Molly's Cupcakes
Assorted Cupcakes
12 Assorted Centerfilled
An assortment of our specialty centerfilled cupcakes. These are what we're most known for!
$52.2512 Assorted Mollys
An assortment of our classic Molly cupcakes topped with or without sprinkles. Sprinkles may vary.
$41.254 Mini Assorted Dot Cupcakes
A 4-pack of our mini assorted cupcakes with assorted frosting dipped in colorful dot sprinkles.
$9.0012 Assorted Minis
An assortment of our classic mini Molly cupcakes topped with or without sprinkles. Sprinkles may vary.
$27.0024 Assorted Minis
An assortment of our classic mini Molly cupcakes topped with or without sprinkles. Sprinkles may vary.
$51.504 Assorted Mini Cupcakes
An assortment of our classic mini Molly cupcakes topped with or without sprinkles. Sprinkles may vary.
$9.00Best Seller Box
A box of our four most popular cupcakes and a personalized notecard! Includes the Ron Bennington, Cookie Monster, Cake Batter, and a Red Velvet with Buttercream frosting and sprinkles, plus a notecard. Please write in the special instructions your message - a friendly reminder we will write UP TO 15 WORDS ONLY. Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions
$19.00Birthday Box - Centerfilled
An assortment of some of our best-selling centerfilled cupcakes: half Cake Batter with plastic Happy Birthday! Toothpicks and half of our Cookie Monster cupcakes. Includes personalized notecard - leave message in the special instructions. Up to 15 words (these are small and handwritten! Thank you!). Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions
$21.50 +Birthday Box - Classics
Classic cupcakes of your choice with pastel confetti sprinkles, half of them adorned with plastic Happy Birthday! Toothpicks. Comes with our most popular frostings - does not include cream cheese* (*temperature sensitive*) unless specified in special instructions. Includes personalized notecard - leave message in the special instructions. Up to 15 words (these are small and handwritten! Thank you!). Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions
$17.50 +Chocolate Lover's Box
An assortment of some of our best chocolate-based centerfilled cupcakes including Chocolate Decadence, Molten Flourless Chocolate, Cookies & Cream, and Ron Bennington
$19.00 +Graduation Box
Classic cupcakes of your choice topped with sprinkles in school colors and plastic graduation cap toppers. Comes with our most popular frostings - does not include cream cheese* (*temperature sensitive*) unless specified in special instructions
$18.00 +It's a Baby! Box
Includes our centerfilled Cake Batter (sky blue frosting!), centerfilled White Chocolate Raspberry (raspberry buttercream is pink!), and classic cupcakes of your choice topped with multicolored pastel confetti sprinkles. Includes personalized notecard - leave message in the special instructions. Up to 15 words (these are small and handwritten! Thank you!). Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions
$18.00 +It's a Boy! Box
Half centerfilled Cake Batter (has sky blue frosting!) and half classic cupcakes of your choice. Includes personalized notecard - leave message in the special instructions. Up to 15 words (these are small and handwritten! Thank you!). Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions
$18.00 +It's a Girl! Box
Half of our centerfilled White Chocolate Raspberry (raspberry buttercream is pink!) and half classic cupcakes of your choice. Includes personalized notecard - leave message in the special instructions. Up to 15 words (these are small and handwritten! Thank you!). Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions
$18.00 +Centerfilled Cupcakes
Blueberry Cheesecake *Keep Cold*
Vanilla cake with blueberries and cheesecake baked in, homemade graham cracker pieces, cream cheese frosting mixed with pastry cream, glazed sugared blueberries. Requires refrigeration. *Filling is on top of cupcake instead of inside cupcake
$4.75 +Cake Batter
Vanilla funfetti cake, raw cake batter filling, blue buttercream, rainbow sprinkles
$4.75 +Chocolate Decadence
Chocolate cake, chocolate mousse filling, chocolate ganache, chocolate curls
$4.75 +Cookie Monster
Vanilla chocolate chip cake, raw cookie dough center, buttercream, mini chocolate chips, and a mini chocolate chip cookie
$4.75 +Cr��me Br��l��e *Keep Cold*
Vanilla cake, classic cr��me br��l��e custard, caramelized sugar, glazed berries. Required refrigeration
$4.75 +Molten Chocolate
Flourless chocolate cake, dulce de leche ganache filling, french vanilla buttercream, and chocolate drizzle. *Baked in a shared kitchen with items containing gluten*
$4.75 +Peach Cobbler *keep cold*
Vanilla streusel cake, cinnamon peach puree filling, homemade whipped cream, cinnamon dusting, peach slice. Requires refrigeration.
$4.75 +Peanut Butter Nutella��
Peanut butter cake, Nutella�� filling, Nutella�� buttercream frosting, and dusting of cocoa powder
$4.75 +Red Velvet Lava
Red Velvet cake, dulce ganache filling, french vanilla buttercream, ganache drizzle, red velvet cake crumbles
$4.75 +Ron Bennington
Chocolate cake, peanut butter filling, chocolate ganache, and crushed butterscotch topping
$4.75 +Salted Butterscotch Caramel
Vanilla cake, butterscotch caramel pudding, salted buttercream, and caramel drizzle
$4.75 +Samoa
Vanilla cake, coconut caramel filling, caramel buttercream, toasted coconut, shortbread cookie, and chocolate and caramel drizzle
$4.75 +White Chocolate Raspberry
Vanilla cake with raspberries baked in, white chocolate mousse filling, raspberry buttercream frosting, topped with a fresh raspberry and white chocolate curls
$4.75 +Strawberry Shortcake
Vanilla cake, cooked strawberry puree, buttercream swirl, strawberry shortcake crumble.
$4.75 +Biscoff Cookie - Seasonal LAST DAY 7/31
Vanilla cake, Biscoff cream filling, Biscoff buttercream, topped with Biscoff infused caramel drizzle and a Biscoff cookie.
$4.75 +Lemon Meringue *keep cold* - Seasonal LAST DAY 7/31
Vanilla cake filled with lemon curd, topped with toasted meringue.
$4.75 +S'mores - Seasonal LAST DAY 7/31
Graham cake, milk chocolate ganache filling, toasted marshmallow, chocolate square.
$4.75 +Cookies
Peanut Butter Cookie
$3.50Bars
Treats
Cake Pops
Vanilla, chocolate, or red velvet cake ball dipped in chocolate and decorated with either sprinkles or chocolate drizzle
$3.25Festive Add Ons
Beverages
Classic Molly Cupcakes
Banana Cupcake
Standard-sized classic Molly cupcake. Comes with your choice of frosting and sprinkles. Sprinkles may vary.
$3.75Carrot Cupcake
Standard-sized classic Molly cupcake. Comes with your choice of frosting and sprinkles. Sprinkles may vary.
$3.75 +Chocolate Cupcake
Standard-sized classic Molly cupcake. Comes with your choice of frosting and sprinkles. Sprinkles may vary.
$3.75 +Red Velvet Cupcake
Standard-sized classic Molly cupcake. Comes with your choice of frosting and sprinkles. Sprinkles may vary.
$3.75 +Vanilla Cupcake
Standard-sized classic Molly cupcake. Comes with your choice of frosting and sprinkles. Sprinkles may vary.
$3.75 +Vegan Chocolate Cupcake
Please note: these are made in a shared kitchen with all of our other products. If you have an allergy/intolerance, there is a chance for cross-contact! For same day orders: we do not bake many of these - please call us at 773-883-7220 before placing an order for 3+, does not come with sprinkles unless requested - no dairy/eggs but may contain gelatin (sprinkles).
$3.75Vegan Vanilla Cupcake
Please note: these are made in a shared kitchen with all of our other products. If you have an allergy/intolerance, there is a chance for cross-contact! For same day orders: we do not bake many of these - please call us at 773-883-7220 before placing an order for 3+, does not come with sprinkles unless requested - no dairy/eggs but may contain gelatin (sprinkles).
$3.75