Carmine's Theatre District
MenuAbout
Carmine's Theatre District Menu

Carmine's Theatre District

Dinner, Italian
200 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036
(212) 221-3800
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Carmines Specials

Menu powered by Grubhub

Carmines Tailgate Package

Tailgate Special Feeds 12 -15 People - Includes: Scarpariello Wings, Caesar Salad, Sausage, Peppers, and Onions, Penne Alla Vodka Sauce, our Famous Meatballs & Garlic Bread

$345.00

Carmines Mini Tailgate Package

Tailgate Special Feeds 6 - 8 People - Includes: Scarpariello Wings, Caesar Salad, Sausage, Peppers, and Onions, Penne Alla Vodka Sauce, our Famous Meatballs & Garlic Bread

$172.50

Salad

Caesar Salad

A Carmine's Favorite! Crisp Romaine Lettuce w/ Parmesan Romano Cheese & Homemade Garlic Croutons, Served w/ House-Made Caesar Dressing on the Side. Note: Dressing Always Contains Anchovy Paste. Vegetarian. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Fish.

$37.90

Carmine Salad

Mixed Greens Tossed w/ Tomato, Onions, Pepperoncini, Celery, Radish & Olives, Topped w/ Diced Italian Meats & Cheeses, Served w/ House Vinaigrette on the Side. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Dairy.

$41.35

Mixed Green Salad

Fresh Mixed Greens w/ Tomato, Onions, Pepperoncini, Celery, Radish & Olives, Served w/ House Vinaigrette Dressing on the Side. Vegetarian. Feeds 2-4.

$34.45

Caprese Salad

Ripe Tomatoes Layered w/ Fresh Mozzarella, Black & Green Olives, Onions & Roasted Red Peppers, Dressed w/ Olive Oil & Vinegar. Vegetarian. Gluten-Free. Contains: Dairy.

$41.35

Appetizers

Baked Clams

Fresh Little Neck Clams Baked w/ Seasoned Italian Breadcrumbs & Savory Clam Broth Until Golden & Crispy. A Classic New York Italian Baked Clam Appetizer at Carmine's. Approximately 10-12 Pieces. Contains: Shellfish, Gluten.

$36.75

Fried Calamari

Fresh Calamari Lightly Dusted in Seasoned Flour & Fried Until Golden & Crispy, Served w/ House-Made Spicy Marinara Dipping Sauce. One of the Most Popular Appetizers at Carmine's. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Shellfish.

$54.00

Fried Zucchini

Shoestring Strands of Fresh Zucchini Dredged in Milk, Lightly Breaded in Seasoned Flour, Fried Golden Brown & Finished w/ Grated Romano Cheese. Vegetarian. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$32.15

Garlic Bread

A Carmine's Favorite! Thick-Sliced Artisan Bread Generously Topped w/ House-Made Garlic & Herb Butter, Toasted to Golden Perfection. Approximately 8-9 Pieces. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$22.95 +

Portobello Parmigiana

Large Portobello Mushroom Caps Breaded, Fried & Served Parmigiana Style w/ Marinara Sauce & Melted Cheese. Vegetarian. Feeds 2-3. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$26.40

Roasted Pepper & Anchovy

Freshly Roasted Red Peppers Topped w/ Anchovies & Drizzled w/ Basil Herb Oil. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Fish.

$22.95

Roasted Pepper & Mozzarella

Freshly Roasted Red Peppers Layered w/ Fresh Mozzarella, Topped w/ Anchovies & Drizzled w/ Basil Herb Oil. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Dairy, Fish.

$28.70

Scarpariello Wings

?A Carmine's Favorite! Crispy Pan-Fried Chicken Wings Marinated in Garlic & Rosemary, Tossed in a Spicy Lemon Butter Herb Sauce & Served w/ Creamy Gorgonzola Dipping Sauce. Approximately 20-24 Pieces. Contains: Dairy, Gluten.

$54.00

Spiedini Alla Romana

Thick-Sliced Italian Bread Rubbed w/ Garlic, Layered w/ Fresh Mozzarella Cheese & Stacked, Toasted & Melted, Then Topped w/ a Lemon Butter White Wine Sauce w/ Capers & Anchovies. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Fish.

$32.15

Stuffed Artichoke

Whole Artichokes Stuffed & Baked w/ Seasoned Italian Breadcrumbs in a Savory Chicken Stock. 2 Per Order. Contains: Gluten.

$29.85

Stuffed Mushrooms

Hearty Mushroom Caps Stuffed w/ a Savory Filling of Sweet Italian Sausage, Sweet Pepper & Hot Pepper, Then Baked to Perfection. Approximately 6-8 Pieces. Contains: Gluten, Pork.

$27.55

Zuppa Di Clams Red

Fresh Little Neck Clams Slow-Cooked in Your Choice of Red or White Broth w/ Garlic, White Wine & Fresh Herbs. Approximately 16-18 Pieces. Contains: Shellfish.

$33.30

Zuppa Di Clams White

Fresh Little Neck Clams Slow-Cooked in Your Choice of Red or White Broth w/ Garlic, White Wine & Fresh Herbs. Approximately 16-18 Pieces. Contains: Shellfish.

$33.30

Zuppa Di Mussels Red

Fresh Mussels Simmered in Your Choice of Red or White Broth w/ Garlic, White Wine & Aromatic Herbs. Approximately 18-20 Pieces. Contains: Shellfish.

$33.30

Zuppa Di Mussels White

Fresh Mussels Simmered in Your Choice of Red or White Broth w/ Garlic, White Wine & Aromatic Herbs. Approximately 18-20 Pieces. Contains: Shellfish.

$33.30

Hot Antipasto

A Chef-Curated Assortment of Seasonally Selected Hot Italian Appetizers Including Fresh Seafood, Warm Dips & Assorted Parmigiana Items. Feeds 2-4. Please Inquire Before Ordering if You Have Any Food Allergies or Dietary Restrictions.

$68.95

Cold Antipasto

A Chef-Curated Assortment of Seasonally Selected Cold Italian Appetizers Including Fresh Seafood, Imported Cheeses & Cured Meats. Feeds 2-4. Please Inquire Before Ordering if You Have Any Food Allergies or Dietary Restrictions.

$68.95

Lunch Menu

Caesar Salad Lunch

A Carmine's Favorite! Crisp Romaine Lettuce w/ Parmesan Romano Cheese & Homemade Garlic Croutons, Served w/ House-Made Caesar Dressing on the Side. Note: Dressing Always Contains Anchovy Paste. Vegetarian. Feeds 1-2 Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Fish.

$20.65

Chicken Caesar Salad Lunch

A Carmine's Favorite! Crisp Romaine Lettuce w/ Parmesan Romano Cheese & Homemade Garlic Croutons, Topped w/ Grilled Chicken, Served w/ House-Made Caesar Dressing on the Side. Note: Dressing Always Contains Anchovy Paste. Vegetarian. Feeds 1-2 Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Fish.

$29.85

Shrimp Caesar Salad Lunch

A Carmine's Favorite! Crisp Romaine Lettuce w/ Parmesan Romano Cheese & Homemade Garlic Croutons, Topped w/ Grilled Shrimp, Served w/ House-Made Caesar Dressing on the Side. Note: Dressing Always Contains Anchovy Paste. Vegetarian. Feeds 1-2 Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Fish, Shellfish.

$34.45

Carmines Salad Lunch

Mixed Greens Tossed w/ Tomato, Onions, Pepperoncini, Celery, Radish & Olives, Topped w/ Diced Italian Meats & Cheeses, Served w/ House Vinaigrette on the Side. Add Chicken or Shrimp. Feeds 1-2. Contains: Dairy.

$21.80

Mixed Green Salad Lunch

Fresh Mixed Greens w/ Tomato, Onions, Pepperoncini, Celery, Radish & Olives, Served w/ House Vinaigrette Dressing on the Side. Add Chicken or Shrimp. Vegetarian. Feeds 1-2.

$19.50

Bolognese Lunch

Slowly Simmered Italian Tomato Sauce w/ Ground Beef & Ground Pork Served Over Pasta. Feeds 1-2. Contains: Gluten, Pork.

$27.55

Calamari Red Lunch

Tender Calamari Served w/ Red Sauce (Garlic, Fresh Herbs, Crushed Red Pepper, White Wine & Italian Plum Tomatoes). Feeds 1-2. Contains: Gluten, Shellfish.

$28.70

Calamari White Lunch

Tender Calamari Served w/ White Sauce (Garlic, Olive Oil, Fresh Herbs & Clam Juice). Feeds 1-2. Contains: Gluten, Shellfish.

$28.70

Country Style Lunch

Buttery Sauce w/ Italian Pork Sausage, Prosciutto, Chicken Stock, Cannellini Beans, Broccoli, Onions & Romano Cheese. Feeds 1-2. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Pork.

$27.55

Giardiniera Lunch

A Fresh Italian Garden Medley of Broccoli, Spinach, Plum Tomatoes, Garlic, Onions, Mushrooms, Basil, Parsley, Vegetable Stock & Grated Romano Cheese Tossed w/ Pasta. Vegetarian. Vegan When Ordered Without Cheese. Feeds 1-2. Contains: Gluten, Dairy (Optional).

$25.25

Marinara Lunch

Pasta Served w/ Our Signature Marinara Sauce of Plum Tomatoes, Olive Oil, Garlic, Fresh Herbs & Romano Cheese. Vegetarian. Feeds 1-2. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$24.10

Meatballs Lunch

House-Made Italian Meatballs Crafted From a Blend of Beef & Veal, Slow-Simmered & Served in a Combination of Marinara & Ragu Sauces. Feeds 1-2. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$26.40

Vodka Sauce Lunch

Penne Pasta Tossed in a Creamy Vodka Sauce Made w/ Chopped Plum Tomatoes, Cream, Romano Cheese, Saut��ed Onions, Garlic & Crushed Red Pepper Flakes. Vegetarian. Feeds 1-2. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$25.25

Pomodoro Lunch

Plum Tomatoes Saut��ed in White Wine, Garlic, Olive Oil & Prosciutto Served Over Pasta. Feeds 1-2. Contains: Gluten, Pork.

$25.25

Broccoli Sausage Red Lunch

Saut��ed Broccoli & Crumbled Italian Sausage Served w/ Signature Marinara Sauce. Feeds 1-2. Contains: Gluten, Pork.

$27.55

Broccoli Sausage White Lunch

Saut��ed Broccoli & Crumbled Italian Sausage Served w/ White Sauce (Garlic, Oil w/ Chicken Stock & Fresh Herbs). Feeds 1-2. Contains: Gluten, Pork.

$27.55

Ravioli Lunch

House-Made Three Cheese Ravioli Served w/ Your Choice of Our Slow-Cooked Ragu Sauce or Marinara Sauce. Vegetarian w/ Marinara Option. Feeds 1-2. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$25.25

Broccoli Red Lunch

Saut��ed Fresh Broccoli Served w/ Signature Marinara Sauce. Vegetarian w/ Marinara Option. Feeds 1-2. Contains: Gluten.

$25.25

Broccoli White Lunch

Saut��ed Fresh Broccoli Served w/ White Sauce (Garlic, Oil w/ Chicken Stock & Fresh Herbs). Feeds 1-2. Contains: Gluten.

$25.25

Sausage Lunch

Sweet Italian Pork Sausage Links Served w/ Your Choice of Our Slow-Cooked Ragu Sauce or Marinara Sauce. Feeds 1-2. Contains: Gluten, Pork.

$26.40

Pasta

Bolognese

Slowly Simmered Italian Tomato Sauce w/ Ground Beef & Ground Pork Served Over Pasta. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Pork.

$45.95

Calamari Red

Tender Calamari Served w/ Either Red Sauce (Garlic, Fresh Herbs, Crushed Red Pepper, White Wine & Italian Plum Tomatoes) or White Sauce (Garlic, Olive Oil, Fresh Herbs & Clam Juice). Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Shellfish.

$48.25

Calamari White

Tender Calamari Served w/ Either Red Sauce (Garlic, Fresh Herbs, Crushed Red Pepper, White Wine & Italian Plum Tomatoes) or White Sauce (Garlic, Olive Oil, Fresh Herbs & Clam Juice). Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Shellfish.

$48.25

Clam Sauce RD

Sliced Cherry Stone Clams Cooked w/ Your Choice of White Sauce (Garlic, Olive Oil, Fresh Herbs & Clam Juice) or Red Sauce (Adds Tomato). Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Shellfish.

$44.80

Clam Sauce WH

Sliced Cherry Stone Clams Cooked w/ Your Choice of White Sauce (Garlic, Olive Oil, Fresh Herbs & Clam Juice) or Red Sauce (Adds Tomato). Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Shellfish.

$44.80

Garlic & Oil

Pasta Tossed in Olive Oil, Fresh Herbs, Garlic & Chicken Stock, Topped w/ Seasoned Breadcrumbs & Romano Cheese. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$34.45 +

Giardiniera

A Fresh Italian Garden Medley of Broccoli, Spinach, Plum Tomatoes, Garlic, Onions, Mushrooms, Basil, Parsley, Vegetable Stock & Grated Romano Cheese Tossed w/ Pasta. Vegetarian. Vegan When Ordered Without Cheese. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy (Optional).

$40.20 +

Lasagna

Layers of Seasoned Ground Beef & Veal Layered w/ Three Italian Cheeses, Baked Until Bubbly & Topped w/ Our Signature Marinara Sauce. A Classic Italian Family-Style Baked Lasagna at Carmine's. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$48.25

Manicotti

Thin Italian Egg Crepes Stuffed w/ a Four-Cheese Mixture, Baked Over a Layer of Our Signature Marinara Sauce. Vegetarian. Approximately 5-6 Pieces. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Eggs.

$42.50

Marinara

Pasta Served w/ Our Signature Marinara Sauce of Plum Tomatoes, Olive Oil, Garlic, Fresh Herbs & Romano Cheese. Vegetarian. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$37.90 +

Meatballs

A Carmine's Favorite! House-Made Italian Meatballs Crafted From a Blend of Beef & Veal, Slow-Simmered & Served in a Combination of Marinara & Ragu Sauces. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$48.25

Mixed Seafood RD

A Generous Combination of Lobster, Shrimp, Clams, Mussels & Calamari Served w/ Your Choice of White (Garlic & Oil w/ Herbs) or Red (Adds Plum Tomato & Marinara) Sauce. One of the Best Italian Seafood Pasta Dishes at Carmine's. Feeds 3-5. Contains: Gluten, Shellfish.

$113.85

Mixed Seafood WH

A Generous Combination of Lobster, Shrimp, Clams, Mussels & Calamari Served w/ Your Choice of White (Garlic & Oil w/ Herbs) or Red (Adds Plum Tomato & Marinara) Sauce. One of the Best Italian Seafood Pasta Dishes at Carmine's. Feeds 3-5. Contains: Gluten, Shellfish.

$113.85

Vodka Sauce

A Carmine's Favorite! Pasta Tossed in a Creamy Vodka Sauce Made w/ Chopped Plum Tomatoes, Cream, Romano Cheese, Saut��ed Onions, Garlic & Crushed Red Pepper Flakes. Vegetarian. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$44.80 +

Pomodoro

Plum Tomatoes Saut��ed in White Wine, Garlic, Olive Oil & Prosciutto Served Over Pasta. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Pork.

$39.05 +

Ragu

Homemade Meatballs & Italian Sausage Slow-Cooked in a Rich, Shredded Meat Tomato Ragu Sauce. Feeds 3-5. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Pork.

$48.25

Ravioli

House-Made Three Cheese Ravioli Served w/ Your Choice of Our Slow-Cooked Ragu Sauce or Marinara Sauce. Vegetarian w/ Marinara Option. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$42.50

Broccoli Sausage RD

Saut��ed Broccoli & Crumbled Italian Sausage Tossed w/ Pasta, Served w/ Your Choice of Signature Marinara or White Sauce (Garlic, Oil w/ Chicken Stock & Fresh Herbs). Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Pork.

$45.95

Broccoli Sausage WH

Saut��ed Broccoli & Crumbled Italian Sausage Tossed w/ Pasta, Served w/ Your Choice of Signature Marinara or White Sauce (Garlic, Oil w/ Chicken Stock & Fresh Herbs). Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Pork.

$45.95

Broccoli RD

Saut��ed Fresh Broccoli, Served w/ Your Choice of Signature Marinara or White Sauce (Garlic, Oil w/ Chicken Stock & Fresh Herbs). Vegetarian w/ Marinara Option. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten.

$41.35 +

Broccoli WH

Saut��ed Fresh Broccoli, Served w/ Your Choice of Signature Marinara or White Sauce (Garlic, Oil w/ Chicken Stock & Fresh Herbs). Vegetarian w/ Marinara Option. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten.

$41.35 +

Country Style

Pasta in a Rich, Buttery Sauce w/ Italian Pork Sausage, Prosciutto, Chicken Stock, Cannellini Beans, Broccoli, Onions & Romano Cheese. Feeds 3-5. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Pork.

$45.95

Sausage

Sweet Italian Pork Sausage Links Served w/ Your Choice of Our Slow-Cooked Ragu Sauce or Marinara Sauce. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Pork.

$44.80

Shrimp Red

Shrimp Saut��ed w/ Fresh Garlic & Herbs, Served w/ Your Choice of White Sauce (Garlic, Olive Oil, Fresh Herbs & Clam Juice) or Red Sauce (Adds Tomato). Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Shellfish.

$50.55

Shrimp White

Shrimp Saut��ed w/ Fresh Garlic & Herbs, Served w/ Your Choice of White Sauce (Garlic, Olive Oil, Fresh Herbs & Clam Juice) or Red Sauce (Adds Tomato). Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Shellfish.

$50.55

Pesto

$42.50

Entrees

Porterhouse

A Massive 45 Oz Porterhouse Steak Seasoned & Cooked to Your Liking, Finished w/ Olive Oil, Fresh Herbs & Garlic. A Showstopping Italian Steakhouse Entr��e at Carmine's. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-4.

$178.25

Porterhouse Contadina

A 45 Oz Porterhouse Steak Cooked to Your Liking, Served w/ Saut��ed Peppers & Onions, Roasted Potatoes, Italian Sausage Links & Finished w/ Sweet & Spicy Pepperoncini Juice. Gluten-Free. Feeds 3-5. Contains: Pork.

$201.25

Porterhouse Peppers Onion

A 45 Oz Porterhouse Steak Cooked to Your Liking, Served w/ Seasoned Saut��ed Peppers & Onions. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-4.

$184.00

Porterhouse Pizzaiola

$184.00

Chicken Contadina

Whole Chicken Cut on the Bone, Pan-Fried & Served w/ Roasted Peppers, Potatoes & Sweet Italian Sausage, Topped w/ Sweet Pepper Vinegar. Gluten-Free. Feeds 3-5. Contains: Pork.

$65.50

Chicken Cutlet

Thin-Pounded, Breaded Chicken Cutlet Pan-Fried to a Crispy Golden Brown. A Classic Italian-Style Breaded Chicken Cutlet at Carmine's, Perfect for Sharing at the Table. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten.

$44.80

Chicken Lemon

Tender Chicken Scaloppine Saut��ed in a Bright Lemon Butter Sauce, Served Over Saut��ed Spinach. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-3. Contains: Dairy.

$45.95 +

Chicken Marsala

Tender Chicken Scaloppine Saut��ed w/ Fresh Sliced Mushrooms & Simmered in a Deep, Rich Veal Stock & Marsala Wine Sauce. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-3.

$48.25 +

Chicken Parmigiana

A Carmine's Favorite! Breaded Chicken Pan-Fried to Crispy Golden Brown, Topped w/ Melted Mozzarella & Romano Cheese & Served Over Marinara Sauce. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$48.25 +

Chicken Saltimbocca

Thin-Sliced Chicken on a Bed of Saut��ed Spinach, Topped w/ Prosciutto & Melted Mozzarella in a Marsala Wine Sauce. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-3. Contains: Dairy, Pork.

$48.25 +

Chicken Scarpariello

Whole Chicken Cut on the Bone, Marinated in Lemon, Garlic & Rosemary, Pan-Fried & Finished w/ a Zesty Lemon Butter Sauce. A Signature Italian-American Chicken Dish at Carmine's. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-4.

$56.30 +

Shrimp Fra Diavolo

Shrimp Saut��ed in a Spicy Marinara Sauce w/ White Wine & Fresh Herbs. Spicy. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-3. Contains: Shellfish.

$50.55 +

Shrimp Marinara

Plump Shrimp Saut��ed w/ Garlic & Fresh Herbs in a Rich Marinara Sauce w/ White Wine. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-3. Contains: Shellfish.

$50.55 +

Shrimp Parmigiana

Breaded Shrimp Pan-Fried Until Golden, Topped w/ Melted Mozzarella & Marinara Sauce. Feeds 2-3. Contains: Shellfish, Gluten, Dairy.

$52.85 +

Shrimp Scampi

Shrimp Broiled w/ Garlic Breadcrumbs & Served in a Savory Sauce of Garlic, Clam Juice, Olive Oil & Butter. Feeds 2-3. Contains: Shellfish, Gluten, Dairy.

$51.70 +

Salmon Oreganata

A 22 Oz Salmon Fillet Topped w/ Garlic Butter & Seasoned Breadcrumbs, Broiled & Served w/ a Scampi Sauce Alongside Clams & Mussels. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Fish, Shellfish, Gluten, Dairy.

$89.70 +

Veal Cutlet

Thin-Pounded, Breaded Veal Cutlet Pan-Fried to a Crispy Golden Brown. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten.

$51.70

Veal Lemon

Thin-Sliced Veal Scaloppine Saut��ed in a Bright Lemon Butter Sauce, Served Over Saut��ed Spinach. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-3. Contains: Dairy.

$52.85 +

Veal Marsala

Tender Veal Scaloppine Saut��ed w/ Fresh Sliced Mushrooms & Simmered in a Deep, Rich Veal Stock & Marsala Wine Sauce. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-3.

$52.85 +

Veal Parmigiana

Thin-Pounded, Breaded Veal Pan-Fried to Crispy Golden Brown, Topped w/ Melted Mozzarella & Served Over Marinara Sauce. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$56.30 +

Veal Saltimbocca

Thin-Sliced Veal on a Bed of Saut��ed Spinach, Topped w/ Prosciutto & Melted Mozzarella in a Marsala Wine Sauce. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-3. Contains: Dairy, Pork.

$56.30 +

Heros

#1 Cold Italian Hero

A Classic Italian Cold Cut Sub Loaded w/ Genoa Salami, Prosciutto, Mortadella & Provolone Cheese, Topped w/ Roasted Peppers, Lettuce & Tomato. One of the Best Italian Hero Sandwiches at Carmine's. Served w/ Your Choice of Side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Pork.

$22.95

#3 Chicken Combo Hero

Crispy Chicken Cutlet w/ Fried Eggplant, Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella Cheese & Tomato Sauce on a Fresh Italian Hero Roll. Served w/ Your Choice of Side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Pork.

$22.95

#3 Veal Combo Hero

Crispy Veal Cutlet w/ Fried Eggplant, Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella Cheese & Tomato Sauce on a Fresh Italian Hero Roll. Served w/ Your Choice of Side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Pork.

$27.55

#4 Hot Italian Hero

Grilled Soppressata, Mortadella, Provolone Cheese, Roasted Peppers & Hot Cherry Peppers Piled on Garlic Bread. Spicy. Served w/ Your Choice of Side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Pork.

$22.95

#5 Italian Cheese Steak Hero

Sliced Steak Saut��ed w/ Peppers & Onions on Garlic Bread. Served w/ Your Choice of Side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad. Contains: Gluten.

$22.95

Chicken Parm Hero

Crispy Breaded Chicken Cutlet Topped w/ Marinara Sauce & Melted Mozzarella on a Fresh Hero Roll. Served w/ Your Choice of Side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$20.65

Eggplant Parm Hero

Lightly Breaded & Fried Eggplant Layered w/ Marinara Sauce & Melted Mozzarella on a Fresh Hero Roll. Vegetarian. Served w/ Your Choice of Side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$21.80

Meatball Parm Hero

Homemade Italian Meatballs Smothered in Marinara Sauce w/ Melted Mozzarella on a Fresh Hero Roll. Served w/ Your Choice of Side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$21.80

Sausage & Pepper Hero

Italian Sausage Links w/ Saut��ed Peppers & Onions on a Fresh Hero Roll. Served w/ Your Choice of Side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad. Contains: Gluten, Pork.

$20.65

Veal Parm Hero

Crispy Breaded Veal Cutlet Topped w/ Marinara Sauce & Melted Mozzarella on a Fresh Hero Roll. Served w/ Your Choice of Side Caesar or Mixed Green Salad. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$25.25

Sides

Eggplant Parm

Thinly Sliced Eggplant Lightly Battered, Fried & Layered w/ Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella & Romano Cheeses, Then Piled High & Baked Until Bubbly. A Legendary Italian Eggplant Parm Side at Carmine's. Vegetarian. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$44.80 +

Side Broccoli

Fresh Broccoli Spears Saut��ed w/ Garlic, Olive Oil & Chicken Stock. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-3.

$26.40

Side Contadina Potatoes

Sliced Potatoes Roasted to Golden Perfection. Vegan. Gluten-Free.

$21.80

Side Escarole

Fresh Escarole Saut��ed w/ Garlic, Olive Oil & Chicken Stock. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-3.

$26.40

Side Focaccia

A Generous Portion of Our Homemade Italian Focaccia Bread, Baked Fresh Daily. Vegan. Contains: Gluten.

$10.30

Side Marinara Sauce

A Pint of Our Homemade Italian Marinara Sauce, Made w/ Plum Tomatoes & Fresh Herbs. Perfect for Dipping or Bringing the Carmine's Flavor Home. Vegan. Gluten-Free.

$8.00

Side Meatballs

A Carmine's Favorite! Six Oversized Homemade Meatballs Crafted From Beef & Veal, Served in Our Signature Marinara Sauce. Contains: Gluten, Dairy.

$33.30

Side Spinach

Fresh Spinach Saut��ed w/ Garlic & Olive Oil. Vegan. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-3.

$25.25

Side Peppers & Onion

Red & Green Peppers w/ Spanish Onions Saut��ed in Garlic, Oil & Fresh Herbs. Vegan. Gluten-Free. Feeds 2-3.

$22.95

Side Sausage

Sweet Italian Fennel Sausage Links Pan-Fried Until Perfectly Browned. Gluten-Free. Approximately 3-4 Pieces. Contains: Pork.

$29.85

Dessert

3pc Cannoli

Crispy Chocolate-Covered Cannoli Shells Filled w/ Sweet Ricotta, Candied Fruit, Chocolate Chips & Pistachios. Vegetarian. 3 Pieces. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Tree Nuts.

$14.90

6pc Cannoli

Crispy Chocolate-Covered Cannoli Shells Filled w/ Sweet Ricotta, Candied Fruit, Chocolate Chips & Pistachios. Vegetarian. 3 Pieces. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Tree Nuts.

$22.95

Bread Pudding

A Carmine's Favorite! Toasted Italian Bread w/ Golden Raisins & Chocolate Chips, Soaked in a Vanilla Cinnamon Custard w/ Eggs & Heavy Cream, Baked Until Crispy Brown & Served Warm w/ Whipped Cream on the Side. Vegetarian. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Eggs.

$31.05

Cheesecake - Whole Mini

Homemade Italian Cheesecake Made w/ Creamy Ricotta on a Marble Chocolate Pound Cake Crust, Topped w/ Fresh Strawberries. Vegetarian. Serves 4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Eggs.

$34.45

Cheesecake 1/2 Mini

Homemade Italian Cheesecake Made w/ Creamy Ricotta on a Marble Chocolate Pound Cake Crust, Topped w/ Fresh Strawberries. Vegetarian. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Eggs.

$24.10

Chocolate Torte

A Rich, Creamy Flourless Chocolate Cake w/ a Hint of Coffee Liqueur, Served w/ Fresh Cream & Strawberries. A Decadent Gluten-Free Italian Chocolate Dessert at Carmine's. Gluten-Free. Vegetarian. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Dairy, Eggs

$22.95

Fresh Fruit

A Seasonal Assortment of Fresh Fruit, Beautifully Arranged for Sharing. Vegan. Gluten-Free. Dairy-Free. Feeds 2-4.

$34.45

Shortcake

House-Made Marble Pound Cake Soaked w/ Strawberry Syrup, Layered w/ Whipped Cream & Fresh Strawberry Slices, Drizzled w/ Coffee Liqueur & Sprinkled w/ Pistachio Nuts. Vegetarian. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Eggs, Tree Nuts, Alcohol.

$26.40

Tiramisu

A Carmine's Favorite! Homemade Ladyfinger Sponge Cake Soaked in Espresso & Coffee Liqueur, Layered w/ Sweet, Airy Mascarpone & Zabaglione Cream & Covered w/ Semi-Sweet Belgian Chocolate Shavings. Vegetarian. Feeds 2-4. Contains: Gluten, Dairy, Eggs, Alcohol.

$34.45
Restaurant closed
.

About Carmine's Theatre District

  • 200 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036
  • Dinner, Italian, Lunch Specials, Pasta
  • (212) 221-3800
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / Carmine's Theatre District
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2026 Grubhub Holdings Inc.