16 Handles Frozen Yogurt & Ice Cream - UES 2ND AVE
Popular menu items
Arriba Coffee Frozen Yogurt
Rich, dark roast coffee frozen yogurt made with 100% Arabica coffee beans
$7.45 +Home Essential Items
Fresh-Baked Desserts
Warm Chocolate Chip Cookie
A classic! Baked fresh using 16 Handles' famous chocolate chunk cookie dough!
$2.50Warm Chocolate Chip Brownie
Rich and fudgy, made from pure melted chocolate with the special addition of semi-sweet chocolate chips on top
$4.00Warm Apple Pie
$5.00Chocolate Cookie Pop
Chocolate with chocolate frosting and Cheetos dusting. Made by Sully and Vanilla
$2.95Cookies n' Cream cake Pop
New flavor alert!! Cookies n’cream for the win!!! Is it cake, is it ice cream? Does it matter?! Made by Sully and Vanilla
$2.95Cookie Dough by DŌ
Vegan Signature Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Signature chocolate chip made in vegan recipe. 8 oz. container
$12.50Signature Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Signature cookie dough + chocolate chips. 8 oz. container
$12.50Cake Batter Cookie Dough
Cake batter, white chocolate and milk chocolate chips with colorful sprinkles. 8 oz. container
$12.50Mochi Ice Cream by My/Mo
Strawberry Mochi Ice Cream
Real-fruit strawberry ice cream wrapped in a pillowy layer of chewy mochi dough
$2.49 +Mango Mochi Ice Cream
The tangy and sweet taste of mango ice cream combined with a layer of mochi dough
$2.49 +Cookies & Cream Mochi Ice Cream
An indulgent flavor with rich ice cream and crisp, chocolatey cookie pieces wrapped in My/Mo mochi dough
$2.49 +Green Tea Mochi Ice Cream
An indulgent flavor with rich ice cream and crisp, chocolatey cookie pieces wrapped in My/Mo mochi dough
$2.49 +Acai Bowls
The OG Acai Bowl
Organic Brazilian açaí with coconut flakes, granola, fresh blueberries & strawberries, and honey (toppings included on the side)
$9.95 +Peanut Berry Acai Bowl
Organic Brazilian açaí with granola, fresh blueberries & strawberries, and peanut butter (toppings included on the side)
$9.95 +Tropical Acai Bowl
Organic Brazilian açaí with dark chocolate nibs, coconut flakes, and fresh kiwi & strawberries (toppings included on the side)
$9.95 +Custom Acai Bowl
Organic Brazilian açaí plus your choice of toppings. Build your acai bowl exactly how you want it!
$9.95 +Soft-Serve Classics
Tahitian Vanilla Bean Frozen Yogurt
Our Artisan vanilla soft-serve, made with simple, natural ingredients like real Tahitian vanilla
$7.45 +Arriba Coffee Frozen Yogurt
Rich, dark roast coffee frozen yogurt made with 100% Arabica coffee beans
$7.45 +Euro Tart Frozen Yogurt
The new classic. Our latest tart fro-yo recipe is our very own, made with all natural ingredients that perfectly balance tart and sweet.
$7.45 +Peanut Butter Perfection Frozen Yogurt
Artisan peanut butter frozen yogurt flavored with real roasted peanuts
$7.45 +Salted Caramel Frozen Yogurt
One of our most popular flavors ever—the perfect sweet & salty dessert
$7.45 +Salted Caramel
$7.45 +Seasonal & Specialty Soft-Serve
Butter Cookie Ice Cream
Inspired by classic butter cookies—the sweet, melt-in-your-mouth centerpiece on any holiday cookie platter. A hint of vanilla perfects our recipe for rich Butter Cookie Ice Cream. Like warm, fresh-from-the-oven cinnamon buns on a Sunday morning. All the cinnamon and brown sugar deliciousness, none of the dairy... Oatly oatmilk soft serve is a holiday miracle.
$7.45 +Lemon Sunshine
$7.45 +NY Cheesecake Frozen Yogurt (No Sugar Added)
All the iconic flavor of a slice of homemade New York cheesecake swirled into our fro-yo, this time with a no sugar added recipe!
$7.45 +Oh My Pumpkin PIe
$7.45 +Butter Pecan Ice Cream
NEW! Sweet and nutty, this classic ice cream parlor flavor is made with real pecans folded into our signature soft-serve ice cream
$7.45 +Cookie Dough Ice Cream
Cookie Dough Ice Cream is the perfect indulgence. We fold real cookies and chocolate chips into 16 Handles' all natural, soft serve ice cream. Treat yo'self!
$7.45 +Cookie and Cream Ice Cream
NEW: Delicious, silky sweet cream folded full with real OREO® cookies makes what might be our most delicious ice cream yet
$7.45 +Pistachio Gelato
$7.45 +Dunk Yo Cookies
$7.45 +NSA Ripe Raspberry Frozen Yogurt
Indulge in the taste of real raspberries by the spoonful, swirled to perfection in this no sugar added fro-yo flavor
$7.45 +Pistachio Gelato
$7.45 +Cake Cake cake Batter (No Sugar Added)
You want it, we got it. Cake, cake, cake batter goodness with no added sugar
$7.45 +Green Tea Vanilla
$7.45 +Mint Chocolate Chip Frozen Yogurt
Who doesn't love the refreshing combination of mint and real chocolate? Our mint chip flavor is all natural and ultra-flavorful
$7.45 +Just Peachy Frozen Yogurt
$7.45 +Strawberry Banana (No Sugar Added)
The world's favorite fruity combo, made with no added sugar
$7.45 +Pina Colada
Our Piña Colada flavor is like a vacation in your cup! This bright and sweet swirl is made with real pineapple and coconut for an authentic, tropical flavor. You'll feel like you're sitting by the pool, even if you're really on your couch.
$7.45 +Strawberry (No Sugar Added)
$7.45 +Strawberry Fields Yogurt
Strawberry frozen yogurt with a summery, sweet taste you're sure to love
$7.45 +Chocolate Mint
$7.45 +Georgia Peach
$7.45 +Cotton Candy Frozen Yogurt
$7.45 +Mint Chocolate Chip
$0.00Sweet Cream
$7.45 +NSA Pecan Praline Frozen Yogurt
$7.45 +Chocolate Daydream Frozen Yogurt (No Sugar Added)
Chocolate fro-yo worth daydreaming about, made with no added sugar
$7.45 +Banana Pudding Frozen Yogurt
$7.45 +Blue Sky
$7.45 +Vegan (Dairy Free) Soft-Serve
OAT-ly Vanilla
Like warm, fresh-from-the-oven cinnamon buns on a Sunday morning. All the cinnamon and brown sugar deliciousness, none of the dairy... Oatly oatmilk soft serve is a holiday miracle.
$7.45 +Coco Loco Sorbetto
$7.45 +Pomegranate Raspberry Sorbet
This classic superfruit sorbet has been on our menu since opening day!
$7.45 +Silk Almond Vanilla Sorbet
$7.45 +Peach Sangria Sorbet
$7.45 +Strawberry Lemonade
Sweet, tart, smooth and always refreshing, this sorbet blends two favorite flavors into one unforgettable treat that makes it taste like summer all year long
$7.45 +Vegan Cookie Dough Craving
$7.45 +Welch's Concord Grape Sorbet
$7.45 +Vegan Cookie Dough Craving
Dairy-free chocolate cookie crumbles are folded into our creamy cashew-milk soft serve for a vegan take on classic cookies 'n' cream
$7.45 +Glinda's ™ Strawberry Vanilla Sorbet
We partnered up with the hit Broadway musical Wicked to celebrate 16 years they've been on Broadway! Have a bite of Glinda's Strawberry Vanilla, and she'll surely get you back home to Kansas in a jiffy! Limited Time Only! Vegan. Non-dairy
$7.45 +Kiwi Strawberry Sorbet
$7.45 +Strawberry Vanilla Sorbet
$7.45 +Chcolate Devotion
$7.45 +Coco Loco Sorbet
$7.45 +Raspberry Lime Mojito Sorbet
Notes of raspberry, mint, and lime make this classic drink the perfect inspiration for our sorbet
$7.45 +Green Apple Sorbet
$7.45 +Black Raspberry Made with Oak Milk Frozen Yogurt
NEW! Made with oat milk, our latest vegan flavor is a non-dairy twist on a classic ice cream flavor!
$7.45 +Peppermint Chocolate Candy
NEW! Mint + chocolate are a perfect pair, and this season, our new Peppermint Chocolate Candy is deliciously dairy free, made with oat milk!
$7.45 +Passion Fruit Orange Sorbet
$7.45 +Watermelon Sorbet
$7.45 +Oatly Chocolate
NEW from 16 Handles x Oatly! Chocolate lovers, prepare to be delighted. This chocolatey oatmilk soft serve has all of the decadence but none of the dairy. Indulgence awaits—you just have to order it!
$8.40 +Oatly Chai Tea
NEW from 16 Handles x Oatly! Chai Tea is our oatmilk soft serve version of the café-classic drink. Chai spices are balanced with sweet notes from vanilla Oatly to create dessert perfection. Available exclusively at 16 Handles!
$7.45 +Oat-Ly Chai Tea (vegan)
$94.45 +Oat-Ly Vanilla
From 16 Handles and Oatly! Bold but balanced, cool but creamy, decadent but dairy-free! Let this description be the sign you're looking for: Vanilla oatmilk soft serve is exactly what you need today.
$7.45 +Strawberry Lemonade
$7.45Oat-Ly Banana
$7.45 +Smoothies
Fro-Yo Milkshakes and Frappes
Artisan Coffee Frappe
An iced, blended coffee shake made with our Arriba Coffee frozen yogurt plus brewed coffee and premium sauces and syrups. Available in coffee, caramel, and mocha!
$7.95 +Fresh Fruit and Snacks
Banana
$1.00Rice Krispy Treat
$2.95Beverages
Catering Packages
Starter Package
Priced per person. Your choice of up to 4 flavors, branded spoons, cups, napkins, and 1 free topping.
$6.50Just Right Package
Priced per person. Your choice of up to 6 flavors, branded spoons, cups, napkins, and 1 free topping.
$8.00Treat Yo'self Package
Priced per person. Your choice of up to 8 flavors, branded spoons, cups, napkins, and 1 free topping.
$10.00