Sarabeth's (Upper West Side)
MenuAbout
Sarabeth's (Upper West Side) Menu

Sarabeth's (Upper West Side)

American, Dinner
423 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
(212) 496-6280
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Popular menu items

Menu powered by Grubhub

Basket of Popovers

orange marmalade

$12.00 +

Farm Chicken

confit chicken croquette, sweet potato puree, shaved Brussels sprouts, golden raisins, herb chicken jus

$29.00

Deviled Eggs

$14.00

Fruity Beginning

Four Flowers Juice

orange, fresh pineapple, banana & pomegranate juice. We apologize but fruits in this item are not removable.

$12.00 +

Morning Fruit Bowl

grapefruit & orange, sliced banana & strawberry

$14.00 +

Light Breakfast

Apple Cinnamon Granola

Greek yogurt, golden raisins, coconut, almonds, banana

$15.00

Breakfast Bowl

Quinoa, smoked salmon, avocado, pickled onions, pepita, cherry tomato.

$21.00 +

Steel Cut Oats

chia, pistachio, raspberry

$14.00 +

Signature Avocado Toast

smashed avocado, sea salt, heirloom cherry tomato, burrata, pepita, petits market greens

$20.00 +

Popovers

Wild Mushroom Popover

boursin cheese, truffle oil, chives. Served with local greens.

$24.00 +

Goldie Lox Popover

smoked salmon, cream cheese. Served with local greens.

$24.00 +

Green & White Popover

scallions, cream cheese. Served with local greens.

$24.00 +

Basket of Popovers

orange marmalade

$12.00 +

Basket Of Muffins

$19.00 +

Basket of Blueberry Popovers

earl grey cream cheese

$15.00 +

Sweet Breakfast

Fat & Fluffy French Toast

Comes with organic maple syrup from Doerfler's Farm & strawberries.

$24.00 +

Lemon Ricotta Pancakes

Comes with organic maple syrup from Doerfler's Farm & blackberries.

$24.00 +

Buttermilk Pancakes

Comes with organic maple syrup from Doerfler's Farm & strawberries.

$24.00 +

Extraordinary Eggs & Omelettes

Spinach & Goat Cheese Omelette

Served with local greens and guests' choice of sour dough or 7 grain toast, scone, banana muffin or pumpkin muffin

$24.00 +

Sarabeth's Quiche

leeks, ham, potato, gruyere not served with additional toast.

$23.00 +

Garden Omelette

Peas, zucchini, mushrooms, cheddar cheese. Served with local greens and guests' choice of sour dough or 7 grain toast, scone, banana muffin or pumpkin muffin

$23.00 +

Farmer���s Omelette

Leeks, Ham, Potato, Gruyere. Served with local greens and guests' choice of sour dough or 7 grain toast, scone, banana muffin or pumpkin muffin

$23.00 +

Eggs Benedict

canadian bacon, hollandaise, peppers, chives. Served with local greens.

$25.00

Salmon Benedict

hollandaise, peppers, chives. Served with local greens.

$26.00

2 Eggs Any Style

Guests' choice of eggs any style. Choice of avocado, chicken sausage, smoked salmon, double cut bacon. Served with local greens & guests' choice of 7 grain or sour dough toast, pumpkin muffin, banana muffin or scone.

$23.00 +

*Cheese Omelette

Guests' choice of cheddar or gruyere. Served with local greens and guests' choice of sour dough or 7 grain toast, scone, english muffin, banana muffin or pumpkin muffin

$20.00 +

*Plain Omelette

$20.00 +

Appetizers

Velvety Tomato Soup

cheddar cheese, dill

$16.00

Crab & Guacamole

house made chips

$22.00

Deviled Eggs

capers, cornichon, parsley

$15.00

Crispy Calamari

Spicy marinara, garlic aioli

$20.00

Baby Beet Salad

baba ganoush, crispy sunchokes, dill, pepitas, pomegranate vinaigrette

$16.00

Short Rib Tater Tots

chipotle aioli

$16.00

Guacamole & Chips

housemade chips

$16.00

Market Soup

Chicken Tortilla

$16.00

Salads

5 Lettuce Caesar Salad

shaved Parmesan, garlic & herb croutons

$16.00 +

Sarabeths Chopped Salad

Market vegetables, salami, feta, lemon, vinaigrette.

$18.00 +

Power Bowl

shredded kale, quinoa, pistachios, apples, beets, goat cheese, sherry shallot vinaigrette

$19.00 +

Seafood Cobb Salad

Maine Lobster, crab meat, shrimp, avocado, bacon, egg, tomato, onion, blue cheese

$33.00 +

Sammy's & Entrees

Classic Lobster Roll

remoulade, coleslaw, chips

$36.00 +

Adult Grilled Cheese

3 cheeses, pretzel bread, house-made pickles, velvety tomato soup

$24.00 +

One Great Burger

aged cheddar, pickled green tomatoes, bacon, jalape��o marmalade, saut��ed onions, house cut french fries

$25.00 +

Chicken Pot Pie

wild mushrooms, rainbow carrots, fingerling potatoes, herb b��chamel

$29.00

Crispy Buttermilk Chicken Sandwich

pickles, coleslaw, jalapeno marmalade, french fries

$26.00 +

Steak Frites

steak, house cut fries, b��arnaise sauce

$36.00 +

Faroe Island Salmon

Eggplant Caponata, wilted spinach, basil oil

$32.00

Roasted Turkey Club

Bacon jam, Burrata, arugula, avocado, croissant

$25.00

Appetizers

Velvety Tomato Soup

cheddar cheese, dill

$16.00

Meatballs

pomodoro, basil

$17.00

Crispy Calamari

spicy marinara, garlic aioli

$20.00

Bang Bang Shrimp

ginger, sweet chili, avocado, micro mint

$15.00

Baby Beet Salad

baba ganoush, crispy sunchokes, dill, pepitas, pomegranate vinaigrette

$16.00

Guacamole & Chips

$20.00

Burrata

maple roasted squash, hazelnut crumble, cranberry gastrique, verjus grapes

$18.00

Crab & Guacamole

homemade chips

$22.00

Salads

5 Lettuce Caesar Salad

shaved Parmesan, garlic & herb croutons

$16.00 +

Sarabeths Chopped Salad

cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, onion, garbanzo beans, red peppers, salami, feta, kalamata olives, lemon oregano vinaigrette

$19.00 +

Power Bowl

shredded kale, quinoa, pistachios, apples, beets, goat cheese, sherry shallot vinaigrette

$19.00 +

Seafood Cobb Salad

Main Lobster, crab meat, shrimp, avocado, bacon, egg, tomato, onion, blue cheese

$33.00 +

Sammy's & Entrees

Classic Lobster Roll

remoulade, coleslaw, chips

$36.00 +

Adult Grilled Cheese

3 cheeses, pretzel bread, house-made pickles, velvety tomato soup

$24.00 +

One Great Burger

aged cheddar, pickled green tomatoes, bacon, jalape��o marmalade, saut��ed onions, house cut french fries

$25.00 +

Steak Frites

steak, house cut fries, b��arnaise sauce

$36.00

Faroe Island Salmon

Eggplant Caponata, wilted spinach, basil oil

$32.00

Farm Chicken

confit chicken croquette, sweet potato puree, shaved Brussels sprouts, golden raisins, herb chicken jus

$29.00

Chicken Pot Pie

wild mushrooms, rainbow carrots, fingerling potatoes, herb b��chamel

$29.00

Crab Cake Sandwich

sesame bun. tartar sauce. house cut french fries

$27.00

Pan Seared Branzino

roasted root vegetables, parsnip puree, apple cider pan sauce

$31.00

Pumpkin Ravioli

beech mushrooms, pepitas, mache, sage brown butter vinaigrette

$28.00

Sides

Truffle Fries

$12.00

French Fries

$12.00

Side Local Green Salad

$12.00

Side of Salmon

$14.00

Side of Bread

$3.00

Side of Avocado 1\2

$5.00

Chips

$5.00

French Green Beans

shallots and dill

$12.00

1/2 Cup Heavy Cream

$3.00

Brussels Sprouts

$12.00

Eggplant Caponata

capers basil

$12.00

Snacks

Deviled Eggs

$14.00

Short Rib Tator Tots

$16.00

Bang Bang Shrimp

ginger, sweet chili, avocado, micro mint

$15.00

Crispy Calamari

spicy marinara, garlic aioli

$20.00

Tuna Tartare Tacos

$16.00

Crab & Guacamole

homemade chips

$22.00

Fruity Beginning

Four Flowers Juice

orange, fresh pineapple, banana & pomegranate juice. We apologize but fruits in this item are not removable.

$12.00

Morning Fruit Bowl

grapefruit & orange, sliced banana & strawberry

$14.00 +

Light Breakfast

Apple Cinnamon Granola

Greek yogurt, golden raisins, coconut, almonds, banana

$15.00

Breakfast Bowl

quinoa, smoked salmon, avocado, pickled onions, pepitas, cherry tomatoes

$21.00 +

Steel Cut Oats

chia, pistachio, raspberries

$14.00

Signature Avocado Toast

smashed avocado, sea salt, heirloom cherry tomato, burrata, pepita, petits market greens

$20.00 +

Popovers

Goldie Lox Popover

smoked salmon, cream cheese. Served with local greens.

$24.00 +

Wild Mushroom Popover

boursin cheese, truffle oil, chives. Served with local greens.

$24.00 +

Green & White Popover

scallions, cream cheese. Served with local greens.

$24.00 +

Basket of Popovers

orange marmalade

$12.00 +

Basket Sarabeths Muffins

English, bran, banana, pumpkin, corn

$19.00 +

Basket of Blueberry Popovers

earl grey cream cheese

$15.00 +

Sweet Breakfast

Fat & Fluffy French Toast

Comes with organic maple syrup from Doerfler's Farm & strawberries.

$24.00 +

Lemon Ricotta Pancakes

Comes with organic maple syrup from Doerfler's Farm & blackberries.

$24.00 +

Buttermilk Pancakes

Comes with organic maple syrup from Doerfler's Farm & strawberries.

$24.00 +

Extraordinary Eggs & Omelettes

Spinach & Goat Cheese Omelette

Served with local greens & guests' choice of 7 grain or sour dough toast, pumpkin muffin, banana muffin or scone.

$24.00 +

Sarabeth's Quiche

leeks, ham, potato, gruyere not served with additional toast.

$23.00 +

Garden Omelette

peas, zucchini, mushrooms, cheddar Served with local greens & guests' choice of 7 grain or sour dough toast, pumpkin muffin, banana muffin or scone.

$24.00 +

Farmers Omelette

leeks, ham, potato, gruyere Served with local greens & guests' choice of 7 grain or sour dough toast, pumpkin muffin, banana muffin or scone.

$23.00 +

Classic Ham Benedict

canadian bacon, hollandaise, peppers, chives Served with local greens

$26.00

Salmon Benedict

hollandaise, peppers, chives Served with local greens

$27.00

2 Eggs Any Style

Guests' choice of eggs any style. Choice of avocado, chicken sausage, smoked salmon, double cut bacon. Served with local greens & guests' choice of 7 grain or sour dough toast, pumpkin muffin, banana muffin or scone.

$23.00 +

*Plain Omelette

$20.00 +

*Cheese Omelette

Guests' choice of cheddar or gruyere. Served with local greens and guests' choice of sour dough or 7 grain toast, scone, english muffin, banana muffin or pumpkin muffin

$20.00 +

Sides

Three-Pepper Home Fries

$12.00

Applewood Smoked Bacon

$12.00

Chicken Apple Sausage

$12.00

Side of Smoked Salmon

$12.00

Side of 1/2 Avocado

$5.00

Truffle Fries

$12.00

French Fries

$12.00

Local Greens Salad

$12.00

One Egg Side

$3.00 +

Two Eggs Side

$6.00 +

Three Eggs Side

$9.00 +

Side of Sourdough

$3.00

Side of 7 Grain Toast

$3.00

English Muffin

$3.00

Pumpkin Muffin

$3.00

Banana Muffin

$3.00

Bran Muffin

$3.00

Corn Muffin

$3.00

One Popover

$3.00

Side of Yogurt

$3.00

Yogurt

$5.00

Appetizers

Velvety Tomato Soup

cheddar cheese, dill

$16.00

Crab & Guacamole

house made chips

$22.00

Deviled Eggs

capers, cornichon, parsley

$15.00

Short Rib Tater Tots

chipotle aioli

$16.00

Basket Sarabeths Muffins

English, bran, banana, pumpkin, corn

$19.00

Guacamole & Chips

housemade chips

$16.00

Salads

5 Lettuce Caesar Salad

shaved Parmesan, garlic & herb croutons

$16.00 +

Sarabeths Chopped Salad

Market vegetables, salami, feta, lemon, vinaigrette.

$18.00 +

Power Bowl

shredded kale, quinoa, pistachios, apples, beets, goat cheese, sherry shallot vinaigrette

$19.00 +

Seafood Cobb Salad

Maine Lobster, crab meat, shrimp, avocado, bacon, egg, tomato, onion, blue cheese

$33.00 +

Sammy's & Entrees

Classic Lobster Roll

remoulade, coleslaw, chips

$36.00 +

Adult Grilled Cheese

3 cheeses, pretzel bread, house-made pickles, velvety tomato soup

$24.00 +

One Great Burger

aged cheddar, pickled green tomatoes, bacon, jalape��o marmalade, saut��ed onions, house cut french fries

$25.00 +

Crispy Buttermilk Chicken Sandwich

pickles, coleslaw, jalapeno marmalade, french fries

$26.00 +

Steak Frites

steak, house cut fries, b��arnaise sauce

$36.00 +

Turkey Club

arugula, bacon jam, burrata, avocado, served on a croissant with house made potato chips

$24.00

Chicken Pot Pie

wild mushrooms, rainbow carrots, fingerling potatoes, herb b��chamel

$29.00

Appetizers

Crab & Guacamole

house made chips

$22.00

Velvety Tomato Soup

cheddar cheese, dill

$16.00

Meatballs

pomodoro, basil

$17.00

Crispy Calamari

spicy marinara, garlic aioli

$20.00

Bang Bang Shrimp

ginger, sweet chili, avocado, micro mint

$15.00

Guacamole & Chips

$20.00

Baby beet Salad

herb whipped goat cheese, pistachio, strawberries, opal basil, frisee

$16.00

Burrata

maple roasted squash, hazelnut crumble, cranberry gastrique, verjus grapes

$18.00

Salads

5 Lettuce Caesar Salad

shaved Parmesan, garlic & herb croutons

$16.00 +

Sarabeths Chopped Salad

cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, onion, garbanzo beans, red peppers, salami, feta, kalamata olives, lemon oregano vinaigrette

$19.00 +

Power Bowl

shredded kale, quinoa, pistachios, apples, beets, goat cheese, sherry shallot vinaigrette

$19.00 +

Seafood Cobb Salad

Main Lobster, crab meat, shrimp, avocado, bacon, egg, tomato, onion, blue cheese

$33.00 +

Sammy's & Entrees

Classic Lobster Roll

remoulade, coleslaw, chips

$36.00 +

Adult Grilled Cheese

3 cheeses, pretzel bread, house-made pickles, velvety tomato soup

$24.00 +

One Great Burger

aged cheddar, pickled green tomatoes, bacon, jalape��o marmalade, saut��ed onions, house cut french fries

$25.00 +

Steak Frites

steak, house cut fries, b��arnaise sauce

$36.00

Faroe Island Salmon

Eggplant Caponata, wilted spinach, basil oil

$32.00

Farm Chicken

confit chicken croquette, sweet potato puree, shaved Brussels sprouts, golden raisins, herb chicken jus

$29.00

Chicken Pot Pie

wild mushrooms, rainbow carrots, fingerling potatoes, herb b��chamel

$29.00

Crab cake Sandwich

sesame bun, tartar sauce, house cut french fries

$27.00

Pan Seared Branzino

roasted root vegetables, parsnip puree, apple cider pan sauce

$31.00

Pumpkin Ravioli

beech mushrooms, pepitas, mache, sage brown butter vinaigrette

$28.00

Sides

Truffle Fries

$12.00

French Fries

$12.00

Side Local Green Salad

$12.00

Side of Salmon

$14.00

Side of Bread

$3.00

Side of Avocado 1\2

$5.00

Chips

$5.00

French Green Beans

shallots and dill

$12.00

Eggplant Caponata

capers and basil

$12.00

Wild Mushroom Ragout

$12.00

Snacks

Deviled Eggs

$14.00

Short Ribs Tater Tots

$16.00

Bang Bang Shrimp

$15.00

Crispy Calamari

$20.00

Tuna Tartare Tacos

$16.00

Crab and Guacamole

$22.00

Coffee

Latte

$7.00 +

Cappuccino

$7.00 +

Espresso

$4.75 +

Double Espresso

$7.50 +

Macchiatto

$5.00 +

Cortado

$6.00 +

Moccha

$5.00 +

Americano

$6.00 +

Cafe Au Lait

$5.00 +

Flat White

$5.50 +

Iced Decaf Coffee

$5.00 +

Iced Latte

$7.00 +

Iced Cappuccino

$6.00 +

Iced Americano

$7.00 +

Hot Tea

$5.00 +

Iced Tea

$5.00 +

Hot Chocolate

$8.00 +

Milk

$4.00 +

Chocolate Milk

$5.00 +

Chai Latte

$8.00 +

Iced Chai Latte

$8.00 +

To Go Coffee

$5.00 +

To Go Decaf Coffee

$5.00 +

To Go Cold Brew

$6.00 +

Lavender Latte

$7.00 +

Pumpkin Spice Latte

$7.00 +

Pumpkin Spice Cappuccino

$7.00 +

Vanilla Latte

$7.00 +

Vanilla Cappuccino

$7.00 +

Soda

Shirley Temple

$6.00

Juice & Mocktails

4 Flowers Juice

$12.00

Orange Juice

$10.00

Grapefruit Juice

$10.00

Cranberry Juice

$6.00

Tomato Juice

$6.00

Apple Juice

$6.00

Pineapple Juice

$6.00

Lemonade

$6.00 +

Lavender Lemonade

$7.00

Sarabeth's Pink Lemonade

$7.00

Mai Tai Blossom

$7.00

Arnold Palmer

$6.00

Virgin Bloody Mary

$13.00

Mocktail

$13.00

Canned Beverages

Saratoga Large Sparkling

$10.00

Saratoga Small Sparkling

$6.00

Saratoga Large Flat

$10.00

Saratoga Small Flat

$6.00

Can Coke

$4.50

Can Diet Coke

$4.50

Can Sprite

$4.50

Can Ginger Ale

$4.50

Can Seltzer

$4.50

Can Ginger Beer

$4.50

Sm Bottle Tonic

$4.50

Sarabeth's Desserts

Chocolate Truffle Cake

strawberry raspberry sauce

$14.00

Seasonal Crostata

apple crostata, vanilla gelato, caramel sauce

$14.00

Cheesecake

orange apricot marmalade

$14.00

Ice Cream Sandwich

classic chocolate chip cookie, vanilla gelato

$8.00

Cookie

$4.00

Locally Made Gelato & Sorbet

Seasonal sorbet, sea salt caramel gelato, vanilla gelato, chocolate gelato

$14.00

Single Scoop of Gelato or Sorbet

Guests' choice of vanilla gelato, chocolate gelato, sea salt caramel gelato, and mango sorbet.

$5.00

Brunch

Fall Frittata

pancetta, delicata squash, kale, red pepper, goat cheese, fresh herbs, fig balsamic drizzle, choice of toast

$28.00

Apple Cider Waffle

caramelized apples, pomegranate seeds, powdered sugar, maple syrup, whipped butter

$24.00

Grilled Jumbo Shrimp BLT

sourdough bread, avocado, pickles, coleslaw, chipotle aioli, house made potato chips

$24.00

Week

Chicken tortilla soup

cilantro, avocado, lime

$16.00

Weekend

Butternut Squash Soup

feta cheese, corinader

$16.00

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail

Arugula, red onions, cucumbers, heirloom cherry tomatoes, feta cheese, lemon dressing

$18.00
Restaurant closed
.

About Sarabeth's (Upper West Side)

  • 423 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
  • American, Dinner, Hamburgers, Salads, Sandwiches
  • (212) 496-6280
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / Sarabeth's (Upper West Side)
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.