The Sweet Shop NYC
Popular menu items
Caffé Panna + The Sweet Shop NYC Pint: The Eppy Espresso
New! Premium Pints in collaboration with Caffé Panna! Attn: Caffeine Lovers! This brew is for you! Caffé Panna starts with Espresso Flecked, Sweet Cream Ice Cream and mixes in The Sweet Shop NYC's Speciality Chocolate Chips and Dark Chocolate Covered Espresso Beans. Perfect way to start to day or when you want a boost of energy! We love this one! This is a limited edition flavor, only available at The Sweet Shop NYC, subject to sell out!
$22.50Mango Sorbet
They only use mangos that are sweet, slightly acidic and mild-flavored like peaches; the sorbet is very smooth and the flavor is intense! Kid Favorite. Made by hand by Il Laboratorio Del Gelato on The Lower East Side Of NYC.
$5.95 +JoMart Chocolate Covered Oreo Box
Hand dipped MILK Chocolate Covered Oreos with Seasonal Sprinkles. Made by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. Classic gold box with 6 pcs.
$22.50AS SEEN ON INSTAGRAM!
Caffé Panna + The Sweet Shop NYC Pint: Chocolate Buttercrunch Swirl
New! Premium Pints in collaboration with Caffé Panna! Caffé Panna starts with their Milk Chocolate Ice Cream, adds a swirl of their housemade caramel and chunks of The Sweet Shop NYC's Milk and Dark ButterCrunch to make this outstanding flavor. This is a limited edition flavor, only available at The Sweet Shop NYC, subject to sell out!
$22.50Caffé Panna + The Sweet Shop NYC Pint: Oreo Nonpareils Chunk
New! Premium Pints in collaboration with Caffé Panna! Caffé Panna starts with their signature Oreo's and Cream Ice Cream and adds big chunks of The Sweet Shop NYC's Milk, Dark and White Chocolate Nonpareils to create this awesome flavor. This is a limited edition flavor, only available at The Sweet Shop NYC, subject to sell out!
$22.50Cup of Pie: APPLE Pie with Ice Cream
Yum! Our APPLE Pie is scooped and served in a cup! Want it warm? Simply remove the lid and microwave for 45 secs. (Please be careful as the filling gets very hot). Served with a single scoop of vanilla ice cream on the side, topped with a drizzle of premium artisan hot salted caramel sauce and crust bits. ENJOY! 4 oz. scoop of each, pie & ice cream.
$13.50Cup of Pie: PECAN Pie with Ice Cream
A scoop of yummy PECAN Pie served in a cup! Want it warm? Simply remove the lid and microwave for 45 secs. (Please be careful as the filling gets very hot). A 4 oz. scoop of pie served with a single scoop of vanilla ice cream, topped with crust bits and a pecan (pie and ice cream packed separately). ENJOY!
$13.50Cup of Cake: Dos Choco
Sweet Shop Fave! Double Chocolate Dos Choco: Cup of CAKE is like having a Birthday Party in a Cup! Delicious Milk Chocolate Layer Cake with Real Chocolate Buttercream Frosting is scooped into a Cup and topped with Artisan Chocolate Ice Cream, chocolate sprinkles and a chocolate nonpareil. 3 oz. cup of cake with a 4 oz. scoop of ice cream, served on the side. YUM!!
$13.50The Clark: Peanut Butter Sundae
Fan Favorite! This one is BIG and pure decadence! Three scoops of ice cream: chocolate and 2 scoops of peanut butter topped with premium hot fudge sauce, our fresh house made chocolate and vanilla whipped cream, 2 peanut butter cups and a peanut crunch bar, finished with chocolate peanut butter cookie crumble!! Yum!
$18.95Caffé Panna + The Sweet Shop NYC Pint: Matty's Masterpiece
New! Premium Pints in collaboration with Caffé Panna! This is a flavor combo that Matthew created and it's been a house fave, Now Caffé Panna puts a spin on it with Salted Italian Imported Mascarpone Ice Cream then adds a ripple of fudge and Callebaut Chocolate chunks. This is a limited edition flavor, only available at The Sweet Shop NYC, subject to sell out!
$22.50Artisan Ice Creams, Sundaes, Sorbets and Italian Ices
Caffé Panna + The Sweet Shop NYC Pint: Movie Night
New! Premium Pints in collaboration with Caffé Panna! Caffé Panna starts with their Classic Vanilla Ice Cream, and mixes in The Sweet Shop NYC's Movie Night faves: Milk Chocolate Covered Raisins, Milk Chocolate Peanuts and Snicker's Bites. This is a limited edition flavor, only available at The Sweet Shop NYC, subject to sell out!
$22.50Caffé Panna + The Sweet Shop NYC Pint: The Eppy Espresso
New! Premium Pints in collaboration with Caffé Panna! Attn: Caffeine Lovers! This brew is for you! Caffé Panna starts with Espresso Flecked, Sweet Cream Ice Cream and mixes in The Sweet Shop NYC's Speciality Chocolate Chips and Dark Chocolate Covered Espresso Beans. Perfect way to start to day or when you want a boost of energy! We love this one! This is a limited edition flavor, only available at The Sweet Shop NYC, subject to sell out!
$22.50Caffé Panna + The Sweet Shop NYC Pint: Matty's Masterpiece
New! Premium Pints in collaboration with Caffé Panna! This is a flavor combo that Matthew created and it's been a house fave, Now Caffé Panna puts a spin on it with Salted Italian Imported Mascarpone Ice Cream then adds a ripple of fudge and Callebaut Chocolate chunks. This is a limited edition flavor, only available at The Sweet Shop NYC, subject to sell out!
$22.50Caffé Panna + The Sweet Shop NYC Pint: Vanilla Buttercrunch Swirl
New! Premium Pints in collaboration with Caffé Panna! Caffé Panna starts with their Vanilla Bean Ice Cream, adds a swirl of their housemade caramel and chunks of The Sweet Shop NYC's Chocolate Cashew ButterCrunch to make this awesome flavor. This is a limited edition flavor, only available at The Sweet Shop NYC, subject to sell out!
$22.50Caffé Panna + The Sweet Shop NYC Pint: Chocolate Buttercrunch Swirl
New! Premium Pints in collaboration with Caffé Panna! Caffé Panna starts with their Milk Chocolate Ice Cream, adds a swirl of their housemade caramel and chunks of The Sweet Shop NYC's Milk and Dark ButterCrunch to make this outstanding flavor. This is a limited edition flavor, only available at The Sweet Shop NYC, subject to sell out!
$22.50Caffé Panna + The Sweet Shop NYC Pint: Oreo Nonpareils Chunk
New! Premium Pints in collaboration with Caffé Panna! Caffé Panna starts with their signature Oreo's and Cream Ice Cream and adds big chunks of The Sweet Shop NYC's Milk, Dark and White Chocolate Nonpareils to create this awesome flavor. This is a limited edition flavor, only available at The Sweet Shop NYC, subject to sell out!
$22.50Hand Packed Pint of Ice Cream
The BEST way to enjoy our specialty ice creams. Our Hand packed, 16 oz. in our signature ENJOY container. You can choose up-to two flavors!
$14.95 +The Clark: Peanut Butter Sundae
Fan Favorite! This one is BIG and pure decadence! Three scoops of ice cream: chocolate and 2 scoops of peanut butter topped with premium hot fudge sauce, our fresh house made chocolate and vanilla whipped cream, 2 peanut butter cups and a peanut crunch bar, finished with chocolate peanut butter cookie crumble!! Yum!
$18.95The S'more Sundae!
Every day is SUNDAE with this fan fave! 3 scoops of Chocolate and 2 of Toasted Marshmallow Ice Cream, covered in Coop's Premium Small Batch Hot Fudge and then topped with our House Made Chocolate and Vanilla Whipped Cream, a JoMart Chocolate Covered S'more Marshmallow and a Luxardo cherry!!
$18.95The 3 Little Bears Sundae
A triple scoop of ice cream: Chocolate, Vanilla, and Strawberry with a 1/4 lb. of all 3 chocolate covered gummy bears (milk, dark & white chocolate) floating in Coop’s Hot fudge, finished with house made whipped cream and 3 little bears sitting on top!
$18.95Dairy-Free Cookies & Cream Ice Cream
Vegan, Dairy-Free Vanilla Ice Creamy frozen dessert with crushed Oreo's mixed in! Ingredients include: Tapioca syrup, pea protein, coconut oil, etc. Handcrafted by Alphapbet Scoop in the East Village, NYC.
$5.95 +Dairy-Free Vanilla Ice Cream
Vegan, Dairy-Free Vanilla Ice Creamy frozen dessertI. Ingredients include: Tapioca syrup, pea protein, coconut oil, etc. Handcrafted by Alphapbet Scoop in the East Village, NYC.
$5.95 +Apple Cinnamon Ice Cream
Seasonal flavor! A mild fresh apple favored Ice Cream with a swirl of real fresh ground cinnamon. Hand made by Il Laboratorio del gelato on the lower east side of NYC.
$5.95Banana Ice Cream
Made with perfectly ripe bananas, this tropical flavor pairs so well with hot fudge! Yum! Made by hand by Il Laboratorio Del Gelato on The Lower East Side Of NYC.
$5.95 +Birthday Cake Ice Cream
Party Time! A smooth creamy vanilla cake batter with rainbow sprinkles swirled inside. Made by hand by Il Laboratorio Del Gelato on the Lower East Side of NYC.
$5.95 +Butter Praline Pecan Ice Cream
Rich, smooth, creamy, buttery ice cream with delicious roasted praline pecan pieces blended in add a perfect sweet and slightly salty crunch! Handcrafted by Alphabet Scoop in the East Village, NYC.
$5.95 +Candyman's Chocolate Malt Ice Cream
This is the Candyman's Fave! Milk Chocolate Perfection! A lightly malted chocolate, with a custard like texture, this was a secret only flavor for years! Now available to you, we think it's the best chocolate ice cream in NYC! Made by hand by Il Laboratorio Del Gelato on the Lower East Side of NYC.
$5.95 +Chocolate Fudge Brownie Ice Cream
Rich, creamy, Chocolate Ice Cream with with fudge and little chunks of fudgey brownie bites mixed in! Handcrafted by Alphapbet Scoop in the East Village, NYC.
$5.95 +Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream
Rich, creamy, Chocolate Ice Cream with Reese's PB cups and a ribbon of smooth peanut butter! Handcrafted by Alphabet Scoop in the East Village, NYC.
$5.95 +Coffee Dream Ice Cream
The perfect cup of java! The Coffee Dream Ice Cream is so smooth and creamy with great coffee flavor and an old fashioned texture that we just love! Handcrafted by Alphapbet Scoop in the East Village, NYC.
$5.95 +Cookie Dough Ice Cream
Tiny chocolate chip cookie dough balls are dancing inside this delicious vanilla ice cream! It has a smooth, creamy, old fashioned texture that we just love! Handcrafted by Alphapbet Scoop in the East Village, NYC.
$5.95 +Cookies & Cream Ice Cream
Top Seller! The BEST vanilla ice cream is filled with tons of crushed Oreos! Made by Hand by Il Laboratorio del gelato on the lower east side of NYC.
$5.95 +Dark Chocolate w/Chips Ice Cream
Attention Chocolate Lovers! Super dark chocolate ice cream with chunks of Belgian dark chocolate. YUM! Made by hand by Il Laboratorio Del Gelato on The Lower East Side Of NYC.
$5.95 +Eggnog Ice Cream
Tis the season! Enjoy a scoop of this delicious creamy seasonal Eggnog Ice Cream before it's gone! From Il Laboratorio Del Gellato.
$5.95 +Espresso Ice Cream
Wake Up with the delicious ice cream, made with organically grown, locally roasted La Colombe espresso beans, that are crushed and steeped to bring out the beans flavor. Made by hand by Il Laboratorio Del Gelato on The Lower East Side Of NYC.
$5.95 +Fresh Ginger Ice Cream
Fresh Ginger, so much flavor, without an overpowering heat! It has a smooth, creamy, old fashioned texture that we just love! Handcrafted by Alphapbet Scoop in the East Village, NYC.
$5.95 +Fresh Mint Chip Ice Cream
A Sweet Shop NYC Original. The best Mint Chip Ice Cream is made with Fresh spearmint and chunks of dark Belgium chocolate . Made by hand by Il Laboratorio Del Gelato on The Lower East Side Of NYC.
$5.95 +Matcha Green Tea Ice Cream
Matcha, green tea ice cream, the subtle earthy flavor, makes this a house fave! It has a smooth, creamy, old fashioned texture that we just love! Handcrafted by Alphapbet Scoop in the East Village, NYC.
$5.95 +Mascarpone Ice Cream
FANTASTICO ! Mascarpone is the main ingredient in tiramisu, somewhat similar to cream cheese, this velvety soft Italian cheese is mild and sweet. Get it with Hot Fudge ! Made by hand by Il Laboratorio Del Gelato on The Lower East Side Of NYC.
$5.95 +Mocha Cookie Crumble Ice Cream
Coffee and Chocolate blended together become Mocha add to that, crushed Oreo cookies and you have an ice cream dream come true! It has a smooth, creamy, fluffy, old fashioned texture that we just love! Handcrafted by Alphabet Scoop in the East Village, NYC.
$5.95 +Peanut Butter Ice Cream
Using southeastern U.S. peanuts are milled with skins on to form a crunchy peanut butter; skins contribute to the flavor and speckled appearance. Made by hand by Il Laboratorio Del Gelato on The Lower East Side Of NYC.
$5.95 +Pistachio Ice Cream
Roasted California pistachios are blended into a chunky butter and turned into the most incredibly real pistachio ice cream ever! Made by hand by Il Laboratorio Del Gelato on The Lower East Side Of NYC.
$5.95 +Razzle Dazzle Ice Cream
White Chocolate Ice Cream swirled with rich raspberry sauce and mini dark chocolate raspberry truffle bites. Handcrafted by Alphabet Scoop in the East Village, NYC.
$5.95 +Salted Caramel Ice Cream
Fave Flavor! A delicious sweet and salty ice cream, with real mediterranean sea salt and swirls of salted caramel sauce. Made by hand by Il Laboratorio Del Gelato on The Lower East Side Of NYC.
$5.95 +Strawberry Ice Cream
Best Strawberry Ice Cream ever! Using only strawberries picked at perfect ripeness, and plenty of them, this ice cream is just perfect. Made by hand by Il Laboratorio Del Gelato on The Lower East Side Of NYC.
$5.95 +Toasted Marshmallow Ice Cream
They toast marshmallows to their darkest brown to achieve the caramel and coffee flavors that characterize the fireside treat. Think S'more only cold. Made by hand by Il Laboratorio Del Gelato on The Lower East Side Of NYC.
$5.95 +Ube Ice Cream
Limited Edition: UBE is a sweet purple yam, which is blended into a vanilla base. A beautiful lavender color with a sweet creamy flavor. Hurry before it's gone! Handcrafted by Alphabet Scoop in the East Village, NYC.
$5.95 +Vanilla Ice Cream
Best Vanilla Ever ! A unique blend of bourbon and tahitian extracts, along with carefully extracted vanilla beans, give this flavor an unforgettable taste! Hand made by Il Laboratorio del gelato on the lower east side of NYC.
$5.95 +Black Currant Sorbet
Elegance meets icy perfection. This flavor is the perfect balance of slightly sweet and tart. Made by hand by Il Laboratorio Del Gelato on The Lower East Side Of NYC.
$5.95 +Mango Sorbet
They only use mangos that are sweet, slightly acidic and mild-flavored like peaches; the sorbet is very smooth and the flavor is intense! Kid Favorite. Made by hand by Il Laboratorio Del Gelato on The Lower East Side Of NYC.
$5.95 +Chocolate Italian Water Ice
So good! Light refreshing chocolatey flavor, we just love it! Real Old school Chocolate Italian Water Ice. Made by Benfaremo - The Lemon Ice King of Corona in Corona Queens, NY. Naturally Dairy Free and Vegan.
$5.95 +Lemon Italian Water Ice
This one is one of NYC's most loved lemon Italian ices. So real you may even find a lemon pit or rind. Made by Benfaremo - The Lemon Ice King of Corona in Corona Queens, NY. Naturally Dairy Free and Vegan.
$5.95 +Spumoni Italian Water Ice
A yummy combo of flavors! Pistachio, Vanilla and Chocolate, Made by Benfaremo - The Lemon Ice King of Corona in Corona Queens, NY. Naturally Dairy Free and Vegan.
$5.95 +USA Rainbow Italian Water Ice
KIDS FAVORITE ! Cherry, Blueberry and Lemon Italian ice Super Yummy. Made by Benfaremo - The Lemon Ice King of Corona in Corona Queens, NY. Naturally Dairy Free and Vegan.
$5.95 +Vanilla Chocolate Chip Italian Water Ice
Vanilla with Chocolate Chip Water Ice. Made by Benfaremo - The Lemon Ice King of Corona in Corona Queens, NY. Naturally Dairy Free and Vegan.
$5.95 +Gift Boxes: Chocolates
Mayana 16 pc. Box of Chocolates
Beautiful Handmade Chocolates by Mayana Chocolate in Wisconsin. Each and ever piece is a DELICIOUS piece of art. Large box with 16 pieces of chocolate.
$50.00Mayana 9 pc. Box of Chocolates
Beautiful Handmade Chocolates by Mayana Chocolate in Wisconsin. Each and ever piece is a DELICIOUS piece of art. Medium box with 9 pieces of chocolate.
$30.00Mayana 4 pc. Box of Chocolates
Beautiful Handmade Chocolates by Mayana Chocolate in Wisconsin. Each and ever piece is a delicious piece of art. Small box with 4 pieces of chocolate.
$15.00JoMart Chocolate Covered Oreo Box
Hand dipped MILK Chocolate Covered Oreos with Seasonal Sprinkles. Made by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. Classic gold box with 6 pcs.
$22.50The Black Box: Handcrafted Assorted Chocolates
Delicious and Beautiful! Handcrafted Assorted Artisan Chocolates, both creamy milk chocolate and rich dark chocolate covered specialties vary and can include: marzipan, caramel, nuts, truffle, marshmallow, buttercrunch. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1.5 lb. box filled with ASSORTED chocolates. Large Black Box (approx. 40 pcs.)
$68.50JoMart Gold Box of Assorted Chocolates
Handmade chocolates by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. Old fashioned, delicious ASSORTED (milk & dark) chocolates, Gold Jomart Box (approx. 25 pcs.)
$40.00Cup of PIE!
Cup of Pie: PECAN Pie with Ice Cream
A scoop of yummy PECAN Pie served in a cup! Want it warm? Simply remove the lid and microwave for 45 secs. (Please be careful as the filling gets very hot). A 4 oz. scoop of pie served with a single scoop of vanilla ice cream, topped with crust bits and a pecan (pie and ice cream packed separately). ENJOY!
$13.50 +Cup of Pie: CHERRY Pie with Ice Cream
Yummy, award winning CHERRY Pie scooped and served in a cup! Want it warm? Simply remove the lid and microwave for 45 secs. (Please be careful as the filling gets very hot). Served with a single scoop of vanilla ice cream on the side, topped with crust bits and a Luxardo Cherry. ENJOY! 4 oz. scoop of each, pie & ice cream.
$13.50 +Cup of Pie: Kelly BERRY with Ice Cream
Yummy, award winning (Kelly Berry, we call it that since it's Kelly the Candyman's fave!) Blackberry Pie scooped and served in a cup! Want it warm? Simply remove the lid and microwave for 45 secs. (Please be careful as the filling gets very hot). Served with a single scoop of vanilla ice cream on the side, topped with crust bits. ENJOY! 4 oz. scoop of each, pie & ice cream.
$13.50 +Cup of Pie: APPLE Pie with Ice Cream
Yum! Our APPLE Pie is scooped and served in a cup! Want it warm? Simply remove the lid and microwave for 45 secs. (Please be careful as the filling gets very hot). Served with a single scoop of vanilla ice cream on the side, topped with a drizzle of premium artisan hot salted caramel sauce and crust bits. ENJOY! 4 oz. scoop of each, pie & ice cream.
$13.50 +Cup of Pie: Pecan-PLAIN
A scoop of yummy PECAN Pie served in a cup! Want it warm? Simply remove the lid and microwave for 45 secs. (Please be careful as the filling gets very hot). A 4 oz. scoop of pie, topped with crust bits.
$7.50 +Cup of Pie: Cherry-PLAIN
Yummy, CHERRY Pie scooped and served in a cup! Want it warm? Simply remove the lid and microwave for 45 secs. (Please be careful as the filling gets very hot). Topped with crust bits. 4 oz. scoop.
$7.50 +Cup of Pie: Kelly Berry-PLAIN
Yummy, award winning (Kelly Berry, we call it that since it's Kelly the Candyman's fave!) Blackberry Pie scooped and served in a cup! Want it warm? Simply remove the lid and microwave for 45 secs. (Please be careful as the filling gets very hot). Topped with crust bits. ENJOY! 4 oz. scoop.
$7.50 +Cup of Pie: Apple-PLAIN
Yum! Our APPLE Pie is scooped and served in a cup! Want it warm? Simply remove the lid and microwave for 45 secs. (Please be careful as the filling gets very hot). Topped with crust bits. ENJOY! 4 oz. scoop of pie.
$7.50 +Cup of CAKE!
Cup of Cake: Dos Choco
Sweet Shop Fave! Double Chocolate Dos Choco: Cup of CAKE is like having a Birthday Party in a Cup! Delicious Milk Chocolate Layer Cake with Real Chocolate Buttercream Frosting is scooped into a Cup and topped with Artisan Chocolate Ice Cream, chocolate sprinkles and a chocolate nonpareil. 3 oz. cup of cake with a 4 oz. scoop of ice cream, served on the side. YUM!!
$13.50Cup of Cake: Pink Rainbow
Pink Rainbow: Cup of CAKE is like having a birthday party in a cup! Delicious Rainbow Sprinkles Layer Cake with Real Vanilla Buttercream Frosting is scooped into a cup and topped with Fresh Strawberry Ice Cream, rainbow sprinkles and a white chocolate nonpareil! 3 oz. cup of cake with a 4 oz. scoop of ice cream, served on the side. YUM!!
$13.50Cup of Cake: Vanilla Rain
New! Vanilla Rain: Cup of CAKE is like having a Birthday Party in a Cup! Delicious Vanilla Layer Cake with Real Vanilla Buttercream Frosting is scooped into a Cup and topped with Artisan Vanilla Ice Cream, chocolate sprinkles and a chocolate nonpareil. 3 oz. cup of cake with a 4 oz. scoop of ice cream, served on the side. YUM!!
$13.50The BEST! Fresh Baked COOKIES
Birthday Cake Cookie - By Gracie Baked
A funfetti cookie mixed with chunks of cake and m&ms! We bake a fresh batch of Gracie Baked cookies daily at The Sweet Shop NYC.
$4.50Cookies and Cream Cookie - By Gracie Baked
It’s a yummy sugar cookie with tons of Oreo cookies mixed in! If you like Oreos, you’ll love this! We bake a fresh batch of Gracie Baked cookies daily at The Sweet Shop NYC.
$4.50Half Baked Chocolate Chip Cookie - By Gracie Baked
Triple chip cookie: milk, dark and butterscotch chips. It’s crispy around the edges and chewy in the middle! It's the best of both worlds! We bake a fresh batch of Gracie Baked cookies daily at The Sweet Shop NYC.
$4.50Snack Attack Fresh Baked Cookie - By Gracie Baked
The Snack Attack is like having all your favorite snacks in one big delicious Sweet & Salty cookie, it has both Chocolate & Peanut Butter Chips, Pretzels, Potato Chips and a ribbon of Caramel made by @graciebaked you need this now!!!
$4.50Apple Pie Cookie - By DŌ Cookie Dough
Inspired by Thanksgiving Pies, this seasonal cookie, is a fall fave! Sugar cookie + apple pie filling + pie crust pieces all baked to perfection! A big yummy cookie from DŌ Edible & Bakeable Cookie Dough Confections in NYC.
$4.50Chocolate Dream Cookie - By DŌ Cookie Dough
Yum! Chocolate, chocolate and more chocolate. Starting with the Brownie Batter dough, chocolate chips, and crunchy Oreo cookies make the ultimate chocolate lover’s dream come true! A big yummy cookie from DŌ Edible & Bakeable Cookie Dough Confections in NYC.
$4.50Gimme S’more Cookie - By DŌ Cookie Dough
Gimme S’more, combines everything you love about the classic fireside snack! Crispy graham crackers, Hershey's rich milk chocolate and scrumptiously sticky toasted marshmallows! A big yummy cookie from DŌ Edible & Bakeable Cookie Dough Confections in NYC.
$4.50Old Fashioned Chocolate Chip Cookie - By DŌ Cookie Dough
Old fashioned flavor, just like grandma would bake! A big yummy cookie from DŌ Edible & Bakeable Cookie Dough Confections in NYC.
$4.50PB Snickerdoodle with Chocolate Chips Cookie (Vegan & GLUTEN FREE) -
Peanut butter dough is blended with sweet and spicy cinnamon sugar and rich chocolate chips. So good you’d never know it’s GLUTEN FREE AND VEGAN. A big yummy cookie from DŌ Edible & Bakeable Cookie Dough Confections in NYC.
$4.50Dark Chocolate Chip with Sea Salt - By SweetDough™
It's our best selling cookie! A thin, buttery cookie with big chunks of dark chocolate and sea salt. The perfect balance of sweet and salty, and it's delicious! We bake a fresh batch of SweetDough™ cookies daily at The Sweet Shop NYC.
$4.50Oatmeal Currant Cookie - By SweetDough™
It's one of the best oatmeal cookie we've ever had, and it also has delicious currants dancing inside. We bake a fresh batch of SweetDough™ cookies daily at The Sweet Shop NYC.
$4.50Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie - By SweetDough™
A chocolatey cookie with chunks of peanut butter chips. We bake a fresh batch of SweetDough™ cookies daily at The Sweet Shop NYC.
$4.50Snickerdoodle Cookie - By SweetDough™
A buttery and chewy cookie with sugar and cinnamon. We bake a fresh batch of SweetDough™ cookies daily at The Sweet Shop NYC.
$4.50Sprinkles Cookie - By SweetDough™
A yummy, buttery sugar cookie packed with rainbow sprinkles! We bake a fresh batch of SweetDough™ cookies daily at The Sweet Shop NYC.
$4.50The Sweet Shop NYC Ice Cream Sammy
Fresh Baked Cookies Ice Cream Sandwich
Create your own BIG Ice Cream Sammy! Choose two of our Fresh Baked Cookies and a Scoop of your favorite Ice Cream! It doesn't get any better than this!! YUM!! **Please put your two cookies and ice cream flavor in the Special Instructions.** Subject to availability.
$13.50Good Batch Ice Cream Sandwiches
Brownie Caramel Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich
Yummy brownie cookies, salted caramel sauce and house made vanilla ice cream. Made by The Good Batch in Brooklyn.
$9.50Chocolate Chunk Oatmeal Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich
Sea salt oatmeal chocolate chunk cookies, fudge drizzle, vanilla ice cream. Made by The Good Batch in Brooklyn.
$9.50Confetti Cake Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich
Confetti cookies, lemon buttercream, house made vanilla ice cream and sprinkles! Made by The Good Batch in Brooklyn
$9.50Frozen Cheesecake Cookie Sandwiches
Chocolate Chip Frozen CHEESECAKE Cookie Sandwich
They take the Original Cheesecake and add milk chocolate chips, the perfect combo and then sandwich it between two soft chocolate fresh baked thin cookies cookies and Frozen!. YUM!! Handmade by Grandma's Cheesecake Sandwiches, in Whitestone, NY. Contains 1 Sandwich: Net Wt. 4 oz.
$9.50Milk Chocolate Frozen CHEESECAKE Cookie Sandwich
A smooth, luscious mini Milk Chocolate Cheesecake sandwiched between two soft chocolate fresh baked thin cookies make this one the perfect chocolate lover’s treat cookies and Frozen!. YUM!! Handmade by Grandma's Cheesecake Sandwiches, in Whitestone, NY. Contains 1 Sandwich: Net Wt. 4 oz.
$9.50Original Frozen CHEESECAKE Cookie Sandwich
The OG!! Creamy, old school taste, this cheesecake is whipped to perfection and then perfectly sandwiched between two fresh baked crisp golden vanilla cookies cookies and Frozen! YUM!! Handmade by Grandma's Cheesecake Sandwiches, in Whitestone, NY. Contains 1 Sandwich: Net Wt. 4 oz.
$9.50Pumpkin Frozen CHEESECAKE Cookie Sandwich
Seasonal! Hurry, fill your freezer with these! Craving something Pumpkiny? Look no further!! Fresh baked pumpkin cake is crumbled into chunks and then mixed into the delicious cheesecake and then perfectly sandwiched between two fresh baked crisp golden vanilla cookies and Frozen! YUM!! Handmade by Grandma's Cheesecake Sandwiches, in Whitestone, NY. Contains 1 Sandwich: Net Wt. 4 oz.
$9.50Ice Cream Floats
Bubble Up Float
Glass bottle of ice cold lemon/lime cane soda, served with a cup of hand scooped vanilla ice cream on the side, so you can pour and enjoy! Twist to open bottle.
$9.95Cheerwine Float
Glass bottle of ice cold cherry flavored, sugar cane soda, served with a cup of vanilla ice cream on the side. Just pour and enjoy! Twist to open bottle.
$9.95Cream , Creme - Soda Float
Glass bottle of ice cold cream flavored sugar cane soda (soda brand may vary), served with a cup of hand scooped vanilla ice cream on the side, so you can pour and enjoy! Twist to open bottle.
$9.95Diet Root Beer Float
Glass bottle of ice cold Diet Root Beer soda ((soda brand may vary), served with a cup of vanilla ice cream on the side. Pour and enjoy! Twist to open bottle.
$9.95Orange Soda Float
Glass bottle of Orange cane soda, served with a cup of hand scooped vanilla ice cream on the side, so you can pour and enjoy!
$9.95Cola Float
Glass bottle of ice cold Cola flavored sugar cane soda, served with a cup of vanilla ice cream on the side. Twist to open bottle.
$9.95The Classic: Root Beer Float
The Classic Float, just like you remember! Old fashioned, glass bottle of real sugar cane Root Beer (soda brand may vary) served with a cup of hand scooped vanilla ice cream on the side, so you can pour and enjoy! Twist to open bottle.
$9.95A La Mode Nut Free Ice Cream
Chocolate - Nut Free
Delicious Chocolate Ice Cream. Pre-packaged small cup. 3.5 oz. Made by A La Mode Ice Cream in NYC.
$4.00Chocolate PINT Nut Free
Delicious Chocolate Ice Cream. PrePackaged in a 16 oz. pint container. Made by A La Mode Ice Cream in NYC.
$10.95Partly Cloudy - Nut Free
Blue cotton candy ice cream with mini marshmallows. Small, pre-packed cup 3.5 oz. Made by A La Mode Ice Cream in NYC.
$4.00Partly Cloudy PINT Nut Free
Blue cotton candy ice cream with mini marshmallows! PrePackaged in a 16 oz. pint container. Made by A La Mode Ice Cream in NYC.
$10.95Pink Sprinkle Vanilla - Nut Free
Pink-hued vanilla ice cream with rainbow sprinkles, mixed inside. Small, pre-packed cup 3.5 oz. Made by A La Mode Ice Cream in NYC.
$4.00Pink Sprinkle Vanilla PINT Nut Free
Pink-hued vanilla ice cream with rainbow sprinkles mixed inside. PrePackaged in a 16 oz. pint container. Made by A La Mode Ice Cream in NYC.
$10.95Coop's MicroCreamery™ Ice Cream Sauce Toppings
Coop's Hot Fudge Sauce Mini
Small batch, award winning hot fudge topping, sold in their signature tiny "dripping" jar. Handmade with European Chocolate, fresh cream, sugar, cocoa and butter. Needs to be warmed to used as a topping, or eat from the jar! Absolutely No Gluten, No GMOs, No Preservatives, No Corn Syrup and No Artificial Anything. 3 oz. Jar.
$7.95Coop's Hot Salted Caramel Sauce Mini
Small batch, handmade, award winning salted caramel sauce, sold in their signature "dripping" tiny jar. This delicious sauce has a deep, rich flavor, we dare you to resist eating it directly from the jar! Sauce needs to be warmed to use for topping ice cream. No Gluten, No GMOs, No Preservatives, No Corn Syrup, No Artificial Anything. 3 oz.
$7.95Coop's Hot Salted Caramel Sauce
Small batch, handmade, award winning salted caramel sauce, sold in their signature "dripping" jar. This delicious sauce has a deep, rich flavor, we dare you to resist eating it directly from the jar! Sauce needs to be warmed to use for topping ice cream. No Gluten, No GMOs, No Preservatives, No Corn Syrup, No Artificial Anything. 10.6 oz. Jar.
$12.95Coop's VEGAN Hot Fudge Sauce
Small batch, award winning vegan hot fudge topping, sold in their signature "dripping" jar. Dairy-Free, Lactose-Free rich, dark Hot Fudge made with coconut cream and coconut oil. Needs to be warmed to used as a topping, or eat from the jar! Absolutely No Gluten, No GMOs, No Preservatives, No Corn Syrup and No Artificial Anything. 10.6 oz. Jar.
$12.95Coop’s Hot Fudge Sauce
Small batch, award winning hot fudge topping, sold in their signature "dripping" jar. Handmade with European Chocolate, fresh cream, sugar, cocoa and butter. Needs to be warmed to used as a topping, or eat from the jar! Absolutely No Gluten, No GMOs, No Preservatives, No Corn Syrup and No Artificial Anything. 10.6 oz. Jar.
$12.95DO Edible Cookie Dough
DO - Edible Cookie Dough: Brookie Dough
Chocolate Chip Dough and Brownie Batter Swirled Together! Yum! Pre-packed in a 4 oz. cup from DŌ, Cookie Dough Confections in New York City.
$6.50DO - Edible Cookie Dough: Cake Batter
Cake Batter: Chocolate Chip Dough + White Chocolate Chips + Seasonal Sprinkles, it's like a birthday party in a cup! Pre-packed in a 4 oz. cup from DŌ, Cookie Dough Confections in New York City.
$6.50DO - Edible Cookie Dough: VEGAN PB Snickerdoodle with Chocolate Chips Cookie (Vegan & GLUTEN FREE)
eanut butter dough is blended with sweet and spicy cinnamon sugar and rich chocolate chips. So good you’d never know it’s GLUTEN FREE AND VEGAN. A big yummy cookie from DŌ Edible & Bakeable Cookie Dough Confections in NYC.
$6.50DO - Edible Cookie Dough: Signature Chocolate Chip
The classic cookie dough packed with chocolate chips and ready to eat!! Pre-packed in a 4 oz. cup from DŌ, Cookie Dough Confections in New York City.
$6.50DO - Edible Cookie Dough: VEGAN Chocolate Chip
The classic cookie dough packed with chocolate chips and ready to eat, now available as VEGAN. Pre-packed in a 4 oz. cup from DŌ, Cookie Dough Confections in New York City.
$6.50Crispery Crispycakes: Marshmallow Rice Treat
Chocolate Brownie Crispycake: Marshmallow Rice Treat
The gooey sweetness of the marshmallow and the delectable crunch of the crispies come together in a treat that is handmade to perfection. we love this yummy, chocolately brownie marshmallow treat. Made by The Crispery. 1 pc. approx. 6 oz.
$7.75Cookies & Cream-Oreo Crispycake: Marshmallow Rice Treat
Better than your childhood fave...the marshmallowy Crispycake is filled with oreo's and then topped with one! 1 pc. approx. 6 oz.
$7.75Fruity Ringlets Crispycake: Marshmallow Treat
The Crispery’s Fruity Ringlets Marshmallow Crispycakes are loaded with Fruit Loops for a colorful twist on the childhood favorite treat, there are no rice crispies in this one. 1 pc. approx. 6 oz.
$7.75Pretzel Surprise Crispycake: Marshmallow Rice Treat
Sweet & Salty! Layered with chocolate, caramel and pretzels for a salty, sweet marshmallow crunchy, crispy treat! 1 pc. approx. 6 oz.
$7.75Rainbow "Sprinkles" Crispycake: Marshmallow Rice Treat
Fan Favorite! Topped with bright rainbow sprinkles or little balls (nonpareils) based on availability for a colorful twist on your childhood favorite marshmallow, rice crispy treat. 1 pc. approx. 6 oz.
$7.75S'mores Crispycake: Marshmallow Rice Treat
Just like eating S'mores around a campfire only better! Graham cracker and chocolate is stuffed into the middle of the marshmallow rice crispy treat and then the top is toasted. 1 pc. approx. 6 oz.
$7.75Fat Witch Baby Brownies
Fat Witch Baby: Brownie Bite
This mini size (two bite) Brownie packs a lot of chocolately flavor! The original, no nuts. Individually wrapped. Made by Fat Witch Bakery in NYC, since 1991. Approx. 1 oz.
$3.25Fat Witch Baby: Caramel Brownie Bite
This mini size (two bite) Caramel Brownie is super moist, chocolate and caramel! Individually wrapped. Made by Fat Witch Bakery in NYC, since 1991. Approx. 1 oz.
$3.25Fat Witch Baby: Blondie Bite
This mini size (two bite) Blondie has chocolate chips. Individually wrapped. Made by Fat Witch Bakery in NYC, since 1991. Approx. 1 oz.
$3.25Stuff from the Jars
Black Licorice: Allsorts
A British confection, consisting of a variety of multi-colored fondant and black licorice shapes.
$4.00 +Black Licorice: Australian
Our most popular! Australian Black Licorice is best known for its unique taste and soft and chewy texture. Made with real licorice extract for a rich, taste.
$4.00 +Black Licorice: Finnish
Tried and true licorice connoisseurs are sure to appreciate our black Finnish licorice. Packed with the perfect amount of sweetness with a dash of savory flavor, this sticky licorice is a bit stiffer than its Australian rival.
$4.00 +Black Licorice Squares
Slightly chewy and filled with heady molasses and anise flavors, this candy is a decadent treat for anyone who loves black licorice! We call this one Harry, it's his fave!
$4.00 +Black Licorice: Cats
Purrrrfectly delicious! More sweet than salty, traditional Dutch black licorice cats
$4.00 +Black Licorice: Scottie Dogs
Made with real licorice root and pure anise, these dogs are bursting with flavor – perfect for real black licorice and dog lovers.
$4.00 +Black Licorice: Salty Coins
Salty Black Licorice Coins. Also know as Muntdrops, this thin black licorice has a round shape, firm texture, with a bit of sweetness combined with a slightly salty taste. Each coin is embossed with a 1, 5, 10. 20, and 50 Euro denominations. Imported from Holland.
$4.00 +Black Licorice: Double DZ Salt
These Double Salt Black Licorice (DZ) rounds are a flavor tradition! Lots of flavor, big on salt & firm texture. Made In Holland.
$4.00 +Black Licorice: Honey Beehive
Authentic Dutch Licorice, made in the Netherlands, with real honey and a touch of salt. The candy is in the shape of a beehive.
$4.00 +Candy Corn: Jelly Belly Brand
The halloween classic! Ours is so good, we carry it year round! From Jelly Belly!
$4.00 +Dr. Who Jelly Babies
In the British television show Doctor Who, Jelly babies were often mentioned. Fruit flavored English gummy babies dusted in corn starch.
$4.00 +Gumdrops
Soft, chewy and big! Classic gumdrops are a timeless treat. Assorted flavors: cherry, orange, black licorice, lemon, lime and pineapple. Covered in sugar.
$4.00 +The Sweet Shop NYC Gummy Mix
We hand select an assortment of our faves for the day and mix them a big jar! You never know what you'll get.
$4.00 +Gummy Bears
Sweet Shop Fave! Some days we have mini bears, sometimes cubs, but no matter which one you get, they are all awesome! All your favorite fruity and chewy flavors in one place!
$4.00 +Gummy Butterflies
Beautiful Butterflies! Just like our gummy bears, these colorful, bite-sized, mini multi-color butterflies come in 6 assorted colors and flavors: Grape, Strawberry, Orange, Blue Raspberry, Cherry, and Green Apple.
$4.00 +Gummy Blue Sharks
Big blue raspberry flavored sharks with white bellies. Sizes vary, sometimes giant, sometimes small. Always delicious!
$4.00 +Gummy Cola Bottles
Cola gummies are a classic confectionary treat savored by candy lovers of all generations. They have that unique nostalgic penny candy look, with a refreshing cola flavor.
$4.00 +Gummy Chicken Feet
Yep, they look just like chicken feet...but they are so good....and a vibrant cherry flavor!
$4.00 +Gummy Eye Balls
Fruit-flavored, yummy gummy bloodshot eyeballs! Perfect for Halloween or keeping an EYE on things!
$4.00 +Gummy Green Apple Rings
An apple a day, keeps the doctor away! Yummy, sweet and tart green and white apple rings.
$4.00 +Gummy HARIBO Cherries
Life is like a bowl of Cherries! Twin cherries on a green stem, intense fruity flavor, from Haribo!
$4.00 +Gummy Pigs
Yummy Gummy Pink Pigs! Oh so soft and chewy these raspberry flavored gummies are super fun!
$4.00 +Gummy Pineapple Rings
Delicious pineapple gummy rings, have a tangy pineapple flavor with a dusting of sugar. It's a little taste of the tropics in these thin rings!
$4.00 +Gummy Pink Flamingos
Fun, pink flamingos are strawberry flavored yummy gummies! Perfect for tropical parties!
$4.00 +Gummy Pink Cadillacs
Pink Cadillacs! A yummy sweet ride down memory lane, fun shape gummy candy just like the car. Three shades of pink, fruity flavors: strawberry, black currant and cherry.
$4.00 +Gummy Red Juicy Lips
Big Red Juicy Lips, Gummy and jelly. The best is part is, they are 100% yummy!
$4.00 +Gummy Tropical Drops
Tropical Drops are tasty rainbow colored gummies with sparkly sanding sugar for an extra hint of sweetness. Brilliantly colored and flavored with a tropical fruit flavor,
$4.00 +Gummy Unicorns
Magical Unicorns! Each soft, chewy, pastel colored unicorn has a fun fruit flavor like blue raspberry grape, and strawberry.
$4.00 +Gummy Watermelon Ring
A Crowd favorite ! Each of the Rings are packed with delicious and mouth watering watermelon flavor!
$4.00 +Gummy Worms
The Classic! Creepy, Yummy, Gummy, delicious WORMS!! Assorted super fruity flavors.
$4.00 +Jelly Bean Mix: Jelly Belly Brand
The classic mix of 49 yummy flavors. Delicious, fat free, gluten free, and just 4 calories per bean! From Jelly Belly, the BEST!
$4.00 +Jordan Almonds
Jordan almonds are candy-covered almonds that are a classic wedding candy. Giving 5 Jordan almonds symbolize five wishes for the bride and groom: health, happiness, fertility, financial stability, and longevity. We just love them for their pastel colors and crunchy almond shell!
$4.00 +Rainbow Licorice Shooters: Australian
Soft, chewy, bite sized pieces in assorted colors and flavors: lemon, green apple, cherry, blue raspberry, and cola, filled with sweet cream.
$4.00 +Red & White Cream Bites: Australian
Strawberry & Cream Bites offer the classic combination of sweet strawberry and smooth cream. Shaped like a small roll, they're filled with cream, red & white licorice chews.
$4.00 +Red Licorice: Australian
The classic!! Soft, chewy red Australian licorice. We love it, and it's one of The Shop's best sellers too!
$4.00 +Red Licorice: Finnish
Strawberry-flavored. Packed with the perfect amount of sweetness this European licorice is a bit firmer than its Australian rival.
$4.00 +Red Licorice: Wheels
Classic strawberry licorice strips rolled up into a fun wheel! Slightly firmer, if you like softer licorice, please try our bag of shoestring Red Laces.
$4.00 +Red Licorice: Squares
Red licorice strawberry flavored squares, we love the firmer texture of this yummy bite of imported licorice.
$4.00 +Red Swedish Fish
Swedish Fish are known for being red, chewy and delicious. Chewy and delicious taste and texture. Some say they taste like cherry, other strawberry, either way, you're going to love the fruity flavor!
$4.00 +Rainbow Swedish Fish
Rainbow Swedish Fish are chewy and delicious! A combination of fruity flavors in 4 different colors: Classic Red, Green, Yellow and Orange.
$4.00 +Skittles
Taste the rainbow! Skittles have it all — fruit chews in a crisp candy shell and a rainbow of colors. We love the original blend of strawberry, green apple, orange, lemon and grape. And, Skittles are gluten-free!
$4.00 +The Sweet Shop NYC SOUR Gummy Mix
We hand select an assortment of our favorite SOURS for the day and mix them in a big jar! You never know what you'll get.
$4.00 +Sour Jelly Bean Mix - Jelly Belly Brand
The mix of 5 sour jelly beans includes: Sour Apple, Sour Cherry, Sour Grape, Sour Lemon and Sour Orange, these are sure to make you pucker!
$4.00 +Sour Blue Gummy Sharks
Take a bite of these sweet and sour sharks! Two flavors, sour blue raspberry and sweet marshmallow yummy gummies!
$4.00 +Sour Blue Raspberry Bottles
Fun blue raspberry sour bottles are the perfect mix of blue raspberry with sour sugar dusting.
$4.00 +Sour Dudes
Sour Dudes aren't really that sour! But they do have great taste. Assorted flavors, chewy bites, sweet and slightly sour. GREAT FOR KIDS !
$4.00 +Sour Flower Power
A delicious sweet and sour flower. Each is a triple flavored blossom with apple. strawberry and watermelon.
$4.00 +Sour Grapefruit Slices
Sparkling Grapefruit citrus flavor is tangy and sweet, grapefruit slices, sanded gummy slices. Made by Haribo.
$4.00 +Sour Patch Kids
Sour watermelon flavored green log filled with a sweet pink cream. Imported from Sweden.
$4.00 +Sour Lips - Red and Pink Mixed
Sending you a big kiss! These lips are super sour and chewy! Mwahhh! Made by Jelly Belly.
$4.00 +Sour Swedish Tongues
Swedish gummy candy "tongues" assorted EXTRA SOUR gummies with European texture and flavor.
$4.00 +Sour Swedish Pink Skulls
Sour Pink Skulls have sour raspberry and marshmallow flavor, we think they taste like cotton candy with a sour sugar coating. Imported from Sweden.
$4.00 +Sour Swedish Rainbow Skulls
Super Sour! These have great flavor and European chewy texture. The Skull's sour sugar coating make these gummies fun to eat. Imported from Sweden.
$4.00 +Sour Swedish Tools (Wrenches)
Swedish Sour Tools (Wrenches) are so crazy good! You will love these jaw clenching, super sour candies that explode with strawberry & apple flavors. Excellent sour flavor and texture, imported.
$4.00 +Sour Neon Worms
The classic sour worm! Yummy, dusted with a sour coating giving it it's tart sour taste. Assorted colors and flavors include lemon, orange, strawberry, blue raspberry and green apple.
$4.00 +Sour Patch Watermelon Rinds
The Best! A combo of sweet watermelon flavor that's covered in a tangy blast. Sour Patch Watermelon are tiny slices of soft, chewy sour sanded watermelon candy that are positively addictive! We love these!
$4.00 +Sour Power Belts: Apple
Customer fave! Top selling Sour! Super sour power ribbons "belts" of sweet and sour green Apple flavor!
$4.00 +Sour Power Belts: Rainbow
Customer fave! Top selling Sour! Super sour power ribbons "belts" of sweet and sour in a rainbow of flavors!
$4.00 +Sour Power Belts: Strawberry
Customer fave! Top selling Sour! Super sour power ribbons "belts" of sweet and sour Strawberry flavor!
$4.00 +Sour Power Belts: Watermelon
Customer fave! Top selling Sour! Super sour power ribbons "belts" of sweet and sour Watermelon flavor!
$4.00 +Sour Red Swedish Fish
The childhood classic, only it's SOUR! Red Fish are covered in sour sugar. What a great twist on a Swedish fish!
$4.00 +Sour Rainbow Bricks
Sour Rainbow Bricks! A square of rainbow colors in fruity flavors, covered in sour sanding sugar.
$4.00 +Sour Rainbow Cream Bites
Rainbow colored and fruit flavored cream filled and covered in sour sanding sugar for a fun combo of sweet and sour!
$4.00 +Sour Stars and Moons
Gummy Sour Stars & Moons are covered in a glittery sugar coating that gives these heavenly-inspired gummy candies an alluring twinkle.
$4.00 +MILK Chocolate Foiled Wrapped Hearts
Delicious solid milk-chocolate HEARTS wrapped in RED colored Italian foil. Premium chocolates made by Madelaine Chocolates in Rockaway, NY, since 1949.
$7.25 +CandyLand
The Sweet Shop NYC: Mystery Gummy Box
TOP SELLER!! A fun box filled with our favorite picks of gummy and sour gummy candies. Yummy candy and a surprise in every box. You're sure to find a new fave in your mystery box. Made by us! Packaging and content may vary. Approx. 1/2 lb.
$10.00DARK Chocolate Muddy Bites
Muddy Bites are the best part of a Sundae Cone, that perfect last bite at the end of the cone! Bag of bite Sized Waffle Cone Ends Filled with DARK Chocolate. 2.33 oz. Approx. 12 pcs. per bag.
$9.50MILK Chocolate Muddy Bites
Muddy Bites are the best part of a Sundae Cone, that perfect last bite at the end of the cone! Bag of bite Sized Waffle Cone Ends Filled with MILK Chocolate. 2.33 oz. Approx. 12 pcs. per bag.
$9.50100 Grand Bar
100 Grand, originally called the $100,000 Candy Bar and then, from the 1970s through the mid-1980s, as the $100,000 Bar is a candy bar produced by the Ferrara Candy Company, a subsidiary of Ferrero. The candy bar was created in 1964 by Nestlé. It weighs 1.5 ounces (43 g) and includes chocolate, caramel and crisped rice.
$2.75AfterShocks Popping Candy
AfterShocks Iconic Spiked bag is super cool and filled with 20 tiny individual pouches of popping candy. 1.06 oz. Assorted flavors, we'll pick one for you.
$6.00AfterShocks Popping Candy Gummy Fries
Dip your fries into the popping candy and enjoy! Popping candy with Fruity Gummy "fries", individually wrapped 3 packs in one outer pouch.
$6.00Airheads Filled Ropes
Chewy and Sweet, filled with a with the fruity, tangy sweetness you love in a fun. Chewy, soft texture that's fun to eat. Original Fruit Flavors, Blue Raspberry, Cherry, Orange, Strawberry, Watermelon. Net wt. 2 oz. package.
$3.75Annie B’s Caramel Popcorn
So delicious! Original caramel covered popcorn made by Annie B's Caramel Co. Made from non-GMO popcorn and quality caramel. 2.25 oz bag.
$3.75Astronaut Ice Cream Sandwich
Old School Favorite!! This is the one the astronauts took to the moon! Freeze dried trio of flavors: chocolate, vanilla and strawberry ice cream sandwich (not cold).
$6.00Bag of Unicorn Farts: Cotton Candy
Sugar is sweet, lemons are tart. We love you more than a Bag of Unicorn Farts! Delicious Fruity flavored Cotton Candy, makes a FUN gift! Made in the USA. 3 oz. bag
$6.00Bag of Reindeer Farts: Cotton Candy
Straight from Santa's Workshop at the North Pole comes a delicacy so rare that few know it exists. Sweet as a Candy Cane...Reindeer Farts Cotton Candy is a perfect stocking stuffer. Made in the USA. 3 oz. bag
$6.00Big Gummy Bear
Fun and Yummy, our Big Gummy Bear is individually packaged in a clear bear shaped container. 12 ounces of gummy goodness, colors and flavors vary: red/cherry, green/apple, orange/orange, and blue/blue raspberry. 1 pc.
$10.00Big League Chew GUM
Pouch filled with shredded gum, made to like chewing tobacco-a habit common among ballplayers in the 1970s. Assorted flavors, we'll pick one for you!
$2.75Klepper & Klepper The Best Licorice Ever - Honey
The Best Licorice Ever, according to the makers Klepper and Klepper. Real Old Fashioned Black licorice, these are made with the best honey they could find, hard chew licorice, round shape. Gluten and Gelatin Free. Handmade in the Netherlands, upholding positive environmental practices while making their products. Vegan. 7 oz. bag
$7.50Klepper & Klepper The Best Licorice Ever - Sweet
The Best Licorice Ever, according to the makers Klepper and Klepper. Real Old Fashioned Black licorice, these are sweet, capsule shaped, hard but chewy licorice. Gluten and Gelatin Free. Handmade in the Netherlands, upholding positive environmental practices while making their products. Vegan. 7 oz. bag
$7.50Klepper & Klepper The Best Licorice Ever - Sea Salt
The Best Licorice Ever, according to the makers Klepper and Klepper. Real Old Fashioned Black licorice, these are mildly salty, made with unrefined Celtic licorice and are diamond shaped, hard licorice. Gluten and Gelatin Free. Handmade in the Netherlands, upholding positive environmental practices while making their products. Vegan. 7 oz. bag
$7.50Bottle Caps Candy
Bottle Caps are sweet pressed candies made to look like metal soda bottle caps in grape, cola, orange, root beer, and cherry flavors. 1.77 oz.
$2.75Broadway Licorice Roll
A re-creation of the Classic! Remered as the Delfa Roll or Danish Ribbon, it's a delicious candy roll of red strawberry licorice.
$2.75Bubble Tape Gum
Hubba Bubba Bubble Tape. 6 feet of chewing, bubble blowing fun! Original flavor.
$2.75Bubblegum Cigarettes
Nostalgic Candy: the original candy gum cigarette, no smoking here, just chewing! Assorted packs, we'll pick one for you! Psst, these are the ones that when you bow through them the sugar looks like smoke.
$3.00Butterfinger
It consists of a layered crisp peanut butter core covered in a chocolatey coating. They call it a one of a kind - crispety, crunchety, peanut-buttery chocolate bar, made since 1923!
$2.75Candy Buttons
Bring the fun of childhood back with Candy Buttons. Classic pink, yellow and blue dots in cherry, lemon and lime flavors sit on peel and eat sheets. A fun and nostalgic candy experience, 1 oz. package with 4 sheets.
$3.50Candy Cigarettes
Candy cigarettes, 10 white candy cigs in a box. Assorted "brands", we'll pick a pack for you!
$3.00Charleston Chew Chocolate
Chewy, chocolate flavored nougat wrapped in a rich, chocolaty coating have made Charleston Chew an American favorite since 1922. We love it frozen!
$2.75Charleston Chew Strawberry
Chewy, strawberry flavored nougat wrapped in a rich, chocolaty coating have made Charleston Chew an American favorite since 1922. We love it frozen! One 1.8 oz. Bar.
$2.75Charleston Chew Vanilla
Chewy, vanilla flavored nougat wrapped in a rich, chocolaty coating have made Charleston Chew an American favorite since 1922. We love it frozen!
$2.75Chowards Peppermints
These should bring back some old school memories! Choward's uses real Peppermint Oil to produce a strong mint with a smooth taste. The C. Howard Company Inc. was started in New York City in the early 1930’s and still manufactures these in NY to this day.
$2.75Chowards Scented Gum
This gum should bring back some old school memories! Choward's Scented Gum is a very unusual combination of flavors, including cinnamon, clove and a hint of the flowery violet. They call it "Fragrance that refreshes after eating, smoking or drinking." The C. Howard Company Inc. was started in New York City in the early 1930’s and still manufactures these in NY to this day.
$2.75Chowards Violets
These should bring back some old school memories! Choward's Violet Mints have a super unique and nostalgic floral flavor and fragrance. The C. Howard Company Inc. was started in New York City in the early 1930’s and still manufactures these in NY to this day.
$2.75Clark Bar
An American classic has returned! Delicious real milk chocolate filled with real peanut butter crunch.
$2.75Clark Peanut Butter Cup
An American classic has returned! Delicious real milk chocolate filled with real peanut butter crunch.
$2.75Colorado Candy Co Hard Candy
Old Fashioned, small batch, handmade hard candies. Such delicious candies available in natural flavors with no preservatives added. Choose a flavor: Lemon, Root Beer, Orange. Clear box.
$10.00Dinosaur Candy Spray
Cool dinosaur candy spray, remove head to spray candy. Three different colors/flavors: Watermelon, Strawberry, Blue Raspberry. We'll pick one for you!
$6.00Emoji Gummy Kebab
Fun, gummies are stacked on a stick and topped with an Emoji. Assorted, we'll pick one for you!
$5.50Freeze Dried Candy: Frings Blue Raspberry Gummy
Freeze Dried Candy: Blue Raspberry Gummies, freeze dried for 24 hours in small batches by hand in Ohio. Net wt. 1.8 oz. 8-9 pcs. per bag. FYI: These are Super Fragile and subject to breakage and crumble. But still just as Yummy!
$15.95Freeze Dried Candy: Frizzlies 5 Flavor Gummies
Freeze Dried Candy: Green apple, cherry, lemon, orange, and watermelon Gummies, freeze dried for 24 hours in small batches by hand in Ohio. Net wt. 1 oz. 4-5 pcs. per bag. FYI: These are Super Fragile and subject to breakage and crumble. But still just as Yummy!
$8.95Freeze Dried Candy: Frigglers Sour Neon Gummy Worms
Freeze Dried Candy: Neon Sour Worm Gummies, freeze dried for 24 hours in small batches by hand in Ohio. Net wt. 1.8 oz. 8-9 pcs. per bag. FYI: These are Super Fragile and break easily, but are still awesome!
$8.95Freeze Dried Candy: Friddles Wildberry Skittles
Freeze Dried Candy Wildberry Skittles, freeze dried for 24 hours in small batches by hand in Ohio. Net wt. 3.5 oz. approx. 90 pcs. per bag. FYI: These are Super Fragile and subject to breakage and crumble. But still just as Yummy!
$8.95Fruit Jellie Squeeze Candy
The viral TikTok jelly fruit candy! Fun fruits filled with Jelly that you squeeze. Strawberry, Sour Apple, Pineapple, Grape, and Orange. 1 BAG
$7.50Fun Dip
It all starts with the candy Lik-A-Stix. Lick it up and dip into the sugary sweet and mildly sour kick powder.
$2.50Giant Chewy Sweet Tarts
Just like sweet tarts...only GIANT!! Chewy, sweet, tart and each one is about the size of a half dollar.
$3.00Giant Gummy Bear Lolly
The classic gummy bear just got a BIG upgrade. Three delicious fruity flavors of cherry, lemon, and sour apple make up this gummy bear on a stick. Makes a fun gift for the gummy bear lover!
$20.00Goetze's Classic Caramel Cream
An American classic! Rich caramel with a creamy vanilla center. They aren’t too sticky, and they aren’t too sweet. soft, chewy, caramel creams still packaged the same old fashioned way. Net Wt. 1.9 oz. package.
$2.75Goetze's Caramel Cream with Oreo
New! Oreo Cookies and Goetze's Caramel Creams blended together, surrounding a creamy center is sure to be a new classic. Net wt. 1.9 oz. package.
$2.75Goldenberg's Peanut Chews In Original Dark
Finally, dark chocolate lovers can rejoice! Yummy chewy chocolate bites loaded with crunchy peanuts. Net Wt. 2.0 Oz
$2.75Gummy Candy Sushi-Large
This colorful set creatively combines gummy, marshmallow, and licorice to form classic sushi favorites. No fishy flavors here, all sweet and ready to eat! Approximately 21 pcs. in each bento box.
$18.95Gummy Candy Sushi-Small
This colorful set creatively combines gummy, marshmallow, and licorice to form classic sushi favorites. No fishy flavors here, all sweet and ready to eat! Approximately 9 pcs. in each bento box.
$8.95Gummy Pizza-Large
It's a pizza with all the toppings...made from GUMMY CANDY! Comes in it's delivery box. FUN & YUMMY!
$18.95Gummy Pizza-Small
Delicious gummy candies put together to look like a mini pizza pie with toppings! Served in a small cardboard pizza box.
$8.95Gummy Taco
Perfect for Taco Tuesday or any day! Made to look like a taco, in a cardboard tortilla, it's filled with 23 gummies that look like: tomatoes, cheese, lettuce, protein, and salsa! Individually wrapped, 4.05 oz.
$8.95Handmade Jumbo Candy Cane
Hammond's candy canes are all handmade and the size may vary. These are larger candy canes that store bought boxed candy canes. Each Cane is individually wrapped. Hammond's handmade Candy Canes have been a holiday tradition since 1920. Assorted Flavors, we'll pick one for you!
$4.00Jawbreaker on a Stick
A golf ball size jawbreaker on a stick. Bet you can't get to the middle of this one!
$4.00Jelly Belly™ Jelly Bean Gift Box
20 original Jelly Belly flavors, the assortments are separated into their own spot, flavor description chart included. Nice acrylic box for yourself or gifting!
$25.00Juicy Drop GUM
Sweet Gum with Sour Gel to squirt on top! Assorted flavors, we'll pick one for you!
$4.75Juicy Drop Gummies
Squeeze the sour gel pen onto the sweet gummies - try a little or a lot! Assorted flavors, we'll pick one for you!
$4.75Juicy Drop RE MIX
One side is Sweet and and the other is Sour! Fun and Yummy Chewy Candy. Assorted flavors, we'll pick one for you!
$4.75Juicy Drop Taffy
Chewy taffy and sour gel that can be used to create the perfect mix of sweet and sour in every delicious bite. Assorted flavors, we'll pick one for you! 2.36 oz.
$4.75Kaboom Candy
Fun! Yummy sour cherry popping candies in a colorful red container with a novelty fuse.
$6.00King Sized Goldenberg's Peanut Chew in Original Dark
Finally, dark chocolate lovers can rejoice! Yummy chewy chocolate bites loaded with crunchy peanuts. Net Wt. 3.3 Oz
$4.25Laffy Taffy Banana
Banana Laffy Taffy Stick. Sweet and Stretchy. Tangy and Chewy! A joke on every label is what makes this so much fun!
$2.75Laffy Taffy Grape
Grape Laffy Taffy Bar. Sweet and Stretchy. Tangy and Chewy! A joke on every label is what makes this so much fun!
$2.75Laffy Taffy Strawberry
Strawberry Laffy Taffy Bar. Sweet and Stretchy. Tangy and Chewy! A joke on every label is what makes this so much fun!
$2.75Luscious Gourmet Lollies
The original Linda's Lollies, handmade gourmet Lollipops. Assorted flavors, we'll pick one for you!
$1.95McGraws Giant Flat Taffy Candy
Original old fashioned flat taffy. Made in the USA by Hammonds. Each piece is 12" long, super thin and is individually wrapped. One .75 oz. Assorted flavors, we'll pick one for you.
$3.00Moose Munch Caramel Popcorn
Moose Munch! Buttery, crunchy Caramel popcorn made by Harry & David. Everyone's favorite features butter toffee popcorn, cashews, almonds and peanuts in this 4-ounce package.
$10.00Nerds Candy
Sweet, little, crunchy bites! The box contains two separate flavors: Strawberry/Grape and Watermelon/Cherry. We'll pick one for you. 1 box, 1.65 oz.
$2.75Nerds Rope
The perfect combination of a "sweet & crunchy". A chewy rope is covered in tiny nerds candy. Assorted flavors vary, we'll pick one for you. Net Wt. .92 oz Each Rainbow Nerds Rope measures 13" long and is individually wrapped
$2.75Nestle Crunch Bar
Even more Scrumptious! Yum! Creamy milk chocolate and crisped rice, the Classic!
$2.75Nik L Nip
Just like you remember! “Bite ‘Em, Drink ‘Em, Chew ‘Em”. For nearly a century, fruit-flavored, liquid-filled Nik-L-Nip Mini Drinks have been a favorite. Five fruity flavors: Chillin' Cherry, O-So Orange, Hello Lemon, Blazin' Blue Raspberry, and Groovin' Green.
$2.75Novelty Milk Chocolate Bar
Yummy, creamy milk chocolate bar. Let us pick one for you from our seasonal selection of fun wrappers. 1.75 oz. bar.
$3.00Old Fashioned Cotton Candy
The classic, fluffy spun sugar floss! Sure to bring back summertime memories of fun at carnivals, beaches and more! Delicious blue and pink cotton candy in a re-sealable container.
$5.50Orthodox Chews Salt Water Taffy
Delicious and Fun! Bag of Old Fashioned Salt Water Taffy bites. 1 lb bag
$13.50Pop Rocks
FUN! The Original Popping Candy. Assorted Flavors, we'll pick one for you! One 0.33 oz bag.
$3.00Prisoner of Love: Solid Chocolate Handcuffs
Perfect Fun for your Valentine! These "lifesize" chocolate handcuffs are made Milk Belgian Chocolate. Fun Gift! In it's own box: 4.5 oz.
$12.50Rainbow Licorice Laces
Bag of assorted flavor laces hand packaged at The Sweet Shop NYC. 1/4 lb. bag. Imported from Holland.
$5.00Razzles Original
irst it's Candy, Then it's Gum! Morphing from a tasty, fruit-flavored candy into an equally tasty and chewable piece of gum, Razzles offers a hybrid of confectionary treats in every round, bite-sized tablet. Blaze'n Blueberry, Gushin' Grape, Luscious Lemon, Razzle Raspberry, and Tangerine Orange. 1.4 oz. pouch.
$2.75Razzles Sour
First it's Candy, then it's Gum! Morphing from a tasty, fruit-flavored candy into an equally tasty and chewable piece of gum, Razzles offers a hybrid of confectionary treats in every round, bite-sized tablet. Each delicious sour candy filled pouch includes five mouth puckering flavors: Blue Raspberry, Cherry, Lemon, Lime, and Orange. 1.4 oz. pouch.
$2.75Razzles Tropical
First it's Candy, Then it's Gum! Morphing from a tasty, fruit-flavored candy into an equally tasty and chewable piece of gum, Razzles offers a hybrid of confectionary treats in every round, bite-sized tablet. Kiwi-Lime, Pineapple, Strawberry-Banana, Tangerine, and Tropical Punch. 1.4 oz. pouch.
$2.75Reed's Root Beer Candy
Reed’s individually wrapped hard candy has returned! Root Beer flavored hard candies. Each roll contains 7 individually wrapped candies. 1.01 oz. roll.
$2.75Reed's Cinnamon Candy
Reed’s individually wrapped hard candy has returned! Sweet cinnamon candies, 7 individually wrapped candies. 1.01 oz roll
$2.75REESE’S GIANT SIZED, PEANUT BUTTER BAR
GIANT Reese’s milk chocolate peanut butter BAR. Net Wt. 6.8 Oz
$7.50Regal Crown Sour Cherry Candy
Regal Crown Sour Cherry hard candy has finally made its return! Each roll contains 7 individually wrapped candies. 1.01 oz. roll.
$2.75Regal Crown Sour Lemon Candy
Regal Crown Sour Lemon hard candy has finally made its return! Each roll contains 7 individually wrapped candies. 1.01 oz. roll.
$2.75Ring Pop
The Classic! Ring pop...a wearable plastic ring with a large hard candy "jewel". Assorted flavors, we'll pick one for you!
$1.50Rock Candy Lolly Pop
The classic rock candy, individually wrapped on a stick. The sticks measure approximately 6 1/2 inches, and the rock candy measures approximately 4 inches. Assorted flavors: cherry, grape, blue raspberry, strawberry, cotton candy, watermelon, and clear (natural)., we'll pick one for you! 1 pc.
$3.00Slime Licker
Toxic Waste® Slime Lickers™ : Sour rolling liquid candy, is a TikTok sensation! Try it and see why! Experience the sourest candy on the planet. The super-sour flavors vary: Blue Raspberry and Strawberry, we'll pick one for you! 2 oz. container, 1 pc. gluten-free
$8.95SMARTIES Roll
The OG big Smarties! Classic Flavors: there are six colors of candy tablets that are randomly mixed together; White: Orange/Cream, Yellow: Pineapple, Pink: Cherry Green: Strawberry, Purple Grape and Orange.
$2.75Sour Flush Candy
FUN!! A tiny toilet filled with sour powder and a lolly to dip inside! No toilet paper required! Assorted flavors, we’ll pick one for you!
$4.25Sour Gummy French Fries
Cute box of Sour Gummy French Fries. Little yellow strips look like yummy french fries. 1.9 oz box .
$7.50Sour Swedish Viking Gummy Bag
Premium Swedish Candy. Strawberry, pear, cherry, black currant, lemon and orange flavored sour gummy. 4 oz. resealable bag. - Non GMO - Free of High Fructose Corn Syrup - Free of Synthetic Colors - 0g Trans Fat Per Serving - Gluten Free - Gelatin Free
$6.00Sugar Daddy Mini Size
America's oldest and most popular milk caramel lollipop! Warning: Hard caramel, be careful with your teeth on this one!
$1.00Super Blow Pop
Super Blow Pops are twice the size of regular blow pops. Every pop starts as a delicious fruit flavored hard candy shell, filled with a soft bubble gum center. Assorted flavors vary, we'll pick one for you! 1 pc.
$2.00Sweet Shot: Liquid Sour Candy
A fun candy syringe! Sour candy gel that's oozing with great taste. Sour flavors include Watermelon (green), Strawberry (red) and Blue Raspberry (blue). Assorted, we'll pick one for you! One tube: Net wt. 4 oz.
$5.00SweeTarts
SweeTarts! They're a sweet, but tart and tangy, mouth-puckering candy. Bite 'em... you'll see. They're sweet, no they're tart!
$2.75The Candy Man's Silkies
A Sweet Shop FAVE!! A handmade marshmallow covered in delicious chewy caramel. 1 pc. individually wrapped, made just for us. Please request Chocolate or Vanilla.
$1.50Toasted Coconut Marshmallows
Handmade Marshmallow covered in toasted coconut. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. Approx. 6-8 pcs. in a bag.
$7.50Tootsie Pop
The Original! A Tootsie Pop is a hard candy lollipop filled with chocolate-flavored chewy Tootsie Roll candy. How many licks does it take? Assorted flavors, we'll pick one for you!
$1.00Toxic Waste Drum Candy
SUPER SOUR HARD CANDY!!! Each container is shaped like a drum of Toxic Waste filled with an assortment of super-sour flavors.
$4.00Triple Push Pop
Lovers of Push Pops® will enjoy having three times the flavor and three times the fun with Fruit Triple Power Push Pops. Each push pop case comes with 3 separate pops in Watermelon, Strawberry, and Blue Raspberry flavors that can be eaten one, two or all three at a time. And of course, the pops can be stored neatly in the container for later licking.
$5.00Warhead Extreme Sour Minis Hard Candy
SOUR POWER! Five assorted flavors of super sour, tiny hard candies. Resealable plastic box. 1.75 oz.
$3.50Whatchamacallit Bar
It's Back! A marshmallow peanut buttery Rice Krispy bottom, a layer of caramel, topped with melted chocolate chips.
$2.75Whirly Pop
There's nothing more iconic than a big swirly lolly! These Whirly Pop lollipops are 5.25" wide and are on a wooden stick, individually wrapped and gluten-free. 1 pc. 6 oz. Colors vary, we'll pick one for you!
$7.95MILK Chocolate POPing Candy Bar
We LOVE this New POPing Milk Chocolate Bar! Creamy milk chocolate with popping candies mixed in! 1.75 oz. bar
$3.50Super Mario Heart
Cute little heart shaped clear red box with Nintendo Super Mario shrink wrap, pack of 12 small cherry candies inside. Fun Kids Valentine! 1 pc.
$1.50Theatre Box of Classic Candy
Airheads Theater Box
Each box contains 6 individually wrapped bars of fruity, tangy candy in these classic flavors: Watermelon, Blue Raspberry, Orange, White Mystery, Cherry and Grape. They're also: peanut and tree nut free, gluten free, and kosher.
$3.75Bit-O-Honey Theater Box
Made with real honey and almond bits blended into delicious taffy! No artificial flavors. Gluten Free. Low Fat. Theater Box. Perfect for movie night or any time! Net Wt. 4 oz.
$3.75Boogers Theater Box
Yes, BOOGERS!! These tangy and yummy gummy boogers are deliciously gross! LOL Flavors include Snottermelon, Sour Green Boogies and Lemon Loogy. Net wt. 3.5 oz. box.
$3.75Boston Baked Beans Theater Box
The Original! These hard candy-coated peanuts are made the way they have always been made, since 1924. Sweet, salty and crunchy. Net wt. 4.3 oz box.
$3.75Chewy Red Hots Theater Box
Great Red Hot cinnamon flavor in every chewy bite! Net wt. 5.5 oz box.
$3.75Chuckles MINIS Theater Box
A miniature version of the classic Chuckles Candy. Sweet, sugar-coated, jelly candy in an assortment of flavors including lemon, lime, cherry, orange, and licorice. Theater Box. Perfect for movie night or any time! Net Wt. 5 oz.
$3.75Cookie Dough Bites Theater Box
The Original Cookie Dough Bites are bite size cookie dough covered in creamy milk chocolate. Try'em Frozen! Theater Box. Perfect for movie night or any time! Net Wt. 3.1 oz.
$3.75Crows Black Licorice Theater Box
The classic, soft black licorice flavored gum drops. Net wt. 6. 5 oz. box.
$3.75DOTS Theater Box
Assorted fruit flavored gumdrops. They're still making these chewy DOTS in the original 5 Flavors: Cherry, Strawberry, Lemon, Lime, and Orange. Perfect for movie night or any night! Net Wt. 6.5 oz.
$3.75Everlasting Gobstopper Theater Box
Tiny jawbreakers that change color and flavor! Perfect for movie night or any night! Net wt. 5 oz.
$3.75Good and Plenty Theater Box
The classic! Pink and white candy coated black licorice flavored candy bites. Crunchy, chewy and delicious! Net wt. 6 oz. box.
$3.75Hot Tamales Theater Box
The OG Cinnamon Candy! Spicy and intense chewy cinnamon flavored candies, super refreshing taste! Theater Box. Perfect for movie night or any time! Net Wt. 5 oz.
$3.75Jujubes Theater Box
Just like you remember them! Each box of Jujubes contains a rainbow of colors & five refreshingly fruity, classic flavors you'll love to chew: lilac, violet, lime, lemon & wild cherry. Net wt. 5.5 oz. box.
$3.75Jujyfruits Theater Box
Jujyfruits are small, chewy, fruit-shaped and flavored candies. The shapes are Pineapple, Tomato, Raspberry, Grape Bundle, Asparagus Bundle, Banana & Pea Pod. Fruity flavors correspond to the colors (not the shapes) and include RED raspberry, BLACK licorice, GREEN lime, ORANGE orange and YELLOW lemon. Net wt. 5 oz. box.
$3.75Junior Caramels Theater Box
Bite-sized, soft buttery caramel pieces covered in creamy milk chocolate. Net wt. 3.6 oz. box, approx. 27 pieces.
$3.75Junior Mints Theater Box
"It's chocolate, it's peppermint, it's delicious!" Bite sized pieces of creamy mint, covered in thick dark chocolate. Theater Box. Perfect for movie night or any time! Net Wt. 3.5 oz.
$3.75Lemonhead Theater Box
The original lemon candy! Lemonheads are round, lemon-flavored candy, with a sweet coating, soft sour shell, and a hard candy core. Perfect for movie night or any night! Net wt. 5 oz.
$3.75Mike and Ike Jolly Joes Theater Box
If it's all GRAPE that you're looking for, then you're going to love these crunchy and chewy grape flavored Mike and Ike candy. Net Wt. 5 oz. Box.
$3.75Mike and Ike Mega Mix Sour Theater Box
With 10 mouth-puckering, sour fruit flavored candies in one box, they are guaranteed to pack a powerful punch. Flavors include Sour Zappin’ Apple, Sour Slammin’ Strawberry, Sour Screamin’ Cherry, Sour Juicy Lemon, Sour Green Limeade, Sour Pucker Punch, Sour Power Pineapple, Sour Watermelon Wipeout, Sour Grape Soda and Sour Shockin’ Raspberry. Net wt. 5 oz. box.
$3.75Mike and Ike Original Fruits Theater Box
MIKE AND IKE® Original Fruits, bursting with five FRUCHEWY® flavors including: Cherry, Lemon, Lime, Orange and Strawberry. These are still a fan favorite! Net Wt. 5 oz. box
$3.75Mike and Ike Tropical Typhoon Theater Box
Jam-packed with five tropical FRUCHEWY® flavored candies to send your taste buds twirling! Enjoy mouth-watering flavors including Paradise Punch, Kiwi-Banana, Caribbean Punch, Strawberry-Banana and Mango! Net wt. 5 oz. box.
$3.75Milk Duds Theater Box
The classic!! Milk Duds are caramel nuggets covered in milk chocolate. Net wt. 5 oz. box.
$3.75Nerds Gummy Clusters Theater Box
We just love the chewy and crunchy New Nerds cluster, it's fun to eat this sweet and sour treat. Net wt. 3 oz. box.
$3.75Rainbow Nerds Theater Box
TINY, TANGY and CRUNCHY: Rainbow Nerds are a mix of fruity flavors in a rainbow of colors. Net wt. 5 oz. box
$3.75Red Hots Theater Box
1930's, the Ferrara Pan Candy Company created the famous Red Hot using the cold panned candy method. Red Hots are also known as "cinnamon imperials"
$3.75Runts Theater Box
These retro candies are small with a BIG flavour. First introduced in 1982 and came from the Willy Wonka factory. Runts candy comes in the shape of five fruits and have a crunchy then powdery consistency. A mix of green apple, strawberry, grape, orange and banana. Net wt. 5 oz. box
$3.75Sour Big Chewy Nerds Theater Box
Big Chewy, Sweet Crunchy and Sour Chewy, all in a delicious assortment of sweet & tangy flavors. Net Wt. 4.25 oz. box
$3.75Spree Theater Box
One of famous candy maker Wonka's most beloved creations, the original Spree is available in the classic theater box. Sweet meets Tangy! Theater Box. Perfect for movie night or any time! Net Wt. 5 oz.
$3.75The Sweet Shop NYC Fudge
Birthday Cake Fudge
Memories of a childhood birthday party or a wonderful birthday gift. Yum! Blue birthday cake with rainbow sprinkles. Homestyle fudge, 1 pc. 2" square
$3.95Chocolate Fudge
Memories of a sweet summer by the sea! Smooth chocolate, classic homestyle fudge, 1 pc. 2" square
$3.95Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge
Peanut Butter Lovers Delight! Chocolate and Peanut butter flavored homestyle fudge, 1 pc. 2" square
$3.95Granny's Toll House Fudge
Granny's Best! Creamy Fudge with chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough inside. 1 pc. 2" square
$3.95Cookie's & Cream Fudge
Cookies & Cream homestyle fudge. White fudge with crushed Oreo's inside. 1 pc. 2" square
$3.95TOFFEE - BUTTERCRUNCH - BRITTLE
Dave's Sweet Tooth Toffee: Dark Chocolate
Handmade, small batch goodness! Light, buttery, toffee coated in a mix of deep dark chocolate and crushed almonds. Made in Michigan. 4 oz. bag
$9.95Dave's Sweet Tooth Toffee: Maple Bourbon Pecan
Dave’s famous toffee made with Michigan maple sugar, decadent dark chocolate, and Journeyman Distillery Bourbon, topped with a dusting of pecans. Made in Michigan. 4 oz. bag
$9.95Dave's Sweet Tooth Toffee: Milk Chocolate
Handmade, small batch goodness! Light, buttery, toffee coated in a mix of deep MILK chocolate and crushed almonds. Made in Michigan. 4 oz. bag
$9.95Dave's Sweet Tooth Toffee: Peanut Butter
Handmade, small batch goodness! Milk chocolate, peanut butter chips, almonds, top our rich, buttery toffee. Made in Michigan. 4 oz. bag
$9.95Enstrom Milk Chocolate Covered Almond Toffee Bite
The perfect bite size piece of buttery almond toffee covered in thick milk chocolate from Enstrom Toffee and Confectionary in Colorado. 1 pc.
$1.75Enstrom: DARK Chocolate Covered Almond Toffee Bite
The perfect bite size piece of buttery almond toffee covered in thick dark chocolate from Enstrom Toffee and Confectionary in Colorado. 1 pc.
$1.75JoMart MILK Chocolate Buttercrunch Bark
MILK Chocolate is mixed with crushed Buttercrunch Toffee and made into large sheets, we break up the sheets into bite size pieces of bark, sold in a clear cello bag, hand tied, 1/4 lb. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn.
$13.00JoMart Old Fashioned Peanut Brittle
This yummy, crunchy peanut brittle is handmade with cane sugar and real butter in small batches and spatula spread on a marble table just like it has been since 1946 when JoMart Chocolates first made it. Once the brittle sets, it's broken up into bite sized pieces. Packed in 6 oz. heat-sealed pouch.
$14.00Jones Toffee Co. Dark Chocolate Covered Maple Bourbon Pecan Toffee
Dark chocolate covered maple bourbon toffee, topped with Mississippi pecans. Cooked in small batches just the way Grandma Jones made it! Handmade in Laurel, MS. 4 oz. box.
$14.00Jones Toffee Co. Milk Chocolate Covered Pecan Toffee
Topped with creamy milk chocolate and Mississippi pecans. Cooked in small batches just the way Grandma Jones made it! Handmade in Laurel, MS. 4 oz. box.
$14.00Jones Toffee Co. Salted Pistachio Brittle
Handmade Pistachio brittle, with just a hint of cayenne and sprinkle of salt! It's Sweet with a touch of Heat! Cooked in small batches just the way Grandma Jones made it! Handmade in Laurel, MS. 4 oz. box.
$14.00Laughing Moon Chocolates: Dark Chocolate Buttercrunch
Yummy, buttery, sweet and crunchy, and topped with DARK chocolate and fresh toasted pecans pieces. Handmade in Vermont. 7 oz. bag
$17.95Laughing Moon Chocolates: Milk Chocolate Buttercrunch
Yummy, buttery, sweet and crunchy, and topped with MILK chocolate and fresh toasted pecans pieces. Handmade in Vermont. 7 oz. bag
$17.95Caramels
Annie B's Sea Salt Caramel Bites Bag
Hand crafted, small batch, sea salt caramels. Made in Minnesota, by Annie B's. 4 oz bag (approx. 15 pcs.) of individually wrapped caramel bites.
$10.75Annie B's Butter Rum Caramel
Handcrafted. Super buttery, with a warm golden color of aged dark rum caramel will make your mouth water. Each bite has a sweet molasses and sugarcane flavor with just a hint of oak. 1 piece. Each caramel measures approximately 3” long and weighs .5 oz.
$1.25Annie B's Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel
Handcrafted using natural ingredients including chocolate, butter, brown sugar and condensed milk, these caramels, are buttery with a pinch of Sea Salt. 1 piece. Each caramel measures approximately 3” long and weighs .5 oz.
$1.25Annie B's Original Caramel
The Original and best-selling caramels are still slow-cooked in copper pots, just as they have been since 1978 at Annie B's in Minnesota. Handcrafted using natural ingredients including butter, brown sugar and condensed milk, these caramels, are buttery with a perfect chewy texture. 1 piece. Each caramel measures approximately 3” long and weighs .5 oz.
$1.25Annie B's Sea Salt Caramel
Handcrafted using natural ingredients including butter, brown sugar and condensed milk, these caramels, are buttery with a pinch of Sea Salt. 1 piece. Each caramel measures approximately 3” long and weighs .5 oz.
$1.25SUSS Bourbon Sea Salt Caramel
Bourbon lends a subtle, smooth whiskey flavor that hits your palate and a light and delicate French sea salt enhances the flavor of this caramel. Handmade and hand wrapped.
$7.50SUSS Sea Salt Caramel
A classic caramel with Fleur de Sel de Camargue, a light and delicate French sea salt that enhances the vanilla flavor. Handmade and hand wrapped. 4 oz. bar.
$7.50Chocolate Covered: Specialties
The Sweet Shop NYC: Mystery Chocolate Box
A fun retro popcorn box to give or enjoy yourself! We make a different mix of yummy assorted chocolate treats, including milk, dark and white chocolates. May contain nuts. 1 box net wt. 1/2 lb.
$10.00DARK Chocolate Covered Plain Vanilla Handmade Marshmallows
A fresh handmade vanilla marshmallow hand-cut and dipped in the finest dark Belgian chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$13.50 +DARK Chocolate Covered Caramel Handmade Marshmallows
A layer of salted vanilla caramel, topped with a fresh handmade vanilla marshmallow. Each piece is hand cut and dipped in dark Belgian chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$13.50 +DARK Chocolate Covered S'more Marshmallows
Handmade marshmallow, sitting on a graham cracker base, and covered in DARK Belgian chocolate. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$13.50 +DARK Chocolate Covered Marshmallows with Tart Raspberry Jelly
A sweet & tart, fluffy pillow of perfection! It's a fresh vanilla handmade marshmallow hand cut and sitting on top of a square of tart raspberry handmade jelly and then dipped in the finest dark Belgian chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Chocolates of Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$13.50 +DARK Belgian Chocolate Covered Honeycomb/Sponge Candy
An Old Fashioned Favorite! Chunks of Sponge candy hand dipped in rich dark chocolate. Crunchy and delicious! Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$13.50 +DARK Chocolate Covered Graham Cracker
Crisp graham crackers are dipped generously in a rich, dark chocolate. Made for The Sweet Shop NYC. 1 pc.
$3.50DARK Belgian Chocolate Almond Bark
We break the sheets of dark chocolate almond bark into large size pieces, sold in a clear cello bag, hand tied. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn.
$13.50DARK Chocolate Covered Marshmallow Pie
A Tate's chocolate chip cookie with fresh marshmallow swirled on top and dipped in dark chocolate, made by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn.
$7.00DARK Chocolate Covered Marzipan
Dark Chocolate Pistachio Marzipan With Green Sprinkles -handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$13.50 +DARK Chocolate Covered Orange Peels
Delicious Belgian dark chocolate covered candied orange peels. Made special for The Sweet Shop NYC.
$7.25 +DARK Chocolate Covered Oreo
Yum! An Oreo cookie covered in rich dark chocolate. Made special for The Sweet Shop NYC.
$3.00DARK Chocolate Covered Salted Caramels
A small of triangle of salty, smooth handmade caramel covered in DARK Chocolate and topped with Sea Salt, handmade for us by JoMart, Chocolates of Brooklyn, NY
$13.50 +DARK Chocolate: Bear Paw
This big delicious Bear Paw is handmade with delicious caramel and Georgia pecans on one side and DARK chocolate on the other. 1 pc.
$7.95DARK Chocolate Ginger Stars
Dark Chocolate star shaped chocolate bites, topped with crystalized ginger. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$8.00DARK Chocolate Nonpareil STARS
Dark Chocolate star shaped chocolate bites, topped with Snow White nonpareils. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$8.00DARK Chocolate Nonpareils
Top Seller! These rich dark chocolate nonpareils are coated in snow white nonpareil seeds. Made for The Sweet Shop NYC.
$7.25 +DARK Handmade Chocolate Covered Raspberry Jelly’s
A perfect bite! A delicious rectangle of tart, handmade raspberry jelly, dipped in the finest DARK chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$13.50 +MILK Chocolate Covered Plain Vanilla Handmade Marshmallows
A Classic! A delicious plain vanilla. fresh handmade marshmallow. Each piece is hand-cut and dipped in creamy milk chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$13.50 +MILK Chocolate Covered Handmade Caramel Marshmallows
A layer of vanilla caramel, topped with a fresh handmade vanilla marshmallow. Each piece is hand cut and dipped in creamy milk chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$13.50 +MILK Chocolate Covered S'more Marshmallows
Handmade marshmallow, graham cracker base, and covered in creamy MILK chocolate. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$13.50 +MILK Chocolate Covered Marshmallows with Tart Raspberry Jelly
A sweet & tart, fluffy pillow of perfection! It's a fresh vanilla handmade marshmallow, hand-cut and sitting on top of a square of tart raspberry handmade jelly and then dipped in the finest dark Belgian chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$13.50 +MILK Chocolate Almond Bark
We break the sheets of milk chocolate almond bark into large size pieces, sold in a clear cello bag, hand tied. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn.
$13.50MILK Chocolate Covered Animal Crackers
Fun and delicious! New, yummy Chocolate Covered Animal Crackers handmade by Colts chocolate in Nashville. Got Milk? 2 oz bag, with 12 pcs.
$5.50MILK Chocolate Covered Caramels
A small square of Handmade Caramel covered in Milk Chocolate, made for us by JoMart Chocolates of, Brooklyn, NY
$13.50 +MILK Chocolate Covered Cookie Dough Balls
Please don't blame us if addiction occurs. These Milk Chocolate Covered Cookie Dough Balls are awesome! (marble sized balls). YUM!
$7.25MILK Chocolate: Bear Paw
This big delicious Bear Paw is handmade with delicious caramel and Georgia pecans on one side and MILK chocolate on the other. 1 pc.
$7.95MILK Chocolate Covered Marshmallow Pie
A Tate's chocolate chip cookie with fresh marshmallow swirled on top and dipped in Milk chocolate, made by JoMart.
$7.00MILK Chocolate Covered Marzipan
Milk Chocolate Pistachio Marzipan With Green Sprinkles -handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$13.50 +MILK Chocolate Covered Oreo
Yum! An Oreo cookie covered in creamy milk chocolate. Made for The Sweet Shop NYC.
$3.00MILK Chocolate Covered Salted Caramels
A small of triangle of salty, smooth handmade caramel covered in creamy MILK Chocolate and topped with Sea Salt, handmade for us by JoMart, Brooklyn, NY
$13.50 +MILK Chocolate Nonpareil STARS
Milk Chocolate star shaped chocolate bites, topped with rainbow nonpareils. Hand tied cello bag, net wt. 2.5 oz. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$8.00MILK Chocolate Nonpareils
Top Seller! These sweet milk chocolate nonpareils are coated in a rainbow of beautiful multicolor nonpareil seeds. Made for The Sweet Shop NYC.
$7.25 +The Jakewich Marshmallow Cookie Sandwich
Two Tate's chocolate chip cookies with handmade marshmallow inside. Handmade by JoMart in Brooklyn. Assorted, we'll pick one for you.
$7.00The Coconut Mini Bar: Covered in MILK Chocolate
Think "AlmondJoy" Bar, but handmade and covered real chocolate. Chewy coconut, toasted almonds, covered in creamy MILK chocolate. YUM! A two bite handmade mini bar. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$3.75The Coconut Mini Bar: Covered in DARK Chocolate
Think "Mounds" Bar, but handmade and covered real chocolate. Chewy coconut, covered in rich DARK chocolate. YUM! A two bite handmade mini bar. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$3.75The King Mini Bar: Covered in DARK Chocolate
A two bite handmade bar. Peanut butter, banana ganache covered in DARK chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$3.75The King Mini Bar: Covered in MILK Chocolate
A two bite handmade bar. Peanut butter, banana ganache covered in MILK chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$3.75The Punky Mini Bar: Covered in DARK Chocolate
A delicious, two bite bar with handmade marshmallow, sitting on a bed of salted caramel covered in DARK chocolate and sprinkled with sea salt, handmade by JoMart in Brooklyn.
$3.75The Punky Mini Bar: Covered in MILK Chocolate
A delicious, two bite bar with handmade marshmallow, sitting on a bed of salted caramel covered in milk chocolate and sprinkled with sea salt, handmade by JoMart in Brooklyn.
$3.75The S'nacker Mini Bar: Covered in DARK Chocolate
Handmade peanuts, nougat, and caramel covered in Dark Chocolate. Better than a snickers! Handmade by JoMart Chocolates, Brooklyn NY, since 1946.
$3.75The S'nacker Mini Bar: Covered in MILK Chocolate
Peanuts, nougat and caramel covered in Milk Chocolate. Better than a snickers! Handmade by JoMart Chocolates, Brooklyn NY, since 1946.
$3.75The Sweet Shop NYC: Candyman Bar
Named for Kelly the Candyman, it's his favorite, it's a thick Graham Cracker with Raspberry Jelly, tripled dipped in rich dark chocolate. Did we mention...it's delicious!?!?!
$4.50The Sweet Shop NYC: Dark Chocolate Cherry Cordials
Just like you remember! A perfect dark chocolate shell, filled with a juicy cordial cherry!
$13.50The Sweet Shop NYC: MILK Chocolate S’mores Marshmallow Bar
A BIG, delicious caramel-flavored graham cracker topped with fluffy marshmallow and triple dipped in creamy milk chocolate. Pop in the microwave for 5-10 seconds for an ooey gooey treat that will remind you of a campfire. YUM!!
$6.00WHITE Chocolate Nonpareil STARS
White Chocolate star shaped chocolate bites, topped with rainbow nonpareils. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. Net wt. 2.5 oz. Approx. 25 pcs. per cello bag.
$8.00MILK Chocolate Covered Pretzel Ball Bites
Top Seller! These sweet white chocolate nonpareils are coated in a rainbow of beautiful multicolor nonpareil seeds. Made for The Sweet Shop NYC.
$7.25 +WHITE Chocolate Nonpareils
Top Seller! These sweet white chocolate nonpareils are coated in a rainbow of beautiful multicolor nonpareil seeds. Made for The Sweet Shop NYC.
$7.25 +DARK-Single Chocolate Covered Caramel Handmade Marshmallow
A layer of salted vanilla caramel, topped with a fresh handmade vanilla marshmallow. Hand cut and dipped in DARK Belgian chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$2.25MILK-Single Chocolate Covered Caramel Handmade Marshmallow
A layer of salted vanilla caramel, topped with a fresh handmade vanilla marshmallow. Hand cut and dipped in MILK Belgian chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$2.25DARK-Single Chocolate Covered Vanilla Handmade Marshmallow
A fresh handmade vanilla marshmallow, hand cut and dipped in DARK Belgian chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$2.25MILK-Single Chocolate Covered Vanilla Handmade Marshmallow
A fresh handmade vanilla marshmallow, hand cut and dipped in MILK Belgian chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$2.25DARK-Single Chocolate Covered S'more Handmade Marshmallow
The S'more! A handmade marshmallow, sitting on a graham cracker base covered in DARK Belgian chocolate. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$2.25MILK-Single Chocolate Covered S'more Handmade Marshmallow
The S'more! A handmade marshmallow, sitting on a graham cracker base covered in MILK Belgian chocolate. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$2.25MILK-Single Chocolate Covered Tart Raspberry Jelly Handmade Marshmallow
A sweet & tart, fluffy pillow of perfection! It's a fresh vanilla handmade marshmallow, hand-cut and sitting on top of a square of tart raspberry handmade jelly and then dipped in the finest DARK Belgian chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$2.25DARK-Single Chocolate Covered Tart Raspberry Jelly Handmade Marshmallow
A sweet & tart, fluffy pillow of perfection! It's a fresh vanilla handmade marshmallow, hand-cut and sitting on top of a square of tart raspberry handmade jelly and then dipped in the finest DARK Belgian chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$2.25Chocolate Covered: Sweet & Salty
Chocolate Drizzle Popcorn
YUM! Air popped popcorn drizzled with milk & dark Belgian chocolate, with a touch of salt. Sweet meets Salty perfection! Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. Net Wt. 4 oz.
$10.50DARK Chocolate Covered Drizzle Pretzel
A bow shaped pretzel, covered in dark chocolate and drizzled with white chocolate. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$3.00DARK Chocolate Covered M&M Pretzel
A bow shaped pretzel, covered in DARK chocolate and topped with mini M&M's. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$3.00DARK Chocolate Covered Sea Salt Bow Pretzel
A bow shaped pretzel covered in dark chocolate and then topped with sea salt. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$3.00Fatty Sundays: Salted Caramel Pretzels
Inside this little box you'll find pretzels covered in decadent 70% dark chocolate, topped with rich caramel bits and sea salt. There are 3 pcs. of 4" long pretzels in a box.
$5.75Fatty Sundays: Sprinkles Pretzels
Inside this little box you'll find pretzels covered in creamy Milk Chocolate and topped with Rainbow Sprinkles. There are 3 pcs. of 4" long pretzels in a box.
$5.75Fatty Sundays: Toffee Pretzels
Inside this little box you'll find pretzels covered in creamy milk chocolate and crunchy toffee bits. Yum! The perfect combo of sweet and salty! There are 3 pcs. of 4" long pretzels in a box.
$5.75MILK Chocolate Caramel Covered Pretzel
A bow shaped pretzel, dipped in handmade caramel and then double dipped in creamy MILK chocolate and drizzled with dark chocolate. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$4.25MILK Chocolate Cookies and Cream Bow Pretzel
A milk chocolate hand dipped pretzel, covered with crushed oreo crumbs! Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$3.00MILK Chocolate Covered Drizzle Pretzel
A bow shaped pretzel, covered in milk chocolate and drizzled with white chocolate. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$3.00MILK Chocolate Covered M&M Pretzel
A bow shaped pretzel, covered in MILK chocolate and topped with mini M&M's. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$3.00MILK Chocolate Covered Potato Chips
TOP SELLER!! Sweet and Salty! Kettle Potato chips hand dipped and covered in creamy milk chocolate. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$13.50MILK Chocolate Covered Sprinkles Pretzel
A bow shaped pretzel, covered in MILK chocolate and topped with Rainbow Sprinkles. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$3.00Mini MILK Chocolate Covered Pretzels
The perfect mix of sweet and salty! A hand packed bag of mini bow pretzels covered in creamy milk chocolate. Great for sharing! 1/4 lb. bag.
$8.00The BIG Pretzel: DARK Chocolate with Sea Salt
Sweet & Salty! Solid DARK chocolate in the shape of a bow pretzel, filled with pretzel pieces and topped with sea salt. We call this the "Big Pretzel, 'cause it's really big!" So good!! Handmade by JoMart Chocolate in Brooklyn, since 1946.
$9.00The BIG Pretzel: MILK Chocolate with Sea Salt
Sweet & Salty! Solid milk chocolate in the shape of a bow pretzel, filled with pretzel pieces and topped with sea salt. We call this the "Big Pretzel" So good!! Handmade by JoMart Chocolate in Brooklyn, NY. Since 1946.
$9.00WHITE Chocolate Covered Pretzel
A bow shaped pretzel covered in white chocolate. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$3.00WHITE Chocolate Covered Sprinkles Pretzel
A bow shaped pretzel covered in white chocolate and then topped with rainbow sprinkles. 1 pc. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$3.00Chocolate Covered: Nuts, Raisins, Beans, etc.
DARK Chocolate Covered Almonds
Simply the best! Supreme sized, toasted almonds. Triple dipped in smooth DARK chocolate.
$7.25 +DARK Chocolate Covered Cashews
Premium freshly roasted with a touch of salt, Big Cashews covered in a triple layer of creamy DARK Chocolate!
$11.00 +DARK Chocolate Covered Swedish FISH
A Sweet Shop NYC Fave! Red Swedish Fish covered in thick DARK chocolate.
$6.50 +DARK Chocolate Covered Malt Balls
Our Malt Balls are a Sweet Shop fave! Big and richly coated in layers of real DARK Chocolate.
$6.50 +DARK Chocolate Covered Espresso Beans
Hand-picked estate Arabica espresso beans covered in dark chocolate.
$7.25 +DARK Chocolate Covered Raisins
Jumbo, sweet and chewy raisins, triple dipped in smooth DARK chocolate. Watch out Raisinette’s, we’re big and yummy!
$7.25 +MILK Chocolate Covered Jumbo Raisins
Jumbo, sweet and chewy raisins, triple dipped in smooth MILK chocolate. Watch out Raisinette’s, we’re big and yummy!
$7.25 +MILK Chocolate Covered Almonds
Simply the best! Supreme sized, toasted almonds. Triple dipped in smooth MILK chocolate.
$7.25 +MILK Chocolate Covered Peanuts
Twice as nice! Extra large Virginia Peanuts, freshly roasted, and double dipped in creamy Milk Chocolate.
$7.25 +MILK Chocolate Covered Macadamia Nuts
These are so good!! Premium Macadamia nuts are triple dipped in creamy MILK chocolate.
$11.00 +MILK Chocolate Covered Cashews
Premium freshly roasted with a touch of salt, Big Cashews covered in a triple layer of creamy MILK Chocolate!
$11.00 +MILK Chocolate Covered Swedish FISH
A Sweet Shop NYC Fave! Red Swedish Fish covered in thick MILK chocolate.
$6.50 +MILK Chocolate Covered Malt Balls
Our Malt Balls are a Sweet Shop fave! Big and richly coated in layers of real MILK Chocolate.
$6.50 +PEANUT BUTTER Covered Malt Balls
These are so good! Big and richly coated in a layer of real Milk Chocolate and then a coating of soft'ish Peanut Butter, great flavor and crunch.
$6.50 +ULTIMATE Malted Milk Balls
Fan Fave! Triple coated! Dark, Milk and White chocolate covered malt balls. The best of all worlds!
$6.50 +The Ultimate MIX
A deluxe combination of both Milk and Dark chocolate covered premium assorted nuts and big raisins, maybe a pinch of dark chocolate orange peel. We love this MIX!
$7.25 +Peanut Butter ＆ Chocolate Lovers
Colts Bolt: DARK Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup with Almonds
Insanely delicious Peanut Butter Cups with Whole Roasted Almonds is what sets Colts Bolts apart from the rest! We love them!! Dark Chocolate yummy peanut butter perfection! Handmade in Nashville, TN. 1 pc. 2 oz.
$4.75Colts Bolt: MILK Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup with Almonds
Insanely delicious Peanut Butter Cups with Whole Roasted Almonds is what sets Colts Bolts apart from the rest! We love them!! Milk Chocolate yummy peanut butter perfection! Handmade in Nashville, TN. 1 pc. 2 oz.
$4.75Giant PB Cup: CHOCOLATE LOVER
A giant (the size of a cupcake), milk AND dark chocolate, creamy peanut butter filled cup, loaded with classic Oreo, M&M and mini Fudge Stripe cookies, drizzled in more chocolate and topped with a mini Milky Way bar! YUM!! Made by 4am Candy Co. in Broooklyn!
$9.50Giant PB Cup: COOKIE MONSTER!
A giant (the size of a cupcake), milk chocolate, creamy peanut butter cup, loaded with golden and classic Oreo cookies, drizzled in more chocolate and topped with M&M’s and Mini Oreos! YUM!! Made by 4am Candy Co. in Broooklyn!
$9.50Giant PB Cup: S'MORES
Who want's S'more?!?! You're going to love this giant (the size of a cupcake), milk chocolate, creamy peanut butter cup, loaded with roasted marshmallows and fudge grahams with chunks of Hershey’s classic chocolate on top! YUM!!! Made by 4am Candy Co. in Broooklyn!
$9.50Laughing Moon: Peanut Butter Cup DARK Chocolate
Do you love PB & Chocolate?? These DARK Chocolate peanut butter cups are super SMOOTH!! Creamy DARK chocolate filled with truffle like peanut butter, are going to become a favorite!!! 2 cups in a pack. From Laughing Moon Chocolates, handmade in Vermont.
$8.50Laughing Moon: Peanut Butter Cup MILK Chocolate
Do you love PB & Chocolate?? These Milk Chocolate peanut butter cups are super SMOOTH!! Creamy chocolate filled with truffle like peanut butter, are going to beecome a favorite!!! From Laughing Moon Chocolates, handmade in Vermont.
$8.50The Sweet Shop NYC DARK Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
We love peanut butter and chocolate!! And we're sure you will too when you try our premium big DARK chocolate peanut butter cup, 1 pc.
$7.00The Sweet Shop NYC MILK Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
We love peanut butter and chocolate!! And we're sure you will too when you try our premium big MILK chocolate peanut butter cup, 1 pc.
$7.00MILK Chocolate Truffle Peanut Butter Eye Balls
Creepy Peepers! Foil wrapped to look like spooky eye balls. Milk Chocolate covered Peanut Butter truffle cream, so good!
$6.50 +Tony’s Chocolonely Chocolate Bars
Tony’s Chocolonely: 32% Milk Chocolate with Caramel & Sea Salt
Classic milk chocolate with crunchy caramel (yea, you heard right) and flakes of sea salt. Sweet and salty never tasted soooo good! 6.35 oz. bar.
$7.95Tony’s Chocolonely: 32% Milk Chocolate Bar
Not just a classic milk chocolate bar, but our classic chocolate bar. It was the first bar Tony’s ever made, back in 2005. They gave it a screaming red wrapper to attract attention to their main mission - 100% slave-free chocolate. 6.35 oz. bar.
$7.95Tony’s Chocolonely: 42% Dark Milk Chocolate Pretzel Toffee
Pretzel? Yummy. Toffee? Yes please. Dark milk chocolate? Say it ain't so! Put crunchy pretzel pieces with a sweet toffee crunch in dark milk chocolate, This is a WINNER!! Made from fair trade sourced cocoa beans, this is a delicious, creamy, thick premium chocolate bar! YUM! 6.35 oz. Bar.
$7.95Tony’s Chocolonely: 51% Dark Chocolate Almond Sea Salt Bar
Dark Chocolate, Almonds and Sea Salt, pure perfection! Made from fair trade sourced cocoa beans, this is a delicious, creamy, thick premium chocolate bar! YUM!! 6.35 oz. bar.
$7.95Tony’s Chocolonely: 32% Milk Chocolate Wafer Cookie Bar
Sounds strange coming from us, but sometimes the simpler, the better. And this bar is proof! Crispy wafer covered in silky smooth milk chocolate. Yep, that's it. Can you already hear the crunch? . 6.35 oz bar.
$7.95Tony’s Chocolonely: 70% Dark Chocolate
Made from fair trade sourced cocoa beans, this is a delicious, creamy, thick premium 70% Dark chocolate bar! YUM! 6.35 oz. bar.
$7.95Fruition Chocolate Bars
Fruition 100% Hundred Percent
100% Dark Chocolate. Bright and dark. This blend of two of our favorite origins highlights juicy red berry flavors and an intensely roasted cocoa base. Handcrafted from Dominican and Peruvian Cacao. Sugar free. 2.12 oz. bar.
$18.50Fruition 74% Bolivian Chocolate
Rare cacao gathered in the wild forests of Itenez, Bolivia after being fermented and dried, and is finally dried again and sorted at the renowned Hacienda Tranquilidad. This bar is pleasantly complex with an earthy and bright, yet chocolate-centric flavor profile. 2. 12 oz. bar.
$18.50Mayana Chocolate Bars
Mayana - Coconut Dream Bar
We love this bar! Crispy Coconut Cookie, Salted Caramel, Creamy Coconut, 66% Dark Chocolate. Handmade by Mayana Chocolates in WI. 3.5 oz. bar in a box.
$9.50Mayana - Fix Bar
One thing leads to another in Mayana's Fix Bar. With vanilla-bean shortbread, fleur de sel caramel and their own 66% custom-blend dark chocolate, this bar delivers every bit of the fix it promises! Handmade by Mayana Chocolates in WI. 3.5 oz. bar in a box.
$9.50Mayana - Kitchen Sink Bar
It's all here, everything you need to indulge your sweet tooth...peanut butter, pretzel and crisp rice combined with milk chocolate, fleur de sel caramel and their signature 66% dark chocolate for a taste experience unlike any other, its a FAVE! Handmade by Mayana Chocolates in WI. 3.5 oz. bar in a box.
$9.50Mayana - Pride Bar
Featuring salted peanut caramel, peanut butter nougat, 66% dark chocolate and topped with rainbow sprinkles! Handmade by Mayana Chocolates in WI. 3.5 oz. bar in a box.
$9.50Mayana - Space Bar
You'll want some serious alone time with this one! Mayana's Space Bar features vanilla-bean nougat, toasted almonds, fleur de sel caramel and their 66% custom blend of dark chocolate to let you get away from it all. Handmade by Mayana Chocolates in WI. 3.5 oz. bar in a box.
$9.50Raaka Virgin Chocolate Bars
Raaka Bourbon Cask Aged Chocolate Bar
Raaka ages single origin Tanzanian cacao in bourbon casks for two months, creating a deeply nuanced bar with a cocktail-like vibe: oaky and smooth, with a hint of cherry cordial on the finish. Good Food Award Winner.
$9.75Raaka Maple and Nibs Chocolate Bar
This maple-sweetened bar tastes like a brownie straight out of the oven. Rich and smooth on the inside, generously sprinkled with toasted nibs for a crispy, crunchy outside. Perfect for those looking for alternative sugars. Cane Sugar Free.
$9.75Raaka Oat Milk Bar
This bar reminds us of homemade granola covered in chocolate; it could be breakfast, but it could also be dessert. Cane sugar-free. Cacao from Semuliki Forest in Uganda brings fruity cocoa notes, while gluten-free oat flour creates the cookie bite. They sweeten this bar with maple sugar for a rounded, warm finish. At 58% cacao, this is one of their signature dark milk chocolates; sweet and creamy but still cacao forward and 100% vegan.
$9.75Raaka Pink Sea Salt Chocolate Bar
A fruity, complex salted dark chocolate to end all salted dark chocolates. Made with single origin cacao from Zorzal Cacao, a farm and fermentary within a bird sanctuary in the Dominican Republic, and sprinkled with Peruvian pink salt sourced from Salt of the Earth Co.
$9.75Hot Cocoa At Home
Felice Hot Cocoa Mix
DELICIOUS! Rich Hot Cocoa. You can use any type of milk you like to make this. Coop's uses only the finest European chocolate, they also include a recipe for chocolate pudding from "scratch". It's also All Natural, Gluten Free and VEGAN with NO Additives or Artificial anything and is non-GMO and Certified Kosher Parve. 22 oz. container.
$16.50Milk Chocolate Hot Cocoa Bomb
Handmade by JoMart Chocolates, these premium Hot Chocolate Bombs are delicious. Simply drop the bomb into a mug of warm milk and watch the magic happen! 1 pc.
$10.00Retro Cane Sugar Sodas
Bubble Up Soda
$4.00Cheerwine Soda
$4.00Cream Soda
$4.00Frostie Orange Soda
$4.00Root Beer Soda
$4.00Bottled Water
Fiji Water
FIJI Water, The planets best water! Its soft, smooth taste comes from its extraordinary source. 330mL (11.15oz) bottle. a protected artesian aquifer found deep underground in the remote Fiji Islands. FIJI Water is the choice of discerning top chefs, fine restaurants and hotels around the world.
$3.00Perrier
Perrier Carbonated Mineral Water inspires the imagination and stimulates the senses. Originating in the south of France, Perrier sparkling water has been a sparkling fusion of French mineral water and uplifting bubbles since 1863
$3.00SPRING TREATS!
MILK Chocolate Covered OREO Box
Hand dipped MILK Chocolate Covered Oreos with Seasonal Sprinkles. Made by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. Classic gold box with 6 pcs.
$22.50MILK Chocolate Marshmallow Egg
These are so good! Creamy MILK chocolate egg shell filled with handmade marshmallow. Wrapped in foil. Made by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1 pc.
$3.75MILK Chocolate Foil Eggs in a Basket
A tiny little "basket" with grass and 3 Milk Chocolate Foil covered eggs made in France, wrapped in cello and tied with fabric ribbon. Perfect to decorate your table or as a treat from the Easter Bunny!
$9.00Sanded Gummy Eggs Bag
Perfect for Easter Baskets! A cello bag of yummy gummy eggs. Pastel colors covered in sanded sugar. 1/4 bag tied with a fabric ribbon.
$7.50Marble Gummy Eggs Bag
Perfect for Easter Baskets! A cello bag of yummy gummy eggs. Marble colored eggs. 1/4 bag tied with a fabric ribbon.
$7.50WINTER TREATS!
MILK Chocolate Christmas Foiled Wrapped Balls
Delicious solid milk-chocolate ball comes wrapped in brightly colored Italian foil, like a tiny Christmas ornament. Bite-sized balls are great for decorating a Gingerbread house! Perfect as a stocking stuffer too!
$7.25 +Mini Hot Chocolate Bombs
Makes a fun and delicious Hot Chocolate or just eat these chocolate bombs as is! For Hot Chocolate: Drop 7-10 mini Hot Chocolate Bombs into a cup of warm milk, stir and watch the magic happen! Check out our IG for how we made it! Each bomb is filled with a marshmallow dough center, covered in rich dark chocolate and dusted with cocoa. YUM!
$7.25 +Ribbon Candy
Old-Fashioned Mini Ribbon Candy Christmas Mix. Santa would love these beautiful and delicious Peppermint, Cherry and Cinnamon thin ribbon candy pieces in a 5 oz. bag. Perfect for your holiday candy dish!
$8.95Jelly Bean Holiday Favorites
Five holiday-inspired jelly bean flavors include Hot Chocolate, Cranberry Sauce, Pumpkin Pie, Candy Cane, and Egg Nog. Fun and tasty, cute box, will satisfy any Jelly Belly fan. 4.25 box
$10.00