Sutton Cafe
MenuAbout
Sutton Cafe Menu

Sutton Cafe

American, Breakfast
1026 1st Ave, New York, NY 10022
(212) 421-9184
Menu About
Loading menu item photos

Eggs and Omelettes

Menu powered by Grubhub

1 Egg Any Style

$8.75 +

1 Egg Any Style with Ham

$11.75 +

1 Egg Any Style with Bacon

$11.75 +

1 Egg Any Style with Sausage

$11.75 +

1 Egg Any Style with Canadian Bacon

$12.25 +

1 Egg Any Style with Turkey Bacon

$12.25 +

1 Egg Any Style with Turkey Sausage

$12.25 +

2 Eggs Any Style

$9.95 +

2 Eggs Any Style with Ham

$12.95 +

2 Eggs Any Style with Bacon

$12.95 +

2 Eggs Any Style with Sausage

$12.95 +

2 Eggs Any Style with Canadian Bacon

$13.45 +

2 Eggs Any Style with Turkey Bacon

$13.45 +

2 Eggs Any Style with Turkey Sausage

$13.45 +

Corned Beef Hash and Eggs

$14.95 +

Steak and Eggs

$22.95 +

Plain Omelette

$11.45 +

Veggie Omelette

$14.45 +

Feta Omelette

$13.45 +

Florentine Omelette

$14.45 +

Greek Omelette

$14.45 +

Spanish Omelette

$14.45 +

Nova and Onions Omelette

$19.95 +

Make Your Own Omelette

$13.45 +

1 Egg

Any style. Served with french fries or home fries and toast.

$6.75 +

2 Eggs

Any style. Served with french fries or home fries and toast.

$7.75 +

Corned Beef Hash and Eggs

Served with french fries or home fries and toast.

$12.45 +

Feta Omelette

Served with french fries or home fries and toast.

$11.45 +

Florentine Omelette

Served with french fries or home fries and toast.

$12.45 +

Greek Omelette

Served with french fries or home fries and toast.

$12.45 +

Nova and Onions Omelette

Served with french fries or home fries and toast.

$17.45 +

Plain Omelette

Served with french fries or home fries and toast.

$7.75 +

Steak and Eggs

Served with french fries or home fries and toast.

$20.45 +

Veggie Omelette

Served with french fries or home fries and toast.

$12.45 +

Griddle Specialties

Plain Griddle

$12.95 +

Plain Griddle with 2 Eggs

Any style. Served with butter and syrup.

$12.45 +

Plain Griddle with Blueberries

Served with butter and syrup.

$12.45

Lumberjack

Served with two eggs and ham, bacon or sausage. Served with butter and syrup.

$15.45 +

Silver Dollar Pancakes

Served with butter and syrup.

$12.75

Chocolate Chip Pancake

Served with butter and syrup.

$12.75

Walnut Pancakes

Served with butter and syrup.

$12.75

Belgian Waffle Sundae

Served with scoop of ice cream, syrup and whipped cream. Served with butter and syrup.

$15.45

Plain Griddle

$12.95 +

Griddle with Ham

$15.95 +

Griddle with Bacon

$15.95 +

Griddle with Sausage

$15.95 +

Griddle with 2 Eggs Any Style

$15.45 +

Griddle with Canadian Bacon

$16.45 +

Griddle with Turkey Bacon

$16.45 +

Griddle with Turkey Sausage

$16.45 +

Griddle with Blueberries

$15.45 +

Lumberjack

Served with 2 eggs and ham, bacon or sausage.

$18.45 +

Silver Dollar Pancakes

$14.45 +

Chocolate Chip Pancakes

$16.45 +

Walnut Pancakes

$16.45 +

Belgian Waffle Sundae

Comes with scoop of ice cream, syrup and whipped cream.

$18.45 +

Odds and Ends

Bagel with Cream Cheese

$4.95

Bagel with Cream Cheese and Nova

$15.95

Bagel Platter

Comes with cream cheese, nova, lettuce, tomato, onions and olives.

$19.45

Danish

$3.75

Turnover

$3.75

Pound Cake

Plain, marble or carrot.

$3.75

Bagel

$2.95

Pita

$2.95

English Muffin

$2.95

Large English Muffin

$3.35

Toast

$2.75

Roll

$2.75

Homemade Muffin

$4.15

Jumbo Cookie

$4.15

Hot Cereal

Oatmeal.

$7.25

Cold Cereal

$5.95

Hot Cereal with Walnuts

$8.95

Hot Cereal with Raisins

$8.95

Avocado Toast

$7.95

Appetizers

Chicken Fingers

$12.95

Homemade French Fried Onion Rings

$8.95

Fried Mozzarella Sticks

Served with marinara sauce.

$10.95

Buffalo Chicken Wings

$12.95

Shrimp Tenders

With homemade marinara sauce, hot or mild.

$14.95

Stuffed Grape Leaves

$9.95

Homemade Chili

$7.45 +

Soup of the Day

Please call restaurant for soup of the day.

$4.25 +

Salads

Greek Salad

Lettuce, tomato, green peppers, onions, cucumbers, olives, anchovies, feta cheese and stuffed grape leaves.

$15.45 +

Grilled Chicken Salad

Grilled chicken breast on top of mixed greens and tomato.

$19.45 +

Slenderella

Individual tuna, salmon or sardines with cottage cheese, lettuce and tomato salad.

$16.45 +

Slim-Line Salad

8 oz. steak or turkey burger with a scoop of cottage cheese, lettuce and tomato salad.

$18.45 +

Tuna Salad

On a bed of lettuce, tomato and cucumbers.

$15.45 +

Chicken Salad

On a bed of lettuce, tomato and cucumbers.

$15.45 +

Egg Salad

On a bed of lettuce, tomato and cucumbers.

$15.45 +

Cantaloupe and Cottage Salad

$12.45 +

Caesar Salad

Fresh romaine lettuce with croutons and our special Caesar dressing.

$13.95 +

Chef's Salad

Julienne of ham, roast beef, turkey, cheese, hard boiled egg, lettuce, tomato and cucumbers.

$20.45 +

Health Salad

Fresh fruit salad, cottage cheese and jello on a bed of lettuce.

$18.45 +

Turkey Bowl

Fresh sliced turkey over mixed greens and tomato salad.

$19.45 +

Large Mixed Green Salad

$13.45 +

Tuna Fish Salad Platter

No celery. Served with potato salad, coleslaw, lettuce and tomato.

$19.45 +

Chicken Salad Platter

No celery. Served with potato salad, coleslaw, lettuce and tomato.

$19.45 +

Egg Salad Platter

No celery. Served with potato salad, coleslaw, lettuce and tomato.

$19.45 +

Salad Nicoise

Chunks of tuna over mixed greens with hard boiled egg, olives, green beans, tomato and anchovies.

$19.45 +

Horiatiki Salad

Tomato, cucumber, onions and feta cheese with grilled chicken.

$19.45 +

Sutton Cafe Salad

Mixed greens, tomato, onions and olives with hamburger or turkey burger.

$19.45 +

Vegetable Plate

Choice of 2 vegetables with baked potato or baked sweet potato.

$19.45 +

Homemade Wraps

Turkey Club Wrap

Delicious, fresh roasted turkey with bacon, romaine lettuce and tomato.

$15.95

Turkey Club Wrap with Side

Delicious, fresh roasted turkey with bacon, romaine lettuce and tomato.

$19.45 +

Sutton Cafe Wrap

Thin sliced Virginia ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato.

$15.95

Sutton Cafe Wrap with Side

Thin sliced Virginia ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato.

$19.45 +

Hot Roast Beef Wrap

Hot roast beef with melted cheese and sauteed mushrooms.

$15.95

Hot Roast Beef Wrap with Side

Hot roast beef with melted cheese and sauteed mushrooms.

$19.45 +

Roast Beef Wrap

Delicious homemade roast beef with Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato.

$15.95

Roast Beef Wrap with Side

Delicious homemade roast beef with Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato.

$19.45 +

Chicken Caesar Wrap

Grilled chicken with Caesar salad.

$15.95

Chicken Caesar Wrap with Side

Grilled chicken with Caesar salad.

$19.45 +

Chicken Salad Wrap

Our own chicken salad with lettuce and tomato.

$15.95

Chicken Salad Wrap with Side

Our own chicken salad with lettuce and tomato.

$19.45 +

Grilled Chicken Wrap

Grilled chicken with melted cheese and sauteed onions.

$15.95

Grilled Chicken Wrap with Side

Grilled chicken with melted cheese and sauteed onions.

$19.45 +

Nova Wrap

Thinly sliced nova with cream cheese, red onions, lettuce and tomato.

$18.00

Nova Wrap with Salad

Thinly sliced nova with cream cheese, red onions, lettuce and tomato.

$22.45 +

Tuna Fish Salad Wrap

Tasty homemade tuna fish with lettuce and tomato.

$15.95

Tuna Fish Salad Wrap with Side

Tasty homemade tuna fish with lettuce and tomato.

$19.45 +

Veggie Wrap

Eggplant, mushroom, onion and spinach.

$15.95

Veggie Wrap with Side

Eggplant, mushroom, onion and spinach.

$19.45 +

Hot Pastrami Wrap

Grilled pastrami with melted Swiss cheese.

$0.00

Sandwiches

Fried Egg Sandwich

$5.25 +

Western Egg Sandwich

$8.95 +

Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato Sandwich

$9.95 +

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

$9.95 +

Cheese Sandwich

$9.95 +

Tuna Fish Salad Sandwich

No celery.

$11.95 +

Chicken Salad Sandwich

No celery.

$11.95 +

Egg Salad Sandwich

$10.95 +

Roast Turkey Sandwich

Carved to order.

$13.95 +

Roast Beef Sandwich

$13.95 +

Virginia Ham Sandwich

$12.45 +

Ham and Cheese Sandwich

$13.95 +

Corned Beef Sandwich

$13.95 +

Hot Pastrami Sandwich

$13.95 +

Meat Loaf Sandwich

$12.95 +

Turkey Meat Loaf Sandwich

$12.95 +

Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich

$13.95 +

Chicken Cutlet Sandwich

$13.95 +

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Sandwich

$15.45 +

Fried Filet Sandwich

$12.95 +

Individual Tuna Sandwich

$12.95 +

Individual Salmon Sandwich

$12.95 +

S and S Sardines Sandwich

$12.95 +

Triple Decker Clubs

1. Turkey Triple Decker Club

Fresh sliced turkey, bacon, lettuce and tomato.

$19.45 +

2. Roast Beef Triple Decker Club

Served with Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato.

$19.45 +

3. Grilled Chicken Triple Decker Club

Grilled breast of chicken with cheese, lettuce and tomato.

$19.45 +

4. Chicken Salad Triple Decker Club

Chicken salad with bacon, lettuce and tomato.

$18.45 +

5. Tuna Salad Triple Decker Club

Tuna salad with sliced egg, lettuce and tomato.

$18.45 +

6. Egg Salad Triple Decker Club

Egg salad with bacon, lettuce and tomato.

$18.45 +

Sutton Cafe Specialties

House Chicken Breast

Grilled breast of chicken, topped with sauteed onions and melted cheese on pita.

$17.45

Chicken Pita Pizza

Grilled chicken breast with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese on pita.

$17.45

First Avenue

Thin sliced roast beef topped with sauteed mushrooms and melted cheese, garnished with potato salad or french fries.

$19.45 +

Monte Cristo

Thin sliced turkey with ham and melted Swiss cheese over challah French toast.

$19.45

Chicken Salad Melt

Served with french fries or potato salad.

$19.45 +

Tuna Salad Melt

Served with french fries or potato salad.

$19.45 +

Open Reuben

Pastrami or corned beef with sauerkraut, topped with melted Swiss on grilled rye bread, garnished with potato salad or french fries.

$19.45 +

Pastrami Grill

Grilled hot pastrami on rye with melted cheese.

$19.45

Grilled Eggplant

Grilled eggplant, peppers, red onion and melted mozzarella on a bun with french fries.

$19.45 +

Chicken Nuggets

Served with french fries in a basket.

$18.45 +

Chicken Fingers

Served with french fries in a basket.

$19.45 +

Fish and Chips

Served with french fries in basket.

$19.45 +

Fried Fish Filet Deluxe

Served with french fries, lettuce and tomato.

$19.45 +

Open Sliced Steak Sandwich

Sliced steak on toast, open faced, with lettuce, tomato and french fries.

$24.45 +

Sutton Meat Loaf

Served with mashed potatoes, crispy onions and barbecue gravy, served open-faced on thick egg bread.

$19.45

Gyro on Pita

Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and tzatziki sauce.

$12.45

Gyro Platter

Served with Greek salad, french fries and tzatziki sauce.

$19.45 +

Chicken Souvlaki on Pita

Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and tzatziki sauce.

$12.45

Chicken Souvlaki Platter

Served with Greek salad, french fries and tzatziki sauce.

$19.45 +

1/2 lb. Steak Burgers

Steak Burger

$9.75 +

Steak Burger Deluxe

Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.

$16.25 +

Garden Burger

$9.75 +

Garden Burger Deluxe

Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.

$16.25 +

Chili Burger

$10.75 +

Chili Burger Deluxe

Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.

$17.25 +

Turkey Burger

$9.95 +

Turkey Burger Deluxe

Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.

$16.45 +

Pizza Burger

$11.50 +

Pizza Burger Deluxe

Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.

$18.00 +

Steak Cheese Burger

$11.25 +

Steak Cheese Burger Deluxe

Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.

$17.75 +

Greek Burger

Sauteed spinach, feta cheese and onion.

$14.75 +

Greek Burger Deluxe

Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.

$21.25 +

Cali Burger

Avocado, bacon and cheddar cheese.

$14.75 +

Cali Burger Deluxe

Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.

$21.25 +

Mex Burger

Avocado, jalapeno peppers and cheddar cheese.

$14.75 +

Mex Burger Deluxe

Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.

$21.25 +

Rodeo Burger

Mushrooms, onions and muenster cheese.

$14.75 +

Rodeo Burger Deluxe

Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.

$21.25 +

Italian Burger

Roasted red peppers, onions and mozzarella cheese.

$14.75 +

Italian Burger Deluxe

Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.

$21.25 +

Hot Pressed Paninis

Eggplant Parmigiana Panini

Topped with mozzarella and tomato sauce.

$19.45 +

Grilled Chicken Panini

Sliced chicken breast, mozzarella cheese, basil and roasted red peppers, sprinkled with balsamic vinaigrette dressing.

$19.45 +

Roast Beef and Mozzarella Panini

Sliced roast beef topped with mozzarella.

$19.45 +

Turkey Panini

Sliced turkey topped with Swiss cheese and grilled tomato, served with a side of honey Dijon dressing.

$19.45 +

Chicken Parmigiana Panini

Pan fried chicken topped with mozzarella and tomato sauce.

$19.45 +

Italian Panini

Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, balsamic vinaigrette and fresh mozzarella.

$19.45 +

Greek Panini

Grilled chicken, feta cheese, tomato and spinach, served with tzatziki sauce.

$19.45 +

Hot Open Sandwiches

Hot Open Freshly Sliced Roast Beef Sandwich

$20.45

Hot Open Freshly Carved Turkey Sandwich

Off the bone.

$20.45

Hot Open Turkey Meatloaf Sandwich

Served with potato and vegetable.

$17.95 +

Hot Open Meatloaf Sandwich

Served with potato and vegetable.

$17.95 +

Mediterranean Specialties

Pasta with Marinara Sauce

$16.45

Pasta with Meat Sauce

$20.45

Pasta with Meatballs

$20.45

Lasagna

$20.95

Vegetarian Lasagna

$20.95

Spinach Pie

$20.95

Eggplant Parmigiana with a Side of Pasta

$20.95

Chicken Cutlet with a Side of Pasta

$22.45

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana with a Side of Pasta

$24.45

Stuffed Pasta Fiesta

Imported Cheese Ravioli

Homemade ravioli stuffed with ricotta and Pecorino Romano with homemade marinara sauce.

$20.45

Beef Ravioli

Homemade ravioli stuffed with sauteed beef and a blend of spices and cheese with homemade marinara sauce.

$20.45

Spinach Ravioli

Homemade ravioli stuffed with spinach, ricotta and Pecorino Romano with homemade marinara sauce.

$20.45

Stuffed Rigatoni

Homemade rigatoni stuffed with ricotta and Pecorino Romano with homemade marinara sauce.

$20.45

Tortellini Tri-Colore

Homemade egg, spinach and tomato tortellini stuffed with ricotta, Parmesan and pecorino Romano with homemade marinara sauce. Served with soup or salad.

$18.45

Stuffed Shells

Homemade jumbo pasta shells stuffed with ricotta and Pecorino Romano with homemade marinara sauce.

$20.45

Entrees

Turkey

Carved roast turkey breast, served with cranberry sauce, vegetables and potatoes.

$24.45 +

Grilled Chicken Breast and Athenian Style

Marinated in fresh garlic, lemon and herbs, served with vegetables and potatoes.

$24.45 +

Poached Chicken Breast

With a balsamic black bean and pepper salsa, served with potatoes or vegetable.

$24.45 +

Roasted 1/2 Chicken

Served with vegetables and potatoes.

$24.45 +

Chicken Breast Florentine

Broiled breast of chicken stuffed with imported feta cheese, spinach and herbs, served with potatoes or vegetable.

$24.45 +

Chicken Kabob

Chunks of chicken breast sauteed with bell peppers, onions and tomatoes, served over rice.

$24.45

Southern Fried Chicken

Honey dipped Louisiana style fried chicken, served with vegetables and potatoes.

$24.45 +

Turkey Meatloaf

Slowly baked turkey meatloaf, served with homemade mushroom gravy, vegetables and potatoes.

$24.45 +

Grilled Pork Chops

Topped with a creamy mushroom sauce, served with vegetables and potatoes. Served with soup or salad.

$23.45 +

Baked Meatloaf

Served with mushroom gravy, mixed vegetables and potatoes.

$24.45 +

Broiled Rib Eye Steak

Topped with garlic flavored sauteed mushrooms, served with vegetables and potatoes.

$28.45 +

Chopped Steak

Topped with sauteed onions or bacon, served with vegetables and potatoes.

$24.45 +

Calf's Liver

Topped with bacon or sauteed onions, served with vegetables and potatoes. Served with soup or salad.

$20.45 +

Broiled Norwegian Salmon

Served with vegetables and potatoes.

$25.45 +

Poached Norwegian Salmon

Served with a creamy dill sauce, vegetables and potato.

$25.45 +

Fish Filet Ala Maison

Cooked in white wine and garlic, served with vegetables and potatoes.

$25.45 +

Shrimp Primavera

Gulf shrimp and diced vegetables, sauteed in garlic and herbs, served over pasta or rice.

$29.45 +

Stuffed Baked Potato

Stuffed Baked Potato with Broccoli and Cheese

Add bacon for an additional charge.

$12.45 +

Stuffed Baked Potato with Garden Salad

$17.45

Stuffed Baked Potato with Caesar Salad

$17.45

Side Orders

French Fries

$6.45

Cheese Fries

$8.95

Sweet Potato Fries

$7.95

Baked Potato

After 12 pm.

$7.45

Baked Sweet Potato

After 12 pm.

$7.25

Home Fried Potatoes

$6.45

Home Mashed Potatoes

$6.45

Rice

$5.95

Pasta with Marinara Sauce

$10.95

Pasta with Olive Oil and Garlic

$10.95

Small Mixed Green Salad

$7.95

Caesar Salad

$7.95

Sauteed Vegetable

$9.95

Vegetable of the Day

Call restaurant for vegetable of the day.

$6.95

Side of Ham

$8.95

Side of Bacon

$8.95

Side of Sausage

$8.95

Side of Canadian Bacon

$9.95

Side of Turkey Bacon

$9.95

Side of Turkey Sausage

$9.95

Side of Corned Beef Hash

$9.95

Coleslaw

$6.45

Potato Salad

$6.45

Cottage Cheese

$6.25

Cranberry Sauce

$5.75

Tzatziki Sauce

$6.95

Marinara Sauce

$6.95

Salad Dressing

$6.95

Desserts

Jello

$4.75

Layer Cake

$7.25

Creamy Cheese Cake

$7.25

Assorted Fruit Pie

$6.25

Fruit Pie a la Mode

$8.25

Creamy Rice Pudding

$6.95

Ice Cream

$4.95 +

Fresh Beginnings

Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice

$5.95 +

Tomato Juice

$4.95 +

Apple Juice

$4.95 +

Individual Pineapple

$4.25

V-8

$4.25

1/2 Grapefruit

$4.95

Fresh Fruit Salad

$7.25

Melon

$6.95

Beverages

Coffee

$2.50

Tea

$2.50

Decaffeinated Coffee

$2.50

Herbal Tea

$2.50

Hot Chocolate

$2.95

Hot Chocolate with Milk

$4.45

Espresso

$4.25

Double Espresso

$5.50

Cappuccino

$6.25

Milk

$3.75 +

Chocolate Milk

$3.75 +

Iced Cappuccino

$6.95

Iced Coffee

$3.50

Iced Tea

$3.50

Ice Cream Soda

$7.95

Fresh Lemonade

$6.25

Fountain Soda

$2.75

Egg Cream

$4.75

Milkshake

$6.95

Double Scoop Milkshake

$6.95

Thick

$7.95
Restaurant closed
.

About Sutton Cafe

  • 1026 1st Ave, New York, NY 10022
  • American, Breakfast, Coffee and Tea, Diner, Dinner, Hamburgers, Italian, Lunch Specials, Mediterranean, Pasta, Salads, Sandwiches, Wraps
  • (212) 421-9184
Powered by Grubhub
Home / NY / New York / Sutton Cafe
About us Contact us Terms of use Privacy Policy Notice of Financial Incentive Do not sell my info
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.