72nd Eatery
MenuAbout
72nd Eatery  Menu

72nd Eatery

American, Breakfast
261 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023
(212) 721-7800
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

HEARTY BREAKFAST

Menu powered by Grubhub

EGG SANDWICH CREATE YOUR OWN

$5.95 +

AVOCADO TOAST

Fresh mashed avocado, basil, cilantro, tomato, and fresh lime juice.

$6.95 +

CINNAMON CHALLA FRENCH TOAST PLATTER

Available in whole wheat.

$9.95 +

FLUFFY BUTTERMILK PANCAKE

Available in whole wheat.

$9.95 +

BAGELS

Plain bagels

$1.75 +

Everything Bagel

$1.75 +

Whole Wheat Bagel

$1.75 +

Sesame Bagel

$1.75 +

Cinnamon raisin Bagel

$1.75 +

Poppy seed Bagel

$1.75 +

BREAKFAST WRAPS

WESTERN WRAP

Egg, Onion, peppers, and ham. on your choice of wrap

$10.95 +

MEAT LOVERS WRAP

Egg, Bacon, ham or sausage. on your choice of wrap

$10.95 +

GREEK FETA WRAP

Egg, Cheese, and tomatoes.

$10.95 +

CALIFORNIA EGG WRAP

Mushrooms, tomatoes, and low fat cheese. Whole wheat, white flour, spinach, and sun dried tomato.

$10.95 +

GARDEN EGG WRAP

Egg, Broccoli, spinach, and mushrooms. on your choice of wrap

$10.95 +

FLORENTINE EGG WRAP

Fresh spinach, tomatoes, and feta cheese. Whole wheat, white flour, spinach, and sun dried tomato.

$10.95 +

3 EGG OMELETTE PLATTER

OMELET PLATTER

American or Swiss. Served with home fries, and toast.

$8.95 +

WESTERN OMELET PLATTER

Onion, peppers, and ham. Served with home fries, and toast.

$11.95 +

MEAT LOVERS OMELET PLATTER

Bacon, ham, and sausage. Served with home fries, and toast.

$13.95 +

GREEK OMELET PLATTER

Feta cheese, and tomatoes. Served with home fries, and toast.

$11.95 +

CALIFORNIA OMELET PLATTER

Mushrooms, tomatoes, and low - fat cheese. Served with home fries, and toast.

$11.95 +

GARDEN OMELET PLATTER

Broccoli, spinach, and mushrooms. Served with home fries, and toast.

$11.95 +

FLORENTINE OMELET PLATTER

Spinach, tomatoes, and feta cheese. Served with home fries, and toast.

$11.95 +

LEO PLATTER

Onion, and scallion. Served with home fries, and toast.

$13.95 +

CREATE YOUR OWN OMELET PLATTER

Build your own omelette with 3 eggs and your choice of fillings.

$10.95 +

LIGHT AND FIT BREAKFAST

HOT OATMEAL

Your choice of fresh apples, raisins, granola, honey, brown sugar, fresh strawberries, cinnamon each. Available in whole wheat.

$5.95 +

FRUIT SALAD

$6.99

YOGURT PARFAIT

Low fat yogurt, granola, fruits.

$5.95

HOT BEVERAGES

COFFEE COLUMBIAN HOUSE BLEND

Rich and smooth blend of Colombian coffee beans.

$2.75 +

DE CAFE COLUMBIAN HOUSE BLEND

Smooth, rich decaf coffee blend.

$2.99 +

LIPTON TEA

A classic cup of hot brewed tea.

$2.75 +

HERBAL TEA

Soothing and calming herbal infusion.

$2.75 +

HOT CHOCOLATE

Rich and creamy beverage to warm your day.

$2.99 +

MOCHA

Rich and creamy espresso drink with a chocolate twist.

$4.99 +

CAPPUCCINO

Rich and smooth espresso-style coffee drink.

$4.99 +

CAFFE LATTE

Rich and smooth espresso-style coffee drink made with steamed milk.

$4.99 +

VANILLA CHAI LATTE

Sweet, and soothing in every single sip. we brew each cup with passion to bring a little extra warmth and comfort to your day. enjoy your wonderful chai moment.

$2.99 +

MATCHA

Pure, vibrant green organic matcha crafted from shade-grown tea leaves for a smooth, rich taste and steady energy. Earthy and natural taste, every sip delivers a clean, antioxidant-packed ritual to elevate your day.

$4.99 +

PASTRIES, COOKIES AND BARS

Muffins

Honey raisin bran, cappuccino, banana walnut, old fashioned blueberry, chocolate chip, and corn.

$4.25

Croissants Plain

Classic French butter croissant baked to a deep golden brown. Crisp and shatteringly flaky on the outside with a soft, airy, honeycomb interior.

$3.99

Cheese Danishes

Crisp, buttery pastry layers surrounding a smooth, sweet vanilla cream cheese center.

$3.99

Scones

Blueberry Flavor Only

$4.29

Cinnamon Bun

Hand-rolled brioche dough fermented slowly for a rich, tender crumb, layered with cultured butter, muscovado sugar, and fragrant Korintje cinnamon. Baked until golden and finished with a velvety vanilla bean glaze.

$3.99

Bars

Caramel Pecan Bar Classic Fudge Bar Lemon Bar Classic Cookie Bar Raspberry Linzer Bar Peanut Butter Bar

$4.25

Cookies

Chocolate chip, black and white, oatmeal raisin, and rainbow sprinkle.

$4.25

Almond Croissant

$3.99

Chocolate Croissant

$3.99

RICE PUDDING

8 oz. home made

$4.49

CEREAL

Kellogg's. 1.5 oz. to 1.3 oz cup. depends on the flavor.

$2.99 +

CEREAL BIG BOX

Size Varies depends on flavors.

$5.99

Apple turnover

Flaky, golden-brown puff pastry folded around a warm, tender filling of spiced apples, brown sugar, and cinnamon. Finished with a light sugar glaze for a crisp, sweet bite every time.

$3.99

DRINKS

FRESH JUICE

Freshly squeezed juices served cold.

$9.95

FRESH LEMONDE

Refreshing drink made with real lemons.

$2.95

TROPICANA JUICE

$3.25

VITAMIN WATER

$3.49

POLAND SPRING WATER

$1.50 +

SNAPPLE

$3.25

BOTTLE SODA 20 oz.

Refreshing drink in a 20 oz bottle.

$2.95

NESQUIK CHOCOLATE MILK

Rich, creamy chocolate milk blended with classic NESQUIK flavor.

$3.50

NESQUIK STRAWBERRY MILK

Sweet and creamy milk infused with strawberry flavor.

$3.95

SAN PELLEGRINO WATER

23.3 oz. sparkling water

$5.25

SMALL FIJI WATER

Small 500 ml

$3.25

LARGE FIJI WATER

Fiji Water 1 Liter.

$4.75

SMALL SMART WATER

Smart water 20 oz.

$3.25

MARTINELLI'S APPLE JUICE

Martinelli's apple Juice 10 oz.

$3.25

GATORADE

591 ml

$3.25

MONSTER ENERGY DRINK

16 oz.

$4.49

MONSTER ENERGY DRINK ZERO ULTRA

16 oz.

$4.49

NAKED SMOOTHIE

15.2 oz.

$5.49

KEVITA

Live Probiotic Kombucha. 15.2 oz.

$5.49

VITA COCO

THE ORIGINAL. 16.9 oz.

$3.95

CLASSIC SANDWICH

NY SIGNATURE SANDWICH

Lean steamed corned beef or pastrami sliced to order and piled high on Jewish rye bread, served with gulden's deli mustard, coleslaw and kosher pickles.

$16.95

GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST SANDWICH

Grilled Chicken Breast, Muenster cheese, arugula, tomatoes, sliced apples, and diagonals dressing on a ciabatta roll.

$13.95

SMOKED TURKEY & BRIE SANDWICH

Served with honey mustard, plum tomatoes and leaf lettuce on a crispy Parisian baguette.

$13.95

PICO DE GALLO SANDWICH

Grilled chicken, cheddar, avocado, lettuce, tomato with herb mayo on Whole Wheat Bread

$13.95

TURKEY AVOCADO SANDWICH

Turkey breast, avocado, lettuce, and tomato with herb mayo sandwich

$13.95

TRADITIONAL TUNA SANDWICH

White albacore tuna tossed with mayo and celery topped with roasted red peppers, plum tomatoes and leaf lettuce.

$13.95

CALIFORNIA TURKEY PITA SANDWICH

Smoked turkey with avocado, tomato, sprouts, cucumber and lemon herb dressing on a whole wheat pita low - cal.

$13.95

ALL-NATURAL TURKEY SANDWICH

Smoked turkey with tomatoes and organic mesclun greens, low fat mayo on a whole wheat pita low - cal.

$13.95

TUNA PITA SANDWICH

White albacore tuna salad, sliced tomatoes, mixed greens on a whole wheat pita low - cal.

$14.95

SMOKED TURKEY PITA SANDWICH

Smoked turkey, green leaf lettuce, plum tomato with honey mustard on a whole wheat pita low - cal.

$13.95

TRADITIONAL NOVA SALMON SANDWICH

Imported smoked Norwegian salmon with chive cream cheese and cucumber on Russian black bread.

$17.95

TURKEY TRIPLE DECAR SANDWICH

Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on white toast.

$15.95

TUNA SALAD CLUB SANDWICH

Albacore tuna salad, sliced hard boiled egg, plum tomato, green leaf lettuce on white toast.

$14.95

CHICKEN SALAD CLUB SANDWICH

Chicken Salad Crispy bacon, sliced tomato, green leaf lettuce on white toast.

$13.95

AVOCADO BLT CLUB SANDWICH

Fresh ripe avocado, crispy bacon, plum tomato, green leaf lettuce on white toast with mayonnaise.

$13.95

CUSTOM SANDWICH

Pick your own.

$6.00 +

POTATO CHIPS

Cape Cod

Original, reduced fat, BBQ, sea salt, and vinegar.

$2.25

Baked Lays

Original, sour cream, and onion.

$2.25

Doritos

Nacho cheese, and cool ranch.

$2.25

YOUR FAVORIT SANDWICHES

SMOKED TURKEY MELT SANDWICH

Grilled vegetable ratatouille, melted Swiss cheese and pesto mayo on focaccia bread.

$14.95

SIERRA TURKEY SANDWICH

Roasted turkey with pepper jack cheese and southwestern at chipotle sauce on five grain bread.

$14.95

ITALIAN CLUB SANDWICH

Turkey, ham, Genoa salami, provolone cheese, red onion, garlic and oil on Napolitano Italian bread.

$14.95

CHICKEN MILANO SANDWICH

Charbroiled chicken breast with fresh mozzarella and pesto mayo on Ciabatta.

$14.95

CUBANO SANDWICH

Roasted ham, fresh turkey, Swiss cheese, dill pickle chips and Russian dressing on crespino flat bread.

$14.95

TUSCAN MELT SANDWICH

Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and fresh basil with pesto mayo on Naples flatbread.

$14.95

TIJUANA SANDWICH

Mexican grilled chicken breast, grilled peppers and onions, chipotle BBQ sauce and Monterey jack on rustic focaccia.

$14.95

CHICKEN PARMISAN SANDWICH

Tender breaded chicken cutlet with homemade marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese and fresh basil in an Italian hero.

$14.95

TURKEY BACON GUACAMOLE SANDWICH

Real turkey breast, crispy smoked bacon, pepper jack cheese, guacamole and ranch in a sourdough Panini.

$14.95

CHICKEN ITALIANO SANDWICH

Grilled chicken breast, fresh mozzarella, sweet peppers, lemon roasted garlic spread and caramelized onions.

$14.95

BURGERS

BBQ BACON BURGER DELUXE

An unforgettable burger grilled with our special hickory BBQ sauce, smothered with caramelized onions and topped with crispy bacon and cheddar cheese served with steak fries and soda.

$17.95

SANTA Fe BURGER DELUXE

Tex - Mex our burger with chipotle sauce, crispy bacon, pepper jack cheese and salsa served with spicy steak fries and soda.

$17.95

TURKEY BURGER

If you want French fry and soda. Add Deluxe option.

$10.95 +

VEGGIE BURGER

If you want French fry and soda add DELUXE option

$10.95 +

MEXICAN BURGER DELUXE

Our chef's homemade Mexican style beef burger served with Pico Gallo, guacamole, pepper jack, lettuce, tomato and pickle served with spicy steak fries and Soda.

$16.95

HAMBURGER

If you want French fry and soda add DELUXE option

$10.95 +

FROM OUR GRILL

GRILLED CHEESE SANDWICH

Melted cheese Sandwich.

$7.95 +

GRILLED CHEESE & FRIES

Melted cheese served with crispy fries.

$9.95 +

REUBEN

Pastrami on seedless Jewish rye bread topped with melted Swiss cheese, Russian dressing and sauerkraut.

$17.95

TUNA MELT

"Our albacore tuna salad, tomato, and mixed greens served open-face with melted American cheese on your choice of bread."

$14.95 +

PHILLY CHEESE STEAK

Prime beef steak, grilled mushrooms, peppers and onions with melted Swiss cheese on a semolina hero.

$14.95

GRILLED CHICKEN DELUXE

Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion, melted swiss and chipotle sauce Served on a toasted bun with lettuce, tomato and fries.

$16.95

FISH & CHIPS

Classic tender fish fillet, tartar sauce and fries.

$16.95

CRISPY CHICKEN FINGER

Served with sweet potato fries, barbeque sauce and our homemade honey mustard sauce.

$16.95

LOUISIANA CHICKEN WING

8 hot wings served with fries and blue cheese dressing.

$16.95

FRESH ENTREE SALAD

GOTHAM CHOPPED SALAD

Chicken breast, country ham, hard boiled eggs, bacon, tomatoes, cheddar and Swiss cheese over iceberg lettuce.

$12.95

CHICKEN CAESAR SALAD

Chicken breast over our crisp, refreshing Caesar salad.

$12.95

SOUTHWESTERN CHICKEN SALAD

Slow roasted Cajun chicken with Santa Fe Cob salad corn, bean, boiled egg, avocado, cherry tomato, eta and crispy noodle served over organic baby greens.

$12.95

ORIENTAL CHICKEN SALAD

Tender chopped chicken in a light sesame ginger dressing with Crispy oriental noodles, oriental vegetables and water chestnuts over our house salad.

$12.95

GREEK SALAD

Cucumber, tomatoes, green pepper, red onion, olives and feta on bed of lettuce, oil, and vinegar oregano.

$11.95

SPINACH SALAD

Goat cheese, spinach, walnuts, dried cranberries, Parmesan cheese, and avocado.

$11.95

ARUGULA SALAD

Walnuts, dried cranberries, Parmesan cheese, avocado, balsamic dressing, and cherry tomato.

$11.95

SIDE SALAD

TUNA SALAD 8oz.

Chilled deli-style tuna salad. 8 oz side portion.

$7.95

ITALIAN TUNA SALAD 8oz.

8 oz side portion of Italian tuna salad.

$7.95

PESTO PASTA SALAD (8 oz)

8 oz side of chilled pasta salad tossed in basil pesto.

$6.25

HOUSE SALAD

Fresh mixed greens, tomato and cucumber.

$7.95

MANGO SALSA BEAN SALAD (8oz.)

Fresh mango mixed with beans, corn, cilantro, onion, for a sweet and savory side salad.

$6.95

BRAZILIAN CHICKEN SALAD (8 oz)

Brazilian-style chicken salad. Chicken, raisin and celery, Chilled 8 oz side portion.

$8.95

SUN-DRIED PASTA SALAD (8 oz)

8 oz side pasta salad with sun-dried mix-ins.

$6.95

VEGGIE COUSCOUS (8 oz)

Light and fluffy North African-inspired side dish made with vegetables.

$7.95

COLE SLAW (8 oz.)

Crisp, refreshing mix of shredded cabbage and more.

$5.95

POTATO SALAD (8 oz.)

$5.95

ENTREE

WHOLE CHICKEN 2 SIDES

Tender whole chicken served with two sides of your choice.

$25.95

HALF CHICKEN WITH 2 SIDES

Tender half chicken served with two sides of your choice.

$16.95

DARK MEAT CHICKEN WITH 2 SIDES

Dark meat chicken served with two sides of your choice.

$11.95

CHICKEN BREAST WITH 2 SIDES

Tender chicken breast served with two sides of your choice.

$13.95

BAKED SALMON FISH WITH 2 SIDES

Oven-baked salmon fillet served with your choice of two sides.

$16.95

MEAT LOAF

$15.95

PIZZA

PERSONAL PIZZA 10 INCH

Individual-sized pizza.

$10.95 +

FULL SIZE PIZZA 18 INCH

Large 18-inch pie perfect for sharing.

$21.95 +

PIZZA SLICE

$3.95 +

FRESH SMOOTHIES

TROPICAL MANGO SMOOTHIE

Banana, Strawberry, Mango

$8.95

TRIPLE BERRY SMOOTHIE

Strawberry, Blueberry, Raspberry.

$8.95

SUNSET SMOOTHIE

Orange, Banana, Orange Juice, Mango

$8.95

ALOHA BERRY SMOOTHIE

Strawberry, Blueberry, Pineapple

$8.95

MOCHA BLAST SMOOTHIE

Espresso, Chocolate Syrup, Yogurt, Skim Milk.

$8.95

FRESHLY SQUEEZED ORANGE JUICE

We squeeze every glass of orange juice freshly the moment you place your order, ensuring you get maximum flavor and a powerful boost of Vitamin C. Please note: Because we use natural, fresh oranges with zero added sugar or artificial ingredients, the natural sweetness and flavor balance subtlely adjust season by season���just as nature intended!

$7.99

ICED BEVERAGES

ICED COFFEE

Smooth, bold coffee poured over ice for the ultimate crisp, refreshing cool-down. It���s chilled to perfection to give you a clean, delicious energy boost. Thank you for visiting us.

$2.99 +

ICED DECAFE COFFEE

$2.99 +

ICED CAPPUCCINO

Bold flavor served icy cold for your daily refresh. Thank you for choosing us to fuel your day���enjoy every drop.

$3.99 +

ICED DECAFE CAPPUCCINO

Bold flavor served icy cold for your daily refresh. Thank you for choosing us to fuel your day���enjoy every drop.

$3.99 +

ICED MOCHA

Freshly brewed and perfectly chilled to keep you cool, focused, and energized. We���re so grateful to help brighten your day with every sip. enjoy your refreshing moment.

$4.99 +

ICED LATTE

Smooth espresso poured over cold, velvety milk and ice for a perfectly balanced refresh. It���s a crisp, creamy classic crafted to cool you down and power your day. thank you for visiting us.

$3.49 +

ICED VANILLA CHAI LATTE

Bold & silky steamed milk for the ultimate flavorful pick-me-up. Thank you for choosing us to brighten your routine���enjoy every drop.

$3.99 +

ICED MATCHA

Vibrant, premium green tea whisked smooth and poured over cold, creamy milk and ice. it���s a clean, crisp boost of natural energy to keep you feeling cool and refreshed. Thank you for visiting us.

$4.99 +

ICED ESPRESSO

Bold espresso poured directly over ice for an intensely crisp and refreshing hit of flavor. It���s a pure, chilled ESPRESSO crafted to awaken your senses and energize your day. thank you for visiting us.

$3.99 +

SOUPS

CHICKEN NOODLE SOUP

$7.95

SPLIT PEA SOUP

vegetarian, no meat

$7.95

CARROT GINGER SOUP

$7.95

MUSHROOM BARLEY SOUP

$7.95

LENTIL SOUP

$7.95

EGG PLATTER

EGG PLATTER CREATE YOUR OWN

2 Eggs served with potatoes and toast.

$10.95 +
Restaurant closed
.

About 72nd Eatery

  • 261 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023
  • American, Breakfast, Dinner, Grill, Hamburgers, Healthy, Lunch Specials, Pizza, Salads, Sandwiches, Vegetarian
  • (212) 721-7800
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / 72nd Eatery
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2026 Grubhub Holdings Inc.