Sugar Sketch
MenuAbout
Sugar Sketch Menu

Sugar Sketch

Bakery, Dessert
172 E 2nd St, New York, NY 10009
(646) 776-4555
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Baby Cupcakes

***CHRISTMAS SPECIAL*** buy 6, get 8

Assorted

$15.00

Make Your Own Baby Cupcake

$2.50 +

*** xmas Special*** Gingerbread Baby Cupcake

Gingerbread Cupcake, Vanilla Buttercream, Cinnamon and Gingerbread Crumbs

$2.50

*** NEW *** Cookies For Santa Baby Cupcake

Vanilla Cupcake, Vanilla Buttercream, Chopped Dark Chocolate, Mini Oreo Cookie

$2.50

*** NEW *** Nutella Cookies for Santa Baby Cupcake

Chocolate Cupcake, Nutella Buttercream, Nutella Drizzle and Chocolate Covered Oreos

$2.50

Banana Split Baby Cupcake

Banana Cupcake with Chocolate Buttercream, caramel drizzle

$2.50

Roasted Almond Baby Cupcake

Vanilla cupcake, Roasted Almond buttercream topped with Almonds (* contains nuts )

$2.50

Almond Biscotto Baby Cupcake

Biscotto Cupcake, Chocolate Buttercream, Almonds and Chocolate Sauce

$2.50

Salted Caramel Baby Cupcake

Chocolate Cupcake, Salted Caramel Buttercream, Salted Caramel Drizzle

$2.50

Red Carpet Baby Cupcake

Red Velvet Cupcake with Cream Cheese Frosting, caramel drizzle

$2.50

Jack O' Lantern Baby Cupcake

Pumpkin Cupcake, Cream Cheese Frosting, Caramel Drizzle

$2.50

Chocolate Splash Baby Cupcake

Chocolate cupcake, chocolate buttercream, chocolate sauce and chocolate crumbs

$2.50

Amarena Baby Cupcake

Vanilla Cupcake, Amarena Syrup, and Amarena Buttercream

$2.50

Tiramisu' Baby Cupcake

Vanilla Cupcake soaked in Espresso, Topped with Mascarpone Buttercream and Cocoa

$2.50

Birthday Cake Baby Cupcake

Vanilla cake with strawberry buttercream and strawberry sauce

$2.50

Nutella Baby Cupcake

Vanilla cupcake with Nutella Buttercream and nutella drizzle

$2.50

Chocolate Peanut Butter Baby cupcake

Chocolate Cupcake, Peanut Butter Buttercream, Peanuts

$2.50

Funfetti Cream Cheese Baby Cupcake

Chocolate Cupcake, Funfetti Cream Cheese Frosting

$2.50

Funfetti Baby Cupcake

Funfetti cupcake, funfetti buttercream

$2.50

Chocolate Madness Baby Cupcake

Chocolate Cupcake, White Chocolate Buttercream, topped with M&M's and chocolate sauce

$2.50

Pistachio Baby Cupcake

Vanilla cupcake, Pistachio Buttercream

$2.50

12. Mini PB & J

Vanilla cake, peanut butter center, strawberry buttercream, crushed peanuts and strawberry sauce

$2.50

13. Mini Raspberry Temptation

Chocolate cupcake with raspberry buttercream with raspberry and chocolate drizzle

$2.50

15. Mini Magic Bar

Coconut cake with chocolate buttercream and coconut flakes

$2.50

17. Mini Brunch Cupcake

Vanilla Cupcake, Caramel-Maple filling with crispy prosciutto, Vanilla Buttercream, Crispy prosciutto and Caramel-Maple drizzle

$2.00

2. Mini Gianduiotto

Gianduia Cupcake with chocolate buttercream and hazelnuts

$2.50

20. Mini Raspberry Lemonade

Lemon Cupcake, Raspberry Buttercream, Raspberry Sauce

$2.50

21. Mini Snoopy Cupcake

Chocolate Cupcake, Cream Cheese Frosting, Chocolate Sauce

$2.50

23. Mini Blue Velvet

Mini Blue Velvet Cupcake with Cream Cheese Frosting and Caramel Drizzle

$2.50

That's Amore! Baby Cupcake

Amaretto Cupcake, Vanilla Buttercream, Almonds

$2.50

9. Mini Apple Twist

Vanilla cupcake with apple/cinnamon center, cinnamon buttercream, salted caramel drizzle

$2.50

Bouncing Bean Baby Cupcake

Coffee cupcake, Chocolate Buttercream, Chocolate/Coffee drizzle

$2.50

Cookies and Cream Baby Cupcake

Vanilla Cupcake, Cookies and Cream Buttercream, Chocolate Sauce

$2.50

Dulce & Gabbana Baby Cupcake

Vanilla Cupcake, Vanilla Buttercream, Dulce the Leche drizzle

$2.50

Gianduiotto Baby Cupcake

Gianduia Cupcake with Chocolate Buttercream and Hazelnuts

$2.50

Mini Go Bananas!

Banana cookie cupcake with Cream Cheese Frosting, chocolate sauce

$2.50

Nuvola Baby Cupcake

Vanilla cupcake with vanilla buttercream and vanilla cake crumbs

$2.50

That's Amore Baby Cupcake

Amaretto Cupcake, Vanilla Buttercream, topped with almonds

$2.50

Gluten Free Cupcakes

Gluten Free Nuvola

Vanilla gluten free cupcake, vanilla cream filling and vanilla buttercream, topped with salted caramel.

$4.00

Gluten Free Chocolate Splash

Chocolate gluten free cupcake, chocolate cream filling and chocolate buttercream, topped with chocolate flakes and chocolate sauce.

$4.00

Gluten Free Red Carpet

Red velvet gluten free cupcake, caramel and pecan filling and cream cheese frosting, topped with caramel and pecans.

$4.00

Gluten Free S'Mores

Gluten Free Vanilla Cake, Chocolate Cream Filling, Chocolate Buttercream, Marshmallows

$4.00

Gluten Free Birthday Cake

Gluten Free Vanilla Cake, Whipped Cream Filling, Strawberry Buttercream, Strawberry Sauce

$4.00

Gluten Free Caramello

Gluten Free Vanilla Cake, Salted Caramel Filling, Vanilla Buttercream, Salted Caramel Drizzle

$4.00

Gluten Free Apple Twist

Gluten Free Vanilla Cake, Apple Cinnamon Filling, Cinnamon Buttercream, Salted Caramel Drizzle

$4.00

Gluten Free Cupid

Gluten Free Chocolate Cake, Vanilla Cream Filling, Strawberry Buttercream, Strawberry Sauce

$4.00

Gluten Free Cherry Blossom

Gluten Free Chocolate Cake, Whipped Cream Filling, Cherry Buttercream, Chocolate flakes

$4.00

Gluten Free Lampone

Gluten Free Vanilla cake, raspberry filling, raspberry buttercream, raspberry drizzle

$4.00

1. Gianduiotto

Gianduia cupcake, chocolate cream filling, chocolate buttercream, hazelnuts

$4.25

2. S'mores

Chocolate cupcake, Vanilla cream filling, Chocolate buttercream, marshmallows

$4.25

3. Snowflake

Coconut cupcake, coconut cream filling, coconut buttercream, coconut flakes

$4.25

4. Red Carpet

red velvet cupcake, caramel filling, cream cheese frosting, caramel drizzle

$4.25

5. That's Amore!

Amaretto cupcake, whipped cream filling, vanilla buttercream, almonds

$4.25

6. Chocolate splash

chocolate cupcake, chocolate cream filling, chocolate buttercream, chocolate sauce

$4.25

7. Birthday Cake

Vanilla cupcake, Whipped cream filling, strawberry buttercream, strawberry sauce

$4.25

8. Apple Twist

Vanilla cupcake, apple/cinnamon filling, vanilla buttercream, cinnamon and salted caramel drizzle

$4.25

9. Nuvola

Vanilla cupcake, vanilla cream filling, vanilla buttercream

$4.25

10. PB & J

Vanilla Cupcake, Peanut butter filling, strawberry buttercream, crushed peanuts and strawberry sauce

$4.25

11. Raspberry Temptation

Chocolate cupcake, raspberry filling, raspberry buttercream, chocolate sauce

$4.25

12. Funfetti

Funfetti cupcake, whipped cream filling, funfetti buttercream

$4.25

13. Magic Bar

Coconut cupcake, chocolate cream filling, chocolate buttercream, coconut flakes

$4.25

14. Bouncing Bean

Coffee Cupcake, Whipped cream filling, chocolate buttercream and chocolate/coffee sauce

$4.25

Gluten Free Cupcake

Assorted flavors --- please call the bakery for daily selection

$4.25

Gluten Free Mini Cupcakes

Assorted flavors - please call the bakery for daily selection. Gluten Free Cupcakes dry fast - to avoid this, we bake them to order! Please allow 20-30 minutes for baking.

$3.00

Gluten Free Large Cupcakes

Assorted flavors - please call the bakery for daily selection. Gluten Free Cupcakes dry fast - to avoid this, we bake them to order! Please allow 20-30 minutes for baking.

$4.50

Christmas Specials

The Grinch Cupcake

Vanilla Green Cupcake, Vanilla Buttercream

$5.00

Santa Cupcake

Vanilla Cupcake, Vanilla Buttercream

$5.00

Christmas Tree Cupcake

Vanilla Cupcake, Vanilla Buttercream, M&M's

$4.50

Christmas Swirl Cupcake

Vanilla Cupcake, Vanilla Buttercream

$4.50

Gingerbread Cookie

$2.00

Cookies

*** NEW *** Gingerbread Cookie

$2.50

double chocolate chocolate chunk

$3.50

Chocolate Chunk Cookie

$3.50

Snickerdoodle Cookie

$3.50

Rocky Road Cookie

$4.00

All Nuts Cookie

$4.00

Biscotti

Traditional almond biscotti.

$1.75

Bull's eye Cookie

With assorted jams

$2.50

Canestrelli Cookies

Italian Sugar Cookie

$1.25

Chocolate Chip Sugar Drizzle

$1.50

Crostata Cookies

Assorted Jams

$1.75

Funfetti Cookie

$3.50

Funfetti Sugar Drizzle

$1.50

Gluten Free Tea Time Cookie

assorted jams; Gluten Free

$2.00

Lemon Apricot Drop

Lemon cookie with Apricot Preserves

$1.00

Lemony Braid

Lemon Cookie with apricot glaze

$1.00

Mezzo Bacio

Hazelnut cookies with chocolate drizzle

$1.75

Mini Chocolate Cookie Sandwich

$1.50

Mocha chocolate chunk Cookie

Coffee cookie with chocolate chunk

$4.00

Oatmeal Cookie

$2.75

Oatmeal Cranberry Cookie

$2.00

Pumpkin Biscotti

$1.75

Rainbow Cookie

Almond cookie layers alternated with apricot preserves.

$2.00

S'mores Cookie

Double chocolate Chunk cookie with Marshmallows

$2.75

Small Cherry-Chocolate Oatmeal Cookie

$2.75

Small Funfetti Cookie

Large funfettI cookie

$2.75

Small Rocky Road Cookie

$2.75

White Chocolate Chip Sugar Drizzle

$1.50

White Chocolate Chunk Cookie

$4.00

White Chocolate Chunk Cookie

$2.75

Pound Cakes and dessert

*** NEW *** Tiramisu Cups

Layers of Mascarpone cream and lady fingers soaked in espresso

$5.00

PUMPKIN Pie bite

1.5" mini pumpkin pie ( contains nuts*)

$2.00

PECAN pie bite

1.5" mini pecan pie ( contains nuts *)

$2.00

mixed berry Pound Cake

$7.00 +

Apple Pound Cake

$5.00 +

Blueberry Pound Cake

$5.00 +

Marble Pound Cake

$5.00 +

Chocolate Pear Pound cake

$5.00 +

Pumpkin Pecan Pound Cake

$5.00 +

*** NEW *** Cannoli

Whipped ricotta filing in a crunchy cannoli shell

$3.00 +

Almond Croissant

$3.50

Apple Muffin

Filled with Apple/cinnamon filling and topped with cinnamon sugar!

$3.75

Banana Nutella Muffin

Vanilla Muffin Filled with fresh Bananas and Nutella

$3.75

Blueberry Bar

Vanilla blueberry.

$3.00

Blueberry Muffin

With Mixed Berry Filling

$3.75

Blueberry Scone

$2.75

Blueberry Yogurt Parfait

Our delicious yogurt, blueberry filling, and granola. All made fresh in house!

$3.00

Cinnamon Bun

$3.50

Coconut Brioche

$3.50

Honey Yogurt Parfait

Our delicious yogurt, honey, and granola. All made fresh in house!

$3.00

Magic Bar

Coconut and chocolate.

$3.00

Marble Muffin

Vanilla Muffin filled with Chocolate Ganache and Chocolate Chunks

$3.00

Mini Apple Turnover

$2.50

Mixed Berry Muffin

Muffin with mixed berry filling and chunks of mixed berries

$3.75

Nutella Muffin

Filled and topped with Nutella

$3.75

Pumpkin Muffin

With Cream Cheese Filling

$3.50

Raspberry Muffin

With Raspberry Filling

$3.50

Raspberry Muffin

Raspberry Muffin with Raspberry Filling

$3.50

Raspberry Yogurt Parfait

Our delicious yogurt, raspberry filling, and granola. All made fresh in house!

$3.00

Pies and Bars

*** NEW *** 9" Apple Pie

Contains Nuts

$30.00

*** NEW *** 9" Pecan Pie

Contains Nuts

$30.00

*** NEW *** 9" Pumpkin Pie

Contains Nuts

$30.00

Pecan Pie Slice

Contains Nuts

$4.00 +

Apple Pie Slice

Contains Nuts

$4.00 +

Pumpkin Pie Bites

1.5" mini pumpkin pie ( contains nuts*)

$2.00

Pecan Pie Bites

1.5 " mini pecan pie ( contains nuts *)

$2.00

Pumpkin Pie slice

Contains Nuts

$4.00 +

Individual Apple Pie

Contains Nuts

$5.00 +

Individual Pumpkin Pie

Contains nuts

$5.00

Individual Pecan Pie

Contains Nuts

$5.00

*** NEW*** Individual Banana cream pie

Banana filling and vanilla pastry cream, topped with fresh whipped cream

$5.00

***NEW*** Chocolate and cream fruit tart

Freshly baked tart shell filled with dark chocolate , homemade pastry cream and topped with fresh berries

$7.00

4" Apple-Almond Tart Pie

$4.00

4" Banana Cream Pie

$4.00

4" Coconut Cream Pie

$4.00

4" Key Lime Pie

$4.00

4" Pecan Pie

$4.00

9" Pumpkin Pie, with No Nuts

$35.00

9" Sweet Potato Pie

$35.00

Apple Pie Slice

$2.75

Blueberry Bar

Vanilla- Blueberry Bar

$3.00

Brownie Bar

Dark Chocolate Brownie

$3.00

Brownie Bites

Dark Chocolate Brownie Bites

$2.00

Crostata Bar

Italian -style bar with jam

$2.75

Granola Bar

With Assorted dried fruits

$3.00

Individual Apple Cream Tart

$5.00

Individual Banana Nutella Cream Tart

$5.00

Individual Blueberry Cream Tart

$5.00

Individual Mixed Berry Cream Tart

$5.00

Individual Strawberry Cream Tart

$5.00

Individual apple cranberry pie

Contains Nuts

$5.00 +

Lemon Bar

$3.00

Lemon Bar

Lemon dreams come true

$2.50

Magic Bar

Chocolate and Coconut

$2.75

Magic Bar

Chocolate- Coconut Bar

$3.00

Peanut Butter Bar

Chocolate and Peanut Butter

$2.75

Pecan Pie Slice

$2.75

Pie Slice

Assorted flavors - call the bakery for daily selction

$4.00

Pumpkin Pie Slice

$2.75

S'mores Bar

Chocolate, vanilla, marshmallows

$2.75

Seasonal Cake Pops

Assorted Flavors decorated with seasonal sprinkles. Available now: Halloween pops!

$2.50

Sweet Potato Pie Slice

$2.75

Gluten Free Mini cupcakes

1. Gianduiotto

gianduia cupcake with chocolate buttercream and hazelnuts

$2.50

Italian Cookies and Biscotti

*** NEW *** Amaretto Cookies

$1.00

Baci (Lady Kisses)

Hazelnut Cookies with Chocolate Ganache

$1.00

Pumpkin Biscotti

$1.00

Pops and mini cakes

Oscars Mini Cupcakes!

Vanilla and Chocolate. Decorated with Marshmallow Popcorn - YUM!

$5.00

Oscars Cupcake Package

4 Oscars Marshmallow Popcorn Cupcakes

$18.00

Cake Pops

Assorted Flavors

$2.50

Mini Assorted flowers

Assorted colorful flowers - mini cupcakes. Vanilla

$5.00

Artichoke Truffle Panzerotto

Italian Style Empanada filled with artichokes, truffles, and cheddar cheese

$6.00

Christmas Canestrelli Cookie

Italian Canestrelli cookie dough, with the colors of the season (green, white, and red) in assorted shapes (Santa boot, Santa glove, Candy Cane, and Christmas tree). Dusted with powdered Sugar

$1.75

Christmas Cookie Ornament

Crostata Cookies cut in the shape of a star, with a heart of either red or green hard candy. String is applied to display on your christmas tree!

$3.00

Dark Chocolate Mousse

$5.00

Decorated Sugar Cookies

Seasonal Decorations. Call the Bakery for daily design

$5.00

Gingerbread Man Cookie

Traditional GingerBread Man Cookie

$2.00

Meringue Kisses

$1.00

Nutella Snow Ball

Soft Vanilla Cake filled with Nutella, topped with marshmallows and coconut flakes

$3.00

Red Roses

Chocolate large red Roses

$6.00

Rollercoaster Bites

Soft Vanilla Cake Roll filled with Vanilla Buttercream

$3.50

Royal Cookie

Sugar Cookies decorated with royal icing. Assorted shapes: Raindeer, Santa, and Snowman

$3.75

Snow Ball

Soft Vanilla Cake filled with Vanilla pastry cream, Topped with marshmallows and coconut flakes

$3.00

Sugar Cookies

$2.00

Sugar Cookies - large

$3.00

Unicorn Cupcakes- contains nuts

Amaretto cupcake, unicorn decoration!

$8.00

St Patty's Shamrock Large Vanilla Cupcake

$6.50

St. Patty's Mini Shamrock Vanilla Cupcake

$4.50

St. Patty's Gold Coins Large Vanilla Cupcake

$6.50

St. Patty's Gold Coins Mini Vanilla Cupcake

$4.50

6 Mini St. Patty's Cupcake Package - Vanilla

$25.00

6 Large St. Patty's Cupcake Package

$35.00

Choco- Peanut Butter Mini Cupcake

Chocolate Cupcake, Peanut Butter Buttercream, Peanuts

$2.50

Piggy Pops

Pigs! Funfetti Pops, covered in white pink chocolate.

$4.50

Bunny pops

Bunnies! Banana Pops, covered in white chocolate

$4.50

Chicks Pops

Chicks! Vanilla Pops, covered in yellow white chocolate.

$4.50

Birdy Pops

Birds! Vanilla Pops, covered in blue white chocolate

$4.50

Mini Bunny Butt Cupcake

Carrot or Vanilla

$5.00

Mini Carrot and Easter Egg Cupcake

Vanilla Cupcake decorated with Carrot and Easter egg

$5.00

Bunny Butt Mini Cake

Red Velvet Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting

$10.00

Butter Cookies

Delicious Butter Cookies with Sea Salt

$2.00

Buttercream Flowers Mini Cupcake

Vanilla or Chocolate

$3.00

Buttercream Flowers Large Cupcake

Vanilla or Chocolate

$4.50

Buttercream Flowers Mini Cupcakes - pack of 6

Vanilla or Chocolate

$15.00

Buttercream Flowers Large Cupcakes - pack of 6

Vanilla or Chocolate

$20.00

Buttercream Flowers Mini Cupcakes - pack of 12

Vanilla or Chocolate

$30.00

Buttercream Flowers Large Cupcakes - pack of 12

Vanilla or Chocolate

$50.00

Buttercream Flowers Mini Cakes

Vanilla Cakes, Salted caramel and vanilla buttercream; Chocolate cakes, salted caramel, vanilla buttercream - topped with buttercream flowers

$6.00

Cake Tasting

Red Velvet Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting, Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Buttercream, Vanilla Cake with Vanilla Buttercream, and Ice Box Inspired Cake tasting

$8.00

Red velvet mini cake

$5.50

Cakes

5" Rev Velvet Cake - feeds 4-5

Red Velvet Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting $5 fee applies for piped writing

$40.00

5" Chocolate Cake - feeds 4-5

Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Buttercream $5 fee applies for piped writing

$40.00

5" Vanilla Cake - feeds 4-5

Vanilla Cake with Vanilla Buttercream $5 fee applies for piped writing

$40.00

Cookie Monster Mini Cake

Blue Vanilla and Chocolate Buttercream

$6.00

Flower Mini Cake

Yellow Vanilla with Strawberry Buttercream, topped with white Buttercream Roses

$6.00

Mini Cake

Assorted Flavors

$6.00

Savory

Italian Cheese Clouds

Italian take on traditional Brazilian pao de queijo. Cheese puffs with cheddar cheese, Parmesan cheese, rosemary, and prosciutto. Gluten free.

$3.50

Traditional Cheese Clouds

Italian take on traditional Brazilian pao de queijo. Cheese puffs with Parmesan and feta cheese. Topped with cheddar cheese, Parmesan cheese, rosemary prosciutto and sea salt. Gluten free.

$3.50

Olive Cheese Clouds

Italian take on traditional Brazilian pao de queijo. Cheese puffs with Parmesan and feta cheese. Topped with cheddar cheese, Parmesan cheese, and mixed olives. Gluten free.

$3.50

Truffle Cheese Clouds

Italian take on traditional Brazilian pao de queijo. Cheese puffs with cheddar cheese, Parmesan cheese and truffle oil. Gluten free.

$3.50

4" Quiche

$4.00

Italian Panzerotto

Empanada filled with prosciutto, cheddar cheese, cherry tomatoes and rosemary.

$5.00

Truffle Panzerotto

Empanada filled with artichoke and truffles.

$5.50

Spinach and Ricotta Turnover

$4.50

Valentine's Day Treats

We Go Together Like Milk and Cookies

Sugar Cookies

$18.00

Sweethearts Cookie Package

Sugar Cookies

$18.00

I Love You To Pizzas!

Sugar Cookies

$18.00

You Stay The Hell Away From Me!

Sugar Cookies

$18.00

5" Heart Cookie

$9.00
FYI, this restaurant is not accepting orders right now.

About Sugar Sketch

  • 172 E 2nd St, New York, NY 10009
  • Bakery, Dessert, Dinner
  • (646) 776-4555
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / Sugar Sketch
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.