Croton Reservoir Tavern
MenuAbout
Croton Reservoir Tavern Menu

Croton Reservoir Tavern

American, Dinner
108 West 40th St, New York, NY 10018
(212) 997-6835
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Shareables

Menu powered by Grubhub

50/50 Wings

Buffalo BBQ, pepper relish and Alabama white sauce.

$14.00 +

Bang Bang Cauliflower

"Szechuan style", sesame, green onion, red chiles.

$16.00

Spicy Brussels Sprouts

Maple, mustard, braised bacon, chili, flaky salt.

$16.00

Blistered Shishito Peppers

Creamy buttermilk aioli, lemon, flaky salt.

$15.00

Hot Spiced Buffalo Chips

Local blue cheese fondue, celery leaves.

$14.00

Fig and Prosciutto Flatbread

Brie, arugula, hot honey.

$19.00

Cast Iron Shrimp

Red shrimp, grilled country bread, white wine, garlic butter.

$20.00

Warm Queso and Chips

Jack and Cotija cheese, chorizo, pico de gallo, roasted poblano.

$16.00

Return of the Mac

Shells, cheddar, Monterey Jack, mozzarella, garlic breadcrumbs.

$17.00

Bridge and Tunnel Tots

Cheese curds, beef gravy, crispy ham, scallions.

$16.00

Hummus

Harissa, extra virgin olive oil, garlic, onion, warm pita.

$14.00

NYC Mega Pretzel

Stone ground mustard, local beer cheese.

$16.00

Crispy Gochujang Brussels

pork belly, soy, chili garlic vinaigrette, cashews

$17.00

Street Corn Hush Puppies

charred corn & jalapeno fritters, Cotija, chamoy mayo, cilantro, lime

$18.00

Summer Squash & Prosciutto Flatbread

green & gold squash, roasted tomato, charred red onion, fresh ricotta, Calabrian Chili, fermented honey, herbs

$18.00

Margherita Flatbread

plum tomato, mozzarella, basil, evoo

$17.00

Tavern Favorites

Cavatelli Primavera

house made semolina cavatelli, local vegetables, pesto, parmesan

$26.00

Chicken Pot Pie

Poached chicken, sauce supreme, carrots, celery, mushrooms, peas, flaky pie crust.

$25.00

Beer Mussels

PEI mussels, golden ale, fennel, shallot, mustard, cream, fries.

$24.00

Reservoir Chip Shop

Local cod, Brooklyn batter, malt vinegar fries, mashed peas, house tartar.

$28.00

Steak Frites

Grilled NY strip, roasted shallot and garlic butter, fries, side salad.

$37.00

Dukkah Crusted Salmon

vermicelli rice, honey roasted baby carrots, asparagus tahini herb yogurt

$32.00

Tuna Nicoise

fennel & coriander crusted rare tuna, green beans, olives, purple potato, tomato, frisee, herb vinaigrette

$34.00

Crab Cake Oscar

lump crab, Jersey corn sauce, shaved asparagus and tomato salad, herbs, chile oil

$30.00

Roasted Peruvian Chicken

1/2 roasted chicken, yucca frita, garlic braised green beans, aji Amarillo sauce.

$34.00

Garden Greens

The Cobb Salad

Mesclun, grilled chicken, crumbled bacon, local blue cheese, egg, avocado, tomato, herb vinaigrette.

$20.00 +

All Hail Caesar Salad

Romaine, Parmesan, ciabatta croutons, Caesar dressing.

$15.00 +

Mediterranean Quinoa Salad

Mixed lettuce, quinoa, cucumber, red onion, peppadew peppers, feta, radish, lemon mint vinaigrette.

$17.00 +

Harvest Salad

Tuscan kale, delicate squash, pomegranate, toasted pumpkin seeds, local blue cheese, cider vinaigrette.

$18.00 +

Chopped Kale

Tuscan kale, Chickpea, cucumber, red onion, feta, peppadew peppers, mint, toasted pita, lemon vinaigrette

$16.00 +

Peaches & Greens

baby arugula, grilled macerated peaches, blueberries, almonds, blue cheese, radicchio, white balsamic vinaigrette

$17.00 +

Handhelds

Croton Crunch Sandwich

Spicy fried chicken, house chili onion crunch, slaw, pickles, brioche bun.

$21.00 +

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

Marinated chicken, crispy bacon, avocado, Swiss, shredded lettuce, tomato, house chipotle ranch, ciabatta.

$21.00 +

Tavern Burger

Shredded lettuce, caramelized onions, pickles, horseradish spread, NY aged cheddar, brioche bun.

$22.00 +

French Onion Dip Sandwich

Thinly sliced steak, aged Gruyere, onion jus, toasted garlic bread, shoestring fries.

$24.00 +

Blackened Mahi Mahi Sandwich

Grilled pineapple pico, mashed avocado, brioche bun.

$25.00 +

New England Lobster Roll

poached lobster, mayo, celery, chive, lemon, brioche roll, house ships

$29.00 +

Pastrami Burger

pastrami spiced patty, gruyere, slaw, pickles, smoked caraway mayo, brioche bun

$21.00 +

Crispy Crab Cake Sandwich

lump carb house tartar, lettuce, tomato, brioche bun

$24.00 +

Sides

Basket of Sweet Potato Tots

Fried grated sweet potatoes.

$12.00

Basket of Fries

Fried potatoes.

$11.00

Green Beans

Sauteed

$9.00

Shishito Peppers

Mildly spicy pepper.

$11.00

Brussel Sprouts

$13.00

Side Salad

$8.00

Our Way [Archived]

OG

Double Certified Angus Beef Patties, Sharp American Cheddar, Handcraft Sauce, Shredded Romaine Lettuce, Tomato, Brioche Bun

$13.00 +

The Oklahoma

Single Certified Angus Beef Patty Smashed With Shaved Onions, Sharp American Cheddar Cheese, Mayo, Mustard, Pickles, Brioche Bun

$9.00 +

Truffle Shuffle

Single Certified Angus Beef Patty, Umami Truffle Spice, Swiss Cheese, Sauteed Mushrooms, Truffle Herb Aioli, Brioche Bun

$10.00 +

The Green Chile

Single Certified Angus Beef Patty, House Spice Blend, Monterey Jack Cheese, Roasted Hatch Chile, Avocado, Lime Aioli, Brioche Bun

$11.00 +

This Little Piggy

Single Certified Angus Beef Patty, Sharp American Cheddar, Pulled Pork, Bacon, BBQ Sauce, Fried Onions, Brioche Bun

$13.00 +

Your Way [Archived]

Single CAB Patty

$9.00 +

Double CAB Patty

$12.00 +

Single Veggie Patty

$10.00 +

Double Veggie Patty

$13.00 +

The Other Way [Archived]

The Ripper

Crispy Fried Weiner, Kraut, Spicy Brown Mustard

$6.00 +

Bacon & Cheese Ripper

Crispy Fried Weiner, Beer Cheese, Crumbled Bacon

$8.00 +

Spicy Chicken Sandwich

Crispy Chicken, Hot Spice, Shredded Romaine Lettuce, Pickles, Ranch

$10.00 +

BBQ Ranch Salad

Mesclun, Romaine, Fried Chicken, Cheddar, Egg, Tomato, Fried Onion, BBQ Sauce, Ranch

$13.00

Soup

Lobster Bisque

Creme fraiche, puff pastry, chives.

$15.00

The Tots [Archived]

Buffalo Tots

Fried Chicken, Buffalo Spice, Bacon, Blue Cheese, Celery

$14.00

Bodega Tots

Chopped Cheese, Caramelized Onion, Lettuce, Tomato, Ketchup, Mayo

$14.00

Southern Belle

Pulled Pork, BBQ Sauce, Beer Cheese, Fried Onions, Roasted Hatch Chile

$14.00

Fries [Archived]

Handcraft Fries

One Size Fits All

$5.00 +

Bag Of Tots

One Size Fits All

$7.00 +

Dipping Sauce [Archived]

Truffle Aioli

$3.00

Lime Aioli

$3.00

Handcraft Sauce

$3.00

Beer Cheese

$3.00

BBQ Sauce

$3.00

Ranch

$3.00

Quench Your Thirst [Archived]

Saratoga Still Water

$4.50 +

Boylan Cane Cola

$4.50 +

Boylan Diet Cola

$4.50 +

Boylan Root Beer

$4.50 +

Boylan Creamy Red Birch Beer

$4.50 +

Boylan Shirley Temple

$4.50 +

Boylan Creme

$4.50 +

Boylan Orange

$4.50 +

Boylan Black Cherry

$4.50 +

Boylan Lime Seltzer

$4.50 +

Boylan Raspberry Seltzer

$4.50 +

Spindrift Lemon Sparkling Water

$4.50 +

Spindrift Lime Sparkling Water

$4.50 +

Spindrift Raspberry Lime Sparkling Water

$4.50 +

Spindrift Grapefruit Sparkling Water

$4.50 +

Spindrift BlackBerry Sparkling Water

$4.50 +

Niagara Water

$4.00 +

Spindrift Cucumber

$4.50 +

Spindrift Cucumber Sparkling Water

$4.50 +
Restaurant closed
.

About Croton Reservoir Tavern

  • 108 West 40th St, New York, NY 10018
  • American, Dinner, Lunch Specials, New American, Salads, Wraps
  • (212) 997-6835
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / Croton Reservoir Tavern
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy policy CA Privacy notice Do not sell my info
© 2023 Grubhub Holdings Inc.