Replay Andersonville
MenuAbout
Replay Andersonville Menu

Replay Andersonville

American, Dinner
5358 N Clark St, Chicago, IL 60640
(773) 654-1369
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Daily Specials

Menu powered by Grubhub

Tomato Bisque

Served with half a slice of Grilled Cheese (American cheese on white toast)

$10.33 +

Beef Chili

Traditional beef chili with beans, corn, celery and peppers topped with sour cream, green onions, and cheddar. Served with side of corn tortilla chips.

$12.94

Touchdown Taters

Loaded potato skins with Replay's house made chili (beef, beans, corn, celery and peppers) topped with sour cream, green onions, and cheddar.

$18.14

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

Hand breaded fried chicken, melted mozzarella, house marinara, arugula, garlic aioli and fried basil on a french roll

$24.64 +

Carnitas Tacos

Corn tortillas filled with home made carnitas, pico de gallo, queso fresco, and pickled red onion. Served with a side of green salsa.

$23.34

Seasonal Offerings

Tomato Bisque

Served with half a slice of Grilled Cheese (American cheese on white toast)

$10.33 +

Beef Chili

Traditional beef chili with beans, corn, celery and peppers topped with sour cream, green onions, and cheddar. Served with side of corn tortilla chips.

$12.94

*Seasonal * Harvest Glow

Roasted sweet potato, roasted cauliflower, candied walnuts, quinoa, pickled red onion and mixed greens tossed in a spicy honey vinaigrette (soy sauce, fresh ginger, chipotle, honey, apple cider, evo, salt, pepper)

$22.04 +

*Seasonal* Bonfire Burger

8 oz. beef patty, rosemary-brown sugar sweet potato, marshmallow fluff, smoked Gouda, arugula, and pickled red onion on a buttery bun.

$25.94 +

*Seasonal* Pumpkin Spice Bread Pudding

Pumpkin, cinnamon, and challah bread pudding topped with ice cream, candied walnuts, and fall-spiced syrup.

$15.54 +

Shareables

Bacon Mac & Cheese

Andersonville's best mac and cheese! Cavatappi noodles with smoked gouda, fontina, and smoked Applewood bacon, baked au gratin with panko crumbles

$24.64 +

BBQ Blitz Flatbread

Smoky bourbon BBQ, chicken, melted mozzarella, and zingy pickled red onions on a crispy flatbread

$19.44

Buffalo Chicken Egg Rolls

Three crispy smoked chicken egg rolls, with blue cheese and buffalo sauce. Served with blue cheese or buttermilk ranch dressing

$19.44

Wisconsin Cheese Curds

Battered, fried and served with side of buttermilk ranch.

$16.84 +

Chicken Tenders

Crispy chicken tenders strips served with choice of two dipping sauces

$20.74 +

Replay Chicken Wings

8 pieces - Hot Honey Mustard, buffalo or BBQ sauce, and fresh celery sticks. Served with your choice of buttermilk ranch dressing or blue cheese dressing

$20.74 +

Chips & Salsa

$6.44

Crispy Cauliflower

Crispy roasted cauliflower, spicy curry, pickle salad

$16.84 +

Fried Pickles

Panko breaded fried pickle chips, chipotle ranch dressing

$16.84 +

Game - Time Nachos

Pepper Jack cheese, guacamole, roasted tomato salsa, pico de gallo, pickled peppers, sour cream

$20.74 +

Pan Seared Brussel Sprouts

Sofrito aioli, balsamic reduction, parmesan cheese

$16.84

Game-Time Totchos

Tater-Tots, Pepper-jack cheese, guacamole, roasted tomato salsa, pico de gallo, pickled peppers, sour cream

$20.74 +

Salads & Wraps

Buffalo

Romaine, celery, carrots, cucumber, cherry tomatoes, buttermilk ranch or blue cheese, choice of protein tossed in buffalo sauce (+2 for steak)

$25.94 +

Caesar

Romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, brioche croutons, homemade caesar dressing

$20.74 +

Cobb

Romaine, green onions, avocado, tomato, hard-boiled egg, blue cheese, buttermilk ranch

$20.74

Santa Fe

Romaine lettuce, fresh corn, black beans, queso fresco, tortilla strips and tomato with a spicy peanut cilantro vinaigrette

$20.74 +

*Seasonal* Strawberry Fields

Quinoa and spring mix tossed with strawberries, candied walnuts, goat cheese, pickled red onion and balsamic vinaigrette

$19.13 +

Mediterranean

Romaine, house-made nut-free pesto, chickpeas, cherry tomatoes, red onion, olives, feta

$20.74 +

Tacos & Quesadillas

Birria Beef Quesatacos

Slow cooked savory Mexican-style beef tacos with Chihuahua cheese crust, pickled red onions, and served with roasted tomato salsa

$23.34 +

Quesadilla - Birria

Slow cooked savory Mexican-style beef with Chihuahua cheese and salsa verde

$24.64 +

Quesadilla - Smoked Chicken

Smoked chicken thighs, poblano peppers, and pepper jack cheese. Served with roasted salsa and sour cream

$24.64 +

Quesadilla - Cheese

Large flour tortilla with Chihuahua cheese. Served with side of sour cream and salsa verde

$14.24 +

Tacos- Cauli Crunch

Three crispy cauliflower tacos with peppery arugula, pickled peppers, and chipotle aioli sauce

$22.04 +

Tacos - Kick'n Shrimp

Three crispy shrimp tacos, topped with fresh arugula, pickled red onions, and a chipotle aioli

$23.34 +

Sandwiches

Cubano

Braised pork shoulder, smoked ham, applewood bacon, monterey jack cheese, dill pickles, mustard aioli and pickled peppers, served on a griddled bolillo roll

$25.94 +

Reuben

House-braised corned beef, Swiss cheese, caraway sauerkraut, Russian dressing on grilled rye bread

$24.64 +

Steak Sandwich

USDA Choice flat iron steak, baby arugula, grilled onion, homemade pesto, garlic aioli on a French baguette

$25.94 +

BLT

Our classic BLT: Bacon, lettuce, tomato, garlic aioli, toasted white bread

$22.03 +

Chicken Sandwich

Chicken breast, chipotle ranch, arugula, tomato and dill pickles; served on brioche bun

$23.34 +

Burgers

*Seasonal* Bonfire Burger

8 oz. beef patty, rosemary-brown sugar sweet potato, marshmallow fluff, smoked Gouda, arugula, and pickled red onion on a buttery bun.

$25.94 +

Bourbon Burger

Served on a pretzel bun, with melted bleu cheese and house-made bourbon BBQ sauce, with lettuce, tomato, onion, and dill pickle

$24.64 +

Build-A-Burger

Build your own burger! 8oz USDA ground chuck burger patty topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, dill pickles and served on a fresh buttery bun. Customize with topping add-ons!

$22.04 +

IMPOSSIBLE Burger Deluxe

Impossible Burger, smoked tomato aioli, avocado and provolone cheese, topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and dill pickle on a buttery bun

$25.94 +

Jalapeno Bacon Burger

Burger with bacon, queso fresco, jalapeno, arugula, tomato, and pickled red onions on a pretzel bun

$25.94 +

Smash Burger

Our signature burger! Two quarter pound hamburger patties, applewood smoked bacon, American cheese, caramelized onions, tomato, arugula lettuce, and fried dill pickles on a buttery bun

$25.94 +

Turkey Burger

8oz ground turkey burger patty topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, dill pickles and served on a fresh buttery bun. Customize with topping add-ons!

$22.04 +

Slider Showdown

Three juicy beef sliders with crunchy pickles, melty American cheese, and a tangy Russian dressing

$24.64 +

Desserts

Brownie Sundae

Served with vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce and whipped cream

$15.24

Cookie Skillet

Chocolate chip cookie, vanilla ice cream, bourbon caramel -30min bake time-���

$16.54 +

Three Scoops Vanilla Ice Cream

$7.50 +

Sides

Hand Cut Fries

$8.80

Brussell Sprouts Side

$8.80

Sweet Potato Fries

$8.80

Tater Tots

$8.80

Side of Avocado

$5.55

Side of Guacamole

$5.55

Small Salad

Mixed greens, cherry tomatoes and cucumbers tossed in a balsamic vinaigrette

$8.80 +

Sliced Tomatoes

$8.80

Side of Tortilla Chips

$5.14

Side of Pico De Gallo

$4.90

Add Cheese

$0.00 +

Sauces

Side of Bleu Cheese Dressing

$0.65

Side of Balsamic Dressing

$0.65

Side of Caesar Dressing

$0.65

Side of Peanut Cilantro Vinaigrette

$0.65

Side of Buttermilk Ranch

$0.65

Side of Chipotle Ranch

$0.65

Side of Thousand Island

$0.65

Side of BBQ Sauce

$0.65

Side of Buffalo Sauce

$0.65

Side of Hot Honey Mustard

$0.65

Side of Bourbon BBQ

$0.65

Side of Garlic Aioli

$0.65

Side of Mustard Aioli

$0.65

Side of Sofrito Aioli

$0.65

Side of Tomato Aioli

$0.65

Side of Chipotle Aioli

$0.65

Side of Cheese Sauce

$3.90

Side of Teriyaki Glaze

$0.65

Side of Curry Sauce

$2.60

Side of Sour Cream

$0.65

Side of Salsa Verde

$1.30

Side of Roasted Tomato Salsa

$1.30

Side of Pesto

$1.23

Side of Ketchup

$0.00

Side of Mustard

$0.00

Side of Mayo

$0.00

Kids Menu

Kid's Cheeseburger

Quarter pound patty, American Cheese, Lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle on a buttery bun with hand cut fries

$16.84 +

Kid's Chicken Fingers

Served with ranch dressing or BBQ sauce and hand cut fries

$15.24 +

Kid's Grilled Cheese

White bread, American Cheese, side of hand cut fries

$13.94 +

Merch

Red Beanie

$21.00

Grey Beanie

$21.00

Black Beanie

$21.00
Restaurant closed
.

About Replay Andersonville

  • 5358 N Clark St, Chicago, IL 60640
  • American, Dinner, Kids Menu, Lunch Specials, Must Try, Tacos
  • (773) 654-1369
Powered by Grubhub
Home / IL / Chicago / Replay Andersonville
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2026 Grubhub Holdings Inc.