Bennett's Market & Deli
Popular menu items
New York Pastrami Sandwich - BEST SELLER
Pastrami on locally baked marble rye with provolone, cabbage slaw and thousand island dressing. Toasted to perfection. Many customers add double pastrami for a true NY style deli sandwich!
$10.00 +Breakfast Sandwich - Best Seller
One of our best selling items! We serve breakfast all day on freshly baked biscuits, NY bagels, or locally baked bread! It's made however you like too!! Pick your cheese and your protein.
$2.00 +Our TOP 5 BEST SELLERS
Turkey Club Sandwich - Our #1 Seller
Best Seller! A triple decker sandwich with our nitrate free bacon, turkey, swiss, lettuce, tomato and mayo on toasted white bread.
$13.00 +Reuben Sandwich - BEST SELLER
Corned beef on locally baked marble rye with swiss, sauerkraut and thousand island dressing. Toasted to ooey, gooey, perfection.
$11.50 +Italian Sandwich - BEST SELLER
Mortadella, cappicolla, genoa salami, provolone, sweet peppers, lettuce, tomato, oregano, mayo, oil and vinegar on a rustic, locally baked ciabatta roll.
$11.50 +New York Pastrami Sandwich - BEST SELLER
Pastrami on locally baked marble rye with provolone, cabbage slaw and thousand island dressing. Toasted to perfection. Many customers add double pastrami for a true NY style deli sandwich!
$10.00 +Tuna Melt BEST SELLER
Our owner Claire’s Favorite! Our freshly made tuna salad, light on mayo, with green apple and celery, is generously scooped on locally baked white bread and then topped with cheddar cheese and broiled until the cheese is melted and perfection.
$10.00 +Neighborhood Favorites
Turkey and Swiss Sandwich -
Roasted turkey breast on locally baked multi grain bread with Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo and whole grain mustard.
$10.00 +Tuna Salad Sandwich
Bennett's house all-white albacore tuna salad, made with apples and celery, lettuce and tomato with choice of bread. Many neighbors say our tuna salad is the best in town!
$9.50 +Roast Beef and Provolone Sandwich
Top round roast beef and provolone on white bread with lettuce, tomato, mayo and whole grain mustard.
$12.50 +BLT Sandwich
Classic bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo on toasted white bread. Consider adding avocado for a creamy kick! Better yet, add one fried egg and avocado!!! YUM!
$8.50 +Chicken Salad Sandwich
Bennett’s house made chicken salad with grapes and nuts is generously scooped on locally baked multigrain bread and topped with lettuce and tomato with choice of bread. Contains nuts.
$9.50 +Hot Roast Beef & Cheddar with Horseradish
Top round roast beef with cheddar toasted on a baguette with our homemade horsey mayo. If you love roast beef and a hot sandwich, this one you will love.
$13.00 +Ham and Cheddar Sandwich
Black forest ham and cheddar on white bread with lettuce, tomato, mayo and whole grain mustard.
$8.00 +Peanut Butter & Jelly
Comfort food at it's finest! Perfect for the little ones or when you are feeling young at heart!
$5.00 +All Day Breakfast
Breakfast Sandwich - Best Seller
One of our best selling items! We serve breakfast all day on freshly baked biscuits, NY bagels, or locally baked bread! It's made however you like too!! Pick your cheese and your protein.
$2.00 +Blox - Neighborhood Favorite
Served on our NY Bagel with lox, cream cheese, red onion and capers.
$12.00NY Bagel
Your choice of plain or everything bagel toasted to perfection with your choice of butter or cream cheese. We source these from a bakery in NYC - so they aren't just NY style bagels, they are actually made in NY bagels!
$3.00 +Broccoli & Cheddar Quiche Slice
Chef John makes all of our quiches in the store. Eat yours slice chilled, room temp, or reheat. Pair it with a side salad, biscuit or cup of our homemade tomato soup!
$7.00 +Soup and Salad
Greek Salad - Customer Favorite
Lettuce, tomato, red onion, cucumber, feta, black olives and pepperoncini with Greek dressing. Add a protein to make it a low carb and delicious meal!
$8.00 +Chicken Salad Salad
Our homemade chicken salad with grapes and nuts is generously scooped on top of a bed of fresh lettuce, with tomato, red onion, cucumber and choice of dressing.
$11.00 +Tuna Salad Salad - Best Seller
Our tuna salad is one of our best sellers! Some say it's the best in the neighborhood. Light on the mayonnaise, our tuna salad has celery and apples in it and is scooped generously on top of a bed of lettuce with tomato, red onion, cucumber and choice of dressing.
$11.00 +Garden Salad with our Homemade Pimento Cheese
Our award winning pimento cheese (made fresh daily) is generously scooped on to a bed of fresh lettuce, with tomato, red onion, cucumber and choice of dressing.
$9.50 +Garden Salad
Lettuce, tomato, red onion, cucumber and provolone with your choice of our house balsamic or greek dressing on the side.
$4.00 +Caprese Salad
Fresh mozzarella and tomatoes on a bed of lettuce with balsamic vinegar and olive oil.
$8.00 +Homemade Tomato Basil Soup - Best Seller
Our homemade tomato soup is a recipe that has been passed down through our owner Claire's family. Add a salad and freshly baked biscuit to make it a meal or add a yummy grilled cheese for the perfect comfort meal.
$4.00 +Vegetarian Sandwiches
American Veggie Sandwich
Our house made cilantro-chickpea spread on multi-grain bread with fresh avocado, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickles and choice of cheese. This sandwich is sooooo good we have many meat eaters order it and then add a protein! Give it a try!
$9.00 +Caprese Sandwich
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and lettuce served on a rustic ciabatta roll (locally baked) with our homemade basil aioli, olive oil and balsamic vinegar. If you are looking for a lighter option, we make this as a salad as well!
$10.50 +Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Melted cheddar and provolone on locally baked white bread. Add a cup of our homemade tomato soup and you've got comfort food at it's finest!
$7.50 +Gluten Free/Dairy Free/Vegan
Gluten Free Mini Cheese Pizza
We have partnered with 2BWhole Gluten Free Bakery, another woman owned business, to carry a variety of her items for our customers. We are ordering in small quantities right now as we learn our customers preferences. Supplies are limited.
$8.85Gluten Free/Dairy Free 5" Apple Pie
We have partnered with 2BWhole Gluten Free Bakery, another woman owned business, to carry a variety of her items for our customers. We are ordering in small quantities right now as we learn our customers preferences. Supplies are limited.
$11.00Gluten Free/Vegan Cinnamon Rolls
We have partnered with 2BWhole Gluten Free Bakery, another woman owned business, to carry a variety of her items for our customers. We are ordering in small quantities right now as we learn our customers preferences. Supplies are limited.
$6.00Gluten Free/Vegan Edible Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
We have partnered with 2BWhole Gluten Free Bakery, another woman owned business, to carry a variety of her items for our customers. We are ordering in small quantities right now as we learn our customers preferences. Supplies are limited.
$4.99Gluten Free/Dairy Free/Vegan 9" Pot Pie
We have partnered with 2BWhole Gluten Free Bakery, another woman owned business, to carry a variety of her items for our customers. We are ordering in small quantities right now as we learn our customers preferences. Supplies are limited.
$19.99Gluten Free/Dairy Free/Vegan 5" Pot Pie
We have partnered with 2BWhole Gluten Free Bakery, another woman owned business, to carry a variety of her items for our customers. We are ordering in small quantities right now as we learn our customers preferences. Supplies are limited.
$7.99Gluten Free/Vegan Donuts - Cinnamon Sugar
We have partnered with 2BWhole Gluten Free Bakery, another woman owned business, to carry a variety of her items for our customers. We are ordering in small quantities right now as we learn our customers preferences. Supplies are limited.
$2.75Gluten Free/Vegan Donuts - Vanilla with Vanilla Glaze
We have partnered with 2BWhole Gluten Free Bakery, another woman owned business, to carry a variety of her items for our customers. We are ordering in small quantities right now as we learn our customers preferences. Supplies are limited.
$2.75Gluten Free/Vegan Donuts - Chocolate with Vanilla Glaze
We have partnered with 2BWhole Gluten Free Bakery, another woman owned business, to carry a variety of her items for our customers. We are ordering in small quantities right now as we learn our customers preferences. Supplies are limited.
$2.75