Holey Cream
MenuAbout
Holey Cream Menu

Holey Cream

Bakery, Dessert
791 9th Ave, New York, NY 10019
(212) 247-8400
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Popular menu items

Menu powered by Grubhub

Vanilla Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Moose Track Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Famous Hot Fudge Sundae

Choose 2 flavors of ice cream.Four scoops of ice cream, famous hot fudge and cake crunch.

$14.50 +

Ice Cream

HOLeY MOLeY Ice Cream

Vanilla ice cream loaded with M&M's, cookie dough and fudge.

$8.00 +

Muddy Boots Ice Cream

Creamy vanilla ice cream loaded with a rich caramel ripple and decadent brownie chunks

$8.00 +

S'mores

$8.00 +

Brownie a la Mode Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Sea Salt Caramel

$8.00 +

Outrageous Chocolate Peanut Butter Deluxe Ice Cream

$8.00 +

HOLeY Peanut Butter M&M Ice Cream

PB Ice Cream loaded with M&Ms, Choc Chunks and Oatmeal Cookies. Must Try!

$7.00 +

Irish Coffee

Made with Jameson!

$8.00 +

Outrageous Java Guatemala Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Outrageous Deep Belgian Chocolate Chip Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Cherry Blossom Ice Cream

Sweetly sublime cherry ice cream bursting with plump, dark Bordeaux cherries

$8.00 +

Outrageous Long Island Raspberry Rhapsody Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Outrageous Dulce de Leche Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Outrageous Caramel Pretzel Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Outrageous Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream

Creamy Cheesecake Ice Cream with Northwest Strawberries and a Graham Cracker Ripple.

$8.00 +

Vanilla Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Chocolate Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Cookies and Cream Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Strawberry Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Midnight Cookies and Cream Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Green Mint Chip Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Pistachio Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Rum Raisin Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Butter Pecan Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Butterscotch Praline Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Peanut Butter Crunch Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Moose Track Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Coffee Oreo Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Birthday Cake Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Hotel Black Bottom Pie Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Matcha Green Tea

$8.00 +

Fat Free NO Sugar Added Vanilla w/ Raspberry Ripple

Reduced fat butter pecan flavored ice cream with fresh roasted pecans and swirled with NSA fat free chocolate syrup

$7.00 +

Wild Blueberry Ice Cream

Wild Maine blueberry flavored ice cream with a homemade blueberry ripple running throughout

$8.00 +

Coconut Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Peanut Butter Oreo

$8.00 +

Milky Way Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Peanut Butter Caramel Cookie Dough Ice Cream

$8.00 +

Frozen Yogurt

Creamy Vanilla Fat Free Frozen Yogurt

$7.00 +

FAT FREE DUTCH CHOCOLATE YOGURT

$7.00 +

Chocolate Peanut Butter Frozen Yogurt

$8.00 +

Raspberry Chip Low Fat Frozen Yogurt

$7.00 +

Mint Chocolate Chip Low Fat Frozen Yogurt

$7.00 +

Cookies and Cream Low Fat Frozen Yogurt

$7.00 +

Chocolate Fat Free Frozen Yogurt

$7.00 +

Peanut Butter Twist Low Fat Frozen Yogurt

$7.00 +

Dutch Chocolate Frozen Yogurt (Fat Free)

$7.00 +

Sorbets

Raspberry Sorbet (Fat Free)

Perfectly ripe raspberry puree blended into a delicious sorbet.

$8.00 +

Mango Sorbet (Fat Free)

Juicy ripe tropical mango puree blended into a delicious sorbet.

$8.00 +

Lemon Sorbet (Fat Free)

Tart lemons blended into a delicious sorbet.

$8.00 +

Famous Donut Ice Cream Sandwich

Donut Ice Cream Sandwich

One donut icing, unlimited dry toppings and up to two ice creams.

$12.50

Flavored Frozen Treats

Medium Frozen Treat

$8.75 +

Large Frozen Treat

$12.75 +

Pint Frozen Treat

$14.00 +

Quart Frozen Treat

$22.00 +

Sundaes

Banana Split Sundae

Choose 2 flavors of ice cream. Four scoops of ice cream, sliced banana, chocolate syrup and cake crunch.

$14.50 +

Famous Hot Fudge Sundae

Choose 2 flavors of ice cream.Four scoops of ice cream, famous hot fudge and cake crunch.

$14.50 +

Holy Cream Surprise Sundae

Choose 2 flavors of ice cream. Four scoops of ice cream. Toppings are the chef's surprise.

$14.50 +

Peanut Butter Cup Sundae

Choose 2 flavors of ice cream. Four scoops of ice cream, hot fudge, peanut butter sauce and Reese's peanut butter cups.

$11.00 +

Make Your Own Sundae

Choose 2 flavors of ice cream. toppings of your choice. includes whipped cream.

$14.50 +

Brownie Explosion Sundae

Choose 2 flavors of ice cream. Four scoops of ice cream, chocolate syrup and brownie chunks.

$14.50 +

Beverages

Bottled Soda

$3.95

Fresh Lemonade

$2.75

Bottled Water

$2.75

PINT SPECIALS!!!

3 Pint Special

$29.50 +

Hot Fresh Hand-Dipped Donuts

Best Seller Dozen Assortment

One each of the following: Chocolate Lover's Assortment (Smores, Nutella, M&M, Oreo), Sprinkle Assortment (Rainbow, Hot Pink, Blue Bomb, Chocolate Rainbow), Candy Donuts Assortment (M&M, Oreo, Heath Bar, Reeses PB Cup)

$32.95

Sprinkle Dozen Assortment

4 Rainbow Donuts, 4 Hot Pink Donuts, 4 Blue Bomb Donuts

$31.95

Candy Donuts Assortment (M&M, Oreo, Heath Bar, Reeses PB Cup)

One each of the following four Donuts: M&M, Oreo, Heath Bar, Reeses PB Cup

$12.95

Chocolate Lover's Assortment (Smores, Nutella, M&M, Oreo)

One each of the following 4 donuts: Smores, Nutella, M&M, Oreo

$12.95

Sprinkle Assortment (Rainbow, Hot Pink, Blue Bomb, Chocolate Rainbow)

One each of the following 4 donuts: Rainbow, Hot Pink, Blue Bomb, Chocolate Rainbow

$11.95

Create Your Own Donut

$3.25

Cookies and Cream Donut

Vanilla icing, Oreo cookie topping and a dark chocolate drizzle.

$3.25

M&M Donut

Vanilla icing, mini M&M topping and a dark chocolate drizzle.

$3.25

Grasshopper Donut

Vanilla Icing with Andes Mint Topping

$3.25

Nutella Donut

Chocolate icing and Nutella filling.

$3.25

Rainbow Donut

Vanilla icing and rainbow sprinkles.

$3.00

Smores Donut

Chocolate icing, graham crack topping and marshmallow drizzle.

$3.25

Dirty Devil Donut

Vanilla icing and cake crunch topping.

$3.00

PB Cup Donut

Vanilla icing, Reese's peanut butter cups and a dark chocolate drizzle.

$3.25

Hot Pink Donut

Vanilla icing and hot pink sprinkles.

$3.00

Snowball Donut

Vanilla icing and white coconut flakes.

$3.00

Fruit Loop Donut

Strawberry icing and Fruit Loop topping.

$3.00

Gummie Bear Delight Donut

Vanilla icing and mini gummy bears.

$3.25

Heath Bar Donut

Vanilla icing and Heath bar topping.

$3.25

Blue Bomb Donut

Vanilla icing with fluorescent blue sprinkles.

$3.00

4 Rainbow Donuts

4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing and Rainbow Sprinkles.

$11.50

4 Chocolate Rainbow Donuts

4 Donuts with Chocolate Icing and Rainbow Sprinkles

$11.50

4 Hot Pink Donuts

4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing and Pink Sprinkles.

$11.50

4 Blue Bomb Donuts

4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing and Blue Sprinkles.

$11.50

4 Dirty Devil Donuts

4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing and Chocolate Crunchies

$11.50

4 Smowball Donuts

4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing and White Coconut Flakes.

$11.50

4 Cookies and Cream Donuts

4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing, Oreo Cookies, and a Chocolate Drizzle.

$11.95

4 Fruit Loop Donuts

4 Donuts with Fruit Loops and Strawberry Icing

$11.95

4 M&M Donuts

4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing, M&Ms, and a Chocolate Drizzle.

$11.95

4 Heath Bar Donuts

4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing, Heath Bar, and a Chocolate Drizzle.

$11.95

4 Reeses Peanut Butter Cup Donuts

4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing, Reeses PB Cups, and a Chocolate Drizzle.

$11.95

4 Smores Donuts

4 Donuts with Chocolate Icing, Graham Cracker topping, and a Marshmallow Drizzle

$11.95

4 Nutella Donuts

4 Chocolate Iced Donuts filled with Nutella.

$11.95

4 Grasshopper Donuts

4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing and Andes Mints

$11.95

4 Gummie Bear Donuts

4 Donuts with vanilla icing and Gummie Bears

$11.95

Delicious Brownies

3 Fudge Brownies

$13.75

Award Winning Brownies

$13.75

Caramel Chew Brownie

$3.75

M&M Brownie

$3.75

Reeses Brownie (Peanut Butter Cup)

$3.75

Oreo Brownie

$3.75

S'mores Brownie

$3.75

Fudge Brownie

$3.50

Cupcakes

Oreo Cookies and Cream Cupcake

$4.50

Vanilla Sprinkle Cupcake

$4.50

Chocolate Cupcake

$4.50

Red Velvet Cupcake

$4.50

Cookies

Three Jumbo Cookies

$9.75

Jumbo Chocolate Chip Cookie

$3.75

Jumbo Rainbow Sprinkle Cookie

$3.75

Jumbo Black and White Cookie

$3.75

Jumbo M&M Cookie

$3.75

Jumbo Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

$3.75

Milkshakes, Frappes and Ice Cream Soda

Milk Shake

$12.50 +

Low-Fat Milk Shake

$12.50 +

Malted Shake

$12.75 +

Fat-Free Milk Shake

$12.50 +

Ice Cream Soda

$12.75

Holey Frappe

$7.75 +

Fresh Fruit Smoothies

Banana Cream Pie Smoothie

Fat-free vanilla frozen yogurt blended with skim milk, banana and graham crack crumbs.

$10.50

Berries & Cream Smoothie

Fat-free black raspberry frozen yogurt blended with cranberry juice, strawberries and banana.

$10.50

Berry Cream Pie Smoothie

Fat free black raspberry frozen yogurt blended with skim milk, strawberries and graham cracker crumbs.

$10.50

Cran-Pineapple Craze Smoothie

Raspberry sorbet blended with cranberry juice, pineapple chunks and banana.

$10.50

Beach Breeze Smoothie

Mango sorbet blended with orange juice, pineapple chunks and banana.

$10.50

Mango Mania Smoothie

Mango sorbet blended with apple juice, mango and banana.

$10.50

Queen of Tarts Smoothie

Lemon sorbet blended with cranberry juice and raspberries.

$10.50

Razzo Mango Smoothie

Mango sorbet blended with apple juice, mangos and raspberry.

$10.50

Strawberry Lemonade Smoothie

Lemon sorbet blended with lemonade and strawberries.

$10.50

Super Pom Smoothie

Raspberry sorbet blended with blueberry-pomegranate juice, pineapple, raspberries and banana.

$7.75

Nutella Smoothie

Made with creamy vanilla fat free yogurt, fresh banana and Nutella.

$10.50
Restaurant closed
.

About Holey Cream

  • 791 9th Ave, New York, NY 10019
  • Bakery, Dessert, Dinner, Ice Cream, Kosher, Kosher-Style
  • (212) 247-8400
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / Holey Cream
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.