Holey Cream
Popular menu items
Peanut Butter Cup Sundae
Choose 2 flavors of ice cream. Four scoops of ice cream, hot fudge, peanut butter sauce and Reese's peanut butter cups.
$9.50 +New Flavors - Winter 2022
Cookie Monster
Vanilla Ice Creamin blue (think Sesame Street's Cookie Monster) , loaded with fresh vanilla bean flavor, and stuffed with chips ahoy and and Oreos cookies
$5.75 +Peanut Butter Oreo Ice Cream
$5.75 +Red Velvet Cupcake Ice Cream
It’s back and better than ever! A rich, velvety ice cream with red velvet cake pieces and a ribbon of sweet chocolate fudge
$5.75 +Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
It’s back and better than ever! Silky brown sugar cinnamon ice cream, swirled with sweet caramel sauce, chocolate flakes, and delicious oatmeal cookie crumbles.
$5.75 +Cinnamon Bun Ice Cream
Cinnamon ice cream with sweet cinnamon swirls and cinnamon sugar dough bites.
$5.75 +Egg Nog Ice Cream
$5.75 +Ice Cream
Muddy Boots Ice Cream
Creamy vanilla ice cream loaded with a rich caramel ripple and decadent brownie chunks
$5.75 +S'mores
$5.75 +Brownie a la Mode Ice Cream
$5.75 +Sea Salt Caramel
$5.75 +HOLeY Peanut Butter M&M Ice Cream
PB Ice Cream loaded with M&Ms, Choc Chunks and Oatmeal Cookies. Must Try!
$5.50 +Cherry Blossom Ice Cream
Sweetly sublime cherry ice cream bursting with plump, dark Bordeaux cherries
$5.75 +Outrageous Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream
Creamy Cheesecake Ice Cream with Northwest Strawberries and a Graham Cracker Ripple.
$5.75 +Vanilla Ice Cream
$5.75 +Chocolate Ice Cream
$5.75 +Cookies and Cream Ice Cream
$5.75 +Strawberry Ice Cream
$5.75 +Green Mint Chip Ice Cream
$5.75 +Pistachio Ice Cream
$5.75 +Rum Raisin Ice Cream
$5.75 +Butter Pecan Ice Cream
$5.75 +Moose Track Ice Cream
$5.75 +Coffee Mud Pie Ice Cream
$5.75 +Birthday Cake Ice Cream
$5.75 +Matcha Green Tea
$5.75 +Fat Free NO Sugar Added Vanilla w/ Raspberry Ripple
Reduced fat butter pecan flavored ice cream with fresh roasted pecans and swirled with NSA fat free chocolate syrup
$5.50 +Wild Blueberry Ice Cream
Wild Maine blueberry flavored ice cream with a homemade blueberry ripple running throughout
$5.75 +Coconut Ice Cream
$5.75 +Milky Way Ice Cream
$5.75 +Frozen Yogurt
Sorbets
Famous Donut Ice Cream Sandwich
Flavored Frozen Treats
Medium Frozen Treat
$7.95 +Large Frozen Treat
$8.75 +Pint Frozen Treat
$9.95 +Quart Frozen Treat
$17.25 +Sundaes
Banana Split Sundae
Choose 2 flavors of ice cream. Four scoops of ice cream, sliced banana, chocolate syrup and cake crunch.
$9.50 +Famous Hot Fudge Sundae
Choose 2 flavors of ice cream.Four scoops of ice cream, famous hot fudge and cake crunch.
$9.50 +Holy Cream Surprise Sundae
Choose 2 flavors of ice cream. Four scoops of ice cream. Toppings are the chef's surprise.
$9.50 +Peanut Butter Cup Sundae
Choose 2 flavors of ice cream. Four scoops of ice cream, hot fudge, peanut butter sauce and Reese's peanut butter cups.
$9.50 +Make Your Own Sundae
Choose 2 flavors of ice cream. toppings of your choice. includes whipped cream.
$9.50 +Brownie Explosion Sundae
Choose 2 flavors of ice cream. Four scoops of ice cream, chocolate syrup and brownie chunks.
$9.50 +Beverages
Stock Up and Save Wednesdays
3 Pints Wednesday Special
$27.00 +Hot Fresh Hand-Dipped Donuts
Best Seller Dozen Assortment
One each of the following: Chocolate Lover's Assortment (Smores, Nutella, M&M, Oreo), Sprinkle Assortment (Rainbow, Hot Pink, Blue Bomb, Chocolate Rainbow), Candy Donuts Assortment (M&M, Oreo, Heath Bar, Reeses PB Cup)
$29.95Candy Donuts Assortment (M&M, Oreo, Heath Bar, Reeses PB Cup)
One each of the following four Donuts: M&M, Oreo, Heath Bar, Reeses PB Cup
$11.95Chocolate Lover's Assortment (Smores, Nutella, M&M, Oreo)
One each of the following 4 donuts: Smores, Nutella, M&M, Oreo
$11.95Sprinkle Assortment (Rainbow, Hot Pink, Blue Bomb, Chocolate Rainbow)
One each of the following 4 donuts: Rainbow, Hot Pink, Blue Bomb, Chocolate Rainbow
$11.504 Reeses Peanut Butter Cup Donuts
4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing, Reeses PB Cups, and a Chocolate Drizzle.
$11.954 Smores Donuts
4 Donuts with Chocolate Icing, Graham Cracker topping, and a Marshmallow Drizzle
$11.95Pint Tuesdays
Daily Specials
Three Jumbo Cookies Special
Choose any 3 cookies. Just type the 3 flavors that you would like in the special instructions box or receive 3 of our choice. Enjoy!
$8.75Pints Monday through Thursday
Choose one flavor per pint. Choosing additional flavors by using the special instructions box will result in an added charge per pint.
$9.00 +Delicious Brownies
3 Fudge Brownies
$9.75Caramel Chew Brownie
$3.50M&M Brownie
$3.50Oreo Brownie
$3.50S'mores Brownie
$3.50Fudge Brownie
$3.50Cupcakes
4 Cupcakes
Type the four flavor that you would like in the special instructions box or receive four of our choice.
$17.50Chocolate Cupcake
$4.50Red Velvet Cupcake
$4.50Jumbo Oreo Cupcake
$4.25Cookies
Milkshakes, Frappes and Ice Cream Soda
Milk Shake
$9.00 +Low-Fat Milk Shake
$9.00 +Malted Shake
$9.00 +Fat-Free Milk Shake
$9.00 +Ice Cream Soda
$7.75Holey Frappe
$7.75 +Fresh Fruit Smoothies
Banana Cream Pie Smoothie
Fat-free vanilla frozen yogurt blended with skim milk, banana and graham crack crumbs.
$9.00Berries & Cream Smoothie
Fat-free black raspberry frozen yogurt blended with cranberry juice, strawberries and banana.
$9.00Berry Cream Pie Smoothie
Fat free black raspberry frozen yogurt blended with skim milk, strawberries and graham cracker crumbs.
$9.00Cran-Pineapple Craze Smoothie
Raspberry sorbet blended with cranberry juice, pineapple chunks and banana.
$9.00Super Pom Smoothie
Raspberry sorbet blended with blueberry-pomegranate juice, pineapple, raspberries and banana.
$7.75