Buttercup Bake Shop
MenuAbout
Buttercup Bake Shop Menu

Buttercup Bake Shop

Bakery, Breakfast
973 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022
(212) 350-4144
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Popular menu items

Menu powered by Grubhub

1 Dozen Mini Cupcakes NUTFREE MINIS

A nut free assortment of mini cupcakes.

$20.00 +

Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Buttercream Slice

$7.00 +

FUNFETTI Birthday Cupcakes

Our Vanilla Cake with Funfetti Rainbow Sprinkles throught. Comes in vanilla buttercream

$4.25 +

✨ SPONTANEOUS BAKING! ✨

Strawberry glazed cake donut

We made use of extra cake batter by whipping up a donut with it. Rainbow sprinkles tossed on a strawberry glaze. You're welcome. THERE MAY BE A LIMIT ON HOW MANY YOU RECEIVE. ORDERS WILL BE ADJUSTED POST DELIVERY.

$3.00

Vanilla mini M&M Cake donut

We made use of extra cake batter by whipping up a donut with it. Rainbow sprinkles tossed on a strawberry glaze. You're welcome.

$3.00

Cinnamon Roll Coated in Glaze

Our attempt at a classic cinnamon roll coated with a thick glaze!

$5.50

Rainbow Cookie Cake Slice

CONTAINS ALMOND FLOUR + ALMOND PASTE! Our version of a rainbow cookie in the best form it could take - a cake. Enjoy a slice, it won't last long. ;)

$10.00

Blueberry yoghurt pudding! Staff favorite*

10oz cup of blueberry yogurt based pudding

$5.75

Peanut Butter Jelly Cinnamon Bun

$6.50

Apple Cinnamon Bun

Contains cranberries, raisins and oats

$6.50

Biscoff Pudding

$5.50

Pumpkin pie bar *staff fav*

$4.00

Nutella Cinnamon Bun

$5.50

Pumpkin Cinnamon Roll

$5.50

Alfajores Cookie

$1.50

Crookie

Delicious chocolate chip cookie and croissant hybrid

$4.75

Raspberry sugar cookie danish

$3.75

Salted Caramel Cookie Danish

$6.00

Strawberry shortcake pudding *New item*

Strawberry Shortcake Pudding is a creamy blend of vanilla pudding, sweet strawberry compote, and crumbled shortcake, and whipped cream. A classic dessert and irresistible treat!

$6.00

Red Velvet Pudding

Vanilla base pudding layered with red velvet cake

$6.00

Spiced Pumpkin Pie Pudding *new yummy item alert*

10oz cup of rich creamy pumpkin pie pudding, spiced cake, cream cheese filling.

$6.00

blueberry yoghurt (LIMITED ONE WEEK ONLY)

$6.00

Cinnamon Bunn (Temporary new item)

Cinnamon bun, not a cupcake =)

$4.25

Cherry Cheese Danish

Nutfree, and fruity! Enjoy the best of both worlds of cherries and cheese.

$4.00

Pecan Danish

Pecan Coated Deliciousness!

$4.00

Raspberry cornbread

$5.00

blueberry cornbread

$5.00

decorated shortbread shape cookies!

decorated shortbread royal icing cookies. Cookies are an assortment and might differ from photo

$4.50

Ube Cinnamon Roll Coated in a Maple Glaze!

Our attempt at a Ube cinnamon roll coated with a thick glaze!

$5.50

Main Menu

1 Dozen Macaron Sampler

Fresh macarons. Salted caramel, pistachio, lemon, chocolate, mocha, vanilla, coconut and raspberry.

$33.50

Specialty Pudding- Strawberry Shortcake

$6.00 +

Specialty Pudding- Tiramisu

$2.00 +

Specialty Pudding- Oreo

$2.00 +

Specialty Pudding- Cookies 'n Cream

$2.00 +

Specialty Pudding- Lemon Raspberry Gingersnap

$2.00 +

Specialty Pudding- Chocolate Milk

$2.00 +

Specialty Pudding- Hazelnut Nutella

$2.00 +

1 Dzn Bar and Cookie Platter **

A platter of 6 of our favorite bars and 6 of our favorite cookies. All in one platter. Please specify if you would like this assortment to be NUT-FREE!!

$39.00 +

1 Dzn Bar Platter - Assorted

Assorted mix of 12 bars. Will include flavors that include nuts unless requested otherwise!!

$54.00

Lemon Vanilla Bundt Cake

A fresh lemon zesty cake and a vanilla glaze.

$5.50 +

Cinnamon Maple Bundt Cake

A moist, rich cinnamon maple bundt cake with cinnamon glaze on top!

$5.50 +

1 Dzn Cookie Platter***

A dozen of our house special cookies in a platter!

$32.50 +

1 Dozen Premium Cupcakes Full size

A dozen of our top flavor cupcakes of the day. Please specify if you would like these to be nut-free!

$47.00 +

1 Dozen Traditional Assortment NUTFREE full size

A dozen traditional cupcakes, free of nut.

$45.00 +

1 Dozen Mini Cupcakes NUTFREE MINIS

A nut free assortment of mini cupcakes.

$20.00 +

1 Dozen Premium Mini Cupcakes Nut-free MINIS

A dozen of our top flavors in mini. A dozen of our top flavors in mini. (coconut, chocolate espresso, salted caramel, lemon raspberry, red velvet, chocolate raspberry, lemon)

$24.00 +

Brownies, Bars, and Squares

1 Dzn Bar and Cookie Platter **

A platter of 6 of our favorite bars and 6 of our favorite cookies. All in one platter. Please specify if you would like this assortment to be NUT-FREE!!

$39.00 +

Lemon Tart Squares**

Our tart lemon squares topped with fine powdered sugar on a soft flaky crust. A topseller.

$4.75 +

S'mores Campfire Bar***

Our top selling bar: Graham cracker crust, marshmallows, rich ganache, topped with torched meringue and chocolate fudge drizzle. Messy, but yummy.

$5.50 +

Gooey Choc Chip Bar

A lovely chewy bar mixed with brown sugar and packed with chocolate chips.

$4.00 +

Magic Coconut Bar

Shredded coconut, walnuts and chocolate chips caramelized in layers in a graham cracker crust.

$4.25 +

Rice Krispie Treat

Original crisped rice cereal coated with a delicious melted marshmallow mix.

$4.00 +

Raspberry White Choc Dream Bar

Our house raspberry fruit spread baked on a delectable graham cracker crust, coated underneath with white chocolate, and topped with sliced almonds

$4.00 +

Fudge Brownie

Rich and moist fudge brownies each infused with a hint of creamy dark chocolate.

$3.99 +

Peanut Butter Mud Bar

A perfect balance of peanut butter, chocolate, pecans and white chocolate in a bar.

$3.50 +

Berry Captain Crunch Cereal Treat

Berry cereal coated with melted marshmallows.

$4.00 +

Oreo fuge bar

Our fudge brownie with Oreo Cookies'n'Creme topping.

$4.50 +

Funfetti Sprinkle Rice Krispy

Puffed rice cereal and rainbow sprinkles all in one.

$4.00 +

Oatmeal Fudge

Housemade fudge layered between a chewy oatmeal crust.

$4.25 +

Raspberry Dream Bar

Luscious white chocolate swirled with homemade seedless raspberry jam atop a buttery shortbread crust.

$4.00 +

Peanut Butter Jelly Bar***

Top Seller: The classic peanut butter and jelly sandwich with a twist. Grape jelly sandwiched between two layers of peanut butter cookie dough. Sprinkled with salty roasted peanuts.

$4.50 +

Apple Pie Bar

Cinnamon flavored bars with apple slices, custard and a buttery crust topping.

$3.25 +

Walnut Brownie

Our traditional brownie mixed and topped with walnuts

$4.00

Peanut Butter Cup bar

smooth peanut butter, topped with a chocolate layer, and a graham cracker crust on the bottom.

$4.25

Oatmeal Fudge Bar

Oatmeal crust with rich chocolate fudge and extra oatmeal pieces of oatmeal on top.

$4.25

Oreo Cheesecake Brownie (RICH)

A rich thick cheesebake oreo with brownie base and oreo bits

$5.45

White chocolate Raspberry Dream almond bar

A rich raspberry coated graham crust with sliced almonds and white chocolate

$4.30

Pecan Pie Bars

A rich square slice of Pecan pie in a bar!

$5.50

Butter Cake Bar * New bar alert! *

Golden butter cake crust topped with gooey butter cake filling.

$4.00

Cherry cheesecake brownie

Fudge brownie base, cherry cheesecake filling on top

$4.50

NEW BAR ALERT* Pumpkin Pie streusel crumb bar *

Delicious smooth pumpkin pie filling with a cinnamon streusel crumb topping on a shortbread crust. A definite staff favorite.

$4.50

1 Dzn Bar Platter - Assorted

Assorted mix of 12 bars. Will include flavors that include nuts unless requested otherwise!!

$54.00

Peanut Butter Bar *New item!!*

Delicious and rich Peanut Butter Bar with peanut butter chips!

$4.50

Brookie *New*

A blend of your favorite Ooey Gooey Chocolate Chip Cookie Bar and Fudge Brownie!

$4.75

Ube Butter Cake Bar **NEW**

An enhanced version of the famous buttercake bar, in UBE flavour.

$4.50

Peanut Butter Reeses Pieces Bar

$5.00

Chocolate Butter Cake Bar

$4.50

Bundt Cakes

Chocolate Sour Cream Cake

10" Cake.

$5.50 +

Lemon Vanilla Bundt Cake

A fresh lemon zesty cake and a vanilla glaze.

$5.50 +

Cinnamon Maple Bundt Cake

A moist, rich cinnamon maple bundt cake with cinnamon glaze on top!

$5.50 +

Blueberry struesel bundt cake (NEW ITEM ALERT)

Just like your favorite blueberry muffins, with a streusel topping.

$5.50

Tres Leches square

$5.00

"Tom Cruise's" white chocolate coconut bundt

A replica of that Mission Impossible guy's famously gifted dessert.

$5.00

Pumpkin Bundt Cake

$5.50 +

Orange Vanilla Bundt Cake Slice

$5.50 +

Blueberry Bundt Cake Slice

$5.50 +

Cakes by the Slice

Buttercup Golden (Vanilla) with Chocolate Buttercream SLICE

$7.00 +

Classic Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Buttercream SLICE

$7.00 +

Humming Bird SLICE

Banana, pineapple, cream cheese, cinnamon, pecan

$7.00 +

Apple Walnut

$6.66 +

Chunky Monkey

Banana and chocolate chip.

$6.00 +

Lemon/Lemon Slice

$7.50 +

Coconut Meringue Slice

$7.25 +

Mochaccino Slice

$7.50 +

Carrot Cake Slice

$7.50 +

Red Velvet Slice

$7.50 +

Vanilla Cake Vanilla buttercream Slice

Vanilla Cake with Rich Vanilla Buttercream.

$7.00 +

Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Buttercream Slice

$7.00 +

Ube Cake with Rich Ube Frosting Slice

$7.50 +

Peanut Butter and Jelly!

$7.25

Gluten free vanilla chocolate cake

Vanilla cake with chocolate buttercream OR Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream

$55.00

Strawberry Slice (staff fav)

Strawberry cake with bits of diced strawberries topped with a white chocolate infused vanilla buttercream

$7.50

Salted Caramel Dulce-de-leche SLICE

$7.25

Dark Chocolate Peanut Buttercup

Dark choc cake with Reese's PB cups inside and PB icing. For all you peanut butter freaks out there

$7.25

Tres Leches Cubes

$7.50

Rainbow Cookie Cake Slice

CONTAINS ALMOND FLOUR + ALMOND PASTE! Our version of a rainbow cookie in the best form it could take - a cake. Enjoy a slice, it won't last long. ;)

$10.00

TRES LECHES * NEW* GIANT Slice

Tres leches cake. Promotional item. May or may not keep on menu for long

$7.50

Matcha Tres Leche!

A vibrant twist on the classic! Our Matcha Tres Leches is a soft sponge cake soaked in a creamy matcha-infused three-milk blend, topped with lightly whipped cream and a dusting of premium green tea powder.

$7.50

Chocolate Tres Leches

Rich, decadent, and irresistible. Our Chocolate Tres Leches takes everything you love about the original and blends it with velvety cocoa goodness. Soaked in a luscious chocolate milk mixture and topped with airy whipped cream and chocolate shavings. It's a chocoholic’s dream come true

$7.50

Whole Cakes

Buttercup Golden Layer Cake (vanilla)

Buttercup Golden vanilla cake with either rich chocolate buttercream or Vanilla buttercream *please choose*

$45.00 +

Classic Chocolate cake

Classic chocolate cake with rich chocolate buttercream or Vanilla Buttercream

$45.00 +

Carrot Cake

Made with fresh carrots, apples, and pecans, frosted with cream cheese frosting (iced in between layers and on top).

$68.00 +

Red Velvet Cake

Yellow cake with a hint of cocoa, dyed a deep beautiful red (tastes like a light chocolate cake). Frosted with cream cheese frosting between layers and on top.

$68.00 +

Lemony Lemon

9"3 layer (12-16 ppl). A lemony cake with fresh lemon zest, and lemon buttercream.

$68.00 +

9" 2 layer Salted Caramel Dulce-de-Leche (10-13 ppl)

Dulce de Leche cake with Swirls of salted caramel buttercream (sea salt).

$58.00 +

Strawberry - White chocolate vanilla buttercream

Strawberry layer cake with strawberry pieces in the batter. Iced with a white chocolate buttercream.

$68.00 +

9"3 Ube *Filipino Yam*

A light, filipino purple yam cake. Iced with an Ube flavored cream cheese frosting.

$68.00 +

Heart Shaped Cake

PRE-ORDER ONLY ITEM! Please order at least 3 days in advance!

$50.00 +

Candles / Sparkler

Individual Candle

Single individual candle

$0.50

Number glitter candles (0 - 9)

Choose your COLOR and NUMBER

$1.99

H-a-p-p-y B-i-r-t-h-d-a-y Candles

Candles individually spell out happy birthday

$3.79

Congratulations Candle

Spells out congratulations.

$3.25

Metallic Gold or Silver Candles

Metallic gold shiny 10 pack Please choose your color

$3.50

Celebration Sparkler (1 single)

Celebration candle, will stay lit anywhere from 10-40 seconds (depending on your karmic connection) These candles don't smoke during lighting, they are considered LOW smoke upon diffusing of flame. Suitable for indoor use ONLY. single sparkler

$4.00

H-A-P-P-Y B-I-R-T-H-D-A-Y Candles

13 individual letter candles (INCLUDES the insert/pick)

$2.99

Beer Candle

Beer shaped candle

$3.25

Champagne Candles

Champagne shaped candles

$3.25

Pack of 24 candles traditional

Traditional pack of yellow, pink, white, blue spiral

$2.99

TALL Rainbow Wavy Candle

Tall candles rainbow color

$3.25

Cupcake shaped candles

$3.25

Princess Castle, Unicorn, Heart Candles

$3.25

Trick candles (re-lights)

$2.99

Swirl pastel candles

$3.50

Butterfly Set

$3.50

Tall Swirly bright candles

$3.50

Make-up Beauty kit

$3.50

Happy Birthday Pick

$0.55

Notecard

Notecard custom

Add your own personalized message

$2.50

Cookies

Samoa toasted coconut *Staff Favorite*

Shortbread cookies coated in caramel, sprinkled with toasted coconut and laced with chocolatey stripes.

$2.55

Triple Chocolate Fudge Pudding Cookie

Chocolate pudding cookie made with Valrhona cocoa powder and chocolate chunks, because chocolate chips aren't as fun.

$2.50 +

Bestest Oatmeal Cinnamon Chocolate Cookie

Oatmeal cinnamon cookie loaded with chocolate chips.

$2.70 +

Chocolate Chip Cookie

A traditional style chocolate chip cookie. Soft but has a slight crunch.

$2.70 +

Salted Caramel Chunk Cookie

Soft and chewy cookie with gooey caramel bits and chocolate chunks topped with sea salt.

$2.50 +

Snikerdoodle Cookie

Cinnamon snickerdoodle cookie. No worries, it's soft.

$2.50 +

Macadamia Nut Cookie

Made with white chocolate.

$2.50

Peanut Butter Cookie

A classic peanut butter cookie loaded

$2.55

1 Dzn Cookie Platter***

A dozen of our house special cookies in a platter!

$32.50

RAINBOW Cookies

Traditional 3 layer almond rainbow cookie

$1.20

Sugar Cookie

$2.00

Black raspberry rainbow cookie

sugar cookie with rainbow sprinkles filled with black cherry.

$3.00

Pecan Sandies * staff fav

Buttery cinnamon sugar cookie with diced pecans.

$2.50

Cup'o'Cookies

A cup of mini chocolate chip crispy cookies.

$5.00

PB&J Cookie !!

Peanut butter Jelly cookie!

$2.50

Biscoff Cookie

Traditional sugar-cookie topped in a Biscoff spread.

$2.75

Coconut Macaron - Choc dipped

Coconut

$2.75

Raspberry Thumbprints

Buttery cookies with a raspberry dollop

$1.50

Lemon thumprints

$1.50

Triple Chocolate Cookie

$2.70

Raspberry Jam Funfetti Cookie

Raspberry Jam Filled Funfetti Sugar Cookie

$3.00

Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie

$3.00

Cream Puffs

Strawberry Cream Puff

$4.50

Green Tea Cream Puff

$4.50

Ube Cream Puff

$4.50

Coffee/Espresso Cream Puff

$4.50

Cupcakes

Apple Pie a La Mode ***

Caramelized apple cinnamon struessel cake topped with a ice-cream scoop style vanilla buttercream.

$4.25 +

FUNFETTI Birthday Cupcakes

Our Vanilla Cake with Funfetti Rainbow Sprinkles throught. Comes in vanilla buttercream

$4.25 +

Buttercup Golden Cupcake

Fluffy vanilla cake with choice of buttercream.

$3.99 +

Classic Chocolate Cupcake

Rich chocolate cake with choice of buttercream.

$3.99 +

Red Velvet Cupcake

Buttery cake with a hint of cocoa topped with cream cheese frosting.

$3.99 +

Lemony Lemon Cupcake

Light and lemony cake with zesty lemon buttercream.

$3.99 +

Chunky Monkey Cupcake

Banana cake filled with chocolate chips and chocolate buttercream.

$4.25 +

Chocolate Lover's Mix Cupcakes

A dozen of our top chocolate cupcake flavors. Contains nuts.

$42.00 +

Hummingbird Cupcake

Banana pineapple cake with cream cheese frosting and chopped pecans.

$4.25 +

Devil Dog Cupcake

Rich chocolate cake with a whipped meringue frosting and chocolate drizzle.

$3.99 +

Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter cupcake

Dark choc cake filled with peanut butter icing with Reese's PB cups inside batter. For all you peanut butter freaks out there.

$4.25 +

Espresso Shot cupcake

Dark choc cake with a nescafe espresso coffee buttercream. Just don't try to eat one and fall asleep. Not happening.

$4.25 +

Lemon Raspberry Torched Meringue

A light lemony cupcake with fresh raspberry jam filling and a whipped torched meringue frosting.

$4.25 +

Oreo Cookies 'n Cream cupcakes

Vanilla cake stuffed with a whole Oreo (yes a whole one) topped with an Oreo crumb buttercream.

$4.25 +

S'mores cupcake

Dark choc cake torched meringue, topped with toasted marshmallow, and don’t forget the graham cracker crust. Definitely addicting

$4.25 +

Salted Caramel Dulce de Leche cupcake

Dulce de Leche cake with Swirls of salted caramel buttercream (sea salt). Sweet and salty, like a typical NY'ker.

$4.25 +

Spiced Carrot cupcake

Carrot cake with apples & walnuts topped with a spiced cream cheese. Definitely a top favorite.

$4.25 +

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cupcake

Vanilla cake with a chocolate chip cookie inside topped with cookie dough molasses buttercream + cookie dough topping.

$4.25

Twinkie

Vanilla cake with light whipped meringue interior and topping. Like a classic Twinky (minus the 37 ingredients)

$3.99

UBE cupcake

Filipino purple yam cake topped with Ube cream cheese icing.

$4.25

Strawberry Cupcake

Light strawberry cake baked with fresh pieces of strawberry iced with a white chocolate infused vanilla buttercream

$4.25

The Thaly *Raspberry Choc*

Soft decadent chocolate cake with a rich raspberry filling, topped with a raspberry buttercream, ganache drizzle.

$4.25

Pumpkin Spice *seasonal*

Pumpkin spice cupcake topped with cream cheese frosting, dusted with cinnamon and drizzled with honey

$3.50

VEGAN! Buttercup Golden Cupcake

Fluffy VEGAN! vanilla cake with choice of icing

$4.50

VEGAN! Chocolate Cupcake

Rich VEGAN! chocolate cake with choice of icing

$4.50

Cannoli Cupcake

Vanilla cupcake filled and topped with cannoli cream

$4.50

Easter Cookies

Easter Green Bunny cookies

delicious handmade sugar cookie decorated with our homemade fondant and a dash of love.

$4.50

Easte Bunny Puff

The Easter bunny is so excite they have their Sunday best on with their fluffy tail. Delicious handmade sugar cookie decorated with our homemade fondant and a dash of love.

$4.50

EasterEgg Sugar Cookies

This little bunny left you an egg this year. Delicious handmade sugar cookie decorated with our homemade fondant and a dash of love.

$4.50

Easter Cross Cookie

Single Cross Cookie Delicious handmade sugar cookie decorated with our homemade fondant and a dash of love.

$4.50

Easter Peep theme Sugar Cookies

Peep This :) Our peep inspired delicious handmade sugar cookie decorated with our homemade fondant and a dash of love.

$4.50

Famous Puddings

Famous Banana Pudding

Layers of luscious vanilla pudding with vanilla wafers and bananas.

$6.00 +

Oreo Cookies and Cream Pudding

$6.00 +

Chocolate Trifle Pudding

$6.00 +

Salted Caramel Pudding

$6.00

Raspberry Lemon Pudding

$6.00

Caramel Brownie Cookie Dough Pudding

Chunks and bits of Chocolate chip bars, fudge brownies, and caramel drizzle goodness layered in our specialty pudding.

$6.00 +

Tiramisu Pudding

The Buttercup twist on an Italian classic. Espresso flavored pudding layered with dark-roast coffee dipped lady fingers, dusted with a layer of Valhrona Cocoa Powder.

$6.00 +

Hazelnut Nutella

Hazelnut flavored pudding layered with pound cake, Nutella and crunchy dried hazelnuts.

$36.00 +

Mini Cheesecakes

Oreo crumb Mini Cheesecake

Oreo cookies and cream interior, oreo crumb topping. Chocolate based crust. Feeds 1-2

$7.99

Red Velvet Mini Cheesecake

$7.00

Chocolate Swirl Mini Cheesecake

$7.00

Marble swirled mini cheesecake

Graham cracker crust, marble ganache swirl cheesecake

$7.00

Raspberry Fruit Mini Cheesecake

$7.00

Pumpkin Spice Mini Cheesecake

$7.99

Peanut Butter Mini Cheesecake

$7.00

Strawberry mini cheesecake

Fresh strawberry swirled cheesecake

$7.00

Marble Swirled Cheesecake

A swirl of Chocolate Marble Ganache. Feeds 1-2

$7.99

Dulce de Leche Swirled Cheesecake

Rich swirl of caramel dulce de leche

$7.00

Funfetti Rainbow Cheesecake

Funfetti rainbow sprinkles throughout cheesecake

$7.00

Strawberry Swirl

Strawberry cheesecake swirled with our homemade strawberry jam. Feeds 1-2

$7.99

Coconut Cheese Cake

$7.00

Raspberry Marzipan cheesecake

Graham cracker crust, raspberry marzipan cheesecake, a hint of almond.

$7.00

Red Velvet Cheesecake

Chocolate crumb crust / Red velvet cheesecake with cream cheese frosting and red velvet cupcake crumbs on top. Feeds 1-2

$7.99

Quadruple Chocolate Cheesecake

A chocolate crumb base, chocolate cheesecake, topped with a ganache fudge and chocolate shavings on top. Feeds 1-2

$7.99

Pumpkin Spice Cheesecake *Staff Favorite*

Our favorite pumpkin spice cheesecake topped with crushed walnuts and cream cheese icing.

$7.99

Vanilla Bean Cheesecake

Vanilla Bean Cheesecake topped with our Vanilla Buttercream. Feeds 1-2

$7.99

Raspberry Marzipan Cheesecake * staff fav*

Raspberry swirled Cheesecake made with Marzipan (almond paste). Feeds 1-2

$7.99

Caramel Pecan Cheesecake

Our traditional cheesecake topped with chopped pecans and our homemade caramel sauce

$7.00

Pistachio Cheesecake

$7.99

Mocha Cheesecake

$7.99

Macarons

1dz Assorted Macarons

Flavors might include: Pistachio, Salted Caramel, Mocha, Mango, Lemon, Raspberry, Oreo cookies, Red velvet, Chocolate, Coconut, Vanilla, Strawberry Cheesecake. Varries.

$40.00

6 Pack Macarons Assorted

An assortment of 6 Macarons. Flavors might include: Oreo, Mango, Lemon, Raspberry, Strawberry Cheesecake, Coconut, Vanilla, Satled Caramel, Mocha, Chocolate, Pistachio, Fruity Pebbles

$21.00

4 Pack Macarons

4 Pack of Macaron assortment

$14.00

Individual Macaron

Please choose one

$3.50

Gluten Free (Friendly) Cupcakes and Bars

Gluten free Carrot Cupcakes

Our famous carrot cupcake iced with a spiced cream cheese frosting. (Includes walnuts)

$4.25

Gluten Free Red Velvet cupcakes

Our traditional authentic cream cheese red velvet cupcake!

$4.25

Gluten Free Vanilla and Vanilla

Our buttercup golden vanilla cake with a vanilla buttercream.

$4.11

Gluten Free Vanilla / Chocolate

Traditional golden vanilla cake with a Chocolate buttercream

$4.11

Gluten Free Chocolate / Vanilla

Chocolate moist cake with a rich vanilla buttercream

$4.11

Gluten Free Chocolate / Chocolate

Our moist chocolate cake with our Chocolate buttercream

$4.11

Gluten Free Gooey Chocolate chip blondie bar

$4.12

Gluten Free chocolate fudge brownie bar

$4.11

Red velvet gluten free

Genuine cream cheese frosting

$4.25

Ice Cream (Home Made)

SWEET CORN * STAFF FAVORITE*

Creamy sweet corn with a hint of maple syrup. Loaded with fresh baked corn cookie pieces.

$4.50 +

S'mores

Milk Chocolate ice cream with ribbons of marshmallow fluff, house made fudge, fire roasted marshmallows and buttery graham cracker crumbs.

$4.50 +

Salted Caramel

Salty caramel ice cream with gobs of dulce de leche swirls

$4.50 +

Cotton Candy

Smooth cotton candy flavor with crunchy cotton candy pieces.

$4.50 +

Cake Batter *STAFF FAVORITE*

Funfetti cake batter ice cream with chunks of pound cake pieces, loaded with rainbow sprinkles.

$4.50 +

Brownie Batter

Liquid brownie ice cream loaded with chunks of our fudge bar and house made fudge sauce.

$4.50 +

Classic Madagascar Vanilla Bean

Classic vanilla flavor speckled with Madagascar Vanilla Bean

$4.50 +

Espresso

Roasted Cafe du Monde coffee ice cream with shards of dark chocolate

$4.50 +

St. Patty's Cupcakes

Single St. Patty's Cupcake

Please choose either Vanilla cupcake / vanilla icing, or Vanilla cupcake/ Chocolate icing, or Chocolate cupcake/chocolate icing, or chocolate cupcake/Vanilla icing. Otherwise staff will choose a flavor for you if not specified =)

$4.11

HAPPY THANKSGIVING! 🦃

9" Pecan Pie !!

Pecan

$31.00

6" Apple Crumb Pie

6" Pie

$11.50

6" Pecan Pie

$11.50

6" Pumpkin Pie

6"

$11.50

6" Tripple-Berry Pie (staff Fav)

Blackberry, blueberry, blackberry pie

$11.50

6" Coconut Cream

$11.50

6" Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

$11.50

9" Peach crumb Pie

9" pie

$27.50

Strawberry Rhubarb slice

1 slice of pie

$6.50

Lemon-Blueberry Pie

$3.50 +

Peach Cobbler

$3.50 +

9" Apple Crumb Pie

Delicious streusel topping

$31.00

3" mini Pumpkin pie

$4.00

3" mini pecan pie

$4.00

3" mini triple berry pie

$4.00

3" mini apple crumb pie

$4.00

3" mini lemon pie

$4.00

3" mini Strawberry Rhubarb pie

$4.00

9" Strawberry Rhubarb pie

$31.00

9" Triple Berry Pie

$31.00

9" Pumpkin Pie

$31.00

9" Coconut Cream Pie

LIMITED STOCK!!!

$30.00

Saint Pattys day cupcakes !!!

6 pack of saint pattys cupcakes

$25.00

4 Pack saint pattys cupcakes

Mix of vanilla, chocolate, red velvet (substitutions may apply depending on stock inventory)

$17.00

1 dz saint pattys cupcakes

Mix of Van, choc, and red velvet cake with assorted buttercream. LIMITED INVENTORY, due to cancellation or substitution in quantity depending on supplies.

$50.00

Valentines Day Cupcakes / Bars / Cookies

One dozen Valentine's cupcakes decorated NO NUTS

1 dozen of mix: Vanilla, chocolate, red velvet.

$50.00

1/2 Dozen Valentines day decorated cupcakes NO NUTS

6 assorted cupcakes (vanilla, chocolate, red velvet) decorated with decons, inscription

$25.00

decorated shortbread shape cookies!

decorated shortbread royal icing cookies. Cookies are an assortment and might differ from photo

$3.75 +

Chocolate Covered Strawberry (smaller)

One single chocolate covered strawberry.

$2.50

Cake Bites

Assortments of Cake bites. Please choose flavor

$3.75

Heart Shaped Fudge brownie

$5.50

Heart Shaped Cake - 8" Vanilla

Vanilla cake, Vanilla Buttercream

$60.00 +

Chocolate Covered Strawberries (larger)

$3.05

Heart Shaped Cake Truffle

Chocolate cake insides. 3"

$5.50

Valentine's Day Cupcake

Please choose flavor. Icing Vanilla.

$4.50

Heart shaped cake - 8" Vanilla

Vanilla cake, chocolate buttercream

$55.00 +

Heart Shaped Cake - 8" Chocolate

Chocolate cake chocolate icing

$55.00 +

Heart shaped cake - 8 Chocolate

Chocolate cake Vanilla buttercream

$55.00 +

Heart shaped cake - 8" Red velvet

NAKED sides

$55.00 +

Heart shaped cake - 8" Red velvet

Red vanilla buttercream icing

$55.00 +

Giant chocolate chunk cookie!

Giant cookie

$15.00 +

1/2 Dozen V-Day Cupcake Assortment

contains vanilla, chocolate, and red velvet! Nut-free!

$25.00
Restaurant closed
.

About Buttercup Bake Shop

  • 973 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022
  • Bakery, Breakfast, Cakes, Dessert, Dinner, Lunch Specials
  • (212) 350-4144
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / Buttercup Bake Shop
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.