16 Handles Frozen Yogurt & Ice Cream
Popular menu items
Tahitian Vanilla Bean Frozen Yogurt
Our Artisan vanilla soft-serve, made with simple, natural ingredients like real Tahitian vanilla
$6.95 +COVID-19 NOTE FROM Team Williamsburg
Food safety is #1
We are open for delivery and pickup! We just wanted to personally let you know how much we value your business and safety during this critical time. Our staff has undergone extensive training, we are following all CDC and Dept. of Health guideline, and we promise to go above and beyond for you. Every single order is made with a FRESH pair of food-grade gloves by a healthy employee wearing a mask. Every surface in the store has been disinfected and sanitized, and we continue to sanitize every 15 minutes. Every employee's health is being monitored, and while nobody has shown any symptoms, our employees know to stay home should they feel at all ill. Additionally, your delivery driver has been educated on contact-less delivery. If you’re anything like us, you’re going to want dessert every day. We are a small business, and we rely on our valued customers to keep the doors open and employees paid. This is going to be tough on everyone, but if you trust us with your dessert needs today, we promise to do our best not to let you down. Thanks for reading, and enjoy your froyo!
$0.00Dessert Bites
Cheesecake Bites
A classic New York dessert in bite-size pieces. The perfect balance of crumbly and creamy, just how a cheesecake ought to be (6 oz)
$4.55Cookie Dough Bites
Edible chocolate chip cookie dough—like the snack-friendly version of licking the spoon (6 oz)
$4.55Rainbow Cookies
The prettiest Italian cookies with notes of almond, raspberry, and chocolate—baked, sliced, and ready to enjoy (6 oz)
$4.55Strawberry Bursting Bubbles
Popping boba filled with strawberry juice. Enjoy them from the jar or add them to your favorite teas (4 oz)
$4.90Hazelnut Crunch
A 16 Handles classic! Crispy cereal pieces folded into rich chocolate, hazelnut, and almond sauce. Indulgent, crunchy, and utterly delightful by the spoonful (4 oz)
$4.90Ice Cream
Cookie Dough Ice Cream
You might say, “it’s just cookie dough” but this is not your ordinary cookie dough. We bring you a soft serve ice cream that is mouth-watering and your next new crave! We started with a creamy vanilla base, then folded in real and gooey chocolate chip cookies to make this custom, all natural, soft serve ice cream. Treat yo'self!
$6.95 +Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream
We make this ice cream with all natural ingredients like strawberry cookies, milk, and sugar just like your favorite bakeshop
$6.95 +COOKIES & CREAM ICE CREAM
NEW: Delicious, silky sweet cream folded full with real OREO® cookies make what might be our most delicious ice cream yet
$6.95 +Butter Cookie Ice Cream
Inspired by classic butter cookies—the sweet, melt-in-your-mouth centerpiece on any holiday cookie platter. A hint of vanilla perfects our recipe for rich Butter Cookie Ice Cream.
$6.95 +Butter Pecan Ice Cream
NEW! Sweet and nutty, this classic ice cream parlor flavor is made with real pecans folded into our signature soft-serve ice cream
$6.95 +Soft-Serve Classics
Tahitian Vanilla Bean Frozen Yogurt
Our Artisan vanilla soft-serve, made with simple, natural ingredients like real Tahitian vanilla
$6.95 +Made with Nutella Frozen Yogurt
Chocolate-hazelnut frozen yogurt made with real Nutella swirled in
$6.95 +Italian Tart Frozen Yogurt
Our classic tart fro-yo flavor, because simple never tasted so good
$6.95 +Cinnamon Rice Pudding
$6.95 +Fudge Brownie
$0.00Green Tea Vanilla
The perfect pairing of naturally bittersweet green tea and a hint of vanilla
$6.95 +Matcha Made in Heaven
$6.95 +Praline (No Sugar Added)
$6.95 +New York Style Cheesecake
$6.95 +Eggnog
$6.95 +No Sugar Added NY Cheese Cake
All the iconic flavor of a slice of homemade New York cheesecake swirled into our fro-yo, this time with a no sugar added recipe!
$6.95 +Oh My Pumpkin
$0.00 +Oh My Pumpkin Pie
$6.95 +Pistachi-yo
$0.00Raspberry Lemon Gelato
$6.95 +So Fresh Mango
$6.95 +So Fresh Mango Sorbet
$0.00 +Sweet Paro Pie
$6.95 +Sweet Taro Pie
$6.95 +Toasty marshmallow
$6.95 +Watermelon Sorbet
$6.95 +Cerealiously loopy
$6.95 +Salted Peanut Butter Cup
Calling all peanut butter lovers! Our smooth and creamy Salted Peanut Butter Cup is made with natural, roasted peanut butter
$6.95 +Mint Chocolate Chip
Who doesn't love the refreshing combination of mint and real chocolate? Our mint chip flavor is all natural and ultra-flavorful
$6.95 +Pina Colada
Our Pina Colada flavor is like a vacation in your cup! This bright and sweet swirl is made with real pineapple and coconut for an authentic, tropical flavor. You'll feel like you're sitting by the pool, even if you're really in your couch
$6.95 +White Chocolate Peppermint
Our signature holiday recipe blends real white chocolate and peppermint into a creamy and festive frozen yogurt
$6.95 +American Apple Pie
Try out NEW Limited seasonal Apple pie frozen yogurt. Taste just like homemade apple pie, perfect for the holidays.
$6.95 +Stok Cold Brew Gelato
$6.95 +Cotton Candy
This carnival favorite has a sweet, airy taste that will make your inner child scream with glee
$6.95 +Mint Chocolate Chip
Who doesn't love the refreshing combination of mint and real chocolate? Our mint chip flavor is all natural and ultra-flavorful
$6.95 +Banana Pudding
Ah, the perfect banana pudding: luscious layers of vanilla cream layered with ripe bananas and Nilla® Wafers. We took those key ingredients and turned them into a beautifully balanced frozen yogurt, made with real bananas and Nilla® Wafers—no extracts or imitators.
$6.95 +Graham Cracker
Enjoy our sweet, cinnamon packed graham cracker frozen yogurt. A fan-favorite with real graham cracker pieces swirled in
$6.95 +Peanut Butter Perfection
Calling all peanut butter lovers! Our smooth and creamy Peanut Butter Perfection is made with natural, roasted peanut butter
$6.95 +Blue sky
Our fro-yo take on blue moon ice cream, a softly sweet and perfectly creamy midwestern classic. Some swear they taste marshmallow and vanilla... others say it's fruity like their favorite cereals. We think it tastes like the first warm, blue-sky days of spring.
$6.95 +Lemon Sunshine
A bright and citrusy lemon frozen yogurt made with real lemons and cream, Lemon Sunshine sparkles like spring sunshine breaking through winter clouds.
$6.95 +Vegan (Dairy Free) Soft-Serve
OATLY ICE LATTE (NEW!)
NEW from 16 Handles and Oatly! Bold but balanced, cool but creamy, decadent but dairy-free! Let this description be the sign you're looking for: ICE LATTE oatmilk soft serve is exactly what you need today.
$6.95 +Vegan Cookie Dough Craving
NEW! All natural soft serve cookie dough flavor folded into our cashew milk base. No dairy, corn syrup, or soy!
$6.95 +COCO LOCO
$6.95 +STRAWBERRY LEMONADE SORBET
Sweet, tart, smooth and always refreshing, this sorbet blends two favorite flavors into one unforgettable treat that makes it taste like summer all year long
$6.95 +Cookies & Cashew Milk
Dairy-free chocolate cookie crumbles are folded into our creamy cashew-milk soft serve for a vegan take on classic cookies 'n' cream
$6.95 +Vegan Pumpkin Spice & Everything Nice
NEW! All natural soft serve with pumpkin, cinnamon, and fall spices folded into our cashew milk base. No dairy, corn syrup, gluten, GMOs or soy! (Contains nuts)
$6.95 +GREEN APPLE SORBET
This sweet, tart, tangy treat doesn't fall far from the tree. It's got the refreshing green apple flavor that Granny would be proud of
$6.95 +OATLY MOCHA (NEW!)
NEW from 16 Handles x Oatly! MOACH is our oatmilk soft serve version of the café-classic drink.
$6.95 +Oatly Caramel Apple
NEW! 16 Handles x Oatly Caramel Apple is handling for the season! Apple, caramel, and cinnamon flavors blend together to make an oatmilk soft serve as classic as apple pie.
$6.95 +Strawberry Lemonade Sorbet
Sweet, tart, smooth, and always refreshing. This sorbet blends two flavors into one unforgettable treat.
$6.95 +Oatly Cinnamon Bun
Like warm, fresh-from-the-oven cinnamon buns on a Sunday morning. All the cinnamon and brown sugar deliciousness, none of the dairy... Oatly oatmilk soft serve is a holiday miracle.
$6.95 +Black Raspberry (Made with Oat Milk)
Our non-dairy twist on the classically sweet ice cream flavor. Made with oat milk!
$6.95 +Strawberry Vanilla Sorbet
An Artisan strawberry sorbet made with real berries and a touch of sweet vanilla
$6.95 +Oatly Banana
A fruity, springtime twist on 16 Handles x Oatly made with real bananas with notes of vanilla. Available exclusively at 16 Handles!
$6.95 +Watermelon Sorbet
Juicy, sweet, and summery watermelon sorbet. It's like a frozen picnic for your taste buds
$6.95 +Smoothies
Cookie Dough by DO, Cookie Dough Confections
(NEW!) Vegan Signature Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Signature chocolate chip made in vegan recipe. 8 oz. container.
$8.95(NEW!) Cake Batter Cookie Dough
Cake batter, white chocolate and milk chocolate chips with sprinkles. 8 oz. container.
$8.95Fro-Yo Milkshakes
Pints
3 for $15 Oh My, Pumpkin Pie Pints
3 pre-packed pints of Oh My, Pumpkin Pie for $15. Not available for other flavors.
$15.00