Popular menu items
Nova Lox Sandwich
Silky smoked Nova lox with cream cheese, ripe tomato, red onion, and briny capers on a freshly baked NYC bagel. Chicago's best lox sandwich, and it's not close.
$18.95 +Breakfast on a Bagel
1 Egg Breakfast
Build your own breakfast sandwich by selecting your bagel flavor, cheese and protein. One of our most popular sandwiches is the Bacon, egg and cheese!
$5.95 +2 Eggs Breakfast
$7.50 +1 Egg White Breakfast
$5.95 +Bagels
Bagel
Classic New York-style bagel, kettle-boiled and baked, with that signature chewy pull and golden crust. Simple and unbeatable.
$2.501/2 Dozen of Bagels
Six fresh-baked NYC-style bagels in your choice of flavors. Perfect for the whole office or family.
$15.00Baker's Dozen of Bagels (13)
Thirteen freshly baked NYC-style bagels with that signature chewy pull and golden crust. The smartest way to stock up.
$25.00Bagels and...
Bagel and Butter
$3.99 +Sandwiches
Nova Lox Sandwich
Silky smoked Nova lox with cream cheese, ripe tomato, red onion, and briny capers on a freshly baked NYC bagel. Chicago's best lox sandwich, and it's not close.
$18.95 +Oven Roasted Turkey Sandwich
$16.95 +Honey Maple Turkey Sandwich
Extra-lean turkey glazed with 100% pure maple syrup and golden honey. Low fat, high protein, and genuinely delicious. Comes with your choice of toppings and a side.
$16.95 +Smoked Turkey Sandwich
$16.95 +Turkey Pastrami Sandwich
Boldly spiced turkey pastrami with authentic deli seasoning piled high on your choice of bagel or bread. Customers can't stop talking about this one.
$16.95 +Poppy Rube's Reuben Sandwich
Corned beef, melted Swiss, tangy sauerkraut, and dressing grilled to perfection on rye. One of the most iconic sandwiches we make.
$16.95The Benny Sandwich
Boar's Head roast beef with horseradish cheddar, house-made giardiniera, caramelized red onion, cilantro, and horseradish sauce. A cult favorite that earns its reputation every single time.
$16.95Corned Beef Sandwich
Slow-cured corned beef stacked generously on your choice of bagel or deli bread. Comes with your choice of toppings and a side.
$16.95 +Pastrami Sandwich
Classic New York pastrami with bold deli spicing, piled high the way it's meant to be made. Comes with choice of side.
$16.95 +Roast Beef Sandwich
Tender oven-roasted beef piled high on your choice of bagel or deli bread. Comes with your choice of toppings and a side.
$16.95 +Ham Sandwich
$16.95 +Honey Glazed Ham Sandwich
$16.95 +Hard Salami Sandwich
Classic deli hard salami with a peppery, full-flavored bite on your choice of bagel or bread. Comes with your choice of toppings and a side.
$16.95 +Roasted Chicken Breast Sandwich
$16.95 +Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
$15.95 +Chicken Salad Sandwich
Creamy house-made chicken salad packed with tender white meat chicken on your choice of fresh bagel or bread. One of our most talked-about items.
$16.95 +Albacore Tuna Salad Sandwich
Albacore is a better source of heart-healthy omega-3 fatty acids than other tuna species & OURS IS AWARD WINNING!!
$16.95 +Egg Salad Sandwich
$13.95 +NYC Triple Decker Club Sandwich
A towering triple-layer deli sandwich stacked with Roasted Turkey Breast, Deluxe Ham, and Crispy Bacon. Go big or go home. Comes with your choice of toppings and a side.
$16.95 +Vegetarian Sandwich
Fresh cut Veggies with your choice of Homemade cream cheese or Boar's Head Cheese (please make your own selection), fugetaboutit
$11.95 +Cream Cheese by the Pound
1/2 lb. Chive Cream Cheese
Smooth cream cheese folded with fresh chives. One of our most beloved schmears.
$6.501/2 lb. Veggie Cream Cheese
A fresh, colorful spread packed with garden vegetables and bright flavor.
$6.501/2 lb. Veggie Lite Cream Cheese
A lighter veggie spread with the same vibrant, garden-fresh taste.
$6.501/2 lb. Artichoke Parmesan Cream Cheese
Earthy artichoke and aged parmesan blended into a rich, savory cream cheese spread.
$6.501/2 lb. Honey Walnut Cream Cheese
Honey cream cheese studded with toasted, crunchy walnuts throughout.
$6.50Miscellaneous
Big Chunk Crumb Cake
Classic New York crumb cake with a thick, buttery topping that melts in your mouth. Also shipped straight from New York.
$5.00Black and White Cookie
The iconic NYC cookie with a soft cake base and a half-and-half coat of chocolate and vanilla icing. Shipped straight from New York.
$5.00Carol's Cookies
Fresh-baked homemade cookies made with care. The perfect sweet finish to any order.
$5.00Beverages
Catering Menu
Baker's Bagel Basket
All presented on trays ready to uncover and serve! An assortment of fresh nyc bagels - flavored cream cheeses and butter - assorted jellies and preserves - includes one 12 oz bottle of tropicana pure premium orange juice per person - coffee or juice include.
$7.95Corey's Nyc Bagel Deli Coffee Traveler
Corey's nyc bagel deli coffee traveler servers 8-10 comes with cups, lids , creamers, sugars and stirrers.
$20.95Baker's Breakfast Basket
All presented on trays ready to uncover and serve! An assortment of fresh nyc bagels, mouth watering homemade muffins and pastries - flavored cream cheeses and butter - assorted jellies and preserves - includes either one 12 oz bottle of tropicana pure premium orange juice per person or coffee per person.
$9.95Fruit Tray
A fresh array of pineapple, strawberries, honeydew cantaloupe, watermelon, grapes and other seasonal fruits.
$59.00 +Lox & Bagels
Nova lox (smoked salmon) with plain and chive cream cheeses, sliced onions, tomatoes and cucumbers and capers. Served with nyc award winning authentic kettle boiled bagels. Also included: homemade cole slaw, potato salad and pickles. Add whitefish salad for an additional charge.
$21.95 +Meat & Cheese Tray
Your selection of boars head deli meats and cheeses. All trays are served with our fresh kettle boiled authentic nyc bagels, fresh baked rye bread, wheat and white breads. Also included: homemade cole slaw, potato salad, pickles, mustard and mayo. Add whitefish salad for an additional charge.
$21.95 +Corey's NYC Bagel Deli Signature Boxed Lunches
Your choice of a sandwich from our award winning boar's head deli meats, a bag of chips, a drink, and a side order of one of the following: coleslaw, potato salad, pasta salad, piece of fruit, or fresh fruit cup. all boxed lunches also include a miniature dessert of the day.
$21.95