Schmackary's
Popular menu items
LARGE ORDER DISCLAIMER
Please Read!
We recommend placing large orders in advance. For orders containing 3 dozen items or more, please place a pre-order at least 1 day in advance. If your order is larger than 3 dozen cookies and is not placed 1 full day before the order, it may be cancelled by the bakery. Thank you.
$0.00Cookie Flights
Today's Flavors
Cookies & Cream Cookie
Dark cocoa, white chocolate, Oreo pieces and vanilla cream cheese frosting.
$3.25 +Black & Tan Cookie
Dark cocoa, semi-sweet chocolate and Guinness. Topped with Guinness infused frosting.
$3.25 +Carrot Cake Cookie
Shredded carrots, sweetened coconut, walnut, raisins, cinnamon and cream cheese frosting.
$3.25 +Lucky Charmed Cookie
Lucky Charms cereal with extra marshmallows, vanilla and marshmallow frosting.
$3.25 +Schmackerdoodle Cookie
Cinnamon sugar chunks, cinnamon chips, white chocolate and rolled in cinnamon sugar.
$3.25 +The Hangover Cookie
Potato chips, walnuts, semi-sweet chocolate, white chocolate, butterscotch, M&Ms, raisins, coconut, cinnamon and oats.
$3.25 +The Hummingbird Cookie
Oats, pineapple, coconut, banana, toasted pecans, vanilla cream cheese frosting. Vegan.
$3.25 +The Peanut Gallery Cookie
Peanut butter, peanut butter chips, and roasted peanut crumbles. There's a chance this cookie contains peanuts...
$3.25 +Peanut Butter Cup Cookie
Peanut butter, semisweet chocolate, mini peanut butter cups, and sea salt.
$3.25 +Yogi Bare Cookie
Oats, peanut butter, cranberries, pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds, slivered almonds, raisins, and apple sauce. Vegan and Gluten-free.
$3.25 +Red, White & Blueberry Cookie
Oats, blueberries, cranberries, Montmorency tart cherries and white chocolate.
$3.25 +Caramel Apple Crisp
oats, Granny Smith apples, white chocolate, toffee bits, cinnamon, topped with salted caramel and streusel
$3.25 +Blueberry Cobbler Cookie
Oats, blueberries, white chocolate, cinnamon, lemon glaze and streusel.
$3.25 +Candy Bar
Snickers, Butterfinger, chocolate toffee bits, peanut bits, peanut butter chips, Reeses Pieces, topped with salted caramel and candy bar bits.
$3.25 +Cereal Killer
Fruity Pebbles, Fruit Loops, Corn Flakes, Rice Krispies, mini marshmallows, topped with marshmallow fluff and toasted cereal mix.
$3.25 +Key Lime Cookie
Key lime oil and zest, white chocolate, pistachios, graham cracker, and lime cream cheese frosting.
$3.25 +The Monster
peanut butter, oats, M&M’s, peanuts bits, semi-sweet chocolate, raisins (gluten-free)
$3.25 +Strawberries & Cream Cookie
Strawberries, white chocolate, topped with strawberry glaze. (gluten free)
$3.25 +Peanut Butter Banana Crunch Cookie
Peanut butter, roasted peanut bits, and crunchy banana chips.
$3.25 +NEW ITEM - @eatingnyc's Chocolate Crunch
triple chocolate cookie / chocolate nutella frosting / sprinkles / crushed peanuts / sugar cone bits
$3.25 +Pumpkin Spice
pumpkin / autumnal spices / cranberries / cinnamon chips / pecans / maple cream cheese frosting
$3.25 +Candied Yam
corn flour / sweet potato / brown sugar / cinnamon / toasted marshmallow (gluten-free)
$3.25 +Peanut Butter After Dark
Dark cocoa, peanut butter, peanut butter chips, and semi-sweet chocolate.
$3.25 +Chocolate Diablo
dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / cayenne pepper / crushed red pepper / cinnamon / paprika
$3.25 +Ginger Rogers
molasses / ginger / white chocolate / cinnamon chips / cinnamon / cloves / black pepper / sweet sugar glaze
$3.25 +Cranberry Dream
oats / dried cranberries / white chocolate chunks / cinnamon / sweet lemon glaze
$3.25 +Mexican Hot Chocolate
Dark cocoa, semi-sweet chocolate, cinnamon, cayenne pepper and powdered sugar. Vegan.
$3.25 +Super "C" Cookie
"Candy Coated Classic Chocolate Chip Cookie" Holiday M&Ms, semi-sweet chocolate, white chocolate and sea salt.
$3.25 +Eggnog Cookie
Nutmeg, Cinnamon and Rum flavored cookie, topped with an eggnog frosting. Gluten free.
$3.25 +Fluffer Nutter
peanuts / peanut butter / peanut butter chips / peanut butter-marshmallow frosting
$3.25 +Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cookie
Semi-sweet chocolate and strawberries, topped with strawberry glaze.
$3.25 +Mocha Java
dark cocoa, semisweet chocolate, espresso & cocoa nibs, topped with vanilla bean and coffee infused frosting.
$3.25 +Treats
Hazel Doodle Cups
Our Schmackerdoodle Cookie baked in a deep dish cup and overflowing with Nutella.
$3.50Doodle Cheesecake Bar
$3.75 +Golden Ticket Bar
$3.75 +Kitchen Sink Bar
Graham cracker crust, Oreos, white & semi-sweet chocolate, butterscotch chips, sweetened coconut, walnut pieces, and sweetened condensed milk.
$3.75 +Rainbow Blondie Bar
$3.75 +Krispie Treats
Every day we take a different kids cereal and turn it into a massive marshmallowy delight! Flavors change daily.
$3.75 +Krispie Swamp Bars
$3.75 +Cookie Cake Slices
Cookie Cakes
Cookies & Cream Cookie Cake
Our Cookies & Cream Cookies, stacked 5 high, layered and topped with our Vanilla Cream Cheese Frosting and oreos.
$30.00Candy Bar Cookie Cake
Our Candy Bar Cookies are stacked 5 high and layered with silky caramel and candy bar pieces, then topped with Chocolate Frosting and more candy bar pieces.
$40.00Red Velvet Cookie Cake
Red Velvet Cookies stacked 5 high, layered and topped with vanilla cream cheese frosting
$40.00Cookie Monster Cookie Cake
Classic Chocolate Chip Cookies, stacked 5 high and layered with Chocolate Frosting, then topped with our signature vanilla cream cheese frosting and decorated like Cookie's favorite Monster.
$45.00Dirty Peppermint Cookie Cake
Dark cocoa, White Chocolate & Peppermint Bits, gone 5 layers deep and topped with our peppermint vanilla frosting!
$40.00Beverages
Boylan's Soda
$2.7520 oz. Smart Water
$2.25Premium Drip Coffee
$2.00 +Old Fashioned Milkshake
Have one of today's cookie flavors blended into a milkshake of your choice!
$5.75 +Latte
$3.75 +Iced Latte
$3.75 +Cappuccino
$3.75 +Americano
$3.25 +Catering Beverages
Catering - Old Fashioned
Catering Best Sellers Cookie Flight
Classic chocolate chip, maple bacon, red velvet and funfetti.
$25.00Catering - Schmalls
Catering - Bars
Catering - Kitchen Sink Bars
Everything but the kitchen sink goes into these decadent treats. Contains nuts.
$21.00 +Catering - Golden Ticket Bars
$21.00 +Catering - Rainbow Blondie Bars
$21.00 +Catering - Brownies
$21.00 +Catering - Rice Krispie Treats
$21.00 +Everyday Classics
Daily Cookies - Monday
Mexican Hot Chocolate
dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / cinnamon / cayenne pepper / powdered sugar (vegan)
$3.25 +Chocolate Covered Pretzel Cookie
Dark cocoa, pretzel bits, semi-sweet chocolate, peanut butter chips and sea salt.
$3.25 +The Hummingbird
Oats, pineapple, coconut, banana, toasted pecans and vanilla cream cheese frosting. Vegan.
$3.25 +Monster Mash Cookie
Peanut butter, oats, m&m's, peanuts, semi-sweet chocolate, and raisins. Gluten-Free.
$3.25 +Ginger Rogers
molasses / ginger / white chocolate / cinnamon chips / cinnamon / cloves / black pepper / sweet sugar glaze
$3.25 +Super C
Candy coated classic chocolate chip cookie - Valentine M&M's, semi-sweet chocolate and sea salt.
$3.25 +Yogi Bare
Oats, peanut butter, cranberries, pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds, slivered almonds, raisins, and apple sauce. Vegan, and gluten-free.
$3.25 +Daily Cookies - Tuesday
Blueberry Cobbler Cookie
Oats, blueberries, white chocolate, cinnamon, lemon glaze and streusel.
$3.25 +Caramel Apple Crisp
Oats, Granny Smith apples, white chocolate, toffee bits, cinnamon, salted caramel and streusel.
$3.25 +Chocolate Diablo Cookie (Tuesday)
Dark cocoa, semi-sweet chocolate, cayenne pepper, crushed red pepper, cinnamon, and paprika.
$3.25 +Chocolate Explosion Cookie
Dark cocoa, semi-sweet chocolate and chocolate cream cheese frosting.
$3.25 +Cookie Dough Cookie (Tuesday)
Sugar cookie base, semi-sweet chocolate chips and cookie dough frosting.
$3.25 +Cookies & Cream Cookie
Dark cocoa, white chocolate, Oreo pieces, and vanilla cream cheese frosting.
$3.25 +Fluffer Nutter
Peanuts, peanut butter, peanut butter chips and peanut butter-marshmallow frosting.
$3.25 +Ginger Rogers
Molasses, ginger, white chocolate, cinnamon chips, cinnamon, cloves, black pepper and sweet sugar glaze.
$3.25 +Mexican Hot Chocolate Cookie (Tuesday)
Dark cocoa, semi-sweet chocolate, cinnamon, cayenne pepper and powdered sugar. Vegan.
$3.25 +PB Remix Cookie
Peanuts, peanut butter, peanut butter chips, chocolate frosting, flutter frosting.
$3.25 +Peanut Butter Cup Cookie (Tuesday)
Peanut butter, semi-sweet chocolate, roasted peanuts and sea salt.
$3.25 +Poisoned Apple Crisp Cookie (Tuesday)
Oats, Granny Smith apples, white chocolate, toffee bits, cinnamon, salted caramel, and streusel.
$3.25 +Pumpkin Spice
Pumpkin, autumnal spices, cranberries, cinnamon chips, pecans, maple cream and cheese frosting.
$3.25 +Thai Chili Peanut Cookie
Peanut butter, garlic, fresh ginger, Thai chilies and sweet & spicy peanut glaze. (Vegan)
$3.25 +Daily Cookies - Wednesday
Red Velvet Cookie
Deep red cocoa, white and semi-sweet chocolate, cream cheese frosting and walnuts.
$3.25 +Pumpkin Spice
pumpkin / autumnal spices / cranberries / cinnamon chips / pecans / maple cream cheese frosting
$3.25 +Chocolate Diablo Cookie (Wednesday)
Dark cocoa, semi-sweet chocolate, cayenne pepper, crushed red pepper, cinnamon and paprika.
$3.25 +Caramel Apple Crisp
$3.25 +Cotton Candy Cookie (Wednesday)
Sweet sugar base, tofu cream cheese and cotton candy butter cream frosting. Vegan.
$3.25 +Dirty Peppermint (Wednesday)
dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / chocolate cream cheese frosting
$3.25 +Hummingbird
oats / pineapple / coconut / banana / toasted pecans / vanilla cream cheese frosting (vegan)
$3.25 +Ginger Rogers
Molasses, ginger, white chocolate, cinnamon chips, cinnamon, cloves, black pepper and sweet sugar glaze.
$3.25 +Glazed Pistachio Cookie (Wednesday)
Chopped pistachios, white chocolate and sweet almond glaze.
$3.25 +PB Remix Cookie
Peanuts, peanut butter, peanut butter chips, chocolate frosting and flutter frosting.
$3.25 +Candied Yam
corn flour / sweet potato / brown sugar / cinnamon / toasted marshmallow (gluten-free)
$3.25 +The Hangover Cookie (Wednesday)
Potato chips, walnuts, semi-sweet chocolate, white chocolate, butterscotch, M&M's, raisins, coconut, cinnamon, and oats.
$3.25 +Yogi Bare
Oats, peanut butter, cranberries, pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds, slivered almonds, raisins, and apple sauce. Vegan and gluten-free.
$3.25 +Daily Cookies - Thursday
Chocolate Duet
deep red cocoa / white and semi-sweet chocolate / cream cheese frosting / walnuts
$3.25 +Chocolate Diablo
dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / cayenne pepper / crushed red pepper / cinnamon / paprika
$3.25 +The Hummingbird
Oats, pineapple, coconut, banana, toasted pecans and vanilla cream cheese frosting. Vegan.
$3.25 +Caramel Apple Crisp
oats / granny smith apples / white chocolate / toffee bits / cinnamon / salted caramel / streusel
$3.25 +Chocolate Covered Pretzel
dark cocoa / pretzel bits / semi-sweet chocolate / peanut butter chips / sea salt
$3.25 +Chocolate Covered Pretzel Cookie
Dark cocoa, pretzel bits, semi-sweet chocolate, peanut butter chips and sea salt.
$3.25 +Chocolate Explosion Cookie (Thursday)
Dark cocoa, semi-sweet chocolate and chocolate cream cheese frosting.
$3.25 +Cookies and Cream Cookie
Dark cocoa, white chocolate, Oreo pieces and vanilla cream cheese frosting.
$3.25 +Pumpkin Spice
pumpkin / autumnal spices / cranberries / cinnamon chips / pecans / maple cream cheese frosting
$3.25 +Hummingbird Cookie (Thursday)
Oats, pineapple, coconut, banana, toasted pecans and vanilla cream cheese frosting. Vegan.
$3.25 +Key Lime Cookie
Key lime oil and zest, whit chocolate, pistachios, graham cracker and lime cream cheese frosting.
$3.25 +Monster
peanut butter / oats / M&M’s / peanuts / semi-sweet chocolate / raisins (gluten-free)
$3.25 +Peanut Butter After Dark Cookie (Thursday)
Dark cocoa, peanut butter, peanut butter chips and semi-sweet chocolate.
$3.25 +Red Velvet Cookie
Deep red cocoa, white and semi-sweet chocolate, cream cheese frosting and walnuts.
$3.25 +The Candy Bar Cookie
Candy mix, peanuts, chocolate toffee bits, candy corn and sweetened coconut.
$3.25 +The Hangover Cookie
Potato chips, walnuts, semi-sweet and white chocolate, butterscotch, M&M's, raisins, coconut, cinnamon and oats.
$3.25 +White Chocolate Cherry Chunker Cookie
White chocolate, Montmorency tart cherries, oats and cinnamon.
$3.25 +Yogi Bare Cookie
Oats, peanut butter, cranberries, pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds, slivered almonds, raisins and applesauce. Vegan. Gluten-free.
$3.25 +Daily Cookies - Friday
Caramel Apple Crisp
$3.25 +Yogi Bare Cookie
Oats, peanut butter, cranberries, pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds, slivered almonds, raisins, apple sauce. Vegan and gluten-free.
$3.25 +Caramel Apple Crisp Cookie
Oats, Granny Smith apples, white chocolate, toffee bits, cinnamon, salted caramel and streusel.
$3.25 +Carrot Cake Cookie (Friday)
Shredded carrots, sweetened coconut, walnut, raisins, cinnamon and cream cheese frosting.
$3.25 +Chocolate Explosion Cookie
Dark cocoa, semi-sweet chocolate and chocolate cream cheese frosting.
$3.25 +Cookies & Cream Cookie
Dark cocoa, white chocolate, Oreo pieces and vanilla cream cheese frosting.
$3.25 +Earl of Chocolate Cookie (Friday)
Semi-sweet chocolate, earl grey, and candied orange peel. Vegan.
$3.25 +Fluffer Nutter
Peanuts, peanut butter, peanut butter chips and peanut butter-marshmallow frosting.
$3.25 +Ginger Rogers
molasses / ginger / white chocolate / cinnamon chips / cinnamon / cloves / black pepper / sweet sugar glaze
$3.25 +The Hummingbird
oats / pineapple / coconut / banana / toasted pecans / vanilla cream cheese frosting (vegan)
$3.25 +Mexican Hot Chocolate Cookie (Friday)
Dark cocoa, semi-sweet chocolate, cinnamon, cayenne pepper and powdered sugar. Vegan.
$3.25 +Monster Cookie
Peanut butter, oats, M&M's, peanuts, semi-sweet chocolate and raisins. Gluten-free.
$3.25 +Peanut Butter After Dark
Dark cocoa, peanut butter, peanut butter chips, and semi-sweet chocolate.
$3.25 +Peanut Butter Patty Cookie
Peanuts, peanut butter, peanut butter chips and chocolate frosting.
$3.25 +Peanut Butter after Dark Cookie (Friday)
Dark cocoa, peanut butter, peanut butter chips and semi-sweet chocolate.
$3.25 +Pumpkin Spice Cookie
Pumpkin, autumnal spices, cranberries, cinnamon chips, pecans and maple cream cheese frosting.
$3.25 +Super C
Candy coated classic chocolate chip cookie - Valentine M&M's, semi-sweet chocolate and sea salt.
$3.25 +The Hangover Cookie (Friday)
Potato chips, walnuts, semi-sweet chocolate, white chocolate, butterscotch, m&m's, raisins, coconut, cinnamon, and oats.
$3.25 +Bacon Chocolate Chip
$3.25 +Yogi Bare
oats / peanut butter / cranberries / pumpkin seeds / sunflower seeds / slivered almonds / raisins / apple sauce (vegan, gluten-free)
$3.25 +Daily Cookies - Saturday
Caramel Apple Crisp
$3.25 +Sweet Corn
Corn flour, cornmeal, sweet corn kernels, cranberries, and pecan bits. Gluten free, contains nuts.
$3.25 +Yogi Bare
Oats, peanut butter, cranberries, pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds, slivered almonds, raisins and applesauce. Vegan and gluten-free.
$3.25 +Candied Yam
Corn flour, sweet potato, brown sugar, cinnamon and toasted marshmallow, gluten free.
$3.25 +Cranberry Dream Cookie
Oats, dried cranberries, white chocolate chunks, cinnamon and lemon glaze.
$3.25 +Fluffer Nutter Cookie
Peanuts, peanut butter, peanut butter chips and peanut butter-marshmallow frosting.
$3.25 +Ginger Rogers (Saturday)
Molasses, ginger, white chocolate, cinnamon chips, cinnamon, cloves, black pepper and sweet sugar glaze.
$3.25 +Glazed Pistachio Cookie (Saturday)
Chopped pistachios, white chocolate and sweet almond glaze.
$3.25 +Honey Bunches Cookie (Saturday)
Oats, honey, granola clusters, toasted almonds and plump raisins.
$3.25 +Hummingbird Cookie (Saturday)
Oats, pineapple, coconut, banana, toasted pecans and vanilla cream cheese frosting. Vegan.
$3.25 +No Tricks, Just Treats Cookie (Saturday)
Candy mix, peanuts, chocolate toffee bits, candy corn, and sweetened coconut.
$3.25 +Peanut Butter Patty Cookie (Saturday)
Peanuts, peanut butter, peanut butter chips and chocolate frosting.
$3.25 +Fluffer Nutter
peanuts / peanut butter / peanut butter chips / peanut butter-marshmallow frosting
$3.25 +Ginger Rogers
molasses / ginger / white chocolate / cinnamon chips / cinnamon / cloves / black pepper / sweet sugar glaze
$3.25 +Red, White & Blue Cookie
Oats, blueberries, cranberries, Montmorency tart cherries and white chocolate.
$3.25 +Strawberries and Cream Cookie (Saturday)
Strawberries and white chocolate and strawberry glaze.
$3.25 +Daily Cookies - Sunday
Blueberry Cobbler Cookie
Oats, blueberries, white chocolate, cinnamon, lemon glaze and streusel.
$3.25 +Monster Cookie
Peanut butter, oats, M&Ms, peanuts, semi-sweet chocolate, and raisins. Gluten-free.
$3.25 +Caramel Apple Crisp
Oats, Granny Smith apples, white chocolate, toffee bits, cinnamon, salted caramel and streusel.
$3.25 +Chocolate Explosion Cookie
Dark cocoa, semi-sweet chocolate and chocolate cream cheese frosting.
$3.25 +Cookies and Cream Cookie
Dark cocoa, white chocolate, Oreo pieces and vanilla cream cheese frosting.
$3.25 +Ginger Rogers Cookie (Sunday)
Molasses, ginger, white chocolate, cinnamon chips, cinnamon, cloves, black pepper and sweet sugar glaze.
$3.25 +Green Tea Cookie (Sunday)
Matcha green tea, white chocolate, macadamia nuts and green tea glaze.
$3.25 +The Hummingbird
Oats, pineapple, coconut, banana, toasted pecans, and vanilla cream cheese frosting. Vegan.
$3.25 +Key Lime
Key lime oil and zest, white chocolate, pistachios, graham crackers and lime cream cheese frosting.
$3.25 +Peanut Butter After Dark
Dark cocoa, peanut butter, peanut butter chips, and semi-sweet chocolate.
$3.25 +Poisoned Apple Crisp Cookie (Sunday)
Oats, Granny Smith apples, white chocolate, toffee bits, cinnamon, salted caramel, and streusel.
$3.25 +Pumpkin Spice
Pumpkin, autumnal spices, cranberries, cinnamon chips, pecans and maple cream cheese frosting.
$3.25 +Red Velvet Cookie
Deep red cocoa, white and semi-sweet chocolate, cream cheese frosting and walnuts.
$3.25 +Super C Cookie
Candy coated classic chocolate chip cookie - Valentine M&M's, semi-sweet chocolate and sea salt.
$3.25 +Sweet Corn Cookie
Corn flour, cornmeal, sweet corn kernels, cranberries and pecan bits. Gluten-free.
$3.25 +The Candy Bar Cookie
Candy mix, peanuts, chocolate toffee bits, candy corn and sweetened coconut.
$3.25 +The Hangover Cookie
Potato chips, walnuts, semi-sweet chocolate, white chocolate, butterscotch, M&Ms, raisins, coconut, cinnamon and oats.
$3.25 +White Chocolate Cherry Chunker Cookie
White chocolate, Montmorency tart cherries, oats and cinnamon.
$3.25 +Yogi Bare Cookie
Oats, peanut butter, cranberries, pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds, slivered almonds, raisins and apple sauce. Vegan and gluten free.
$3.25 +Yogi Bare Cookie
Oats, peanut butter, cranberries, pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds, slivered almonds, raisins and applesauce. Vegan, gluten free.
$3.25 +