Island Burger & Shakes
MenuAbout
Island Burger & Shakes Menu

Island Burger & Shakes

Dinner, Hamburgers
422 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
(212) 877-7934
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Appetizers

Menu powered by Grubhub

Spicy Smothered IB Wings

$7.00 +

Corn on the Cob

Cotija cheese, mayo and chile spice.

$8.00

Grilled Asparagus

Parmigiano Reggiano and balsamic vinegar.

$7.00

Chili Works and Chips

Spicy chili, cheddar sour cream and onions.

$9.25

Guacamole and Chips

$9.25

Salsa and Chips

$9.25

Salsa, Guacamole and Chips

$10.75

Build Your Own

Build Your Own Burger

Served with lettuce, red onion and pickles on the side.

$10.95 +

Build Your Own Grilled Chicken Breast Burger

Served with lettuce, red onion and pickles on the side.

$10.95 +

Build Your Own Turkey Burger

Served with lettuce, red onion and pickles on the side.

$10.95 +

Decadent

Raoul's Burger

Au poivre, Swiss, mushrooms and ciabatta.

$16.95

Sam I Am Burger

Pesto, ham, American cheese and egg.

$16.95

Mona Lisa Burger

Mozzarella, pesto, sauteed onions, mushrooms, roasted peppers, Parmigiana and on ciabatta.

$15.95

Will's Burger

Bacon, cheddar, sour cream, sauteed onions and scallions on sourdough.

$15.95

Hippo Burger

Curried sour cream, bacon, cheddar, guacamole, sauteed onions, scallions and whole wheat pita.

$15.95

Hobie's Burger

Au poivre, bleu cheese, sauteed onions, bacon and sourdough.

$16.95

Hot

The Clyde Burger

Blackened, salsa, bleu, avocado and bacon.

$16.95

Bourbon Street Burger

Blackened, bacon, Jack, bayo mayo, sauteed onions and sourdough.

$15.95

Barzels Burger

Blackened, Jack, bacon, horseradish and ciabatta.

$15.95

Deluxe Chili Burger

Chili, white cheddar, sour cream, BBQ and sourdough.

$15.95

Duke's Burger

Blackened, Jack, jalapeno and sourdough.

$15.95

Napalm Burger

Blackened, BBQ, jalapeno, cheddar and habanero.

$15.95

Pepe's Burger

Blackened, Jack cheese, guacamole, bacon and sauteed onions.

$15.95

South of the Border Burger

Jack cheese, salsa, guacamole and jalapeno.

$15.95

Mild

Parmigiana Marinara Burger

Mozzarella and Parmesan on ciabatta.

$14.95

Boss' Bacon Burger

Jack, ranch and toasted rye.

$15.95

Patty Melt

Swiss, sauteed onions and toasted rye.

$13.95

The People's Choice Burger

Swiss, onion and mushrooms.

$13.95

Frog Boursin Burger

Bacon and sauteed onions.

$14.95

Route 66 Burger

Avocado, Swiss bacon and dark rye.

$15.95

Saratoga Burger

HSB sauce, bacon, cheddar and sourdough.

$15.95

The Derby Burger

Avocado, bleu and bacon.

$15.95

Here's Gianni Burger

Parmesan spread, roasted peppers, bacon and ciabatta.

$15.95

A Little Kick

Cowboy Burger

BBQ, bacon, sauteed onions, cheddar, ranch and sourdough.

$15.95

Black n' Blue Burger

Blackened and bleu cheese.

$14.95

Miss Hula Burger

Ham, Swiss, honey mustard and pineapple.

$15.95

Tijuana Burger

Bacon, Jack, guacamole and sauteed onions.

$15.95

Derrick's Burger

Blackened, pesto and Ciabatta.

$14.95

Honey West Burger

Ham, cheddar and honey mustard.

$14.95

Sandwiches

Mozzarella, Pesto, Tomato and Onion Sandwich

$11.00

Salsa, Jack Cheese, Guacamole and Jalapeno Sandwich

$10.50

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

$9.25

Guacamole, Bacon, Cheddar, Tomato and Onion Sandwich

$10.50

Grilled Ham and Swiss on Rye

$10.75

BLT Sandwich

$9.25

Fajitas

Chicken Fajitas

Sauteed onions, peppers, guacamole and salsa.

$15.25

Big Ass Fajitas

Chicken fajita with shredded cheddar, Acapulco sauce and sour cream.

$16.75

Small Salads

Pecan Crusted Goat Cheese Salad

Mixed greens, carrots, cranberries, honey and vinaigrette.

$11.00

Mixed Greens and Tomato Salad

$7.25

Small Caesar Salad

$8.25

Small Quinoa Salad

Black olives, tomatoes, cucumbers, onion, parsley and mint dressing.

$8.25

Small Kale Salad

Pumpkin seeds, tomatoes and pecorino vinaigrette.

$8.25

Main Course Salads

Caesar Salad

$12.00 +

Kale Salad

Baby kale, pumpkin seeds, tomatoes and Pecorino vinaigrette dressing.

$12.00 +

Pear Salad

Mesclun greens, walnuts, pear and Gorgonzola.

$12.00 +

Quinoa Salad

Quinoa, black olives, tomatoes, cucumbers, onion and mint dressing.

$12.00 +

Cabo San Lucas Salad

Mixed greens, cheddar, Jack cheese, salsa, guacamole, jalapeno, onions, roasted peppers and tortilla chips.

$12.00 +

Tommy's Phuket Salad

Mixed greens, avocado, roasted peppers, jalapeno, tomatoes, onions and mushrooms.

$12.00 +

Cobb Salad

Mixed greens, bacon, bleu cheese, avocado, egg and tomatoes.

$12.00 +

Boo Zoo Salad

Mixed greens, bacon, cheddar, tomatoes, onions, mushrooms and jalapeno.

$12.00 +

Tuscan Salad

Mixed greens, fresh mozzarella, onions, roasted peppers, olive, artichoke hearts, tomato and Parmigiano Reggiano.

$12.00 +

Sides

French Fries

$7.75 +

Sweet Potato Fries

$7.75 +

Classic Baked Potato

Butter, sour cream, cheddar, bacon and chives.

$7.00

Standard Baked Potato

With butter and sour cream.

$5.25

Onion Rings

$6.75

Beverages

Soda

Canned 12oz

$2.25

Honest Tea

$3.75

Arnold Palmer

$3.75

Apple Juice

Bottled 12oz

$3.75

From the Fountain

Malted Shake

Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, black and white.

$6.50

Milk Shake

Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, black and white.

$6.00

Ice Cream Float

Ice cream and soda of your choice.

$6.50
FYI, this restaurant is not accepting orders right now.

About Island Burger & Shakes

  • 422 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
  • Dinner, Hamburgers, Ice Cream, Lunch Specials, Salads, Sandwiches, Shakes
  • (212) 877-7934
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / Island Burger & Shakes
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.