Pie-Eyed Pizzeria
Popular menu items
16" Thin Crust (Medium)
$24.75 +Appetizers
Fries
$3.50Seasoned Fries
$4.00Cheese Fries
$4.25Garlic Bread
$5.25Cheesy Garlic Bread
$6.25Pizza Bread
$7.00Mozzarella Sticks
$7.00Fried Mac & Cheese
$8.00Salads
Chicken Caesar Salad
Grilled chicken breast with Romaine lettuce, housemade croutons, Parmesan, Caesar dressing
$9.50Sandwiches
Italian Beef
$8.00 +Meatball Sandwich
$8.00 +Italian Beef in Marinara
$9.00 +Beef Meatball Combo
$10.00 +BBQ Beef
$9.00 +BBQ Chicken
$9.00 +Buffalo Chicken
$9.00 +Chicken Breast Sandwich
$9.00 +Chicken Parmesan
$10.00 +Butterfly Fried Shrimp
Plain Shrimp (5)
$5.00Plain Shrimp (10)
$9.50Plain Shrimp (20)
$18.00Buffalo Shrimp (5)
$6.00Buffalo Shrimp (10)
$11.50Buffalo Shrimp (20)
$22.00Wings & Drumsticks
Boneless Wings (8)
$10.00Boneless Wings (16)
$19.00Jumbo Whole Wings (3)
Fresh whole wings consisting of a wingette and a drumette. Baked & flash fried
$10.00Jumbo Whole Wings (6)
Fresh whole wings consisting of a wingette and a drumette. Baked & flash fried
$19.00Chicken Strips
Desserts
Chocolate Fudge Cake
$7.00Carrot Cake
$7.00Eli's Original Cheesecake
Combination of slow-cultured cream cheese, sour cream, sugar, Madagascar vanilla beans and whole eggs. All baked on a crisp all-butter shortbread cookie crust.
$5.00Eli's Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
Eli's creamy cheesecake bursting with bittersweet chocolate chips, baked on an all-butter chocolate cookie crust.
$5.00Eli's Pumpkin Praline Cheesecake
Made with real pumpkin and seasonal spices, hand-decorated with billows of pumpkin mousse and garnished with crunchy praline, baked on an all-butter shortbread cookie crust.
$7.00Red Velvet Cake
$7.00Sides & Extra Sauces
Balsamic Vinaigrette
$1.00BBQ Sauce
$1.00Bleu Cheese
$1.00Buffalo Sauce
$1.00Caesar
$1.00Cheddar Cheese Sauce
$1.00Cocktail
$1.00Honey Mustard
$1.00Hot Giardiniera
$1.00Jalapeños
$1.00Ketchup
$0.00Louisiana Hot Sauce
$1.00Mango Habanero
$1.00Marinara
$1.00Mayo
$1.00Parmesan
$0.00Pizza Sauce
$1.00Ranch
$1.00Red Pepper Flakes
$0.00Sweet Peppers
$1.00Pizza of the Month - Elote Pie
14" Thin Crust - Elote Pie
Butter Crust, Mozzarella, Corn, Cotija, Mayo, Chili Powder, Cilantro, Lime, Sour Cream, Valentina Hot Sauce
$28.5016" Thin Crust - Elote Pie
Butter Crust, Mozzarella, Corn, Cotija, Mayo, Chili Powder, Cilantro, Lime, Sour Cream, Valentina Hot Sauce
$31.0018" Thin Crust - Elote Pie
Butter Crust, Mozzarella, Corn, Cotija, Mayo, Chili Powder, Cilantro, Lime, Sour Cream, Valentina Hot Sauce
$33.50Thin Crust Pizza
Vegan Pizza
10" Vegan Pizza
$13.00 +Deep Dish Pizza (requires 45 min pickup time)
Stuffed Pizza (requires 45 min pickup time)
Gourmet Pizzas
Buffalo Chicken Pizza*
Oven roasted Buffalo chicken, Gorgonzola cheese, scallions, Buffalo sauce, blue cheese drizzle
$27.50 +The Italian Beef Pizza*
The best parts of our Italian beef sandwich combined to create a spicy, delicious pizza.
$27.50 +Monster Pie*
Hot Sopressata, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Red Bell Peppers, Extra sauce
$27.50 +Caprese Pizza*
Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, Tomatoes, Fresh Cracked Pepper, Sea Salt, Extra-Virgin Olive Oil
$27.50 +