Molly's Cupcakes
Assorted Cupcakes
Assortment of 6 Mollys & 6 Centerfilled
An assortment of 6 classic Molly cupcakes and 6 Centerfilled cupcakes
$46.75Best Seller Box
A box of our four most popular cupcakes and a personalized notecard! Includes the Ron Bennington, Cookie Monster, Cake Batter, and a Red Velvet with Buttercream frosting and sprinkles, plus a notecard. Please write in the special instructions your message - a friendly reminder we will write UP TO 15 WORDS ONLY. Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions section.
$19.00Chocolate Lover's Box
An assortment of some of our best chocolate-based centerfilled cupcakes including Chocolate Decadence, Molten Flourless Chocolate, Cookies & Cream, and Ron Bennington.
$19.00 +Birthday Box - Centerfilled
An assortment of some of our best-selling centerfilled cupcakes: half Cake Batter with plastic Happy Birthday! toothpicks and half of our Cookie Monster cupcakes. Includes personalized notecard - leave message in the special instructions. Up to 15 words (these are small and handwritten! Thank you!). Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions.
$21.50 +Birthday Box - Classics
Classic cupcakes of your choice with pastel confetti sprinkles, half of them adorned with plastic Happy Birthday! toothpicks. Comes with our most popular frostings - does not include cream cheese* (*temperature sensitive*) unless specified in special instructions. Includes personalized notecard - leave message in the special instructions. Up to 15 words (these are small and handwritten! Thank you!). Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions.
$17.10 +It's a Baby! Box
Includes our centerfilled Cake Batter (sky blue frosting!), centerfilled White Chocolate Raspberry (raspberry buttercream is pink!), and classic cupcakes of your choice topped with multicolored pastel confetti sprinkles. Includes personalized notecard - leave message in the special instructions. Up to 15 words (these are small and handwritten! Thank you!). Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions.
$16.80 +It's a Girl! Box
Half of our centerfilled White Chocolate Raspberry (raspberry buttercream is pink!) and half classic cupcakes of your choice. Includes personalized notecard - leave message in the special instructions. Up to 15 words (these are small and handwritten! Thank you!). Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions.
$16.80 +It's a Boy! Box
Half centerfilled Cake Batter (has sky blue frosting!) and half classic cupcakes of your choice. Includes personalized notecard - leave message in the special instructions. Up to 15 words (these are small and handwritten! Thank you!). Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions.
$16.80 +Lucky Box of 4 *AVAILABLE THROUGH 3/18*
*AVAILABLE THROUGH 3/18 ONLY* 4-pack cupcake box including Chocolate with Buttercream frosting topped with gold and shamrock sprinkles and a gold chocolate coin, Vanilla with Chocolate frosting and shamrock sprinkles, Salted Butterscotch Caramel, seasonal flavor Key Lime Pie, and a notecard.
$16.00Easter Box of 4
*AVAILABLE THROUGH 4/1 ONLY* 4-pack cupcake box including Chocolate with Buttercream frosting topped with pastel pearl sprinkles, Vanilla with Chocolate frosting topped with milk chocolate eggs, White Chocolate Raspberry, seasonal flavor Key Lime Pie, and a notecard.
$16.00Mother's Day Box of 4
Available 5/8 - 5/12. Celebrate mom with a box of the best! Comes with a classic vanilla cupcake with chocolate frosting and spring-themed sprinkles, a red velvet with buttercream and spring-themed sprinkles, centerfilled White Chocolate Raspberry, our seasonal Strawberry Shortcake (refrigeration required), and a notecard. Please write your message in the special instruction - we can fit up to 15 words! If there isn't a message, we won't include the card unless requested otherwise.
$16.00Valentine's Box
A box of 4 cupcakes including White Chocolate Raspberry, Flourless Molten, Red Velvet Lava, and a classic Red Velvet with Vanilla frosting topped with heart sprinkles. Includes a notecard.
$19.50The Lucky Box
A box of 4 cupcakes including seasonal Lucky Charms, seasonal Key Lime Pie, Butterscotch Caramel, and a classic Chocolate with Vanilla frosting topped with shamrock sprinkles and a gold chocolate coin.
$18.50Center Filled Cupcakes
Chocolate and Peanut Butter (The Ron Bennington)
A Cupcake Wars Winner! Chocolate cake filled with peanut butter, frosted with chocolate ganache and topped with crushed Butterfinger!
$4.75Very Vanilla!
Vanilla cake filled with diplomat cream frosted with French vanilla buttercream topper with a vanilla wafer cookie.
$4.75Triple Chocolate
Rich chocolate choco-chip cake, filled with a creamy chocolate pudding, topped with chocolate ganache buttercream, and sprinkled with chocolate curls. A chocolate lover's dream!
$4.75White Chocolate Raspberry
Vanilla-raspberry cake, filled with white chocolate mousse, topped with raspberry buttercream, and sprinkled with white chocolate curls
$4.75Cookies-N-Cream
Chocolate cake filled with cookies-'n-cream mousse, topped with vanilla buttercream and a mini Oreo cookie
$4.75Salted Caramel Butterscotch
Vanilla caramel cake filled with butterscotch pudding, topped with a salted vanilla buttercream and drizzled with housemade caramel sauce
$4.75Peanut Butter Nutella
Peanut butter cake filled with Nutella, topped with Nutella buttercream and dusted with cocoa powder
$4.75Cookie Monster
Vanilla chocolate-chip cake, filled with safe cookie dough, topped with vanilla buttercream, and garnished with a mini chocolate chip cookie
$4.75Cake Batter
Vanilla funfetti cake, filled with safe cake batter, frosted with colorful buttercream and topped with rainbow sprinkles! NOTE: Most often this frosting is sky blue--occasionally we switch it up. If you need this cupcake to be blue, write it in the special instructions. No other color requests will be fulfilled.
$4.75Flourless Molten Chocolate *Gluten-Friendly
Flourless chocolate cake filled with dulce de leche ganache, topped with a French vanilla buttercream, and drizzled with chocolate sauce. NOTE: This is "gluten-friendly:" not made with gluten, but prepared in a shared kitchen.
$4.75Chocolate Mousse
Chocolate cake filled with chocolate mousse, topped with chocolate ganache and chocolate curls
$4.75Samoa
Vanilla cake with a caramel filling; topped with buttercream, chocolate and caramel drizzle, and a homemade shortbread cookie
$4.75Creme Brulee *requires refrigeration
Vanilla cake filled with classic creme brulee custard, topped with flambeed sugar and fresh berries. NOTE: *requires refrigeration
$4.75Peach Cobbler *requires refrigeration
A Cupcake Wars Winner! Vanilla brown sugar streusel cake filled with a cinnamon peach puree; topped with homemade whipped cream, cinnamon, and a sliced peach. NOTE: *requires refrigeration
$4.75Blueberry Cheesecake *requires refrigeration
Vanilla blueberry cake topped with cream cheese pastry cream mix, homemade graham cracker, and fresh blueberries *requires refrigeration
$4.75LAST DAY 7/31: Seasonal Centerfilled: S'mores
Graham cracker cake filled with milk chocolate ganache topped with toasted marshmallow and a mini Hershey bar
$4.75LAST DAY 4/30 - Seasonal Centerfilled: Lemon Strawberry
Vanilla cake with strawberry filling topped with lemon buttercream and strawberry sugar
$4.75Boston Cream - Seasonal LAST DAY 12/31
Vanilla cake filled with pastry cream dipped and frosted with chocolate ganache, and topped with white chocolate curls.
$4.75Passionfruit: AVAILABLE UNTIL 6/30
Passionfruit: Orange zest cake filled with blackberry puree topped with passionfruit buttercream and a fresh blackberry.
$4.75LAST DAY 7/31: Seasonal Centerfilled: Lemon Meringue
Lemon cake filled with lemon curd and topped with toasted meringue
$4.75Candy Bar: Last Day 9/30!
Vanilla cake with caramel peanut filling. Crunchy peanut butter frosting dipped in a chocolate shell. Only around for a limited time!
$4.75Pecan Pie - Seasonal LAST DAY 11/30
Brown sugar cake with pecan pieces baked in, filled with pecan pie filling topped with brown sugar buttercream and a candied pecan
$4.75Tiramisu *requires refrigeration - Seasonal LAST DAY 1/31
Coffee-soaked vanilla cake filled with mascarpone topped with whipped cream and a dusting of cocoa powder *Must stay cold!*
$4.75Last Day 2/28: Seasonal Centerfilled: Muddy Buddy
Last Day Available 2/28: Chocolate cake with a puppy chow filling (cereal, peanut butter, chocolate, powdered sugar) topped with peanut butter buttercream, puppy chow, and a dusting of powdered sugar
$4.75Last Day 2/28: Seasonal Centerfilled: Maple Crumb Cake
Last Day Available 2/28: Sour cream cake with cake crumbs baked in with a creamy cinnamon filling topped with maple buttercream and cake crumbs
$4.75LAST DAY 3/31: Seasonal Centerfilled: Mint Chocolate Chip
Chocolate cake with a creamy mint chip filling topped with mint buttercream and chocolate chips
$4.75Mixed Berry: Last Day 8/30!
Vanilla cake filled with a mixed berry puree topped with buttercream and fresh berries
$4.75Seasonal Centerfilled: Cherry Velvet
Red velvet chocolate cake filled with cherry puree topped with black cherry buttercream and fresh cherry
$4.75Seasonal Centerfilled: German Chocolate
Chocolate cake filled with coconut pecan filling, topped with ganache and pecans.
$4.75LAST DAY 2/28- Seasonal Centerfilled: Chocolate Raspberry
Last day available is 2/28! Chocolate cake filled with raspberry puree topped with chocolate buttercream and a fresh raspberry
$4.75LAST DAY 6/30: Strawberry Shortcake
Rich vanilla cake filled with luscious strawberry filling, topped with french buttercream and a fresh red strawberry.
$4.75Choco-ccino: Last Day 8/30!
This riff on our classic chocolate cake, filled with coffee ganache and topped with espresso buttercream, is bound to perk up your day. Our Choco-ccino is also topped with chocolate espresso beans.
$4.75AVAILABLE UNTIL 9/30: Muddy Buddy
A milk chocolate cake with puppy chow filling, topped with peanut butter buttercream and puppy chow with powdered sugar
$4.75Key Lime Pie - Seasonal LAST DAY 4/30
Vanilla cake with graham base filled with lime curd and topped with lime buttercream.
$4.75Strawberry Shortcake - Seasonal LAST DAY 4/30 *keep cold*
Vanilla cake filled with strawberry filling, topped with whipped cream swirl and strawberry shortcake crumbles.
$4.75Raspberry Lemon - LAST DAY 4/30
A lemon cake filled with raspberry puree at the bottom and lemon curd at the top, topped with a buttercream swirl and a pink white chocolate drizzle.
$4.75Seasonal Centerfilled: Apple Pie - Last Day 10/31 *KEEP COLD*
*KEEP COLD!* Cinnamon cake with an apple pie filling topped with whipped cream, caramel drizzle, and cinnamon streusel. Last day available: October 31st!
$4.75Seasonal Centerfilled: Pumpkin Spice - Last Day 10/31 *KEEP COLD*
*KEEP COLD!* Pumpkin cake filled with a creamy mascarpone filling and topped with a cinnamon buttercream swirl.
$4.75Dulce De Leche Churro
Vanilla cinnamon cake, filled with dulce de leche mousse, topped with caramel buttercream, cinnamon sugar sprinkle, caramel drizzle, and a mini churro.
$4.75Red Velvet Lava
Red Velvet cupcake dipped in ganache, filled with dulce ganache and topped with french vanilla buttercream, a ganache drizzle, and red velvet crumbles.
$4.75Lemon Drop - Seasonal LAST DAY 2/28
Vanilla cake, lemon curd filling, sugar "rim", buttercream frosting, and topped with a candied lemon slice.
$4.75Cherry Chocolate - Seasonal LAST DAY 2/28
Red velvet cake with a vanilla cake swirl, cherry chocolate mousse filling, white buttercream frosting, topped with a ganache drizzle and a maraschino cherry.
$4.75Strawberry Bubbles *requires refrigeration - Seasonal LAST DAY 2/28
Vanilla cake with a strawberry puree filling, champagne whipped cream swirl, topped with heart sprinkles.
$4.75Lucky Charms - Seasonal LAST DAY 3/31
Vanilla cake dyed green, cereal milk pastry cream filling, rainbow buttercream swirl, gold sprinkles.
$4.75Dubai Chocolate - Seasonal LAST DAY 4/30
Chocolate cake, white chocolate pistachio mousse filling, pistachio buttercream, raspberry drizzle, topped with kataifi pistachio crumbles.
$4.75Classic Cupcakes
Vegan Vanilla
Please note: these are made in a shared kitchen with all of our other products. If you have an allergy/intolerance, there is a chance for cross-contact! For same day orders: we do not bake many of these - please call us at 773-883-7220 before placing an order for 3+ does not come with sprinkles unless requested - no dairy/eggs but may contain gelatin.
$3.65Vegan Chocolate
Please note: these are made in a shared kitchen with all of our other products. If you have an allergy/intolerance, there is a chance for cross-contact! For same day orders: we do not bake many of these - please call us at 773-883-7220 before placing an order for 3+ does not come with sprinkles unless requested - no dairy/eggs but may contain gelatin.
$3.65Vegan Red Velvet
Please note: these are made in a shared kitchen with all of our other products. If you have an allergy/intolerance, there is a chance for cross-contact! For same day orders: we do not bake many of these - please call us at 773-883-7220 before placing an order for 3+ does not come with sprinkles unless requested - no dairy/eggs but may contain gelatin.
$3.65Cookies
Sugar Sprinkle
$3.50Peanut Butter Cookie
$3.50Bars
Extra Treats
Cake Pop
A cake pop dipped in chocolate and topped with sprinkles. *chocolate cake pops dipped in milk chocolate, vanilla and red velvet cake pops dipped in white chocolate
$3.00Mini Cheesecake
$5.50Festive Add-Ons
Note Card
Include a festive note card! UP TO 15 WORDS (these are SMALL and handwritten! Thank you!)
$1.00Beverages
Valentine's Day - Available 2/8 - 2/15
*Available 2/8 - 2/15 only!* Valentine's Lover's Box
*Available 2/8 - 2/15 only!* Our Valentine's Day box is back! It includes three centerfilled cupcakes: White Chocolate Raspberry, Strawberry Champagne, and Red Velvet Lava and a classic Mollys chocolate with buttercream frosting topped with heart sprinkles. Notecard included.
$16.00Valentine's Chocolate Lovers Box
*Available 2/12 - 2/14 only!* Our Valentine's Day Chocolate Lover Box is back! Includes two centerfilled cupcakes, Chocolate Mousse and seasonal Chocolate Raspberry, plus two chocolate/chocolate classic Mollys with heart sprinkles and fondant LOVE toppers. Box adorned with custom Molly's notecard and small bow. Include your message for the box in the special instructions.
$17.00Pink Ombre Molly Dozen
*These are only available 2/12 - 2/15. Orders placed outside of these dates are subject to cancellation.* Valentine's dozen box filled with an assortment of vanilla, chocolate, and red velvet cakes topped with pink ombre vanilla and buttercream frostings and festive Valentine's sprinkles
$37.00Valentine's Notecard
*Available 2/12 - 2/14 only!* Orders placed outside of these dates are subject to cancellation. Don't leave your Valentine's hanging - let them know who their delivery is from with a personalized Molly's logo notecard with cute red and white striped bow. Please leave your message in the special instructions.
$1.00Strawberry Champagne
Vanilla cake filled with strawberry puree topped with champagne whipped cream and heart sprinkles
$3.90Mixed Berry
*Available 2/12 - 2/14 only!* Vanilla cake with blueberries baked in filled with a mixed berry puree topped with buttercream and fresh berries
$3.90Chocolate Raspberry
*Available 2/12 - 2/14 only!* Chocolate cake filled with raspberry puree topped with chocolate buttercream and a fresh raspberry
$3.90PRE ORDER BY 2/10! Chocolate Truffle Box Available 2/12-2/14 only
*Available 2/12 - 2/14 only!* Hand made assortment of four chocolate truffles filled with: strawberry champagne caramel chocolate mousse
$9.00Molly's Market
Face Mask
A perfect gift idea. Handmade exclusively for us by @masksandmasks Double stitched quilters cotton. Pleated and revisable with elastic ear loops. Mask sold by Molly's Cupcakes are not medical-grade. Molly's cannot make medical or health claims. Check out the CDC website for guidance on masks if you have any questions.
$11.99Crew Neck Shirt
Available in XS-L White t-shirt with Molly's logo and blue collar and sleeve piping Measurements are estimates and taken with shirt laying flat! Chest measurement taken from seam to seam under sleeves, length measurement taken from top of back collar to base. Extra Small: chest 17", length 24" Small: chest 17.5", length 24.5" Medium: chest 18", length 25" Large: chest 19.5", length 25.5"
$21.00V Neck Shirt
Available in XS-L White t-shirt with Molly'ss logo, blue sleeves, and brown collar and sleeve piping. Measurements are estimates and taken with shirt laying flat! Chest measurement taken from seam to seam under sleeves, length measurement taken from top of back collar to base. Extra Small: chest 17.5", length 25" Small: chest 19", length 25" Medium: chest 19.5", length 26" Large: chest 20.5", length 27"
$21.00