Lilli's Bake Shop
Seasonal pies
Pumpkin pie slice
$5.50Pecan pie slice
$5.50Banana cream pie
$22.00 +Pumpkin pie
$22.00 +Pecan pie
$22.00 +Chocolate cream pecan pie
$22.00 +apple pie
$22.00 +strawberry Rhubarb pie
$22.00 +Mixed berries pie
$22.00 +Lemon meringue pie
$22.00 +Chocolate pudding cream pie
$22.00 +Flavors of the month
S'mores lava cookie
2 layers of s'mores cookies stuffed with marshmallows Graham crackers and Hershey kisses baked to perfection and drizzled with Hershey chocolate sauce
$7.50Nutella stuffed chocolate chip cookie dough
2 layers of gooey and buttery cookie dough stuffed with Generous amount off Nutella and loaded with Hershey chocolate kisses
$7.50Pumpkin spice cheesecake
$5.99Red velvet cheesecake
$5.99Turtle pumpkin pie cheesecake on a stick
Pumpkin New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in toasted pecans drizzled with caramel salted caramel then sprinkled with cinnamon and nutmeg
$10.50Mini gluten free Tiramisu
Alternating layers of espresso soaked gluten free sponge cake and mascarpone cream, finished with a dusting of cocoa powder Gluten Free
$6.25Snickers bar brownie
Chocolate chip fudge brownie dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate covered in Snickers bites drizzled with caramel salted caramel and sprinkled with sea salt
$9.99Mochachino cake slice
rich chocolate cake infused with espresso, accompanied by a fluffy mocha buttercream and topped with flourishes of meringue.
$6.99Red velvet cheesecake
Red velvet new York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in red velvet tasted cake crumbs topped with white chocolate chips and drizzled with red velvet white chocolate
$10.49Main Menu
1 Dozen Macaron Sampler
Fresh macaroons. If needed, enter desired quantity of flavors in special instructions.
$36.001 Dozen Traditional Assortment
A dozen traditional cupcakes, free of nut. Buttercup golden with vanilla buttercream, buttercup golden with chocolate buttercream, classic chocolate with vanilla buttercream, classic chocolate with chocolate buttercream, devil dog.
$42.00Cookie Lovers Platter
An assortment of a dozen cookie. Raspberry thumbprint, caramel chocolate chunks and triple chocolate.
$31.00Cheesecake on a stick creations
The exotic cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in coconut and drizzled with Brazilian condensed milk
$10.50Peanut butter Nutella cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate drizzled with Nutella and creamy peanut butter
$10.50The allergy shot cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate Rolled in crushed hazelnut and drizzled with Nutella
$10.50Snickers bar cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate Covered with snickers bites then drizzled with Carmel salted caramel age spring with sea salt
$10.50Oreo Nutella
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate Rolled in Oreo crumbs drizzled with Nutella and topped with whole Oreo
$10.50The campfire cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate Rolled in crushed Graham crackers and covered with homemade torched marshmallows and drizzled with Hershey chocolate syrup
$10.50Reese's cups cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate Rolled in crunched Reese's pieces topped with mini Reese's chocolate chips and drizzled with creamy Reese's peanut butter sauce
$10.50Triple chocolate cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate Topped with brownie bites rolled in chocolate sprinkles and drizzled with chocolate sauce
$10.50Dulce de leche cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate Drizzled with caramel and salted caramel then sprinkled with sea salt
$10.50Raspberry madness cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate Rolled in white chocolat chips topped with homemade raspberry jam then drizzled with white chocolate sauce
$10.50Oreo dream cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate Covered in crushed Oreo drizzled with homemade chocolate and white chocolate y
$10.50Peanut butter finger cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate Rolled in crushed Butterfinger and nutter butter crackers then drizzled with creamy peanut butter
$10.50Pecan pie cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in toasted pecan drizzled with caramel salted e age sprinkled with cinnamon
$10.50English Toffee cheesecake
New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate Covered in Heath English Toffee bites drizzled with caramel salted caramel and sprinkled with sea salt
$10.50Cheesecakes slices
Lili's cheesecake
A layer of chocolate chip brownie with a layer of smooth cheesecake topped with whole Oreo and covered with chocolate cookie dough
$9.19Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
New York style cheesecake studded with chocolate chips and covered with chocolate flakes, sits on a sponge cake base
$5.50Dulce De Leche Cheesecake
A cookie crust holds a velvety dulce de leche cheesecake, topped with dulce de leche mousse and chocolate shavings
$5.50Oreo cheesecake
$5.50Rainbow cheesecake
$5.50Giant stuffed cookies
S'mores lava cookie
2 layers of s'mores cookies stuffed with marshmallows Graham crackers and Hershey kisses baked to perfection and drizzled with Hershey chocolate sauce
$7.50Nutella stuffed cookie dough
2 layers of gooey and buttery cookie dough stuffed with Generous amount off Nutella and loaded with Hershey chocolate kisses
$7.50Cheesecake stuffed red velvet lava cookie
2 layers of white chocolate loaded red velvet cookies stuffed with our famous NY cheesecake and more white chocolate chips and drizzled with white chocolate sauce
$7.50Peanut butter overload lava cookie
2 layers of PB chocolate chip cookies stuffed with generous amount of creamy peanut baked to perfection drizzled with PB sauce and sprinkled with crushed peanuts
$7.50Organic PB brownie overload
A giant gooey Chocolate Chip brownie topped with organic smooth peanut butter and covered with chocolate ganache... This meant to be shared
$7.50Giant Cookies
The Bestest Cookie
$3.99Triple Chocolate Cookie
Chocolate pudding cookie made with Valrhona cocoa powder and chocolate chunks.
$2.50Caramel Chocolate Chunk Cookie
Ooey gooey caramel loaded with chocolate chunks and sprinkled with sea salt.
$2.99Triple Chocolate Fudge Pudding Cookie
Chocolate pudding cookie made with Valrhona cocoa powder and chocolate chunks.
$2.50St patricks cookie
Hand made to perfection cookie .. check out IG @buttercup_timessquar for different styles
$7.50Giant s'mores cookie
$3.99Edible cookie dough
Bars and Squares
Lili's bar
Chocolate chip cookie dough crust topped with whole Oreo and covered with Gooey chocolate chip brownies
$5.50Oreo cheesecake brownie bar
Chocolate chip Brownie crust topped with whole Oreos and covered with smooth cheesecake
$4.99Brookie bar
Chocolate chip cookie dough topped with chocolate chip brownie and a whole lot it chocolate chips
$4.50Reese's peanut butter bar
Chocolate chip brownie wiped with Reese's peanut sauce mixed and topped with Reese's peanut pieces
$4.50Italian cannoli
Small cannoli
A tube-shaped shells filled with chocolate chips ricotta cream topped with powdered sugar
$2.50Large cannoli
A tube-shaped shells filled with chocolate chips ricotta cream topped with powdered sugar
$3.50Chocolate dipped large cannoli
A tube-shaped shells filled with chocolate chips ricotta cream topped with powdered sugar
$4.50Macarons
One Macaron
Fresh macarons. Salted caramel, pistachio, lemon, chocolate, vanilla, coconut, autumn blossom, blueberry, cake batter, cappuccino, chocolate mint, cookie dough, dulce de leche, green tea, lavender, marshmallow, Nutella, Oreo, passion fruit, pumpkin, raspberry, red velvet, rose water, strawberry, strawberry shortcake and tiramisu.
$3.006 macarons
A dozen of our top selling flavors or you can choose your flavor. If needed, enter desired quantity of flavors in special instructions.
$18.001 Dozen Assorted Macarons
A dozen of our top selling flavors or you can choose your flavor. If needed, enter desired quantity of flavors in special instructions.
$36.001 Dozen Macaron Sampler
Fresh macaroons. If needed, enter desired quantity of flavors in special instructions.
$36.00Traditional cupcakes
Dozen of assorted traditional cupcakes
Vanilla chocolate red velvet lemon and devil dog cupcakes
$42.00Specialty cupcake
S'mores cupcake
$3.99Twinkie cupcake
$3.99Strawberry cupcake
Strawberry cake stuffed with strawberry jam and iced with white chocolate cream cheese
$4.00Signature Glass collection
Coppa 3 Chocolates
Delicious combination of silky dark, milk and white chocolate creams with a layer of hazelnut crunch, presented in an elegant glass
$6.25Creme Brulee & Berries
A layer of raspberry sauce topped with a creamy custard and decorated with mixed berries coated in caramel
$6.25Tiramisu Cup
Coffee and Zabaione cream on a layer of sponge cake soaked in espresso, dusted with cocoa powder.
$6.25Gluten-Free
Gluten-Free Mini Red Velvet Cake
Alternating layers of gluten-free red-hued chocolate sponge cake and cream cheese icing topped with gluten-free cake crumbs.
$6.99Gluten-Free Mini Carrot Cake
Alternating layers of gluten-free carrot cake spiced with cinnamon, chopped walnuts and pineapple and a smooth cream cheese icing finished with white chocolate curls.
$6.99Gluten-Free Mini Chocolate Cake
Alternating layers of gluten-free chocolate sponge cake and chocolate and vanilla creams topped with shaved chocolate and a chocolate square.
$6.99Cake by the Slice
Red Velvet Cake Slice
3 Layers of red velvet cake covered in our signature Cream cheese frosting
$6.95Chocolate cake with vanilla Buttercream
Layers of vanilla cake stuffed and covered with delicious creamy chocolate buttercream
$6.95German chocolate cake
A massive 3 layers of german chocolate cake stuffed and topped with coconut and pecan filling
$8.50Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Slice
Layers of dark chocolate cake stuffed and covered with smooth peanut butter butter cream.
$7.50PB & J Slice
$6.95Red velvet cake
$7.50Chocolate Cake Slice
Silky smooth chocolate buttercream between and covered our famous chocolate sponge cake.
$6.95A lemony cake with fresh lemon zest, and lemon buttercream.
A lemony cake with fresh lemon zest, and lemon buttercream.
$6.95Mochachino cake slice
rich chocolate cake infused with espresso, accompanied by a fluffy mocha buttercream and topped with flourishes of meringue.
$6.99Layer Cakes (24hrs NOTICE REQUIRED)
Vanilla Lover 7" Two Layers Cake
Layers of vanilla cakes covered and stuffed with vanilla buttercream. Requires 24 hour notice.
$39.00Vanilla Lover 9" Two Layers Cake
Vanilla cake stuffed and covered with vanilla buttercream. Requires 24 hour notice.
$55.00Chocolate 7" Two Layers Cake
Chocolate cake stuffed and covered with chocolate buttercream. Requires 24 hour notice.
$39.009" Chocolate Cake
Chocolate cake stuffed and covered with chocolate buttercream. Requires 24 hour notice.
$55.00Red Velvet Cake
Yellow cake with a hint of cocoa, dyed a deep beautiful red (tastes like a light chocolate cake). Frosted with cream cheese frosting between layers and on top. Inscription available. Requires 24 hour notice.
$38.00 +Red Velvet 9" Three Layers Cake
Our famous red velvet cake paired with our signature cream cheese makes a perfect smooth combination. Requires 24 hour notice.
$62.00Dulce de Leche (Salted Caramel) 9” Two Layers Cake
Dulce de leche swirled cake with salted caramel buttercream..yummm. Requires 24 hour notice.
$55.00Classic vanilla Layer Cake with Chocolate Icing
A “not so standard” chocolate cake and our most popular choice for birthdays. Inscription available. Requires 24 hour notice.
$32.00 +Classic Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Icing & Rainbow Sprinkles
A chocolate cake made moist with buttermilk and sour cream. Inscription available. Requires 24 hour notice.
$32.00 +Apple Walnut Cake
A moisty, fruity cake made with apples, whole wheat flour, walnuts, and caramel cream cheese frosting with caramel swirled on top. Requires 24 hour notice.
$34.00 +Coconut Cake
Our buttercup golden cake with coconut filling between the layers and meringue frosting on the outside, topped with shredded coconut. Inscription available. Requires 24 hour notice.
$38.00 +Carrot Cake
Made with fresh carrots, apples, and pecans, frosted with cream cheese frosting (iced in between layers and on top). Inscription available. Requires 24 hour notice.
$38.00 +Mochaccino Cake
A rich chocolate cake infused with espresso, accompanied by a fluffy mocha buttercream and topped with flourishes of meringue. Inscription available. Requires 24 hour notice.
$38.00 +Lemon Cake
A lemony cake with fresh lemon zest, and lemon buttercream. Inscription available. Requires 24 hour notice.
$38.00 +German Chocolate Cake
A light, sweet chocolate cake iced with coconut pecan filling in between the layers and on top. Inscription available. Requires 24 hour notice.
$38.00 +Peanut Butter and Jelly Cake
Reminiscent of childhood, this peanutty yellow cake is topped with peanut butter icing and filled with pockets of yummy fruit jelly. Inscription available. Requires 24 hour notice.
$38.00 +Full Sheet Cake
Requires 24 hour notice. Serves 60-80+. Additional fees may apply depending on flavor.
$345.00Pies
Apple crumble pie 3"
$4.006" Apple crumb pie
$13.0010" Apple crumb pie
$26.003" Pumpkin pie
$4.006" pumpkin pie
$13.0010" pumpkin pie
$26.003" Bourbon pecan pie
$4.006" Bourbon pecan pie
$13.0010" Bourbon pecan pie
$26.00Triple berry pie 3"
$4.003" Pecan pie
$4.003" Mini Pies
Enter desired quantity of each pie in special instructions. Requires 24 hour notice. (Pumpkin, blueberry lemonade, strawberry rhubarb, apple crumble, pecan)
$3.506" Pie
Requires 24 hour notice. (Pumpkin, blueberry lemonade, strawberry rhubarb, apple crumble, pecan)
$10.009" Pie
Requires 24 hour notice. (Pumpkin, blueberry lemonade, strawberry rhubarb, apple crumble, pecan)
$24.00