Hill and Bay
MenuAbout
Hill and Bay  Menu

Hill and Bay

American, Dinner
581 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10016
(212) 245-5554
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Popular menu items

Menu powered by Grubhub

Signature Grill House Burger

Black angus blend, bacon, cheddar, romaine, tomato, red onion, 581 sauce.

$18.95 +

Ranger Burger

Black angus blend, jalapeños, pepper jack cheese, crispy fried onions, chipotle mayo.

$18.95 +

Utensils

Utensils

$0.00

Brunch

HB Bennies

Poached eggs, buttermilk biscuit, hollandaise, tater tots. Bacon, spinach or smoked salmon.

$20.95 +

HB Sausage Benny

Poached eggs, buttermilk biscuit, sausage, sausage gravy, cheddar cheese, tater tots.

$20.95

Huevos Rancheros

Corn tortillas, black beans, cheese, tomatillo salsa, avocado, sour cream, eggs any style.

$20.95

Eggs Any Style

Two eggs, multigrain toast, tater tots.

$19.95 +

Scrambler

Your choice of ingredients mixed into scrambled eggs. Comes with tater tots & multigrain toast.

$20.95 +

NY Strip Steak & Eggs

Two eggs, multigrain toast, tater tots.

$30.95 +

5 Easy Pieces

2 eggs any style, choice of pancakes or french toast, choice of bacon or sausage.

$19.95 +

Buttermilk Griddle Cakes

Add bacon, pecans, chocolate chips, nutella, seasonal berries or banana.

$14.95 +

French Toast

Add bacon, pecans, chocolate chips, nutella, seasonal berries or banana.

$14.95 +

New Yawker

Choice of multi-grain or plain bagel, smoked salmon, caper cream cheese, red onion, tomato.

$19.95

House Made Granola

Greek yogurt, fruit and berries.

$14.95

Burgers

Signature Grill House Burger

Black angus blend, bacon, cheddar, romaine, tomato, red onion, 581 sauce.

$18.95 +

H&B Classic Burger

Black angus blend, romaine, tomato, red onion.

$17.95 +

Ranger Burger

Black angus blend, jalapeños, pepper jack cheese, crispy fried onions, chipotle mayo.

$18.95 +

Salmon Burger

Avocado, arugula, balsamic, red onion.

$20.95 +

Turkey Burger

Free-range blend, crispy fried onions, pepper jack cheese, barbecue sauce.

$18.95 +

Buffalo Chicken Burger

Breaded chicken breast, buffalo sauce, pepper jack cheese, chipotle mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion.

$18.95 +

Lentil Veggie Burger

lentil, onion, garlic, panko breadcrumbs, carrot, jalapenos, cheddar cheese

$17.95 +

Sandwiches

The Big Cheesy

Cheddar, brie, gruyere, multi-grain bread.

$14.95

Chipotle Chicken Wrap

Pepper jack, romaine, tomato, onion, chipotle mayo.

$17.95

Hangover Helper

Eggs, pepper jack, avocado, bacon, chipotle aioli, brioche bun.

$16.95

Tuna Melt

Cheddar, multigrain bread.

$15.95

Eggplant Parm

Tomato sauce, parmesan, mozzarella, baguette.

$15.95

Chicken Parm

Tomato sauce, parmesan, mozzarella, baguette.

$18.95

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

buttermilk fried chicken,buffalo sauce, romaine, carrots, celery, cheddar, blue cheese

$17.95

Caesar Chicken Wrap

buttermilk fried chicken, parmesan, radish, romaine, anchovy vinaigrette

$17.95

BLT

bacon, letuce, tomato, mayo, multigrain bread

$14.95

Salads

Angelic's Delight

Beets, greens, goat cheese, candied pecans, balsamic vinaigrette.

$17.95 +

You Gotta Try The Burrata

Burrata, arugula, tomato, lemon juice, fig balsamic reduction, extra virgin olive oil.

$19.95 +

All Kale Caesar

Grilled chicken breast, radish, shaved parmesan, anchovy vinaigrette.

$21.95

Cauli Rice & Shaved Brussels Sprouts

Dried cranberries, sliced almonds, balsamic dressing.

$18.95 +

Soy Sesame Salmon

Cabbage, carrot, scallion, crispy noodles, almonds, cucumber, soy-sesame vinaigrette.

$24.95

NY Strip Chop

Grilled steak, greens, radicchio, bacon, blue cheese, hard-boiled egg, sherry vinaigrette.

$27.95

H&B Shrimp Salad

Arugula, lemon dressing, roasted almonds, chopped red onions, avocado.

$24.95

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Fried boneless chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, romaine, diced carrots & celery, cheddar, blue cheese dressing.

$21.95

Share Plates

Buttermilk Fried Boneless Chicken

Comes with buffalo blue cheese and honey dijon dipping sauce.

$18.95

Grilled Mahi Mahi Tacos

Corn tortillas, tri-colored slaw, chipotle mayo, tomatillo salsa.

$19.95

Avocado Toast

Olive oil, lemon juice, pepper flakes. Choice of side salad, egg or cup of soup.

$16.95

Wings

Choice of buffalo or Asian glazed.

$14.95 +

Marvelous Mac and Cheese

Jack, cheddar, asiago.

$16.95 +

Nonni's Meatballs

Ground beef, sweet fennel sausage, parmesan.

$16.95

Guacamole w/ Tortilla Chips

avocado, jalapeño, onion, cilantro, lime juice, tomato

$19.95

Quesadilla

Tortilla, mixed cheese, pico de gallo, sour cream, choice of chicken, steak, shrimp or veggie.

$18.95

Sides

Shoestring Fries

$6.95 +

Sweet Potato Fries

$6.95 +

Tater Tots

$6.95 +

Biscuits & Gravy

$6.95

French Onion Soup

w/ gruyere

$11.95

Tomato Soup

$9.95

Bagel

$4.95 +

5-Grain Toast

$2.95

Fresh Fruit

$9.95

Half Avocado

$6.95

Bacon

$8.95

Sausage

$8.95

Smoked Salmon

$13.95

Side Salad

Mixed greens, tomatoes, balsamic vinaigrette

$6.95

Lentil Soup

w/ Parmesan and bacon

$8.95

Pastries

Carrot Walnut Muffin

$3.95

Blueberry Muffin

$3.95

Chocolate Banana Muffin

$3.95

Chocolate Zucchini Muffin

$3.95

Chocolate Chip Cookie

$3.95

Oatmeal Cranberry Cookie

$3.95

Brownie

$3.95

Coffees, Teas, Etc.

Coffee

$2.40 +

Decaf

$2.40 +

Cold Brew

$3.65 +

Iced Tea

$3.50 +

Espresso

$2.65 +

Double Espresso

$3.05 +

Cappuccino

$3.90 +

Iced Cappuccino

$4.65 +

Latte

$3.90 +

Iced Latte

$4.65 +

Mocha

$4.65 +

Iced Mocha

$5.15 +

Chai Latte

$4.15 +

Iced Chai Latte

$4.65 +

Americano

$3.15 +

Cortado

$3.55 +

Flat White

$3.55 +

Macchiato

$3.05 +

Hot Cocoa

$3.50 +

Hot Tea

$2.50 +

Dr Feel Good

$6.00 +

Vanilla Nice

$5.00 +

Smoothies

There's Something About Berry

Blueberry, beet, spinach, oj, banana.

$9.95 +

The Green Mile

Spinach, pineapple, peach nectar, banana.

$9.95 +

The Hulk

Kale, spinach, pineapple, ginger, lemon.

$9.95 +

Last Mango in Paris

Mango, banana, almond milk, honey, greek yogurt.

$9.95 +

The Nutty Professor

Almond milk, cocoa, peanut butter, honey, banana.

$9.95 +

Dude, Where's My Orange?

Oj, mango, sweet potato, ginger, banana.

$9.95 +

50 Shades of Strawberry

Strawberry, mango, oj, banana.

$9.95 +

Pineapple Express

Pineapple, mango, banana, greek yogurt.

$9.95 +

Beer (alcohol)

Montauk - Wave Chaser

IPA - Draft 16 oz

$8.00

Threes - Logical Conclusion

IPA - Draft 16 oz

$9.00

Narragansett

Lager - Draft 16 oz

$7.00

Founders

Porter - Draft 16 oz

$9.00

Allagash - White

Belgian Style Wheat Beer - Draft 16 oz

$9.00

Blue Point

Toasted Lagerr - 16 oz Draft

$8.00

Corona

Mexican Lager - Bottle

$6.00

Miller Lite

Light Lager - Bottle

$6.00

Brooklyn

Lager - Draft 16 oz

$6.00

Dogfish Head 90 Minute IPA

India Pale Ale - Bottle

$8.00

Ithica Flower Power

American IPA - Bottle

$7.00

Wolffer Estate

Dry Rosé Cider - Bottle

$12.00

Modelo

Mexican Lager - Bottle

$6.00

Samuel Smith

Imperial Stout - Bottle

$9.00

Tecate

Mexican Lager - Can

$6.00

Original Sin

Black Widow - Blackberry Apple Cider - Can

$7.00

Brooklyn (Non-Alcoholic)

Hoppy Amber Ale - Can

$6.00

Cocktails (alcohol)

The Spice

Jalapeño infused tequila, pineapple juice, lime juice

$13.00

Peach Perfect

Gin, peach liqueur, peach nectar, bitters sparkling wine.

$13.00

Ferris Mule'ers Day Off

Vodka, ginger beer, fresh lime juice.

$13.00

Benedict Cucumberbatch

Vodka, elderflower liqueur, cucumber water, lemon, splash ginger beer.

$13.00

The Devil Wears Vida

Rum, Del Maguey Vida mezcal, lime juice, simple syrup.

$13.00

Whiskey Business

Whiskey, raspberry liqueur, Domaine Canton, lemon juice, club soda.

$13.00

Blazing Apples

house made hot apple cider, whiskey

$15.00

Paloma

Tequila, grapefruit juice, club soda, bitters.

$13.00

Bloody Murray

Vodka, tomato juice, spices, fresh horseradish, lemon and lime juices.

$13.00

Bay Flower Bellini

Sparkling wine, elderflower liqueur, peach nectar.

$13.00

Aperol Spritz

$13.00

Wine by the Glass (alcohol)

Pinot Noir

Pas De Problema - France - 6 oz pour

$10.00

Malbec

Alhambra - Argentina - 6 oz pour

$12.00

Cabernet Sauvignon

Vista Point -California - 6 oz pour

$9.00

Pinot Grigio

Vista Point - California - 6 oz pour

$9.00

Sauvignon Blanc

Rain - New Zealand - 6 oz pour

$11.00

Chardonnay

The Atom - California - 6 oz pour

$11.00

Sparkling Rosé

Simonet - France - 6 oz pour

$11.00

Prosecco

Cavicchioli 1928 - Italy - 6 oz pour

$12.00

Rosé

Borsao - Spain - 6 oz pour

$9.00

Soft Drinks

Coke

$3.00

Diet Coke

$3.00

Sprite

$3.00

Ginger Ale

$3.00

Club Soda

$3.00 +

Lemonade

$3.00 +

Iced Tea

$3.00 +

Iced Tea & Lemonade

$3.00 +

Cranberry Juice

$5.00

Grapefruit Juice

$5.00

Orange Juice

$5.00

Pineapple Juice

$5.00

Poland Spring

$3.00

Desserts

Butterscotch Bread Pudding

Brioche, butterscotch custard, ice cream.

$12.95

Warm Apple Cobbler

Buttermilk biscuit top, ice cream.

$12.95

Hot Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae

Chocolate ganache, ice cream, whipped cream.

$12.95

Key Lime Pie

Graham cracker crust, whipped cream.

$12.95

Chocolate Peanut Butter Silk Pie

Graham cracker crust, ganache, candied peanuts, whipped cream.

$12.95

Dulce De Leche Brownie Sundae

Ice cream, butterscotch chips, whipped cream.

$12.95

Utensils

Utensils

$0.00

Entrees

Argentinian Steak Frites

NY strip steak, fries, chimichurri sauce.

$34.95

Pan Seared Mahi Mahi

Sautéed broccoli, mango-pineapple salsa.

$24.95

Salmon Caponata

sauce (olives, eggplant, squash, tomato), mashed potatoes

$25.95

Thai Chili Glazed Salmon

Sweet chili sauce, sautéed spinach.

$25.95

Chicken Mash Kale

Grilled boneless half chicken, mashed potatoes, sautéed kale, mushroom-red wine sauce.

$27.95

Pasta Bolognese

Penne, beef, sausage, marinara, cream.

$20.95 +

Chicken Piccata

Spaghetti, lemon butter wine sauce, caper, shallot.

$20.95

Spinach Ravioli

Truffle-parmesan cheese sauce, tomato, shallot.

$18.95 +

Chicken Parmesan

Spaghetti, marinara, parmesan, mozzarella.

$25.95

Eggplant Parmesan

Spaghetti, marinara, parmesan, mozzarella.

$20.95

Burgers

Signature Grill House Burger

Black angus blend, bacon, cheddar, romaine, tomato, red onion, 581 sauce.

$18.95 +

H&B Classic Burger

Black angus blend, romaine, tomato, red onion.

$17.95 +

Ranger Burger

Black angus blend, jalapeños, pepper jack cheese, crispy fried onions, chipotle mayo.

$18.95 +

Salmon Burger

Avocado, arugula, balsamic, red onion.

$20.95 +

Turkey Burger

Free-range blend, crispy fried onions, pepper jack cheese, barbecue sauce.

$18.95 +

Buffalo Chicken Burger

Breaded chicken breast, buffalo sauce, pepper jack cheese, chipotle mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion.

$18.95 +

Lentil Veggie Burger

lentil, onion, garlic, panko breadcrumbs, carrot, jalapenos, cheddar cheese

$17.95 +

Salads

Angelic's Delight

Beets, greens, goat cheese, candied pecans, balsamic vinaigrette.

$17.95 +

You Gotta Try The Burrata

Burrata, arugula, tomato, lemon juice, fig balsamic reduction, extra virgin olive oil.

$19.95 +

All Kale Caesar

Grilled chicken breast, radish, shaved parmesan, anchovy vinaigrette.

$21.95

Cauli Rice & Shaved Brussels Sprouts

Dried cranberries, sliced almonds, balsamic dressing.

$18.95 +

Soy Sesame Salmon

Cabbage, carrot, scallion, crispy noodles, almonds, cucumber, soy-sesame vinaigrette.

$24.95

NY Strip Chop

Grilled steak, greens, radicchio, bacon, blue cheese, hard-boiled egg, sherry vinaigrette.

$27.95

H&B Shrimp Salad

Arugula, lemon dressing, roasted almonds, chopped red onions, avocado.

$24.95

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Fried boneless chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, romaine, diced carrots & celery, cheddar, blue cheese dressing.

$21.95

Share Plates

Wings

Choice of buffalo or Asian glazed.

$14.95 +

Grilled Mahi Mahi Tacos

Corn tortillas, tri-colored slaw, chipotle mayo, tomatillo salsa.

$19.95

Buttermilk Fried Boneless Chicken

Comes with buffalo blue cheese and honey dijon dipping sauce.

$18.95

Nacho Libre

Corn tortillas, black beans, shredded cheese, pico de gallo, sour cream.

$18.95 +

Marvelous Mac and Cheese

Jack, cheddar, asiago.

$16.95 +

Nonni's Meatballs

Ground beef, sweet fennel sausage, parmesan.

$16.95

Mozzarella Sticks

Marinara sauce.

$12.95

Avocado Toast

Olive oil, lemon juice, pepper flakes. Choice of side salad or cup of soup.

$15.95

Guacamole w/ Tortilla Chips

avocado, jalapeño, onion, cilantro, lime juice, tomato

$19.95

Sides

Shoestring Fries

$6.95 +

Sweet Potato Fries

$6.95 +

Tater Tots

$6.95 +

Crispy Brussels Sprouts

Pancetta, cider agrodolce.

$11.95

Sautéed Broccoli

$11.95

Buffalo Cauliflower

breaded/fried, tossed in buffalo sauce

$9.95

Sauteed Kale

$9.95

Mashed Potatoes

$8.95 +

Half Avocado

$6.95

French Onion Soup

w/ gruyere

$11.95

Tomato Soup

$9.95

Side Salad

Mixed greens, tomatoes, balsamic vinaigrette

$6.95

Lentil Soup

w/ Parmesan and bacon

$8.95

Beer (alcohol)

Montauk - Wave Chaser

IPA - Draft 16 oz

$8.00

Threes - Logical Conclusion

IPA - Draft 16 oz

$9.00

Narragansett

Lager - Draft 16 oz

$7.00

Founders

Porter - Draft 16 oz

$9.00

Allagash - White

Belgian Style Wheat Beer - Draft 16 oz

$9.00

Blue Point

Toasted Lagerr - 16 oz Draft

$8.00

Corona

Mexican Lager - Bottle

$6.00

Miller Lite

Light Lager - Bottle

$6.00

Brooklyn

Lager - Draft 16 oz

$6.00

Dogfish Head 90 Minute IPA

India Pale Ale - Bottle

$8.00

Ithica Flower Power

American IPA - Bottle

$7.00

Wolffer Estate

Dry Rosé Cider - Bottle

$12.00

Modelo

Mexican Lager - Bottle

$6.00

Samuel Smith

Imperial Stout - Bottle

$9.00

Tecate

Mexican Lager - Can

$6.00

Original Sin

Black Widow - Blackberry Apple Cider - Can

$7.00

Brooklyn (Non-Alcoholic)

Hoppy Amber Ale - Can

$6.00

Cocktails (alcohol)

The Spice

Jalapeño infused tequila, pineapple juice, lime juice

$13.00

Peach Perfect

Gin, peach liqueur, peach nectar, bitters sparkling wine.

$13.00

Ferris Mule'ers Day Off

Vodka, ginger beer, fresh lime juice.

$13.00

Benedict Cucumberbatch

Vodka, elderflower liqueur, cucumber water, lemon, splash ginger beer.

$13.00

The Devil Wears Vida

Rum, Del Maguey Vida mezcal, lime juice, simple syrup.

$13.00

Whiskey Business

Whiskey, raspberry liqueur, Domaine Canton, lemon juice, club soda.

$13.00

Blazing Apples

house made hot apple cider, whiskey

$15.00

Paloma

Tequila, grapefruit juice, club soda, bitters.

$13.00

Bloody Murray

Vodka, tomato juice, spices, fresh horseradish, lemon and lime juices.

$13.00

Bay Flower Bellini

Sparkling wine, elderflower liqueur, peach nectar.

$13.00

Aperol Spritz

$13.00

Wine by the Glass (alcohol)

Pinot Noir

Pas De Problema - France - 6 oz pour

$10.00

Malbec

Alhambra - Argentina - 6 oz pour

$12.00

Cabernet Sauvignon

Vista Point -California - 6 oz pour

$9.00

Pinot Grigio

Vista Point - California - 6 oz pour

$9.00

Sauvignon Blanc

Rain - New Zealand - 6 oz pour

$11.00

Chardonnay

The Atom - California - 6 oz pour

$11.00

Sparkling Rosé

Simonet - France - 6 oz pour

$11.00

Prosecco

Cavicchioli 1928 - Italy - 6 oz pour

$12.00

Rosé

Borsao - Spain - 6 oz pour

$9.00

Soft Drinks

Coke

$3.00

Diet Coke

$3.00

Sprite

$3.00

Ginger Ale

$3.00

Club Soda

$3.00 +

Lemonade

$3.00 +

Iced Tea

$3.00 +

Iced Tea & Lemonade

$3.00 +

Cranberry Juice

$5.00

Grapefruit Juice

$5.00

Orange Juice

$5.00

Pineapple Juice

$5.00

Poland Spring

$3.00

Smoothies

There's Something About Berry

Blueberry, beet, spinach, oj, banana.

$9.95 +

The Green Mile

Spinach, pineapple, peach nectar, banana.

$9.95 +

The Hulk

Kale, spinach, pineapple, ginger, lemon.

$9.95 +

Last Mango in Paris

Mango, banana, almond milk, honey, greek yogurt.

$9.95 +

The Nutty Professor

Almond milk, cocoa, peanut butter, honey, banana.

$9.95 +

Dude, Where's My Orange?

Oj, mango, sweet potato, ginger, banana.

$9.95 +

50 Shades of Strawberry

Strawberry, mango, oj, banana.

$9.95 +

Pineapple Express

Pineapple, mango, banana, greek yogurt.

$9.95 +

Coffees, Teas, Etc.

Coffee

$2.40 +

Decaf

$2.40 +

Cold Brew

$3.65 +

Iced Tea

$3.50 +

Espresso

$2.65 +

Double Espresso

$3.05 +

Cappuccino

$3.90 +

Iced Cappuccino

$4.65 +

Latte

$3.90 +

Iced Latte

$4.65 +

Mocha

$4.65 +

Iced Mocha

$5.15 +

Chai Latte

$4.15 +

Iced Chai Latte

$4.65 +

Americano

$3.15 +

Cortado

$3.55 +

Flat White

$3.55 +

Macchiato

$3.05 +

Hot Cocoa

$3.50 +

Hot Tea

$2.50 +

Dr Feel Good

$6.00 +

Vanilla Nice

$5.00 +

Desserts

Butterscotch Bread Pudding

Brioche, butterscotch custard, ice cream.

$12.95

Warm Apple Cobbler

Buttermilk biscuit top, ice cream.

$12.95

Hot Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae

Chocolate ganache, ice cream, whipped cream.

$12.95

Key Lime Pie

Graham cracker crust, whipped cream.

$12.95

Chocolate Peanut Butter Silk Pie

Graham cracker crust, ganache, candied peanuts, whipped cream.

$12.95

Dulce De Leche Brownie Sundae

Ice cream, butterscotch chips, whipped cream.

$12.95

Pastries

Carrot Walnut Muffin

$3.95

Blueberry Muffin

$3.95

Chocolate Banana Muffin

$3.95

Chocolate Zucchini Muffin

$3.95

Chocolate Chip Cookie

$3.95

Oatmeal Cranberry Cookie

$3.95

Brownie

$3.95

Utensils

Utensils

$0.00

Entrees

Argentinian Steak Frites

NY strip steak, fries, chimichurri sauce.

$34.95

Pan Seared Mahi Mahi

Sautéed broccoli, mango-pineapple salsa.

$24.95

Salmon Caponata

sauce (olives, eggplant, squash, tomato), mashed potatoes

$25.95

Thai Chili Glazed Salmon

Sweet chili sauce, sautéed spinach.

$25.95

Chicken Mash Kale

Grilled boneless half chicken, mashed potatoes, sautéed kale, mushroom-red wine sauce.

$27.95

Pasta Bolognese

Penne, beef, sausage, marinara, cream.

$20.95 +

Chicken Piccata

Spaghetti, lemon butter wine sauce, caper, shallot.

$20.95

Spinach Ravioli

Truffle-parmesan cheese sauce, tomato, shallot.

$18.95 +

Chicken Parmesan

Spaghetti, marinara, parmesan, mozzarella.

$25.95

Eggplant Parmesan

Spaghetti, marinara, parmesan, mozzarella.

$20.95

Burgers

Signature Grill House Burger

Black angus blend, bacon, cheddar, romaine, tomato, red onion, 581 sauce.

$18.95 +

H&B Classic Burger

Black angus blend, romaine, tomato, red onion.

$17.95 +

Ranger Burger

Black angus blend, jalapeños, pepper jack cheese, crispy fried onions, chipotle mayo.

$18.95 +

Salmon Burger

Avocado, arugula, balsamic, red onion.

$20.95 +

Turkey Burger

Free-range blend, crispy fried onions, pepper jack cheese, barbecue sauce.

$18.95 +

Buffalo Chicken Burger

Breaded chicken breast, buffalo sauce, pepper jack cheese, chipotle mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion.

$18.95 +

Lentil Veggie Burger

lentil, onion, garlic, panko breadcrumbs, carrot, jalapenos, cheddar cheese

$17.95 +

Salads

Angelic's Delight

Beets, greens, goat cheese, candied pecans, balsamic vinaigrette.

$17.95 +

You Gotta Try The Burrata

Burrata, arugula, tomato, lemon juice, fig balsamic reduction, extra virgin olive oil.

$19.95 +

All Kale Caesar

Grilled chicken breast, radish, shaved parmesan, anchovy vinaigrette.

$21.95

Cauli Rice & Shaved Brussels Sprouts

Dried cranberries, sliced almonds, balsamic dressing.

$18.95 +

Soy Sesame Salmon

Cabbage, carrot, scallion, crispy noodles, almonds, cucumber, soy-sesame vinaigrette.

$24.95

NY Strip Chop

Grilled steak, greens, radicchio, bacon, blue cheese, hard-boiled egg, sherry vinaigrette.

$27.95

H&B Shrimp Salad

Arugula, lemon dressing, roasted almonds, chopped red onions, avocado.

$24.95

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Fried boneless chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, romaine, diced carrots & celery, cheddar, blue cheese dressing.

$21.95

Share Plates

Wings

Choice of buffalo or Asian glazed.

$14.95 +

Grilled Mahi Mahi Tacos

Corn tortillas, tri-colored slaw, chipotle mayo, tomatillo salsa.

$19.95

Buttermilk Fried Boneless Chicken

Comes with buffalo blue cheese and honey dijon dipping sauce.

$18.95

Nacho Libre

Corn tortillas, black beans, shredded cheese, pico de gallo, sour cream.

$18.95 +

Marvelous Mac and Cheese

Jack, cheddar, asiago.

$16.95 +

Nonni's Meatballs

Ground beef, sweet fennel sausage, parmesan.

$16.95

Mozzarella Sticks

Marinara sauce.

$12.95

Avocado Toast

Olive oil, lemon juice, pepper flakes. Choice of side salad or cup of soup.

$15.95

Guacamole w/ Tortilla Chips

avocado, jalapeño, onion, cilantro, lime juice, tomato

$19.95

Sides

Shoestring Fries

$6.95 +

Sweet Potato Fries

$6.95 +

Tater Tots

$6.95 +

Crispy Brussels Sprouts

Pancetta, cider agrodolce.

$11.95

Sautéed Broccoli

$11.95

Buffalo Cauliflower

breaded/fried, tossed in buffalo sauce

$9.95

Sauteed Kale

$9.95

Mashed Potatoes

$8.95 +

Half Avocado

$6.95

French Onion Soup

w/ gruyere

$11.95

Tomato Soup

$9.95

Side Salad

Mixed greens, tomatoes, balsamic vinaigrette

$6.95

Lentil Soup

w/ Parmesan and bacon

$8.95

Beer (alcohol)

Montauk - Wave Chaser

IPA - Draft 16 oz

$8.00

Threes - Logical Conclusion

IPA - Draft 16 oz

$9.00

Narragansett

Lager - Draft 16 oz

$7.00

Founders

Porter - Draft 16 oz

$9.00

Allagash - White

Belgian Style Wheat Beer - Draft 16 oz

$9.00

Blue Point

Toasted Lagerr - 16 oz Draft

$8.00

Corona

Mexican Lager - Bottle

$6.00

Miller Lite

Light Lager - Bottle

$6.00

Brooklyn

Lager - Draft 16 oz

$6.00

Dogfish Head 90 Minute IPA

India Pale Ale - Bottle

$8.00

Ithica Flower Power

American IPA - Bottle

$7.00

Wolffer Estate

Dry Rosé Cider - Bottle

$12.00

Modelo

Mexican Lager - Bottle

$6.00

Samuel Smith

Imperial Stout - Bottle

$9.00

Tecate

Mexican Lager - Can

$6.00

Original Sin

Black Widow - Blackberry Apple Cider - Can

$7.00

Wolffer Estate

Dry Rosé Cider - Bottle

$11.00

Cocktails (alcohol)

The Spice

Jalapeño infused tequila, pineapple juice, lime juice

$13.00

Peach Perfect

Gin, peach liqueur, peach nectar, bitters sparkling wine.

$13.00

Ferris Mule'ers Day Off

Vodka, ginger beer, fresh lime juice.

$13.00

Benedict Cucumberbatch

Vodka, elderflower liqueur, cucumber water, lemon, splash ginger beer.

$13.00

The Devil Wears Vida

Rum, Del Maguey Vida mezcal, lime juice, simple syrup.

$13.00

Whiskey Business

Whiskey, raspberry liqueur, Domaine Canton, lemon juice, club soda.

$13.00

Blazing Apples

house made hot apple cider, whiskey

$15.00

Paloma

Tequila, grapefruit juice, club soda, bitters.

$13.00

Bloody Murray

Vodka, tomato juice, spices, fresh horseradish, lemon and lime juices.

$13.00

Bay Flower Bellini

Sparkling wine, elderflower liqueur, peach nectar.

$13.00

Aperol Spritz

$13.00

Wine by the Glass (alcohol)

Pinot Noir

Pas De Problema - France - 6 oz pour

$10.00

Malbec

Alhambra - Argentina - 6 oz pour

$12.00

Cabernet Sauvignon

Vista Point -California - 6 oz pour

$9.00

Pinot Grigio

Vista Point - California - 6 oz pour

$9.00

Sauvignon Blanc

Rain - New Zealand - 6 oz pour

$11.00

Chardonnay

The Atom - California - 6 oz pour

$11.00

Sparkling Rosé

Simonet - France - 6 oz pour

$11.00

Prosecco

Cavicchioli 1928 - Italy - 6 oz pour

$12.00

Rosé

Borsao - Spain - 6 oz pour

$9.00

Soft Drinks

Coke

$3.00

Diet Coke

$3.00

Sprite

$3.00

Ginger Ale

$3.00

Club Soda

$3.00 +

Lemonade

$3.00 +

Iced Tea

$3.00 +

Iced Tea & Lemonade

$3.00 +

Cranberry Juice

$5.00

Grapefruit Juice

$5.00

Orange Juice

$5.00

Pineapple Juice

$5.00

Poland Spring

$3.00

Smoothies

There's Something About Berry

Blueberry, beet, spinach, oj, banana.

$9.95 +

The Green Mile

Spinach, pineapple, peach nectar, banana.

$9.95 +

The Hulk

Kale, spinach, pineapple, ginger, lemon.

$9.95 +

Last Mango in Paris

Mango, banana, almond milk, honey, greek yogurt.

$9.95 +

The Nutty Professor

Almond milk, cocoa, peanut butter, honey, banana.

$9.95 +

Dude, Where's My Orange?

Oj, mango, sweet potato, ginger, banana.

$9.95 +

50 Shades of Strawberry

Strawberry, mango, oj, banana.

$9.95 +

Pineapple Express

Pineapple, mango, banana, greek yogurt.

$9.95 +

Coffees, Teas, Etc.

Coffee

$2.40 +

Decaf

$2.40 +

Cold Brew

$3.65 +

Iced Tea

$3.50 +

Espresso

$2.65 +

Double Espresso

$3.05 +

Cappuccino

$3.90 +

Iced Cappuccino

$4.65 +

Latte

$3.90 +

Iced Latte

$4.65 +

Mocha

$4.65 +

Iced Mocha

$5.15 +

Chai Latte

$4.15 +

Iced Chai Latte

$4.65 +

Americano

$3.15 +

Cortado

$3.55 +

Flat White

$3.55 +

Macchiato

$3.05 +

Hot Cocoa

$3.50 +

Hot Tea

$2.50 +

Dr Feel Good

$6.00 +

Vanilla Nice

$5.00 +

Desserts

Butterscotch Bread Pudding

Brioche, butterscotch custard, ice cream.

$12.95

Warm Apple Cobbler

Buttermilk biscuit top, ice cream.

$12.95

Hot Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae

Chocolate ganache, ice cream, whipped cream.

$12.95

Key Lime Pie

Graham cracker crust, whipped cream.

$12.95

Chocolate Peanut Butter Silk Pie

Graham cracker crust, ganache, candied peanuts, whipped cream.

$12.95

Dulce De Leche Brownie Sundae

Ice cream, butterscotch chips, whipped cream.

$12.95

Pastries

Carrot Walnut Muffin

$3.95

Blueberry Muffin

$3.95

Chocolate Banana Muffin

$3.95

Chocolate Zucchini Muffin

$3.95

Chocolate Chip Cookie

$3.95

Oatmeal Cranberry Cookie

$3.95

Brownie

$3.95

Utensils

Utensils

$0.00

Entrees

Argentinian Steak Frites

NY strip steak, fries, chimichurri sauce.

$34.95

Pan Seared Mahi Mahi

Sautéed broccoli, mango-pineapple salsa.

$24.95

Salmon Caponata

sauce (olives, eggplant, squash, tomato), mashed potatoes

$25.95

Thai Chili Glazed Salmon

Sweet chili sauce, sautéed spinach.

$25.95

Chicken Mash Kale

Grilled boneless half chicken, mashed potatoes, sautéed kale, mushroom-red wine sauce.

$27.95

Pasta Bolognese

Penne, beef, sausage, marinara, cream.

$20.95 +

Chicken Piccata

Spaghetti, lemon butter wine sauce, caper, shallot.

$20.95

Spinach Ravioli

Truffle-parmesan cheese sauce, tomato, shallot.

$18.95 +

Chicken Parmesan

Spaghetti, marinara, parmesan, mozzarella.

$25.95

Eggplant Parmesan

Spaghetti, marinara, parmesan, mozzarella.

$20.95

Burgers

Signature Grill House Burger

Black angus blend, bacon, cheddar, romaine, tomato, red onion, 581 sauce.

$18.95 +

H&B Classic Burger

Black angus blend, romaine, tomato, red onion.

$17.95 +

Ranger Burger

Black angus blend, jalapeños, pepper jack cheese, crispy fried onions, chipotle mayo.

$18.95 +

Salmon Burger

Avocado, arugula, balsamic, red onion.

$20.95 +

Turkey Burger

Free-range blend, crispy fried onions, pepper jack cheese, barbecue sauce.

$18.95 +

Buffalo Chicken Burger

Breaded chicken breast, buffalo sauce, pepper jack cheese, chipotle mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion.

$18.95 +

Lentil Veggie Burger

lentil, onion, garlic, panko breadcrumbs, carrot, jalapenos, cheddar cheese

$17.95 +

Salads

Angelic's Delight

Beets, greens, goat cheese, candied pecans, balsamic vinaigrette.

$17.95 +

You Gotta Try The Burrata

Burrata, arugula, tomato, lemon juice, fig balsamic reduction, extra virgin olive oil.

$19.95 +

All Kale Caesar

Grilled chicken breast, radish, shaved parmesan, anchovy vinaigrette.

$21.95

Cauli Rice & Shaved Brussels Sprouts

Dried cranberries, sliced almonds, balsamic dressing.

$18.95 +

Soy Sesame Salmon

Cabbage, carrot, scallion, crispy noodles, almonds, cucumber, soy-sesame vinaigrette.

$24.95

NY Strip Chop

Grilled steak, greens, radicchio, bacon, blue cheese, hard-boiled egg, sherry vinaigrette.

$27.95

H&B Shrimp Salad

Arugula, lemon dressing, roasted almonds, chopped red onions, avocado.

$24.95

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Fried boneless chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, romaine, diced carrots & celery, cheddar, blue cheese dressing.

$21.95

Share Plates

Wings

Choice of buffalo or Asian glazed.

$14.95 +

Grilled Mahi Mahi Tacos

Corn tortillas, tri-colored slaw, chipotle mayo, tomatillo salsa.

$19.95

Buttermilk Fried Boneless Chicken

Comes with buffalo blue cheese and honey dijon dipping sauce.

$18.95

Nacho Libre

Corn tortillas, black beans, shredded cheese, pico de gallo, sour cream.

$18.95 +

Marvelous Mac and Cheese

Jack, cheddar, asiago.

$16.95 +

Nonni's Meatballs

Ground beef, sweet fennel sausage, parmesan.

$16.95

Mozzarella Sticks

Marinara sauce.

$12.95

Avocado Toast

Olive oil, lemon juice, pepper flakes. Choice of side salad or cup of soup.

$15.95

Guacamole w/ Tortilla Chips

avocado, jalapeño, onion, cilantro, lime juice, tomato

$19.95

Sides

Shoestring Fries

$6.95 +

Sweet Potato Fries

$6.95 +

Tater Tots

$6.95 +

Crispy Brussels Sprouts

Pancetta, cider agrodolce.

$11.95

Sautéed Broccoli

$11.95

Buffalo Cauliflower

breaded/fried, tossed in buffalo sauce

$9.95

Sauteed Kale

$9.95

Mashed Potatoes

$8.95 +

Half Avocado

$6.95

French Onion Soup

w/ gruyere

$11.95

Tomato Soup

$9.95

Side Salad

Mixed greens, tomatoes, balsamic vinaigrette

$6.95

Lentil Soup

w/ Parmesan and bacon

$8.95

Beer (alcohol)

Montauk - Wave Chaser

IPA - Draft 16 oz

$8.00

Threes - Logical Conclusion

IPA - Draft 16 oz

$9.00

Narragansett

Lager - Draft 16 oz

$7.00

Founders

Porter - Draft 16 oz

$9.00

Allagash - White

Belgian Style Wheat Beer - Draft 16 oz

$9.00

Blue Point

Toasted Lagerr - 16 oz Draft

$8.00

Corona

Mexican Lager - Bottle

$6.00

Miller Lite

Light Lager - Bottle

$6.00

Brooklyn

Lager - Draft 16 oz

$6.00

Dogfish Head 90 Minute IPA

India Pale Ale - Bottle

$8.00

Ithica Flower Power

American IPA - Bottle

$7.00

Wolffer Estate

Dry Rosé Cider - Bottle

$12.00

Modelo

Mexican Lager - Bottle

$6.00

Samuel Smith

Imperial Stout - Bottle

$9.00

Tecate

Mexican Lager - Can

$6.00

Original Sin

Black Widow - Blackberry Apple Cider - Can

$7.00

Brooklyn (Non-Alcoholic)

Hoppy Amber Ale - Can

$6.00

Cocktails (alcohol)

The Spice

Jalapeño infused tequila, pineapple juice, lime juice

$13.00

Peach Perfect

Gin, peach liqueur, peach nectar, bitters sparkling wine.

$13.00

Ferris Mule'ers Day Off

Vodka, ginger beer, fresh lime juice.

$13.00

Benedict Cucumberbatch

Vodka, elderflower liqueur, cucumber water, lemon, splash ginger beer.

$13.00

The Devil Wears Vida

Rum, Del Maguey Vida mezcal, lime juice, simple syrup.

$13.00

Whiskey Business

Whiskey, raspberry liqueur, Domaine Canton, lemon juice, club soda.

$13.00

Blazing Apples

house made hot apple cider, whiskey

$15.00

Paloma

Tequila, grapefruit juice, club soda, bitters.

$13.00

Bloody Murray

Vodka, tomato juice, spices, fresh horseradish, lemon and lime juices.

$13.00

Bay Flower Bellini

Sparkling wine, elderflower liqueur, peach nectar.

$13.00

Aperol Spritz

$13.00

Wine by the Glass (alcohol)

Pinot Noir

Pas De Problema - France - 6 oz pour

$10.00

Malbec

Alhambra - Argentina - 6 oz pour

$12.00

Cabernet Sauvignon

Vista Point -California - 6 oz pour

$9.00

Pinot Grigio

Vista Point - California - 6 oz pour

$9.00

Sauvignon Blanc

Rain - New Zealand - 6 oz pour

$11.00

Chardonnay

The Atom - California - 6 oz pour

$11.00

Sparkling Rosé

Simonet - France - 6 oz pour

$11.00

Prosecco

Cavicchioli 1928 - Italy - 6 oz pour

$12.00

Rosé

Borsao - Spain - 6 oz pour

$9.00

Soft Drinks

Coke

$3.00

Diet Coke

$3.00

Sprite

$3.00

Ginger Ale

$3.00

Club Soda

$3.00 +

Lemonade

$3.00 +

Iced Tea

$3.00 +

Iced Tea & Lemonade

$3.00 +

Cranberry Juice

$5.00

Grapefruit Juice

$5.00

Orange Juice

$5.00

Pineapple Juice

$5.00

Poland Spring

$3.00

Smoothies

There's Something About Berry

Blueberry, beet, spinach, oj, banana.

$9.95 +

The Green Mile

Spinach, pineapple, peach nectar, banana.

$9.95 +

The Hulk

Kale, spinach, pineapple, ginger, lemon.

$9.95 +

Last Mango in Paris

Mango, banana, almond milk, honey, greek yogurt.

$9.95 +

The Nutty Professor

Almond milk, cocoa, peanut butter, honey, banana.

$9.95 +

Dude, Where's My Orange?

Oj, mango, sweet potato, ginger, banana.

$9.95 +

50 Shades of Strawberry

Strawberry, mango, oj, banana.

$9.95 +

Pineapple Express

Pineapple, mango, banana, greek yogurt.

$9.95 +

Coffees, Teas, Etc.

Coffee

$2.40 +

Decaf

$2.40 +

Cold Brew

$3.65 +

Iced Tea

$3.50 +

Espresso

$2.65 +

Double Espresso

$3.05 +

Cappuccino

$3.90 +

Iced Cappuccino

$4.65 +

Latte

$3.90 +

Iced Latte

$4.65 +

Mocha

$4.65 +

Iced Mocha

$5.15 +

Chai Latte

$4.15 +

Iced Chai Latte

$4.65 +

Americano

$3.15 +

Cortado

$3.55 +

Flat White

$3.55 +

Macchiato

$3.05 +

Hot Cocoa

$3.50 +

Hot Tea

$2.50 +

Dr Feel Good

$6.00 +

Vanilla Nice

$5.00 +

Desserts

Butterscotch Bread Pudding

Brioche, butterscotch custard, ice cream.

$12.95

Warm Apple Cobbler

Buttermilk biscuit top, ice cream.

$12.95

Hot Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae

Chocolate ganache, ice cream, whipped cream.

$12.95

Key Lime Pie

Graham cracker crust, whipped cream.

$12.95

Chocolate Peanut Butter Silk Pie

Graham cracker crust, ganache, candied peanuts, whipped cream.

$12.95

Dulce De Leche Brownie Sundae

Ice cream, butterscotch chips, whipped cream.

$12.95

Pastries

Carrot Walnut Muffin

$3.95

Blueberry Muffin

$3.95

Chocolate Banana Muffin

$3.95

Chocolate Zucchini Muffin

$3.95

Chocolate Chip Cookie

$3.95

Oatmeal Cranberry Cookie

$3.95

Brownie

$3.95
Restaurant closed
.

About Hill and Bay

  • 581 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10016
  • American, Dinner, Lunch Specials
  • (212) 245-5554
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / Hill and Bay
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.