Sticky's Finger Joint
MenuAbout
Sticky's Finger Joint Menu

Sticky's Finger Joint

American, Chicken
31 W 8th St, New York, NY 10011
(212) 777-7131
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Chicken Thighs

Menu powered by Grubhub

Hot Honey Thigh Basket (8PC)

8 piece crunchy chicken thighs drizzled with Hot Honey Sauce, dusted with Carolina Reaper flakes and garnsihed with scallions; serived with classic or cajun fries

$13.60 +

Chicken Thigh Basket (8PC)

8 piece crunchy chicken thighs with your choice of two sauces and either classic or cajun fries.

$11.60 +

Chicken Thighs (8PC)

8 piece crunchy chicken thighs with your choice of two sauces.

$8.95 +

Hot Honey Thighs (8PC)

8 piece crunchy chicken thighs drizzled with Hot Honey Sauce, dusted with Carolina Reaper flakes and garnished with scallions

$10.95 +

Desserts

Cookie

Sticky's Best Damn Chocolate Chip Cookie

$2.25

Wraps

Classic Wrap*

Two fingers: crunchy, grilled, or veggie with greens, tomatoes, red onions, carrots, purple slaw vinaigrette in a whole wheat wrap

$10.55 +

Ranch BLT Wrap*

Two fingers: crunchy, grilled, or veggie with greens, tomatoes, red onions, cheddar, chopped bacon, buttermilk baby ranch in a whole wheat wrap. Make it spicy by adding buffalo balsmic maple.

$11.55 +

Chicken 'n Fry Baskets

Large Chicken Popper Basket (16 PC)

16 chicken poppers with your choice of three sauces and either classic or cajun fries.

$13.25 +

Medium Chicken Popper Basket (12 PC)

12 chicken poppers with your choice of two sauces and either classic or cajun fries.

$11.60 +

Small Chicken Popper Basket (8 PC)

8 chicken poppers with your choice of one sauce and either classic or cajun fries.

$9.55 +

Large Chicken Finger Basket (5PC)

5 crunchy fingers with your choice of three sauces and either classic or cajun fries.

$13.25 +

Medium Chicken Finger Basket (4PC)

4 crunchy fingers with your choice of two sauces and either classic or cajun fries.

$11.60 +

Small Chicken Finger Basket (3PC)

3 crunchy fingers with your choice of one sauce and either classic or cajun fries.

$9.55 +

Large Grilled Finger Basket (5PC)

5 grilled fingers with your choice of three sauces and either classic or cajun fries.

$13.25 +

Medium Grilled Finger Basket (4PC)

4 grilled fingers with your choice of two sauces and either classic or cajun fries.

$11.60 +

Small Grilled Finger Basket (3PC)

3 grilled fingers with your choice of one sauce and either classic or cajun fries.

$9.55 +

Vegetarian Classics

Large Mushroom Popper Basket (16 PC)

[Vegan] 16 bite-sized crunchy crimini mushrooms with your choice of one sauce and either classic or cajun fries.

$13.25 +

Medium Mushroom Popper Basket (12 PC)

[Vegan] 12 bite-sized crunchy crimini mushrooms with your choice of two sauces and either classic or cajun fries.

$11.60 +

Small Mushroom Popper Basket (8 PC)

[Vegan] 8 bite-sized crunchy crimini mushrooms with your choice of three sauces and either classic or cajun fries.

$9.55 +

Large Mushroom Poppers (16 PC)

[Vegan] 16 bite-sized crunchy crimini mushrooms with your choice of one sauce.

$10.95 +

Medium Mushroom Poppers (12 PC)

[Vegan] 12 bite-sized crunchy crimini mushrooms with your choice of two sauces.

$8.95 +

Small Mushroom Poppers (8 PC)

[Vegan] 8 bite-sized crunchy crimini mushrooms with your choice of three sauces.

$7.25 +

Large Veggie Finger Basket (5PC)

5 vegetarian fingers with your choice of three sauces and either classic or cajun fries.

$13.25 +

Medium Veggie Finger Basket (4PC)

4 vegetarian fingers with your choice of two sauces and either classic or cajun fries.

$11.60 +

Small Veggie Finger Basket (3PC)

3 vegetarian fingers with your choice of one sauce and either classic or cajun fries.

$9.55 +

Large Veggie Fingers (5PC)

5 vegetarian fingers with your choice of three sauces.

$10.95 +

Medium Veggie Fingers (4PC)

4 vegetarian fingers with your choice of two sauces.

$8.95 +

Small Veggie Fingers (3PC)

3 vegetarian fingers with your choice of one sauce.

$7.25 +

Chicken

Large Chicken Fingers (5PC)

5 crunchy fingers with your choice of three sauces.

$10.95 +

Medium Chicken Fingers (4PC)

4 crunchy fingers with your choice of two sauces.

$8.95 +

Small Chicken Fingers (3PC)

3 crunchy fingers with your choice of one sauce.

$7.25 +

Large Chicken Poppers (16 PC)

16 chicken poppers with your choice of three sauces.

$10.95 +

Medium Chicken Poppers (12 PC)

12 chicken poppers with your choice of two sauces.

$8.95 +

Small Chicken Poppers (8 PC)

8 chicken poppers with your choice of one sauce.

$7.25 +

Large Grilled Chicken Tenders (5PC)

5 grilled tenders with your choice of three sauces.

$10.95 +

Medium Grilled Chicken Tenders (4PC)

4 grilled tenders with your choice of two sauces.

$8.95 +

Small Grilled Chicken Tenders (3PC)

3 grilled tenders with your choice of one sauce.

$7.25 +

Sandwiches

Classic Sandwich

Sticky's sauce, purple slaw, pickles and your choice of two fingers: crunchy, grilled or veggie in between a potato bun. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$11.45 +

Spicy Chicken Sandwich

Sticky's sauce, nashville numb, cumin, pickles and your choice of two fingers: crunchy, grilled or veggie in between a potato bun. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$11.45 +

Bacon Mac Sandwich

Mac Sauce, chopped bacon, caramelized onions, pickles and your choice of two fingers: crunchy, grilled or veggie in between a potato bun. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$12.45 +

Honey BBQ Sandwich

Sassy BBQ, honey, chopped bacon, cheddar, pickles and your choice of two fingers: crunchy, grilled or veggie in between a potato bun. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$12.45 +

Signatures

Thai Fiesta - Large

Mac sauce, thai sweet chili, taco seasoning, B&W sesame seeds over your choice of 3 tenders or 8 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$13.25 +

Thai Fiesta - Medium

Mac sauce, thai sweet chili, taco seasoning, B&W sesame seeds over your choice of 4 tenders or 12 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$10.95 +

Thai Fiesta -Small

Mac sauce, thai sweet chili, taco seasoning, B&W sesame seeds over your choice of 5 tenders or 16 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$9.25 +

Buffalo Ranch - Large

Buffalo balsamic maple, Buttermilk baby ranch, carrots on side and parsley over your choice of 5 fingers or 16 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$13.25 +

Buffalo Ranch - Medium

Buffalo balsamic maple, Buttermilk baby ranch, carrots on side and parsley over your choice of 4 fingers or 12 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$10.95 +

Buffalo Ranch - Small

Buffalo balsamic maple, Buttermilk baby ranch, carrots on side and parsley over your choice of 3 fingers or 8 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$9.25 +

General Sticky 'Tso - Large

General t'sticky sauce, scallions, hot peppers, B&W sesame seeds over your choice of 5 fingers or 16 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$13.25 +

General Sticky 'Tso - Medium

General t'sticky sauce, scallions, hot peppers, B&W sesame seeds over your choice of 4 fingers or 12 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$10.95 +

General Sticky 'Tso - Small

General t'sticky sauce, scallions, hot peppers, B&W sesame seeds over your choice of 3 fingers or 8 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$9.25 +

Honey BBQ - Large

Sassy BBQ, honey, chopped bacon, shredded cheddar over your choice of 5 fingers or 16 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$14.25 +

Honey BBQ - Medium

Sassy BBQ, honey, chopped bacon, shredded cheddar over your choice of 4 fingers or 12 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$11.95 +

Honey BBQ - Small

Sassy BBQ, honey, chopped bacon, shredded cheddar over your choice of 3 fingers or 8 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$10.25 +

Vampire Killer - Large

Vampire aioli, grated parmesan, garlic chips, pink peppercorn flakes over your choice of 5 fingers or 16 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$13.25 +

Vampire Killer - Medium

Vampire aioli, grated parmesan, garlic chips, pink peppercorn flakes over your choice of 4 fingers or 12 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$10.95 +

Vampire Killer - Small

Vampire aioli, grated parmesan, garlic chips, pink peppercorn flakes over your choice of 3 fingers or 8 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.

$9.25 +

Specialty

Popper Nachos

Homemade Tortlla Chips, chicken poppers, pico de gallo, mac sauce, cray sauce, B&W sesame seeds.

$11.90 +

Double Carlos' Hot Chicken (2PC)

Two Chicken fingers coated in Carlos’s blazing hot Carolina Reaper sauce served on two pieces of potato bread with pickles.

$8.95 +

Single Carlos' Hot Chicken (1PC)

One chicken finger coated in Carlos’s blazing hot Carolina Reaper sauce served on a piece of potato bread with pickles.

$4.95 +

Chicken n' Waffles

Waffle sauce, graham crackers, and crushed red pepper flakes over a mix of chicken poppers and bite-sized waffles.

$10.95 +

Salads

Classic Salad

Two fingers: crunchy, grilled, or veggie over a bed of greens, tomatoes, red onions, carrots, purple slaw, vinaigrette.

$10.55 +

Ranch BLT Salad

Two fingers: crunchy, grilled, or veggie over a bed of greens, tomatoes, red onions, cheddar, chopped bacon, buttermilk baby ranch. Make it spicy by adding buffalo balsamic maple.

$11.55 +

Fries

Classic Fries

3/8th" straight cut fries with crispy batter.

$4.45 +

Cajun Fries

3/8th" straight cut fries with cajun seasoning.

$4.45 +

Bacon Mac Fries

3/8th" straight cut fries dressed with mac sauce and chopped bacon, parsley.

$6.45 +

Truffle Parm Fries

3/8th" straight cut fries tossed in truffle salt and parmesan cheese, parsley

$6.45 +

Fiesta Fries

3/8th" straight cut fries dressed with Thai SweetChili sauce and mac sauce, and topped with taco seasoning and B&W sesame seeds, parsley.

$5.45 +

S'more Fries

3/8th" straight cut fries dressed with marshmallow sauce, chocolate sauce, crushed graham crackers and mini marshmallows, parsley.

$6.45 +

Sauces

Buffalo Balsamic Maple

Homemade buffalo w/a splash of balsamic and maple syrup.

$0.85

Buttermilk Baby Ranch

The anti-hidden valley ranch.

$0.85

Caribbean Sweet Heat

Hot pineapple mango chutney.

$0.85

Chipotle Aioli

Creamy chipotle pepper dip.

$0.85

Cray

Peruvian inspired cilantro jalapeño sauce.

$0.85

General T'sticky

A sticky’s take on the traditional american-chinese sauce.

$0.85

Hot asian BBQ

Pan Asian sweet and spicy BBQ.

$0.85

Lemon Picata

Light & fresh lemon aioli with garlic & capers.

$0.85

Mac Sauce

Cheddar cheese sauce w/diced jalapeño.

$0.85

Nashville Numb

Southern & szechuan inspired hot sauce.

$0.85

S'more Sauce

Chocolate + marshmallow.

$0.85

Salsa Verde

Spicy Mexican roasted green pepper sauce.

$0.85

Sassy BBQ

Sweet and tangy BBQ sauce.

$0.85

Sticky's Sauce

Creamy white BBQ sauce, our namesake.

$0.85

Sunny Mustard

A soon-to-be-classic honey mustard.

$0.85

Thai Sweet

Sweet-n-sour w/mild chili flakes.

$0.85

Vampire Aioli

Creamy roasted garlic dip.

$0.85

Waffle Sauce

Sweet maple frosting.

$0.85

Drinks

Strawberry Lemonade

Homemade lemonade made with meyer lemons and strawberries.

$3.55

Mango Mint Splash

Homemade mango nectar with mint leaves and a splash of lemon juice.

$4.05

Slightly Sweet Tea

Homemade black pekoe tea with honey and lemon.

$3.25

Bottled Water

$2.05

Watermelon Lemon Lime Soda

Sticky's Own Watermelon Lemon Lime Soda

$3.25

Sides

Pickles

Sliced crunchy dill pickles in a 4oz container.

$2.45

Purple Slaw

Vinegar based red cabbage slaw with herb seasoning in a 4oz container.

$2.45

Side Salad

Mixed greens, tomatoes, carrots and red onions. Comes with sticky’s vinaigrette.

$5.45
FYI, this restaurant is not accepting orders right now.

About Sticky's Finger Joint

  • 31 W 8th St, New York, NY 10011
  • American, Chicken, Sandwiches, Vegetarian
  • (212) 777-7131
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / Sticky's Finger Joint
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.