Popular menu items
Appetizers
12" Whole Wheat Pizza
Mozzarella cheese & home-made sauce served on a thin & crispy 12”tortilla.
$9.99Bruschetta
6 pieces. Seasoned Italian bread toasted, topped with a diced tomato & red onion mixture.
$9.99Buffalo Wings
$9.99 +French Fries
$6.99 +Onion Rings
$6.99 +Fried Calamari
$14.99 +Garlic Bread
$6.50 +Garlic Bread with Mozzarella
$8.50 +5 Pieces Grilled Rollatini
Thin slices of eggplant stuffed with mixed vegetables & ricotta cheese topped with mozzarella & pesto marinara sauce.
$17.99Filet Blanket Bites
Our filet mignon cubes are seared to perfection & wrapped in crispy bacon served with a drizzle of balsamic glaze.
$23.99Mussles with Marinara
$12.99 +Clams with Marinara
$12.99 +Sautéed Broccoli Rabe
$13.99 +Sautéed Broccoli
$13.99 +Sautéed Spinach
$13.99 +Cheese Quesadilla
Cheddar & mozzarella cheese mixed with spinach & mushrooms,. Served with a side of bruschetta topping, sour cream & tomato sauce.
$12.50 +Soups
Chicken Noodle Soup
Chicken, spaghetti, white onions, potatoes, carrots & celery in a chicken broth.
$7.50Soup Special
$7.50Salads
Antipasto Salad
Bed of romaine lettuce served with ham, salami, provolone, fresh mozzarella, and roasted red peppers.
$15.99 +Caesar Salad
Romaine hearts tossed in caesar dressing topped with croutons and grated parmigiana cheese.
$10.25 +Caprese Salad
Sliced fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, pesto and basil lightly seasoned with salt, pepper and olive oil over a bed of romaine.
$11.99 +Greek Salad
Feta cheese, Kalamata olives, red onions, cucumbers, and tomatoes with mixed greens in our red wine vinaigrette.
$11.99 +House Garden Salad
Romaine lettuce and mixed greens topped with tomatoes, cucumbers, black olives, carrots, and red onions.
$10.50 +Spinach Salad
Cucumbers, tomatoes, roasted red peppers, red onions, walnuts, and feta cheese over a bed of fresh spinach.
$10.99 +Spinach + Red Beet Salad
Slices of roasted red beets, spinach, goat cheese and candied walnuts, tossed with creamy champagne dressing and goat cheese.
$9.99 +6. House Garden Salad with Tuna
$11.99 +Panico's Buns
Heroes
5. Meatball Parmigiana Hero
$9.99 +Chicken Parmigiana Hero
$9.99 +Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
$9.99 +Shrimp Parmigiana Hero
$11.00 +Philly Cheesesteak Hero
Choice of chicken or beef with mozzarella, green peppers, white onions, and potatoes.
$9.99 +3. Fresh Mozzarella Hero
$5.50 +6. Veal Parmigiana Hero
$9.00 +13. Peppers and Eggs Hero
$7.00 +14. Potatoes and Eggs Hero
$7.00 +Sandwiches
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Comes with broccoli rabe and fresh mozzarella and side balsamic vinaigrette.
$9.99 +17. Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Comes with roasted red peppers, arugula and fresh mozzarella and side balsamic vinaigrette.
$9.99 +Crispy Chicken Ranch Sandwich
Comes with lettuce, tomatoes, crispy chicken tenders and ranch dressing.
$9.99 +Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Comes with cucumber, lettuce, red onions, sauteed chicken breast and a side of bleu cheese.
$9.99 +Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich
Choice of chicken or beef with mozzarella, green peppers, white onions and potatoes.
$9.99 +Baked
Large Beef Lasagna
Large. Ground beef mixed with ricotta layered between ridged pasta, topped with mozzarella and baked to perfection with tomato sauce on top to finish.
$17.99Stuffed Shells
Ricotta-filled shells baked with a top layer of mozzarella and finished with our ground tomato sauce. The small portion includes 4 pieces of ricotta-filled shells baked, large portion includes 6 pieces of ricotta-filled shells baked.
$13.99 +Baked Ziti
Penne pasta mixed with ricotta and ground tomato sauce, then baked with a top layer of mozzarella cheese and finished with our ground tomato sauce.
$13.99 +Baked Ravioli
Ricotta-filled ravioli baked with mozzarella on top then finished with our ground tomato sauce. The small portion includes 4 pieces of ricotta-filled ravioli baked, large portion includes 8 pieces of ricotta-filled ravioli baked.
$12.99 +Eggplant Parmigiana
Thin sliced eggplant battered and pan-seared, then baked to perfection with a layer of mozzarella cheese and finished with our ground tomato sauce. Upgrade to breaded eggplant for an additional charge.
$14.99 +Eggplant Rollatini
Thin sliced eggplant battered and pan-seared, then rolled with a ricotta center and baked to perfection with a layer of mozzarella cheese and finished with our ground tomato sauce over penne pasta.
$15.99 +Baked Lasagna with Meat with 2 Sides
Large. Ground beef mixed with ricotta layered between ridged pasta, topped with mozzarella and baked to perfection with tomato sauce on top to finish.
$20.49 +Baked Ziti with 2 Sides
Penne pasta mixed with ricotta and ground tomato sauce, then baked with a top layer of mozzarella cheese and finished with our ground tomato sauce.
$16.49 +Baked Ravioli with 2 Sides
Ricotta-filled ravioli baked with mozzarella on top then finished with our ground tomato sauce. The small portion includes 4 pieces of ricotta-filled ravioli baked, large portion includes 8 pieces of ricotta-filled ravioli baked.
$16.49 +Stuffed Shells with 2 Sides
6 pieces / 4Pieces ricotta-filled shells baked with a top layer of mozzarella and finished with our ground tomato sauce. The small portion includes 3 pieces of ricotta-filled shells baked, large portion includes 6 pieces of ricotta-filled shells baked.
$16.49 +Eggplant Parmigiana with 2 Sides
Thin sliced eggplant battered and pan-seared, then baked to perfection with a layer of mozzarella cheese and finished with our ground tomato sauce. Upgrade to breaded eggplant for an additional charge.
$16.49 +Eggplant Rollatini with 2 Sides
Thin sliced eggplant battered and pan-seared, then rolled with a ricotta center and baked to perfection with a layer of mozzarella cheese and finished with our ground tomato sauce.
$16.49 +Gluten Free Penne
Gluten Free Penne
Choose your sauce: tomato sauce, butter, garlic, and oil or vegetarian marinara.
$11.99 +Pasta
Create Your Own Pasta
Pick your pasta: penne, fettuccine, spaghetti or cappellini. Upgrade for an additional charge: cavatelli, cheese tortellini or gnocchi. Pick your sauce: ground tomato, garlic and oil, plum tomato marinara, or butter sauce. Upgrade for an additional charge: Alfredo, creamy pink vodka, creamy pesto, meat sauce, or pesto.
$10.99 +Cavatelli and Chicken
Ricotta infused pasta with sautéed chicken and broccoli in garlic and oil sauce.
$16.99 +Fettuccine Con Clams
Sauteed little neck clams with broccoli rabe in a lemon garlic white wine sauce. The small portion includes 6 pieces of sauteed little neck clams, large portion includes 12 pieces of sauteed little neck clams.
$18.99 +Shrimp Alfredo
Jumbo shrimp & broccoli with fettuccine in Alfredo sauce. 3Piece shrimp with small size and 6piece with large size.
$20.99 +Spaghetti and Meatballs
2piece with small, 4 piece meatballs with large, over spaghetti in tomato sauce
$17.99 +Fettuccine Carbonara
Fettuccine pasta with sauteed pieces of chicken, bacon, tomatoes and peas in cream sauce.
$14.99 +Panico's Spaghetti and Meatball
Meatballs over spaghetti in tomato sauce. The small portion includes 2 meatballs, the large portion includes 4 meatballs.
$12.99 +Seafood
Zuppa di Pesce
The small portion includes 2 pieces of clams, 2 pieces of mussels, calamari, and 2 pieces of shrimp in marinara sauce served over fettuccine. The large portion includes 4 pieces of clams, 4 pieces of mussels, calamari, and 4 pieces of shrimp in marinara sauce served over fettuccine.
$20.99 +Mussels Marinara
Steamed mussels served over fettuccine and topped with marinara sauce. 6piece with small portion, 12piece with large portion.
$17.99 +Clams Marinara
Clams served over fettuccine and topped with our marinara sauce. 6piece with small portion, 12piece with large portion.
$17.99 +Balsamic Salmon
8 oz. grilled salmon served with roasted potatoes and sauteed spinach with a balsamic glaze.
$25.99 +Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Jumbo shrimp served in a spicy marinara over fettuccine. The small portion includes 3 pieces of jumbo shrimp, large portion includes 6 pieces of jumbo shrimp.
$19.99 +Shrimp Parmigiana
Breaded jumbo shrimp, deep-fried, and served over fettuccine with a layer of melted mozzarella and topped with our ground tomato sauce. The small portion includes 3 pieces of breaded jumbo shrimp, large portion includes 6 pieces of breaded jumbo shrimp.
$19.99 +Shrimp Scampi
Jumbo shrimp served in a white wine butter sauce over fettuccine. The small portion includes 3 pieces of jumbo shrimp, large portion includes 6 pieces of jumbo shrimp.
$17.99 +3. Large Salmon of the Day
8 oz. grilled salmon served with roasted potatoes and sauteed spinach with a balsamic glaze.
$17.75 +Chicken
Chicken Parmigiana
Deep-fried chicken breast covered with mozzarella cheese and served in tomato sauce over penne pasta.
$16.99 +Chicken Francese
Chicken breast covered in egg, deep-fried, then served in a buttery lemon white wine sauce.
$16.99 +Chicken Murphy
Hot or sweet: chicken breast with onions, potatoes, mushrooms, and hot or sweet peppers in a white wine sauce.
$16.99 +Chicken Saltimbocca
Thin slices of chicken breast topped with prosciutto and mozzarella cheese with a white wine sauce over penne pasta.
$16.99 +Chicken Parmigiana with 2 Sides
Deep-fried chicken breast covered with mozzarella cheese and served in tomato sauce.
$16.49 +Chicken Francese with 2 Sides
Chicken breast covered in egg, deep-fried, then served in a buttery lemon white wine sauce.
$16.49 +Chicken Murphy with 2 Sides
Hot or sweet: chicken breast with onions, potatoes, mushrooms, and hot or sweet peppers in a white wine sauce.
$16.49 +Chicken Savoy with 1 Side
Chicken breast served with sweet peppers in a balsamic reduction sauce.
$12.99 +Chicken Savoy with 2 Sides
Chicken breast served with sweet peppers in a balsamic reduction sauce.
$16.49 +Chicken Giambotta with 1 Side
Chicken breast with sauteed garlic, mushrooms, peppers, potatoes, and sausage in wine sauce.
$12.99 +Chicken Giambotta with 2 Sides
Chicken breast with sauteed garlic, mushrooms, peppers, potatoes, and sausage in wine sauce.
$16.49 +Chicken Saltimbocca with 2 Sides
Thin slices of chicken breast topped with prosciutto and mozzarella cheese with a white wine sage sauce.
$16.49 +Steak
Filet Mignon
Served with mashed potatoes, steamed broccoli, and grilled carrots topped with a red wine reduction sauce.
$30.00 +Veal
Veal Francese
Coated in egg, pan-seared, then served in a buttery lemon white wine sauce over fettuccine pasta.
$15.99 +Veal Parmigiana
Deep-fried, veal breast covered with mozzarella cheese and served in a tomato sauce over fettuccine pasta.
$15.99 +Veal Murphy
Hot or sweet: veal cutlet with onions, potatoes, mushrooms & (hot or sweet) peppers in a white wine sauce over fettuccine pasta.
$15.99 +Veal Piccata with 1 Side
Veal coated in egg, deep-fried, served with capers in a buttery lemon white wine sauce.
$15.99 +Veal Piccata with 2 Sides
Veal coated in egg, deep-fried, served with capers in a buttery lemon white wine sauce.
$19.49 +Veal Parmigiana with 2 Sides
Deep-fried, veal breast covered with mozzarella cheese and served in a tomato sauce.
$19.49 +Osso Bucco Della Casa with 2 Sides
Panico's signature dish; we prepare our shank sauce daily.
$43.50 +Brick Oven Pizzas
Brookside Avenue Pizza
Chopped fresh tomato, fresh mozzarella, red onions, basil, and olive oil white pie.
$14.99 +Fulton Street Pizza
Hot sausage and broccoli rabe with hot cherry peppers, garlic, and oil sauce. White pie.
$14.99 +Neilson Street Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana pizza with chicken breast, mozzarella, and tomato sauce.
$14.99 +New Street Pizza
Philly steak with green peppers, onions, potatoes, mozzarella, and yellow American cheese. White pie.
$14.99 +Gluten Free Cheese Pizza
$12.99 +16. Paterson Street Pizza
Chicken Murphy pizza with mushrooms, peppers, onions, potatoes and wine sauce.
$16.99 +Calzones and Strombolis
Garlic Knots
Dessert Pizzas
Cannoli Pizza
Pizza dough crust topped with chocolate chip cannoli cream and crushed cannoli shells.
$16.99 +Desserts
Home-Made Brownie
$7.00Creme Brulee
$9.00Tiramisu
$8.00Italian Cheesecake
$8.00Cannoli
$7.00Ice Box Cake
$6.00Chocolate Ice Cream
$5.50Vanilla Ice Cream
$5.50Beverages
Fountain Soda
$3.50Seltzer
$1.50Can Soda
$1.75Red Bull
$4.25Coffee
$2.99Tea
$2.99Cappuccino
$3.99Espresso
$2.99Whole Milk
$2.99Chocolate Milk
$3.99Hot Chocolate
$3.99Shirley Temple
$3.99Liter Pellegrino
$5.99Pineapple Juice
$1.252 Liter Bottle
$3.50Orange Juice
$2.80Menu Coupons (Archived)
Big Game Special (Archived)
Pizza Slices (Archived)
Catering Packages
Catering Package 1
Includes 2 salad courses, 1 pasta course, 3 entrees (chicken, fish, and eggplant rollatini), and 1 dessert course.
$31.95Catering Package 2
2 hot appetizers, bruschetta, tomato and mozzarella (family style), 2 salad courses, 1 pasta course, 3 entrees (chicken, fish, and pork), and 3 dessert courses.
$38.95Catering Package 3
Choice of 4 hot appetizers, bruschetta and cold antipasto (family style). 2 salad courses, choice of 2 types of pasta, 4 entrees (chicken, fish, veal and filet mignon), and 3 dessert courses.
$48.95Caterung Individual Trays
Veal Parmigiana Tray
$49.00 +Veal Francese Tray
$49.00 +Veal Marsala Tray
$49.00 +Veal with Peppers Tray
$49.00 +Fried Calamari Tray
$45.00 +Broccoli with Garlic Oili Tray
$22.00 +Broccoli Oreganata Tray
$22.00 +Spinach Oreganata Tray
$22.00 +Penne Vodka Tray
$39.00 +Baked Ziti Tray
$37.00 +Lasagna – Meat Tray
$37.00 +30 Large Stuffed Shells Tray
$34.00 +Cavatelli with Broccoli Tray
$37.00 +Meat Ravioli Tray
$37.00 +Cheese Ravioli Tray
$37.00 +Sausage and Peppers Tray
$37.00 +Eggplant Parmigiana Tray
$40.00 +Eggplant Rollantini Tray
$40.00 +Chicken Cacciatore Tray
$40.00 +Boneless Chicken Francese Tray
$40.00 +Boneless Chicken Parmigiana Tray
$40.00 +Boneless Chicken Murphy Tray
$40.00 +Chicken Marsala Tray
$40.00 +Boneless Chicken Savoy Tray
$40.00 +Garden Salad Tray
$25.00 +Catering Panico's Deals
Catering Deal for 10
Includes assorted focaccia sandwich platter, assorted sub sandwich platter, full tray of garden salad, and 2 large plain pizzas.
$135.00Catering Deal for 15
Includes full tray of chicken parmagiana, full tray of baked ziti, sub sandwich platter, full tray of garden salad, focaccia and homemade bread.
$200.00Catering Deal for 20
Includes full tray of penne vodka, full tray of eggplant rollatini, homemade wrap platter, 4 large plain pizzas, full tray of Caesar salad, focaccia and homemade bread.
$265.00Catering Deal for 25
Includes full tray of stuffed shells, full tray of sausage, peppers and onions, full tray of chicken francese, 5 large plain pizzas, full tray of bruschetta, focaccia and homemade bread.
$325.00