Bennett’s Sandwich Shop
MenuAbout
Bennett’s Sandwich Shop Menu

Bennett’s Sandwich Shop

Dinner, Lunch
84 Peterborough St, Boston, MA 02215
(857) 239-9736
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

CHEESESTEAKS

Menu powered by Grubhub

Famous Steak And Cheese

100% all-natural sirloin steak is grilled and shaved to perfection and served with melted cheese and grilled onions, peppers, and/or mushrooms.

$11.59 +

Wicked Steak And Cheese

**NEW** spiced up with sriracha aioli and hot pepper spread.

$11.59 +

Left Coast Steak And Cheese

**NEW** lettuce, tomato, mayo and american cheese.

$11.59 +

Backyard Steak And Cheese

**NEW** served with pickles, mayo, barbecue and american cheese.

$11.59 +

Philly Pizza Steak

**NEW** marinara sauce and provolone cheese.

$11.99 +

CHICKEN CHEESESTEAKS

Famous Chicken Cheesesteak

shaved chicken breast with melted american cheese and your choice of grilled onions, peppers, and/or mushrooms.

$11.59 +

Wicked Chicken Cheesesteak

**NEW** spiced up with sriracha aioli and hot pepper spread.

$11.59 +

Left Coast Chicken Cheesesteak

**NEW** lettuce, tomato, mayo and american cheese.

$11.59 +

Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak

**NEW** mixed with hot sauce and drizzled with ranch.

$11.59 +

GRILLED CHICKEN

"F" Bomb

seasoned grilled strips of chicken breast served with melted american cheese, and grilled onions, peppers, and/or mushrooms.

$11.59 +

Wicked Grilled Chicken

"F" bomb spiced up with our delicious hot pepper spread and sriracha aioli.

$11.59 +

CHICKEN TENDER SUBS

Chicken Tender Sub

**NEW** lettuce, tomato, mayo and american cheese.

$11.59 +

Tender Parm

**NEW** chicken tenders mixed with marina sauce, provolone cheese and topped with oregano and grated parm.

$11.99 +

CHEESEBURGER

Cheeseburger

american cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, ketchup and mayo

$8.19 +

PASTRAMI

Pastrami

melted provolone cheese and yellow mustard.

$8.19 +

MEATBALL

Meatball

provolone cheese, oregano and topped with grated parm.

$6.99 +

VEGETARIAN

Grilled Veggie

grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms with melted american and provolone cheese & lettuce, tomatoes, pickles and hot pepper spread.

$10.49 +

Cold Subs

Italian

genoa salami, hot capicola, ham, and pepperoni with provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil+vinegar, salt+pepper+oregano.

$8.09 +

Wicked Italian

spiced-up italian with banana peppers, sriracha aioli and hot pepper spread.

$8.09 +

Turkey

all-natural pan roasted turkey with lettuce, tomato, onion, provolone cheese, mayo, oil+vinegar, salt+pepper+oregano.

$7.49 +

Wicked Turkey

spiced-up turkey with banana peppers, sriracha aioli and hot pepper spread.

$7.49 +

TBLT

all-natural pan roasted turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, american cheese and mayo.

$8.09 +

BLT

grilled bacon, melted american cheese, served with freshly sliced shredded lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.

$7.09 +

Going HAM

thinly sliced ham served with lettuce, onion, fresh peppers, american cheese, mayo, oil+vinegar and salt+pepper.

$8.09 +

Ham + Turkey

served with lettuce, tomato, onion, american cheese, mayo, oil+vinegar and salt+pepper.

$8.09 +

Ham + Salami

lettuce, tomato, onion, american cheese, mayo, oil+vinegar and salt+pepper.

$8.09 +

Salami

genoa salami served with lettuce, tomato, onion, american cheese, mayo, oil+vinegar and salt+pepper.

$7.49 +

Tuna

white albacore tuna mixed with mayo, lettuce, tomato and salt+pepper.

$7.49 +

Chicken Salad

white diced chicken mixed with celery salt and mayo served with lettuce, tomato and salt+pepper.

$6.75 +

Cold Veggie

american and provolone cheese served with lettuce, tomato, pickles, onion, banana peppers, fresh peppers, hot pepper spread, oil+vinegar, salt+pepper..

$6.99 +

Mediterranean Falafel

**NEW** deep fried falafel served with hummus, shredded lettuce, onion, fresh peppers, tzatziki, oil+vinegar and topped with our hot pepper spread.

$11.59 +

Salads

Garden Salad

freshly sliced iceburg lettuce, tomato, pickles, onion, banana peppers, fresh peppers, and your choice of protein and dressing.

$8.79 +

Italian Salad

**NEW** italian meats and provolone cheese complete with fresh chopped veggies a side of oil+vinegar.

$12.19 +

Mediterranean Salad

**NEW** falafel, hummus, freshly sliced lettuce, tomato, onion, fresh peppers, drizzled with tzatziki and served with a side of oil+vinegar.

$11.59 +

Chef Salad

**NEW** ham, turkey and provolone cheese complete with fresh chopped veggies a side of oil+vinegar.

$12.19 +

Melts

Grilled Cheese

classic with melted white american cheese.

$5.39 +

Tuna Melt

**NEW** white albacore tuna with melted american cheese, lettuce and tomato.

$9.99 +

Steak Melt

**NEW** 100% all-natural shaved sirloin served with melted american cheese.

$10.49 +

Lobster Grilled Cheese

**NEW** buttery grilled cheese served with maine lobster, melted provolone cheese and topped with sriracha aioli. sub for regular mayo if you can't handle the heat.

$25.79 +

Maine Lobster

Lobster Roll

our famous "Lobstah" roll! over a quarter pound of fresh maine lobster meat served on a lightly toasted gourmet roll with light mayo, drawn butter and light lettuce.

$23.49 +

Lobster Sub

our famous "Lobstah" sub! over half a pound of fresh maine lobster meat served on our lightly toasted small signature sub roll with light mayo, drawn butter and light lettuce.

$46.79 +

Lobster Grilled Cheese

**NEW** buttery grilled cheese served with maine lobster, melted provolone cheese and topped with sriracha aioli. sub for regular mayo if you can't handle the heat.

$25.79 +

Sides

Fries

$4.49 +

Port Fries

$5.79 +

Hash Browns

$4.09 +

Small Chicken Tenders

$8.19 +

Large Chicken Tenders

$11.59 +

Small Buffalo Tenders

$9.29 +

Large Buffalo Tenders

$12.79 +

Drinks

Bennett's Root Beer

$2.69

Bennett's Diet Root Beer

$2.69

Bennett's Cream Soda

$2.69

Bennett's Ginger Ale

$2.69

Bennett's Grape Soda

$2.69

Bennett's Raspberry Lime

$2.69

Bennett's Orange Soda

$2.69

Bottled Water

$2.39

Orange Juice

$2.79

Coke

$2.39

Diet Coke

$2.39

Coke Zero

$2.39

Sprite

$2.39

Dr. Pepper

$2.39

Gold Peak Sweet Tea

$2.79

Gold Peak Unsweetened Tea

$2.79

Honest Tea Green Tea

$2.79

Honest Tea Half And Half

$2.79

Blue Powerade

$2.79

Red Powerade

$2.79

Vitamin Water-Power C

$2.79

Vitamin Water-XXX

$2.79

Vitamin Water- Citrus

$2.79

Vitamin Water-Lemonade

$2.79

Aha sparkling watermelon lime water

$2.79

Aha sparkling Mango Black Tea Water

$2.79

Aha Blueberry Pomegranate Sparkling Water

$2.79

Aha Raspberry Acai Sparkling Water

$2.79

Coffee

George Howell Hot Nitro Brew

$4.50

George Howell Nitro Cold Brew

$4.50

Vanilla Nitro Cold Brew

$4.50

George Howell Nitro Cold Brew 64oz Growler

$24.00 +

Chips

Cape Cod Original

$1.79

Cape Cod BBQ

$1.79

Cape Cod Salt + Vinegar

$1.79

Treats

Bennett's Whoopie Pie

$3.89

Salted Caramel Brownie

$3.99

Chocolate Chip Cookie

$2.69

Rice Krispy

$2.69

Catering/Group Ordering

Famous Cheesesteak Box - Serves 10-12

$120.00 +

Signature Colds Box - Serves 10-12

$120.00 +

Salads - Serves 15-20

$41.99 +

Tenders - Serves 8-10

$44.99 +

Buffalo Tenders - Serves 8-10

$49.99 +

Fries - Serves 7-10

$25.99 +

Port Fries - Serves 7-10

$31.99

Chicken Salad/lb

$16.99 +

Tuna Salad/lb

$16.99 +

CHEESESTEAKS

Famous Steak And Cheese

100% all-natural sirloin steak is grilled and shaved to perfection and served with melted cheese and grilled onions, peppers, and/or mushrooms.

$11.59 +

Wicked Steak And Cheese

**NEW** spiced up with sriracha aioli and hot pepper spread.

$11.59 +

Left Coast Steak And Cheese

**NEW** lettuce, tomato, mayo and american cheese.

$11.59 +

Backyard Steak And Cheese

**NEW** served with pickles, mayo, barbecue and american cheese.

$11.59 +

Philly Pizza Steak

**NEW** marinara sauce and provolone cheese.

$11.99 +

CHICKEN CHEESESTEAKS

Famous Chicken Cheesesteak

shaved chicken breast with melted american cheese and your choice of grilled onions, peppers, and/or mushrooms.

$11.59 +

Wicked Chicken Cheesesteak

**NEW** spiced up with sriracha aioli and hot pepper spread.

$11.59 +

Left Coast Chicken Cheesesteak

**NEW** lettuce, tomato, mayo and american cheese.

$11.59 +

Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak

**NEW** mixed with hot sauce and drizzled with ranch.

$11.59 +

GRILLED CHICKEN

"F" Bomb

seasoned grilled strips of chicken breast served with melted american cheese, and grilled onions, peppers, and/or mushrooms.

$11.59 +

Wicked Grilled Chicken

"F" bomb spiced up with our delicious hot pepper spread and sriracha aioli.

$11.59 +

CHICKEN TENDER SUBS

Chicken Tender Sub

**NEW** lettuce, tomato, mayo and american cheese.

$11.59 +

Tender Parm

**NEW** chicken tenders mixed with marina sauce, provolone cheese and topped with oregano and grated parm.

$11.99 +

CHEESEBURGER

Cheeseburger

american cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, ketchup and mayo

$8.19 +

PASTRAMI

Pastrami

melted provolone cheese and yellow mustard.

$8.19 +

MEATBALL

Meatball

provolone cheese, oregano and topped with grated parm.

$6.99 +

VEGETARIAN

Grilled Veggie

grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms with melted american and provolone cheese & lettuce, tomatoes, pickles and hot pepper spread.

$10.49 +

Cold Subs

Italian

genoa salami, hot capicola, ham, and pepperoni with provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil+vinegar, salt+pepper+oregano.

$8.09 +

Wicked Italian

spiced-up italian with banana peppers, sriracha aioli and hot pepper spread.

$8.09 +

Turkey

all-natural pan roasted turkey with lettuce, tomato, onion, provolone cheese, mayo, oil+vinegar, salt+pepper+oregano.

$7.49 +

Wicked Turkey

spiced-up turkey with banana peppers, sriracha aioli and hot pepper spread.

$7.49 +

TBLT

all-natural pan roasted turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, american cheese and mayo.

$8.09 +

BLT

grilled bacon, melted american cheese, served with freshly sliced shredded lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.

$7.09 +

Going HAM

thinly sliced ham served with lettuce, onion, fresh peppers, american cheese, mayo, oil+vinegar and salt+pepper.

$8.09 +

Ham + Turkey

served with lettuce, tomato, onion, american cheese, mayo, oil+vinegar and salt+pepper.

$8.09 +

Ham + Salami

lettuce, tomato, onion, american cheese, mayo, oil+vinegar and salt+pepper.

$8.09 +

Salami

genoa salami served with lettuce, tomato, onion, american cheese, mayo, oil+vinegar and salt+pepper.

$7.49 +

Tuna

white albacore tuna mixed with mayo, lettuce, tomato and salt+pepper.

$7.49 +

Chicken Salad

white diced chicken mixed with celery salt and mayo served with lettuce, tomato and salt+pepper.

$6.75 +

Cold Veggie

american and provolone cheese served with lettuce, tomato, pickles, onion, banana peppers, fresh peppers, hot pepper spread, oil+vinegar, salt+pepper..

$6.99 +

Mediterranean Falafel

**NEW** deep fried falafel served with hummus, shredded lettuce, onion, fresh peppers, tzatziki, oil+vinegar and topped with our hot pepper spread.

$11.59 +

Salads

Garden Salad

freshly sliced iceburg lettuce, tomato, pickles, onion, banana peppers, fresh peppers, and your choice of protein and dressing.

$8.79 +

Italian Salad

**NEW** italian meats and provolone cheese complete with fresh chopped veggies a side of oil+vinegar.

$12.19 +

Mediterranean Salad

**NEW** falafel, hummus, freshly sliced lettuce, tomato, onion, fresh peppers, drizzled with tzatziki and served with a side of oil+vinegar.

$11.59 +

Chef Salad

**NEW** ham, turkey and provolone cheese complete with fresh chopped veggies a side of oil+vinegar.

$12.19 +

Melts

Grilled Cheese

classic with melted white american cheese.

$5.39 +

Tuna Melt

**NEW** white albacore tuna with melted american cheese, lettuce and tomato.

$9.99 +

Steak Melt

**NEW** 100% all-natural shaved sirloin served with melted american cheese.

$10.49 +

Lobster Grilled Cheese

**NEW** buttery grilled cheese served with maine lobster, melted provolone cheese and topped with sriracha aioli. sub for regular mayo if you can't handle the heat.

$25.79 +

Maine Lobster

Lobster Roll

our famous "Lobstah" roll! over a quarter pound of fresh maine lobster meat served on a lightly toasted gourmet roll with light mayo, drawn butter and light lettuce.

$23.49 +

Lobster Sub

our famous "Lobstah" sub! over half a pound of fresh maine lobster meat served on our lightly toasted small signature sub roll with light mayo, drawn butter and light lettuce.

$46.79 +

Lobster Grilled Cheese

**NEW** buttery grilled cheese served with maine lobster, melted provolone cheese and topped with sriracha aioli. sub for regular mayo if you can't handle the heat.

$25.79 +

Sides

Fries

$4.49 +

Port Fries

$5.79 +

Hash Browns

$4.09 +

Small Chicken Tenders

$8.19 +

Large Chicken Tenders

$11.59 +

Small Buffalo Tenders

$9.29 +

Large Buffalo Tenders

$12.79 +

Drinks

Bennett's Root Beer

$2.69

Bennett's Diet Root Beer

$2.69

Bennett's Cream Soda

$2.69

Bennett's Ginger Ale

$2.69

Bennett's Grape Soda

$2.69

Bennett's Raspberry Lime

$2.69

Bennett's Orange Soda

$2.69

Bottled Water

$2.39

Orange Juice

$2.79

Coke

$2.39

Diet Coke

$2.39

Coke Zero

$2.39

Sprite

$2.39

Dr. Pepper

$2.39

Gold Peak Sweet Tea

$2.79

Gold Peak Unsweetened Tea

$2.79

Honest Tea Green Tea

$2.79

Honest Tea Half And Half

$2.79

Blue Powerade

$2.79

Red Powerade

$2.79

Vitamin Water-Power C

$2.79

Vitamin Water-XXX

$2.79

Vitamin Water- Citrus

$2.79

Vitamin Water-Lemonade

$2.79

Aha sparkling watermelon lime water

$2.79

Aha sparkling Mango Black Tea Water

$2.79

Aha Blueberry Pomegranate Sparkling Water

$2.79

Aha Raspberry Acai Sparkling Water

$2.79

Coffee

George Howell Hot Nitro Brew

$4.50

George Howell Nitro Cold Brew

$4.50

Vanilla Nitro Cold Brew

$4.50

George Howell Nitro Cold Brew 64oz Growler

$24.00 +

Chips

Cape Cod Original

$1.79

Cape Cod BBQ

$1.79

Cape Cod Salt + Vinegar

$1.79

Treats

Bennett's Whoopie Pie

$3.89

Salted Caramel Brownie

$3.99

Chocolate Chip Cookie

$2.69

Rice Krispy

$2.69

Bennett's Pumkin Whoopie Pie

$3.89

Catering/Group Ordering

Famous Cheesesteak Box - Serves 10-12

$120.00 +

Signature Colds Box - Serves 10-12

$120.00 +

Salads - Serves 15-20

$41.99 +

Tenders - Serves 8-10

$44.99 +

Buffalo Tenders - Serves 8-10

$49.99 +

Fries - Serves 7-10

$25.99 +

Port Fries - Serves 7-10

$31.99

Chicken Salad/lb

$16.99 +

Tuna Salad/lb

$16.99 +

Breakfast Bowls

Bennett's Bowl

Served daily until 10:30 am. **NEW** 3 scrambled eggs, hashbrowns, grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms and american cheese. add your choice of protein to complete the bowl. Breakfast items ordered after 10:30 am may not be fulfilled.

$8.79 +

STEGG Bowl

Served daily until 10:30 am. **NEW** 100% all-natural shaved sirloin steak, 2 scrambled eggs, hashbrowns, grilled onions and peppers, american cheese, drizzled with ketchup and sriracha aioli. Breakfast items ordered after 10:30 am may not be fulfilled.

$11.09 +

Signature Breakfast Sandwiches

Steak, Egg & Cheese

Our signature steak, egg and cheese! Served daily until 10:30 am. Breakfast items ordered after 10:30 am may not be fulfilled.

$9.99 +

Wicked Steak, Egg & Cheese

Our signature steak, egg and cheese topped off with sriracha aioli and hot pepper spread! Served daily until 10:30 am. Breakfast items ordered after 10:30 am may not be fulfilled.

$9.99 +

Pastrami, Egg & Cheese

Served daily until 10:30 am. **NEW** served with melted provolone cheese and sriracha aioli. Breakfast items ordered after 10:30 am may not be fulfilled.

$10.49 +

Market Square

Served daily until 10:30 am. **NEW** Our signature veggie breakfast sandwich! Fried eggs with lettuce, tomato, onion, melted American cheese, mayo and ketchup. Breakfast items ordered after 10:30 am may not be fulfilled.

$9.29 +

Classic Breakfast Sandwiches

Bacon, Egg & Cheese

Served daily until 10:30 am. Breakfast items ordered after 10:30 am may not be fulfilled.

$6.39 +

Sausage, Egg & Cheese

Served daily until 10:30 am. Breakfast items ordered after 10:30 am may not be fulfilled.

$6.39 +

Ham, Egg & Cheese

Served daily until 10:30 am. Breakfast items ordered after 10:30 am may not be fulfilled.

$6.39 +

Turkey, Egg & Cheese

Served daily until 10:30 am. Breakfast items ordered after 10:30 am may not be fulfilled.

$6.39 +

Egg & Cheese

Served daily until 10:30 am. Breakfast items ordered after 10:30 am may not be fulfilled.

$6.39 +

English Muffins

Bacon, Egg & Cheese English Muffin

Served daily until 10:30 am. Breakfast items ordered after 10:30 am may not be fulfilled.

$6.39 +

Sausage, Egg & Cheese English Muffin

Served daily until 10:30 am. Breakfast items ordered after 10:30 am may not be fulfilled.

$6.39 +

Ham, Egg & Cheese English Muffin

Served daily until 10:30 am. Breakfast items ordered after 10:30 am may not be fulfilled.

$6.39 +

Turkey, Egg & Cheese English Muffin

Served daily until 10:30 am. Breakfast items ordered after 10:30 am may not be fulfilled.

$6.39 +

Egg & Cheese English Muffin

Served daily until 10:30 am. Breakfast items ordered after 10:30 am may not be fulfilled.

$6.39 +

Sides

Hash Browns

$4.09 +

Fries

$4.49 +

Port Fries

$5.39 +

Small Chicken Tenders

$8.19 +

Small Buffalo Tenders

$9.29 +

Large Chicken Tenders

$11.59 +

Large Buffalo Tenders

$12.79 +

Coffee

George Howell Hot Nitro Brew

$4.50

George Howell Nitro Cold Brew

$4.50

Vanilla Nitro Cold Brew

$4.50

George Howell Nitro Cold Brew Growler

$24.00 +

Drinks

Orange Juice

$2.69

Bottled Water

$2.29

Bennett's Root Beer

$2.59

Bennett's Cream Soda

$2.59

Bennett's Raspberry Lime

$2.59

Bennett's Ginger Ale

$2.59

Bennett's Grape Soda

$2.59

Bennett's Orange Soda

$2.59

Bennett's Diet Root Beer

$2.59

Coke

$2.29

Diet Coke

$2.29

Sprite

$2.29

Dr. Pepper

$2.29

Coke Zero

$2.29

Red Powerade

$2.69

Blue Powerade

$2.69

Gold Peak Sweet Tea

$2.69

Gold Peak Unsweetened Tea

$2.69

Honest Tea Green Tea

$2.69

Honest Tea Half & Half

$2.69

Vitamin Water-Power C

$2.69

Vitamin Water-XXX

$2.69

Vitamin Water- Citrus

$2.69

Vitamin Water-Lemonade

$2.69

Aha Sparkling watermelon lime water

$2.69

Aha sparkling Mango Black Tea Water

$2.69

Aha Blueberry Pomegranate Sparkling Water

$2.69

Aha Raspberry Acai Sparkling Water

$2.69

Treats

Bennett's Whoopie Pie

$3.79

Salted Caramel Brownie

$3.99

Chocolate Chip Cookie

$2.79

Rice Krispy

$2.79

Chips

Cape Cod Original

$1.79

Cape Cod BBQ

$1.79

Cape Cod Salt + Vinegar

$1.79
FYI, this restaurant is not accepting orders right now.

About Bennett’s Sandwich Shop

  • 84 Peterborough St, Boston, MA 02215
  • Dinner, Lunch, Sandwiches
  • (857) 239-9736
Powered by Grubhub
Home / MA / Boston / Bennett’s Sandwich Shop
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy policy CA Privacy notice Do not sell my info
© 2023 Grubhub Holdings Inc.