Popular menu items
Smoked Turkey Sandwich
Turkey, lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumbers, your choice of cheese and bread.
$15.95 +Breakfast on a Bagel
Bagels
Bagels and...
NYC Specials
Bagel Flats
$1.29Breakfast Bagel and 10 oz. Tropicana OJ
Restaurant cannot accommodate any special instructions for menu items.
$6.49Combo Deal
Cream Cheese by the Pound
Fresh Salads
Mixed Greens Salad
Our house salad with romaine lettuce and mixed field greens with cucumbers, tomatoes, and onions.
$11.95 +Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, shredded Parmesan cheese, croutons, and our creamy Caesar dressing.
$11.95 +Tex-Mex Salad
Mixed field greens, corn, black beans, plum tomatoes, cilantro, tortilla chips, white cheddar cheese, honey-lime vinaigrette and topped with our spicy peanut sauce.
$11.95 +NYC Chopped Salad
Mixed field greens, chopped turkey, ham, bacon, egg, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions and your choice of dressing.
$11.95 +Sandwiches
Poppy Rube's Reuben Sandwich
Hot corned beef, Swiss cheese, Russian dressing or 1000 Islands, and sauerkraut.
$15.95Smoked Turkey Sandwich
Turkey, lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumbers, your choice of cheese and bread.
$15.95 +The Benny Sandwich
Warm roast beef, melted horseradish cheddar cheese, red onions, cilantro, horseradish sauce, and giardiniera peppers.
$15.95Corned Beef Sandwich
$15.95 +Pastrami Sandwich
$15.95 +Turkey Pastrami Sandwich
$14.95 +Roast Beef Sandwich
$15.95 +Ham Sandwich
$15.95 +Honey Glazed Ham Sandwich
$15.95 +Roasted Chicken Breast Sandwich
$15.95 +Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
$13.95 +Salami Sandwich
$15.95 +Cracked Pepper Turkey Sandwich
$15.95 +Oven Roasted Turkey Sandwich
$15.95 +Honey Maple Turkey Sandwich
$15.95 +Lite Tuna Salad Sandwich
$15.95 +Albacore Tuna Salad Sandwich
$15.95 +NYC Triple Decker Club Sandwich
$15.95 +Egg Salad Sandwich
$12.95 +Vegetarian Sandwich
$10.95 +Albacore Tuna Salad Sandwich
Served with pickle and choice of coleslaw, pasta salad, potato salad, chips or piece of fruit. Restaurant cannot accommodate any special instructions for menu items.
$10.89 +Chicken Salad Sandwich
All white breast. Served with pickle and choice of coleslaw, pasta salad, potato salad, chips or piece of fruit. Restaurant cannot accommodate any special instructions for menu items.
$10.89 +Low Fat Veggie Tuna Salad Sandwich
Low fat Hellmann's. Served with pickle and choice of coleslaw, pasta salad, potato salad, chips or piece of fruit. Restaurant cannot accommodate any special instructions for menu items.
$10.89 +Nova Lox Sandwich
Nova Lox, tomato, red onion, cucumbers,cream cheese and capers (please select toppings).
$17.95 +Miscellaneous
Beverages
Naked Juices
$5.99Coffee
$1.89 +Tea
$1.89 +NYC Bottled Water
$2.95Dr. Brown's Soda
$2.9912 oz. Can of Soda
$1.75Gatorade
$3.9516 oz. Snapple
$2.95Milk
$2.09Coke Bottle
$3.99Pepsi Bottle
$3.99Hot Cocoa
$1.89 +Catering Menu
Boxed Lunch
Any sandwich, bag of chips, a side of coleslaw, potato salad, pasta salad, piece of fruit or fresh fruit cup, can of soda and a miniature dessert.
$12.95NYC Sandwich Tray
Assorted sandwiches sliced in halves, served on catering trays. Includes pickles and 2 side choices. Served with our award winning NYC kettle boiled bagels, fresh, baked rye, wheat and white breads, assorted rolls, kosher pickles, mustard, mayo and more.
$12.95NYC Sandwich with Fresh Fruit Tray
Assorted sandwiches sliced in halves, served on catering trays. Served with our award winning NYC kettle boiled bagels, fresh, baked rye, wheat and white breads, assorted rolls, kosher pickles, mustard, mayo and more.
$12.95Meat and Cheese Tray
Choose 3 meats and 2 cheeses. Served with our award winning NYC kettle boiled bagels, sliced kosher pickles, coleslaw, potato salad or pasta salad.
$13.75Meat and Cheese with Fresh Fruit Tray
Choose 3 meats and 2 cheeses. Served with our award winning NYC kettle boiled bagels.
$13.75Lox and Bagel Tray
Nova lox with plain or chive cream cheeses, sliced red onions, tomatoes, sliced cucumbers and capers. Served with our award winning NYC kettle boiled bagels, sliced kosher pickles, coleslaw, potato salad or pasta salad. Add white fish salad for an additional charge.
$13.49 +Lox and Bagel with Fresh Fruit Tray
Nova lox with plain or chive cream cheeses, sliced red onions, tomatoes, sliced cucumbers and capers. Served with our award winning NYC kettle boiled bagels. Add white fish salad for an additional charge.
$13.49 +Catering NYC Bagel Basket
Made fresh daily. Assortment of our award winning NYC kettle boiled bagels, flavored cream cheeses, butter, jelly and preserves. Choose from a 12 oz. bottle of tropicana pure premium orange juice, a 10 oz. hot cup of coffee, or our own bottled spring water. All paper goods included upon request.
$6.95Catering NYC Bagel Breakfast Basket
Made fresh daily. Assortment of our award winning NYC kettle boiled bagels, muffins and assorted pastries, flavored cream cheeses, butter, jelly and preserves. Choose from a 12 oz. bottle of tropicana pure premium orange juice, a 10 oz. hot cup of coffee, or our own bottled spring water. All paper goods included upon request.
$8.95Hot Breakfast Sandwich Tray
Choose from bacon, egg and cheese sausage, egg and cheese ham, egg and cheese or turkey, egg and cheese. Served with our award winning NYC kettle boiled bagels, fresh, baked rye, wheat and white breads, assorted rolls, kosher pickles, mustard, mayo and more.
$6.95Muffin Tray
$29.95 +Catering Yogi Bar
Vanilla yogurt, granola and fresh assorted berries. Granola parfait also available.
$5.95Fresh Seasonal Fruit Tray
Pineapple, cantaloupe, honeydew, watermelon, strawberries, blueberries, grapes and more.
$49.00 +Catering Fresh Entree Salad
Mixed Greens Salad Tray
Romaine lettuce and mixed field greens with cucumbers, tomatoes and onions.
$29.95 +Tex-Mex Salad Tray
Mixed field greens with corn, black beans, plum tomatoes, cilantro, tortilla chips, white cheddar cheese with honey-lime vinaigrette and topped with our spicy peanut sauce.
$29.95 +Caesar Salad Tray
Romaine lettuce, shredded Parmesan cheese, croutons and our creamy Caesar dressing.
$29.95 +NYC Chopped Salad Tray
Mixed field greens, chopped turkey, ham, bacon, egg, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions and your choice of dressing.
$29.95 +