The Sweet Shop NYC
Popular menu items
Vanilla Ice Cream
$5.25 +Chocolate Chunk Ice Cream
$5.25 +Sprinkles Ice Cream
$5.25 +Coffee Crunch Ice Cream
$5.25 +Cookies and Cream Gelato
$5.25 +Sour Power Belts Strawberry
$4.00 +Artisan Ice Creams
Vanilla Ice Cream
$5.25 +Chocolate Chunk Ice Cream
$5.25 +Sprinkles Ice Cream
$5.25 +Cherry Miso Ice Cream
$5.25 +Thai Tea Ice Cream
$5.25 +Coffee Crunch Ice Cream
$5.25 +Cinnamon Apple Ice Cream
$5.25 +Cookies and Cream Gelato
$5.25 +Pomegranate Gelato
$5.25 +Marscapone Gelato
$5.25 +Salted Caramel Gelato
$5.25 +Banana Gelato
$5.25 +Rum Raisin Gelato
$5.25 +Brown Sugar Gelato
$5.25 +Fresh Mint Chip Gelato
$5.25 +Strawberry Gelato
$5.25 +Butternutcrunch Gelato
$5.25 +Toasted Marshmallow Gelato
$5.25 +Olive Oil Gelato
$5.25 +Banana Nut Ice Cream (Vegan)
$5.25 +Olive Oil Ice Cream
$5.25 +Red Velvet Ice Cream
$5.25 +Thai Iced Tea Ice Cream
$5.25 +Pecan Pie Ice Cream
$5.25 +Black Sesame Gelato
$5.25 +Mint Chip Ice Cream (Vegan)
$5.25 +Burnt Marshmallow Ice Cream
$5.25 +White Chocolate Gelato
$5.25 +Pistachio Gelato
$5.25 +Peanut Butter Gelato
$5.25 +Burnt Caramel Ice Cream
$5.25 +Astronaut Ice Cream Sandwich
Freeze dried chocolate, vanilla and strawberry ice cream candy chips (not cold)
$6.00Astrorox Astronaut Ice Cream
A freeze dried combination of chocolate, vanilla and strawberry micro-dot ice cream balls (not cold)
$4.50Cookie Dough Ice Cream Vegan
$5.25 +Passion Fruit Sorbet
$5.25 +Brown Butter Pecan Gelato
$5.25 +Peanut Butter Smores
$5.25 +Maitake Mushroom Malt
$5.25 +Mascarpone Gelato
$5.25 +Toasted Coconut Gelato
$5.25 +Mango Sorbet
$5.25 +Orange ice cream
$5.25 +Vanilla Saffron Gelato
$5.25 +Honey Lavender Gelato
$5.25 +Pumpkin Cheesecake Ice Cream
$5.25 +Brown Butter Sage Ice Cream
$5.25 +Banana Pudding Ice Cream
$5.25 +Peppermint Stick Gelato
$5.25 +Eggnog Gelato
$5.25 +Matcha Crunch Ice Cream
$5.25 +Banana Puddin’
$5.25 +White Chocolate Gelato
$5.25 +MELT Bakery Ice Cream Sandwiches
Evil Twin Ice Cream Sandwich
The evil twin to the classic - chocolate chip walnut cookies with chocolate ice cream !
$6.25A La Mode Nut Free Ice Cream
Ice Cream Floats
Bundaberg Ginger Beer Float
Bottle of soda served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream on the side.
$8.95Cream Soda Float
$8.95SweetDough™ Fresh Baked Cookies
Fat Witch Brownies
Sugar Cane Sodas
Dad’s Root Beer
$4.00Big Red
Known for its unique taste and red color. Its flavor, though often thought to be "bubble gum", is actually a Cream soda flavor.
$4.00People's POPS popsicles
Candy Land
The Candy Man's Pudgies
Made for The Sweet Shop NYC. Individually wrapped, delicious chunks of buttery, caramel.
$1.50SUSS Sea Salt Caramel
A classic caramel with Fleur de Sel de Camargue, a light and delicate French sea salt that enhances the vanilla flavor. Handmade and hand wrapped.
$5.95SUSS Bourbon Sea Salt Caramel
Bourbon lends a subtle, smooth whiskey flavor that hits your palate and a light and delicate French sea salt enhances the flavor of this caramel. Handmade and hand wrapped.
$5.95Cacao Sampaka Gin and Tonic Bar
One bite of the Gin and Tonic bar captures the crunch of ice, the bitterness of quinine, the floral bouquet of citrus and even a hint of effervescence
$9.50Chupa Whistle Pop
$3.00Bubble Tape Gum
$2.75Broadway Licorice Roll
A recreation of the classic Delpha Roll Danish Ribbons a delicious candy roll of licorice.
$2.50Fun Dip
$2.50Original Moon Pie
Two round graham cracker cookies, with marshmallow filling in the center, dipped in a flavored coating.
$4.00Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Caramel on a Stick
Made just for us! A large square of caramel and peanut butter covered in milk chocolate on a stick, rich and delicious!
$7.50Chocolate Peanut Butter Sports Bar
A soft peanut butter filling in a milk chocolate bar, wrapped with your favorite sports team name and logo!
$3.25Banana Moon Pie
$4.00Yowie
$5.00Violet Crumble
$6.00Pop rocks
$2.50Charleston Chew Vanilla
$2.50Whimsical Candy Company
S'morelicious Candy Bars
Handmade Marshmallow, Salted Caramel, Graham Cracker covered in milk chocolate.
$6.25RubyLu Caramels
Sea Salt Caramel
$1.20Orange Caramel
$1.20Cinnamon Caramel
$1.20Coffee Caramel
$1.20Apple Cider Caramel
$1.20Marshmallow Caramel
$1.20Honey Walnut Caramel
$1.20Stuff from the Jars: candy by the pound
Gummy Chicken Feet
Yep, they look just like chicken feet...but they are so good....and a vibrant cherry flavor! Per pound.
$5.00 +Sour Patch Watermelon Slices
Just like a Sour Patch Kid, but in the shape of a tiny watermelon slice. Sanded. Per pound.
$14.50Jelly Belly Jelly Bean Mix
$5.00 +Juicy Gummy Whales
Plump and juicy just like real whale blubber, these delicious gummy sea mammals feature a blue marshmallow base and a red gummy top filled with cherry jelly. Per pound.
$5.00 +Sour Power Belts Apple
$4.00 +Sour Power Belts Strawberry
$4.00 +Sour Cola Bottles
$4.00 +Sour Raspberry Bottles
$4.00 +Sour Worms
$4.00 +Sour Bears
$4.00 +Black Salty Fish Licorice
$5.00 +Caramel Milk Hand Made Marshmallows
Handmade marshmallow, layer of salty carmel, covered in milk chocolate.
$11.00 +S'more Dark Hand Made Marshmallows
Handmade marshmallow, graham cracker base, covered in dark Belgian chocolate.
$11.00 +White Chocolate Nonpareils
$5.75 +Brittle Brothers Peanut Butter Bacon Brittle
Per pound. Gourmet brittle, handmade in TN. The best we've ever tried!
$25.00Dark Nonpareils
$5.75 +Black Australian Licorice
$5.00 +Sour Santa Gummies
$4.00 +Skulls and Bones Hard Candy
$4.00 +Sour Jacks Gummy Watermelon
$4.00 +Sour Skull Gummies
$4.00 +Rainbow Cream Bite Gummies
$4.00 +Jelly Belly Sour Lips
$4.00 +Sour Strawberry Logs
$4.00 +Sour Gummy Octopus
$4.00 +Pink Sour Skulls
$4.00 +Jordan Almonds
$4.00 +Gumdrops
$4.00 +Sour Gummy Pigs
$4.00 +Gummy Cola
$4.00 +Milk Chocolate Nonpareils
$5.75 +Black Finnish Licorice
$4.00 +Finnish Red Licorice
$4.00 +Chocolate Covered: Nuts, Raisins, Beans, etc.
Chocolate Covered Specialties
Buttercrunch
The Sweet Shop NYC Fudge
Theatre Box of Classic Candy
Spree Theater Box
$3.25Red Hots Theater Box
$3.25Cry Baby Theater Box
$3.25Jujubes Theater Box
$3.25Runts Theater Box
$3.25Junior Mints Theater
$3.25Tony’s Chocolate Bars
Pump Street Bakery Chocolate Bars
Pump Street Bakery 100% Ecuador Chocolate Bar
Made from pure Heirloom Cacao, no added sugar yields earthy flavour and low acidity.
$16.5080% Honduras Chocolate Bar
Distinctively sweet for a high percentage dark bar, this chocolate has hints of smokey molasses and allspice, balanced with subtle fruity tones.
$16.5072% Madagascar Chocolate Bar
A dark chocolate packed with flavour brought out of the fruity Madagascan beans. This chocolate has high notes of citrus mellowing into tropical fruits & ending with balanced acidity.
$16.50Pump Street Bakery 66% Sourdough & Sea Salt Chocolate Bar
A unique combination of dark chocolate and sourdough. Sourdough crumbs and a touch of sea salt add crunch and a smooth, malty flavour to the Ecuadorian chocolate.
$18.50Pump Street Bakery 60% Rye Crumb, Milk & Sea Salt Chocolate Bar
The mellow creaminess of the milk chocolate shows off the nuttiness and acidity of the rye grain.
$18.50Raaka Virgin Chocolate Bars
Raaka Coconut Milk Chocolate Bar
COCONUT MILK (60% CACAO) Ingredients: Organic cacao beans, organic cane sugar, organic coconut, organic cacao butter
$9.75Raaka Bourbon Chocolate Bar
BOURBON CASK AGED (82% CACAO) Ingredients: Organic cacao beans, organic cane sugar, organic maple sugar, organic cacao butter
$9.75Raaka Pink Sea Salt Chocolate Bar
PINK SEA SALT (71% CACAO) Ingredients: Organic cacao beans, organic cane sugar, organic maple sugar, organic cacao butter, Peruvian pink sea salt
$9.75Raaka Maple and Nibs Chocolate Bar
MAPLE AND NIBS (75% CACAO) Ingredients: Organic cacao beans, organic maple sugar, organic cacao butter
$9.75Raaka Cabernet Sauvignon Chocolate Bar
CABERNET SAUVIGNON (68% CACAO) Ingredients: Organic cacao beans, organic cane sugar, organic cacao butter, Cabernet Sauvignon
$9.75Raaka 100% Cacao
$9.25Ritual Chocolate
Fruition Chocolate Bars
38% Toasted White Chocolate Bar
Vanilla Couverture Reminiscent of Dulce de Leche and Brown Butter
$12.0043% Brown Butter Milk Chocolate
Locally churned Ronnybrook Farm Dairy browned butter lends deep caramel flavors to this interpretation of a classic milk chocolate.
$12.0056% Dark Milk with Flor de Sal
Straddling the line between light and dark, this bar is accentuated by the addition of Peruvian warm spring salt
$12.0070% Rustic Crunch
A coarsely stone-ground dark chocolate with cocoa nibs, Ceylon cinnamon and whole vanilla bean
$12.00100% Hundred Percent
100% Dark Chocolate. Bright and dark. This blend of two of their favorite origins highlights juicy red berry flavors and an intensely roasted cocoa base. Sugar Free.
$16.2568% Maranon Dark Milk
A very dark-milk chocolate made from pure Nacional cocoa beans from the remote Marañón Canyon of Peru.
$18.5061% Hudson Valley Bourbon Dark Milk
Roasted cocoa nibs aged with Tuthilltown Spirits bourbon barrel staves are then crafted into a creamy dark milk chocolate with hints of oak and bourbon.
$16.5085% Tumaco Colombian Dark Chocolate
Limited Release: Made with Heirloom Designated Cocoa Beans Ingredients: Cocoa Beans, Cane Sugar
$18.5076% Maranon Peru
Made from highly sought-after Pure Nacional cocoa beans from the remote Marañón Canyon of Peru. Unique because of the notably high percentage of white beans, this bar's gentle tannins evoke flavors of toasted walnuts.
$16.50Fruition 74% Heirloom Bolivian Chocolate
Good Food Award Winner - Incredible Wild Heirloom Bolivia Dark Chocolate
$18.50Crispery Crispycakes: Marshmallow Rice Treat
Fruity Ringlets Crispycake: Marshmallow Rice Treat
The Crispery’s Fruity Ringlets Marshmallow Crispycakes are loaded with Fruit Loops for a colorful twist on the childhood favorite treat.
$6.00Rainbow Sprinkles Crispycake: Marshmallow Rice Treat
Topped with bright rainbow sprinkles or little balls (nonpareils) for a colorful twist on your childhood favorite treat.
$6.00Pretzel Surprise Crispycake: Marshmallow Rice Treat
Layered with chocolate, caramel and pretzels for a salty, sweet treat!
$6.00Chocolate Oreo Crispycake: Marshmallow Rice Treat
Better than your childhood fave...the marshmallowy Crispycake is half dipped in dark chocolate.
$6.00Chocolate Brownie
$7.00Worms In Dirt
$5.00Gilda's Biscotti
Lemon Fig Biscotti
Candied lemon peel and dried Calamyrna figs, the best way to finish a meal. 8 oz. bag
$9.25Chocolate Espresso Biscotti
The richest biscotti, extra-dark cocoa powder, bittersweet chocolate chips, and ground La Colombe espresso allows them to stand on their own. 8 oz. bag
$9.25Dad's Midnight Stash Biscotti
The ever so popular “Dad’s Midnight Stash” is a collection of “ends” of all 7 flavors. An assorted bag, if you will! Perfect for late night nibbling, it’s a cult favorite for sure. 8 oz. bag
$9.25Bittersweet Biscotti Bark
The Bittersweet Bark is a massively addictive seasonal offering of chocolate insanity. Gilda's folds their sweet crispy biscotti crumbs into dark chocolate and break up the cooled finished slab into “bark.” Habit forming! 8oz. bags.
$9.25