Sarge’s Delicatessen & Diner
Popular menu items
Fresh Roast Turkey Sandwich
$25.68 +Half Sandwich and Soup
$28.02 +Classic Sarge's Sandwiches
Hot Pastrami Sandwich
We cure our pastrami in-house with our special blend of spices. It is then slow cooked to perfection.
$31.53 +Tongue Sandwich
$32.70 +Fresh Roast Turkey Sandwich
$25.68 +Hot Brisket of Beef Sandwich
$30.36 +Turkey Pastrami Sandwich
$26.85 +Rolled Beef Sandwich
$31.53 +Salami Sandwich
$25.68 +Hard Salami Sandwich
$25.68 +Boiled Ham Sandwich
$23.34 +Chopped Liver Sandwich
$24.51 +Chicken Salad Sandwich
$22.17 +Egg Salad Sandwich
$19.83 +Tuna Salad Sandwich
$21.00 +Whitefish Salad Sandwich
$23.34 +Baked Salmon Salad Sandwich
$23.34 +The Hudson “Born December 12th 2018”
Open faced Pastrami & Corned Beef stacked on Rye, Swiss cheese and Sauerkraut grilled.
$38.55 +Sweet Baby Dave's Smokehouse Pastrami
Sarge's homemade pastrami topped with coleslaw and chipotle honey mustard on a toasted hero.
$32.70 +Half Sandwich and Soup
$28.02 +Sarge's Hot Sandwiches
The Third Avenue
Hot Corned Beef & Hot Pastrami, Open on Rye Bread with French Fries & Stuffed Derma
$40.89French Dip Sandwich
Shaved Prime Roast Beef Dipped in Au Jus on a Club Roll with Horseradish Sauce and Au Juson the side with fries
$37.38Cheese Steak
Shaved slow roasted prime Roast Beef, smothered with sautéed Onions & Peppers, topped with melted American cheese on a toasted Garlic Club Roll with Fries
$37.38Chicken Parm Sandwich
Fried Chicken cutlet, topped with melted Mozzarella Cheese & Tomato Sauce on a toasted Garlic Club Roll with fries
$32.70Chicken Loco
Chicken Cutlet, Pastrami, Melted Swiss, Cole Slaw, & Russian Dressing on a Toasted Club Roll with fries
$35.04Sarges Favorite
Hot slow-cooked brisket of beef on potato pancake with homemade gravy and applesauce.
$35.04The Suzy Greenberg
Fried Chicken Cutlet, Melted Mozzarella, Bacon & Russian Dressing on a Toasted Club Roll
$29.19Boneless Chicken Sandwich
On a Kaiser Roll (Grilled or Fried) with Lettuce & Tomato served with French Fries
$26.85 +Craving Something Different?
Chicken Pot Pie
Blend of chicken, peas, carrots, onions, potatoes and fresh cream in a pie shell pastry.
$23.34Grilled Cheese
$12.81 +Mulberry Street
Genoa salami, pepperoni, ham, capicola, provolone, lettuce, tomato, roasted red peppers, oil & vinegar on a hero.
$26.85 +Unreal Deli
Unreal Corned Beef or Turkey Sandwich
Your choice of Mrs. Goldfarb's 100% plant-based corned beef or turkey 100% vegetarian.
$22.17 +Unreal Corned Beef or Turkey Reuben
Your choice of Mrs. Goldfarb's 100% plant based Corned Beef or Turkey served with Swiss Cheese and Sauerkraut grilled to perfection.
$26.85 +Sarge's Noshes Franks and Appetizers
Knish
$9.30Stuffed Knish
Square potato knish stuffed with a hot dog, corned beef or pastrami topped with mustard or Russian, grilled add melted cheese and sauerkraut.
$13.95 +Gefilte Fish
$12.81Chopped Liver
$17.49Stuffed Derma
Our kishka is famous (watch the 3rd episode of season one of "The Deuce" on HBO. A scene in this episode was filmed at Sarge's.
$19.83Stuffed Cabbage
$19.83Potato Pancake (1)
$8.13Chicken Fingers
$19.83Jewish Dairy Specials
Sides
French Fries
$11.64Sweet Potato Fries
$12.81Coleslaw
$8.13Potato Salad
$8.13Macoroni Salad
$8.13Corned Beef Hash
$21.00Side of Bacon
$10.47Breakfast Sausage
$10.47Egg Barley and Mushrooms
$13.98Kasha Varnishkas
$13.98Baked Beans
$11.64Pickled Tomatoes
$9.30Tossed Green Salad
$11.64Stuffing
$10.47Fruit Salad
$9.30side Sauerkraut
$6.96Sweet Peppers
$9.30Hot Peppers
$9.30Side Tomato
$3.45Side Avocado
$5.79Side Egg
$3.51Sarge's Famous Burgers
Salads
Chopped Salad
with Iceberg, Romaine, Radicchio, Cucumber, Tomato, Green Onions, Chick Peas and Roasted Corn
$24.51 +Cobb Salad
Grilled Chicken Breast, Avocado, Crumbled Bleu Cheese, Bacon, Sliced Egg & Tomatoes on Mixed Greens
$29.19 +Eggs
Smoked Fish
Pick Two Combo
Choice of Two Smoked Fish Selections, accompanied by Two Bagels, Cream Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and Bermuda Onion
$49.08Herrings
$15.15 +Deli Meat
Beef Bologna (1lb)
$24.57Beef Franks (1lb)
$25.74Beef Knockwurst (1lb)
$25.74Beef Salami (1lb)
$24.57Boiled Ham (1lb)
$17.55Brisket (1lb)
$42.12 +Corned Beef (1lb)
$44.46 +Hard Salami (1lb)
$32.76Liverwurst (1lb)
$16.38Pastrami (1lb)
$49.14 +Roast Beef (1lb)
$39.78Rolled Beef (1lb)
$49.14Tongue (1lb)
$51.48Turkey Pastrami (1lb)
$37.44Unreal Corned Beef (1lb)
$24.57Unreal Turkey (1lb)
$24.57Whole Roast Chicken
$21.00Half Roast Chicken
$11.64Fried Chicken Breast
$9.30Deli Items
Mustard (1/2)
$4.07MUSTARD
$0.00Russian (1/2lb)
$5.24RUSSIAN
$0.00MAYO
$0.00Single Bagel
$1.76Challah Bread (Loaf)
$10.47Rye Bread (Slice)
$0.47Rye Bread (1/2 Loaf)
$6.96Rye Bread (Loaf)
$13.92Plain Cream Cheese (1lb)
$11.70Baked Salmon Salad (1lb)
$33.93Belly Lox (1lb)
$59.67Chicken Salad (1lb)
$22.23Chopped Herring (1lb)
$16.38Cole Slaw (1lb)
$11.70Cottage Cheese
$8.13Cranberry Sauce
$6.96Cucumber Salad (1lb)
$11.70Egg Salad (1lb)
$17.55Gravy
$6.96 +Gravy ON SIDE
$0.00Herring Filet (EA)
$4.68Kasha Varnishkas (1lb)
$11.70Macaroni Salad (1lb)
$11.70Nova Salmon (1lb)
$59.67Potato Salad (1lb)
$11.70Smoked Sable (1lb)
$76.05Smoked Whitefish (1lb)
$32.76Sturgeon (1lb)
$76.05Tuna Salad (1lb)
$22.23Whitefish Salad (1lb)
$33.93Olives
$8.13SM Pickle (EA)
$1.46LG Pickle (EA)
$4.10Chocolate Babka
$18.66Ruggelach (1lb)
$20.97Deli Cheese
Cheddar Cheese (1lb)
$15.21American Cheese (1lb)
$12.87Mozzarella Cheese (1lb)
$15.21Muenster Cheese (1lb)
$15.21Plain Cream Cheese (1lb)
$11.70Swiss Cheese (1lb)
$17.55Provolone Cheese (1lb)
$17.55Deli Soups
Matzo Ball Soup
Chicken consomme with 1 matzo ball. Freshly made every day, enjoy it plain or add in one or more of our soup extras.
$9.95 +Kreplach Soup
$9.95 +Matzo Noodle Soup
Chicken consomme with 1 matzo ball and noodles. Freshly made every day, enjoy it plain or add in one or more of our soup extras.
$9.95 +Noodle Soup
$9.95 +Rice Soup
$9.95 +Mushroom Barley Soup
$9.95 +French Onion
$11.95Dry Matzo Ball
$4.62Dry Kreplach
$4.62Dry Noodles
$4.62 +Matzo Ball soup for 2
$28.95 +Kreplach Soup for 2
$28.95 +Deli Drinks
Dr Browns
$4.62Fountain Soda
$3.80 +Can Soda
$3.80Legendary Egg Cream
$6.96Milkshake (Extra Thick)
$10.47Columbian Coffee
$4.10 +Hot Tea
$4.10 +Juice
$5.79Orange Juice
$6.96Iced Tea
$4.68 +Bottle of Water
$2.93Iced Coffee
$4.68 +Salad Platter
Salad Platter
$25.68Smoked Fish Sld Platter
$31.53Cold Cuts Platters
Assorted Cold Cuts Ala Sarge
Choice of any 4 Meats or Cheese, with Cole Slaw & Potato Salad (Enough for 2)
$46.74 +Cold Roast Beef Platter
$36.21 +Cold Sliced Turkey Platter
Center Cut Slices & Lots of Them, Served with Potato Salad & Cole Slaw
$35.04 +Entrees (Copy)
Pot Roast
$38.55"Specials"
Choice of grilled or boiled knockwurst, served with sauerkraut, baked beans, and french fries
$32.70