The Sweet Shop NYC
Popular menu items
The S'more Sundae!
Every day is SUNDAE!! A customer fave! Chocolate chunk and toasted marshmallow ice cream, covered with Coop's premium hot fudge, our giant milk chocolate covered marshmallow and graham cracker S'more cookie and topped with our house made chocolate and vanilla whipped cream and a Luxardo cherry!!
$16.50Vanilla Ice Cream
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from OddFellows Ice Cream.
$5.25 +Chocolate Chunk Ice Cream
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from OddFellows Ice Cream.
$5.25 +Sprinkles Ice Cream
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from OddFellows Ice Cream.
$5.25 +Coffee Crunch Ice Cream
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from OddFellows Ice Cream.
$5.25 +Cookies and Cream Gelato
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato.
$5.25 +Salted Caramel Gelato
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato.
$5.25 +From Gracie Baked: Half Baked Chocolate Chip Cookie
Triple chocolate cookie with salt, it’s crunchy and chewy!
$3.95From Gracie Baked: Cookies and Cream Cookie
It’s a yummy sugar cookie with tons of Oreo cookies mixed in! If you like Oreos, you’ll love this!
$3.95SPECIAL ORDERS
SPECIAL OCCASION? Send a gift with a handwritten note.
Let us know if you're sending this to someone as a gift, we can add a bow, tissue and a handwritten note. Please write your note in the special instructions.
$5.00Valentine Heart Box Large
$50.00Chocolate Boxes
Jomart Chocolate Gift Box
Handmade chocolates by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. Old fashioned, delicious chocolates, available in MILK, DARK or ASSORTED, please specify in Special Instructions. 1/2 lb. Black Box with our Signature Black and White Stripe ribbon (approx. 25 pcs.)
$29.95Mayana 4pc Box
Beautiful Handmade Chocolates by Mayana Chocolate in Wisconsin. Each and ever piece is a delicious piece of art.
$15.00Mayana 9pc Box
Beautiful Handmade Chocolates by Mayana Chocolate in Wisconsin. Each and ever piece is a delicious piece of art.
$30.00Mayana 16pc Box
Beautiful Handmade Chocolates by Mayana Chocolate in Wisconsin. Each and ever piece is a delicious piece of art.
$50.00Solid Chocolate Champagne Bottle
A foil covered, solid milk chocolate champagne bottle, ready for gifting! Perfect for anniversaries and special occasions. 8 oz.
$19.50Artisan Ice Creams
The Clark: Peanut Butter Sundae
This one is BIG & is pure decadence! 3 scoops of Ice Cream: chocolate and peanut butter topped with Premium Hot Fudge Sauce, our fresh house made chocolate and vanilla Whipped Cream, 2 Clark Bars: 1 Crunch Bar and 2 pcs, of Clark Peanut Butter Cups, and finished with chocolate peanut butter cookie crumbs!! YUM!
$16.50The S'more Sundae!
Every day is SUNDAE!! A customer fave! Chocolate chunk and toasted marshmallow ice cream, covered with Coop's premium hot fudge, our giant milk chocolate covered marshmallow and graham cracker S'more cookie and topped with our house made chocolate and vanilla whipped cream and a Luxardo cherry!!
$16.50The 3 Little Bears Sundae
A triple scoop of ice cream: Chocolate, Vanilla, and Strawberry with a 1/4 lb. of all 3 chocolate covered gummy bears (milk, dark & white chocolate) floating in Coop’s Hot fudge, finished with house made whipped cream and 3 little bears sitting on top!
$19.50Vanilla Ice Cream
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from OddFellows Ice Cream.
$5.25 +Chocolate Chunk Ice Cream
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from OddFellows Ice Cream.
$5.25 +Sprinkles Ice Cream
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from OddFellows Ice Cream.
$5.25 +Coffee Crunch Ice Cream
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from OddFellows Ice Cream.
$5.25 +Cookies and Cream Gelato
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato.
$5.25 +Mascarpone Gelato
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato.
$5.25 +Fresh Mint Chip Gelato
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato.
$5.25 +Salted Caramel Gelato
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato.
$5.25 +Banana Gelato
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato.
$5.25 +Strawberry Gelato
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato.
$5.25 +Espresso Gelato
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato.
$5.25 +Toasted Marshmallow Gelato
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato.
$5.25 +Pistachio Gelato
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato.
$5.25 +Peanut Butter Gelato
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato.
$5.25 +Black Currant Sorbet
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Sorbet.
$5.25 +Vanilla Chocolate Chip Pre-Packed "Pint" container
Pre-packed premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato, in their signature rectangular 20 oz. size.
$14.50Milk Chocolate Malt (Candyman) Pre-Pack "pint"
Pre-packed premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato, in their signature rectangular 20 oz. size.
$14.50OddFellows Ice Cream Co. Peanut Butter S’mores
Peanut butter ice cream with graham cracker soil, mini marshmallows and magic dark chocolate chips, 14 oz pre-packed "pint" container.
$14.50Dark Chocolate with Chocolate Chip Gelato
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato.
$5.25 +Mango Sorbet
Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium sorbet from Il Laboratorio del Gelato.
$5.25 +Peppermint Stick Gelato
Seasonal Flavor! Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato.
$5.25 +Eggnog Gelato
Seasonal Flavor! Hand scooped and served in our signature "take out" container with our silver spoon, delicious, premium ice cream from Il Laboratorio del Gelato.
$5.25 +Vegan Chocolate Chunk 14 oz. PrePack
Delicious, premium ice cream made and pre-packed by OddFellows Ice Cream Co. A cashew milk based chocolate ice cream with dark chocolate chunks.
$14.50Vegan Coconut Caramel W/ Chocolate 14 oz. PrePack
Delicious, premium ice cream made and pre-packed by OddFellows Ice Cream Co. A coconut milk based ice cream with coconut caramel and dark chocolate chunks.
$14.50Cherry Miso Ice Cream
$5.25 +Thai Tea Ice Cream
$5.25 +Cookie Latte Ice Cream
$5.25 +Peach Gelato
$5.25 +Rum Raisin Gelato
$5.25 +Brown Sugar Gelato
$5.25 +Butternutcrunch Gelato
$5.25 +Olive Oil Gelato
$5.25 +Banana Nut Ice Cream (Vegan)
$5.25 +Olive Oil Ice Cream
$5.25 +Red Velvet Ice Cream
$5.25 +Thai Iced Tea Ice Cream
$5.25 +Pecan Pie Ice Cream
$5.25 +Black Sesame Gelato
$5.25 +Lemon Berry Oatmeal (Vegan)
$5.25 +Burnt Marshmallow Ice Cream
$5.25 +White Chocolate Gelato
$5.25 +Burnt Caramel Ice Cream
$5.25 +Eggnog Ice Cream
$5.25 +Astrorox Astronaut Ice Cream
A freeze dried combination of chocolate, vanilla and strawberry micro-dot ice cream balls (not cold)
$4.50Vegan Hazelnut Ice Cream
$5.25 +Exotic Fruits Sorbet
$5.25 +Brown Butter Pecan Gelato
$5.25 +Peanut Butter Smores
$5.25 +Maitake Mushroom Malt
$5.25 +Allspice Gelato
$5.25 +Toasted Coconut Gelato
$5.25 +Orange ice cream
$5.25 +Vanilla Saffron Gelato
$5.25 +Honey Lavender Gelato
$5.25 +Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream
$5.25 +Brown Butter Sage Ice Cream
$5.25 +Banana Pudding Ice Cream
$5.25 +Matcha Rocky Road Ice Cream
$5.25 +Banana Puddin’
$5.25 +Choco Torta Ice Cream
$5.25 +White Chocolate Gelato
$5.25 +Mint Cookie Ice Cream
$5.25 +Coop's MicroCreamery™ Ice Cream Sauce Toppings
Coop’s Hot Fudge Sauce Jar
Small batch, award winning hot fudge topping, sold in their signature "dripping" jar. Handmade with European Chocolate, fresh cream, sugar, cocoa and butter. Needs to be warmed to used as a topping, or eat from the jar! Absolutely No Gluten, No GMOs, No Preservatives, No Corn Syrup and No Artificial Anything. 10.6 oz. Jar.
$12.95Coop's VEGAN Hot Fudge Jar
Small batch, award winning vegan hot fudge topping, sold in their signature "dripping" jar. Dairy-Free, Lactose-Free rich, dark Hot Fudge made with coconut cream and coconut oil. Needs to be warmed to used as a topping, or eat from the jar! Absolutely No Gluten, No GMOs, No Preservatives, No Corn Syrup and No Artificial Anything.
$12.95Coop's Hot Salted Caramel Topping
Small batch, handmade, award winning salted caramel sauce, sold in their signature "dripping" jar. This delicious sauce has a deep, rich flavor, we dare you to resist eating it directly from the jar! Sauce needs to be warmed to use for topping ice cream. No Gluten, No GMOs, No Preservatives, No Corn Syrup, No Artificial Anything.
$12.95Coop's Hot Fudge Mini
Small batch, award winning hot fudge topping, sold in their signature tiny "dripping" jar. Handmade with European Chocolate, fresh cream, sugar, cocoa and butter. Needs to be warmed to used as a topping, or eat from the jar! Absolutely No Gluten, No GMOs, No Preservatives, No Corn Syrup and No Artificial Anything. 3 oz. Jar.
$7.95Coop's Hot Salted Caramel Mini
Small batch, handmade, award winning salted caramel sauce, sold in their signature "dripping" tiny jar. This delicious sauce has a deep, rich flavor, we dare you to resist eating it directly from the jar! Sauce needs to be warmed to use for topping ice cream. No Gluten, No GMOs, No Preservatives, No Corn Syrup, No Artificial Anything. 3 oz.
$7.95A La Mode™ Nut-Free Ice Cream
Partly Cloudy - NF
Blue cotton candy ice cream with mini marshmallows. Small, pre-packed cup 3.5 oz.
$3.00Pink Sprinkle Vanilla - NF
Pink-hued vanilla ice cream with rainbow sprinkles, mixed inside. Small, pre-packed cup 3.5 oz.
$3.00Partly Cloudy PINT NF
Blue cotton candy ice cream with mini marshmallows! PrePackaged in a 16 oz. pint container.
$10.00Pink Sprinkle Vanilla PINT NF
Pink-hued vanilla ice cream with rainbow sprinkles mixed inside. PrePackaged in a 16 oz. pint container.
$10.00MELT Bakery™ Ice Cream Sandwiches
The Classic Ice Cream Sandwich
Classic-chocolate chip walnut cookies and vanilla ice cream Belgian chocolate and pure, highest-quality Madagascar vanilla come together in our bestselling ice cream sandwich of all time.
$6.50Ice Cream Floats
Root Beer Float
Glass bottle of soda sugar cane soda, served with a cup of vanilla ice cream on the side.
$8.95Moxie Float
$8.95Frosty Orange Soda Float
Glass bottle of soda sugar cane soda, served with a cup of vanilla ice cream on the side.
$8.95Black Cherry Float
Glass bottle of soda sugar cane soda, served with a cup of vanilla ice cream on the side.
$8.95Johnnie Ryan Cola Float
Glass bottle of soda sugar cane soda, served with a cup of vanilla ice cream on the side.
$8.95Bubble Up Float
Glass bottle of soda sugar cane soda, served with a cup of vanilla ice cream on the side.
$8.95Cream Soda Float
Glass bottle of soda sugar cane soda, served with a cup of vanilla ice cream on the side.
$8.95Diet Root Beer Float
Glass bottle of soda sugar cane soda, served with a cup of vanilla ice cream on the side.
$8.95Cheerwine Float
Glass bottle of soda sugar cane soda, served with a cup of vanilla ice cream on the side.
$8.95DŌ, Edible Cookie Dough
Edible Cookie Dough: Signature Chocolate Chip
The classic cookie dough...ready to eat!! Pre-packed in a 4 oz. cup from DŌ, Cookie Dough Confections in New York City.
$6.50Edible Cookie Dough: Brookie Dough
Chocolate Chip Dough and Brownie Batter Swirled Together! Yum! Pre-packed in a 4 oz. cup from DŌ, Cookie Dough Confections in New York City.
$6.50Edible Cookie Dough: Cake Batter
Cake Batter: Chocolate Chip Dough + White Chocolate Chips + Seasonal Sprinkles, it's like a birthday party in a cup! Pre-packed in a 4 oz. cup from DŌ, Cookie Dough Confections in New York City.
$6.50Edible Cookie Dough: PB Snickerdoodle (GLUTEN FREE & VEGAN)
A yummy Peanut Butter dough with Cinnamon Sugar and Chocolate Chips and this flavor also happens to be GLUTEN FREE & VEGAN! Pre-packed in a 4 oz. cup from DŌ, Cookie Dough Confections in New York City.
$6.50FRESH BAKED COOKIES
From DŌ Cookie Dough: Sugar Cookie
Just like Grandma's! A big yummy cookie from DŌ Edible & Bakeable Cookie Dough!
$3.50From DŌ Cookie Dough: Gimme S’more
Gimme S’more, combines everything you love about the classic fireside snack! Crispy graham crackers, Hershey's rich milk chocolate and scrumptiously sticky toasted marshmallows!
$3.50From DŌ Cookie Dough: Chocolate Dream
Yum! Chocolate, chocolate and more chocolate. Starting with the Brownie Batter dough, chocolate chips, and crunchy Oreo cookies make the ultimate chocolate lover’s dream come true!
$3.50From DŌ Cookie Dough: PB Snickerdoodle with Chocolate Chips Cookie
GLUTEN FREE & VEGAN: Peanut butter dough is blended with sweet and spicy cinnamon sugar and rich chocolate chips. So good you’d never know it’s gluten-free AND vegan.
$3.50From Gracie Baked: Caramel Potato Chip Cookie
A yummy, gooey, brown butter cookie mixed with caramel covered potato chips-sweet and salty!
$3.95From Gracie Baked: Half Baked Chocolate Chip Cookie
Triple chocolate cookie with salt, it’s crunchy and chewy!
$3.95From Gracie Baked: Cookies and Cream Cookie
It’s a yummy sugar cookie with tons of Oreo cookies mixed in! If you like Oreos, you’ll love this!
$3.95From DŌ Cookie Dough: Old Fashioned Chocolate Chip Cookie
Just like Grandma's! A big yummy cookie from DŌ Edible & Bakeable Cookie Dough!
$3.50Fat Witch™ Baby Brownies
Fat Witch Baby: Brownie
This mini size brownie packs a lot of chocolately flavor! The original, no nuts. Individually wrapped. Made by Fat Witch Bakery in NYC, since 1991. Approx. 1 oz.
$3.00Caramel Baby Brownie
This mini size brownie is super moist, chocolate and caramel! Individually wrapped. Made by Fat Witch Bakery in NYC, since 1991. Approx. 1 oz.
$3.00Blonde Baby Brownie
This mini size blondie has chocolate chips. Individually wrapped. Made by Fat Witch Bakery in NYC, since 1991. Approx. 1 oz.
$3.00Crispery Crispycakes: Marshmallow Rice Treat
Fruity Ringlets Crispycake: Marshmallow Treat
The Crispery’s Fruity Ringlets Marshmallow Crispycakes are loaded with Fruit Loops for a colorful twist on the childhood favorite treat, there are no rice crispies in this one.
$7.50Rainbow "Sprinkles" Crispycake: Marshmallow Rice Treat
Topped with bright rainbow sprinkles or little balls (nonpareils) based on availability for a colorful twist on your childhood favorite treat.
$7.50Pretzel Surprise Crispycake: Marshmallow Rice Treat
Layered with chocolate, caramel and pretzels for a salty, sweet treat!
$7.50Chocolate Oreo Crispycake: Marshmallow Rice Treat
Better than your childhood fave...the marshmallowy Crispycake is half dipped in dark chocolate.
$7.50Worms In Dirt
$7.50Caramel & Cream Crispycake: Marshmallow Rice Treat
Delicious Crispycake with a layer of creamy caramel, yummy!
$7.50TOFFEE / BUTTERCRUNCH
Laughing Moon Chocolates: Milk Chocolate Buttercrunch
Yummy, buttery, sweet and crunchy, and topped with MILK chocolate and fresh toasted pecans pieces! 6 oz. bag
$13.50Laughing Moon Chocolates: Dark Chocolate Buttercrunch
Yummy, buttery, sweet and crunchy, and topped with DARK chocolate and fresh toasted pecans pieces! 6 oz. bag
$13.50Enstrom Milk Chocolate Covered Almond Toffee Bite
The perfect bite size piece of buttery almond toffee covered in thick milk chocolate from Enstrom Toffee and Confectionary in Colorado.
$1.75Enstrom Dark Chocolate Covered Almond Toffee Bite
The perfect bite size piece of buttery almond toffee covered in thick dark chocolate from Enstrom Toffee and Confectionary in Colorado.
$1.75Dave's Sweet Tooth Toffee: Dark Chocolate
Handmade, small batch goodness! Light, buttery, toffee coated in a mix of deep dark chocolate and crushed almonds. Made in Michigan. 4 oz. bag
$7.50Dave's Sweet Tooth Toffee: Milk Chocolate
Handmade, small batch goodness! Light, buttery, toffee coated in a mix of deep MILK chocolate and crushed almonds. Made in Michigan. 4 oz. bag
$7.50Dave's Sweet Tooth Toffee: Peanut Butter
Handmade, small batch goodness! Rich, buttery toffee, milk chocolate, peanut butter chips and almonds. Made in Michigan. 4 oz. bag
$7.50BACON BITES: PREMIUM CHOCOLATE COVERED BACON TREATS
BACON BITES: BLING…home the bacon!
Now you can bring home this BLINGalicious GOLDEN Chocolate Dipped Bacon! Covered in real 23kt Edible Gold, it’s Blingy, Beautiful and Delicious! Handmade with extra thick cut, cured smokey bacon dipped DARK chocolate and topped with edible gold. Approx. 4 oz.
$25.00BACON BITES: ORIGINAL DARK
Handmade with extra thick cut, cured smokey bacon and a generous dipping of smooth 55% DARK chocolate. Approx. 4 oz.
$22.00BACON BITES: MILK CHOCOLATE COVERED
Handmade with extra thick cut, cured smokey bacon and a generous dipping of creamy MILK chocolate. Approx. 4 oz.
$22.00BACON BITES: PEANUT BUTTER
Handmade with extra thick cut, cured smokey bacon and a generous dipping of smooth DARK 55% chocolate topped with a drizzle of creamy peanut butter. Approx. 4 oz.
$22.00BACON BITES: REESE’S PEANUT BUTTER
Handmade with extra thick cut, cured smokey bacon and a generous dipping of creamy MILK chocolate topped with a drizzle of Reese’s peanut butter. Approx. 4 oz.
$22.00BACON BITES: BACON AND EGGS
Handmade with extra thick cut, cured smokey bacon with a generous dipping of smooth DARK 55% chocolate paired with GUMMY sunny side up Eggs. Makes for a FUNNY and YUMMY Breakfast!! Total Approx. 6 oz.
$22.00BACON BITES: BIG BROWNIE
A huge, moist and gooey, yummy brownie with chocolate chips, topped with Bacon Bites Bacon and double dipped in smooth 55% DARK CHOCOLATE. Approx. 8 oz.
$18.50BACON BITES: OREOS IN MILK CHOCOLATE
A 3 Pack of Chunky Double STUF Oreos, topped with smokey bacon and double dipped in creamy milk chocolate, decorated with tiny pink piggy sprinkles!
$14.95BACON BITES: DARK CHOCOLATE COVERED BACON TWINKIE
They start with a Hostess Twinkie sitting on a piece of chocolate covered smoked bacon and then its hand drenched in 55% smooth DARK Chocolate! Just WOW!! 1 pc.
$18.50BACON BITES: MILK CHOCOLATE COVERED BACON TWINKIE
They start with a Hostess Twinkie sitting on a piece of chocolate covered smoked bacon and then its hand drenched in Creamy MILK Chocolate! Just WOW!! 1 pc.
$18.50RubyLu Caramels
Sea Salt Caramel
$1.20Orange Caramel
$1.20Cinnamon Caramel
$1.20Coffee Caramel
$1.20Apple Cider Caramel
$1.20Marshmallow Caramel
$1.20Honey Walnut Caramel
$1.20Cupid’s Hearts - Chocolate Caramels
10 piece Foil wrapped handmade Chocolate with Caramel Inside
$20.00CandyLand
The Candy Man's Pudgies
Made for The Sweet Shop NYC. Individually wrapped, delicious chunks of buttery, caramel.
$0.75Jawbreaker on a Stick
A golf ball size jawbreaker on a stick. Bet you can't get to the middle of this one!
$4.00Broadway Licorice Roll
A recreation of the classic Delfa Roll Danish Ribbons, a delicious candy roll of red strawberry licorice.
$2.50Twist N Lik Ice Cream Cone
Just remove the cap, twist the bottom and the fruit flavored candy will dispense from the top. Assorted flavors, we'll pick one for you. One 0.64 oz.
$2.50The Candy Man's Silkies
A handmade marshmallow covered in delicious chewy caramel. 1 pc. individually wrapped, made just for us. Please request Chocolate or Vanilla Sea Salt. A Sweet Shop FAVE!!
$1.50Charleston Chew Vanilla
Chewy, vanilla flavored nougat wrapped in a rich, chocolaty coating have made Charleston Chew an American favorite since 1922. We love it frozen!
$2.50Charleston Chew Chocolate
Chewy, chocolate flavored nougat wrapped in a rich, chocolaty coating have made Charleston Chew an American favorite since 1922. We love it frozen!
$2.50Charleston Chew Strawberry
Chewy, strawberry flavored nougat wrapped in a rich, chocolaty coating have made Charleston Chew an American favorite since 1922. We love it frozen! One 1.8 oz. Bar.
$2.50Chuckles
Jelly candies coated with a light layer of sugar. They come in five flavors: cherry, lemon, lime, orange, and licorice. Each package of Chuckles contains one piece of each.
$2.50Gummy Pizza ( Small )
Delicious gummy candies put together to look like a mini pizza pie with toppings! Served in a small cardboard pizza box.
$7.50Bar None
It's back!! Made with a cocoa wafer, chocolate crème, peanuts and a milk chocolate coating.
$2.50Mystery Gummy Box
TOP SELLER!! A fun box filled with our picks of gummy and sour gummy candies. We make a surprise mix of our top sellers! You're sure to find a new fave in your mystery box. Made by us!
$10.00Candy Cigarettes
Candy cigarettes, have 10 white candy cigs in a box. Assorted, we'll pick a pack for you!
$3.00Bubblegum Cigarettes
Nostalgic Candy: the original candy gum cigarette, no smoking here, just chewing! Assorted packs, we'll pick one for you!
$3.00Nik L Nip
Just like you remember! “Bite ‘Em, Drink ‘Em, Chew ‘Em”. For nearly a century, fruit-flavored, liquid-filled Nik-L-Nip Mini Drinks have been a favorite. Five fruity flavors: Chillin' Cherry, O-So Orange, Hello Lemon, Blazin' Blue Raspberry, and Groovin' Green.
$2.50Big Gummy Bear
Yummy Gummy! A big, almost a pound, individually wrapped bear. One is 14 oz. Assorted flavors, we'll pick one for you.
$8.00SUSS Sea Salt Caramel
A classic caramel with Fleur de Sel de Camargue, a light and delicate French sea salt that enhances the vanilla flavor. Handmade and hand wrapped.
$5.95SUSS Bourbon Sea Salt Caramel
Bourbon lends a subtle, smooth whiskey flavor that hits your palate and a light and delicate French sea salt enhances the flavor of this caramel. Handmade and hand wrapped.
$5.95Cacao Sampaka Gin and Tonic Bar
One bite of the Gin and Tonic bar captures the crunch of ice, the bitterness of quinine, the floral bouquet of citrus and even a hint of effervescence
$9.50Chupa Whistle Pop
They're back!! What could be better? A whistle made out of a strawberry lolly!! Yummy!
$3.00Bubble Tape Gum
$2.75Fun Dip
It all starts with the candy Lik-A-Stix. Lick it up and dip into the sugary sweet and mildly sour kick powder.
$2.50Original Moon Pie
Two round graham cracker cookies, with marshmallow filling in the center, dipped in a flavored coating.
$4.00Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Caramel on a Stick
Made just for us! A large square of caramel and peanut butter covered in milk chocolate on a stick, rich and delicious!
$7.50Chocolate Peanut Butter Sports Bar
A soft peanut butter filling in a milk chocolate bar, wrapped with your favorite sports team name and logo!
$3.25Banana Moon Pie
$4.00Gummy Pizza-Large
It's a pizza with all the toppings...made from GUMMY CANDY! Comes in it's delivery box. FUN & YUMMY!
$15.00Yowie
$5.00Violet Crumble
Similar to it's English cousin the Crunchie Bar, this one hails from Australia. It's a rich honeycomb toffee that's covered in a smooth layer of rich chocolate.
$6.00Giant Chewy Sweet Tarts
Just like sweet tarts...only GIANT!! Sweet, tart and each one is about the size of a half dollar.
$3.00Orthodox Chews Salt Water Taffy
Delicious and Fun! 1 lb bag of Old Fashioned Salt Water Taffy bites.
$13.50Celebrations™ Champagne Bottle Candy Assortment
Individually wrapped European chocolates including mini bards of Bounty, Twix, Dove, Milky Way, Snickers. Great gift for a celebration or office.
$12.00Kinder Joy EGG
Half of the egg is two layers of soft cream, chocolate-covered wafer bites filled with sweet cocoa cream, all to be eaten with a spoon included. The other half of the egg hides a surprise toy. Fun and Yum!
$5.00Gummy Candy Sushi (mini)
This colorful set creatively combines gummy, marshmallow, and licorice to form classic sushi favorites. No fishy flavors here, all sweet and ready to eat! Approximately 9 pcs. in each bento box.
$7.50Gummy Candy Sushi (large)
This colorful set creatively combines gummy, marshmallow, and licorice to form classic sushi favorites. No fishy flavors here, all sweet and ready to eat! Approximately 21 pcs. in each bento box.
$15.00Sweet Tart Ropes
Soft, bendable licorice and SweeTARTS All in one, chewy with a fruit-punch filling. 3 oz. bag
$3.75Jelly Belly™ Jelly Bean Gift Box
20 original Jelly Belly flavors, the assortments are separated into their own spot, flavor description chart included.
$25.00McGraws Giant Flat Taffy Candy
Original old fashioned flat taffy. Made in the USA by Hammonds. Each piece is 12" long, super thin and is individually wrapped. One .75 oz. Assorted flavors, we'll pick one for you.
$3.00Handmade Jumbo Candy Cane
Hammond's candy canes are handmade and the size may vary. Each Cane is individually wrapped. Hammond's handmade Candy Canes have been a holiday tradition since 1920. Assorted Flavors, we'll pick one for you!
$4.00ASTRONAUT ICE CREAM SANDWICH
Old School Favorite!! Freeze dried chocolate, vanilla and strawberry ice cream sandwich. (not cold)
$6.00CLARK BAR
An American classic has returned! Delicious real milk chocolate filled with real peanut butter crunch.
$2.50CLARK PEANUT BUTTER CUP
A yummy milk chocolate peanut butter cup filled with CLARK BAR crunch, YUM!!!
$2.50REESE’S GIANT SIZED, PEANUT BUTTER BAR
GIANT Reese’s milk chocolate peanut butter BAR Net Wt. 6.8 Oz
$6.25REESE’S KING SIZED, MINI PEANUT BUTTER CUPS
Mini milk chocolate peanut butter cups just like a Reese’s only smaller. Net Wt. 2.5 Oz
$4.255TH AVENUE BAR
Not for just STARGATE lovers! Made with crunchy peanut butter in a rich chocolate coating. Net Wt. 2.0 Oz
$2.50TWIX CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER COOKIE BAR
Milk chocolate and creamy peanut butter in a TWIX cookie bar. Net Wt. 1.68 Oz
$2.50GOLDENBERG’S PEANUT CHEWS IN ORIGINAL DARK
Finally, dark chocolate lovers can rejoice! Yummy chewy chocolate bites loaded with crunchy peanuts. Net Wt. 2.0 Oz
$2.50KING SIZED GOLDENBERG’S PEANUT CHEWS IN ORIGINAL DARK
Finally, dark chocolate lovers can rejoice! Yummy chewy chocolate bites loaded with crunchy peanuts. Net Wt. 3.3 Oz
$4.25JIMMIE STIX by BOYER
Milk chocolate and peanut butter covered pretzel sticks. An old-fashioned treat! Net Wt. 1.8 Oz
$2.50Whatchamacallit Bar
It's Back! A marshmallow peanut buttery Rice Krispy bottom, a layer of caramel, topped with melted chocolate chips
$2.50Tabasco Jelly Belly Jelly Beans
Are you a hot sauce fan? If so, turn your love of all things spicy into a sweet snack with Tabasco® jelly beans from Jelly Belly. These candies aren’t just made with a little bit of spice for a kick. They really bring the heat, so you better have a glass of water ready to go! This is the sizzling snack you’ve been searching for, and the tangy, spicy flavor is sure to have you reaching for more. Even if you don’t love spicy foods yourself, you can bet that anyone you know who likes hot sauce is sure to go excited about these Tabasco® Jelly Belly jelly beans. 1/3 lb. handpicked bag
$7.50Candy Gummy Noodles
$7.50Gummy Taco
$7.50BIG LEAGUE CHEW
$2.75Ring Pop
$1.50Stuff from the Jars:
The Sweet Shop NYC Gummy Mix
We hand select an assortment of our faves for the day and mix them a big jar! You never know what you'll get. Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$4.00 +The Sweet Shop NYC SOUR Gummy Mix
We hand select an assortment of our favorite SOURS for the day and mix them a big jar! You never know what you'll get. Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$4.00 +Milk Chocolate Covered Gummy BEARS
Real Swedish gummy bears coated with milk chocolate. Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$6.25 +Dark Chocolate Covered Gummy BEARS
Real Swedish gummy bears coated with dark chocolate. Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$6.25 +White Chocolate Covered Gummy BEARS
NEW!! Real Swedish gummy bears coated with white chocolate. Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$6.25 +Milk Chocolate Covered Swedish FISH
A Sweet Shop NYC Fave! Red Swedish Fish covered in thick MILK chocolate. Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$6.25 +Dark Chocolate Covered Swedish FISH
A Sweet Shop NYC Fave! Red Swedish Fish covered in thick DARK chocolate. Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$6.25 +Gummy Bears
A yummy assortment of tiny bears! Each is a different flavor! Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$4.00 +Gummy Chicken Feet
Yep, they look just like chicken feet...but they are so good....and a vibrant cherry flavor! Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$4.00 +Haribo Peaches
HARIBO Peaches are sweet, velvety soft, and irresistibly delicious. As peachy as they come! Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$6.25 +Haribo Grapefruit Slices
Grapefruit sanded gummy slices. Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$6.25 +Haribo Cherries
Life is like a bowl Cherries! Twin cherries on a green stem, intense fruity flavor. The perfect cherry on top of any day! Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$4.00 +Sour Patch Watermelon Slices
A tiny watermelon slice. Sour sanded. Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$4.00 +Jelly Belly brand: Assorted Flavors Jelly Bean Mix
Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$6.25 +Blue Gummy Sharks ( small )
These sharks give you two flavors, blue raspberry and sweet marshmallow. Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful, perfect one person.
$4.00 +Juicy Gummy Whales
These adorable little treats have a marshmallow base and jelly filled top, in red and blue.
$6.25 +Salty Coins: Black Licorice
Salty Black Licorice Coins. Also know as Muntdrops, this thin black licorice has a round shape, firm texture, with a bit of sweetness combined with a slightly salty taste. Each coin is embossed with a 1, 5, 10. 20, and 50 Euro denominations. Imported from Holland. Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$6.25 +Black Licorice Cats
Imported, European licorice. Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$6.25 +Black Licorice: Honey Beehive
Authentic Dutch Licorice, made in the Netherlands, with real honey and a touch of salt. The candy is in the shape of a beehive. Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$14.50Black Licorice: Australian
Our most popular! Australian Black Licorice is best known for its unique taste and soft and chewy texture. Made with real licorice extract for a rich, taste.
$6.25 +Black Finnish Licorice
Tried and true licorice connoisseurs are sure to appreciate our black Finnish licorice. Packed with the perfect amount of sweetness with a dash of savory flavor, this sticky licorice is a bit stiffer than its Australian rival.
$4.00 +Swedish Black Licorice Espresso Rolls
European black licorice roll, filled with an espresso cream. Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$4.00 +Tiny (Dolly mix) Licorice Allsorts
A British confection, consisting of a variety of multi-colored fondant and black licorice shapes. Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$6.25 +Red Licorice: Finnish
Strawberry-flavored. Packed with the perfect amount of sweetness this licorice is a bit stiffer than its Australian rival.
$4.00 +Red Licorice Wheels
$4.00 +Sour Strawberry Logs
$4.00 +White Chocolate Nonpareils
Top Seller! These sweet white chocolate nonpareils are coated in a rainbow of beautiful multicolor nonpareil seeds. Made for The Sweet Shop NYC. Sold by the 1/4 lb.
$5.75 +Milk Chocolate Nonpareils
Top Seller! These sweet milk chocolate nonpareils are coated in a rainbow of beautiful multicolor nonpareil seeds. Made for The Sweet Shop NYC. Sold by the 1/4 lb.
$5.75 +Dark Chocolate Nonpareils
Top Seller! These rich dark chocolate nonpareils are coated in snow white nonpareil seeds. Made for The Sweet Shop NYC. Sold by the 1/4 lb.
$5.75 +Sour Santa Gummies
Ho, Ho, Ho!! It's Christmas all year with our favorite gummy, the Sour Santa! Great texture and a sweet-tart cherry flavor. We carry these year round when available! A CUSTOMER FAVE!!
$4.00 +Red Sour Lips
Sending you a big kiss! These lips are super sour and chewy! Mwahhh! Candy sold by weight. A 1/4 lb. is a small handful.
$4.00 +Skulls and Bones Hard Candy
Skulls & Bones Candies, are almost like tiny SweetTarts, covered in a colorful candy shell. They come in an assortment of colors and flavors including watermelon, lemon-lime, orange, cherry, raspberry, grape, and lemon.
$4.00 +Sour Gummy Octopus
Customer Favorite! Chewy, sour and sanded with sugar. A round center with eight little tentacles.
$4.00 +Gumdrops
$4.00 +Gummy Cola
$4.00 +Swedish Watermelon
$4.00 +Bubblegum Bottles gummies
$4.00 +Australian Red Cream Bites
Strawberry & Cream Bites offer the classic combination of sweet strawberry and smooth cream. Shaped like a small roll, they're filled with cream, red & white licorice chews.
$4.00 +Australian Licorice Shooters
$4.00 +Dr. Who Jelly Babies
$4.00 +Sour Rainbow Sticks
$4.00 +Red Gummy Lips
$4.00 +Speckled Malt Ball Eggs
$14.50 +Jordan Almonds
Jordan almonds are candy-covered almonds that are a classic wedding candy. Giving 5 Jordan almonds symbolize five wishes for the bride and groom: health, happiness, fertility, financial stability, and longevity. We just love them for their pastel colors and crunchy almond shell!
$4.00 +Sour Cola Bottles
$4.00 +Sour Raspberry Bottles
$4.00 +Sour Worms
The classic sour worm! Yummy, dusted with a sour coating giving it it's tart sour taste. Assorted colors and flavors include lemon, orange, strawberry, blue raspberry and green apple.
$4.00 +Black Salty Fish Licorice
$6.25 +S'more Dark Hand Made Marshmallows
Handmade marshmallow, graham cracker base, covered in dark Belgian chocolate.
$11.00 +Brittle Brothers Peanut Butter Bacon Brittle
Per pound. Gourmet brittle, handmade in TN. The best we've ever tried!
$25.00Sour Skull Gummies
$4.00 +Rainbow Cream Bite Gummies
$4.00 +Watermelon Sour Skulls
$4.00 +Sour Gummy Pigs
$4.00 +Gummy Snowflakes
$4.00 +Sour Tongues
$4.00 +Rainbow Sour Belts
$4.00 +Army Men Gummies
$4.00 +Pink Sour Skulls
$4.00 +Dark Chocolate Gummy Bears
$6.25 +Chocolate Covered Specialties
Milk Chocolate Covered Potato Chips
TOP SELLER!! Kettle Potato chips hand dipped and covered in creamy milk chocolate. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$11.00 +The Sweet Shop NYC Peanut Butter Cup
We love peanut butter and chocolate!! And we're sure you will too when you try our premium big peanut butter cup, please specify Milk or Dark in the special instructions box. 1 pc.
$6.50Dark Chocolate Covered Orange Peel
Delicious dark Belgian chocolate covered candied orange peels. Made for The Sweet Shop NYC.
$7.50 +Milk Chocolate Covered Chocolate Caramel
A small square of Handmade Caramel & Handmade Marshmallow, covered in Milk Chocolate, made for us by JoMart, Brooklyn, NY
$10.50Dark Chocolate Covered Drizzle Pretzel
A bow shaped pretzel, covered in dark chocolate and drizzled with white chocolate. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$3.00Milk Chocolate Drizzle Pretzel
A bow shaped pretzel, covered in milk chocolate and drizzled with white chocolate. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$3.00White Chocolate Sprinkle Pretzel
A bow shaped pretzel covered in white chocolate and then topped with rainbow sprinkles. 1 pc. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$3.00Dark Sea Salt Bow Pretzel
A bow shaped pretzel covered in dark chocolate and then topped with sea salt. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$3.00White Chocolate Pretzel
A bow shaped pretzel covered in white chocolate. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$3.00Cookies and Cream Bow Pretzel
A milk chocolate hand dipped pretzel, covered with crushed oreos! Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$3.00White Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel
A bow shaped pretzel covered in peanut butter then dipped in white chocolate.
$3.00Dark Chocolate Ginger Stars
Dark Chocolate star shaped chocolate bites, topped with crystalized ginger. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$8.00Dark Chocolate Sesame Stars
Dark Chocolate star shaped chocolate bites, topped with toasted sesame seeds! Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$8.00Milk Chocolate Nonpareil Stars
Milk Chocolate star shaped chocolate bites, topped with rainbow nonpareils. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$8.00Dark Chocolate Nonpareil Stars
Dark Chocolate star shaped chocolate bites, topped with Snow White nonpareils. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$8.00Dark Chocolate Covered Oreo
Yum! An Oreo cookie covered in rich dark chocolate. Made for The Sweet Shop NYC.
$2.50Chocolate Drizzle Popcorn
Air popped popcorn drizzled with dark Belgian chocolate. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$7.00The Sweet Shop NYC Mystery Chocolate Box
We pick our daily favorites of chocolate treats, milk, dark and white chocolates. May contains nuts.
$10.00Dark Chocolate Covered Marshmallow Pie
A Tate's chocolate chip cookie with fresh marshmallow swirled on top and dipped in dark chocolate, made by JoMart.
$6.00The S'nacker Bar: Covered in Dark Chocolate
Handmade peanuts, nougat, and caramel covered in Dark Chocolate. Better than a snickers! Handmade by JoMart Chocolates, Brooklyn NY, since 1946.
$3.50The Punky Bar: Covered in Dark Chocolate
A delicious, two bite bar with handmade marshmallow, sitting on a bed of salted caramel covered in DARK chocolate and sprinkled with sea salt, handmade by JoMart in Brooklyn.
$3.50The Punky Bar: Covered in Milk Chocolate
A delicious, two bite bar with handmade marshmallow, sitting on a bed of salted caramel covered in milk chocolate and sprinkled with sea salt, handmade by JoMart in Brooklyn.
$3.50The King Bar: Covered in Milk Chocolate
A two bite handmade bar. Peanut butter, banana ganache covered in milk chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$3.50The King Bar: Covered in Dark Chocolate
A two bite handmade bar. Peanut butter, banana ganache covered in DARK chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$3.50The Candyman Bar
The Sweet Shop NYC FAVE!! Named for Kelly the Candyman's, it's his favorite, it's a thick Graham Cracker with Raspberry Jelly, tripled dipped in rich dark chocolate. It's delicious!
$3.50Eye Balls: Assorted Flavors
Creepy Peepers! Foil wrapped to look like spooky eye balls. Three assorted flavors: Fudge, Caramel, Peanut Butter, Chocolaty filled candies.
$7.00Dark Belgian Chocolate Almond Bark
We break the sheets of dark chocolate almond bark into large size pieces, sold in a clear cello bag, hand tied. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn.
$11.50Milk Chocolate Almond Bark
We break the sheets of milk chocolate almond bark into large size pieces, sold in a clear cello bag, hand tied. Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn.
$11.50Dark Belgian Chocolate Covered Honeycomb / Sponge Candy
An Old Fashioned Favorite! Chunks of Sponge candy hand dipped in rich dark chocolate. Crunchy and delicious! Handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1/4 lb bag.
$11.00Milk Chocolate Covered Marzipan
Milk Chocolate Pistachio Marzipan With Green Sprinkles, handmade by JoMart Chocolates in Brooklyn, NY since 1946. 1/4 lb. bag.
$11.00Large MILK Chocolate Pretzel with Sea Salt
Sweet & Salty! Solid milk chocolate in the shape of a bow pretzel, filled with pretzel pieces and topped with sea salt. We call this the "Big Pretzel" So good!! Handmade by JoMart Chocolate.
$7.75Large DARK Belgian Chocolate Pretzel with Sea Salt
Sweet & Salty! Solid dark chocolate in the shape of a bow pretzel, filled with pretzel pieces and topped with sea salt. We call this the "Big Pretzel" So good!! Handmade by JoMart Chocolate.
$7.75Jakewich Marshmallow Cookie Sandwich
Two Tate's chocolate chip cookies with handmade marshmallow inside. Handmade by JoMart in Brooklyn. Assorted, we'll pick one for you.
$4.50Dark Chocolate Covered Graham Cracker
Crisp graham crackers are dipped generously in a rich, dark chocolate. Made for The Sweet Shop NYC.
$2.75Milk Chocolate Covered Cookie Dough
Hand tied bag clear bag of Milk Chocolate Covered Cookie Dough Balls (1/3 lb. marble sized balls)
$7.50Hand Dipped Pretzel
$2.75Milk Chocolate Covered Oreo
Yum! An Oreo cookie covered in creamy milk chocolate. Made for The Sweet Shop NYC.
$2.50GIANT CASHEW TURDLE!
Yummy, chewy caramel & cashew clusters, covered in creamy milk chocolate. They’re super POOPular! And did we mention…they’re HUGE and NUTTY! Approx. 6 oz.
$8.95GIANT PECAN TURDLE!
Yummy, chewy caramel & pecan clusters, covered in creamy milk chocolate. They’re super POOPular! And did we mention…they’re HUGE and NUTTY! Approx. 6 oz.
$8.95Legally Addictive
$13.50Milk Chocolate Marshmallow Pie
A Tate's chocolate chip cookie with fresh marshmallow swirled on top and dipped in Milk chocolate, made by JoMart.
$6.00The S'nacker Bar: Covered in Milk Chocolate
Peanuts, nougat and caramel covered in Milk Chocolate. Better than a snickers! Handmade by JoMart Chocolates, Brooklyn NY, since 1946.
$3.50Chocolate Easter Bunny
4 oz. Dark Chocolate Solid Bunny, handmade by JoMart in Brooklyn, NY since 1946.
$16.00Dark Chocolate Covered Handmade Marshmallows
A fresh handmade vanilla marshmallow hand-cut and dipped in the finest dark Belgian chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946. Sold by 1/4 lb.+
$11.00 +Caramel Milk Hand Made Marshmallows
A layer of vanilla caramel, topped with a fresh handmade vanilla marshmallow. Each piece is hand cut and dipped in creamy milk chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946. Sold by 1/4 lb.+
$11.00 +Tart Raspberry Milk Chocolate Covered Handmade Marshmallows
A sweet & tart, fluffy pillow of perfection! It's a fresh vanilla handmade marshmallow, hand-cut and sitting on top of a square of tart raspberry handmade jelly and then dipped in the finest dark Belgian chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946. Sold by 1/4 lbs.+
$11.00 +Tart Raspberry Dark Chocolate Covered Handmade Marshmallows
A sweet & tart, fluffy pillow of perfection! It's a fresh vanilla handmade marshmallow hand cut and sitting on top of a square of tart raspberry handmade jelly and then dipped in the finest dark Belgian chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946. Sold by 1/4 lbs.+
$11.00 +Caramel Dark Chocolate Covered Handmade Marshmallows
A layer of vanilla caramel, topped with a fresh handmade vanilla marshmallow. Each piece is hand cut and dipped in dark Belgian chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946. Sold by 1/4 lb.+
$11.00 +Plain Vanilla Milk Chocolate Covered Handmade Marshmallows
A Classic! A delicious plain vanilla. fresh handmade marshmallow. Each piece is hand-cut and dipped in creamy milk chocolate. Hand Crafted by JoMart Brooklyn, NY since 1946. Sold by 1/4 lb.+
$11.00 +Chocolate Covered: Nuts, Raisins, Beans, etc.
Whimsical Candy Company
S'morelicious Candy Bars
Handmade Marshmallow, Salted Caramel, Graham Cracker covered in milk chocolate.
$6.25People's POPS popsicles
Buttercrunch
Sugar Cane Sodas
Johnnie Ryan Creme Soda
An American classic since 1935. Cream soda flavor. Authentic pure cane sugar taste.
$4.00Cheerwine
$4.00Tiddlywink’s Toffee
The Sweet Shop NYC Fudge
Theatre Box of Classic Candy
Spree Theater Box
$3.25Red Hots Theater Box
$3.25Cry Baby Theater Box
$3.25Jujubes Theater Box
$3.25Runts Theater Box
$3.25Junior Mints Theater
$3.25Tony’s Chocolate Bars
Tony’s Dark Milk Chocolate Pretzel Toffee 42%
Made from fair trade sourced cocoa beans, this is a delicious, creamy, thick premium chocolate bar! YUM
$7.95Tony’s Chocolonely 70% Dark Chocolate
Made from fair trade sourced cocoa beans, this is a delicious, creamy, thick premium chocolate bar! YUM
$7.95Tony’s Chocolonely 32% Milk Chocolate
Made from fair trade sourced cocoa beans, this is a delicious, creamy, thick premium chocolate bar! YUM
$7.95Pump Street Bakery Chocolate Bars
Pump Street Bakery 100% Ecuador Chocolate Bar
Made from pure Heirloom Cacao, no added sugar yields earthy flavour and low acidity.
$18.5080% Honduras Chocolate Bar
Distinctively sweet for a high percentage dark bar, this chocolate has hints of smokey molasses and allspice, balanced with subtle fruity tones.
$16.5072% Madagascar Chocolate Bar
A dark chocolate packed with flavour brought out of the fruity Madagascan beans. This chocolate has high notes of citrus mellowing into tropical fruits & ending with balanced acidity.
$16.50Pump Street Bakery 66% Sourdough & Sea Salt Chocolate Bar
A unique combination of dark chocolate and sourdough. Sourdough crumbs and a touch of sea salt add crunch and a smooth, malty flavour to the Ecuadorian chocolate.
$18.50Pump Street Bakery 60% Rye Crumb, Milk & Sea Salt Chocolate Bar
The mellow creaminess of the milk chocolate shows off the nuttiness and acidity of the rye grain.
$18.50Ritual Chocolate
Raaka Virgin Chocolate Bars
Raaka Coconut Milk Chocolate Bar
COCONUT MILK (60% CACAO) Ingredients: Organic cacao beans, organic cane sugar, organic coconut, organic cacao butter
$9.75Raaka Bourbon Chocolate Bar
BOURBON CASK AGED (82% CACAO) Ingredients: Organic cacao beans, organic cane sugar, organic maple sugar, organic cacao butter
$9.75Raaka Pink Sea Salt Chocolate Bar
PINK SEA SALT (71% CACAO) Ingredients: Organic cacao beans, organic cane sugar, organic maple sugar, organic cacao butter, Peruvian pink sea salt
$9.75Raaka Maple and Nibs Chocolate Bar
MAPLE AND NIBS (75% CACAO) Ingredients: Organic cacao beans, organic maple sugar, organic cacao butter
$9.75Raaka Maple & Nibs
$9.75Raaka Cabernet Sauvignon Chocolate Bar
CABERNET SAUVIGNON (68% CACAO) Ingredients: Organic cacao beans, organic cane sugar, organic cacao butter, Cabernet Sauvignon
$9.75Raaka 100% Cacao
$9.25Fruition Chocolate Bars
38% Toasted White Chocolate Bar
Vanilla Couverture Reminiscent of Dulce de Leche and Brown Butter
$12.0043% Brown Butter Milk Chocolate
Locally churned Ronnybrook Farm Dairy browned butter lends deep caramel flavors to this interpretation of a classic milk chocolate.
$12.0056% Dark Milk with Flor de Sal
Straddling the line between light and dark, this bar is accentuated by the addition of Peruvian warm spring salt
$12.0070% Rustic Crunch
A coarsely stone-ground dark chocolate with cocoa nibs, Ceylon cinnamon and whole vanilla bean
$12.00Fruition 100% Hundred Percent
100% Dark Chocolate. Bright and dark. This blend of two of their favorite origins highlights juicy red berry flavors and an intensely roasted cocoa base. Sugar Free.
$18.2568% Maranon Dark Milk
A very dark-milk chocolate made from pure Nacional cocoa beans from the remote Marañón Canyon of Peru.
$18.5061% Hudson Valley Bourbon Dark Milk
Roasted cocoa nibs aged with Tuthilltown Spirits bourbon barrel staves are then crafted into a creamy dark milk chocolate with hints of oak and bourbon.
$16.5085% Tumaco Colombian Dark Chocolate
Limited Release: Made with Heirloom Designated Cocoa Beans Ingredients: Cocoa Beans, Cane Sugar
$18.5076% Maranon Peru
Made from highly sought-after Pure Nacional cocoa beans from the remote Marañón Canyon of Peru. Unique because of the notably high percentage of white beans, this bar's gentle tannins evoke flavors of toasted walnuts.
$16.50Fruition 74% Heirloom Bolivian Chocolate
Good Food Award Winner - Incredible Wild Heirloom Bolivia Dark Chocolate
$18.50Gilda's Biscotti
Lemon Fig Biscotti
Candied lemon peel and dried Calamyrna figs, the best way to finish a meal. 8 oz. bag
$9.25Chocolate Espresso Biscotti
The richest biscotti, extra-dark cocoa powder, bittersweet chocolate chips, and ground La Colombe espresso allows them to stand on their own. 8 oz. bag
$9.25Dad's Midnight Stash Biscotti
The ever so popular “Dad’s Midnight Stash” is a collection of “ends” of all 7 flavors. An assorted bag, if you will! Perfect for late night nibbling, it’s a cult favorite for sure. 8 oz. bag
$9.25Bittersweet Biscotti Bark
The Bittersweet Bark is a massively addictive seasonal offering of chocolate insanity. Gilda's folds their sweet crispy biscotti crumbs into dark chocolate and break up the cooled finished slab into “bark.” Habit forming! 8oz. bags.
$9.25