 candles. pink, white, blue, yellow.

$3.00

Happy Birthday Candles

A pack of 14 candles, each spelling one letter. Spells " H A P P Y B I R T H D A Y !"

$3.79

Number Candles

Please specify what number! 0 - 9 and color light pink, light blue, light purple, light green.

$25.99

CONGRATULATIONS candles

15 candles, each spelling one word. ' C O N G R A T U L A T I O N S "

$3.50

Beer Can candle

A pack of 6 beer-can shaped candles (white can)

$3.00

Champagne Candles

A pack of 6 champagne bottle candles (green bottle )

$3.00

Note Cards

Note Cards

Note Cards for Cupcakes

$3.00 +

ST. PATTY'S CUPCAKES !

Single St. Patty's cupcake

Please choose either Vanilla cupcake / vanilla icing, or Vanilla cupcake/ Chocolate icing, or Chocolate cupcake/chocolate icing, or chocolate cupcake/Vanilla icing. Otherwise staff will choose a flavor for you if not specified =)

$4.10

Bunt slices

Lemon Vanilla Bunt

$5.25

Maple cinnamon bunt

$5.25

Blueberry Bundt

$5.50
Restaurant closed
.

About Buttercup Bake Shop

  • 167 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016
  • Bakery, Breakfast, Cakes, Dessert, Dinner, Lunch Specials
  • (212) 350-4144
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / Buttercup Bake Shop
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.