The Original Carlo's Pizzeria
MenuAbout
The Original Carlo's Pizzeria Menu

The Original Carlo's Pizzeria

American, Calzones
74-02 Metropolitan Ave, Middle Village, NY 11379
(718) 894-7915
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Big Game Special Packages

Menu powered by Grubhub

Package 1

1 regular pie, 12 wings, 12 mozzarella sticks, 12 garlic knots and 1liter soda.

$50.00

Package 2

2 pies, 1 sicillian pie , 30 wings, 1 free topping and 2 liter soda.

$85.00

Package 3

2 pies,24 wings and 2 liter soda.

$60.00

Package 4

2 pies,1 free topping , 12 garlic knots and 2 liter soda.

$55.00

Package 6

1 regular pie, 12 wings and 12 garlic knots.

$45.00

Carlos Homemade Sauce To Go

Vodka Sauce

Pint size filled with our homemade vodka sauce

$9.00 +

Tomato & basil Sauce

Pint size filled with our homemade Tomato & basil sauce

$6.00 +

Fra Diavolo sauce

Pint size filled with our spicy marinara sauce

$8.00 +

Marinara sauce

Pint size filled marinara sauce with tomato and fresh garlic

$7.00 +

Beverages

Coffee

$4.00

Espresso

$3.50

Cappuccino

$5.00

Tea

$3.00

Can Soda

$2.00

1 Liter Soda

$3.00

2 Liter Soda

$4.00

Snapple

$2.50

Juice

$2.00

Bottled Water

$2.00

Salads

Cold Antipasto

$15.00 +

Seafood Salad

$19.00

House Salad

$8.00 +

Grilled Chicken Salad

$14.00 +

Caesar Salad

$10.00 +

Caesar Salad with Chicken

$15.00 +

Avocado Salad

$13.00 +

Chef Salad

Hard-boiled egg, ham, provolone, onions, tomatoes, and black olives.

$16.00 +

Greek Salad

$13.00 +

Calamari Salad

$16.00

Buffalo Chicken Salad

$15.00 +

Carlos salad

Arugula, fried calamari, and feta cheese

$17.00

Arugula salad

$11.00 +

Appetizers

Bruschetta Bread

$13.00 +

Buffalo fried calamari

Spicy fried calamari topped with drizzled blue cheese

$19.00

Hot Antipasto

$19.00

Stuffed Mushroom

$14.00

Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato

$16.00

Roasted Pepper and Fresh Mozzarella

$17.00

Shrimp Cocktail

$17.00

Baked Clams

Half dozen.

$15.00

Mussels

Marinara or white wine.

$17.00

Fried Calamari

$16.00

Mozzarella Sticks

Six pieces.

$8.00

Garlic Bread

$6.00 +

Garlic Knots

Six pieces.

$4.50 +

Buffalo Wings

Six pieces.

$7.00

French Fries

$8.00 +

Zucchini Sticks

$10.00 +

Soup of the Day

$7.00 +

Spinach Side Order

$10.00 +

Broccoli Side Order

$10.00 +

Broccoli Rabe

$12.00 +

Artichoke

Call us for availability

$8.00

Calamari Oreganato

$19.00

Calamari Alla Carlo’s

Hot cherry peppers, seasoned in fra diavolo glaze

$19.00

Hot Heroes

Meatball Hero

$8.00 +

Veal cutlet with lettuce & tomato hero

$14.00 +

Chicken with lettuce & Tomato hero

$12.00 +

Chicken Caesar hero

Your choice of chicken grilled or fried with Romain lettuce, topped with Caesar dressing

$13.00 +

Drunken meatball hero

Our homemade meatballs with vodka sauce

$12.00 +

Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Hero

$15.00 +

Drunken Veal cutlet hero

Veal cutlet topped with our famous homemade vodka sauce

$15.00 +

Drunken chicken hero

Chicken cutlet topped with our famous homemade vodka sauce

$13.00 +

Drunken shrimp hero

Fried shrimp with vodka sauce

$15.00 +

Veal Cutlet Roasted Pepper Fresh Mozzarella hero

$16.00

Chicken Cutlet Roasted Pepper Fresh Mozzarella Hero

$14.00

Sausage Hero

$9.00 +

Chicken Cutlet Hero

$10.50 +

Sausage and Peppers Hero

$11.00 +

Eggplant Hero

$9.00 +

Grilled Chicken Hero

$10.50 +

Veal Cutlet Hero

$12.00 +

Veal and Peppers Hero

$13.00 +

Egg Hero

With peppers or potatoes.

$8.00 +

Fried Shrimp Hero

With lemon or tartar sauce.

$11.00 +

Shrimp Hero

With marinara sauce.

$11.00 +

Cheesesteak Hero

$13.00 +

Chicken Marsala Hero

$12.00 +

Chicken Francese Hero

$12.00 +

Chicken Bacon Ranch Hero

$12.00 +

Buffalo Chicken Hero

$12.00 +

Chicken Entrées

Chicken Capriciossa

Breast of chicken with fresh diced tomatoes, red onions, and balsamic vinegar.

$21.00 +

Chicken Francese

Breast of chicken sautéed with white wine, butter, and lemon.

$21.00 +

Chicken Marsala

Breast of chicken sautéed with mushrooms and Marsala wine.

$21.00 +

Chicken Rollatini

Breast of chicken stuffed with prosciutto or spinach and provolone in white wine.

$24.00 +

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana

Breast of chicken in a marinara sauce with Parmigiana.

$17.00 +

Chicken Cutlet

Breast of chicken in a marinara sauce.

$15.00 +

Chicken Pizziola

Breast of chicken sautéed with mushrooms and a touch of marinara sauce.

$22.00 +

Chicken Cacciatore

Breast of chicken sautéed with mushroom, onion, pepper, olive, and a touch of marinara sauce.

$23.00 +

Chicken Sorentino

Eggplant, prosciutto, and cheese with mushroom sauce.

$24.00 +

Chicken Alla Carlo's

Fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, in a mushroom sauce

$24.00 +

Veal Entrées

Veal Rollatini

Veal stuffed with prosciutto or spinach and provolone in a white wine sauce.

$24.00 +

Veal spiedini

Veal stuffed with chopped prosciutto, bread crumbs, & provolone

$25.00 +

Veal Francese

Veal sautéed with white wine, butter, and lemon.

$23.00 +

Veal Capriciossa

Veal with fresh diced tomatoes, red onion, and balsamic vinegar.

$23.00 +

Veal Marsala

Veal sautéed with mushrooms in a Marsala sauce.

$23.00 +

Veal Parmigiana

Veal in a marinara sauce with Parmigiana.

$19.00 +

Veal Cutlet

Veal in a marinara sauce.

$17.00 +

Veal Sorentino

Veal, eggplant, prosciutto, and cheese sautéed with mushroom sauce.

$26.00 +

Veal Pizziola

Veal sautéed with mushrooms and a touch of marinara sauce.

$24.00 +

Veal Alla Carlo’s

Fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, in a mushroom sauce

$26.00

Seafood Entrées

Shrimp Oreganato

Broiled with bread crumbs and a touch of clam sauce.

$23.00 +

Fish & Chips

Fried flounder fish filet, French fries, with a side of tarter sauce

$15.00

Salmon Oreganato

$26.00 +

Calamari Oreganato

Broiled with breadcrumbs and a touch of clam sauce.

$21.00 +

Shrimp

Sautéed with a marinara sauce or tartar sauce.

$18.50 +

Shrimp Scampi

Sautéed with white wine, butter, and lemon.

$23.00 +

Shrimp Francese

Sautéed with white wine, butter, and lemon.

$23.00 +

Shrimp Parmigiana

Sautéed in a marinara sauce and Parmigiana.

$20.00 +

Shrimp and Calamari

Sautéed in a marinara sauce.

$25.00 +

Scungilli and Calamari

Sautéed in a marinara sauce.

$26.00 +

Scungilli and Shrimp

Sautéed in a marinara sauce.

$27.00 +

Scungilli

Sautéed in a marinara sauce.

$21.00 +

Calamari Marinara

Sautéed in a marinara sauce.

$20.00 +

Seafood Marinara

$28.00 +

Seafood Fra Diavolo

$28.00 +

Fish Fillet

Broiled or fried.

$24.00 +

Fish Fillet Francese

Sautéed with white wine, butter, and lemon.

$26.00 +

Shrimp & Chicken Alla Francese

$28.00 +

Vegetarian Entrées

Eggplant

With marinara sauce.

$13.00 +

Eggplant Parmigiana

Eggplant with marinara and Parmigiana.

$15.00 +

Eggplant Rollatini

Eggplant with ricotta and Parmigiana in a marinara sauce.

$18.00 +

Steak

Skirt Steak

$26.00 +

Carlo's Skirt Steak

Cherry peppers & onions

$29.00 +

Skirt Steak & Broccoli Rabe

$30.00 +

Pasta Dishes

Pasta with Pesto

Your choice of pasta with our homemade pesto sauce

$16.00 +

gnocchi

$13.00 +

Cavatelli

$16.00 +

Lasagna

$14.00

Baked Ziti

$14.00 +

Baked Ziti Sicilian-Style

Eggplant.

$16.00

Cheese Ravioli

$14.00 +

Meat ravioli

$14.00 +

Tortellini

Cheese or meat.

$14.00 +

Manicotti

$13.00

Pasta with Meatball

$13.00 +

Stuffed Shells

$14.00

Pasta with Fried Chicken and Broccoli

$17.00 +

Pasta with Grilled Chicken & Broccoli

$17.00 +

Pasta Alfredo

$14.00 +

Pasta with Sausage

$13.00 +

Pasta Primavera

$16.00 +

Pasta Vodka Sauce

$16.00 +

Linguine with Clam Sauce

$18.00

Pasta with Spinach and Fresh Tomatoes

$17.00 +

Pasta with Garlic and Oil

$11.00 +

Pasta with Broccoli Rabe and Sausage

$17.00 +

Pasta Bolognese

With meat sauce.

$15.00 +

Pasta Carbonara

$17.00 +

Pasta with Broccoli

$14.50 +

Pasta with tomato Sauce

$10.00 +

Tortellini with Alfredo

$17.00 +

Pasta al Carlo's

Meat sauce and peas.

$15.00 +

Spinach Lasagna

$16.00

Money Bag Alla Vodka

$16.00 +

Sides

Hot Cherry Peppers

$6.00

Meatballs with Sauce

$7.00

Sausage with Sauce

$7.00

Brick Oven Pizza

Brick Oven Regular Pizza

Plum tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil.

$19.00 +

Brick Oven Arugula and Prosciutto Pizza

Arugula, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella cheese, and fresh basil

$25.00 +

Brick Oven Bianca Pizza

Artichokes, ricotta, fresh mozzarella, and basil

$25.00 +

specialties

Chicken Roll

$9.00 +

Sausage Roll

$9.00 +

Broccoli Roll

$9.00 +

Eggplant Roll

$9.00 +

Cheese Calzone

$9.00 +

Cheese Calzone with a Filling

$11.00 +

Rice Ball

$7.50 +

Pepperoni Roll

$5.50 +

Spinach Wheel

$5.50 +

Stromboli

$9.00 +

Spinach Roll

$9.00 +

Potato Croquette

One piece.

$2.00 +

Broccoli Rabe and Sausage Panini

$13.00 +

Grilled Chicken Panini

$10.00 +

Beef Patties

$5.00 +

Beef Patties with Cheese

$6.00 +

Pepperoni Bites

five pieces

$5.50 +

Buffalo Chicken Roll

$9.00 +

Stuffed artichoke

$8.00

Speciality Slices

Specialty Slice

$5.50 +

Carlo's Original Pizza and Slices

Cheese Pizza

$17.00 +

Sausage Pizza

$20.00 +

Meatballs Pizza

$20.00 +

Pepperoni Pizza

$20.00 +

Anchovies Pizza

$20.00 +

Green Peppers Pizza

$20.00 +

Black Olives Pizza

$20.00 +

Extra Cheese Pizza

$20.00 +

Mushrooms Pizza

$20.00 +

Spinach Pizza

$22.00 +

Broccoli Pizza

$22.00 +

Chicken Pizza

$23.00 +

Eggplant Pizza

$22.00 +

Sicilian Pie

$23.00 +

Carlo's Upside-Down Sicilian Pizza

Twelve slices.

$24.00 +

Slice

$3.25 +

Sicilian Slice

$3.50 +

Grandma Slice

$3.50 +

Carlo’s Upside-Down Sicilian Slice

$3.50 +

Onion Sfingione Slice

$3.50 +

Special Pies

Vodka Sauce Grandpa Pie

$29.00

Eggplant Rollatini Pie

Fried eggplant with mozzarella cheese, tomato sauce, and ricotta

$28.00 +

Carlo’s Money Bag Pie

Cheese filled pasta with your choice of sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese

$29.00 +

Buffalo Chicken Salad Pie

$31.00 +

Chicken Marsala Pie

$29.00 +

Chicken Francese Pie

$29.00 +

Drunken Grandma Pie

Grandma pie with vodka sauce

$30.00

Carlo’s Tri Color Grandma pie

Grandma pie with Pesto, vodka, and marinara sauce

$30.00

Drunken Regular Pie

Regular pie with vodka sauce

$25.00 +

Drunken Sicilian Pie

Sicilian pie with vodka sauce

$30.00

Pesto Pie

$24.00 +

White Pie with Ricotta and Spinach

$27.00 +

Arugula and Prosciutto Pie

$29.00 +

White Clam Sauce Pie

$34.00 +

Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pie

$34.00 +

Artichoke & Spinach Pie

Artichokes, spinach, mozzarella cheese, drizzled in heavy cream

$27.00 +

Philly Cheese Steak Pie

$29.00 +

Red Clam Sauce Pie

$34.00 +

Carlo's Special Pizza

$26.00 +

White Pizza

Ricotta.

$22.00 +

Vegetarian Pizza

$27.00 +

Chicken and Tomato Pizza

$27.00 +

Fresh Mozzarella and Sliced Tomato Pizza

$22.00 +

Baked Ziti Pizza

$26.00 +

Lasagna Pizza

$27.00 +

Sfingione Pizza

Onions and bread crumbs.

$18.00

Sicilian Special Pizza

$31.00

Grandpa Pie

Pie with Fresh mozzarella topped with marinara sauce

$28.00

Chicken Broccoli Pizza

$27.00 +

Stuffed Pizza Pie

Ham or spinach.

$27.00

Grandma Pie

$23.00

Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza

$31.00 +

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

$27.00 +

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

$27.00 +

Penne Vodka Sauce Pizza

$27.00 +

Hawaiian Pizza

$27.00 +

BBQ Chicken Pizza

$27.00 +

Calamari Pizza

$27.00 +

Salad Pizza

$26.00 +

Tostino Pizza

Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, tomato, basil, and olive oil.

$31.00

White prosciutto pie

Pie with mozzarella, ricotta cheese, and prosciutto

$29.00 +

Pan Pizza

Deep Dish Pizza

"10" inch personal deep dish pizza made to your liking

$11.00 +

Gluten Free Pizza

Gluten Free Pizza

12 inch personal size pie with mozzarella cheese and sauce

$15.00 +

Daily Specials

$1.00 Off Regular Pie Monday Special

Plum tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil.

$18.00 +

Pasta with Broccoli Monday Special

$13.50 +

Pasta with Bolognese Monday Special

$14.00 +

Pasta with Meatballs Tuesday Special

$12.00 +

Baked Ziti Tuesday Special

$13.00

Cheese Ravioli Tuesday Special

$13.00

Lasagna Wednesday Special

$13.00

Tortellini Wednesday Special

$13.00

Manicotti Wednesday Special

$12.00

Tortellini Alfredo Wednesday Special

$16.00

Chicken Parmigiana with Pasta Thursday Special

$16.00 +

Eggplant Parmigiana with Pasta Thursday Special

$14.00 +

Stuffed Shells Thursday Special

$13.00

Desserts

Rainbow Cookie Cake

$6.00

Cannoli

$5.50

Ice Cream Truffles

$7.00

Chocolate Mousse Cake

$5.50

Nutella Pie

14". Nutella and marshmallows with powdered sugar on top.

$14.00

Tiramisu

$5.50
FYI, this restaurant is not accepting orders right now.

About The Original Carlo's Pizzeria

  • 74-02 Metropolitan Ave, Middle Village, NY 11379
  • American, Calzones, Chicken, Dinner, Italian, Lunch Specials, Pasta, Pizza
  • (718) 894-7915
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / Middle Village / The Original Carlo's Pizzeria
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.