Playa Betty's
MenuAbout
Playa Betty's Menu

Playa Betty's

Californian, Dinner
320 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023
(212) 712-0777
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Popular menu items

Menu powered by Grubhub

Hang 10 Burrito

Overstuffed San Diego-Style burrito, made with skirt steak, french fries, lettuce, jack cheese, guacamole & sour cream. Served with pico de gallo.

$18.00 +

Taco Dinner

Choose any three tacos, comes with brown rice & your choice of pinto or black beans.

$20.00

Playa Quesadilla

Flour tortilla stuffed with Jack cheese, black beans, and pico de gallo. Add Steak $3, Add Chicken $2.

$18.00 +

Appetizers

Guacamole 2.0

Our take on the make it the way you want it!!! Creamy hass Avocado base accompanied by sides of onion, tomato, cilantro, jalapeño peppers, pumpkin seeds, pomegranate & habanero peppers (if you feel adventurous)

$14.00 +

Queso Plain

Austin Style Cheese Dip

$14.00 +

Chorizo Queso

Austin Style Cheese Dip with Chorizo

$16.00 +

Mexican Grilled Corn

Grilled corn on the cob, served with a chili aioli, lime juice and cotija cheese

$14.00

Totchos

Tater Tots topped with classic nacho toppings: Cheese, Guacamole, Sour Cream & Pico de Gallo

$15.00 +

Appetizer Caser Chavez Salad

Spicy Caesar Salad made with romaine lettuce, roasted corn, avocado, grated cotija cheese, crispy tortilla strips & chipotle caesar dressing.

$14.00 +

Buffalo Cali Bites

Cauliflower served buffalo wing style with vegan soy ranch

$15.00 +

Tortilla Soup

A black bean broth with grilled chicken, tortilla strips, jack cheese & sliced avocado.

$9.00 +

Rad Wings

Sweet & spicy chicken wings tossed in classic Catalina dressing and chili flakes. Served with Vegan Soy Ranch.

$16.00 +

Chips n Salsa

House made Tortilla chips, Avocado-tomatillo Salsa, Chipotle-tomatillo salsa & Habanero salsa

$8.00

Enchiladas/Bowls/Entree

Chicken Enchiladas

Classic chicken enchiladas suizas with tomatillo salsa, lettuces, cotija cheese, sour cream & pico de gallo. Served with black beans & brown rice.

$20.00 +

Short Rib Enchiladas

Braised beef short rib, salsa roja, lettuces, pico de gallo, queso fresco & sour cream. Served with black beans & brown rice.

$22.00 +

Vegan Enchiladas

Stewed Summer squash, roasted corn & poblano pepper, vegetarian Pepper Jack Cheese, tomatillo salsa and Pico de Gallo. Served with Black Beans and Brown Rice.

$18.00 +

Cheese Enchilada

Classic enchiladas served with jack cheese, pico de gallo, tomatillo sauce & sour cream. Served with black beans & brown rice.

$18.00 +

Beachfire Chicken 1/2

Fire roasted marinated chicken served with grilled lime halves, grilled scallions, hoseamade salsas, corn tortillas & Mexican grilled corn.

$22.00 +

Beachfire Chicken Whole

Fire roasted marinated chicken served with grilled lime halves, grilled scallions, housemade salsas, corn tortillas & Mexican grilled corn.

$30.00 +

Hang 10 Burrito

Overstuffed San Diego-Style burrito, made with skirt steak, french fries, lettuce, jack cheese, guacamole & sour cream. Served with pico de gallo.

$18.00 +

Surf and Turf Burrito

Carne Asada & Grilled Shrimp, Kale, Hearts of Palms, Crispy Rice Noodles, pico de gallo, jack cheese & Teriyaki Mayo Sauce.

$21.00

Cali Carnitas

Braised pork shoulder marinated in dried chiles & orange juice. Served with cactus salad, black beans, brown rice, corn tortillas & pickled jalapeno.

$21.00 +

Grilled Salmon Beach Kabobs

Cherry tomatoes, Zucchini, Red Bell Pepper, Red Onions grilled on skewers served over Quinoa & Kale with Lemon-Tahini sauce with an aji pepper sauce on the side.

$24.00

Taco Dinner

Choose any three tacos, comes with brown rice & your choice of pinto or black beans.

$20.00

Playa Quesadilla

Flour tortilla stuffed with Jack cheese, black beans, and pico de gallo. Add Steak $3, Add Chicken $2.

$18.00 +

Dharma Bowl

Build Your Own Healthy Grain Bowl with your choice of Select Grains, Beans, Greens and Protein. (Tofu shown in picture)

$20.00 +

Kalefornia Salad

A fresh kale salad served with quinoa, toasted walnuts, chickpeas, sliced avocado in a lemon-tahini dressing. Add protein for $3.

$16.00 +

Entree Caesar Chavez Salad

A satisfying romaine salad with roasted corn, crispy tortilla strips, cotija cheese in a spicy chipotle dressing. Add protein for a full meal.

$18.00 +

Baja Burger

Los Angeles Style Beef Burger with American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Pickle and Betty's Secret Sauce Served with Tater Tots. Add Bacon or Guac for $2.00, Extra Patty $3.00

$16.00 +

Taco Truck Tacos

Baja Fish Taco

Tempura Battered Alaskan cod, shredded cabbage, avocado, pico de gallo, cotija cheese & jalapeño crema.

$7.00

Carne Asada

Grilled marinated skirt steak topped with caramelized onions, guacamole, cilantro, and lime. (Guac has onions and cilantro)

$7.00 +

The Marley

Jamaican style jerk chicken served with braised cabbage, tomato, red pepper, roasted Habanero salsa & Sweet plantain.

$6.00 +

Shrooms Asada

Grilled portabello mushrooms with caramelized onions, guacamole, cilantro and lime. (Guac has onions and cilantro).

$6.00 +

Seared Ahi Tuna

Seared ahi tuna with a jicama slaw & chipotle-lime aioli.

$7.00

Al Pastor

Spit grilled marinated pork served with pickled onion, cilantro, pineapple & avocado-tomatillo salsa.

$6.00

Vegan "ish" (Heart of Palm)

Breaded hearts of palm, vegan cheese, cabbage slaw, Valentina hot sauce aioli (vegan)

$5.00 +

Short Rib

Braised beef short rib topped with pickled red onion, cilantro, cotija cheese & chipotle-tomatillo salsa

$7.00

Southern Girl

Fried Chicken with shredded lettuce, pico de gallo & jalapeno crema.

$7.00

I Can Hass

Tempura Battered Hass Avocado with Lettuce and Pico de Gallo and Cotija Cheese

$6.00

Sides

Rice n Beans

$4.50

Side Corn Tortillas

$2.00

Side Flour Tortillas

$2.00

Side of Chips

$4.00

Side French Fries

$4.00

Side Tots

$4.00

Side House Guac

$4.00

Side Queso

$1.00

Side Sour Cream

$0.75

Side Pico

$0.75

Side Tomatillo

$0.75

Side Jalapeño Crema

$0.75

Side Chili Arbol

$0.75

Side Pickled Jalapeño

$1.00

Side Mojo

$0.75

Side Avocado

$2.00

Side Bacon

$2.50

Side Vegan Ranch

$0.75

Kids Menu

Kids Cheese Quesadilla

Combo comes with Tater Tots & Mini Queso. Add a choice of juice (Red Jacket Apple Juice, Lemonade, Chocolate or Plain Milk) and a scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream for $4.00 extra

$6.00 +

Chicken Finger Taco

Combo comes with Tater Tots & Mini Queso. Comes with your choice of juice (Red Jacket Apple Juice, Lemonade, Chocolate or Plain Milk) and a Scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream.

$6.00 +

Kids's Betty Bowl

Brown rice, Sweet Potato, zucchini & Chicken. Comes with your choice of a juice (Red Jacket Apple Juice, Lemonade, Chocolate or Plain Milk) and a scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream.

$6.00 +

Kids Beef Slider

Beef Slider With American Cheese. Combo comes with Tater Tots & Mini Queso. Comes with your choice of juice (Red Jacket Apple Juice, Lemonade, Chocolate or Plain Milk) and a Scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream.

$6.00 +

Desserts

Churro Ice Cream Sandwich

Two cinnamon sugar coated circular churros sandwiching creamy vanilla gelato.

$9.00

Mexican Coke Float

Classic ice cream soda, made with Mexican Coke and creamy vanilla gelato.

$9.00

Brunch/Taco/Entree/Bowl

Steak & Egg Taco

Steak with Scrambled Eggs, Cilantro, Cotija Cheese on a Flour Tortilla

$7.00

Shortrib & Egg Taco

Braised beef Shortrib, Scrambled Eggs, Cilantro and Cotija Cheese on a Flour Tortilla.

$6.00

Migas Taco

Eggs scrambled with shredded corn tortillas, chili de arbol & jack cheese, served on flour tortilla

$6.00

Chorizo/Potato & Egg Taco

Scrambled eggs topped with chorizo, potatoes, slasa verde & cotija cheese served on flour tortilla

$7.00 +

Breakfast Quesadilla

Scrambled Eggs, jack cheese, black beans. Pico de gallo, sour cream, and guacamole come on the side. Add Steak $3, Add Bacon $2

$18.00 +

Cali-Style Club Sandwich

Grilled chicken, Monteray jack, avocado, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo on grilled sour dough. Served with Tater Tots and side salad with a light vinagrette dressing.

$16.00 +

Breakfast Burrito

Overstuffed Venice Beach style burrito with scrambled eggs, jack cheese, lettuce, guacamole & tater tots with pico on the side. Add bacon or turkey sausage for $2

$18.00 +

OG Egg Sandwich

Scrambled cheese eggs & chives with crispy bacon, grilled tomatoes & melted red onions on brioche.

$15.00 +

Fluffy Corn Pancakes

Sweet corn pancakes topped with berries & organic maple syrup.

$14.00 +

Dawn Patrol Breakfast Bowl

Build a Healthy Breakfast Bowl with your choice of grain, bean, protein and style of eggs. Comes with cherry tomatoes, sauteed spinach and a side of aji pepper sauce.

$19.00

Kalefornia Salad

Lemony Kale, Chickpeas, Quinoa, Avocado, Toasted Walnuts and a Lemon-Tahini Dressing. Add a protein for $3.

$18.00 +

Taco Brunch

Your choice of 3 tacos and black or pinto beans with rice.

$20.00

Brunch Sides

Side Egg

$4.00

Side Turkey Sausage

$3.00

Side Bacon

$2.50

Side Veggie Bacon

$3.00

Side French Fries

$4.00

Side Tots

$4.00

Side Avocado

$2.00

Side Pico

$0.75

Side Sour Cream

$0.75

Side Tomatillo

$0.75

House Cocktails

"Wild Fire" Mezcal Toddy

A great combination of Mezcal, Reposado tequila, Curacao, Lemon, Star Anise and spicy agave syrup!!! Served Hot!

$15.00

Mulling Over Montauk - Mulled Wine

Red Wine, Apricot Liqueur, Orange, Lemon and Spices. Served Hot

$12.00

Tropical Paradise Pomegranate Margarita

La Pinta Pomegranate Tequila, Hint of Mezcal, Citrus & Black Lava Salt Rim and Pomegranate Seeds

$12.00

Frozen Paloma

Jose Cuervo 100% Agave Tradicional Silver Tequila, Grapefruit, and a Pink Peppercorn Salt Rim Nut Allergy

$14.00 +

Betty's Rita

Our own secret recipe made with Jose Cuervo 100% Agave Tradicional Reposado Tequila served on the rocks or straight up!

$14.00 +

Skinny Dip

El Jimador Silver tequila, organic agave, and lime, served straight up.

$14.00 +

Holla Pain Yo

Tanteo jalapeno-infused tequila with lime, served on the rocks.

$14.00 +

More Pain Yo

A hotter version of the Holla Pain Yo! Made with Tanteo Habanero Infused Tequila

$14.00

Paloma Oaxaca

400 Conejos Mezcal, Grapefruit Essence, Jarritos Toronja, Smoked Salt Rim

$14.00

Spiked Horchata

Homemade Horchata, Flor de Cana Anejo Oro, Orange Bitters

$14.00

Build Your Margarita

$14.00 +

Sangria

House-made Red Sangria served with a blend of fruits.

$11.00

Margarita Special Mango

Our classic Betty's Rita with a Wave of Mango Flavor

$12.00 +

Margarita Special Strawberry

Our Classic Betty's Rita with a Wave of Strawberry Flavor

$12.00 +

Margarita Special Cactus Pear

Our Classic Betty's Rita with a Wave of Cactus Pear Flavor

$12.00 +

Margarita Special Passionfruit

Our Classic Betty's Rita with a Wave of Passionfruit Flavor

$12.00

Pico Back Shots

$9.00

Topo Chico Cool as a Cucumber

Organic Crop Cucumber-Infused Vodka, Cucumber, Lime, Topo Chico Lime

$15.00

Laguna Beach GnT

Gray Whale Gin, London Essence Grapefruit & Rosemary Tonic, Citrus

$15.00

Island Rum Punch

Gosling's Dark Seal Rum & Gosling's Gold Seal Rum with Housemade Falernum, Tropical Fruit Juices, and Bitters.

$15.00

Playa Mai Tai

DeNada Reposado Tequila, 400 Conejos Mezcal, Orange Curacao, Almond Orgeat and lime. Our take on a beach cocktail classic!

$15.00

Betty's Mezcalita

A refreshing Mezcal cocktail with all the refreshing citrus ingredients in our margarita and finished with a smoked salt rim!

$15.00 +

Bottomless Brunch

Only available before 3:30pm. Bottomless brunch includes your choice of mimosa, sangria, or cactus pear bellini for 1 hour with the purchase of an entree or two tacos.

$24.00

Tanteo Jalapeno Bloody Maria

Classic house-made Bloody mix with Tanteo Jalapeno Tequila.

$14.00

Tanteo Habanero Bloody Maria

Classic house-made Bloody mix with Tanteo Habanero Tequila.

$14.00

Tanteo Chipotle Bloody Maria

Classic house-made Bloody mix with Tanteo Chipotle Tequila.

$14.00

Pitchers

Paloma Pitcher

$70.00

Betty's Margarita Pitcher

$65.00

Tropical Paradise Pomegranate Pitcher

$55.00

Holla Pain Yo Pitcher

$65.00

More Pain Yo Pitcher

$65.00

Skinny Dip Pitcher

$65.00

Strawberry Margarita Pitcher

$55.00

Mango Margarita Pitcher

$55.00

Cactus Pear Margarita Pitcher

$55.00

Passionfruit Margarita Pitcher

$55.00

Sangria Pitcher

$55.00

The Classic's

Aperol Spritz

$14.00 +

Bellini

$14.00 +

Betty Blue

$12.00 +

Black Russian

$11.00 +

Bloody Mary

$14.00 +

Caipiroska

$13.00 +

Caiparinha

$13.00 +

Coppertone

$8.00 +

Cosmo

$13.00 +

Cuba Libre

$10.00 +

Dark & Stormy

$14.00 +

Espresso Martini

$13.00 +

French Martini

$12.00 +

Gibson

$12.00 +

Gimlet

$12.00 +

Greyhound

$10.00 +

Hairy Navel

$10.00 +

Irish Coffee

$12.00 +

Kir

$10.00 +

Kir Royale

$11.00 +

Lemon Drop Martini

$13.00 +

Long Island Iced Tea

$15.00 +

Michelada

$14.00 +

Mimosa

$14.00 +

Mojito

$12.00 +

Moscow Mule

$14.00 +

Old Fashioned

$13.00 +

Rob Roy

$10.00 +

Rumrunner

$11.00 +

Rusty Nail

$12.00 +

Salty Dog

$10.00 +

Screwdriver

$14.00 +

Sea Breeze

$10.00 +

Sex on the Beach

$10.00 +

Sidecar rocks

$12.00 +

Smokey Playa

$13.00 +

Tequila Sunrise

$10.00 +

Tom Collins

$10.00 +

TT Pico Back

$3.00 +

Vodka Sour

$10.00 +

Washington Apple

$13.00 +

Whiskey A Gogo

$13.00 +

Whiskey Sour

$10.00 +

White Russian

$11.00 +

White Wine Spritzer

$11.00 +

Wipe Out

$13.00 +

Brunch Cocktails

Betty's Bubbly Trio

Enjoy a chilled bottle of premium Cava with our Playa Peach Nectar, Prickly Pear Puree and fresh OJ served on the side for your delight!

$36.00

Sangria

House-made Red Sangria served with a blend of fruits.

$11.00

Tanteo Jalapeno Bloody Maria

Classic house-made Bloody mix with Tanteo Jalapeno Tequila.

$14.00

Tanteo Habanero Bloody Maria

Classic house-made Bloody mix with Tanteo Habanero Tequila.

$14.00

Tanteo Chipotle Bloody Maria

Classic house-made Bloody mix with Tanteo Chipotle Tequila.

$14.00

DRAFT BEER

Two Roads Hefeweizen

$4.00

Two Roads Hefeweizen PITCHER

$16.00

Montauk "Wave Chaser" IPA

$8.00

Montauk "Wave Chaser" IPA PITCHER

$32.00

Blue Point Toasted Lager

$8.00

Blue Point Toasted Lager PITCHER

$32.00

Betty's "Beach Blonde" Lager

Take 5 with a refreshing, crisp, easy-drinking American Blonde lager, 4.4%ABV

$8.00

Betty's "Beach Blonde" PITCHER

Founder's Solid Gold is a drinkable premium lager brewed with the highest quality ingredients, 4.4%ABV.

$32.00

BEER BTLS & CANS

Cigar City Jai Alai

An intense bouquet of tangerine and candied orange peel, clementines, Valencia orange, and subtle caramel against an assertive bitterness and rich malt character.

$8.00

Cigar City Florida Man

Aromas of nectarine, honeydew, and orange zest with peach esters. Bright citrus flavors of clementine meet stonefruit and guava flavors while a snappy bitterness, bread-like malt flavors and spirited carbonation provide balance.

$8.00

Cigar City Margita Gose

Flavors of ripe limes, lemon zest and Valencia orange complimented by a zesty, tart sourness and a soft salinity. Bright, tropical, and refreshing.

$7.00

Corona Light Can

$7.00

Tecate Can

$7.00

Modelo ESP Can

$7.00

North Coast Old Rasputin

Imperial Stout, 9% ABV

$9.50

Corona Extra BTL

$9.00

Racer 5 IPA BTL

IPA, 7.5% ABV

$8.00

Zemilla Mexican Cider Rose BTL

Hard Rose Cider, 4% ABV

$7.00

Ommegang Witte BTL

American Wheat Beer, 5.2% ABV

$8.00

Heineken NA "00" BTL

Non-Alcoholic Beer

$7.00

Negra Modelo BLT

$7.00

Bohemia BTL

$7.00

Coronita

$4.00

Bucket of Coronita

$20.00

WINE GL & BTL

Betty's Bubbly Trio

Enjoy a chilled bottle of premium Cava with our Playa Peach Nectar, Prickly Pear Puree and fresh OJ served on the side for your delight!

$36.00

GL-Prosecco

$12.00

GL-Seeker Sauv. Blanc

$13.00

GL-Hess Chardonnay

$12.00

GL-Salmon Riesling

$10.00

GL-Saleya Rose

$13.00

GL-Seeker Pinot Noir

$13.00

GL-Montes Cabernet Sauv.

$11.00

GL-Alta Vista Malbec

$12.00

BTL-Seleya Rose

$52.00

SODA & MINERAL WATER

Topo Chico Mineral Water

$5.00

Lime Topo Chico Mineral Water

$5.00

Grapefruit Topo Chico Mineral Water

$5.00

Jarritos Tamarind Soda

$4.50

Jarritos Grapefruit Soda

$4.50

Jarritos Mandarina Soda

$4.50

Jarritos Guava Soda

$4.50

Jarritos Mango Soda

$4.50

Mexican Coke

500 mL bottle/1 Pint

$4.50

Fountain Coke

$3.50

Fountain Pepsi

$3.50

Fountain Mountain Dew

$3.50

Fountain Ginger Ale

$3.50

Soda Water

$3.50

Shirley Temple

$4.00

Arnold Palmer

$3.50

Lemonade

$5.50

Ice-Tea

$3.50

Fever Tree Tonic Water

$4.00

Fever Tree GingerBeer

$4.00

Virgin Cocktail

$6.50

JUICE

Arnold Palmer

$3.50

Ice-Tea

$3.50

Lemonade

$5.50

Grapefruit Juice

$5.50

Pineapple Juice

$5.50

Orange Juice

$5.50

Cranberry Juice

$5.50

Apple Juice

$5.50

COFFEE & TEA

Coffee

$4.00

Decaf Coffee

$4.00

Afficionado Cold Brew Coffee

$6.00

Hot Tea

$4.25
Restaurant closed
.

About Playa Betty's

  • 320 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023
  • Californian, Dinner, Lunch Specials, Mexican
  • (212) 712-0777
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / Playa Betty's
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy policy CA Privacy notice Do not sell my info
© 2023 Grubhub Holdings Inc.