Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery
MenuAbout
Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery Menu

Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery

Bakery, Breakfast
365 Grand St, New York, NY 10002
(212) 995-1960
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

The Cast Cupcakes

Menu powered by Grubhub

I love you 4 pack

This assorted 4 pack of assorted cupcakes is sure to win you a kiss this Valentine's Day. Sprinkles may vary.

$20.00

I love you assorted 6 pack

This assorted 6 pack of assorted cupcakes is sure to win you a kiss this Valentine's Day. Sprinkles may vary.

$30.00

Sunshine Cupcake

Classic yellow cake with vanilla buttercream. Colors for icing vary and so do sprinkles

$4.35 +

Black and White Just Right Cupcake

Dark chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream. Icing color and sprinkles may vary.

$4.35 +

Bob Cupcake

Yellow cake with chocolate almond buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.

$4.35 +

Ooey Gooey Cupcake

Dark chocolate cake with chocolate almond buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.

$4.35 +

Sexy Red Velvet Cupcake

Red velvet cake with satin buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.

$4.35 +

Sassy Red Velvet Cupcake

Red velvet cake with chocolate almond buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.

$4.35 +

Lemon Yummy Cupcake

Lemon cake with lemon buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.

$4.35 +

Strawberry Cupcake with Cream Cheese

Strawberry cake with cream cheese icing. Also known as The Strawberry Shortcake Cupcake. Sprinkles may vary. Strawberries on the side, not included.

$4.35

Pistachio Cupcake

Pistachio cake with satin buttercream with a pistachio on top.

$4.35 +

Oreo Cookie Cupcake

Oreo cupcake with cream cheese with cookie crumble on top.

$4.35 +

Faux-conut Cupcake

Yellow cake with vanilla buttercream and coconut shreds.

$4.35 +

Pumpkin Cupcake

Pumpkin cake with cream cheese icing with a walnut on top.

$4.35 +

German Chocolate Cupcake

This light chocolate cake topped with a coconut, pecan topping is sure to make your taste buds scream, Yummy!

$4.35

Holla Back Girl Cupcake

Banana cake with of cream cheese. Sprinkles may vary.

$4.00 +

The Creamscicle

Orange infused cupcake with cream cheese is a subtle explosion of flavors. Perfect for spring. A new staff favorite.

$4.35

Limited Engagement - Goodie Goodie Cupcake

Dark chocolate cake with whipped peanut butter buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.

$3.50 +

Carrot Cupcake SPECIAL

This classic feel good carrot cupcake with Cream Cheese is perfect for a day like today or any day.

$3.75

LIMITED ENGAGEMENT! Strawberry Peanut Butter Cupcake

Bits of Strawberry baked into this cupcake with a Whipped Peanut Butter Icing. Also known as the "Pinch Me Cupcake". Sprinkles may vary.

$3.50 +

Holiday Kissable Cupcake

It's our Chocolate Peppermint Cake with Cream Cheese and Crush Candy Cane. It's the most wonderful time of the year!

$3.50 +

S'mores Cupcake-NEW FLAVOR

Chocolate cupcake with our whipped buttercream, graham cracker cookie bottom, marshmallow and a drizzle of chocolate ganache. Good with or without a fire.

$3.75

4th of July 6 pack - Sunshine Cupcakes

Get your Stars, Stripes, Red, White & Blue on with this Patriotic 6-pack of our classic and definitely NOT boring Vanilla/Vanilla cupcakes.

$22.00

German Chocolate Imposter!

Once in awhile a sequel is better than the original. Our new version has dark chocolate cake which complements the sweet sticky coconut-y and pecan-y topping to perfection!

$3.75

The Crapple

Apple cake with cream cheese icing and our homemade caramel.

$4.00

Spooky Cupcakes

Add spooky faces to your favorite cupcakes. Spooky faces may vary.

$4.75

The Pudding Posse

Banana Pudding

Layers of creamy vanilla pudding, nilla wafers and bananas. It's Stupid Good.

$5.00 +

Chocolate Chip Deliciousness

Layers of home made chocolate chip cookies, butterscotch pudding and whip cream.

$5.00 +

Chocolate Bomb

Layers of home made dark chocolate cake, chocolate pudding and chocolate whip cream.

$5.00 +

Strawberry Lemon Trifle

Layers of our lemon cake, frozen strawberries and whip cream.

$5.00 +

The Nog

Super moist pumpkin cake with our secret eggnog pudding, whip cream and a dash of nutmeg.

$5.00 +

Mint Chocolate Chip Pudding

Made our own mint chocolate chip cookies, layer it with vanilla pudding and mint whip cream.

$5.00 +

Schmapple Pudding - It's back!

Layers of our classic yellow cake, sliced apples, layers of vanilla pudding, caramel whip cream and walnuts.

$5.00 +

The Coffee Java Xpress

Layers of our coffee cake, coffee pudding and coffee whip cream.

$5.00 +

The Creamsicle

This take on memories of the Ice Cream Truck. Layers of orange infused cake with layers of vanilla pudding and fresh whip cream.

$5.00 +

Awesome Peanut Butter Chocolate Pudding

Layers of home made peanut butter cookies, whipped peanut butter cream and peanut butter whip cream.

$5.00 +

Sexy Red Velvet Pudding

Layers of red velvet cake, vanilla pudding, whipped sweetened cream cheese whip cream and pecans.

$5.00 +

Peep Pudding

Layers of chocolate cake, white chocolate pudding, chocolate cookie crumble, coconut, marshmallows and cream will have you chirping "Peep! Peep!" for joy!

$5.00 +

The Lep - St. Patrick's Day Special

Home made Irish Soda bread, layered with vanilla pudding and Baileys Whip Cream. The Lep will make you feel like you have the Luck of the Irish.

$5.00 +

The Psychedlic Pistachio Dream Pudding

Layers of our amazing pistachio cake, pistachio pudding and a raspberryy whip cream. OMG! The colors are groovy and the tast psychedlic.

$5.00 +

Cakes

7" 2 layer Sunshine Cake

7" 2 layer Yellow cake with Vanilla buttercream and sprinkles. Icing color and sprinkle choice may vary. Perfect for a small gathering of 8 -1 0 people.

$47.00 +

7" 2 Layer Bob with Chocolate Almond Buttercream

Yellow cake with Chocolate Almond Buttercream. This cakes serves 8-10. Sprinkles may vary. Inscription is included.

$47.00

7” 2 layer Black & White Cake

This 7” 2 layer Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Buttercream with Sprinkles. Perfect for a small gathering 8 - 10 people. Sprinkles and icing color may not be the same as depicted in the photo.

$47.00 +

4" Sunshine Cake Cake

Individual 4" 2 layer yellow cake with vanilla buttercream. Serving 2 - 4. Icing color and sprinkles may vary

$27.00 +

4" 2 layer Bob Cake

Our "boy next door" cake with a twist. Classic vanilla cake with chocolate almond buttercream. Yummo! Serving size individual or 2 - 4 small servings. Sprinkles may vary.

$27.00 +

4" Black & White Cake

Individual chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream. Servings 2 - 4. Icing color and sprinkles may vary.

$27.00 +

4" 2 layer Ooey Gooey Cake

This dark chocolate cake with chocolate almond buttercream is just perfect for and individual or 2-4 small servings. Sprinkles included. Sprinkles may vary.

$27.00 +

7" 2 layer Strawberry with Cream Cheese

Strawberry cake with cream cheese icing. Also known as The Strawberry Shortcake Cupcake. Sprinkles may vary.

$45.00 +

4" 2 layer Sexy Red Velvet Cake

When you need a little sexy in your life and cupcake is just not enough! Sexy red velvet cake with our light, buttery and not too sweet satin buttercream. Serves for 2-4. Sprinkles may vary.

$27.00 +

4" 2 Layer Pistachio Cake

Perfect for 2-4 servings or one very hungry person! Our fabulous pistachio cake with satin buttercream and pistachio border. Toppings may vary.

$27.00 +

4" 2 layer Oreo Cookie

This childhood favorite cookie transformed into a cake. Sprinkles may vary.

$27.00 +

7" Strawberry Short Cake

This 7” 2 layer Strawberry Shortcake is simply put, delish. Perfect for a small gathering of 6-8 servings. Fresh Whip, Fresh Strawberries.

$65.00 +

Slice of Chocolate cake with Mocha Buttercream

Slice of Dark Chocolate cake with Mocha Buttercream. Who doesn't like coffee & chocolate mixed together?

$5.00

10" 2 layer Black & White Cake - RARE FIND!

Our chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream. A tried and true classic. Serves 20-25.

$75.00

RARELY AVAILABLE!! 7" SEXY RED VELVET CAKE

Our famous RED VELVET cake with our signature Satin Vanilla Buttercream -very buttery, not too sweet. Perfect for this sophisticated little cake. SPRINKLES! Toppings may vary. Serves 8 - 10 people.

$40.00

7" 3 layer German Chocolate Cake

This light chocolate cake topped with a coconut, pecan topping is sure to make your taste buds scream, Yummy!

$48.00

4" 2 layer Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Whipped Buttercream

This yummy dark chocolate cake with a not so sweet chocolate whipped buttercream is perfect for a little pick me up. Sprinkles may vary.

$25.00

Mother’s Day Cake - Pre-Order by Friday 5/11

4” 2 layer cake.

$20.00

4" 2 layer Be Mine Sunshine Cake

Our classic yellow cake with vanilla buttercream. Sprinkles may vary. Choose your inscription,

$25.00 +

1/2 Sheet Cake Black & White

Dark Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Buttercream.

$115.00 +

Mini Cupcakes

Mini Ooey Gooey/Bob Combo Cupcakes

Chocolate cake and Vanilla cake with our classic chocolate almond buttercream and sprinkles. Sprinkle choice may vary. 6 of each flavor. Pack of 12.

$25.00

Mini Sunshine Cupcakes

Yellow cake with vanilla buttercream in assorted colors (pink, blue, green & yellow). Pack of 12. Sprinkle choice may vary.

$25.00

Mini Black & White Cupcakes

Dark chocolate cake with various colored buttercream (blue, pink & white). Pack of 12. Sprinkles may vary.

$25.00

Mini Sexy Red Velvet Cupcakes

Sexy Red Velvet cake with Satin Buttercream (Pack of 12). Lighter buttercream. Sprinkles choice may vary.

$25.00

Mini Assorted Chocolate Cupcakes

Mini chocolate cupcakes with assorted icings (chocolate almond, vanilla and peanut butter) Pack of 12

$25.00

4th of July Mini Sunshine Cupcakes

Be the STAR of the BBQ with these adorable patriotic mini cupcakes in vanilla/vanilla

$25.00

Mini Oreo

Mini Oreo cupcakes.

$24.00

Mini Strawberry with cream cheese.

Strawberry cake with cream cheese and sprinkles. Yummy

$24.00

Mini Sunshine & Bob cupcakes

Combination of yellow cake with vanilla & chocolate almond buttercream. Assorted colors and sprinkles.

$24.00

Vegan Treats! We do not keep a separate kitchen.

Vegan Banana Puddin'

This Vegan Banana Puddin' has layers of creamy vanilla pudding, bananas and homemade vegan nilla wafers. It is Stupid Good just like it's Non-Vegan counterpart.

$5.00 +

Slice of Vegan Chocolate Bundt Cake

100% Vegan! Super chocolately moist slice of yummy

$4.85

Vegan Sunshine Vanilla with Vanilla

Yellow cake with vanilla buttercream. 100% vegan.

$4.35

Vegan French Toast cupcake

Vanilla cupcake with a cinnamon and nutmeg spiced vanilla buttercream. 100% vegan!

$4.35

Vegan Black & White

Dark Chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream. 100% vegan and still a classic.

$4.35

Vegan Chocolate Explosion Cupcake

Vegan Chocolate cake with Vegan Chocolate Buttercream. So decadent! 100% Vegan

$4.35

Vegan Bob

Yellow cake with chocolate buttercream. 100% vegan.

$4.35

4" 2 layer Vegan Chocolate Explosion

This All Vegan Chocolate Cake and chocolate icing is like boom to your taste buds. Contains Soy.

$25.00

Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookie

You wouldn't believe us if we said it is 100% Vegan. You just have to try to believe.

$2.00

9" 2 layer Vegan Sunshine

The Vegan version of our classic Sunshine cake with Vegan Vanilla Buttercream Whether you're vegan or just act like one, you'll love this cake! :).

$60.00

4" 2 layer Vegan Sunshine Cake

The Vegan version of our classic Vanilla cake with Vanilla, Vanilla Buttercream Whether you're vegan or just act like one, you'll love this cake! :)

$25.00

Vegan Lemon Cake with Lemon Glaze

100% vegan! Fluffy lemon cake with a tart and sweet lemon glaze!

$5.00

Vegan Iced Sugar Cookie

The vegan version of our popular iced sugar cookie! Very lightly sweetened cookie with our sweet vegan vanilla buttercream smeared on top. Yumm-omg!

$2.25

NEW!!! Vegan Apple Cider Donut

Baked to vegan perfection, dipped in vegan butter and rolled in a cinnamon and nutmeg sugar

$3.00

Vegan Chocolate Covered Strawberry! - NEW!!!

Our classic yellow cake with fresh strawberries mixed in to create this Amazing combination of a cupcake. Top it off with our Chocolate Buttercream. You got an extra dose of Yummy! 100% Vegan

$4.35

4" 2 Layer Vegan Chocolater Explosion

This All Vegan Chocolate Cake and chocolate icing is like boom to your taste buds. Contains Soy.

$25.00

Vegan Mini Vanilla Bundt Cakes

Our mini vegan vanilla bundt cakes are the perfect size to go with your morning coffee or the late afternoon slump. 100% vegan with a not too sweet glaze of lemon or chocolate.

$4.00

Thumbprint cookies

Vegan Buttery shortbread thumbprint with an organic raspberry jam, a bit of vanilla extract!

$1.85

Big Chocolate Chip Cookie

Sweet and Crunchy on the edges. Chewy in the middle. You get the best of both worlds with this 100% vegan BIG chocolate chip cookie!

$2.50

Ginger Lemon Drop Cupcake

This vegan cupcake has lemon and ginger topped with a lemon buttercream.

$3.25

Orange Blossom Earl Grey Cupcake

Earl grey infused cupcake with a sunny orange buttercream.

$3.25

Vegan Chocolate French Toast-NEW FLAVOR

A marriage of chocolate cake and the cinnamon and nutmeg spiced vanilla buttercream. 100% Vegan!

$3.25

Vegan Frech Toast Cake in a Cup

Vanilla cake with a cinnamon and nutmeg spiced vanilla buttercream. Everything you love about the cupcake only in a cup. 100% Vegan

$4.25

Vegan Oatmeal Cookie

This Oatmeal Cookie is seriously good and oh so Chewy! 100% Vegan

$1.00

4.5" Vegan Apple Pie

Fresh apples baked and topped a 100% Vegan Butter.

$7.25

Vegan Lemon Yummy

This all vegan lemon cupcake with lemon vegan buttercream will make you pucker. 100% Vegan

$4.00

Vegan Banana Bread

Super-moist classic banana bread! Perfect for those mornings you wake up craving something sweet, but it's maybe too early for a cupcake. :)

$5.00

Gluten Free - We do not keep a separate kitchen.

GLUTEN FREE Espresso Brownie

Gluten Free - Espresso chocolate brownie. Rich, rich and rich and Big!

$5.25

Gluten Free Sunshine Cupcake

This gluten free vanilla cupcake has everything its counterpart has without the bellyache. Yellow cupcake with vanilla buttercream and sprinkles. Sprinkles may vary.

$5.00

GF Bob Cupcake

This gluten free vanilla cupcake has everything its counterpart has without the bellyache. Yellow cupcake with chocolate almond buttercream and sprinkles. Sprinkles may vary.

$5.00

Other Treats

Raspberry Cream Cheese Bun

With raspberry and cream cheese baked in.

$3.75

Pumpkin Coffee Cake

This pumpkin coffee cake with walnuts and cinnamon is so Fall Yummy!

$5.00

Marble Bundt

If you like this and that, then this Marble Bundt cake is right up your alley. A lovely swirl of both vanilla and chocolate cake. Get it before the staff gobbles it up. Perfect afternoon treat with that cup of coffee.

$5.00

Slice of Pistachio Bundt Cake

This amazing pistachio bundt cake is delicious in its simplicity.

$5.00

Whole Coffee Cake

This classic coffee cake with cinnamon and walnuts baked in with a sugary walnut top. Was rated as one of New York's best coffee cakes.

$55.00

Slice of Coffee Cake

This classic coffee cake with cinnamon and walnuts baked in with a sugary walnut top. Was rated as one of New York's best coffee cakes.

$5.00

Slice of Apple Bundt Cake

This staff favorite has chunks of apple baked in.

$5.00

Flan

Spanish custard with caramel sauce.

$7.00

Tres leche

Our classic Tres leche with rum! (Contains alcohol.)

$8.25

Blueberry Muffin

No fuss, no muss and lots of blueberries.

$3.75

Whole Pistachio Bundt Cake

This amazing pistachio bundt cake is delicious in its simplicity.

$45.00

Orange Delight Bundt Cake

For those of you that love the citrus, you will love this orange infused bundt cake.

$4.58

Whole Apple Bundt

If just one slice of our inescapeable apple cake is not enough...here's the whole bundt and nuthin but the bundt!

$55.00

Bob Cake BY THE SLICE!!

Our boy next door cake - vanilla cake with chocolate almond buttercream

$7.00

Whole Marble Bundt Cake

If you like this and that, then this Marble Bundt cake is right up your alley. A lovely swirl of both vanilla and chocolate cake. Get it before the staff gobbles it up. Perfect afternoon treat with that cup of coffee.

$45.00

SLICE OF MICHAEL'S BDAY CAKE - BLACK & WHITE...JUST RIGHT!

Today's slice-of-the-day is another chocolate fave! The Black & White Cake - dark chocolate cake with sweet buttercream icing! LET'S ALL CELEBRATE AS A FAMILY WITH MICHAEL! EVEN THOUGH HIS BDAY ISN'T UNTIL 6/11 :)

$7.00

Holiday Chocolate Donut

Rich Chocolate Donut covered in Chocolate Ganache and Holiday Sprinkles with a dash of cinnamon.

$3.50

Slice of Lemon Bundt Cake

Moist and Densely Lemony Bundt with a Lemon Glaze - for all you lemon lovers!

$4.85

Black & White Cake In A Cup

Layers of dark chocolate cake vanilla buttercream and sprinkles all in a cup. Sprinkle combinations may vary.

$6.25

Sunshine Cake In A Cup

Layers of yellow cake, vanilla buttercream and sprinkles all in a cup.

$6.25

SLICE OF "OOPS! I SCREWED UP THE ORDER" CAKE

A luscious vanilla cake with coconut between the layers and chocolate buttercream, garnished with more coconut shreds and a pretty border of buttercream flowers. Can you say "Mounds Bar"???

$7.00

Slice of Pineapple Upside Down Cake

RARELY AVAILABLE!!! - This scrumptious classic pineapple upside down cake with all the buttery brown sugary goodness, pecans and of course maraschino cherries!

$4.85

Gingerbread Cake - NEW!!

Moist and spicy! Classic gingerbread with lotsa ginger and molasses. Makes you feel warm all over!

$4.85

NEW! Honey Apple Bundt

A traditional honey cake with apples. Only lightly sweet and perfect for the upcoming holidays! Or any old day.....with a cup of tea or coffee. :)

$4.85

Slice of Funfetti Cake

Grab a big wedge of this classic piece of Americana cake. Vanilla cake topped with a sugary vanilla buttercream. Put on your party hat, pull out the pin-the-tail on the donkey, pour yourself a big glass of milk (yeah, almond milk is ok) and enjoy! Sprinkles may be different than photo.

$7.00

Baby Lemon Bundt with Lemon Glaze

Perfect summer treat! If you want a cake all to yourself and you "don't want no stinkin' slices" - this is for you!

$4.50

Bob Cake In A Cup

Yellow cake with chocolate almond buttercream and sprinkles. Sprinkle combinations may vary.

$6.00

Ooey Gooey Cake in a Cup

Layers of dark chocolate cake and our classic chocolate almond buttercream. Topped with sprinkles.

$6.00

Ginger Spice Cake

Cinnamon, clove, fresh ginger and some black pepper to add zip to the tongue. Fresh lemon glaze just seals the deal

$3.75

Homemade Granola - New Item

A chewy, nutty blend of rolled oats, nuts, raisins, coconut, honey and a dash of cinnamon. Perfect snack or mix with your fave yogurt. 12 oz weight.

$6.00

Pumpkin Coffee Cake Bundt Slice

World's haven't collided like this since someone accidentally got their chocolate into someone else's peanut butter!

$4.85

Red velvet cake by the slice

Succulent Sexy Red Velvet Cake by the slice! Light chocolate red velvet cake with our silky satin buttercream.

$6.00

SLICE OF CAKE - OOEY GOOEY OMG!

Today's Slice-of-the-Day is our most decadent chocolate cake with our trademark chocolate almond buttercream. Are you having one of those days when you need something bigger than just a cupcake? With a chocolate punch? We got you covered.

$7.00

Apple Cider Donut

A fluffy circle of cinnamon-y, sugar-y goodness. Made with real apple cider and genuine love :)

$3.75

Assorted Bars

Lemon Bars

Shortbread crust with just the right amount of lemon to make you pucker!

$4.00

Oooh Brownies

Espresso chocolate brownie. Rich, rich and rich and Big!

$5.00

Yum-yum Bars

Shortbread crust layered with semi-sweet chocolate chips, raspberry preserves with a shortbread, chocolate chip crumble. Contains Walnuts.

$5.00

Holiday Chocolate Brownie

Candy Cane Chocolate Brownie. Our awesome chocolate espresso brownie infused with pure mint and crushed candy canes. Ho ho ho and happy new year! Get them while you can.

$5.50

My Heart Brownie

This cute little version of our espresso brownie is available today to show some extra love to someone or me, myself and I.

$5.00 +

Hot Out of the Oven Cookies

Chocolate Chip Cookie

This is that no frills, oversized, over chipped chocolate chip cookie.

$1.25

Gigantic Iced Sugar Cookies

OUTRAGEOUSLY LARGE AND VAGUELY MISSHAPEN!!!!!! SLATHERED WITH OUR CLASSIC VANILLA BUTTERCREAM. For those of you who like our standard sized cookie but like to live a little on the edge....go for it! You won't be disappointed. Icing colors vary.

$3.00

Iced Sugar Cookies!!!

Classic butter cookie with buttercream and sprinkles. Sprinkles may vary.

$2.50

Sugar Cookie

Classic buttery sugary cookie.

$1.25

Mint Chocolate Chip Cookie

Mint chocolate cookies like those classic thin mint cookies, only better.

$1.25

Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

Oats and Raisins...yummy

$0.75

Peanut Butter Cookie

C'mon - you know these make you feel like a kid again! Plus peanut butter's kinda good for you, right?

$1.25

Red Velvet Cookies - Chocolate Lovers Dream Cookie

These cookies have a rich cocoa taste that make them sexy on the palate. Sprinkles may vary.

$0.85

Ginger Cookies

A zingy, zanger twist of ginger will make you sing for these Ginger Cookies.

$1.00

German Chocolate Cookie

Like the cake - only crunchier and chewier! Chocolate, coconut, pecans = yum

$1.25

Valentines Day Iced Sugar Cookies

Our popular Iced Sugar Cookies, just a little sweeter.

$3.00

Cheesecake

Whole NY Cheesecake

Good old fashion NY Cheesecake with a classic graham cracker crust.

$60.00

Slice New York Cheesecake

Good old fashion NY Cheesecake with a classic graham cracker crust.

$7.00

Mini Cheesecake

Simple cheesecake. quantity 1

$3.50

Fancy Schamansey Cheesecake

A blueberry and strawberry combo cheesecake with a nilla wafer bottom.

$3.25

Chocolate Chippie Cheesecake

Who doesn't like some chocolate with their cheesecake. Add in some mini chocolate chips and its a score of yumminess! Oh, don't forget the nilla wafer bottom.

$3.25

Mini Cheesecake with chocolate drizzle and a raspberry whip cream

Simple mini cheesecake drizzled with chocolate and a dollop of raspberry whip cream. The perfect bite size treat when you just want a little something.

$4.00

Pie

4.5" Mini Double Crusted Apple Pie

Fresh apples baked and topped with home made crust. Just the right size for you.

$6.50

4.5" Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

Explosion of strawberries and the tangy tartness of the rhubarb that comes with that first bite topped with an oat crumble.

$6.50

4.5" Mini Blueberry Crumble Pie

Good old fashion blueberry pie with that classic crumble on top. This was a dad favorite.

$6.50

Slice of Peanut Butter Icebox Pie

If you like Peanut Butter this is the pie for you. Baked Graham Cracker Crust filled with Whipped Peanut Butter. Decadent!!!

$7.25

9" Double Crusted Apple Pie

Fresh apples baked and topped with home made crust. Classic pie anytime of the year.

$40.00

9" Blueberry Crispy Crumble

Good ol' fashioned blueberry pie with just the right amount of sweet and a crispy baked crumble top.

$40.00

9" Pecan Pie

This Southern Pecan Pie won’t let you down. Rich but not too sweet.

$40.00

9” Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

This home made Strawberry Rhubarb pie is sure to make your mouth pucker with sweetness. Most popular pie.

$40.00

9" Pumpkin Pie

Classic Pumpkin Pie that is just how you love it - nothin' fancy, just home made and good.

$40.00

9" Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

Explosion of strawberries and the tangy tartness of the rhubarb that comes with that first bite topped with an oat crumble.

$40.00

4.5" Mini Pumpkin Pie

Classic Pumpkin Pie that is just how you love it - nothin' fancy.

$6.50

Slice Coconut Cream Pie

Home made baked crust filled with creamy coconut filling topped with fresh whip cream and coconut shreds. Rumor has it the best around.

$7.25

4.5" Mini Pecan Pie

Southern style pecan pie that is rich but not too sweet

$6.50

9" Coconut Cream Pie - Whole Pie

A creamy coconut-y custard pie with fresh whipped cream. Rich and decadent, but not overly sweet!

$45.00

9" Peanut Butter Ice Box Pie

Dunno if you remember Clark Bars from when you were a kid? Maybe I'm dating myself here, but this is reminiscent of the peanut butter nougat in that candy bar. If that reference doesn't mean anything to you, I'd say it's like a thick peanut butter mousse sitting cozily on a graham cracker crust

$45.00

Mini Coconut Cream Pie

Home made baked crust filled with creamy coconut filling topped with fresh whip cream and coconut shreds. Rumor has it the best around.

$6.50

4.5" Mini Peanut Butter Pie

If you love peanut butter this is the pie for you. Graham cracker crust filled with creamy peanut butter cream.

$6.50

Slice of Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

Tart and Sweet with a rolled oat topping. Celebrate summer with one of our most popular pies!

$6.00

Beverages

Poland Spring Water (Flat)

16 oz Poland Spring Flat Water

$1.25

Beverages

Choose One Coke, pepsi, flat water, capri juice, brisk iced tea

$1.50

Promotion

Pudding

Choose your FREE TEASER PUDDING with purchase of $25.00 or more. Make sure to click at checkout to redeem!

$3.00

Holidays

Holiday Iced Sugar Cookies

Pre-order these adorable and delicious Iced Sugar Cookies. Yes, they taste as good as they look. Must be 21 to purchase.

$2.25

Holiday Assorted Mini Cupcake Pack

Festive holiday assortment of Mini vanilla & chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream. All decorated with cute little sugar candies. Colors and candies may vary. Ho, ho, ho.

$20.00

I Bundt You Mini Bundt Cake

A dark chocolate bundt cake with a vanilla or chocolate glaze. Perfect size treat for your sweetie. With assorted sprinkles.

$5.00

Heart Iced Sugar Cookies

Our classic butter sugar cookie with vanilla buttercream. Make it extra special with a limited for today only Heart Cookie.

$3.00

Halloween Iced Sugar Cookies

Classic butter cookie with halloween decorations.

$2.25

Feeling Lucky Assorted 4 pack

This assorted 4 pack of cupcakes is sure to make anyone feel lucky. Sprinkles may vary

$16.00

Feeling Lucky Assorted 6 pack

This assorted 6 pack of cupcakes is sure to make anyone feel lucky. Sprinkles may vary.

$25.00

Green with Envy Sunshine 4 pack

This 4 pack of our classic Sunshine cupcakes is sure to make anyone feel lucky. Sprinkles may vary.

$16.00

Green with Envy Sunshine 6 pack

This 6 pack of our classic Sunshine cupcakes is sure to make anyone feel lucky. Sprinkles may vary.

$25.00

Peeps vs. Bunny Assorted 4 pack

This adorable assorted 4 pack of Sunshine, Bob, Ooey Gooey & Black & White cupcakes is a competition of who is the cutest. Sprinkles may vary. Vanilla & Chocolate Almond Buttercream

$15.00

Hey Chickie 4 pack Sunshine Cupcakes

This 4 pack of the classic yellow cake with vanilla buttercream and little chickies. Will make anyone chirp for joy this Easter. Sprinkles may vary.

$15.00

I Love you Bunny Much - Sunshine 6 pack

How much Bunny do you love? Well 6 Sunshine cupcakes says ALOT!

$22.00

You're Eggstra Special - Assorted 6 pack

This assorted six pack of 2 Sunshine, 2 Black & White, 1 Bob & 1 Ooey Gooey. It's not everyday that you get to be Eggstra Special. Yellow & Chocolate Cake with Vanilla & Chocolate Almond Buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.

$22.00
Restaurant closed
.

About Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery

  • 365 Grand St, New York, NY 10002
  • Bakery, Breakfast, Coffee and Tea, Dessert, Dinner, Lunch Specials
  • (212) 995-1960
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.