The Meatball Shop
Popular menu items
3 Meatballs
3 balls, served with your choice of sauce, Parmesan cheese and focaccia bread. /// Perfect Balls: a portion of the cooking process involves the use of the same oil that has cooked gluten and dairy. Please note if you have any severe allergies, reach out directly to the restaurant to discuss in more detail.
$11.00 +Make it a Bowl
3 balls and base together in a bowl, with Parmesan cheese and focaccia bread./// Perfect Balls: a portion of the cooking process involves the use of the same oil that has cooked gluten and dairy. Please note if you have any severe allergies, reach out directly to the restaurant to discuss in more detail.
$18.50 +Kitchen Sink Salad
3 balls and sauce, served over the chef's selection of greens and sink veggies. Gluten free option. /// Perfect Balls: a portion of the cooking process involves the use of the same oil that has cooked gluten and dairy. Please note if you have any severe allergies, reach out directly to the restaurant to discuss in more detail.
$22.00 +OG NYC Hero
3 classic balls on a baguette with tomato sauce and mozzarella. Served with a simple salad. * Classic balls contain beef and pork.
$17.00 +During this time and to eliminate the possibility of any contamination, we will not be providing utensils with deliveries.
-
$0.00Baller Boxes
Baller Box
2 bottles of Prosecco or wine + mini buffalo balls + 2 ball and sauce combos + 1 large salad + 3 large sides + 4 pieces focaccia ** Serves 4. Must be 21 to purchase.
$175.00 +Sweet and Boozy Baller Box
Choice of a Build your own Spiked Hot Chocolate or Build your own Hot Buttered Bourbon + 6 freshly baked cookies ** Serves 4. Must be 21 to purchase.
$55.00Cocktails
Fool-Aid Punch - 1 Pouch
Brandy, rum, citrus, grape drink. Carafe of Fool-Aid served in an individual pouch. Must be 21 to purchase.
$16.00Fool-Aid Punch - 4 Pouches
Brandy, rum, citrus, grape drink. 1 carafe of Fool-Aid per individual pouch. Must be 21 to purchase.
$60.00Devils Juice Sangria - 1 Pouch
Pear, apple, citrus, cinnamon. Carafe of Sangria served in an individual pouch. Must be 21 to purchase.
$18.00Devils Juice Sangria - 4 Pouches
Pear, apple, citrus, cinnamon. 1 carafe of Sangria per individual pouch. Must be 21 to purchase.
$68.00All'ways Old Fashioned
Rittenhouse rye 100, demerara syrup, housemade bitters. Must be 21 to purchase.
$15.00All'ways Old Fashioned for 4
Rittenhouse rye 100, demerara syrup, housemade bitters. Must be 21 to purchase.
$54.00Pomegranate Moscow Mule for 4
Reyka vodka, pomegranate, lime, ginger beer. Must be 21 to purchase.
$50.00 +Smokey the Pear for 4
Milagro silver, mezcal, pear, agave, triple sec, lime. Must be 21 to purchase.
$46.00Raspberry Basil Moscow Mule
Reyka vodka, ginger beer, raspberry, basil, lime. Must be 21 to purchase.
$14.00Rose Sangria
Rose, peach schnapps, peaches, pineapple, lemon, strawberries. Must be 21 to purchase.
$9.00 +Strawberry Jalapeno Margarita
Milagro silver, triple sec, strawberry, jalapeno, lime. Must be 21 to purchase.
$13.00Raspberry Basil Moscow Mule for 4
Reyka vodka, ginger beer, raspberry, basil, lime. Must be 21 to purchase.
$52.00Strawberry Jalapeno Margarita for 4
Milagro silver, triple SEC, strawberry, jalapeno, lime. Must be 21 to purchase.
$48.00Beer
Wine
Chianti Colli Senesi
Castello DI Farnetella, D.O.C.G., Tuscany, Italy 2017. Must be 21 to purchase.
$12.00 +Cabernet Sauvignon
Charles and Charles, Columbia Valley, Washington, 2016. Must be 21 to purchase.
$13.00 +Dolcetto d'Alba Bottle
Prunotto, Alba, Piedmonte, Italy 2017. Refreshing, vibrant red featuring dark fruits, fragrant and fruity, with floral and mineral undertones. Fresh supple finish, with no hard edges. Must be 21 to purchase.
$40.00Rose
Syrah/Carignan Moulin DE Gassac, ‘Guilhem’ Languedoc-Roussillon, France 2019. Must be 21 to purchase.
$11.00 +Whiskey (2 oz.)
Zero Proofers
Balls and Sauce
Gobble Gobble Balls
3 gobble gobble balls (turkey, pork, cranberries) & a stuffing ball served with turkey gravy and cranberry sauce. Make it a bowl over mashed potatoes or sweet potatoes!
$13.00 +3 Meatballs
3 balls, served with your choice of sauce, Parmesan cheese and focaccia bread. /// Perfect Balls: a portion of the cooking process involves the use of the same oil that has cooked gluten and dairy. Please note if you have any severe allergies, reach out directly to the restaurant to discuss in more detail.
$11.00 +Make it a Bowl
3 balls and base together in a bowl, with Parmesan cheese and focaccia bread./// Perfect Balls: a portion of the cooking process involves the use of the same oil that has cooked gluten and dairy. Please note if you have any severe allergies, reach out directly to the restaurant to discuss in more detail.
$18.50 +Bucket o Balls
20 balls with your choice of meat and sauce. /// Perfect Balls: a portion of the cooking process involves the use of the same oil that has cooked gluten and dairy. Please note if you have any severe allergies, reach out directly to the restaurant to discuss in more detail.
$65.00 +Bucket For Later
20 frozen balls with your choice of meat and sauce + 1 jar of our Classic Tomato Sauce.
$50.00Family Meal for 4
2 ball and sauce combos +1 large salad +1 large side +4 pieces focaccia +4 cookies.
$80.00 +Thanksgiving Dinner (Per Person)
Minimum 4 people. Gobble gobble balls (turkey, pork, cranberries) + Stuffing balls + Turkey gravy + Cranberry sauce + Green beans with black pepper butter + Brussels sprouts with apples, onions and candied pecans + Honey roasted carrots with walnuts, prunes and mint + Smashed sweet potatoes with autumn butter and candied pecans - OR - Classic & creamy mashed potatoes, + Focaccia
$27.00 +Gobble Gobble Bucket O' Balls
20 Gobble gobble balls (turkey, pork, cranberries), 8 Stuffing balls, Turkey gravy, Cranberry sauce
$85.00 +RESTAURANT WEEK - Spaghetti and Meatballs
The Meatball Shop's Classic Spaghetti and Meatballs! 3 classic balls with classic tomato sauce, served over spaghetti and topped with grana. Served with a side of focaccia and a salad.
$20.21 +Small Bites
Butternut Squash and Pear Soup
Roasted butternut squash and pear soup garnished with sunflower seeds, chives and a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil. Gluten free.
$10.00 +Mini Buffalo Chicken Balls
Bite-size buffalo chicken balls, covered in Frank's Red Hot. Like a great buffalo wing without the bones, served with a side of blue cheese and celery. Gluten free.
$10.50 +Avocado Toast
Toasted focaccia bread topped with fresh avocado tossed in our house made pesto sauce. Finished with ricotta salata and a drizzle of Calabrian chili oil. Option to add a fried egg!
$14.00 +Crispy Chickpeas
Chickpeas seasoned with salt, smoked paprika, onion powder, and garlic. Vegan and gluten free.
$5.00 +Seasonal Ricotta
Seasoned ricotta topped with marinated butternut squash, honey and walnuts. Served with focaccia, select the Gluten Free option for celery instead.
$13.00 +Sicilian White Bean Hummus
Italian white bean hummus garnished with a dollop of chili garlic puree and finished with a drizzle of olive oil. Vegan. Select the Gluten Free option for a side of celery instead of focaccia.
$10.00 +Salads
Kitchen Sink Salad
3 balls and sauce, served over the chef's selection of greens and sink veggies. Gluten free option. /// Perfect Balls: a portion of the cooking process involves the use of the same oil that has cooked gluten and dairy. Please note if you have any severe allergies, reach out directly to the restaurant to discuss in more detail.
$22.00 +Kitchen Sink Salad - Gobble Gobble
3 Gobble Gobble balls, served over the chef's selection of greens and sink veggies. Gluten free option.
$22.00 +Simple Salad
Mixed greens with shaved radish, chives, and red wine vinaigrette. Vegan and gluten free.
$8.50 +Caesar Salad
Romaine with crispy capers and garlic croutons. Select Gluten Free for no croutons.
$10.00 +Wild Arugula Salad
Peppery greens in a traditional Italian style salad with fennel, mint, grana and citrus. Gluten free.
$11.00 +Big Italian Salad
Italian chopped salad with pepperoncinis, artichokes, green olives, chickpeas, grana and traditional Italian vinaigrette. Gluten free.
$12.00 +Baby Kale Salad
Baby kale tossed in tahini dressing, topped with fresh avocado, crisped sweet potato, and sunflower seeds. Vegan and gluten free.
$12.00 +Shaved Brussels Sprouts Salad
Hearty salad with brussels sprouts, almonds, cranberries and citrus. Vegan and gluten free.
$12.00 +Sandwiches
Gobble Gobble Hero
3 gobble gobble balls (turkey, pork, cranberries) on a baguette with turkey gravy and cranberry sauce. Served with a simple salad.
$17.00 +OG NYC Hero
3 classic balls on a baguette with tomato sauce and mozzarella. Served with a simple salad. * Classic balls contain beef and pork.
$17.00 +The Sauzeech' Hero
3 pork balls on a baguette with peppers and onions, tomato sauce and mozzarella. Served with a simple salad.
$17.00 +The Skinny Eggplant Hero
Eggplant, tomato sauce and mozzarella on a baguette. Served with a simple salad.
$17.00 +Build Your Own Hero
3 balls on a baguette with sauce and mozzarella. Served with a simple salad. /// Perfect Balls: a portion of the cooking process involves the use of the same oil that has cooked gluten and dairy. Please note if you have any severe allergies, reach out directly to the restaurant to discuss in more detail.
$19.00 +Gobble Gobble Smash
2 gobble gobble balls (turkey, pork, cranberries) on a brioche bun with turkey gravy and cranberry sauce. Served with a simple salad.
$15.00 +Chicken Parm Parm Smash
2 chicken balls on a brioche bun with tomato sauce, parmesan cream sauce and mozzarella. Served with a simple salad.
$15.00 +The Veggie Smash
2 veggie balls on a brioche bun with pesto and mozzarella. Served with a simple salad.
$15.00 +Build Your Own Smash
2 balls on a brioche bun with sauce and mozzarella. Served with a simple salad. /// Perfect Balls: a portion of the cooking process involves the use of the same oil that has cooked gluten and dairy. Please note if you have any severe allergies, reach out directly to the restaurant to discuss in more detail.
$17.00 +Pastas (GF options)
Seasonal Risotto
Creamy Italian rice dish with butternut squash, brown butter and sage. Gluten free.
$18.00 +Plates
Gobble Gobble Plate
3 Gobble gobble balls (turkey, pork, cranberries) + Stuffing ball + Green beans with black pepper butter + Smashed sweet potatoes with autumn butter and candied pecans. Served with Turkey gravy and Cranberry sauce.
$26.00 +Chicken Parm with Spaghetti
Buttermilk marinated, mozzarella, tomato sauce, served with a side of spaghetti.
$25.50 +Eggplant Parm with Spaghetti
Layers of eggplant, tomato sauce and mozzarella (gluten free). Served with a side of spaghetti.
$25.50 +Chicken Piccata with Carrots
Pan seared chicken breast topped with our delicious piccata sauce. Served with a side of roasted carrots. Gluten free.
$23.50 +Tuscan Braised Short Ribs with Mashed Potatoes
Slow cooked short ribs braised with rosemary and red wine. Served with a side of mashed potatoes. Gluten free.
$27.50 +Market Fish with C'alliflower
Mild flavored, white, flaky fish topped with a fennel relish. Served with a side of c'alliflower. Gluten free.
$24.50 +Roasted Eggplant with Green Beans
Feta, marinated tomatoes, pickled onions, served with green beans. Gluten free.
$21.00 +Gobble Gobble Plate
3 Gobble gobble balls (turkey, pork, cranberries) + Stuffing ball + Green beans with black pepper butter + Smashed sweet potatoes with autumn butter and candied pecans. Served with Turkey gravy and Cranberry sauce
$26.00 +Veggies and Sides
Mashed Potatoes
Classic, creamy mashed potatoes prepared from Yukon Gold potatoes, topped with chives. Gluten free.
$8.50 +Freshly-Milled Polenta
From wild hive farm, creamy corn polenta finished with Parmesan cheese. Gluten free.
$8.50 +Smashed Sweet Potato
Smashed sweet potatoes topped with a fall spiced butter and candied pecans. Gluten free.
$9.50 +C'alliflower
Cauliflower flash fried and tossed in Caesar dressing to give it a nice flavored crust. Gluten free.
$9.50 +Carrots with Prunes and Walnuts
Honey roasted carrots, topped with walnuts, prunes and mint. Gluten free.
$9.50 +Brussels Sprouts
Roasted Brussels sprouts tossed with apples, onion and candied pecans. Vegan and gluten free. Option to add bacon!.
$9.50 +Roasted Butternut Squash
Roasted butternut squash topped with ricotta salata and finished with a drizzle of saba. Gluten free.
$9.50 +White Beans
Hot white beans topped with fried breadcrumbs. Vegan. Select the gluten free option for no breadcrumbs.
$9.50 +Side of Gluten Free Pasta
Tossed with your choice of sauce and finished with Parmesan cheese.
$11.00 +Roasted Summer Corn
Corn on the cob cut into rings, oven roasted and tossed with pesto. Gluten free.
$9.50 +Asparagus and Potato (cold)
Chilled asparagus and red bliss potatoes, feta cheese and dill tossed in a lemon vinaigrette
$9.50 +