Gooey on the Inside Cookies
MenuAbout
Gooey on the Inside Cookies Menu

Gooey on the Inside Cookies

American, Bakery
163 Chrystie Street, New York, NY 10002
(646) 972-0409
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

**NEW**Warm Soft Baked Cookie Dough

Menu powered by Grubhub

Birthday Cake Cookie Dough

It's our AWESOME birthday cake cookie dough. It's warm. It's gooey gooey. It's covered with white chocolate ganache. Need I say more?.....Oh! and it's yummy

$9.99 +

Chocolate Chip Chunk Cookie Dough

It's our AWESOME chocolate chip cookie dough. It's warm. It's gooey gooey. It's covered with chocolate ganache. Need I say more?.....Oh! and it's yummy

$9.99 +

S'Mores Cookie Dough

It's our AWESOME s'mores dough. It's warm. It's gooey gooey. It's covered with chocolate ganache and marshmallow fluff. Need I say more?.....Oh! and it's yummy

$9.99 +

**NEW**Cap'n Crunch Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Chunk Dough

It's our AWESOME peanut butter chocolate chip cookie dough. It's warm. It's gooey gooey. It's covered with chocolate ganache and peanut butter. Need I say more?.....Oh! and it's yummy

$9.99 +

Red Velvet Cookie Dough

It's our AWESOME red velvet cookie dough. It's warm. It's gooey gooey. It's covered with white chocolate ganache and sweet cream cheese frosting. Need I say more?.....Oh! and it's yummy

$9.99 +

Caramel Chocolate Chip Chunk Cookie Dough

It's our AWESOME caramel chocolate chip cookie dough. It's warm. It's gooey gooey. It's covered with chocolate ganache and Cadbury caramel spread. Need I say more?.....Oh! and it's yummy

$9.99 +

**NEW** Pumpkin Brulée Cookie Dough

It's our AWESOME pumpkin crème bruée cookie dough. It's warm. It's gooey gooey. It's covered with white chocolate ganache and custard. Need I say more?.....Oh! and it's yummy

$9.99 +

Dunkaroo Cookie Dough

$9.99 +

**NEW** Oatmeal Maple & Crushed Waffle Cone Cookie Dough

$9.99 +

**NEW** Sweet Potato Pie Cookie Dough

$9.99 +

**New** White Chocolate Fruity Pebbles Cheese Cake Cookie Dough

$9.99 +

**NEW** Flavor of the Munch Dough

Red Velvet

$9.99 +

**NEW**Cuppa Joe Exotic Dough

Dark Chocolate Espresso Caramel

$9.99 +

**NEW**Where is Chu Husband, Carole Baskin Dough

Churro-Inspired Cookie with Nutella filling

$9.99 +

Jumbo Cookies

**NEW** Nutella Toasted Marshmallow

Dark Chocolate cookie with toasted marshmallow bits and a creamy nutella center

$5.00

**NEW** Dunkaroo

A yummy white chocolate cookie topped with vanilla icing, graham cracker crumbs, rainbow sprinkles and teddy graham cookies

$5.00

**NEW** Honeycomb Cookie

Surprisingly made using no honey at all, honeycomb is a crunchy, chewy, caramel candy. We break it into chunks and fold it into our burnt brown sugar cookie dough. The honeycomb remains crispy on the inside, chewy on the outside and bleeds micro ribbons of caramel throughout the cookie.

$5.00

Birthday Cake Cookie

Now it can be your birthday everyday! This birthday cake cookie complete imported French white chocolate chunks, real pieces of birthday cake and colorful sprinkles. You'll enjoy every last bite.

$5.00

Chocolate Chip Chunk Cookie

Our chocolate chip cookies are Chewy Gooey Melt-in-Your-Mouth! Rich dark and milk chocolate chips are combined with dark chocolate chunks in a delicious golden cookie.

$5.00

S'mores Cookie

Campfire not required! A sumptuous blend of French milk chocolate, dark chocolate, marshmallows and golden cookie make this childhood favorite treat come to life. Ooey-Gooey perfection in every bite.

$5.00

Cap'n Crunch Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Chunk Cookie

This cookie is Chewy Gooey Melt-in-Your-Mouth! Peanut butter chips, rich dark and milk chocolate chips are combined with dark chocolate chunks in a delicious golden cookie.

$5.00

Red Velvet Cookie

Red Velvet If you love red velvet cake, you'll go insane over this cookie. It's moist texture is yummily complemented with a sweet cream-cheese frosting center and topped-off with hunks of French white chocolate chunks. It taste just like the cake!

$5.00

**Limited Edition** Caramel Chocolate Chip Chunk

If you LOVE our chocolate chip cookies then you'll REALLY LOOOOOOOOOVE this upgrade. We've added delectable Cadbury Caramel Chocolate Spread to our cookie cores. They are EVEN MORE Ooey Gooey Melt-in-Your-Mouth!

$5.00

**NEW** Peanut Butter & Jelly S'Mores Cookie

**NEW**This was THE after school go-to snack! It's now A sumptuous blend of French milk chocolate, dark chocolate, followed by a layer peanut butter, raspberry jelly and marshmallows all in a golden cookie. Ooey-Gooey perfection in every bite.

$5.00

**NEW** Carrot Cake Cookie

If you love carrot cake, you'll go insane over this cookie. It's moist texture is "yummingly" complemented with a sweet cream-cheese frosting center and topped-off with hunks of French white chocolate chunks. It taste just like the cake!

$5.00

**NEW** Oatmeal Butterscotch Pumpkin Spice Cookie

Our Seasonal oatmeal cookie is a yummy blend of carefully pumpkin spices, golden oats, butterscotch and white chocolate chips with a pumpkin puree. Get it before it's gone!

$5.00

**NEW** Pumpkin Brulée Cookie

A sumptuous golden pumpkin cookie with hints of nutmeg and bourbon vanilla extract with a creamy crème brulée center.

$5.00

**NEW**Marshmallow Sweet Potato Pie

If you love sweet potato pie then you’ll love this cookie. A wonderful blend of cinnamon spices, chunks of sweet potato & fudge coupled with white chocolate. It's topped-off with a layer of ooey gooey toasted marshmallow. Here for a limited time only.

$5.00

Choco-Chewy Cookie

Overflowing with a trio of dark chocolate, milk chocolate & white chocolate this mammoth cookie with a creamy caramel center is topped-off with clusters of caramel bits.

$5.00

Dark Chocolate Ganache and Toffee Vanilla Cookie

Overflowing with chunks of dark chocolate this mammoth cookie with a creamy caramel/ganache center is topped-off with clusters of imported French white chocolate.

$5.00

Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie

Overflowing with chunks of dark chocolate this mammoth cookie with a creamy peanut butter center is topped-off with clusters of mini peanut butter cups.

$5.00

Fluffernana Cookie

Your favorite afterschool sandwich has been made over into an AWESOME cookie! We’ve added bananas to the dynamic duo of peanut butter & marshmallow fluff. It’s the ultimate sweet trinity!

$5.00

White Chocolate Chunk Cookie

Our white chocolate chunk cookies are Chewy Gooey Melt-in-Your-Mouth! Rich, French white chocolate is deliciously coupled with a  golden cookie.

$5.00

White Chocolate S'mores Cookie

A sumptuous blend of French white chocolate, marshmallows and golden cookie make this childhood favorite treat come to life. Ooey-Gooey perfection in every bite.

$5.00

**NEW** Dark Chocolate Cookie Butter

$5.00

**NEW** Oatmeal Maple & Crushed Waffle Cone Cookie

$5.00

**New** White Chocolate Fruity Pebbles Cheese Cake Cookie

$5.00

**NEW**Flavor of the Munch

Red Velvet

$5.00

**NEW** Cuppa Joe Exotic Cookie

Dark Chocolate Espresso Caramel

$5.00

**NEW** Churro Cookie

Churro-Inspired Cookie with Nutella Filling

$5.00

Goowees

6 Piece Birthday Cake Goowees

Yummy birthday cake cookie bites complete with imported French white chocolate chunks, real pieces of birthday cake and colorful sprinkles. You'll enjoy every last bite. “Go Shorty! It’s your birthday!”

$9.99

6 Piece Chocolate Chip Chunk Goowees

Our chocolate chip cookie bites are Ooey Gooey Melt-in-Your-Mouth! Rich dark and milk chocolate chips are combined with dark chocolate chunks in a delicious golden cookie.

$9.99

6 Piece S'mores Goowees

Campfire not required! A sumptuous blend of French milk chocolate, dark chocolate, marshmallows and golden cookie make this childhood favorite treat come to life. Ooey-Gooey perfection in every cookie bite.

$9.99

6 Piece White Chocolate Smores Goowees

A sumptuous blend of French white chocolate, marshmallows and golden cookie make this childhood favorite treat come to life. Ooey-Gooey perfection in every cookie bite.

$9.99

6 Piece Cap'n Crunch PB Chocolate Chip Chunk Goowees

This cookie bite is Chewy Gooey Melt-in-Your-Mouth! Peanut butter chips, rich dark and milk chocolate chips are combined with dark chocolate chunks in a delicious golden cookie.

$9.99

6 Piece White Chocolate Chunk Goowees

Our white chocolate chunk cookie bites are Chewy Gooey Melt-in-Your-Mouth! Rich, French white chocolate is deliciously coupled with a golden cookie.

$9.99

6 Piece Fluffernana Goowees

Your favorite afterschool sandwich has been made over into an AWESOME cookie bite! We’ve added bananas to the dynamic duo of peanut butter & marshmallow fluff. It’s the ultimate sweet trinity!

$9.99

6 Piece Choco-Chewy Goowees

Overflowing with a trio of dark chocolate, milk chocolate & white chocolate this mammoth cookie bite with a creamy caramel center is topped-off with clusters of caramel bits.

$9.99

6 Piece Dark Chocolate Ganache and Toffee Vanilla Goowee

Overflowing with chunks of dark chocolate these mammoth cookie bites with a creamy caramel/ganache center are topped-off with clusters of imported French white chocolate.

$9.99

6 Piece Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Goowee

Overflowing with chunks of dark chocolate these mammoth cookie bites with a creamy peanut butter center are topped-off with clusters of mini peanut butter cups.

$9.99

6 Pieces Marshmallow Sweet Potato Pie

If you love sweet potato pie then you’ll love this version. A wonderful blend of cinnamon spices, chunks of sweet potato, brown sugar and everything nice and topped-off with a gooey toasted marshmallow. Here for a limited time only.

$9.99

**NEW** 6 Piece Caramel Chocolate Chip Goowees

If you LOVE our chocolate chip cookies then you'll REALLY LOOOOOOOOOVE this GOOWEE upgrade. We've added delectable Cadbury Caramel Chocolate Spread to our cookie cores. They are EVEN MORE Ooey Gooey Melt-in-Your-Mouth!

$9.99

***NEW***6 Piece Marshmallow Sweet Potato Goowees

If you love sweet potato pie then you’ll love these cookie bites. A wonderful blend of cinnamon spices, chunks of sweet potato & fudge coupled with white chocolate chips. It's topped-off with a layer of caramel & ooey gooey toasted marshmallow. Here for a limited time only.

$9.99

**NEW** 6 Piece Peanut Butter & Jelly Goowees

This was THE after school go-to snack back in the day.! It's now a sumptuous blend of French milk chocolate, dark chocolate, followed by a layer peanut butter, raspberry jelly and marshmallows all perfectly packaged in a bite-sized cookie. Ooey-Gooey perfection in every bite.

$9.99

**NEW** 6 Piece Oatmeal Butterscotch Pumpkin Spice Goowees

Our seasonal oatmeal cookie bites are a yummy blend of carefully pumpkin spices, golden oats, butterscotch and white chocolate chips with a pumpkin puree center. Get it before it's gone!

$9.99

**NEW** 6 Piece Crème Brûlée Goowees

A sumptuous golden white chocolate cookie bite with hints of nutmeg and bourbon vanilla extract with a creamy crème brulée center

$9.99

6 Piece Red Velvet Goowees

If you love red velvet cake, you'll go insane over these cookie bites. Their moist texture is "yummingly" complemented with a sweet cream-cheese frosting center and topped-off with hunks of French white chocolate chunks. It taste just like the cake!

$9.99

**NEW** 6 piece Dark Chocolate Cookie Butter Goowees

$9.99

**NEW**6 piece Oatmeal Maple & Crushed Waffle Cone Goowees

$9.99

**NEW** 6 Piece White Chocolate Fruity Pebbles Cheese Cake Goowees

$9.99

**NEW** 6 Piece Flavor of the Munch Goowees

Red Velvet

$9.99

**NEW** 6 Piece Cuppa Joe Exotic Goowees

Dark Chocolate Espresso Caramel

$9.99

**NEW** 6 Piece Churro Goowees

Churro-Inspired Cookie with Nutella Filling

$9.99

Deep Fried Cookie Bites

Birthday Cake -4pc

Everyone's favorite indulgent fair food is now a click away. These yummy bites consist of a fluffy, golden-brown fried dough that yields a warm and melty birthday cake creme center,topped-off with a dusting of powdered sugar.

$9.99

Chocolate Chip Chunk-4pc

Everyone's favorite indulgent fair food is now a click away. These yummy bites consist of a fluffy, golden-brown fried dough that yields a warm and melty chocolate creme center,topped-off with a dusting of powdered sugar.

$9.99

S'Mores-4pc

Everyone's favorite indulgent fair food is now a click away. These yummy bites consist of a fluffy, golden-brown fried dough that yields a warm and melty chocolate & marshmallow creme center,topped-off with a dusting of powdered sugar.

$9.99

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip-4pc

Everyone's favorite indulgent fair food is now a click away. These yummy bites consist of a fluffy, golden-brown fried dough that yields a warm and melty peanut butter chocolate creme center,topped-off with a dusting of powdered sugar.

$9.99

Warm Molten Cookie in a Jar

**NEW** Ooey Gooey Carrot Cake Cookie in a Jar

Our warm ooey gooey molten carrot cake cookie with cream cheese frosting is popular for a reason: It's cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm white chocolate through the middle. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$9.99 +

Ooey Gooey Birthday Cake Cookie in a Jar

Our warm ooey gooey molten white chocolate birthday cake cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$9.99 +

Ooey Gooey Chocolate Chunk Cookie in a Jar

Our warm ooey gooey molten chocolate chunk cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$9.99 +

Ooey Gooey S'mores Cookie in a Jar

Our warm ooey gooey molten chocolate & marshmallow Smores cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$9.99 +

Ooey Gooey Cap't Crunch Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Chunk Cookie in a Jar

Our warm ooey gooey molten Peanut Butter Chocolate chip chunk cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$9.99 +

**NEW** Ooey Gooey Caramel Chocolate Chip in a Jar

Our warm ooey gooey molten caramel chocolate chip with ganache are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$9.99 +

**NEW** Ooey Gooey PB & J Smores in a Jar

Our warm ooey gooey molten chocolate, peanut butter, jelly & marshmallow Smores cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate ganache through the middle. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$9.99 +

Ooey Gooey Red Velvet Cookie in a Jar

Our warm ooey gooey molten red velvet cookie with cream cheese frosting is popular for a reason: It's cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm white chocolate through the middle. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$9.99 +

**NEW** Ooey Gooey Pumpkin Brulée Cookie in a Jar

Our warm ooey gooey molten pumpkin brulée with crème brulée ganache are popular for a reason: They're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm white chocolate through the middle. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$9.99 +

**NEW** Ooey Gooey Oatmeal Butterscotch Pumpkin Spice Cookie in a jar

Our warm ooey gooey molten oatmeal butterscotch pumpkin spice cookie with white chocolate ganache & pumpkin puree are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate-pumpkin through the middle. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$9.99 +

**NEW**Ooey Gooey Marshmallow Sweet Potato Cookie in a jar

Our warm ooey gooey molten sweet potato cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm white chocolate ganache through the middle and topped off with a layer of toasted marshmallow.

$9.99 +

Ooey Gooey Choco-Chewy Cookie in a Jar

Our warm ooey gooey molten Choco-Chewy cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic

$9.99 +

Ooey Gooey Dark Chocolate Ganache Toffee Vanilla Cookie in a Jar 16 oz.

Our warm ooey gooey molten dark chocolate chocolate ganache cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$9.99 +

Ooey Gooey Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie in a Jar

Our warm ooey gooey molten dark chocolate peanut butter cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$9.99 +

Ooey Gooey Fluffernana Cookie in a Jar

Our warm ooey gooey molten Fluffernana cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$9.99 +

Ooey Gooey Marshmallow Sweet Potato Pie

If you love sweet potato pie then you’ll love this version. A wonderful blend of cinnamon spices, chunks of sweet potato, brown sugar and everything nice and topped-off with a gooey toasted marshmallow. Here for a limited time only.

$9.99 +

Ooey Gooey White Chocolate Chunk Cookie in a Jar

Our warm ooey gooey molten white chocolate chunk cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$9.99 +

Ooey Gooey White Chocolate S'mores Cookie in a Jar

Our warm ooey gooey molten chocolate cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$9.99 +

**NEW** Nutella Toasted Marshmallow

$9.99 +

**NEW** Dunkaroo

A yummy white chocolate cookie topped with vanilla icing, graham cracker crumbs, rainbow sprinkles and teddy graham cookies

$9.99 +

**NEW** Dark Chocolate Cookie Butter

$9.99 +

**NEW** Ooey Gooey Oatmeal Maple & Crushed Waffle Cone in a Jar

$9.99 +

**NEW** Ooey Gooey White Chocolate Fruity Pebbles Cheese Cake in a Jar

$9.99 +

**NEW** Ooey Gooey Flavor of the Munch in a Jar

Red Velvet

$9.99 +

**NEW** Cuppa Joe Exotic

Dark Chocolate Espresso Caramel

$9.99 +

**NEW** Churro

Churro-Inspired Cookie with Nutella Filling

$9.99 +

Warm Molten Cookie in a Jar a la Mode

16 oz. Ooey Gooey Birthday Cake Cookie in a Jar a la Mode

Our warm ooey gooey molten white chocolate birthday cake cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. If that’s not enough we’ve lobbed on a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$19.99

16 oz. Ooey Gooey Chocolate Chunk Cookie in a Jar a la Mode

Our warm ooey gooey molten chocolate chunk cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. If that’s not enough we’ve lobbed on a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$19.99

16 oz. Ooey Gooey S’mores Cookie in a Jar a la Mode

Our warm ooey gooey molten chocolate & marshmallow Smores cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. If that’s not enough we’ve lobbed on a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$19.99

16 oz. Ooey Gooey White Chocolate S’mores Cookie in a Jar a la Mode

Our warm ooey gooey molten chocolate cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. If that’s not enough we’ve lobed on a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$19.99

16 oz. Ooey Gooey Cap'n Crunch Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Chunk Cookie in a Jar a la Mode

Our warm ooey gooey molten Peanut Butter Chocolate chip chunk cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. If that’s not enough we’ve lobbed on a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$19.99

16 oz. Ooey Gooey White Chocolate Chunk Cookie in a Jar a la Mode

Our warm ooey gooey molten white chocolate chunk cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. If that’s not enough we’ve lobed on a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$19.99

Ooey Gooey Dark Chocolate Ganache Toffee Vanilla

Our warm ooey gooey molten dark chocolate chocolate ganache cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. If that’s not enough we’ve lobed on a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$19.00

Ooey Gooey Marshmallow Sweet Potato Pie

If you love sweet potato pie then you’ll love this version. A wonderful blend of cinnamon spices, chunks of sweet potato, brown sugar and everything nice and topped-off with a gooey toasted marshmallow. If that’s not enough we’ve lobed on a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream.Here for a limited time only.

$19.00

16 oz. Ooey Gooey Fluffernana Cookie in a Jar a la Mode

Our warm ooey gooey molten Fluffernana cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. If that’s not enough we’ve lobed on a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$19.99

16 oz. Ooey Gooey Choco-Chewy Cookie in a Jar a la Mode

Our warm ooey gooey molten Choco-Chewy cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. If that’s not enough we’ve lobed on a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$19.99

**NEW** 16oz. Ooey Gooey Caramel Chocolate Chip in Jar A La Mode

Our warm ooey gooey molten caramel chocolate chip with ganache are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate through the middle. If that's not enough we've lobbed on a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$19.99

**NEW** 16 oz. Ooey Gooey Sweet Potato Cookie in a Jar a la Mode

Our warm ooey gooey molten sweet potato cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm white chocolate ganache through the middle. It's topped off with a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$19.99

**NEW** 16oz Ooey Gooey Peanut & Jelly S'Mores Cookie in a jar A La Mode

Our warm ooey gooey molten chocolate, peanut butter, jelly & marshmallow Smores cookies are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate ganache through the middle. And topped off with a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream.The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$19.99

**NEW** Ooey Gooey Oatmeal Butterscotch Pumpkin Spice Cookie in a jar à la mode

Our warm ooey gooey molten oatmeal butterscotch pumpkin spice cookie with white chocolate ganache & pumpkin puree are popular for a reason: they're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm chocolate-pumpkin through the middle. And topped off with premium vanilla ice cream.The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$19.99

**NEW** Ooey Gooey Pumpkin Brulée Cookie in a jar à la mode à la mode

Our warm ooey gooey molten pumpkin brulée with crème brulée ganache are popular for a reason: They're cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm white chocolate through the middle. And a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$19.99

16 oz. Ooey Gooey Red Velvet Cookie in a Jar à la Mode

Our warm ooey gooey molten red velvet cookie with cream cheese frosting is popular for a reason: It's cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm white chocolate in the middle. If that's not enough, we've lobbed on a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$19.99

16 oz. Ooey Gooey Carrot Cake Cookie in a Jar à la Mode

Our warm ooey gooey molten carrot cake cookie with cream cheese frosting is popular for a reason: It's cakey on the outside with an irresistible center of warm white chocolate in the middle. If that's not enough, we've lobbed on a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream. The first time you try one, it may seem like magic.

$19.99

**NEW** Ooey Gooey Dark Chocolate Cookie Butter Cookie in a jar à la mode à la mode

$19.99

**NEW** Ooey Gooey Dunkaroo Cookie in a jar à la mode à la mode

$19.99

**NEW** 16oz. Ooey Gooey White Chocolate Fruity Pebbles Cheese Cake in a Jar a la Mode

$19.99

**NEW** Ooey Gooey Oatmeal Maple & Crushed Waffle Cone Cookie in a jar à la mode à la mode

$19.99

**NEW** Ooey Gooey Flavor of the Munch Cookie in a jar à la mode à la mode

Red Velvet

$19.99

**NEW** Ooey Gooey Cuppa Joe Exotic Cookie in a jar à la mode à la mode

Dark Chocolate Espresso Caramel

$19.99

**NEW** Ooey Gooey Churro Cookie in a jar à la mode à la mode

Churro-Inspired Cookie with Nutella Filling

$19.99

Cookie Dips

Vanilla Chocolate Dip

Perfect for "cookie" dunking

$1.50

Chocolate Dip

Perfect for "cookie" dunking

$1.50

Caramel Chocolate Dip

Perfect for "cookie" dunking

$1.00

Nutella

Perfect for "cookie" dunking

$2.00

Marshmallow Fluff

Perfect for "cookie" dunking

$1.50

Cookie Butter/Speculoos

Perfect for "cookie" dunking

$1.00

Cookie Butter Cookie Spread

Birthday Cake Jar

$10.50

Chocolate Chip Chunk Jar

$10.50
FYI, this restaurant is not accepting orders right now.

About Gooey on the Inside Cookies

Info

Gooey on the Inside wants to take you back to your childhood by making your favorite treats from "back in the day". All our products are made by hand with all-natural and carefully curated ingredients. No preservatives or hydrogenated oil. We are more than a name, we are purveyors of all things "Gooey on the Inside".

Who Wants a Cookie? You do!

We currently do not have a retail storefront that can accommodate customer walk-ins with no advance notice. If you wish to place a same day PICK- UP order, all you have to do is place your order on the Menupages platform. Pre-pay for it and it will be ready for pickup at our Sullivan street commercial catering kitchen location. It's that simple

  • 163 Chrystie Street, New York, NY 10002
  • American, Bakery, Dessert, Dinner, Late Night, Lunch Specials
  • (646) 972-0409
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / Gooey on the Inside Cookies
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.